A Christmas Carol - Nostalgia Critic
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 12. 2023
- WANT EARLY ACCESS AND UNEDITED REACTIONS? CHECK OUT OUR PATREON!: / renegadefaction
#nostalgiacritic #christmas #channelawesome
Discord: / discord
A Christmas Carol - Nostalgia Critic: • A Christmas Carol - No...
Patron Saints:
aaron patrick
Adam Gleaton
AlaskanJosh98
Alessandro Inzirillo
Alex
Alex Jay
Alexander Rost
Aliff Sonny
Alunnar
Amy Howell
Anathon
Andre Bradford C Diaz
Andres Vega
Andrew Davis
Andrew Inman
Angel Rivera
Anoj
Anton Björn Emilsson
Apple_Juice426
Arcane_Rogue
Arctic Fox
Arencano
Arkion
Ashley Short
Ashley White
Asrieldreemur
Austin Ramirez
AWG
Azuma
Based Libertarian
Bass564
Benjamin Jenyns
Big Fuze
Black knight
BlackCatEd
Blake Thompson
Blazer64
Blizzky
Blueberry
Brenden wells
Brennan Gerrell
Brittany Goen
Bulkswine
Canadian_Caesar
Casey
CHA0SXIII
Chance Jensen
Charles Rogue Dragon
Charleston Gamer
Chase Wagner
cheesesoda
Chris Dryden
Chrisian A Moore
Christina Carley
Christopher
ChronoVulpes
Church
Clock-Tok
Cody Barnes
ColdPhilly
Colton
colton biggerstaff
Coma Blitz
CommanderNomNom
Connor Brown
Corey Costello
Cowboy Coyote
CptBlitz
Crimson Reaper
Crimson Revenant
CursingThrone92
D
D.M.C.
Dana Mario
Daniel Gonzalez
Daniel Metcalfe
DanielFRod
Dark Lord
Dark_SinTeX
Darkcarkiller666
Darkened_SNIP3R
DarkPrime25
David Chisholm
Deathgrips099
Delta
DemonGamer67
Devin bristol
Dezso Teo
Dimitri Mendev
Donald Armstrong IV
douledamn
Dr.Skuller
dragonking unity
dubstepgamer X
DudeInBlue
DunnBeDa1
Dwayne Pope
DWhit
Dylan Tapp
Eagle Squad
Eddy Reinhart
Elias Cristerna
Elijah Moffett
Elliott Leeks
Eoin Conlon
Epic Bingewatcher
Eric Banks
ERIC BARTON
Erick Ruiz
Ethan Davis
Ethan Peregoy
Eviltwin01
Evo
Extinctionteam75
FaalofMan20
Faletlon
Finnishturska87
Fluffyfreshmeat
fly crap
fnaf3tank
FranklyHam
Freddy69
FunkyJunky22
Gamara204
Gamegod4
Garrett
Gary Platt
Gavin Hintz
Geno
Ghostrider Gold
godzilla 312
goldenluger
GoldenSun762
Grayscale
Grayson Benner
gunnerzblades
HailRedKing
Hastur, The Yellow King
HelBoy16
Henny Zhi
Hikoro
HimuraXIII
InquisitorXarius
Inverse Voltage
iPhoenixPlayz
Isaac Roa
Jacob Pollard
Jacob W.
Jacobus06
James Andersen
James Eugene
James Fernandez
James Nicholson
James Pagel
Jared Cappel
Jason Green
Jazz 1255
JD
JDawg9903
Jeffrey
Jeffrey Rillon
Jeremy Kaulmann
Jestapath
Jim Kerrigan
Jimmy Nguyen
Johan Cedillo
Johan Stenfelt
John
John Cabral
JohnFastolf101
Jonathan A Vicars
Jonathan Rager
Jonathon Forney
Jordan
Jordan Wu
Joseph Allan
Joseph Dungan
Josh King
Joshua Gair
Joshua Sharer-Martin
Joshua Webb
Jovan Ramos
Juan Garcia
Just Chris
Justin
KaijuPaladinGabriel
Kara Rohlman
Kau Komori
Kay Scruton
Kelvin gaming
King Joe
klmx
kris cook
Kristian Laber
Kwang Chul Kim
Kylen
Lake Hawk
Landon Hiles
Laptop759
Lazzy
Lea
LeaderBlue
Lily Panda
Lindsey Rapisarda
Lj O'Rourke
Lofti
LovetheDove
LRC Napkin
Lucas Hogh-Janovsky
Lucius
Luckless
Luis Hernandez
Luis Soriano
Luke Byers-Jones
Majorkingbob
Malum Nuntius
Manam Kung
Marcus L
Mark Lynn
Marshall Seldon
Marshall Taylor
Martin Girouard
Martin Tømmerholen
MarvinatorHD
Matt Way
Matthew Hemingway
Matthew Paulson
Matthias Fuchs
max
max mckenzie
Melissa Espinoza
Melymel
Michael
Michael Evans
Michael Gregory Cote
michi_9871
Mighty Snake
Miguel Castillo-Bailey
Mikaal mcqran
MoistureMolly
Monsi7
Mr. Happy
Mr. I Like Spam
Mystique Meredith
Name Unknowner
Nathan Fair
Nathan Prieto
nek
NexusDreamZ
Nicholas Delcambre
Nick J
Nicolas Dealey
Nightwolf37
Noah Barnhardt
Noah Morgan
Nora Schnee
Noran Maann
Nova Rose
NullVoid
Oax Al
OhHai_Its Joe
OKTOKAT
omar
Omniczar
Owen
paranoid mind
Patience Daniel
Peter Keogh-Lynn
Phantom Pyralis
PhantomICE87
Philip Munoz
Phillip J Smith Jr
Plaguemonk42
PotterBrony
Ramon Moreno
rashaun moore
ray kent
Reaver Daemon
Recurve Gaming
Redemption
René Goor
Rerekura mataamua
Richman1887
Rick Hound
RiZen
Robert F. Atrozskin
Robert Farrow
Roninn Hasstings
Ronny123
ross lingard
Roy Marax
ryan anderson
Ryu
SøvuOwO
Sandru
Sant25
Scar
Scott Slade
Scott Wright
Sean Anderson
SeaRaccoon
Shadow Quill
ShaiGuy
Sharkman
Shimell Williams
SilentValor
Singed Corpse
SlayerG88
Slendecker
Sliksick
Slip
smite me god
SNIPERSLAYER999
Snow
Somerandomguy
Son_of_Nemesis
Son_of_Revan
SouthStar
speeder2020
Sref
stephen crowell
stevmaster11
SuperMandibleClaw
Syenna Lupfer
Szymon K.
Tenebris Narud
tentaculls
Tesla116
TFrenchCanadian
The Angry Jew
The Dark Lord of terrible wrestling
The Gimpster 101
The Lord of the Meeps
The Manx
Theironcart
TheLoneLogan
TheQ651
TheTinman1996
Thezion1111
Thomas Martin
Thomas S
T-Money
Tokusa
Tomas Barreda (Tomyhill)
Touch Me
Travis Tierney
Tribal Typhoon
Tristan johnson
TrueAuraGuardian
Tshad Oswald
Twigo
Twiska
Tyler bandin
Under
Underuins
Unksa1198 Why
Valkyrie
Van Hohenheim
Videogamefreak34
Voltage
Vueko
weber_ dk
WeskerStars1987
William A. Riley
Willie Broughton
Wok
Wolfe26
Wulfric
X3ra
Xankoshu
Xavier Lavoie
Xaviro_
Xicen
Xmnan
yeetyeet 277
Yuriko
Zekria
Zone Z1 - Zábava
19:24
Jim Carey: “I was a BOY!”
James Woods: “Where is the PROOF!”
John Travolta: “While you were still learning how to SPELL YOUR NAME…!”
Tommy Wiseau: “You are TEARING ME APART, Lisa!”
🤣
I remember this movie scaring the crap out of me when I saw it in theaters as a 9 year old
So it did its job?
Let me guess, it was the future ghost that really got you?
My favorite version of a Christmas Carol is the first one I saw with Scrooge McDuck when I was a kid.
I'm 20 now and it's still my favorite to this day.
Mickey's Christmas Carol. That was my first one as well, and I am rather upset that it has pretty much been forgotten and not shown.
Fun Fact: Pretty sure that was my first exposure to that too. Only complaint is that it's too short.
I think the chase scene does have a meaning, I think it's supposed to tell us that death is always coming and no matter how much you run, it catches you, and to death, you're just a small thing to death. Notice after scrooge is caught that he's shown what happens after he died, so in a way this scene was to show that death is coming, and scrooge has to make a choice on what happens in the middle
that's what i felt when i saw the movie
@@gabrieldreemurr right, it took me a rewatch to get it, but when it hits, it makes sense
Didn't need to be so extreme
@@ForrestFox626 true,but still
@@ForrestFox626 that's what makes it so magical
YESSSS!!! I have been wondering if you were going to be reacting to this review! Also, 3:38
Fun Fact: Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol was published on December 19th, 1843, and it just so happens that that day is *my birthday!*
Thanks.
Thanks Caleb
You were born on December 19th, 1843?!
lol jk have an early happy birthday from me.
My personal all time favorite one is one that Doug has already reviewed..."A Muppets Christmas Carol."
19:09 - 19:35 Not only his favorite Scrooge line read, but Doug did it himself as Ask That Guy during a sketch in one of his episodes, where he answers that he has feelings for his GPS, voiced by Doug's wife, around the time he asked her to marry him, and Ask That Guy proposes to his GPS. There's a cut to time later, where Ask That Guy and his GPS are having marriage troubles, and like Scrooge and Isabelle here, Ask That Guy uses that same phrase, "I WAS A BOY!"
3:03 he was just a producer on that. The person who directed it was Simon Wells, one of the co directors of the Prince of Egypt.
I think Nate was thinking of the Grinch Book Sequel not a Grinch Movie Sequel. For there is the book sequel called "How the Grinch Lost Christmas"
There is also a Grinch Prequel called "Halloween is Grinch Night"
This adaptation really stuck on me, while giving me the ideals along with Return to Oz to make Horror never gory and choose wisely on the jump scares, and to have the good ending moments be at its subtle level and never half *ssed
(Also my favorite adaptation as I grew older was Richard Donners Scrooged)
“He also fat check, FACT checked himself”
Another actor I could imagine playing Scrooge would have to be David Bradley, as his perfomance as Argus Filch (the Hogwarts caretaker) in the “Harry Potter” movies shows he was born to play the part.
Also if someone could do their own take on “A Christmas Carol”, it could be set in 1944 during World War II (101 years after the original book was published). If that could happen, Ebenezer Scrooge & Jacob Marley’s company could provide war bonds or something important enough to make them & Bob Cratchit exempt from being drafted to fight in war. On top of being ill, Tiny Tim could be a child evacuee who can’t receive medicine from overseas due to Britain cutting off imports due to the war. Meanwhile, Fred’s wife could offer Scrooge to visit for Christmas dinner, while Fred himself is away fighting in the war. Scrooge could secretly be a fascist activist who sees himself as the dictator of fascist Britain before he dies according to the Ghost of Christmas Future, even mingling with Hitler & Mussolini. In that depiction, Scrooge’s actions could indirectly cause Tiny Tim’s death in a bombing raid if the Nazis defeated the American forces & took back Normandy, far away from his parents. WHAT DO YOU THINK?!
For a muppet christmas carol I always called the ghost of christmas present muppet Hagrid
I recommend you guys should definitely watch Nostalgia Critic's review of the second worst Christmas Special titled...
Rapsittie Street Kids: Believe In Santa
(Warning) It's Worse Than The Christmas Tree... beware.
I want them to watch his review of Deck the Halls, the forgotten sequel to Christmas with the Kranks.
You should do NC most insane Christmas rom-com next
My favorite version of a Christmas Carrol is the one with George C. Scott. Bob Marley scared me as a kid, especially his sudden loud screams.
The version with George C. Scott is my favorite in terms of being deeper and more serious. However, the Muppet version is my favorite light-hearted version.
Mickey's will always hold a special place in my heart.
same. Mickey's version was my first exposure to the story
George C. Scott still remains my favorite version of Scrooge, also Christopher Plummer's version of Scrooge from The Man Who Invented Christmas is pretty underrated
21:00
Wait, WHAT?! 😳
21:18
Oh, phew! 😅
you almost gave me a heart attack when you said that the 2000 Grinch was getting a sequel! thank GOD thats NOT happening
Ah yes! Rickman would have been EPIC
Nick you should watch "Scrooge" with Albert Finney from 1970. It's a musical, though it's a good one. The other Christmas Carol's I enjoy are The Muppets, The Flinstones, the one with Patrick Stewart, The man who invented Christmas & the one episode of The Real Ghostbusters "X-Mas Mark's the spot".
Ghost of Christmas present is my favorite because you could see him age in every scene and that final moment when the 2 children repeat scrooges words back at him while Present just laughs is so cool
Even if far flawless, this is still my favourite or second favourite version of A Christmas Carol.
I'm so glad you guys are watching NC more often now. If you get the time, please watch his review of the Supergirl movie from the 1980s, I think it's one of his funniest.
This movie scared the shit out of me when I first saw it!
I remember how it scared the c*** out of me when I first saw it in theaters.
The background music in this video is so good!
The only other version of A Christmas Carol that I saw aside from the Mickey Mouse one, and Scrooged, is the Patrick Stewart one. I don’t know if that one is well liked, or it’s hated, but I remember liking it well enough. Of all of them though, my favorite probably is Mickey Mouse, followed by this, and then Scrooged.
omg yes I never would've thought of Rickman as Scrooge! What a lost opportunity :(
Also, Rickman Scrooge counting his money (wait for it...)
Three hundred.. and ninety... four.
I did this play at my high-school and I played one of Bob's kids it was an really fun experience as we had
To rush around to meet the Christmas deadline
First version of A Christmas Carol I've ever seen was the one with Patrick Stewart. As for one that sticks out and is my favorite, the Muppets Christmas Carol. Now, I personally don't really care for the Muppets in general. What really sells that adaptation for me was how they handled the Ghost of Christmas Present. I always understood that Christmas Present was meant to help Scrooge see the joys of Christmas and actually start to feel what it's about, while also telling Scrooge what will happen if nothing changes. But this version of Christmas Present treats Scrooge like a friend the whole time. At no point does he take a moment to scare the absolute shit out of him like in the Jim Carrey version. And the one in the Patrick Stewart version just seems....bored most of the time. I've seen a couple other adaptations as well, but they don't stick out to me. Anyway, it seemed like out of all the adaptations, the Muppets version of Christmas Present was the most successful in showing Scrooge the true joys and meaning of Christmas, and his departure actually saddened Scrooge. And then Christmas Future, the one who is supposed to be scary, also doesn't spend alot of time scaring the shit out of Scrooge. The design is...lackluster. I always preferred the close resemblance to the Grim Reaper. That said, I do like that this Ghost of Christmas Future appears more like a ghost than in other adaptations. Anyway, the Muppets version of Christmas Future acted as more of a gentle guide, even putting a hand on Scrooge as they guide him to the next part. And when Scrooge vows to change, I feel the spirits giving Scrooge a second chance was more believable. Here with Jim Carrey's version, at best, I could see it as the spirits playing a really messed up prank on Scrooge. Other than that, it would make more sense for them to decide that they just kill him anyway or something. That said, the design for Christmas Future in the Jim Carrey version was brilliant, making them more like a shadow than a physical entity.
Now, the ideal Christmas Carol for me would be one that combines what was done well in each adaptation, because they all bring something to the table, as far as I know. Though I can only really name two. One being the portrayal of the Ghost of Christmas Present being closer to the Muppets version. Doesn't have to actually be a Muppet, just has to do a good job at showing Scrooge the joys and meaning of Christmas. And two being Christmas Future being a shadow, though I'd say tone down the action and jumpscares by.....alot. Instead, have them be something that just gives the feeling that you know they're always there, creeping behind you. It'd be something to only send chills up your spine, even if you know the spirit doesn't actually intend to harm.
You HAVE to look at his review of Muppet Christmas Carol next! He talks a lot more about his love for the story there.
For me, the Mickey Mouse version will always hold my heart.
This film was off when it came to it’s tone, it was like 70% to the source material but it was to scary, I want to see the critic review Scrooged to see how he thinks of this adaption of the Christmas Carol story .
I still protest that The Muppet Christmas Carol is the best interpretation of the Charles Dickens classic story from December 19th, 1943. It seemed to have found a perfect balance of relatability for audiences of all ages as far as i could tell and it has been my favorite since it’s original theatrical release back 1992 when it was competing against and inevitably came up short against Home Alone 2: Lost In New York at the domestic box office. Bah humbug and on a more positive note God bless us, everyone.
This Christmas Carol is my favourite of all time (who knew that Jim Carry can play not as Jim Carry, but if you think this Christmas Carol wasn’t good or even not scary enough there’s always a Broadway version of Christmas Carol, it will give you nightmares trust me I know that, The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come looks like a Dead Rotten Corpse that comes alive)
Hope youll check out his review of The Muppet Christmas Carol
Ah yes one of my childhood fever dream movies
Shrek the Third is an Horrifying film
the only version that i remember the most was Scrooge's Ghostly Tale it was not the best one but it's one of the versions i know
Next Saturday me and my Dad are planning to see a professional production of A Christmas Carol with John Ratzenberger playing Scrooge
I enjoyed this as a kid kinda still do mostly becuaese of how awesome the soundtrack is the opening title and christmas present scores are really good
I remember watching this movie but not all the way through. I had just tuned into it super late. 😂😂😂
Leave it to the guy with the face to be in a traumatizing movie
This movie scared me as a kid when I first saw it but I love it now
I’m genuinely curious on what happened to Robert zemeckis
How do you go from making great movies like back to the future, who framed Roger rabbit, forest gump and castaway to making cgi abominations no seriously dude what happened to him
He saw potential in a technology and wanted to pursue it. And later went back to more traditional films like The Walk.
@@KeybladeMasterAndyyeah and he made Pinocchio because Disney put some money in his pockets
🤷♂️Why does everyone forget Romancing the Stone??
@SJ_RANKS *That* Pinocchio was a mistake; the only reason people went to see it was Tom Hanks. It was just a setup for callback easter eggs and even a set-up for the villain in Wish (2023).
@@SJ_RANKS Your point? Some jobs are just jobs.
16:40
That’s what she said 😆
I love this movie so much it’s probably one of my favorite Christmas movies along with home alone and the polar express
How about Nostalgia Critic Muppet Christmas Carol?
I love renegades I’m still a proud patreon supporter I love all of you
Can't remember, have they done Nostalgia Critic's Home Alone 2 review?
My favorite is the 1984 version with George C. Scott.
Its weird. When this movie slows down, it's damn-near amazing! When it's going over-the-top, it's really distracting.
Looked it up, apparently Scrooge's fiancee is named Belle
My favourite versions are the muppets one and Scrooge, the more recent animated one on Netflix
I want this movie to be in Kingdom Hearts 4! I want to fight against the Ghost of Christmas Future as Sora!
I actually really like seeing all the different versions of a Christmas story.
All the similarities and the differences are very interesting to me, because sometimes the alterations can be interesting twists but to see the expected is still warranted.
That being said, one of the most interesting reinterpretations for me, actually comes from my little pony friendship is magic.
With their episode “heartwarming tale”
Being only a half hour long,
(if even that)
they zoom through the points pretty quickly they still managed to do their own thing.
Using the fact that it’s a musical episode to get a lot of information out quickly through song.
Their version of Scrooge hates the holiday because she was taught by somebody just as bitter as she becomes. That’s such a holiday is pointless when you should be focusing on trying to better yourself.
And she takes this to such a literal extreme, that she quickly puts together a spell that if she uses, it would literally remove the holiday from the world and of course, the holiday spirits are going to have something to say about that.
And their version of Christmas future, is downright chilling, with the heavy implication that it isn’t just their version of Scrooge that’s dead in the future.
Scrooge McDuck Mickey's Christmas Carol I Got Scared😱😱😱 When He Looked Over Railing Downstairs 😱😱😱 My Sliding Window At Night Open I'm Not Lying
It was still enjoyable... But yeah, I've seen better. Still, there are some good things in it, and this is a very adaptable story and there are still a lot of other versions out there, even a couple of Operas and I swear I am not making that up, so you're likely to find one that you'll like.
Edit: Also I agree, Alan Rickman would've made an amazing Scrooge. Too bad we'll never get a change to see it. RIP Alan, you are a legend.
My favorite version is from Starkid. A VHS Christmas Carol. The music is Great.
Mine was the muppet Christmas carol
I've always defended these mocap movies for the most part, but this is still somewhere in my top 5 Christmas Carol adaptations. EXCEPT for the carriage chase. I usually skip that part.
What an amazing movie.
My favorite is ms Scrooge and my second favorite is the Mickey mouse one
Simon Wells Directed Mars Needs Moms, not Robert Zemeckis
I mean, I didn't mind this film.
Nate was wrong? Internet reaction = 🤯
I never knew about A Christmas Carol growing up
Not even the original book?
@@jordanhunter3375 no it was never mentioned in my school none of my classmates or teachers talked about it
@@jakobmata7011 Huh.
@@jordanhunter3375 the closest I ever heard of the author was in the Matilda movie other than that growing up it was never mentioned
@@jakobmata7011I'd recommend it.
Jim Carrey Christmas > Tim Allen Christmas
Pls tell me renegade will be watching Aris new video with nick
Do catnap recall vhs poppy playtime chapter 3
I'm sorry but that thumbnail is way too cluttered. It took me half a minute to figure out what I was looking at.
I love this film