Send This To Your Wizard If "They Didn't Ask How Big The Room Was, They Cast Fireball"

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 1. 06. 2024
  • Welcome to "So You Pissed Off The Dungeon Master", where I give you responses you can send to your players for stupid things they've done in your D&D and other TTRPG games.
    Do you need any responses for things your players have done? Let me craft together the perfect message for the thing they've done!
    Join the discord!
    / discord
    #dnd
  • Hry

Komentáře • 844

  • @TheCantripCast
    @TheCantripCast  Před 3 měsíci +1670

    Yes I know fireball doesn't destroy objects that are carried or worn. It's a skit video. Fire hot. Fire hurt.

    • @chongwillson972
      @chongwillson972 Před 3 měsíci +98

      @TheCantripCast
      wait what if one of the party members heals from fire damage?

    • @TheCantripCast
      @TheCantripCast  Před 3 měsíci +198

      ​@@chongwillson972then fire.... help?

    • @Ishstalla
      @Ishstalla Před 3 měsíci +51

      DM makes the rules as far as I'm concerned. 😂 Just call it a house rule.

    • @joshuagross3151
      @joshuagross3151 Před 3 měsíci +7

      I assume the edge lord is next on the chopping block?

    • @puddel9079
      @puddel9079 Před 3 měsíci +8

      Hear me out, what if that upcast fireball was easy to track by the local authorities?

  • @Varatho
    @Varatho Před 3 měsíci +2463

    "BUT It ignites flammable objects in the area that AREN'T being worn or carried!!!"
    Congratulations! You ignited the floor you are standing on, the walls surrounding you, the roof above you, and every piece of furniture in the room. Which then proceeds to light you and your belongings on fire because a fire-room is no longer a fireball.

    • @leos.2322
      @leos.2322 Před 3 měsíci +62

      Usually the room isn't flammable, you know stone and dirt don't catch fire

    • @Anergyne
      @Anergyne Před 3 měsíci +294

      @@leos.2322 Do you have any idea how much wood was used in medieval architecture? Buildings made out of stone were a rarity.

    • @aereonexapprentice7205
      @aereonexapprentice7205 Před 3 měsíci +99

      ​@@leos.2322The stone and dirt does not catch on fire, but the fire still lingers onto them due to the fire's magical properties and how powerful a fireball is compared to your regular fire like stoves and campfires

    • @SavannoBaalphegore
      @SavannoBaalphegore Před 3 měsíci +17

      i mean for the sketch its funny, but i think actually that this rule should be interpreted like that the wizard automatically put a barrier around himself and his belongings, because anything else would be dumb. at least that's how interpret it in my games and my groups for various effects that say things like this xD

    • @Telogor
      @Telogor Před 3 měsíci +13

      ​@@aereonexapprentice7205 So it's like magical napalm?

  • @Manzana1C
    @Manzana1C Před 3 měsíci +748

    Chad Nudist Dragonkin Sorcerer: What spell book? What clothes? What fire damage?

    • @nathanielbass771
      @nathanielbass771 Před 3 měsíci +80

      the level 2 rogue and monk: what fireball? (evasion check)

    • @SageWon-1aussie
      @SageWon-1aussie Před 3 měsíci +11

      Party of one for where do you keep your coins?

    • @lemax6865
      @lemax6865 Před 3 měsíci +46

      @@SageWon-1aussie Prison pocket. Makes paying for lunch really awkward, but I'm guessing the kind of guy who does that finds it funny. Might find the guards are less receptive to his sense of humor, though.

    • @deathbringer9893
      @deathbringer9893 Před 3 měsíci

      @@SageWon-1aussie ever heard of foreskin

    • @Thomas-zt7dm
      @Thomas-zt7dm Před 3 měsíci +20

      @@lemax6865no shoes, no shirt, no service, lunch isn’t bought but hunted lol

  • @HurrikanEagle
    @HurrikanEagle Před 3 měsíci +727

    So, my old DM didn't go to THIS degree. But I do distinctly remember that we would specify (when the situation called for it).
    "I cast fireball into the middle of the room, as part of finishing the casting of the spell, I close the door with the opposite hand AFTER the fireball has crossed the threshhold into the room"

    • @michaelmarsh1723
      @michaelmarsh1723 Před 3 měsíci +44

      It's not a ball of fire that you lob. It's a concussive blast (from rapidly superheated air that expands outwards from a central point violently) that appears at a point within range. There's no travel time, nothing to dodge... it just... IS. That's why it's never required an attack roll from your wizard, just a reflex save from the enemies to get lucky and dodge AWAY from it, rather than into it.

    • @emarusso5758
      @emarusso5758 Před 3 měsíci +39

      @@michaelmarsh1723if it was a concussive blast it wouldn’t make Fire Damage. More like bludgeoning or even force damage.

    • @TrixyTrixter
      @TrixyTrixter Před 3 měsíci +119

      ​@michaelmarsh1723 So very wrong... Literally the first part of the description for the spell.
      "A bright streak flashes from your pointing finger to a point you choose within range and then blossoms with a low roar into an explosion of flame."
      You do infact send it from yourself to the location. So a DM can absolutely allow the wizard to close the door as soon as the mote passes the threshhold.

    • @rhael42
      @rhael42 Před 3 měsíci +35

      ​@@michaelmarsh1723 go actually read the entry for fireball. you couldn't be more wrong.

    • @yorickvlt1021
      @yorickvlt1021 Před 3 měsíci +27

      @michaelmarsh1723 me when I spread misinformation on the internet

  • @directerjb
    @directerjb Před 3 měsíci +231

    JoCat said it best: " You'll either be dead from getting caught in your own fireballs or killed by your fellow party members caught in your fireball."

  • @DillsArtThing
    @DillsArtThing Před 3 měsíci +188

    I do not play DND, but im just imagining a DM with a stream deck and a projector screen behind them ready to choose from a wide selection of these videos at the press of a button.

  • @Gam3Junkie7
    @Gam3Junkie7 Před 3 měsíci +298

    I did this without thinking once, but it wasn't Fireball, it was Shatter...on a ship...a FROZEN ship out in the middle of a FROZEN lake...*click tongue*, yeah~...there wasn't a ship after that and we were half dead from shrapnel as we fled to the nearest town, freezing our bleeding butts off.

    • @michaelmarsh1723
      @michaelmarsh1723 Před 3 měsíci +38

      On the plus side, being cold enough (pretty darn cold, tbh) is proven to lower heart rate and slow vital functions, so you'll take longer to bleed out. Could be worse, is all I mean.

    • @GBS4893
      @GBS4893 Před 3 měsíci +16

      intelligence versus wisdom, am i right?

    • @ozpin8329
      @ozpin8329 Před 2 měsíci +9

      I had my first ever character death two sessions ago when I forgot the battlefield layout. The Roll20 map showed a ruin with an open doorway, which the DM described as an archway of a partially collapsed tower.
      An hour of incredibly intense roleplay later a fight breaks out and my character gets cornered in this open doorway, so I cast Shatter on the surrounding area to hit a few enemies. I had forgotten that it was an archway and there was still twenty feet of brick above me that would promptly collapse. The DM offered to let me take it back when I realized what I had done but I went through with it because it fit the character and was a great story moment.

    • @CrizzyEyes
      @CrizzyEyes Před měsícem +3

      @@ozpin8329 i killed my rogue because i forgot that a crossing over a pit was supported by rickety boards, explicitly described by the GM, then he promptly failed a reflex save and fell 80 feet into water, fell unconscious from the damage and drowned

  • @adorkmoreon3599
    @adorkmoreon3599 Před 3 měsíci +108

    On a campaign note. Had a group I played with, I ran an upright Dwarven Champion. So this is an event I didn't do but as a player whole heartedly agreed with. The group has been bitching at each other for about ½ the session. We were currently in a tavern going round and round about what we were going to do next. The Sorcerer of the group slid a note over to the DM, DM looked at and said make a roll. 17. Now this wasn't completely out of character for our Sorcerer, he was a lot like a "typical" Bard. No one in the party said anything when he had his character set his mug down and get up and walk out of the tavern. After about a minute of the rest of the group continuing to argue the DM suddenly said "Roll perception." It suddenly went very quite at the table. It wouldn't have been the first time he dropped something on our heads for being stupid. So we rolled, everyone at disadvantage. The highest roll was a 12. Yeah everyone of us failed. Suddenly he starts rolling a crap ton of dice and says a fireball has just gone off in the middle of the table. Our Sorcerer had used slight of hand and dropped a delayed fireball in his mug right before he left the tavern. The party survived but no one was feeling very good being at ground zero for a 12d6 surprise fireball.

  • @GenGBby
    @GenGBby Před 3 měsíci +58

    I've only dealt with this once, and it was when a player went and brought a wand of fireballs. Before then he was fine, just occasionally throwing out fireballs that hit a party member if the situation was bad, but after he got the wand? His first spell was fireball, even with his normal spell slots. He constantly injured the party and at one point downed the healer in the middle of a group of enemies. It was at the point where at one point he had two groups of enemies he could target and he shot at the one where the fighter was in the middle of it already because 'there were more targets there, so it'll deal higher damage', did not matter at all to him that one of those targets was a teammate the healer had to throw spells at to save.
    Eventually we got fed up, the fighter took the wand off him and snapped it in half(taking the full damage of the remaining uncast fireballs from the action), and his response was to ragequit the game because 'we were overreacting about occasional damage' from being hit 2-3 times each combat.

    • @SageWon-1aussie
      @SageWon-1aussie Před 3 měsíci +8

      Snapping a wizard's wand almost always leads to them ragequitting the party. 😂

    • @johnpaullogan1365
      @johnpaullogan1365 Před 3 měsíci +7

      i had a shepherd druid with 2 carts full of expensive stuff, 6 goats, and 4 cows. we got attacked by insets in a cave aand another player whose character had entomophobia as a major part of her character decided to hurl an entire full necklace of fireballs at them. lost all but 1 cow and 1 goat and the rogue who was within 5 ft of ground zero got lucky and made his dex save so was completely unharmed

    • @fredericboucheres2007
      @fredericboucheres2007 Před měsícem

      @@johnpaullogan1365Seems ok to me, since it is justified in character. Sure it sucks, but I suppose the fireball caster did something later to make amends ?

    • @johnpaullogan1365
      @johnpaullogan1365 Před měsícem +2

      @@fredericboucheres2007 not yet. we've only had 2 sessions since and the last 2 sessions we've been dealing with the beholder we accidentally released. our group only is able to meet rather sporadically and the dms trade off so it is split between 2 campaigns

    • @pmangano
      @pmangano Před měsícem +4

      would have made the player change his character to neutral evil and reported to the very zealous local paladin guild.

  • @southron_d1349
    @southron_d1349 Před 3 měsíci +268

    You forgot the 3rd Prize. The volume of a 40' diameter flaming ball/sphere trying to squeeze into a 10'x10'x10 room and the adjacent corridors.
    If you're playing AD&D, then you ARE making saving throws for each and every item worn and carried. The temperature of the spell is quantified in the game so gold rings are definitely melting - including the magical ones.

    • @ozzivpodno1356
      @ozzivpodno1356 Před 3 měsíci +13

      Thank you for this

    • @markusnixon3156
      @markusnixon3156 Před 3 měsíci +21

      There is even a table for how different types of materials save from various types of damage, so yeah even your sword might be unusable if you get a really bad roll, but hey your spellbook might survive, on a really *good* roll! 😅

    • @cumunist2120
      @cumunist2120 Před 3 měsíci +5

      Everyone is dead the fucking campaign is over

    • @markusnixon3156
      @markusnixon3156 Před 3 měsíci +16

      @@cumunist2120 I had a character fall on their backpack full of potions, one was bottled hellfire, another was a ship in a bottle, everything was incinerated, then flooded/steamed, and our next party was introduced on said ship, now sticking out of a hole in the middle of a landlocked area, to continue the campaign. 😆

    • @louiesatterwhite3885
      @louiesatterwhite3885 Před 3 měsíci +1

      Metals melting from an instantaneous fireball doesn't really make sense if you account for physics but hey, it's a game

  • @nickbensema3045
    @nickbensema3045 Před 3 měsíci +14

    "whenever I had a problem, I cast fireball, and right away I had a different problem!" - jason mendoza

  • @Mak10z
    @Mak10z Před 3 měsíci +38

    Evocation Wizard says "my fire only hurts those with hostile intent toward me"

    • @johnpaullogan1365
      @johnpaullogan1365 Před 3 měsíci +7

      and yourself. you can't actually use sculpt spell to exempt yourself since it says other creatures

    • @jk2l
      @jk2l Před 2 měsíci +4

      as the other guy say, here is the quote "When you cast an evocation spell that affects other creatures that you can see, you can choose a number of them equal to 1 + the spell’s level.". it only apply to other creature. remember, details in the fine print. you can exclude your party member to piss at you. but you can't protect yourself from being stupid

    • @NightOfTheRavens
      @NightOfTheRavens Před 2 měsíci

      ​@@jk2l Oh wow, evocation wizards are much worse in DnD then in BG 3.

    • @jk2l
      @jk2l Před měsícem +1

      @@NightOfTheRavens BG3 made everything OP if you know how to build. but it is video game, balance isn't exactly the same as TTRPG where balance is a bit important for group play

    • @skyeschlueter9877
      @skyeschlueter9877 Před měsícem

      ​@@NightOfTheRavensThe ability is still stupidly good in 5e and basically lets you blast with impunity, it's just a little less stupidly good.

  • @a_silentthing6040
    @a_silentthing6040 Před 3 měsíci +291

    laughs in evocation wizard

    • @Michael-bb1cw
      @Michael-bb1cw Před 3 měsíci +18

      Sculpt Spells FOR THE WIN!

    • @WizzoTheMagicMan
      @WizzoTheMagicMan Před 3 měsíci +4

      Exactly lol. Fireball go brrrrr

    • @TheRifild
      @TheRifild Před 3 měsíci +1

      not a dnd expert but wouldn't it still be like the meme "this is fine"?

    • @TrixyTrixter
      @TrixyTrixter Před 3 měsíci +17

      ​@@TheRifild Kinda. But you literally are fine. Since the effect talked about specifically makes X targets of your choice completely immune to the spell. So its like fireball explodes and the fire just turns to move around all the party members.

    • @linkboynine9814
      @linkboynine9814 Před 3 měsíci +11

      @@TheRifild In 5E, Wizards that specialize in the Evocation school of magic get the ability to sculpt their spells at level...two, I think? Possibly level three. Well before the point where they can start slinging fireballs, they've learned to reshape their spells in real time so the explosive magic they unleash doesn't hit their party members, or themselves.

  • @fiendfi7119
    @fiendfi7119 Před 3 měsíci +28

    I love how DnD players are committed enough to act in character even when it's to the detriment of the party

  • @ravenmage1859
    @ravenmage1859 Před měsícem +4

    My players burned down a farm in a forest at one point early in a campaign. Over the following several sessions they began to hear rumors of a wildfire, and at one point they needed to return to their starting town to turn in one of their main quests only to find that a tremendous wildfire had engulfed the entirety of that beginner forest and had spread to decimate their starting town. A conveniently placed eye witness of the original farm burning turned them into wanted fugitives real fast, was a lot of fun to mess with them.

  • @HEARTLESSKAMUI
    @HEARTLESSKAMUI Před 3 měsíci +87

    Two words: Evocation Wizard
    *Cackles in lack of consequences*

    • @Silverfox607
      @Silverfox607 Před 3 měsíci +6

      A fellow wizard of culture 🤝

    • @HEARTLESSKAMUI
      @HEARTLESSKAMUI Před 3 měsíci +5

      @Silverfox607 I couldn't agree more🤝. The eternal quest for knowledge knows no cultural borders. Its hard not to be cultured when you've read manuscripts and poured over tomes from the astral plane to the underdark. Damn I love playing wizards

    • @Apostate_ofmind
      @Apostate_ofmind Před 3 měsíci +3

      im pining so hard to get my second level just for that
      curse me and my multiclassing into cleric, but storm domain is so good

    • @darklordmathias9405
      @darklordmathias9405 Před 3 měsíci +3

      The house, that is currently on fire because of that one chair in the corner, collapses. I need the party to make Dex Saves. 😂😂😂😂

    • @everlastingdragon4520
      @everlastingdragon4520 Před 2 měsíci +1

      Sculpt Spells doesn't apply to yourself; it specifies "other creatures".

  • @kirisaki_touma
    @kirisaki_touma Před 3 měsíci +113

    the voices inside us its winning

  • @gabrielrussell5531
    @gabrielrussell5531 Před 3 měsíci +35

    If they say "I don't care how big the room is" you introduce them to AD&D *Fireball*: If cast into a space too small for the full blast, the excess volume blows back at you.

    • @nichtsicher422
      @nichtsicher422 Před 2 měsíci +7

      This sounds like a mechanic you can use to build a big gun. If you think about it Guns work in a similar way... Be careful about "punishing" player with something like this. It might blow up in your face. *pun intendend*

    • @Cyberzombie23
      @Cyberzombie23 Před 29 dny

      DID I STUTTER I STILL CAST FIREBALL

  • @NLR-J
    @NLR-J Před 3 měsíci +4

    This video doesn't even take into account a situation in which there were hostages in the room, because they're most likely dead or at least very much hurt because of your choice for arson, good job.

  • @countfrackula6707
    @countfrackula6707 Před měsícem +15

    I've done this, once. It was when the DM antagonized my hydrophobic Tabaxi sorceress with water while she was hiding in a barrel on a ship to avoid ... water. "I cast fireball, centered on myself." DM, "You're in a barrel, in a small room." Me, "I don't care how big the room is, I'm freaking the hell out because of my character's actual phobia, I cast FIREBALL!"

    • @CrizzyEyes
      @CrizzyEyes Před měsícem +5

      it's technically aquaphobia because hydrophobia is the medical name for rabies (dumb I know)

    • @nobodyshome6792
      @nobodyshome6792 Před 18 dny

      I have had similar issues when playing characters with flaws. Typically I go for Pica though.
      I did, however, scorch a herbarium once due to my character having lepidopterophobia. (Fear of butterflies.)
      Between the healing and replacing of the herbarium the party was pretty pissed off at me......

  • @Eric4bz
    @Eric4bz Před 2 měsíci +5

    See depending on the structure, fireball either goes kaboom and knocks all the walls down, or if it's made of sturdy stone or is in a cave, an old DM I used to DJ for had the 'shaped charge' effect. Basically if Fireball was thrown into a small room, it would take ANY exit, be it a window or an open door.
    First time the wizard threw a fireball into a glorified janitor closet to deal with a giant spider that nested there. The door blew off, hit him for bludgeoning damage, then the fireball damage shot out - up to as many squares as the small room would have otherwise contained the blaze - and would have killed him if not for the paladin's lay on hands. Second time they were running from undead guards, threw fireball into the same room after everyone ducked behind cover. Shaped charge cleared out the entire horde.

    • @CrizzyEyes
      @CrizzyEyes Před měsícem +1

      You just gave me a brilliant idea for a siege engine in a magical setting. Giant cone on wheels, 10 feet in diameter at the wide end, with a smaller copper cone mounted on the inside against the wide end, pointing inward. Wide end has a small hole in the center. Wide end is placed against gate of defending enemy fortification. Wizard casts fireball into the big cone, it melts the copper cone (AD&D rules say that it melts soft metals like copper) and the force of the heated gas escaping forces the melted copper to stream out of the hole in a scorching jet, punching through most surfaces.

    • @Eric4bz
      @Eric4bz Před měsícem

      @@CrizzyEyes Make it count man. :P

  • @droidBasher
    @droidBasher Před 3 měsíci +9

    Bonus bonus rounds: Structural collapse is one of the leading causes of firefighter deaths! And if your are in an above ground, wooden structure, now the town is on fire since without modern fire fighting capability, the odds of the fire spreading to adjacent buildings is high.

    • @blackhammer5035
      @blackhammer5035 Před 3 měsíci +1

      Old modules sometimes had rules for old structures collapsing due to spells like fireball or lightning bolt.

    • @Blackwing2345635
      @Blackwing2345635 Před 2 měsíci

      imagine collapsing building with fire in 6 seconds. Is it made of nitrocellulose?

    • @SDogo
      @SDogo Před měsícem

      @@Blackwing2345635 The entire build had gone fwoosshhhh

  • @cristianelizondo2477
    @cristianelizondo2477 Před měsícem +2

    What you said: "I cast fireball"
    What I immediately thought: "I cast thunder spell"

  • @alexderus1179
    @alexderus1179 Před měsícem +2

    I do remember a time I "pissed off the dungeon master". An NPC has tried assassinating my character 3 times throughout the campaign. However, each time was a huge fail. So on the 3rd attempt, my character avoids the attack and starts talking to the NPC. My character actually convinced the NPC to get back up after sitting on the floor getting ready to be killed, and then took the NPC to a blacksmith and bought the NPC a better weapon before taking the NPC to a bar and talking things out. The GM was very surprised but let it slide and instead killed the NPC on the next day.

    • @takedown205productions6
      @takedown205productions6 Před měsícem

      To quote a certain DM from Critical Role: "What's up with you guys recruiting useless characters to fight gods with?"

  • @adilrahman6881
    @adilrahman6881 Před 2 měsíci +11

    We need a "You Pissed of the Dungeon Master" episode for the 'excuse' "But that's what my character would."

    • @trishapellis
      @trishapellis Před měsícem +1

      That's an extremely wide net, though. There's two videos in this series now, from what I can see: seducing the dragon, and casting fireball in a small room. Both of these are absolutely things the player could justify with "it's what my character would do".
      So I'd say, you make a series of videos about things someone's character would do, and then there might be a separate video (which the DM may just line up behind the more relevant video about which exact dumb thing the character did) to play when the player justifies with "That's what my character would do" - where the response, I imagine, would be something along the lines of "Congratulations, you made an extremely unlikeable character that would do things that go directly against the party's interests, and you thought everyone would put up with it. Your character is dead now - make a character that *would not make the whole party hate their guts* ."

  • @solarknight3942
    @solarknight3942 Před 3 měsíci +4

    As a reversal: if my players did this, it would be out of a hype moment in roleplay where the whole point is actually the self-sacrifice.

  • @thedominator5620
    @thedominator5620 Před 3 měsíci +7

    "And now for this season's Darwin Awards!"

  • @rust454
    @rust454 Před měsícem +1

    Jokes on you since I had fireball prepared I don't even need a spellbook to keep casting it.

  • @user-ph7om7bm7y
    @user-ph7om7bm7y Před 3 měsíci +74

    Intrusive thoughts wizard is best wizard.

    • @gingermcgingin4106
      @gingermcgingin4106 Před 3 měsíci +9

      There's a reason they're INT & not WIS casters

    • @Merilirem
      @Merilirem Před 3 měsíci +6

      @@gingermcgingin4106 Imagine a wis caster wizard that gave people intrusive thoughts..

    • @johnpaullogan1365
      @johnpaullogan1365 Před 3 měsíci

      we had a wizard whose every spell was reflavored as poop themed. i think he still ekes out a win

  • @herosupport1606
    @herosupport1606 Před 3 měsíci +18

    I would say tight fitting clothes would be fine but anything loose would go up in flames or have the chance to.

  • @scottlincoln9900
    @scottlincoln9900 Před 3 měsíci +6

    Dude you need to make just a ton of these YPODM videos....absolute friggin gold. *chefs kiss*

  • @tophatstudios9069
    @tophatstudios9069 Před 2 měsíci +2

    Ive played a dnd character who unironically used explosives as a melee weapon. ended shockingly well

  • @SZRLM
    @SZRLM Před 3 měsíci +34

    Reject Fireball. Accept Cloudkill and it's partner in crime Arcane Lock.

    • @nathanielbass771
      @nathanielbass771 Před 3 měsíci +1

      hailstorm, go! reflex checks for everyone! XD

    • @ozpin8329
      @ozpin8329 Před měsícem

      I'm a big fan of Forcecage and Sickening Radiance

    • @nathanielbass771
      @nathanielbass771 Před měsícem

      I was a bit of a troll back in the online days but the amount of DPS and blinds that hailstorm gives was just worth the cost. The problem? it's very easy for party members to get involved XD Cloudkill too. The "Grease" spell is the worst one though XD

    • @ozpin8329
      @ozpin8329 Před měsícem

      My favorite reaction from my DM was when I cast Sleet Storm for the first time on a group of about twenty enemies. She had to roll that many dex saves and I will always remember her "Wait, this is just to _knock them prone!?_ There's no actual _damage?"_ made me laugh for ten minutes straight.

    • @nathanielbass771
      @nathanielbass771 Před měsícem

      @@ozpin8329 and prone is a powerful CC almost as strong as stun XD and the spell is ongoing for multiple rounds, so they have to save for it AGAIN at the next check. Twenty enemies... that's... wow that'd take like an hour just to roll the dice and record the numbers. Hi Hailstorm! (does damage and the same thing as sleet )

  • @JohnDoe-vm5rb
    @JohnDoe-vm5rb Před 2 měsíci +2

    They forgot the big reason for looking the dm in the eye, regardless of what happens to players, themselves, or the campaign. "I don't care."
    Also, my fellow players have great trust in me. After all, I'm the one that spotted them the items that give fire resistance.

  • @sutorippuwebmaster8783
    @sutorippuwebmaster8783 Před měsícem +1

    I want more of Bearded Drew Carey roasting bad decisions in D&D.

  • @Blazieth
    @Blazieth Před 3 měsíci +1

    Joke's on you, I'm an Evocation Wizard, I can specifically exclude my allies from the fire!

  • @HolyAwesomeStitches
    @HolyAwesomeStitches Před 3 měsíci +2

    These skits just remind me of how my Rogue has single handedly landed our entire party in prison. Twice.

  • @okinataketori9713
    @okinataketori9713 Před 3 měsíci +1

    Walks into goblin cave: "Die Maggots" (casts fireball in cave)

  • @MarxSoul2001
    @MarxSoul2001 Před 5 dny

    And that's why Arms of Hadar is the superior "cast in a small room and close the door" spell. Much less flamable, much more controllable, still very very effective.

  • @mm-rj3vo
    @mm-rj3vo Před 26 dny +1

    I like to have variable power in how spells work and rolling the dice can be more akin to how much CONTROL you have over your intended spell, rather than a pass/fail.
    You could say "I want to cast a really small fireball" I'd say the control for that has, like, better chances, and gets double advantage, versus like "I want to cast the biggest fireball i possibly can" which means you gotta do like double disadvantage, etc. damage rolls can be different and stuffs

  • @AmaroqStarwind
    @AmaroqStarwind Před 3 měsíci +2

    Better than somebody running around town shouting "fireballfireballfireballfireball" in rapid fire.

  • @alicehiess6508
    @alicehiess6508 Před 14 dny

    One of our players had the bright idea to cast fireball in an engine room. The dm had to retcon it cause the entire moving base went up in a puff of smoke along with the whole party

  • @dra6o0n
    @dra6o0n Před 2 měsíci +1

    The DM could also say that due to the nature of fire, all the oxygen in the room was burned up, and incinerated everyone's lungs.

  • @someperson4249
    @someperson4249 Před 3 měsíci +1

    "spend the entire campaign regaining your party's trust"
    god, yeah, I know that feeling when one of my players runs off to do something or summons without thinking or casts a spell without checking where their allies are. nobody trusts your character after that lmao

  • @Timelord411
    @Timelord411 Před 11 hodinami +1

    I absolutely love these skits.

  • @mattwo7
    @mattwo7 Před 3 měsíci +3

    Chaotic alignments would do this anyway. Even if they got rid of the alignment system.

  • @noahrice3362
    @noahrice3362 Před 3 měsíci +4

    This is so perfect. Now if only I had the perfect opportunity to use this...
    Here's a suggestion, how about when a player kills an important NPC to the quest line, or adopts something that is very likely to kill them later and they know it. Ooh, or maybe something to do with careless use of the Deck of Many things or recklessly use some other sort of powerful magic item or spell... I'd love to punish someone for silvery barbs spamming, I mean seriously, what was WotC thinking when they made that a 1st level spell? It's effectively a more powerful counterspell that works on effectively everything, it should not be so accessible!

  • @LARADEKA
    @LARADEKA Před 3 měsíci +1

    Ah yes...
    The mini-series where every DnD enthusiast gets hammered by the reality of their actions in every round. Fireball seems overkill realistically... if it was for nuking a simple hut.
    A small blast spell in a small space is a bomb-sized nuke to a claustrophobia room. Now do that... but with Lightning Magic.

  • @jefthereaper
    @jefthereaper Před měsícem

    The Elves gathered in meditation to combine their power, so they could cast Fireball as High Magic.
    A 10th slot.

  • @sorasonic1
    @sorasonic1 Před 3 měsíci +1

    Pro tip to everyone out there, if you feel a bag of holding up with seawater mathematically when you tear the bag it instantly expands the contents creating basically a super powerful bomb

  • @logitimate
    @logitimate Před 3 měsíci +1

    1:15 Real-world accuracy (and natural fiber enthusiast) note: _Linen_ and _cotton_ (and, in the modern era, rayon) are mostly cellulose, and generally burn pretty easily. Silk is even more flammable, despite being made of protein. _Wool_ , however, while it _can_ burn, is difficult to ignite, burns slowly, and tends (especially when densely woven) to burn itself out fairly quickly when no longer exposed to an external heat source. This, combined with the fact that it stinks quite badly when it _does_ burn, meaning that you're likely to notice quickly if it catches fire, is a definite advantage to wool over most other materials when making cloth that has an elevated risk of being exposed to sparks, high heat, or open flame, or such as blankets for huddling up in next to a campfire, or clothing to be worn while adventuring with a pyromaniac wizard. By the same token, it has real advantages when making baby blankets, despite the roughness that it can often have. It also retains the majority of its insulting power (although by no means all of it) when soaking wet!
    (Synthetic fibers vary in how readily they ignite, and some of them have the nasty property of readily _melting and sticking to skin_ . Depending on the details of their composition, they may also produce highly toxic smoke.)

  • @oklafornia3643
    @oklafornia3643 Před 10 dny

    Bold words for a guy within fireball range.

  • @nurgleface
    @nurgleface Před 3 měsíci +1

    Honestly if a DM fucked me over like that after someone else cast fireball in that dumb way I'd hate the DM too.

  • @leyrua
    @leyrua Před měsícem

    The sorcerer laughs at the wizard's tears as he shields his precious spellbook with his own body... and casts Fireball.

  • @shred1894
    @shred1894 Před 3 měsíci +1

    The trick is to cast the fireball before you enter the room, like how the marines frag and clear a room.

  • @Vortex1988
    @Vortex1988 Před měsícem +1

    Sounds like the DM forgot that the wizard is an evoker and created pockets of safety around himself and his party. They took no damage. Everything else in the room is pretty crispy though.

  • @lolmanmagee2785
    @lolmanmagee2785 Před 2 měsíci +2

    jokes on you, i am a evocation wizard so nobody in my party took damage :p.

  • @zombiedemon1762
    @zombiedemon1762 Před 3 měsíci +6

    Hope you keep making these because i love it and I want you to keep telling me about new ways to piss off the dungeon master.

  • @Berek71182
    @Berek71182 Před měsícem +1

    Enjoy the pressure from an explosion inside a room that can make you and everyone else deaf for a while. And if you are luckyyou may still be able to walk in a straight line, or walk at all after the Balance organ in the ear took such a hit....

    • @EricTheKei
      @EricTheKei Před měsícem +1

      They (kinda) accounted for this back in AD&D 2e, tho I think it was dropped after that. Fireballs (and, IIRC, similar spells) filled up a specific amount of area (e.g. X number of 10x10-ft cubes). If you cast it in a narrow corridor or a smallish room, you got hit with the backdraft *if you were lucky*; possibly worse.

  • @fluffyfussy
    @fluffyfussy Před měsícem

    My soul as DM needed this really bad. Please keep up this serie, you doing gods work!

  • @timeless9534
    @timeless9534 Před 13 dny

    When I casted Fireball in a tiny room earlier today, it was because I was under a madness effect that made me perceive the floor as a mimic and my party members as untrustworthy. One Fireball and a two-storey fall later, my party members lost a lot of trust in me (In-character). Out of character, the Fireball was so out of pocket that everyone in the group was caught off-guard. Even my DM was surprised. He expected me to smite the floor, not nuke the room with me in it lol.

  • @KittyMax97
    @KittyMax97 Před 3 měsíci +1

    I the second prize was going to be becoming this weeks winner of “congratulations you pissed off your party” 😂
    These are so good, I need more! I’m DM for group of all new players and they would love these 😂😂😂

  • @567secret
    @567secret Před 3 měsíci +1

    Jokes on you, I'm an evocation wizard.

  • @skysamurai4649
    @skysamurai4649 Před 3 měsíci +2

    Technically, clothing pieces have their own hp, and at least masterwork or magical armor generally has enough of them to survive the blast. But yeah, spellbook is definitely gone.

  • @MrStrikecentral
    @MrStrikecentral Před 3 měsíci +2

    I have a question: Why would this piss off the DM? It would only piss off the other players. If I was the DM and someone did this I would be like, "Ok. That just happened. Now deal with it."

  • @NotsilYmerej
    @NotsilYmerej Před 11 dny

    “But I’m a Tiefling, I’m resistant to fire!”
    Everything else isn’t

  • @timothypryor7952
    @timothypryor7952 Před 3 měsíci +64

    Yep, I cast fireball. I also gave everyone in the party damage resistance to fire potions BEFORE the fight. Idiots that didn't drink their potions can suck it.

    • @HEARTLESSKAMUI
      @HEARTLESSKAMUI Před 3 měsíci +11

      Potions? Ha, sculpt spells. Dont worry everyone will be fine. Well, everyone important anyway..

    • @alphastronghold715
      @alphastronghold715 Před 3 měsíci

      Congratulations! You just lit everything in the room on fire and are now suffocating on the smoke! Better hope you brought those…oh wait! There are no items for holding your breath longer or breathing in caustic environments!
      Hope you can GTFO before those 30 seconds are up you low con Wizard!

    • @thexatronantch
      @thexatronantch Před 3 měsíci +1

      also usually when you live by "idahbtrwisicfb" you at least do enough to keep yourself out of the blast zone (unless it's a hail Mary kamikaze)

    • @SageWon-1aussie
      @SageWon-1aussie Před 3 měsíci +1

      Did you pour some potion in your coin purse? Molten gold running down your leg is no fun....😂

  • @ianrager
    @ianrager Před 2 měsíci

    My level 16 high-elf wizard, Zhoenix (pronounced Zee-nix) did this in an act of absolutely insane desperation, severely wounded everything in the room, accidentally killed another PC, and he regretted it for the rest of his life.
    He's in forever retirement for himself, his fellow party members, and also all the way down the line to each of their great-great-great-grandchildren, if they were all to have any (they all stuffed THAT much gold pieces from a dungeon into his bag of holding) and despite his wealth, retirement, and complete and utter comfort, that moment always haunted him until the end of his days.
    Edit: I actually watched the video now. Thankfully, the DM was merciful enough to ensure that, thanks to a direct act from the all-deity, all of our possessions, clothes, and belongings, were miraculously untouched.
    Iff you happen to think that this was too much mercy for an act as heinous as a small-room fireball, realize that this was my third ever character, I had hardly even gotten absolutely anywhere with my previous two characters, and I was about as much of a newbie as I could possibly be.
    I had never heard of any fireball horror stories at that time, which directly to multiversal history repeating itself once again, by a desperate spell-caster yet again casting fireball in a small room.
    I wasn't even doing it for a meme.
    I wasn't even doing it as a joke.
    I was genuinely unironically trying my absolute hardest to avert a TPK in an absolute panic… in the absolute most counterproductive way imaginable.
    Both my PC and myself eternally regretted it.

  • @user-nt6gw5gd8c
    @user-nt6gw5gd8c Před 2 měsíci +1

    the clothing removal part
    me: *looks over at the female rogue being the only one with clothing* "worth it"

  • @Nert9544
    @Nert9544 Před 3 měsíci +48

    I need more my dude….MORE!!!!

  • @garywilliams5718
    @garywilliams5718 Před 3 měsíci +21

    I did notice an oversight in this video...
    Those nice bows your Ranger and Rouge have those have been burnt to crisp, along with anything else that was wooden

    • @BiggieBows1752
      @BiggieBows1752 Před 3 měsíci +2

      Those wouldn’t immediately be destroyed, but definitely damaged and quickly become unusable

    • @garywilliams5718
      @garywilliams5718 Před 3 měsíci

      @BiggieBows1752 Depending on the material used for the string, I believe the string would be ruined beyond repair

    • @BiggieBows1752
      @BiggieBows1752 Před 3 měsíci +1

      @@garywilliams5718 Oh yea you’re right, I was just thinking of the wood parts.

    • @SageWon-1aussie
      @SageWon-1aussie Před 3 měsíci

      Bowstrings are oiled to avoid moisture damage 😂

    • @garywilliams5718
      @garywilliams5718 Před 3 měsíci

      @SageWon-1aussie Fair point, but the bowstring would still probably be ruined, if not snap all together, and if it didn't, then your bow is still gone because if you light a wooden bow on fire, the fire will weaken the wood and then when you try to use it again the bow arms will break because they can no longer hold the tension from being superheated by a stupid wizard/sorcerer, but from my quick research the oiling is to stop your string from being rendered useless from things like rain, and water, however I doubt it can survive an explosion the magnitude of the fireball, I believe it's a 30 ft radius

  • @kingmarsh4657
    @kingmarsh4657 Před 3 měsíci +2

    Please turn this into a full series, this is amazing.

  • @LodanSD
    @LodanSD Před 3 měsíci +1

    My DM once gave my character a Power, I could use a spell from an Anime called Dragonslave: It has a 1-round warmup time and it creates a 5ft radius shield around me to protect me and my party, rains explosive fire across a 50ft radius around me, and puts me into a 3day coma when the spell ends. It was Super Effective inside an unholy cathedral where we fought a cult once...

  • @paranixoussouxinarap4090

    Congratulations on your character being arrested and sentenced to death.
    The player: "What?"

  • @michiwonderoutdoors2282
    @michiwonderoutdoors2282 Před měsícem +1

    I cast Fireball! On the deck of a sailing ship with oiled ropes and fabric sails.

  • @ds2476
    @ds2476 Před měsícem

    "It wasn't my fault, I didn't mean it", singed, naked wild magic sorc :'(

  • @reddart179
    @reddart179 Před 3 měsíci +1

    Divine spell book is immune to fire + general fire immunity.

  • @Stratelier
    @Stratelier Před měsícem

    Sometimes, if you have one problem and think "I'll just cast Fireball" ...
    ... now you have _two_ problems.

  • @snowiestpie451thefox3
    @snowiestpie451thefox3 Před 3 měsíci +1

    I absolutely loving this series so far! It's been very enlighting and entertaining

  • @emilyaw3831
    @emilyaw3831 Před 3 měsíci

    I was so thankful when my players debated for several minutes how the sorceress should best use careful spell to keep the party alive when she was about to cast Fireball for the first time (though she eventually decided that it was a better idea to just cast Burning Hands in the end)

  • @TheCantripCast
    @TheCantripCast  Před 3 měsíci +42

    Fireball

  • @1Maklak
    @1Maklak Před 3 měsíci +5

    I understand clothing, but books catch on fire and burn slowly and the spellbook is bound in leather and kept in leather bag or backpack. It should be salvageable.

    • @smolestoverlord1819
      @smolestoverlord1819 Před 3 měsíci +1

      Unless you take it out to cast something, then it's open and vulnerable imo

    • @1Maklak
      @1Maklak Před 3 měsíci +1

      @@smolestoverlord1819 True. When I first read the rules about spellbooks, I was pretty paranoid about preserving them, for example keeping a book dry.

  • @starburst98
    @starburst98 Před 3 měsíci +1

    Ah, but everyone in the party has a ring of fire resistance, so they have a magical shield that makes them not burn.

    • @SageWon-1aussie
      @SageWon-1aussie Před 3 měsíci

      "Get one free with every purchase of our patented bag of holding and portable hole combo pouch!"

  • @assassincharizard
    @assassincharizard Před 3 měsíci

    Rogues being all evasive in the middle of the fireball like "this is fine"

  • @gloweye
    @gloweye Před 3 měsíci +1

    This is why I tell the rest of my party to invest in Fire Resistance.

  • @nobodyshome6792
    @nobodyshome6792 Před 18 dny

    So back in the 1980s there was this module for D&D, something to do with a fortified city.
    The group got separated up for defense, as a combat oriented cleric, I was placed on a roof with some other spellcasters.
    Once the fight began, I cast heat metal on the armor of the being that was attacking the city. The other cleric in my group followed suit. We moved position and then i cast chill metal on the armor...
    I got a Rod of Destruction a few moments later as the god-animated statue attacking the city exploded. Nearly killed my little squad as well.
    Fun fun.
    Needless to say. I learned very early on to be careful of where i cast which spell.
    Plus in the D&D game on Sega Genesis (The Eternal Sun) if you fireball or lightnjng bolt indoors, you have to dodge or eat the damage. You can't even hse poison cloud inside....

  • @Donovank11z
    @Donovank11z Před 3 měsíci

    Incredible format! And you these videos will be a godsend to me when one of these comes up.

  • @JoshuaCard
    @JoshuaCard Před 3 měsíci +55

    "Oh, what? Did you think that the blaze of fire that you engulfed yourself and your party in wouldn't destroy you had on your persons?"
    Well, given that the spell's description reads: "It ignites flammable objects in the area that aren’t being worn or carried." Yes. Yes, I did.

    • @AidanNaut0
      @AidanNaut0 Před 3 měsíci +3

      You know what tends to happen when EVERYTHING around you is set aflame in a blazing inferno? Stuff starts to ignite, and then be on FIRE.

    • @JoshuaCard
      @JoshuaCard Před 3 měsíci

      @@AidanNaut0 Except this is magical fire. And this magical fire does not ignite stuff that is worn or carried.

    • @user-xf6zi8ii4w
      @user-xf6zi8ii4w Před 3 měsíci +4

      @@JoshuaCard This is a contained explosion, everything inside would be even more damaged, and everything on the outside would be ignited
      So yes, you did not lose your flammable gear. However you are now in a brazen bull, good luck.

    • @JoshuaCard
      @JoshuaCard Před 3 měsíci +1

      @@user-xf6zi8ii4w I'm ok with that. That's within the rules and too be expected based of my foolish actions. A consequence that explicitly contradicts the rules is unfair and if the DM is using their power to change the rules it should be explicitly stated before actions leading to those consequences are locked in.

    • @NoConsequenc3
      @NoConsequenc3 Před 3 měsíci

      @@JoshuaCard Magical fire hot. Hot fire make more hot fire. New Hot Fire not magic. New hot fire set everything on fire. It's really that easy.

  • @taramaforhaikido7272
    @taramaforhaikido7272 Před měsícem +1

    Any good mage will fire proof their robes and spellbook.

  • @glowingfox704
    @glowingfox704 Před 4 dny

    To the other people in my party who ask why I don't constantly use magic:

  • @ElijahCarrows
    @ElijahCarrows Před 2 měsíci

    As someone who ran a Chaotic Neutral Wizard in a custom game of 3e back in school, I can tell you that the DM was PISSED with me because I cast ONE fireball that killed a noble family because they were in the crossfire, plus they were necessary to continue the story... it was TOTALLY worth it.

  • @sir_slimestone3797
    @sir_slimestone3797 Před 3 měsíci +1

    Jokes on you the caster is a sorcerer and doesn't have a spellbook to lose, and can use a focus in place of components

    • @AnriDarkmoor
      @AnriDarkmoor Před 2 měsíci

      I was about to say this lol! Sorcerer don't give a damn :D

    • @morrigankasa570
      @morrigankasa570 Před 19 dny +1

      Even more of a joke on you j3rk DM, the entire rest of the party are either Teiflings or Dragonkin or Forge Domain Clerics or some combination of those things!

  • @indigodragon4098
    @indigodragon4098 Před 2 měsíci +1

    I'm an evocation wizard I'll just use sculpt to spell and we're all fine

  • @Americanbadashh
    @Americanbadashh Před 3 měsíci

    Intrusive thoughts go against the person's nature and ego. What you're thinking of is called, the Dark Urge.

  • @nicovalentine9326
    @nicovalentine9326 Před 17 dny

    *is a Evocation Wizard* "jokes on you"

  • @therizzmtizzm
    @therizzmtizzm Před měsícem

    I love the usage of the Backdraft movie scene photo

  • @WissenschaftZiegen
    @WissenschaftZiegen Před 2 měsíci

    Fire can be pretty useful actually. Imagine the unique puzzle situations you can do with it. Light up areas, reveal solutions, use fire to turn water into vapor for electricity. Not to mention if one is skilled with fire magic, they can control it with ease and elegance that can wrip through enemies and have your clothes and tomes leave unscathed. I say this as a dark wizard. If you like pyromancy, play with fire. If you want to burn an object, burn it. Just be careful when you play with fire though or the next thing turned to ash will be you

  • @tonsu646
    @tonsu646 Před 3 měsíci +1

    i cast Fireball, i then cast counterspell on myself, action surge, Fireball again just to flex on them

    • @SageWon-1aussie
      @SageWon-1aussie Před 3 měsíci

      The flame that burns twice as bright... and you have burned so very brightly.

  • @caseyhastings9219
    @caseyhastings9219 Před měsícem

    "I didn't ask how big the room was. I didn't ask how many enemies are in the room. I didn't ask how far away they are from my allies.
    I said 'I cast fireball.'"

  • @poyitjdr
    @poyitjdr Před 9 dny

    I hope y’all keep making these videos!! They’re cracking me up lol