Thai national recounts experience as hostage in Gaza amid Israel-Hamas war
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 12. 2023
- Twenty-three Thai nationals held hostage in Gaza were released during the temporary cessation of fighting between Israel and Hamas last week. One former hostage, who is now back home with his family in Udon Thani, shared his experience of how he was kidnapped and kept in an underground tunnel for almost two months. The reunion is bittersweet for other families to witness, given the uncertainty surrounding the return of their loved ones who are still missing in the war zone. CNA's Saksith Saiyasombut reports. Read more: cna.asia/3uL0QbW
Subscribe to our channel here: cna.asia/youtubesub
Subscribe to our news service for must-read stories:
Telegram - cna.asia/telegram
WhatsApp - cna.asia/whatsapp
Follow us:
CNA: cna.asia
CNA Lifestyle: www.cnalifestyle.com
Facebook: / channelnewsasia
Instagram: / channelnewsasia
Twitter: / channelnewsasia
TikTok: / channelnewsasia
That mother just left in the dark. She's a strong woman. I'll send her prayers🙏
Your filthy prayers are the very base of this war
Tantura documentary.. it reveals that everything Israel claims is a lie. Look it up.
🕊❤️🩹.
I feel so sad for that mom, I hope her son comes home.
Sorry for the mom! No sorrow for the son!
Unfortunately this statement reflects the coldness and lack of empathy for men by society.
@@mikemoir9600true 👍
@@mikemoir9600 🤣😂🤣Keep crying dude, the wafer’s just giving condolences to the mother.
From ancient conmen and modern conmen enslaved the people not only in Gaza but around the world they make fun impoverished 38 percent poverty and hunger deprivation while this.terrorists leaders turn billionaires using the.people they should represent for.amassing.of wealth .....😢😢😢😢
@@mikemoir9600You are wrong. Thais prize personal self control. It doesn't mean they lack empathy.
Why ins't the answer to the question on how he was treated shown in this video? The reporter says he was beaten, but why not show the part where he says that himself?
yes..something wrong with the reporter..
Surprised anyone can understand the reporter at all, he mumbles his words so much both in Thai and English. And then he has the audacity to mention the beating which the hostage didn’t mention. They shouldn’t employ him 🤦♀️
Because you don't ask victims about their trauma. At least civilised and educated people don't.
I was wondering the same. Why they didn't show him saying that? did he not say it, or did he say something else and the choose to twist it to sound as if he was treated badly!!
@@muniram.810
Well from the experience with western media these days covering the war and the hostages statements, they have been twisting everybody's statement so it would fit their pro-israeli propaganda. You can checkout theri full testimony in other channels and you'll be shocked how much the differences between them. It'll give a hole new story from a completely different angle.
I travelled the world and found the Thai people to be the most respectful, kind and humble people. Love Thai.
You must not be burmese
a lot of tourist scams in thailand.
Most people do a 2 week holiday in Bangkok. You need to spend a longer time in the villages and get to know the people.
Pray for the rest of them to return home safely.
I hope this mother finds her son and that the rest of the hostages are returned safely. It is terrible that they were caught up in a conflict that has nothing to do with them. Having to work abroad to earn a living is hard in itself.
@@mmmm-br5qr Indeed.
@@mmmm-br5qryou wish. 😂Continue to cry😂
@@mmmm-br5qr I doubt these Thais know anything about the history or politics of the area. They are just trying to survive.
Than what about all those palestini children who are under isra*li army and alot of in jail with no charges... they all are hostages too... theyvr innocent too mire than half are children and women. They all r civilians and what about more than 20,000 palestini who were killed by IDF by knowing that they r civilians, what about premature babies that IDF didn't allowed Dr. To evacuate them and they were died in hospital as everyone evacuate and no one were there to care them and they died in incubators what about them?????? R those babies were fighting with them? R they had we@pons???? Nobody answer that?
Tantura documentary.. it reveals that everything Israel claims is a lie. Look it up.
Holding civilians hostage is one of the worst war crimes.
Look into Israel prisons...they have about 6k for years, some with no charges pressed
''When Hong Kong demonstrators throw stones at the police in Hong Kong that's considered to be heroism in the American press.
When in Myanmar, the demonstrators throw slingshot stones at the oppressive army, they're considered to be heroes in the Western press.
When Palestinian kids throw stones and rocks at the oppressive Israeli army, they're called terrorists.''
-- Gabor Mate, a Holocaust survivor
@@annamariana8140 yeah we did they looked like had a good time.
I mean they look like they ate very well.
What about the hostages they ate nothing?
Hamas starved them
Did you condemn Israel for kidnapping Palestinian children and take them as hostage in their prisons?
NO. Don't act as if you are concern.
The history of Israel regime controlling the lives of Palestinians didn't start a few weeks ago!
@@123mikey1000 The hostages themselves claimed they ate what Hamas ate.
I am Thai/ Jewish. So happy for all released & pray for others to return home safely. I also am hoping innocent palestinian children& their caregivers escape this too:(
For that to happen is for Nazi Isreal to grant freedom from occupation to the Palestinians who's land had been stolen
Lols thai also have middle eastern dna hahaha
they are small Thai Muslims but you cant convert to become Jewish @@baikorg
Do you mean that you are Thai who convert to Judaism or you inherited Jewish blood ?.
😂😂first time i heard thai Jewish,next indian jewish
those poor families, my heart goes out to them, I hope their loved ones return to them soon
Palestinians too
🇮🇱
Their karma was they went to an apartheid state to make money and ignored Palestinian rights, so bad things happened.
@@sasachiminesh1204. The evil of Hamas is not the fault of anyone but Hamas.
@@PowerandControlUFU 😂😂😂😂
Thank you for reporting on this. I pray for all the hostages and their safe return 🙏
Isreal doesnt care about their hostages
Amen. ☁️🎺👼🙏✨🌹
Their karma was they went to an apartheid state to make money and ignored Palestinian rights, so bad things happened.
@@sasachiminesh1204 palestinians go to work in israel for more money from gaza, they should get the same fate. no double standards
@@sasachiminesh1204. Palestinian is not in the qur'an, Israel is.
I was very shocked to see the people from Thailand when some of the hostages were released, and to find out there are so many of them that work there is just a big surprise. I hope for peace for everyone.
@@Sa_m-sam As did Qatar and other rich Middle Eastern countries
@@whowanttoknow2611 im not Arab… what has Qatar to do with me? And is Qatar bmbing kids??? Is Qatar an Apartheid?
@@Sa_m-sambro they're being paid and can actually go home unlike in the gulf states.
@@whowanttoknow2611They shouldn't go to the middle east then.
@@Sa_m-samfor 1800 dollars? Plz let me be their slave too 😂. You have no ideia how much money it is in a poor country
"Between 2008 and 2013, a total of 122 Thai workers died in Israel, according to figures provided by Israeli Health Minister Yael German to Israeli daily Ha'aretz.
Out of the 122 dead, 43 died from "sudden nocturnal death syndrome", a mysterious death during the night while sleeping, according to an HRW report.
Such deaths, according to Phil Robertson, deputy director of the Asian division of HRW, have never been investigated by Thai or Israeli governments. In an interview, Robertson said 173 Thai workers interviewed by non-governmental organisation Kav LaOved had complained of long hours, being paid below the minimum wage, and not receiving proper equipment to protect themselves from the use of pesticides"
They won’t mention this
They want to keep things silenced.
@@ibraheem911 No, just like UAE, Saudi and others won't mention how they beat and torture them and keep them from leaving the country.
This is a very common heart syndrome in southeast asia. remember between 2008 and 2013 tens of thousands of thais worked in Israel, so it makes sense 43 would have this rare heart syndrome.
yes minimum wage workers have bad conditions this isn't new and isn't special for Israel. but look at the 1800$ a month they are getting paid this is much more than what foreign workers are getting paid anywhere in the middle east: including UAE, Qatar, Saudi Arabia... where those foreign workers live like animals and can't even return back. 122 is very low compared to how much they die in Qatar or UAE.
what is your point...
It saddens me as I sit here in Bangkok that all these Thai people had to go and some still going through this. The Thai people are such nice and humble people and they went to Israel for betterment of pay to help support their families - they did not deserve this - no one does 😥 🇹🇭 🇮🇱 ☮
Every Thai worker I've met had been extremely nice and respectful. Sad to see them go, but it's also understandable. It's rough down here.
I've never met an unpleasant Thai person.
@@clutternutjack3995 In which country did you meet them?
Is it fair to assume that most Jews in the west will defend Israel but don't want to move there .. because they're afraid of being targeted for living on stolen land?
.... So in order to sustain its settlements, Israel must hire labour from poor foreign countries
@@clutternutjack3995
That's the opposite of my experience. Friendly, helpful people whether they were Israeli Jews, Christians, and Muslims. I met them in the US and Israel.
I met some in Seoul, too. Israelis are very nice people.
Crazy world! Poor people!🙏🙏🙏 for the lives of hostages!
*Lets pray for the millions innocent civilians inside Gaza*
Are there millions? Who is innocent?
Not the members of hamas, pij, or other terrorist groups and their familes.
Not the Palestinians who joined hamas in brutal slaughtering on October 7th;
Not the Palestinians who filled the streets of Gaza to torment the hostages;
Not the Palestinians who used to fill the streets of Gaza shouting: "death to America, death to Israel;"
Not the Palestinians who launched rockets or incendiary balloons into Israel killing humsn life, wildlife, and plant life;
Not the journalists who write lies about the war;
Not the doctors who provide misleading casualty numbers;
Not the doctors who treated a hostage and then let her be murdered;
The teenage hamas combatants.
So who is innocent:
Christians, babies, toddlers, and undoctrinated Palestinians who managed to steer clear of hamas.
Don't forget guys. This is not the first time Hamas took not only Israeli hostages but also foriegn hostages.
You do not learn from the FM, IM, and PM that the settlers, supported by white settlers from the USA and the Anglo-Saxon countries, are committing a pogrom to remove Palestinians from Xrael to the mantra of the Likud, "From the River to the Sea, where there are only Yews."
Driven by Xrael Hannibal Directive and motivated by the 10000 held hostage by Xrael, with acknowledgement from AIPAC and USA.
@@ZhenYaePalestine never existed when jews came back to that land.
@@merniuexobias2208 There you go. The state of Israel never existed either.
@@merniuexobias2208 And the inhabitants have always been there. USA never existed either until the White Settlers went to the Americas - Chosen as it were.
I pray that mother's son comes home to her.
Look into her face one of the saddest faces I ever saw. A mother is despair.
Allah will shun these people for what they did.
No way he was beaten. He MUST say that!
I'm truly sorry for all the Thai workers and their families who had to go through this horrible experience. Hamas is worse than ISIS. and those who justify radical Islamic terror are just as guilty as those who carried out the barbaric acts committed by Hamas on October 7th.
Imagine how the Palestinians feel . If Israel wasn’t so criminal and barbaric it wouldn’t of happened
@@rebeccablossom9823if Hamas didn't massacre last October 7 they will not target Hamas. Palestinian works on Israel. Even Gazan blame Hamas
@@rebeccablossom9823 Your head is upside down. who kidnapped those Hostages?
who is holding hostages? who butchered 1200 innocent civilians?
but convincing a donkey that he's an elephant is not always easy.
seek psychiatric help ASP.
who kidnapped the hostages? WHole of PALENSTINE is HOSTAGe.... now they're treating these occupiers the same way yet you call this logic backwards?@@JadeB628
Learn some FACTS!
History.
@@JadeB628you are the one who needs psychiatric help. You forget about 6 Oct.. 5 Oct tell the doctor you suffer from dementia…
How can the UN ask for ceasefire but not ask Hamas to release hostages
They have a condition to release these hostages.. why can't they comply?
israel is not keeping to any of the agreements! the hostages also get bombed by israel genius!
There are 58 members in the Organization of Islamic Countries, some of them hold the power of oil and gas, e.g. the chief sponsor of Hamas is Qatar that exports 21% of global LNG.
@@greenglitter3058 Nope.
Hamas broke the ceasefire when it was just hours old. Israel didn't retaliate.
On the second hostage release, hamas almost missed the deadline. They were pressured by Qatar to comply with the agreed upon terms.
The ceasefire would have lasted, but hamas wasn't going to release the agreed upon hostages.
Hamas was the first to attack after the ceasefire ended.
Do you enjoy posting lies? Are you a bot?
What have Thai nationals got to do with the conflict?
Why did Singapore sanction Russia and not big countries like the USA and IxReal invading and occupying others.
PAP and CNA do call out the dictators in the US, Xreal, UK and Brussels.
They worked for Isra elis in the occupied territory... .
@@Liboch You're going around in circles with your conclusion.
@@wangchung7599Just like the FM, IM, PM going in circles about making principled stand.😁.
So sad for these people.Praying from Canada.
@@GreenHills-rl8irjesus is a prophet of allah.
@@boodymoai898ISA? 😂
@@GreenHills-rl8ir. Amen, Yeshua ha’Mashiach is King of Kings & LORD of Lords.
all praise Odin
The truth is Even tawrah says it's not esrael land ddd look
Israelis, they disobeyed God’s command and killed the prophets and did very bad badd things, so God punished them by depriving them of it God said in the Qur’an after they disobeyed His commands So God forbade it for them
Even in the books of the Torah, God said, “The lands of your enemies.”
This definitely indicates that it is not your land
🤍The books of the Torah, as it was mentioned in the Book of Leviticus in the twenty-sixth chapter
36And on those who remain among you, I will cast cowardice into your hearts in the lands of their enemies, and they will be defeated by the sound of a rushing leaf, and they will flee like fleeing from a lion. So, they fall and there is no one to chase. 37And they will stumble against one another as before the sword, and there is none that can pursue, and you will not have standing before your enemies. 38And you will perish among the peoples and be devoured. The land of your enemies. 39And those who remain among you will be consumed in your iniquities in the lands of your enemies.🤍
And it came in the book of Deuteronomy, chapter twenty-eight, which reads: 63 And just as the Lord rejoiced over you to do good to you and multiply you, so the Lord rejoices over you to consume you and to destroy you, and you will be rooted out of The land that you are entering to possess. 64And the Lord will scatter you among all the people from one end of the earth to the other, and you will serve there other gods, which you have not known, neither you nor your fathers, of wood. And a stone.
65And in those nations you will not rest, nor will there be rest for your foot, but there the Lord will give you a trembling heart, and fainting of eyes, and a fainting of the soul. 66And your life will hang in the balance before you, and you will be terrified day and night, and you will not be sure of your life. 67In the morning you say, “I wish it were evening,” and in the evening you say, “I wish it were morning,” for the fear of your heart that you terrify, and the vision with your eyes that you see.🤍,
You know the truth well, so you run away and are very afraid. You killed the prophets and did very bad badd things , so God forbade the Holy Land for you, but remember. hell is so painful for ever watch near death experience on CZcams and life is very short save your self
So sad. Everyday people just want to live their lives in peace and happiness, but the narrowminded hatred of our leaders denies this to them.
The sad thing is to be used to work as a slave in occupied lands.
@@boodymoai898They are paid well and send their extra income home to their families. That's why so many do it. They also can leave at any time, whenever they choose. Israel is the safest and fairest Middle Eastern country to work in that way. They are not slaves. There are countries where this sort of work degrades into that very quickly, but Israel is not one of them.
@@maryamjoha Working as slaves for children killers, horrific!
@@boodymoai898 slave? 😂 Slaves make money now? Slaves also choose to be slaves.? Well atleast you know some people did choose slavery to survive under a great house
Which leaders!?
Terrorists attacked them and took them hostage. They have no leaders. They have Hamas who opress thwir felliw Mislim brothers and go hide in tunnels like mice.
You can clearly see in the video, Hamas rockets coming from civilian buildings
Bo Hamas ma gdzieś Palestyńczyków!
Oh, these poor Fakestinians!
This alone is a lost for Israel workforce. Foreigners will be scared to come over to work.
they couldn’t even protect their own people, and killer them ‘accidentally’. ofc foreigners would think twice now
Justice is a prerequisite for peace. No one should be oppressed in his own land. Palestinian civilians have suffered 75 years and still on going.
@@khaderlander2429
Exactly bro , thank you for saying this ❤❤❤
@@khaderlander2429 Yep, these workers who came to help build the occupation not caring about the crimes it commits frequently can get to their home and be safe anytime, but the Palestinians are already in their homeland and are treated much worse than the Africans in america were treated.. no human will take that for too long
And rightfully. Why would a foreigner risk their life. Poverty pushes us anywhere but better be careful.
Thai workers have played a vital role in the Israeli economy for years. My heart goes out to those killed, captured, or traumatized. Sending love and support to all, hoping for their safety and quick release, along with the Israeli hostages. From Tel Aviv with love 🇮🇱 ❤ 🇹🇭
How about 76 years occupation
@@parlindungandongoran3180почему 76?1400лет арабы окупирую земли Иудеи.
При чем тут Тайландцы.
So you're saying these poor Thai workers and others being killed and kept hostage is justified? is that what you're implying? Shame on you@@parlindungandongoran3180
@@user-fz5wo1fp8yработали тут!!! И заробатывали очень хорошо
if you really think Hamas is a resistance group, you're Hamas.
They are no different from the PLO except more brutal. The PLO has successfully created plenty of civil unrest in the neighboring countries that the nearby Arab refused to accept them as refugees for the fear of civil war within the host countries. Just ask Jordan and Lebanon what happened to them when they hosted Palestinians as refugees.
They're hummus not hamas
Thailand never being colonized, that's why you never know what is occupation and colonilaism. Israeli atrocities against Palestinians have been going on for decades before Hamas was formed.
What is idf? Terrorist organisation?
@@titikyulianti2897Before Hamas:
Palestine Islamic jihad, Al-aqsa martyrs brigade, PRC, DFLP, PFLP, PLO, PFLP-GC, Hakarat al-sabireen, PLF etc
Palestinian terrorist organizations kept on murdering Israeli civilians even when Egypt and Jordan occupied Palestine and there was no jewish settlement.
i feel so bad for him, but why you are tr one telling us he was beating and not himself telling this?? kind of suspicious
This is deplorable, that these 31 Thai nationals went through such extreme experiences and they are not related to Israel/Palestinian conflict. I believe many Thai workers were murdered in the fields too. Sincere condolences to all the Thai families who experienced this torture and even those who lost their lives. May G0d Bless these families.
Do you leave the people who came as labor in your ancestors land for work?
These people put food in the mouths of Palestinian's oppressors. Thus, they are helping oppressing Palestinians. They should reconsider what they are doing.
Everybody are related to “Israely/ Palestinian” conflict since it is civilized world/ Islamic barbarity conflict. Islam is trying to dominate everybody.
Yes, I heard that there are hostages killed from the bombardment on Gaza. I don't remember where I heard it but I think it was from the released lady hostage who was yelling at their Prime Minister for bombing Gaza because the hostages were all there and her husband is still there. I think she also said something like while they were held captive, they were afraid Israeli soldiers might come and kill them at any moment. Perhaps she meant accidentally?
Of course the hostage families, Israeli and not, are afraid they will die from the bombs. But the fact is that in the last week several bodies of hostages were found, clearly executed. Why the hell kidnap and murder people who have nothing to do with this? There is a video of an immigrant worker getting beheaded with a hoe. These are crimes against humanity, are you seriosly trying to play them down?@@stephaniejaboh8929
My heart goes out to her. May her son be found soon and may she and all the families of those harmed by Hamas be comforted.
If you only knew she is just putting up a show. I lived for 8 years in her town. This is not how people react to actual sadness. She is more sorry about the missed income and acting in front of the camera. I'm not trying to downplay the fact being taken hostage is terrible by the way, and for the guy it was of course not fun in any way, just informing you that it's not all what it seems. The hostages were treated good by the Palestinians btw.
@@chanimal66 So she's not actually sad for the loss of her son but for the loss of income? Manee was treated good such that he does not want to go back even for such economic gain?
@@emstut First question yes that's what her behavior looks like to me, second, he probably realized it wasn't okay to work in an apartheit colony. His job was probably not amazing too. He can work elsewhere anyways. Lots of Thais go to Japan and Korea, more income and safer.
israel need to stop the war!
And to those harmed by the IOF… stop the madness before more get hurt.
I am so happy they are still willing to come back to Israel despite of his tragic experience🥹
5:48 Actually, he isn't, and who can blame him? The others only stayed because they were living in poverty before and desperately need the money.
Extremely beautiful countryside
I know, if only they were intelligent people they could make a living in their own country.
@@camelliam.4235 How do you know they're not intelligent? Maybe they are more intelligent than you but haven't been afforded the same opportunities.
@@tylerd8245 If you are intelligent, you create your own opportunities. They have an incredible country with alot of potential. Do you realise they go to Israel to work in the desert? If Israelis can grow agriculture on sand, under rocket fire, image what they could do. Anyway, maybe they have a corrupt government, I don't know.
@@camelliam.4235I live in Thailand. The wage structure is low, no matter how hard Thais work. In addition, business of all kinds is extremely competitive. Until you have lived in a country with this kind of economic structure you will not fully understand. The money earned abroad may well constitute the capital to start a viable business, or buy more land to farm. As a young rural Thai he was behaving intelligently according to the circumstances of Thailand.
Yes, I live in the adjoining province.
Hamas NEVER should have taken these people hostage to begin with! Absolute outrage!
I believe they wouldn't if not for the thousands of Palestinians who were held in prisons without charges, many are women and children. As the Thai negotiator said; the cries of the Palestinians were never heard until Hamas took Israeli hostages to do the hostage-exchange. Having said this tho, I still pray hostages will be returned safe. All of them. For both sides. Prayer and safety for them, they should never experience it, and I really pity the Thai hostages who most of them aren't even aware of the conflict 🙏
@SherryRiku94 But he's not Israeli. You are Supporting Hamas to kidnapped other nationalty?
@@kelechijeremiah4465 Who asked him to work in an aparthied state which practices brutal occupation?
@@kelechijeremiah4465hamas are the children who have been orphaned by Israel years ago 😊
Don’t expect to be violent and not get a fight back
They took hostages but never treated them bad they provided them with everything they needed on the other hand idf imprisoned children and women and released them beaten up and abused children with broken arms and one had half of his skull off his head !!!! They wanted those innocent prisoners out and this was the ONLY way
Thailand needs to improve the living conditions in such rural areas so that the people don't have to go abroad to find work, especially not to the Middle East.
Like 80% of the world? Good luck. You want cheap goods, too.
Not so easy. I live in Thailand. No magic formulas here.
Especially not in Israel
@@utubebeena I think many Thais will eventually go back to Israel, especially if they are offered higher wages. They will just refuse to work on the Gaza or Lebanon border.
@@utubebeenaBingooo yep, do not go to a country for work, that is currently at war..I mean who does that?
Praying for the return of Kanmee's son 🙏🏻
Bless the Thai workers who helped a lot in Israel farms, so sad they mostly left Israel😢
It’s a bad idea to work on a stolen property 😊😊😊😊
@@salahali2710Palestine is a lie. Yassir Arafat the 1st leader was Egyptian. Palestinians are Egyptian decent. Not Jewish or Arab.
Immigrants and temporary laborers are underpaid and mistreated regularly in Israel, often having their passports held.
@@lavendeer6290
Source? Names? Cities?
Have you ever been in Israel? I met an Israeli consultant to Kenya. His brother owns a farm and stays in the same dormitory as his Thai workers.
The gentleman interviewed about his experience as a hostage didn't say anything bad about his Israeli employers.
@@lavendeer6290false,israel has a high wages compare to arab neighboring, and also israeli treat their migrant worker human unlike other arab nation, they treat like animal especially those who work in a household
Hams sees these workers as workers, helping to colonise their land. Hard not to be mad at them
hamas said they were on a jihad. The brutal slaughtering by them and Palestinians had nothing to do with anything other than hate.
Israel has citizens of several religions, races, and ethnicities. There is no forcing citizens to be one religion. There is no colonization in Israel. It's a democracy. Democracy and colonization are mutually exclusive.
In Gaza, hamas colonized. They imposed their theocracy on Muslims and Christians alike. Check out the photos. One thing hamas doesn't stage is women covering their hair and dressing in long sleeves. Check out how hot it gets there. Women had no choice. Married women needed written permission from a MAN to leave their homes. It was similar to living in Iran.
What was the purpose of Hamas taking Tia's as hostages? Only thing I can see was to cause pain & great distress to innocent ppl.
You also need to report on the released hostages of the Israeli prisons, the children and the women. So that you understand the way your beloved Israel was dealing with them in prisons, the beating, the starvation, and the SA.
Starvation? U must hv seen them healthy and robust.
Unlike the hostages, they have to undergo agony and torment to see their loved ones and neighbors being killed right in front of their own eyes b4 being taken away. So, how about have u seen the inside of the Gaza prisons? None? Really? Well, u won't see them because they are either dead, killed or tortured. U choose one.
So there is no comparison, really!
@@TheBubblydimpleLiar.
C'mon don't say such things about Raelis, we all know how nice they are, like poneytails. Ooooooh i want one of them, poneytails are so cute and kind.
I'll give you just one example which is easy to fact-check.
When in Israeli jail, prisoners get medical care and even more. Yahya Sinwar, convicted terrorist, was operated on brain there, his tumour removed. He's healthy now, and gratefully operating as no.1 in hamas hierarchy.
Not sure that everywhere in the world everyone can easily afford qualified surgical aid like that
@@marymay3343 Oh ok it happens sometimes you guys have your heart back in your chest. Great news everyone, they don't keep on killng people, they also give medical care when the prison chef is on holiday.
Dissapointingly short testimony from the hostage themselves. They should have asked more questions.
Stop lying, He didn't say that he was beaten by Hamas, but fed and kept safe.
Kept safe from what!
Why is do important to you? He has no motivation to lie.
@@oliverduke1173 from Israel's bombs
01:23 240 hostages kidnapped is way more than "at least 31". Maybe 31 migrant workers.
Three hostages were shot dead despite raising white flags.
"In the Shejaiya camp, two men came out, they were not wearing shirts, they had a white flag tied to a stick and they called out in Hebrew, 'Rescue us'".
This is extremely distressing. I cannot fathom how the 3 young guys felt betrayed by their own people. They were so close to getting home safely and were executed like this - shirtless, shouting in Hebrew and waving a white flag. This is so difficult. And not to sound racist, but one of them definitely does not look like an Arab in any way especially if he was shirtless! This was a huge mistake which makes a hostage deal all the more important now more than ever - their families put all their hopes in the IDF and they were let down big time.
Yes, thank you for noticing that one of the three male hostages was a very fair-skinned, redheaded fellow! I've been arguing about this with someone and yes - I've never served in any kind of armed forces especially in a war-zone! So, as my friend rightly keeps pointing out, I really can't comprehend the heat and danger of battle esp urban warfare, one of the worst. But it's driving me crazy and you are the first person (in my readings and video-viewings) to mention this quite obvious fact ~ one of the hostages def didn't look Middle Eastern! You are not being racist at all to acknowledge a very obvious truth!! 👍👍👍
That third guy was shot by two separate units, a clear indication that all of the units were instructed to take no fighter prisoners even if they surrendered!
@@LisaHawkinsHotJavaYes they look white because they're...well, white 😂
Were you in Gaza?
I questioned how it could have happen and listened to a varierty of opinions.
The group of soldiers involved had uncovered toys with bomb and boobytrapped houses in the area. There were other buildings that had similar messages as the building the hostages were using; the other buildings had been boobytrapped. Earlier in this conflict, hamas members had raised a white flag and attacked IDF.
Thankfully, you and I were not there.
@@drdonna4915So how are they raising white flag and attacking at the same time? That news must be fresh from the Hasbara oven 😂
Such kind and humble people, who`s lives have been turned upside down by senseless violence. All lives matter and we need to stop with violence and inequality.
Tell that to Hamas and their allies. They brought this slaughter to civilians, kidnapped people and have refused them medical care and nourishment, and now hide behind their own civilians and steal their provisions.
So much misery made by Hamas, but nobody tells them to stop or demands they release their hostages. They stupidly blame Israel.
This is so sad 😔
No ceasefire while innocent people are held hostage
Huh? A ceasefire is a condition for hostage release. So you're refusing the hostages the to be released???
Taking civilian hostages is Evil, no matter the situation. Please God this dear lady hears the news her heart desires! Praying for all concerned is this hellish nightmare... 🙏
Shitrael still holds 10.000 palestinians as hostages thats 10.000 mothers who hasn't seen their kids if there was no occupation and violence from israel none of this would've happened to begin with
Israel has been taking thousands of women and children as prisoners without any chargers. This is the only way for them to get back their innocent citizens from the Israel war criminals. Besides they treat hostages well. Israel does this even care about any of them when bombing indiscriminately
@@ggggg3459Agreed. Israelis treat prisoners badly, you hear so many stories of that!
@@ggggg3459 NO, Israel has been convicting and incarcerating criminals who attacked Israelis and tried to commit murder. None of the prisoners released in exchange for Hamas hostages were innocent.
The ladies and "children", who were mostly teenagers, had Arab judges presiding at their trials and were convicted of attempted murder or assault with a deadly weapon.
Don't people who attempt to murder someone or who assault someone belong in jail?
“Truce” for the release of Thai captives actually came after a unknown amount of ransoms were paid to the Palestinian terrorists. If these Thai’s ordeal were terrible, think what it was like for the elderly Israeli women and children hostages that are still in the hands of those low lives ..
Israeli women are safer with Palestinians than they were in Israel.
Three out of five Israeli women have reported sexual assault at some point in their life.
source? I thought the mediator for Thai hostages are Thai muslim scholars in Iran and hamas said Thai hostages will be released without any deal
@@fallinjeong5729 trust the terrorists more huh ..?
@@fallinjeong5729 Well Gee seeing as how the video above says NOT ALL HAVE BEEN RELEASED. I think I'll believe that more than some random guy named fallinjeong5729. Wheres' your source? "scholars" ? LOL yeah ok
@@misterknee the source is interview on sky news with the thai negotiator for hostages
Go to any Middle East country spent time at an airport and see how migrant workers are treated. It is appalling. The fact is they couldn’t survive without them but treat them badly is infuriating . No better than western countries. Just more honest in their racism.
Did Israel pay him and his family a major amount of money ? Will they make sure he is O.K ?
Possibility but he did not say much. You can be scared even in another country
Are his employers still alive or were they murdered on Oct 7?
My neighbor country Thailand 🇹🇭.
Horrible ,yt is not allowing more to see the truth! ...
2 Mil subs and very few views and comments , disgusting!
It's so upsetting so many continue to praise hum mus after all these true accounts have been told
I stand with Israel 🇦🇷🙏
Israel has received six times the media coverage than Palestinians in mainstream media. What are you talking about
bro seriously gave the argentinian flag, free argentina!!!!
You are very right while piers Morgan videos have millions and millions of views of whole adults just yelling at each other yet the victims of Hamas are not being given a fair platform it’s pathetic and sad that CZcams is doing this I hope after this whole war victims and Israel sues tiktok and CZcams!!!
Are you okay Falklands belongs to British as an Argentino 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
Start in 1948 first before you go to 2023
How abt an interview of Palestinians released from Israel prison would appreciate tht
It’s so disgusting what Hamas did to these beautiful people, who just wanted to work in peace 🙏🙏
Just like Singaporeans want to get on with their lives but find themselves trapped intimidated into silence about the atrocities committed by the Zhosen.
@@ZhenYae Hamas is a radical Islamic fighters and very similar to ISIS ideology.
Lord God, help find missing son. In Jesus name, Amen.
Where is the part he told you that hamas beat him?
The the truth these wars must stop
Stay safe 🙏🏼💙🙏🏼💙🙏🏼💙
🍉
🍉
The empathy people in these comments are expressing for the hostages while not mentioning the thousands of Palestinians being held hostage in Israeli prisons, including CHILDREN, while suffering horrible conditions is laughable and just outright hypocritical, if you truly cared about human life, you’d first of all be expressing sorrow for the Palestinians and not just as a “both sides are suffering” mouth piece.
Imagine.... people can empathise with more than one side.
Ask Hamas why they went to start a war that they knew will bring suffering to Gaza
Israel is not a terrorist organization and does not take hostages! They don't kidnap innocent children!
There are prisoners. Some are Palestinian children who stabbed people and they are arrested and not allowed to walk freely on the streets for a short while... until Hamas takes hastages and demand many prisoners for each hostage. Then they are free to stab like there is no tomorrow until someone stops them.
You can not compare a child from a peace loving family, kidnapped from their bedroom to a child who stabbed a teenager or an adult. That is a very unfair comparison and incomprehensive reading of the news!
It’s because this video is about the Thai hostage’s experience. Why can’t people express empathy for the hostages, especially when Thais have nothing to do with the conflict? It doesn’t mean that people don’t have the capacity to empathize with more than 1 person.
The international definition of "child" is ftom birth to age 18. The "children" is Israel were teens arrested and convicted for assault with a deadly weapon. Think Columbine High School shooters or Cambodian child soldiers.
The women were arrested and convicted largely for attempted murder.
These people committed crimes and were not innocent.
Each two worker revised 13-15 thousand dollars "compensation by israel, a lot of money for thais, probably years worth of income.
No one would want to jeopardise that
Sounds like they treated him way better than the other side have been with their hostages
😂😂😂...yes...😅considering that the other side never takes any hostages and Hamas takes even fellow Gazan citizens as hostages. Israeli soldiers freed Gazan citizen hostages, whom Hamas teied to keep in a place to make IDF choose between killing citizens or getting killed themselves!
Israel does have prisoners. Only people who were caught to be criminals or terrorists. Israel does not have to commit suicide to satisfy anyone!
What other side?
Israel? Those in Israeli prison were convicted of attempted manslaughter or assault with a deadly weapon (mostly teenagers). Many of these criminals had Arab judges presiding over their trials.
Doesn't your country arrest and prosecute people who try to commit murder?
Yeah but we sent people to civil court not military court. The law is applied equally here and we don’t have a different set of laws for different people. That would be called apartheid.
Is it the norm to segregate people based on race religion ethnicity where you’re from?
@@peterbeater012ever heard of Sharia law? Muslims demand their sharia laws even when I other countries. Israel let them judge themselves by their own Islamic laws because they no doubt demanded it to be "fair." Muslims have a far worse apartheid system then you could ever imagine. They even insist non Muslims be treated at 2nd class citizens and their rights be recognized above anyone else's, even a democratic country with a republic. Israel isn't the only country allowing this religion and it's own apartheid, genocidal tendancies and treatment of it own people. Many others are too. Perhaps Israel has decided enough is enough.
The Israelis must be held accountable for the genocide of innocent Palestinian civilians.
Open your eyes and ears, please! There are 5 thousand km of tunnels built under Gaza, like Moscow metro! Hamas is holding hostages there and constantly producing rockets and other military stuff. Hamas evil system have to be demilitarized. Only in this situation there hardworking people will be able support their families, enjoy life. Very sorry to hear about missing and kidnapped wonderful and beautiful people! It has to be stopped. ❤️
Now the real question is why these mothers would allow their sons to work in an extremist apartheid country like Israel??
Son brings home the money, life to her is not important as long as the son gave her money every month.
Israel is not a country of apartheid. Stop spreading such ridiculous lies.
@@verindictus3639I guess in your world pigs fly??
So he told you he was beaten why didn't you have that on tape and show it to us? maybe because this wasn't true and you just hearsay?
Maybe he wants his dignity. Would you strip to show a mark?
I'm not asking him to strip I just want to hear him saying that he was beaten@@drdonna4915
the difference between how migrant workers are treated in rich arab countries is insane....
Indonesia Pray for Palestine country 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
8-12-2023 Thai Hostage kidnapped by Hamas recalls 50 days of despair in captivity
Anucha Angkaew, a 28-year-old Thai farm worker, was also among them. Fortunately, he was released after 50 days. He said that while in captivity, he and the other hostages kept hope alive by playing chess and reminiscing about their families and the food in their hometown.
He said that Hamas locked them and an Israeli man in a windowless room of about 1.5 square meters and beat them continuously for two days. They continued to beat the Israelis for the next two days and even whipped them with electric wires.
He estimated that he and three other Thais were told they could go home after four days, were moved to a larger room, slept on rubber mats, had better food, and were no longer beaten. The four were handed over to the Red Cross a few weeks later and left Gaza on November 25.
Wrong! Lies! . I can understand basic thai. He said he and others were never abused. This video and translation is not be believed.
@@mars1pluto I think case by case , after Hxmxs realize he is Thai , they stop abuse him.
27-11-2023 On TH news...
Released Thai hostage says he was not abused by Hamas: The food was good.
Vetoon Phoome told his family that he was not tortured or beaten, and that "the food was good and he was well cared for." He also said that he seemed to be arranged to live in a house instead of a tunnel.
33-year-old Vetoon Phoome communicated with his family via video call after his release. His sister Roongarun Wichanguen later told the media about his situation, describing him as having not lost weight and with a smile on his face.
Hahaha ,CNN always liar. Even the translator also twist the translation
Hamas abuses all hostages even their own people
Liessss
Stay safe Thai brothers, It was not your war but you found yourselves paying heavy prices
Almighty G.D bless you and your Families and gives you Peace in Mind🙏🇮🇱🇹🇭
Why support oppression
Oppression will fail sooner than later.
@@mimimiraj7351
No one is supporting oppression!
The oppressors are Hamas, who were elected democraticly but since 2005 did not allow any elections. They took and continue taking all the food and supplies from the Gazan citizens to use it for weapons and feed and protect themselves, not the citizens.
Even the food, sent as human aid, is kept by Hamas and sold to the citizens for outrageous prices!
Keeping the people in Gaza prisoners can only cultivate hatred, and hatred can only lead to violence. And it's always the weakest ones that pay for it. We must realize that there's only one way to live, and it's by respecting other's space and freedom of mind. Everyone is walking their own personal path to maturity. Every path is different. And all of us are quite confused.
Find out who funds each news outlet and then you will understand why they say what they say!
The taking and abuse of hostages is really evil. I pray God protects and blesses them abundantly. Love from Australia 🇦🇺
at least they were returned in good condition and alive. very different from what Israel has done for decades against the Palestinian people.
yes, I agree, Israel should really stop taking and abusing hostages, fortunately for these guys they were held as war captives by the Palestinians, look how they were released without even a scratch, Israel should take notes.
Yes and the genocide against natives in Australia is a bigger evil!!!!i guess apartheid states support each other!!!!
Thailand should revoke their recognition of “PaIiestine”
God is great 👍 stay blessed lucky
I thought it was a prison. How did the thai workers get in.
They worked near the border like only several kilometers away
Karma. Pure and simple. Those who are on stolen land taken by murder, oppression and apartheid should know that they are taking a risk. Palestinians are defending their right to live on their homeland. That you went there to make money is your bad karma.
So what did the Gazans do that it would go so badly for them?
Beaten? Fake News?
2.3b to ukraine. More than 10k for each citizen of Gaza. And they wont even send 1. Not 1k. Just 1. That is how low my expectations have become.
Do not go back. Your life is more important than money. There are places in Israel that are safer. Just not that area, and a lot of others. The safe places won't need foreign workers. You could be a live in nanny/maid in a good area.
Can CNA interview those released from israel prison without trial and charge?
Yes; they were detained because of illegal acts they committed. The end.
can CNA interview all the babies and innocent children and Civilians Hamas so brutally executed?
@@eb9165sure those children “prisoners” did loads of illegal things right. Of course u wouldn’t question Israel just because they “said so”. Typical
@ateeqahparveen8751 I heard the curry is good in Pakistan? And the hummus is even better underground maybe you should go to where hummus is?
@@ateeqahparveen8751you understand when they say "children" in prison it also includes 16 year olds who tried to stab someone? You don't need to live in any other country. Go get your hummus from your Pakistan street vendor and enjoy
why didn't we hear Israel talking about the Thai hostages, i didn't know about them until I saw them being released, also Hamas released them without any exchange. so was Israel planning on leaving them? am not surprised
they probably got paid for their release.
@@3X0SK3L3TON did you see the interview? a Thai minister said that Hamas said to release them without any condition, they told them to wait for proper conditions and ensure that during the exchange of hostages, they were set free
Israel definitely spoke of the Thai hostages. there is also currently a Chinese girl taken hostage, some Tanzanian foreign workers, some French, Russian and German nationals, and a few muslim Arabs (thankfully 2 got released). I learned this from the times of Israel.
@@whiteimposter9304 Dude it is their modus. They kidnapped people for a profit, either by ransom or an exchange of prisoner/s.
@@3X0SK3L3TON The IDF also imprisoned Palestinians for throwing a rock and for 20 years, you call this a crime?
They give this man money to lie
He shook the captors' hand and smiled before going into the van. This scene is very consistent with other hostages' reaction. If the treatment was as he described, would he still able to display such conduct ? I wonder......
I dare say anyone could display such conduct no matter how bad the treatment, if a gun is being pointed to them off camera and they've been told they must act like they love their captors, or be shot. Numerous prisoners who were released from Nazi concentration camps signed statements saying they were well-fed and well treated, after all!
The released hostages said they were drugged. They were also told to smile and wave.
27-11-2023 On TH news...
Released Thai hostage says he was not abused by Hamas: The food was good.
Vetoon Phoome told his family that he was not tortured or beaten, and that "the food was good and he was well cared for." He also said that he seemed to be arranged to live in a house instead of a tunnel.
33-year-old Vetoon Phoome communicated with his family via video call after his release. His sister Roongarun Wichanguen later told the media about his situation, describing him as having not lost weight and with a smile on his face.
he is very lucky among those hostages bec they transfer them from different militants some are stayed in the house ,hotels.our fellow filipino captive is stayed in a tunnel for almost a months.
the western news twisted the fact,they alway making the fake news
sounds like fake news, bot. No such thing as a happy hostage
@@tochiRTAOur friend happymelon here is helping the terrorist push their propaganda. He thinks us fools to believe there is such thing as happy hostage 😂 Maybe he would like to try being on 😆
@@tochiRTA By Thai news , not from me.
Al Jazeera and TRT world won't show these videos!
Those are terrorist networks. They are even asking for solidarity. Shameless!
Of course they are biased.
they showed better unpropaganda news,watch them for better coverage on the real thing. not the controlled mainstream of course.
Weird that they were freed before all the kids were freed..
They love a good image.
I wish the mother finds her son in good health ❤❤
Thailand is a rich country why are they in such terrible life, working in Israel for salaries that's not fair!
9$ + an hour ... how is that not fair exactly ? even in israel standards they get paid high and they are not even citzens , with the money they make in israel they can leave like wealthy people when they get back to thialnd i think you just defame israel because you are muslim and not because you are honest and look at this honestly
So sad! This whole situation is bad enough, and then there are these poor Thai people who barely speak Hebrew, don't know the history, and had lived amongst Peaceniks who didn't have an issue with the Palestinians and was always trying to help them. They must be so confused stuck in a damp, dark tunnel with no understanding of why or what's happening. Hamas is vile!
How about report about the child "hostages" by the bastions of self-defense
Nope, seems your statement like IDF was. Distorting facts. Theres only israeli occupation, not egypt nor jordan. And they already did it for long time
And yeah, we didnt talk about uighur, syirian etc. Only talk about israel and palestine.
YOU SAID NOTHING basically nothing ABOUT - their TREATMENT IN CAPTIVITY..
.. misleading )
It's heartbreaking to see the UN behave in the manner they are behaving. How can you side with terrorists.?
Colonizers always call people who defend their homeland terrorists, that's the standard,even though the UN has even issued more than 38 resolutions only for Israel,
The UN is not siding with terrorists. UN aid organizations are the only ones left in Gaza. All the others have left cause it is too dangerous. Over 100 UN workers have been killed as Israel has bombed Gaza so badly that it is equivalent in o an atom bomb. 18,000 Gazans are dead. Most are women and children. The UN is trying to stop more being killed.
🍉🇵🇸🍉🇵🇸🍉🇵🇸
🇵🇸
Who are the terrorists
Other two th*y killed? And you were beaten? Why they kept you safe, alive and relatively unharmed when released, when you are a foreigner and not even an Isr*eli? We all know you have been briefed already to say these things
what are u saying?
there isnt a single bruise on him yet it was said he was beaten, Bro?? At least provide evidence if youre gonna report that one thing
So he wasn't hit on his face and hands...
الاسرى لدى حماس معززون مكرمون لا تخافو عليهم،لكن لا تنسو بالدعاء الاسرى الفلسطينيين لدي اسرائيل
The families of the hostages murdered by hamas disagree. There is no honor in abducting babies, children, teens, and adults from over 25 countries and murdering some. It's shameful.
may god help the palestinain ppl
The hostages were escorted by Hammas in military gear but they're not being seen in those gear when IDF entered Gaza.
It has not stopped
Free 🇵🇸
Free Gaza from Hamas.
It's on sale? Wait. Palestine doesn't exist. You're offering something that doesn't exist.