Is Modi’s India Finally Challenging China’s Aggression? | Abhijit Iyer-Mitra
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 06. 2024
- India's election and unexpected result for Narendra Modi's BJP is changing Indian foreign policy, especially over China and the Indo-Sino relationship. Beijing's continued antagonistic behaviour and Xi Jinping's policies are escalating tensions with New Delhi, causing India to align closer to the USA.
In this Part 3, Abhijit Iyer-Mitra - a leading and influential voice on India's foreign policy, covers the biggest systemic priority to Modi: China. We debate the threat India feels from China, how it would be involved in a Taiwan conflict, why its taking more leadership in global institutions, and the future for India in Modi's third term.
↭ PARTS 1 & 2 ↭
Part 1: • Has Modi's Poor Electi...
Part 2: • Can Modi Still Make In...
↭ MORE VIDEOS ↭
► The power of Bharat: • From India to Bharat? ...
► India's fight with Canada: • India-Canada Chaos: Ho...
► India-US dynamics • India USA Power Play: ...
↭ ABHIJIT'S ACCOUNTS ↭
► Profile: southasianvoices.org/author/m...
► X/Twitter: / iyervval
↭ SUPPORT MY WORK ↭
► Patreon: / theglobalgambit
► Buy Me A Coffee: www.buymeacoffee.com/thegloba...
► YT Membership: / @uc7-tpqkmvid. .
↭ ENGAGE WITH ME ↭
► 𝕏/Twitter: (@pkurzin): / pkurzin
► Substack: (The Global Gambit) pyotrskurzin.substack.com/
► Instagram (@theecoexpat): / the.eco.exp. .
↭ PODCAST DOWNLOAD/REVIEW ↭
► (The Global Gambit): podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
↭ CHAPTERS ↭
00:00 Intro
01:08 India-China potential for war
09:00 China and India in G20, QUAD and United Nations
16:30 India's new foreign policy priorities according to Abhijit
19:40 India as leader of the 'global south'
#india #china #geopolitics #modi #war #economy #politics #loksabhaelection2024 - Zábava
Like this? Want MORE? Then SUBSCRIBE to the channel and never miss a video!
Support further by dropping a like and give it a share! 🚀
Good conversation. Invite Abhijit from time to time.
Please close the curtain in the background.
dont stay close to wall
How he has Abhijit and Iyer and Mitra? is he tamil? why he has iyer ? Weird name. North indian sanskrit love?
That said looks brainy. i subscribed because he looks rational. but i need to listen more before i judge his biases and agenda. India need its own deep state. That is my goal. India cant survive with OPEN RAID setup. Country is divided in so many pieces. India need its own shadow state which stay beyond election and it need to be secret.
Also one thing i find is terrible is central govt dismissing local govt on corruption etc. Unless the guy committed genocide or murdered ..central govt should stay off. BJP behaves same like congress before
India need more enlightened people. This is about business and jobs. More factory opens more roads can be built. India lacks investment.
Chinese gets so much investment and whole country benefitted. India need to improve their construction business. I also think indian cement industry should buy off foreign cement industries with mines.
Very realistic take on India.
For India I don’t think there’s any different between China and USA when it comes to trust factor
The other two countries probably feel about the same towards India.
@@billshun3963 that's not a bad thing.. the world needs alternative to US or China
@@billshun3963those two can't complain about trust factor from others when US and china always interfere inside India's internal matters and also meddle in the election process
Nah the US is still better than China
@@billshun3963who even likes China anyway
❤ AIM
Great conversation ..... Abhijit nailed it. Indias current positioning in world geopolitics
Abhijit is brilliant and spot on with his analysis! Enjoy your shows🙏🙏🙏
Thanks for watching. Give it a share 🚀
@@theglobalgambit🤣🤣🤣
India 10 trillion ⁉️
@@minhloi4536huh? Is that a question or a rhetoric?
Britishers had minimum 43 trillion from India @@minhloi4536
Indians want communist rule, but stop dreaming🤣🤣🤣
Modi hai toh mumkin hai
India does have the idea of not trying or aiming to become a hegemon or a great power or something like that. It could pose as a leader of some bloc of nation but mostly has never postured itself in some self-procalimed role of leading the world or anything. It does mostly keep to itself, unless something tough arrives. But due to its population size, good demographics, favourable geopolitical position, etc. and the way with which it has been growing, if standard or favourable global conditions hold in the future, the country will automatically become very powerful even if it does not want to become so. It will be interesting to see what decisions it takes after achieving that position but to take a neutral stance despite wielding great power is something I find very fine and mature and unique too because most other nations or empires till date have had quite the opposite disposition.
That's why India is the oldest continuing civilization with the same dominant religion & culture for the most part despite colonization & forced conversions - while all other ancient civilizations, religions are dead or converted.
India is not even a Great Power.
It's trying to be one though.
⁉️⁉️⁉️
China is not the only country that has a base in Djibouti. The US, France, and Japan also have bases. And all of them kept quiet and let India handle the Houthis.
Before u start recording, make sure background lights r dimmed or switched off, window behind u should b covered with curtain properly to ensure better quality video
I had to listen and not watch--for the window glare
Brrrrooooo really 🤔🥱🤷
What’s your opinion? Do you agree with Abhijit? Share a comment
Your series with Abhijit has been excellent. I recommend you do this on a periodic basis since there is so much happening in the Indo-Pacific.
Multidimensional analysis ❤❤
Unless Indian intel
Agencies doesn’t start hitting CIA in US I dont see India takin global geopolitics seriously
Agree with most, except QUAD. India is more of an irritant in the group.
He's spot onn 👍💯 loved this convo❤
Bharat needs to transition into nuclear power through Thorium instead of uranium or plutonium. There is abundant Thorium in Bharat and Thorium is a cleaner and more efficient source of nuclear power.
Yes, you may right but it will take it's time for the development....
The Murica regime is just using India as a pawn in the geo-political arena. Later they will even pass a bill free Kashmir and free kalistan.
Not easy to extract thoriim from beaches
I thoroughly enjoyed Parts 1 and 2... looking forward keenly to Part 3. Hearing Abhijit Iyer Mitra hold forth on various issues is always a pleasure. As a good host, Pyotr, you do not interrupt your guests which is a very good thing! Cheers!!
OMG..Abhijit is so true about Chinese. I am having such a hard time working on a project in US with Chinese nationals. Whenever you something simple, person says WHAT! OMG
Dude, we indians are not very different. There are good people in every culture.
Since so many Indians are successful in American management roles, Chinese nationals are jealous in a way.
Once they become American, this jealousy changes. It becomes an us versus them mentality
@vamsavardhanavijay5532 sure! I am specifically talking about communication and signaling. In other things, I find them good.
@@ashwanikumar-nk7gd , It seems Indians are so clever that India could not progress in their industrialization.
@@user-ed9so2rb4kTofu dreg construction on unviable housing projects is not called industrialization. LMAO 🤣
@@rohanch07 , You can keep on howling on an issue that China had permitted the "capitalist businessmen" to build the housing estate but with this failure, they will take over this housing business like what Singapore is doing. You can keep howling with your imagination but China is certainly not bothered with what India can do: crawling to their vast imagination to the moon, where what they claimed was just in their imagination!
PPP GDP is now over $14tn not ten.
PPP is not realistic in India. Just look at the general conditions of living in India.
❤❤❤
Thanks
Welcome
Liking the view count Pyotr, looking good brother, just started listening on this one, just came back after watching one and two, peace
The American 7th fleet sent the Task Force 74 headed by USS Enterprise to the Bay of Bengal. The Soviet Pacific submarine challenged the US Aircraft Carrier and blocked them from entering the action theater.
Great video. Please bring it on more. Abhijit is always my favorite analyst. I learn so much thru this interviews
Here for AIM.. Good one 👍🏻
India's world view emanates from Sanatan philosophy that 'world is a family'. No aggressiveness towards living things/beings as they have aatma(conscience) which is part of Paramatma(Super Conscience - i.e GOD). Unfortunately, its does not gel well with abrahamic thought processes. Example Israel/Palestine wars .... NATO/Russia war in Ukraine war.
Yes I do agree with you.. realistic approach....
Rubbish
Wishful thinking. Are they preaching the same old bullshit every Sunday?
Abhijeets insights are always refreshing.
Great podcast
Glad you enjoyed it! Give it a share to support further
Love to see a western geo politics representative taking interest in Indian role
Great discussion and informative. Love the format and Pyotr’s style. Keep it up.
More to come! Give it a share !
🎉
It should be
India is good too, please love us.😅😅😅😅
It’s a necklace of Diamonds not Pearls, anymore?
Which country are you from
Regarding interoperability i think i listened to many retired generals...AIM needs to revisit his opinion.....there is grrater interoperability because of indian mission control computer etc....
FROM WHERE DID YOU LEARN TO READ AND WRITE ENGLISH🤢🤢😁😁🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣.
@@bittoochatterjee2661commie dogs cry me a river 😂🤣
China and India are making “REAL” headway In strengthening there economic ties together. I’m really looking forward to what both countries can do In the near future. The BRICS NATIONS are definitely here to stay. 🇨🇳🤝🇮🇳
With 65 percent international trade happening in USD, BRICS can do nothing. Euro is the next powerful currency not part of the group. India and China multiply by 10 cannot harm $
CHINA needs.to give back AKASI CHIN to INDIA
@@rafeeq_sultana You clearly have very little understanding of the “basic” fundamentals of global economics, trade and business In which “TRUE CHANGE” Is really made.
God bless. 🙏🙏🙏
Don’t even think about it.🤣🤣🤣
Abhijit, we'll let the military deal with joint exercises, we do a lot of exercises, literally one every month. Don't be a coffee table expert.
Did Your Father , Grand father Uncles Ever Participate in Indo Pak War Right from 1947 To 1999
🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔😁😁🤣🤣🤣🤣
Two Of My Maternal Uncles Out Of Five Brothers & My Father Did.
Right from 1947 - 1971 As Indian Air Force Officers Be They as a
Navigator Late Eldest Mama Ji - 1947 & 1962 War. Indo Pak & Indo China War👍👍❤❤
Or
Fighter Pilots My Late Second Eldest Mama Ji And My Father Fighter Pilot's 1965 & 1971 Indo Pak War.
They all Retired as 3 & 2 Star Veteran Officers During Mid 1970, Mid 1985 and Early 1991.
My Father Today 84 Years Old.
Col Suresh Babu Who got killed near the disputed Pangong Lake in Ladakh in 2020 Was " My Friend". ❤❤.
Not Yours 🤢🤢🤢🤢🤢🤢.
Is coffee table the new version of arm chair 😂
@@dibyaraj108 You must be really old or old general if you use Arm Chair! Do you?
What does he mean by the naval ships being unable to talk to the P8i's exactly.?
15:00 to exactly solve this didn't navy come up with their own BMS?
Russian technology⁉️
Economic theories start with a caveat- all other things being equal... In geopolitics too, such assumptions make predictions dicey because things may depend on whether a nation's head of state has got out of the wrong side of the bed, probably..
Economics of wind also doesn't play out well in Germany too :D
Agree. Very lucid
there are many ways to look at this.. one can always give up all ethics and do business with anyone on the planet, then we just create a more chaotic world where money reigns supreme.. or one could proceed keeping ethics in mind. and move towards a more just world.. IMO it is needed..and this is not must with India, USA-China have entered a trade war. Naturally the whole world will feel he impact of that
This very same Abhijit Iyer Mitra used to be far more honest about Modi (from a Hindu and pro nationalistic Indian pov not a Libtard, woke or secular perspective) but then something changed almost overnight about a year back. Maybe he got threatened or got some favors I dont know but he changed his tune. He was one of the best political, geopolitical commentators on or from India to listen to when he used to be honest.
Why don't you come out and say what you really mean instead of beating around the bush ?
@@ramrao668 Lol what beating around the bush? I hate Modi and not because he is anti Muslim or a Fascist as the Congress and left says. No because Modi is vehemently against Hindus in his policies. Abhijit used to agree and criticize Modi nonstop from a Hindu perspective but they got to Abhijit somehow.
Nice one
Six months ago,there were 3 of Indian Army's, Navy's and Air force's chiefs were visited Taiwan and it's a huge things.
And you are falling into the trap of divide and rule of the west , good luck with that
Lovely discussion.... Informative.... Thank you sir.....😊
Please interview Dr.Ankit Shah and Dr.Abhisek Mishra....
Interviewed Ankit already. Will reach out the other gentleman
What is India doing in the BRICS?
Russia
Opportunity ⁉️
Making sure BRICS doesn't become the next EU with Xaina being the hegemon
Defending India's interests from within BRICS. Same thing Chyna and Russia are doing in the BRICS and in the UN Security Council.
Can't let chyna take over russia, have to maintain a balance
I suppose India would also help Taiwan with IT, ethical hacking and protecting Taiwan IT infrastructure & attacking Chinese IT infrastructure.
Also, India under Modi governance is trying to get permanent seat at UN and being a net security provider in and around Asia Pacific/Indo Pacific.
Also, the GDP per capita is still low. And talented Indians leave India and settle in USA. Research and development is still lacking in India. And reservations are leading to Indians migrating to other countries for career opportunities.
Gobar logic , Jaatpaat making india rich😂😂😂😂
Abhijit has a world view and knowledge beyond being an India interpreter. It might surprise you to know that we have opinions about other countries too. You should consider listening to them. He can also give everyone some history lessons. Not the revisionist kind that they might be used to.
Once a servant always a servant
Too many commies 🤣
What spy ballon?
What had china done to you so far aside from the borders dispute.
Reasi pilgrim attack was indirectly done by china
Illegally and forcibly occupied Tibet which has historically been a buffer state between India and China. Provided nuclear weapons to Pakistan for no other reason than to spite India. On going oppression of the ordinary Chinese people. Mercantilist trading policies. Is that enough reasons ?
@@ramrao668
Isn’t true India Government official recognize that Tibet is part of China? Btw, you forgot to mention Taiwan in your complaint.
So nothing. Those are all China's internal issues and nothing to do with India.
China trades peacefully with every country in the world, that's one of your reasons to hate China? Lol.
LOL. I enjoy the delusions of Abhijit very much. Him being wrong about chaar so bar is hilarious.
If you like hilarious , you should read that book where a man rode a donkey to space 😂😂
Hilarious 😂
Ha Ha, giant babaa,what yee know?
@@doublehit1 that is hilarious.. char so par, kiya hogaya yaar
@@wolfwolf7246 i know nothing. But i know char so par did not happen. Did it or is my godi math wrong?
@@hussainshiyam who care about that, Modi ji still up there.
How long did it take India to build her first air-craft carrier or even her little destroyer?
Go to school kid 😂, which weed you are smoking. India already built an aircraft carrier and many destroyers already. Just Google it instead of being a laughing stock
Can you make one, lol.
China is hazemon in this region
Abhi, this will be tough! Because the Papus and Mainos will ensure every Muslim and Christian support China. Also all who China funds. Great mistake Modiji and Manipur!!!
Modiji has to watch it!!
China is a Civilizational State , an enduring civilization . It has historically been a leader and a world power .
India is a western creation , a salmagundi of immigrant and local cultures , certainly not a civilization like China .
India has been a story of military defeats and a cowardly native population .
Being a middle power is like an epochal elevation for India , I'd say .
BTW, i don't think India is going to last long as a political union .
you've been saying that for 70 years now LOL
Tineaman square no elections covid secret missing politician missing sports person a long long list you don't know what civilization is 😅
NO ONE TAKES INDIA "SERIOUSLY" !!!!
Wait for one decade and US will be licking India feet... with condition Modi is our PM
???
❓
This guy is not only a fool living in his paradise but most of his theories are picked from others.
AIM is probably too carried awat by his self obsessions. India has always been thought leaders be it Adi Sankara, Ashoka,Ayurveda,Yoga,Nalanda, Nonviolence of MKG ....Its true we haven't attacked other countries militarily or led an initiative to attcak which is what qualifies for multilateral leadership these days.
He still has a very colonized mindset when it comes to geopolitics.
Why links or compares India with China? They are not relevant 😂
😂😂😂This dude representing India 😂😂😂haha
To be fair Abhijit is a brrath of fresh air conpared to the REST of Godi media ...at least there is a semblance of, if not pretense of intellectual parlance. The rest of Godi media , unlike Abhijit cannot find their Arse! 😂😂😂
Dude of you want real military strategy listen to Major General Rajeev Naranyan or another veteran. Listening to this EX HM graduate ( with no background in military operations) give his take is a waste of time at least in military strategy. Might be valuable in geopolitics though
what media you like, left wing media like the Wire ? The communist manifesto is the height of intellectual pretense LOL
Sores money for report
Again the BS about interoperability. India doesn't induct important naval vessels/assets that can't "talk" to each others.
That's is Congress followers' mentality. Ghandism. Not Subash Chandra boss mentality . Abijith is very pessimistic.
ARE YOU A BENGALI. 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔😕😕😕😕😕😕😁😁😁😁
SUBHASH CHANDRA BOSE WAS A BENGALI , JUST LIKE ME HINDU BRAMAN BENGALI INDIAN. 👍👍👌👌👏👏🤩🤩❤❤🥰🥰😍😍😊😊
Subhas Chandra Bose, who was a member of the Congress, bestowed the title of "Father of the Nation" upon Mahatma Gandhi. He was an exceptionally intelligent and strategic thinker.
AND NOT LIKE YOU
" TOP FLOOR COMPLETELY EMPTY … TAN ,TAN,TAN". NOTHING INSIDE EMPTY VESSEL. ONLY NOISE
Where did you learn to read and write in English?🤢🤢🤢🤢😁😁😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣.
Kale angrej.
This guy is all talk, too biased and ignorant. If china attacks Taiwan or blockade taiwan, India is going to give them everything they want other than weapons and India is in some anti China bloc with USA?
Hahaha. India has never done anything to goo against China or supported western lies or allegations like at the UN.
This Indian guy over rates not just indias capability, but Indian will itself. Or rather the lack of any will.
India too weak to stand up and go against USA and west, and also too scared to go against China in a real forceful way and display of strength and show it's 100% independent and autonomous. India always has excuses and plays victim and tries to play all sides against each other, since it's not strong enough to do anything else and stand up by itself to do everything it wants. And even if it wants to, it does not have the ability.
Like India "sanctioning" or punishing China by banning a few useless apps. India still needs China more than China needs India. India needs China to be strong and to be Indias shield and leverage so India can do deals with USA and West etc.
If china was not strong, India could never even do things like keep supporting Russia and buying oil and making polite snarky comments about EU being hypocrites etc over Russia but India can never talk like that to USA.
AIM ka maal lag raha hai 🤣🤣🤣🤣❤️
This guy discovered has just figured out the perfect formula to exploit the Algorithm.
If he wants to talk about India, it's best that he brings an Indian guest. I don't see the harm in that.
I’m here to engage multiple perspectives and that requires / is the decent thing to engage people from the region and challenge existing views.
@@theglobalgambit Then why don't you suggest this youtuber about which other guests he should bring?. Plz tweet it to him your suggestion list, instead of crying here.
@@theglobalgambit 😄 no man I didn't mean anything personal, it's good you are bringing in multiple views but I just wanted to comment on how the videos where you invite abhijit get the most views ans now he is coming more frequently.
Nonsense person
Disagree in most of the things except climate pacts.
😂Abhijit Iyer is Modi's favorite poster boy ...in a discussion on multilateralism and India's role , Abhijit, almost as a knee jerk felt compelled to bring up Modi and his supposed ability to shed anti-colonial baggage. It takes a lot of dishonesty to say that because almost every election speech that Modi delivered was laced with colonial baggage poiniting to India's Muslim rulers...he incessantly went on about Mughals, Muslims, Mutton, Machlee and Mujrah. We all know what all that rhetoric pointed to... now don't we Abhijit Iyer Mitra? 😅😂😂
In politics sometimes speeches are as per the public u are addressing requirements..not necessarily the views of speaker..only politics compulsion to a extent ...get real abba
Why supposed ability? The shift is real. Read the newspapers and look around.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 yeah imagine being this darn derànged that even bringing up Modi on discussion that is literally centered around Modi and his role gets yóū so riled up 🤣🤣🤣
i can only imagine how bútthúrt yóū were while typing this 🤣
knowing how much Modi actually has done on ground even if he didn't necessarily talk about it in his speeches,
btw i just can't help but be amused at the epitomy dishonesty the likes of yóū have the ability to pull off by making stuff out of nothing convincing people that's what happened and nothing shall move forward until the supposed accountability is addressed and still have the cónniving audacity to accuse others of "dishonesty",
no where has Modi actually said anything about Múslims, "Ghuspaithiya" was supposed to mean illegal Bangladeshi ímmigrants but here we are addressing the non existent bígòtry in Modi's speech while yóū prepare for another round of baseless accusations to corner Modi.
Abhijit has 0 knowledge about how Indian defense equipment works 🤨🤨he is completely idiotic in this field and yet he multiple times brag in such issues like aircraft carrier , different source of equipment - it makes me puke
for a second i though you'd actually know something about where he's wrong.. .but since you have trouble stringing a sentence together coherently, you're likely not educated enough to be in the know... :/
@@anonymouslyopinionated656- must be a leftist or a mullah
@@anonymouslyopinionated656 what does knowledge in defense has to do with education ? what does education has to do with my sentence structure particularly in english , when i can be not a guy from literature studies ? Now lets come to the point out intra and inter operability of our systems in defense equipments - *the only issue are -1> getting permission from the suppliers to integrate the equipment within our ecosystem, which we mostly do get due easily (except from usa) but it consumes time in paperwork and diplomatic talks -if they don't give it , we go for other less nice options , 2> the integration for new systems take more time as we have to ensure smooth transitions and transmissions in systems, 3- logistics for maintenance cost us more . there is absolutely no such things as we can't operate them together, it's hilarious to even think like that - we have money and suppliers to either pay enough or to negotiate for other options
WE WANT FREE KHALISTAN
Empty boobs?
Make in kanada.
why do muslims like you want khalistan
Magnus Carlson interested in international politics
Everything he said about intra compatibility is absolute horseshit
Sorry Mitra--we Indians have always been leaders---not in your face kind---meaning-we do not have to tell anyone we will lead them--but the way we conduct ourselves---others ask us to be their voice--or lead them. Many centuries ago---people came from other countries to study at our universities---because we were leaders in various fields, even now--as you said --India is the global South leader. No we will never be in the middle of the pack.
PRO INDIAN NEO CONS PROPOGANDA DOGS 😅😅😅
❤ AIM