22LR for self defense VS 25ACP???????? Are Budget pocket pistols any good????? Phoenix HP22A / HP25A

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 10. 09. 2024
  • So thanks to the situation that happened in 2020 there are many many more new gun owners. A question we get asked a fair amount is do you think a budget pistol is a good first gun. My opinion is if its what you can afford, or have then yes.
    .
    Would I personally have bought one for my first gun? (NO) Why? Well growing up shooting 22s I know how unreliable they can be. Don't get me wrong they are great for plinking, and less expensive to train with, but I always wanted a 45ACP 1911. So back to the point if I had to pick 1 I would go with the 25ACP! Yes ammo is more expensive/harder to find at times, but centerfire cartridges are so much more reliable than rimfire.
    .
    Something these pistols lack is ease of use. In order to swap mags you have to switch the pistol to safe, then release the mag. The mags don't drop free, but rather have to be pulled out. Once you put a new loaded mag in not only do you have to switch it back to fire, but you also have to rack the slide again. For me that is a deal breaker. Fun to shoot, but wouldn't want to have to rely on one for self defense.
    .
    So why did we get them well because I like pocket pistols, and wanted to be able to give an honest opinion. All in all with close to 2k rounds through the HP22A it has been great.
    .
    We will be doing a 1k subscriber celebration running 1k ads through various guns. So if that's something you'd like to see help us get there by smashing that subscribe button, and sharing our videos!.

Komentáře • 579

  • @2A_CaliGuy
    @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +19

    Something to keep an eye on when it comes to the Phoenix pistols. Had an issue with my HP22A, and decided to do a video showing what it was/how to fix it. Link is below.
    .
    Phoenix HP22A common trigger issue. How to fix it in under 5 minutes. Works for safety selector also
    czcams.com/video/A1GWrtNrkOs/video.html

    • @a.m.pietroschek1972
      @a.m.pietroschek1972 Před rokem +3

      I appreciate your no-nonsense attitude & factual info. Thanks! 🤗 `Helping, to form our opinions is better than trying to convince the salesman way!´

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +2

      @@a.m.pietroschek1972 Thanks I appreciate that. My goal is to give honest reviews. While these little pistols aren’t without their own issues I have definitely enjoyed both of them.

    • @brianmcg.8260
      @brianmcg.8260 Před rokem +1

      Thank you, Sir

    • @finn4004
      @finn4004 Před rokem

      you mixed up the counting

    • @rbm6184
      @rbm6184 Před rokem

      @2A_CaliGuy You can temporarily disable the magazine disconnect safety by putting a sliver of plastic under it to keep it from engaging and since its removable it does not void the warranty. The mag release safety nub will need to be filed down to prevent it from engaging but you will need a new manual safety/slide catch if it ever needs to be sent in for warranty as filing it down may void the warranty. I disabled those two safeties so the pistol functions like a normal pistol and still have the manual safety and the manual firing pin block safety. I got the Heritage Arms Rough Rider single action revolver and the Phoenix Arms HP22A for practice, training, varmint control, and small game. I did not get them for self defense. I would use them if they were all I had but .22 rimfire is not reliable enough for defense. I would not want to use .25ACP either for defense even though its more reliable than .22 rimfire because the mouse calibers below .380ACP have high rates of failure to stop threats over standard calibers. The reason they have high kill numbers is because they are cheap and cheap to shoot so many folks have them. But they have equally high rates of failure to stop threats. All pistols are poor at stopping threats its just that mouse calibers are worse. Best to use a long gun like a shotgun or rifle that generate higher velocity and muzzle energy. Thanks for sharing.

  • @d.tombentz3382
    @d.tombentz3382 Před rokem +34

    The Phoenix HP22a is a good little pistol and has earned my trust for reliability and you can't beat the cost or customer service that comes with it.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +3

      Definitely worth the price. I’ve gotta send mine in for repair, but regardless I’m happy with it.

  • @support_system24_7
    @support_system24_7 Před 11 měsíci +9

    Your mind is the most valuable asset you have in a self defense situation. Train your body and keep your mind sharp. The weapon is an extension of the user.

  • @fit4lifenickzagorov592
    @fit4lifenickzagorov592 Před rokem +22

    I had the HP22a Great little gun ! Acrually its an Amazing piece considering what it costs its hell of a deal! Never jamed on me once I put it through hell at the range and never even cleaned it (back then I was a lazy bastard) .
    I Highly recommend this little gem to anyone looking for a budget pistol.
    The damm thing is as quality built as my old Walter PPK/S. No joke.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +2

      Nice. I’ve got a buddy that hasn’t ever had an issue with his either. Mine I think needs to go back for service. The 25 though has been amazingly reliable. Bang every time , no jams. I like them both!

    • @fit4lifenickzagorov592
      @fit4lifenickzagorov592 Před rokem +5

      @@2A_CaliGuy I am interested in the .25 might pick one up (maybe)
      Its too bad these guys did not make a wider range of caliber guns like 9mm and up. According to the website they only have the Hp 22 and 25 thats it. If they made a decent quality 9 at lets say $300-$350 they can give some guys a run for there money.

  • @timhallas4275
    @timhallas4275 Před 11 měsíci +9

    .22LR was never designed or intended for a handgun. .25ACP was designed specifically for a semi-auto handgun. In fact, it was created to replace .22LR, as a handgun round, because of the reliability issues of rimfire ammo.

  • @thatsmytwocents4372
    @thatsmytwocents4372 Před rokem +16

    With the advances in ammo, especially personal defense ammo, i carry my .22 with no worries !!!

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +4

      22 is definitely a capable round. I wouldn’t want to get hit by any that’s for sure! 🙌🏻

    • @CL-ty6wp
      @CL-ty6wp Před rokem +1

      very little technology in 22lr ammo. Either a lead rn, copper plated rn or hp. Same ammo thats been around forever. Before cci it was winchester super x and remington hornets.
      The biggest downfall of the 22lr is the rimfire primer and it needs a rifle length barrel for full velocity/effectiveness.

  • @SCHUBERT-dd5nz
    @SCHUBERT-dd5nz Před rokem +11

    We purchased an old Raven 25 auto. Was made in the early 1970s. Picked it up for 40 bucks. After a good soaking in cleaning it fires great. Phoenix arms I believe purchased raven in the mid-1980s. Great inexpensive back up guns.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +2

      That’s my understanding as well. Raven, Jennings, Phoenix all based on the same concept. Something the shop said was they were all part of the pacific ring of fire guns. I didn’t look into it much. When I find something inexpensive I tend to just pick it up. Sort of collect them if ya know what I mean. Both my 22/25 by Phoenix have been great. Today I ran a 200 round test on the 22 using CCI 40 grain segmented HPs. Surprisingly I had quite a few failure to fires.
      .
      My experience with the HP22 is based only on my experience with a sample size of 1. I intend to do a similar test with the 25, and also to redo the test on the 22 with different ammos.

    • @SCHUBERT-dd5nz
      @SCHUBERT-dd5nz Před rokem +1

      @@2A_CaliGuy 22. Mag has always been my firearm choice. My dad grew up in southern Virginia. I grew up in Philadelphia. But my dad always used 822 long rifle for hunting and for butchering steer and hog. I started using a 22 single action army handgun. The ballistics were unbelievable. We now hunt, squirrel, rabbit, and groundhog with just the 22 mag bolt action. I also like the inexpensive firearms. I purchased three High Point 45 ACP handguns and three High Point 45 ACP carbines. My Daughter, son and I love them. When I purchased them quite a few years ago I paid less than $1200 for six firearms.

    • @SCHUBERT-dd5nz
      @SCHUBERT-dd5nz Před rokem +1

      @@2A_CaliGuy Great channel keep up the great videos.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      @@SCHUBERT-dd5nz yeah the 22 mag is epic. I have a rough rider in 22 mag, and have been eyeballing a 22 mag upper receiver for another AR build. 22 mag for me is a forever cartridge. It’s got a nice punch. Cheers

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      @@SCHUBERT-dd5nz Thanks I appreciate that, and I’ll definitely keep the content coming!

  • @mcgoodle
    @mcgoodle Před 11 měsíci +5

    I see you've got a helpful cat in your home. 3:56 You dealt with him smoothly, without even breaking stride. Well done.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před 11 měsíci +2

      Yeah she’s awesome. Wasn’t a cat person, but my son found her dipped in red paint. She’s been great. Her names wookie, but I call her wookalus. 😝

  • @SJ-EOR
    @SJ-EOR Před rokem +18

    I’ve shot thousands of rounds through my .22LR Phoenix. It’s a great little gun. Haven’t actually had that many loading misfire problems.
    I also own a .25 in another brand. Fun. But I can’t afford to shoot thousands of rounds through it. I’m not sure I want to count on a .22 for self defense. I always have a 9 handy. But, I’ve been known to carry it a 22 or 25 (different brand) in places I might not carry a 9. Just saying. I’d rather have it than not. But if you practice enough and have good enough placement I’m better off than the guy with a 45 who can’t shoot well. Oh and if I could only own one gun it would be a 22 and I’d be happy to start with the Phoenix. IMHO

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +4

      Scott. That’s what I’m talking about. Good shot placement is key. Having such low recoil they are great for some people. My little 22 Phoenix has been a gem. Haven’t had any feed issues. Have put a decent amount of rounds through it. I’d definitely stick with the P365 for carry, but if I could only pick one of the two I’d have to take the 25acp.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      @@Another-Address Shot placement is key, and no doubt even after a self defense shooting there’s a battle.
      .
      The way I see it is better to have it then not have it. My assumption is that most people will never need to use it, but given the current times who knows.
      .
      If I was going to go somewhere, and the thought of I Need to bring a gun came in my head I’d just stay home. Aside from hiking/backpacking where I’d bring it for snakes. The sad thing is places most people go you wouldn’t think you’d need to carry.
      .
      Going to the grocery store, the movies, restaurants, the mall. These are places you wouldn’t think I need a gun, but having one, and not needing is better then not having one, and needing it.
      The whole thing is criminals don’t obey laws, and laws that infringe only hurt law abiding citizens. With firearm ownership come responsibility. If not securely stored they can fall into the wrong hands.
      However aside from that with criminals they don’t care about laws. It’s illegal to stab people, but criminals do it. It’s illegal to steal, but they do it. It’s illegal to do drugs, but they do them.
      .
      Given the current situation with the economy, the ridiculous high rate of crime. Everyone has the right to feel safe, and enjoy life. That’s why the recent ruling about CCW licensing was so big. There’s areas in CA that unless you donated large sums of money you couldn’t get a CCW.

    • @d.tombentz3382
      @d.tombentz3382 Před rokem

      I like mine also.

  • @bugman-ir8cw
    @bugman-ir8cw Před rokem +38

    If I could only have one.....it would for sure be the 22lr; not the 25. I can buy a bulk pack of 22lr for how much?.....find the ammo it likes, polish here and there and wear it out.....for the price of 500 rounds of .25 caliber a guy can just buy a glock 19 with all the trimmings and forget about bargin guns....ammo price really matters in this catagory....

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +5

      Extremely valid point. You can train a lot more, and a lot cheaper with 22LR. My opinion is based solely on for self defense I trust any centerfire over rimfire. .25acp is not only ridiculously priced it seems to be tough to find.

    • @jeffwilson1217
      @jeffwilson1217 Před rokem +5

      @@2A_CaliGuyI bought a Baby Browning on gunbroker. When I found out the price of 25acp ammo, (40 clams), I got into reloading! I'm 65 and have shot thousands of 22lr. Can't remember ever a time when one didn't fire!

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +4

      @@jeffwilson1217 I’d love to have a baby browning, it’s on my list along with a seacamp, and Raven. Not sure why I like pocket pistols, but I do.

    • @jeffwilson1217
      @jeffwilson1217 Před rokem +3

      @@2A_CaliGuy was lucky enough to score one on gunbroker for only 405 clams! And that's with an extra mag. They usually go for 2 -3 times that, with only one mag!

    • @rickeybullington6314
      @rickeybullington6314 Před rokem +1

      I like my 25 cal.

  • @JamesSmith-gn9ou
    @JamesSmith-gn9ou Před rokem +13

    Considering the price, one of each. One for practice .22 lr and the .25 for self defense, as it is centerfire and more reliable than a rimfire.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +1

      That’s pretty much the same way I feel. Much less expensive to shoot/train with the 22LR , and more faith/trust in centerfire then rimfire.

    • @Aranck-kcnarA
      @Aranck-kcnarA Před rokem

      @Roopster .. I absolutely agree 100%

    • @Aranck-kcnarA
      @Aranck-kcnarA Před rokem +3

      @Roopster .. Crazy lucky is right, holy shit.. A 22lr would have entered his skull spun his brain into cottage cheese

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      @Roopster dang he’s lucky as hell. I wouldn’t want to catch 22, or 25 in the face.

    • @CL-ty6wp
      @CL-ty6wp Před rokem

      @Roopster Both lack velocity from these tiny barrels.
      There is also a video of a man ending a fight/life with a 25 to the brain.

  • @kerrydavidsadler980
    @kerrydavidsadler980 Před rokem +2

    I bought my Phoenix Arms 25 ACP new 3 years ago and have shot hundreds of rounds no problem and use as a carry gun often. It is so easy to hide and carry.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      The 25 is solid. Haven’t had a single issue with it. All in all I like them both. The 22 I had to replace some parts, but after that it’s been running great.

  • @AK-ky3ou
    @AK-ky3ou Před rokem +15

    While I prefer and own .22lr guns. If I only had one of the 2 cals to rely on I’d definitely go with the 25 acp. Great comparison of the guns and calibers.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +1

      I feel the same way, and thank you!

    • @thatsmytwocents4372
      @thatsmytwocents4372 Před rokem +2

      I’m the opposite. I would go with the .22. More advancement in the technology of the round and loads specifically designed for self defense, better velocity, more foot pounds of energy, better availability of ammo, better price on the ammo. My goodness, what ammo manufacturer doesn’t make a self defense round in.22 anymore. I like the Winchester, Sig, and probably carry the Federal Civil Defense the most !!!

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +1

      @@thatsmytwocents4372 I’m going to have to start looking for some good quality defense 22. Here it’s mostly bulk box, or CCI. That’s about all they carry. May be worth ordering some online to my local FFL. Sucks that we can’t order ammo to home here in CA

    • @13BravoBiggunsM110SP
      @13BravoBiggunsM110SP Před rokem

      Wonder what 22 punch would do, since it's designed for short barrel pistols,,? 👍
      Or 25 Buffalo bore hard cast

  • @tominmo8865
    @tominmo8865 Před 5 měsíci +2

    Agree with getting both. Cheap practice 22LR and reliable SD .25 ACP. Makes sense if you just want a pocket gun or as a backup, and this is all you can afford right now. Far better than nothing. The mag safety can be easily disabled, per many YT videos.
    But when you can afford to buy better, and want a pocket pistol, I recommend (and have) the Ruger LCP Max in .380, and a 12-round mag. Get the Mcarbo takedown pin and SS guide rod for reliability, and the more powerful recoil spring for softer shooting. Use either ball ammo such as Fiocchi FMJ or a milder HP such as Remington HTP green & yellow box. With the stock recoil spring and powerful SD ammo like the Sig V-Crown, it is very unpleasant to shoot, so people won't practice with it. I'll take .380 ball over .25 ball any day. I mention Fiocchi because it is the most accurate ball I have found, so far. Better than cheap range ammo, and as cheap or cheaper than most.
    HP is generally a waste of money with these short barrels, but if it's more accurate than ball I will buy it anyway. Shot placement.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před 5 měsíci +1

      Well put. I would love a Ruger LCP max, or even the Ruger LC380 over either of these. Appreciate you watching, and adding some excellent info ! I don’t much care for HP in 380s, and would prefer ball ammo as well.

  • @chrismurray3390
    @chrismurray3390 Před rokem +7

    I have one older Raven and two HP25's and one HP22. All are great guns and not ammo picky and all run great. The mouse guns are the easiest to conceal in my opinion.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      Nice. Glad to hear they all run well. My issues ended up being the loose grips. I did a repair video showing what it was. The trigger bar was hanging up slipping over the sear which caused light strikes repeatedly

  • @CoachKalu
    @CoachKalu Před rokem +2

    I used to have two of them actually. Fun little guns. Great for teaching kids (or anyone who has never fired a gun) firearms safety.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      Yes. I taught my sons with a good ol rough rider single shot revolver, and then introduced them to semi autos with these. My youngest son just stepped up from 22LR to 556 for the first time today! He’s 8 now . Proud dad moment seeing him ring steel today at 100 yards. Now I look forward to seeing him progress into long range soon.

  • @jesspeters1611
    @jesspeters1611 Před rokem +2

    If it's all you can afford, it's better than a sharp stick, plus it reliable and accurate, easy to handle.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      Would you take the 22 or the 25

    • @jesspeters1611
      @jesspeters1611 Před rokem +1

      @@2A_CaliGuy I have the .22. A close friend has one, I was impressed at how well it performed so I purchased one. The .25 ammo is harder to find so I would choose a .22. plus owning other .22 I don't have to buy more ammo types. I did see a test online comparing the two, the .25 was clearly more effective. There are many reviews on the HP22A nearly all are very positive as has been my experience. It's not my only firearm but it is as reliables as any more expensive ones. I didn't even bother to clean it for a long time but kept functioning fine. As for choosing one over the other, the reviews I have seen on the .25.appear to be as good as the HP22A.

  • @cmdrx5099
    @cmdrx5099 Před rokem +3

    I have some .25 acp mouse guns and a .22 lr Phoenix mouse one too. I carry in my pocket the .22, it’s better than a stick on a perp that wants to do grave bodily harm on you. I practice the Israeli draw.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +2

      Nice. I agree it’s better than a stick especially if you’re not carrying said stick. I prefer round in the chamber. Mainly because there’s a good chance you won’t have access to both hands in many scenarios. However if practiced you can get quite good with the Israeli draw. Thanks for watching!

  • @warblerblue
    @warblerblue Před rokem +8

    Keep your rimfires clean and oiled. My experience is You do that and they run well with any type ammo.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      Definitely a great point. I like to clean all my guns after each use, and even though that may be excessive it’s how I was taught. Seems like they all work better that way.
      .
      Something to note when I review, or give my opinion on a gun it’s based only on my experience. For instance I only have 1 so it’s not like I tested 100 of each gun, and I may have gotten a good/bad one.

  • @FlyingSpaghettoMonster
    @FlyingSpaghettoMonster Před rokem +2

    I know most people are buying these as range toys and not to carry, so the safeties are more of an aggravation for those folks, But the way they've designed their safety system actually makes sense for a pocket carry pistol.
    The main safety blocks you from accidently releasing the mag while you fish this thing out of a small pocket or purse. and the firing pin block is the actual safety while carrying. you use it to safely carry this hammer down and then flip it to fire while cocking the hammer back.
    it's a little hair brained but you can kind of see what they intended when they set it up this way.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +1

      I can see that. All in all I do enjoy plinking with them. So now if you had to pick one would you take the 22 or 25, and why?

    • @FlyingSpaghettoMonster
      @FlyingSpaghettoMonster Před rokem +2

      @@2A_CaliGuy the .25s probably what I'll pick up, apparently there's some bullet molds out there on the used market for it, it'd be hella fun to have a reloadable ".22 lr" 😂 although I'd probably want to find the mold before buying the gun

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      It’s definitely nice to be able to reload. The pain is finding the brass after firing it 😂. I have a Lyman 52gr mold. Lee still Carrie’s them I believe they’re under special order now.

  • @Isaac_5.56x45
    @Isaac_5.56x45 Před rokem +8

    Here in my local gun stores in Massachusetts, 25 acp is about $25 for a box of 50 FMJ, and a box of federal 22lr is $20 for 325 rounds, 22lr is my pick. Although my 9mm or 38spl is first choice, my little 22lr LCP is the most concealable thing I have for those dumb places that may frown upon having such a thing...

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +1

      Nice! Yeah 22 let’s you shoot a lot more value wise. Plus there is some pretty reliable defensive ammo available now.

    • @bradleysmith3963
      @bradleysmith3963 Před rokem +3

      I love 22 pistols and have a few but the lcp is hands down the best and most fun to shoot in my opinion. I carry mine with alternating CCI segmented and stingers.

    • @Isaac_5.56x45
      @Isaac_5.56x45 Před rokem +1

      @@bradleysmith3963 I have the CCI segmented as well, great little round.

    • @bradleysmith3963
      @bradleysmith3963 Před rokem

      @@Isaac_5.56x45 there’s a CZcams video by Beyond Seclusion where he shoots segmented rounds into cow parts, “ribs and such” and he uses the lcp2. Very impressive! They would definitely ruin someone’s weekend

    • @Isaac_5.56x45
      @Isaac_5.56x45 Před rokem +1

      @@bradleysmith3963 it's funny you mentioned that because I watched that video about a year ago and had never heard of segmented rounds before, but when I saw what they did to that side of beef, I was sold, absolutely incredible damage, 22lr can cause carnage at close range, and I have shot thousands of rounds through my LCP with only a couple little misfires, and I can shoot a popsicle stick in half from 10 yards with it, it's a great gun and ammo combo.

  • @mikeofmanymikes2630
    @mikeofmanymikes2630 Před 2 měsíci +1

    I was having problems with light strikes so I called Phoenix and they sent me some new recoil springs at no cost. I asked for a new firing pin as well but they told me to try the springs first and call them back if there was still a problem. Good customer service at least.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před 2 měsíci

      They definitely have grade A customer service. I contacted them, and after some R&R I got mine running much better. Still has some issues, and I found QC wise the firing pins are not all the same. The new longer pin has almost no light strikes!

    • @mikeofmanymikes2630
      @mikeofmanymikes2630 Před 2 měsíci

      @@2A_CaliGuy My firing pin barely pokes out of the hole when pressed. Wish they'd just send me a longer one.

  • @CamelWides
    @CamelWides Před rokem +3

    love the video but LOL that cat went FLOATING

  • @jimwebevstr4128
    @jimwebevstr4128 Před rokem +2

    I have a semi automatic 22LR rifle I bought for $35 years ago and it still works great today

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      These have both been great. Issues aside they’re both fun to shoot. The 22 gets shot more 😂 price of 25acp ammo is crazy

  • @jeffwilson1217
    @jeffwilson1217 Před rokem +4

    I'm 65 years old, and have shot thousands of rounds of 22lr. I can't remember a time where one has ever failed to fire.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +1

      I can’t ever remember a 22LR that didn’t fire eventually, but I have had plenty that wanted to be struck again 😂. So if you could only have one would you take the 22 or the 25

    • @jeffwilson1217
      @jeffwilson1217 Před rokem +1

      @@2A_CaliGuy oh, 22lr most definitely.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      @@jeffwilson1217 solid choice. I’ve definitely enjoyed plinking the HP22

    • @arizonaranger527
      @arizonaranger527 Před rokem +1

      I thought I had a malfunction but it was human error with that stupid tab by the hammer 😂

    • @jeffwilson1217
      @jeffwilson1217 Před rokem +1

      @@arizonaranger527 😂 that happened to me, too, a couple times!

  • @Patrick-ih4oe
    @Patrick-ih4oe Před měsícem +1

    I am 77 years young and hear a lot about 22 cal. dud rounds , which is strange because as a child growing up in Texas we NEVER experienced dud rounds .

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před měsícem

      It’s possible quality control isn’t what it used to be. As a kid duds were much less common, but then again I didn’t shoot 1000 rounds in a single range day as a kid either.

  • @frankbrowning328
    @frankbrowning328 Před rokem +3

    I agree. John Browning agreed too. That why he invented the ACP. A 22 or 25 is (Not always but typically) a deep conceal or last ditch gun. In a defensive role they aren't shot very much. It's not like your 22LR rifle that you may shoot several hundred rounds per outing. These types of pistols normally get practiced with a few times ayear. If the price difference in ammo between 22 and 25 is too much you must consider that there are additonal problems to be addressed in the defense budget.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      Well put. I trust 25acp more then 22LR that’s why if I could only have 1 I’d take the 25acp.

    • @FoulPet
      @FoulPet Před rokem

      I think he invented the 380 also and it's a better round.

  • @cericson3426
    @cericson3426 Před rokem +7

    If I absolutely had to carry one of these it would definitely be a 25acp because it is a centerfire round and almost guaranteed 100% of the time to go off.
    Where as you noted 22 long rifle can be sketchy from time to time.
    I've got a Walther P22 and the only thing it will shoot with any consistency is CCI mini mags
    Also as far as the 25 ACP I would carry ball ammo because you're not getting enough velocity to get any expansion on the hollow points.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      100% agree. The HPs we tested in ballistic gel didn’t do well. Almost no expansion, and only 10.5” penetration. Ball ammo did the best penetration wise, and hand loaded 52gr hard cast did similar with little deformation

  • @Narsuitus
    @Narsuitus Před rokem +2

    Thanks for the video.
    I do not trust the reliability of rim-fire ammunition.
    The 25acp center-fire ammunition is the smallest handgun caliber I rely on for self-protection.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +2

      Yeah, I don’t have full faith in rim fire either. I’ve never owned/shot a rim fire that didn’t have an occasional failure to fire.

    • @Narsuitus
      @Narsuitus Před rokem +1

      @@2A_CaliGuy
      I have never owned or shot a rim fire handgun. I have, however, collected over 200 rounds of failure-to-fire ammo that I have collected at the range.

  • @badcompany3828
    @badcompany3828 Před rokem +8

    Take the left grip panel off the gun. You’ll see a bar that slides up and blocks that mag release when it’s on fire mode. Just trim that bar down and you’ll be able to remove the mag is either safe or fire.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      Nice!
      I’m planning to order a spare to mod. I also like that you can take 3 small squares of gorilla tape, and stick it under the magazine disconnect.

    • @badcompany3828
      @badcompany3828 Před rokem

      @@2A_CaliGuy you can just pop that piece out. I did it with a small screwdriver

    • @paulbrinker4973
      @paulbrinker4973 Před rokem +1

      After trimming the bar, can you pull the slide back?

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +2

      @@paulbrinker4973 when it’s on fire yes, but on safe no. Trimming it allows you to remove the mag on safe or fire though

    • @stevengamboa593
      @stevengamboa593 Před rokem

      Did the same time now i love the little booger

  • @markpiersall9815
    @markpiersall9815 Před rokem +2

    In an emergency situation you will not have any ear protection. A 22lr standard ammunition pistol may be an option to protect hearing. Hearing loss and Tinnitus are annoying.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      This is true. I ponder because I wear a headset if the situation ever happened would I even worry to cover the other ear. I’ve shot my p365 chambered in 9mm once with one side of the ear pro off. Wasn’t fun.

  • @raymondpexton5440
    @raymondpexton5440 Před rokem +4

    I have both guns, already fixxed the safety's with the saftey mods so now it works like a regular gun I know it is not under warranty any more but I'm a gun collector and I had to fix both.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +1

      Same here I have no interest in selling mine. I also like to collect. Cool inexpensive guns will always have a spot for me. If I’m running a dros I feel like adding something neat inexpensive is worthwhile

  • @jayrocksxxasap1273
    @jayrocksxxasap1273 Před 3 měsíci +2

    You never slid the safty to off without the clip!!!!! Driving me nuts!!!!

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před 3 měsíci +1

      Good point. I need to revisit this, and give an update. I have fully serviced the little thing, and it’s just as unreliable 😝, but it is easier to operate. Thanks for watching, and the comments!

    • @jayrocksxxasap1273
      @jayrocksxxasap1273 Před 3 měsíci

      @@2A_CaliGuy thank you brother for getting back to me. I havnt looked. Nd just seen it... Im well over 4000 rounds down my acp 25... Still works great. No maintance other then clean.. Because sometimes at range ill just mag dump it.. And usually gets the tip black. Never had 1 problem. And my lr22.. Maybe little over 700 rounds.. Has 1 problem.. I cant miss my target

  • @anthonyhatter1882
    @anthonyhatter1882 Před rokem +4

    Bought one a month ago very happy with it.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      They’ve been great. I do wish I got the range kit that comes with the 5” target barrel. Considering how much fun we have plinking with the 22 I feel like it was a great investment. On the 25acp side we like it, but don’t care for the ammo price vs 22LR lol.

    • @anthonyhatter1882
      @anthonyhatter1882 Před rokem +1

      @@2A_CaliGuy yes thought about getting kit to but like it's compact size wear cargo pants all the time so it perfect for side pockets. Live in the mountains so that ph22 is great gun for rattle snakes when out mowing or in the barn or gardening. Great gun for training a beginners or people that don't have good finger strength.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      @@anthonyhatter1882 good point. Have you ran any snake shot through it to see how it cycles. I picked up some 9mm snake shot for my P365, but haven’t tried it to see how it cycles. Maybe I should do that.

    • @anthonyhatter1882
      @anthonyhatter1882 Před rokem +1

      @@2A_CaliGuy Have snake rounds only in .38 and it #9 shot works well on rats in chicken coop. Have not seen shot shells in hand gun calibers in a long time

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      @@anthonyhatter1882 yeah some have been hard to get. Luckily by us there’s a place that seems to keep 9/38 in stock, but I haven’t been lucky enough to find any 22 in awhile

  • @raymondpexton5440
    @raymondpexton5440 Před rokem +1

    The .22 does not bounce around the body out of a .22 pistol. That is the .223 or .556, out of a rifle, out of a pistol .25acp penetrates farther, it beat all .22 or ammo I stacked up against .25acp.

  • @ronsmith5411
    @ronsmith5411 Před rokem +3

    My dad was a police officer70s 80s, I remember he said he went on a call, he noticed blood on the porch ,he knocked on the door and a guy answered, he had blood blood all on him and his ear was black, he told my dad he tried to commit suicide with his 22 pistol, he said he stuck it in his ear n fired , he layed down on the couch and got a bad head ache so he went next door and got some aspirin , came back put the gun in his ear and shot himself again? The first bullet went in the ear and down into his chest, the second bullet went through the top of his ear hit the scull went up around his head n out just above his other ear

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      Jeez. Hopefully he made it through. I’m going to make a ballistic gel block. Take it out with the 2 Phoenix pistols. I’ll try to get the video up this week. I know I wouldn’t want to get hit by a 22, at the end of the day any bullet is bad news.

    • @dah960
      @dah960 Před 6 měsíci

      Note to self. 22 is not good for head shot unless the eye

    • @journeyman378
      @journeyman378 Před 5 měsíci

      That was probably a 22cal short. Lr would probably killed him.

  • @deborahbarker5175
    @deborahbarker5175 Před rokem +2

    I've done modifications to mine to where it functions exactly like an 1911. Still as safe as before without the California compliant BS. Gun shoots great, never any misfeeds and very dependable..(as reliable as a .22 shell can be.)

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      That’s what I’m talking about. I’ve been meaning to do the mods, but just haven’t. Mines also as reliable as the ammo I feed it 😂. Got a bunch of different types of ammo for some other stuff I plan to do reviews on this weekend.

    • @christinamoneyhan5688
      @christinamoneyhan5688 Před rokem +1

      Yes ,I did the same thing. Too many safeties are not what anyone needs to contend with. As a matter of fact they are more of a threat to you if you are ever confronted by a animal be it two legged or four legged. I carry mine while out and about .

  • @100vg
    @100vg Před měsícem

    You just proved what I've been hearing, that 25ACP is more powerful than 22LR, and it was also said it was designed to be. I have a Phoenix Arms HP25A and I also like ACP over Rim Fire. Never had a misfire with it. I know you had fun at the range with the kids. That's great to see.

  • @jakerook6248
    @jakerook6248 Před rokem +1

    I own the hp22A and love it for summer CC. She has never had a malfunction outside of dud primers on cheap range ammo (always a good hammer strike). Seriously considering picking up the .25 just for the sake of having a more reliable caliber for the same purpose ❤ amazing little pistols, and highly accurate for their size.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      After going through mine it has been a great gun. Possibly I got a bad one, and it didn’t help all the dry fire abuse it was subjected to. The follower mod to hold slide open definitely prevents some of it. All in all great gun. Thanks for watching. I also have the 25, and aside from finding ammo I like it quite a bit

  • @gedocowboy8484
    @gedocowboy8484 Před rokem +2

    After the safety mods my 22 is great. I haven’t had many malfunctions that I can remember, I haven’t shot it in a long while. If you take it to the range and learn what ammo work’s completely reliably, then it can serve in a self defense role. The 22lr has a cool factor with it, and the price can’t be beat. You can spend all day plinking for little money, and keep a bunch of ammo on hand at all times for little money. It’s hard to beat. At some point I’m going to get the nickel version to go with my black one.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +1

      Definitely can plink on a budget with them. I really enjoy mine. I reload my 25 so cost is close to the same, but reloading 25 sorta sucks. Very slow going

  • @fresnogrizzly5290
    @fresnogrizzly5290 Před rokem +2

    Im curious to know if the 25 slide, barrel and magazine fit and function on the 22lr frame. Or even the other way around.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +2

      I believe I tried before, and there was something that didn’t work.

  • @frethand101
    @frethand101 Před 4 měsíci +2

    IDK what the internet commandos say, having a backup of 10+1 in .25acp JHP's on standby in a SOB holster is better than having no backup at all, and that's a hill I'm willing to die on. 🤠
    For some strange reason, there's this growing platoon of online/offline self-defense trainers that have concocted a tossed salad approach to Civilian Self-Defense based on Mil-Spec/LEO Tactics, "when in reality" Civilian Self-Defense is nothing like the afore mentioned arenas. Civilians have the coveted "element of surprise via concealment" affording us the advantage of the "unexpected counterattack", and there's hours-n-hours of cctv footage that clearly display how effective just that one advantage can be once it's been deployed.
    Statistics show that the average civilian gunfight lasts roughly 3-6 seconds, and that's largely to do with the Thugs WTF reaction due to their poorly planned dumb idea that everybody will be scared of "ma gun" and submit to their will, but while they're fantasizing about all the street-cred they're gonna be basking in they never anticipate the wild card that may very well be lurking just beneath a trained civilians garment. ☠☠☠

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před 4 měsíci

      Solid, and true. They typically expect victims, and when someone comes back with any show of force they don’t know what to do. At the end of the day I’m my own first responder. It’s my job to keep myself, and my family safe. Thanks for watching I appreciate you.

  • @notnowchief.3089
    @notnowchief.3089 Před rokem +2

    You can Mod the Mag disconnect. It's fairly simple.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      I like the duct tape trick. A guy posted a video about it.

  • @sonsofliberty3158
    @sonsofliberty3158 Před 11 měsíci +1

    Once you mod out or off all the safety features, this is a badass little gun…. I sold mine because I cracked the lower frame after 5k rounds or so. A friend of mine still has it, & it still runs with the crack inside the lower frame under the barrel. You can buy 4 of these for the cost of 1 SR22 pistol tho, well worth the $$

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před 11 měsíci

      I agree 100% they’re quite a bit of fun. I still have them both. I just used the 25 ACP for a video I did the other day.

  • @KathrynLiz1
    @KathrynLiz1 Před rokem +6

    .22RF ammo varies a lot in quality. I'd be OK with a ,22 with top grade ammo...CCI Mini-mags or Stingers... the hollow points would cause more damage than the FMJs in the .25, although at pistol velocities that would be marginal. Either will get your attention....

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      It definitely would get your attention. The last 200 round test I did was with CCI Segmented HPs, but there was an issue found on my Phoenix. I did a video showing the issue. Now that I’ve got it sorted out I’ll have to redo the test. Mini mags are definitely one of CCIs best ammo.
      Thanks for the comment. I plan to pickup a good variety of ammo soon, and will post a video soon. In the 500 round mossberg maverick video we did Sunday we used a bunch of different ammo, and it felt like a more realistic test of the guns reliability.

    • @jesspeters1611
      @jesspeters1611 Před rokem

      Also Aguilar works equally as reliable as CCI.

    • @CL-ty6wp
      @CL-ty6wp Před rokem +1

      Neither hp expand at pistol velocities and a tumbling 22lr bullet does more dmg than a hp.
      Same reason why the 5.56 in light bullets and slow twist barrels are devastating.

    • @theconservativebeacon878
      @theconservativebeacon878 Před 6 dny

      22lr hits way harder than the 25aco

    • @theconservativebeacon878
      @theconservativebeacon878 Před 6 dny

      25acp 61ft lbs at the muzzle..22lr 110 ft lbs at the muzzle. Do the math

  • @CL-ty6wp
    @CL-ty6wp Před rokem +2

    22 is 100% underrated ballistically , specifically out of a rifle.
    The projectiles tumble which cause significantly more damage than a mushrooming projectile.
    Will easily reach brain, heart , lungs ect, has 0 recoil for follow ups and usually come in 10 shot semi autos.
    If i had to be in a gun fight, i'd grab a 22 rifle over any handgun.
    But yes those stats reflect the fact probably 25% of American households have a 22lr.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +2

      Yeah they definitely don’t have any recoil. All in all they’ve both been great little ranger guns. A rifle would no doubt be better. Plus you get the added velocity from the longer barrel.

  • @criticalmemetheory5404
    @criticalmemetheory5404 Před 5 měsíci +1

    Good to see .25 ACP beating .22LR. But, if I had to buy a budget SD handgun, I’d buy a used .380 LCP or .25/.32/.380 Keltec before throwing away good money on Phoenix Arms products. Thanks for doing that interesting test. 🤙🏻

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před 5 měsíci

      Solid advice. I like the .380 LCP!

  • @ReneeFuller-eh2no
    @ReneeFuller-eh2no Před 3 měsíci +1

    I recently bought a Phoenix Arms firearm. And I'm not happy at all. First off I didn't get the one I ordered. The firearm came bone dry, and the serial number is extremely hard to read.
    When I contacted to them about the firearm not being oiled they said they don't oil their firearms.

    • @Nunbutdatruth
      @Nunbutdatruth Před 3 měsíci +1

      Aw man that sucks😔, I just started my 10 day background check a day ago but mine came somewhat oiled up, best case scenario just buy a kit or the current one you have for cleaning your tools & do the normal maintenance on it before using it

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před 2 měsíci

      Yeah the serial on these is a bit tough. To my surprise though Phoenix Arms has an amazing warranty!

  • @keithfreeman5204
    @keithfreeman5204 Před rokem +2

    I would still pick a 22rf. Availability of Ammo is the reason. From Standard Velocity to the really High Velocity stuff, Round Nose, Hollow Points, Segmenting Rounds, so with Practice a 22 would still be my caliber of choice. A lot of ammo is a really small space.This is for what I call..."Get off Me" guns. The Mini Mag 40g rn.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      Solid choice. Ammo is definitely more available, and priced better for the 22. I like the “Get Off Me” I know I wouldn’t want to get hit by one ☝️ that’s for sure.

  • @Qwijebo
    @Qwijebo Před rokem +3

    Any pistol any caliber in the right hands can kill a perp, .22. 25 or 380.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      Absolutely, and given the small size/low recoil. Someone with limited dexterity May find comfort in smaller calibers. Also training with 22 is quite a bit less expensive then anything else. All about shot placement.
      .
      So if you could only pick 1 would you take the 22, or the 25

  • @thomaspalmer7900
    @thomaspalmer7900 Před rokem +1

    My brother owned a Phoenix Arms .22 years ago and I was one absolute accurate pistol and reliable!!! My personal opinion is I would not want to carry any .22 with less than 3-4” barrel. I will definitely say that I do like small concealable pistols especially the snub nose revolver. I carry a Taurus 605 .357 magnum 2” barrel loaded with .38 +p 125 grain JHP Underwood ammo. I feel very comfortable in that revolver for my total protection if needed!!!

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      My wife loves her Taurus revolver. She also has the 357, and has the Black Talons in it. Something I love about revolvers they are insanely reliable. Go bang everytime. No issues with cases jamming etc.
      For what we paid for the Taurus I’d say it could be the best choice for affordable CCW guns. Nice long trigger pull to fire from uncocked, but having the option to cock the hammer for nice crisp trigger is epic. Another perk is less worry of accidental discharge with it in the uncocked hammer position.

    • @thomaspalmer7900
      @thomaspalmer7900 Před rokem +1

      @@2A_CaliGuy absolutely agree!!! The only issue I had with this revolver is the small grips and I have big hands. I ordered a new bigger set of Hogue grips & actually replaced them earlier today. I can certainly get a big better grip now and better comfort. I have .357 magnum rounds loaded at present but I think I’m going to switch them out tomorrow with the .38 +p 125 grain JHP by Underwood. I hear the .38+p is a great ammo but less recoil than the .357 magnum

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      Yeah I’m not a fan of the smaller grips. They work great for my wife. Something I’ve wanted to get is the Rock Island M206 revolver. For awhile they were under $200, but I haven’t seen them in any stores for a good minute.
      .
      One of the worst parts of Komifornia is the 1 in 30 rule. Makes it hard to grab something when it comes up unless your not currently running a dros, or the shop offers layaway 😆

    • @thomaspalmer7900
      @thomaspalmer7900 Před rokem

      @@2A_CaliGuy so sorry you live in California. I hear people are leaving there by the hordes!! I live in VA & we can pretty much buy what ever firearm we want. We do have a state law that only allows us to buy a 1 handgun per month but can purchase as many rifles & shotguns as you want. Very dumbed stupid law!!!! Shotguns & rifles are far more dangerous & lethal than pistols!!!

  • @joewarrell4455
    @joewarrell4455 Před 6 měsíci +2

    All ammunition malfunctions.personally, I would not choose a 25 over a 22 Lr. Any day of the wk.

  • @DG-nb6fe
    @DG-nb6fe Před rokem +2

    Kel Tec p32 trumps all 22, 25, pistols for CC. 8 rounds of .32acp in Fiocchi fmj has no recoil and plenty of penetration for short self defense distances and easily goes where alot of 9mm and .380s often cannot.
    Jmo.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      Nice I’m going to have to check it out. Wonder if it’s on CA roster.

  • @jayrocksxxasap1273
    @jayrocksxxasap1273 Před 3 měsíci

    I also shot over 2000 rounds out of my 25... Still works great..never a problem.. The 22 is really acurate and i only fired maybe 1000 rounds out of it

  • @eliasarmolina6960
    @eliasarmolina6960 Před rokem +2

    Question: Since you have both could you see if the barrel swap is a possibility? 25ACP to 22LR? I am just curious to see since the frame on both look identical, I am curious to see if the barrels and mags are interchangeable. I have seen that they have 2n1 Conversion Kits, but that is for extended barrels. HP22A to HP25A?

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +2

      Absolutely I’ll check. It does seem it would work with a complete slide/barrel etc swap. The grip module is marked 22/25 on mine. Seems to rack/cycle just fine.
      .
      The barrel/mag swap doesn’t seem it would work as re assembly I mixed up barrel, and there’s a cutout preventing 25 from going into 22. Hopefully that answers your question.

    • @eliasarmolina6960
      @eliasarmolina6960 Před rokem +2

      @@2A_CaliGuy it did. I was just curious and well if they did. I was going to go buy the 22LR barrel and mag; but if I need the slide as well, doesn’t seem to fun to do since I would just buy a new gun at that point which again isn’t to bad haha 25ACP is just hard to find. Thank you for checking.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +2

      Yeah the firing pin is different as well. 22 is on edge, 25 is centered.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +2

      Only good thing so far I’m able to reload my 25acp for about $0.10 per shot. Most of the cost is the damn primers that are overpriced at $70.00

    • @eliasarmolina6960
      @eliasarmolina6960 Před rokem +2

      @@2A_CaliGuy wait you make your own ammo? How do you do that? Possible video; I’m subscribing now.

  • @mindofawarrior1971
    @mindofawarrior1971 Před rokem +2

    I don't think the Phoenix 25 is worth it. When I got mine many years ago I didn't know the 25 acp ammo was very expensive. Like a box of 50 bullets were $35 and up.. I only shot it once at the shooting range. I regret it.. I should have gotten a Phoenix 22lr.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +1

      Ammo for the little bugger is definitely overpriced. I’ve found reloading it makes it more affordable, and because low velocity ammo is recommended I can tailor the loads for it. $0.06 primers $0.02 powder, cast lead bullets from range scrap or wheel weights, and reuse my brass. Thanks for watching. Maybe I should do a video on reloading 25acp

  • @ThierryDeOliveiraBR
    @ThierryDeOliveiraBR Před 11 měsíci +1

    25 ACP is weeker. I choose the .22. But I have other pistol in .25 ACP, Alpha Proj CZ3035, but the barrel is only 2.5".

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před 11 měsíci

      Fair enough. I may snag an RG 25 that I’ve had my eye on for awhile 😝. I was actually surprised how well the 25 did in my recent video. It penetrated the makeshift plate, and (3) 1 gallon water jugs. I know when it comes to 22 there’s definitely a fair selection of stuff that’s much more reliable than the bulk box stuff.
      .
      Thanks for watching I appreciate it.

  • @phoenixskeptic7698
    @phoenixskeptic7698 Před rokem +1

    I got the .22 a couple years ago and modified the safeties. Would never depend on a Phoenix Arms to defend myself.
    Oh, California, that speaks volumes.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +1

      Gotta love Komifornia. Hopefully things will change here soon.

  • @bfuentes99
    @bfuentes99 Před 11 měsíci +1

    I owned an HP22a and after a few years the slide cracked. It was replaced for free but the gun is not something I would bet my life on.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před 11 měsíci

      I’ve heard of a few people that had similar issues. Great for the range, but I agree it’s not something I’d bet my life on. So if you had to pick would you take the 22, or 25?

    • @bfuentes99
      @bfuentes99 Před 11 měsíci +1

      @@2A_CaliGuy I would still choose the 22, even with it being rimfire, you can get better velocity than the 25. Great video!

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před 11 měsíci

      Fair enough. Appreciate the input!

  • @erikwaters4672
    @erikwaters4672 Před 4 měsíci

    I'd take the .25 ACP all day. Centerfire means that it goes bang a bit more than rimfire. I'll just take a tad more care with my shots. These are pistols for use at "bad breath" distances, anyway. It may not go that deep, but again, you have to choose your shots--and targets--well.

  • @CHEECHMUN
    @CHEECHMUN Před 5 měsíci +2

    .25 because it's center fire. Also, if I have to reload, I can!!!

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před 5 měsíci +1

      Solid. I found a mold for 25acp, and really like them with some red dot, and hi tek coating.

  • @smokingcrab2290
    @smokingcrab2290 Před 2 měsíci +1

    If they made this in 32acp, it'd give the Beretta tomcat a run for its money

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před 2 měsíci

      Facts! My tomcat has an issue. The rail portion of the frame cracked.

  • @kirkmorrison6131
    @kirkmorrison6131 Před rokem +1

    There was a case ,(used in a couple of TV shows), were a guy was shot in the chest and died from an embolism. The bullet was found in his ankle

  • @dalesearcy5734
    @dalesearcy5734 Před rokem +1

    I would not use my HP22A as a primary carry gun.
    I have used it as a back up or when a larger gun is not practical to carry.
    No desire to own the .25 version due to ammo cost and availability.
    Use high grade .22 ammo like the Federal Punch and I'm comfortable carrying my HP.22A on occasion but not daily.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      Well said. It’s definitely not my first choice for a carry. Weight size is close to my P238, and not much smaller then my P365

  • @jayfrm65
    @jayfrm65 Před 20 hodinami +1

    So if u have the phoenix arms 25 acp can you use 22lr ammo or will it blow up in will the ammo fit in the magazine

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před 20 hodinami

      @@jayfrm65 na you can’t use 22LR in the 25. It

  • @HarveyMushman888
    @HarveyMushman888 Před 10 měsíci +1

    25 ACP currently .58 cents vs. 22LR at .05 cents. 25 ACP is currently more expensive than .45 ACP

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před 10 měsíci

      Yeah 25 ACP definitely isn’t cheaper to shoot. Even with me reloading for it, and casting my own boolits I’m still above the price of 22LR.
      .
      That said if you could only have one for self defense what would you choose?

  • @anamericancitizen2971
    @anamericancitizen2971 Před rokem +1

    I have a HP22A, I would not buy another one, not because I think its a bad gun, I think its not take down friendly. It shoots fine, it loads fine. I did remover 2 of the 4 safety leaving the hammer safety and the trigger safety. It is a fine gun, now take down may loosen up and I only did it once, it is a pain in the ass, very difficult. This is the only reason I would not buy another one, other than that, I like it. I also bought 2 extra clips for it and extra recoil springs. Gun cost less, parts cost less, clips cost less. Its priced right, but I removed those 2 safety's before I even shot it, it was too safe, so safe I feel it makes it dangerous if you ever need to actually use it because its too complicated, without the 2 safety's its easy.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      Yeah I feel pretty much the same. I’ve gotten used to them finally, but definitely wouldn’t be my first choice for a carry.

  • @user-tr5tt8fc8u
    @user-tr5tt8fc8u Před rokem +4

    LOVE the curious cat 😁
    Thanks for the review

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +2

      Yeah she’s pretty cool. Son found it covered in red oil based paint as a kitten. We cleaned it up, and now she’s part of the family.

  • @anthonyangeli256
    @anthonyangeli256 Před rokem +2

    Correct. But 22lr is very efficient in a revolver or rifle. You should mention that absolute fact to clarify your conclusion.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      I’ll do a follow up video. Depending on the revolver/ammunition. For instance my heritage rough rider has about the same amount of failure to fire as this, but they’re both in the same price range. While I was filming the video for 22LR velocity with barrel length I had the opportunity to shoot about (30) different 22LR guns. I decided to use mostly the buck mark footage, but did shoot everything. There’s no doubt about it 22LR is deadly, but 100% it’s not as reliable as a center fired round.

  • @kowalskikowalski8080
    @kowalskikowalski8080 Před rokem +1

    There are a lot of "friendly" pitbull attacks in my city. I bought the .25 acp to defend myself from "friendly" dogs.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      I haven’t had a single issue with my 25acp other then finding ammo, and ammo price 😂. I finally fixed my HP22A. Did a fun velocity test. All in all if I had to pick one I’d still stick with the 25 because it goes bang everytime

  • @HiredGun5
    @HiredGun5 Před rokem +1

    I have both of these.
    I train with the .22 and carry the .25 when I need a pocket pistol.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +1

      I like it. They’re both great. I agree with you train with the 22 rely on the 25 if needed. Similar to using the CMMG 22LR AR conversion kit. Great for training, but definitely keep the 556/223 for SHTF situation.

  • @denizenofclownworld4853
    @denizenofclownworld4853 Před 6 měsíci +1

    YO DAWG! I see your gun has a safety, so we put a safety in your safety!

  • @GlenMones-le6yf
    @GlenMones-le6yf Před 3 měsíci

    Out of a short barrel 25 and 22 are about equal power wise..BUT .25 ACP .. with it s full metal jacket FMJ hardball.. penetrates hard barriers like the skull and sternum much better than any 22 lr out of a short barrel.... Coupled with the reliability of the centerfire 25 and 25 for self-defense is a much better choice

  • @kevanhubbard9673
    @kevanhubbard9673 Před rokem +3

    .22 would be better as the ammunition is a lot cheaper but power wise .25 and .22 are about the same but I suppose that .25 has a tiny edge having a bigger bullet.If it's correct that the .22 has killed more people than any other cartridge then it's because it's the most common.I have read that about the .22 too but think about the millions upon millions killed by machine guns in just First World War obviously different calibers but not that many varieties.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      Ammo price & availability is definitely better for the 22. I plan to do a better comparison when I get some ballistic gel, and ammo that’s more similar. Having both the same gun is great, but I feel like I should find ammo that’s almost identical also.
      .
      So if you could only pick 1 would you take the 22.

  • @jeffmedina43
    @jeffmedina43 Před rokem +2

    My Phoenix has given me zero problems

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      Nice. I may need to send mine in to have it checked out. Do you have the HP22, or HP25?

    • @jeffmedina43
      @jeffmedina43 Před rokem +1

      @@2A_CaliGuy I have the 22

  • @rangersmith4652
    @rangersmith4652 Před rokem +3

    Fascinating little guns. I have a 25A on its way to my FFL to add to my collection. I don't plan to carry it (a pocket .380 has served me very well for over a decade), but it will be fun at the range.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      I enjoy it. Not my first choice for carry either. My P238 is my favorite pocket gun! Thanks for watching!

    • @boss94ways51
      @boss94ways51 Před 9 měsíci

      So how do you like the 25

    • @rangersmith4652
      @rangersmith4652 Před 9 měsíci

      @@boss94ways51 Sadly, I haven't gotten it to the range since receiving it. Life kicks in sometimes and throws curve balls. No real hurry as it's mostly just for having rather than firing. But I'll get there, probably after the first of the year.

    • @boss94ways51
      @boss94ways51 Před 9 měsíci +1

      ​​@@rangersmith4652ok thx im at counter buying one right now as we speak...lol😅

    • @HeisenbergFam420
      @HeisenbergFam420 Před 8 měsíci +1

      ​@@boss94ways51have you shot your yet ???

  • @SilntObsvr
    @SilntObsvr Před rokem +2

    I'd bet there's a fairly simple way to disable the link between safety and mag latch. Might also be possible to at least make the gun lock open until you drop the mag, so you know you're out before pulling the trigger on an empty chamber, too (lots of small auto pistols do this with a simple notch in the rear of the magazine pusher that catches on the bolt/slide). Making the mag drop free is likely just a matter of some work with emery cloth or a file. Fix those things, and it's no worse (or better) than an Excam or other mid-20th pocket pistols. If it's built out of steel instead of a cast zinc frame I'd surely consider buying one -- I like the .25 round, most of these tiny pistols are more accurate than people believe, and as others have said, .25 is better than .22 just for reliability. Once upon a time (1970s) it was the second biggest selling ammunition caliber in the US, after .22 LR -- suggesting that at least some of those little "purse pistols" were actually going to the range pretty regularly.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      I’ve enjoyed them both. They are cast frames, and you are correct if you wanted you can modify them to be more user friendly. I just got a setup for casting, and just so happened to get a .25 bullet mold from a friend. The only downside to the 25 at the range is ammo isn’t cheap. For self defense ammo it’s not bad, and would work better then nothing.

    • @SilntObsvr
      @SilntObsvr Před rokem

      @@2A_CaliGuy I had the setup to reload .25 once, but I found I could only find about a third of my spent brass at an outdoor range. Between being so small it can vanish between two pieces of gravel or into the cracks between boards in a shooting bench, and needing a close look to sort it from .22 LR, it just wasn't worth reloading (to me). Same has been true for .32 ACP and .380 in my experience.
      Now, if you manage to find or make a brass catcher so you can keep, say, three quarters of your brass, reloading for the tiny semi rounds might become practical -- or if you have a private indoor range so all the brass you pick up is yours and you just have to sort by caliber...

    • @catboi1188
      @catboi1188 Před 7 měsíci

      They sell a kit that keeps it open after last shot 👍 eBay $16 by PA

  • @raymondpexton5440
    @raymondpexton5440 Před rokem +1

    And for the .25acp bashers both barrels are the same length and the .25acp penetrates more plywood than the .22.

  • @raymondpexton5440
    @raymondpexton5440 Před 11 měsíci +2

    I have both guns, I already fixed the safety's so guns work normal, as far as wich one would I carry it a no brainers,.25acp

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před 11 měsíci

      Yup 25 FTW

    • @raymondpexton5440
      @raymondpexton5440 Před 11 měsíci

      Some say I killed warranty, I'm a gun collector, these 2 were real cheap, can always just order the parts and fix them myself, they have never jammed, or misfired as saturday night specials are better than high point, or sccy,

  • @NMI371
    @NMI371 Před rokem +2

    Recently purchased hp25a brand new. 50 round box of pmc through it so far. Haven't had one magazine without at least one jam. Frequently have two jams per magazine. Cleaned and lubed, will try some different ammo. I wouldn't buy it again.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      May need to break in. From one to another in the shop you can feel the difference some are gritty. Hopefully it sorta itself out

  • @jeffwilson1217
    @jeffwilson1217 Před rokem +2

    Bought a box of 25acp pmc bronze last winter, for 40 cookies! I was so shocked, that I immediately got into reloading! Haha 😄

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      Even with primers at $150/1k or $0.15 ea I’d say it’s worth it. Shoot if the projectiles cost you $0.10-$0.15 such little powder we’ll call it $0.02 that’s $0.32 ea x 50 ($16.00) now the only thing is where the heck do you find projectiles, or would it be better to cast the little suckers

    • @jeffwilson1217
      @jeffwilson1217 Před rokem

      @@2A_CaliGuy Graf & Sons Reloading. I believe they were prvi partizan.

  • @raymondpexton5440
    @raymondpexton5440 Před rokem +1

    I have both and never jammed or misfired so they are both sitting in house I keep the .25 next to me with a beretta 950 .25acp next to it and a .357 next to it, both guns have the safeties fixed so they both act like a regular gun.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      I’ve enjoyed both of them. I trust the 25 more then the 22. If I could only have one, and needed it for protection I’d still take the 25. No Jams no failures to fire. Sure ammo is more expensive, and harder to find in some areas, but all of my 22s have had plenty of duds etc. I’d like to get a beretta, or even a seacamp. Recently got a P238 which I like quite a bit.

  • @sasquatch6344
    @sasquatch6344 Před rokem +1

    U can unscrew the grip break a small piece of the safety and 💥 fixed I can clear check it without mad in

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +1

      I used a Dremel to clean mine up. Works much better

  • @MrAvidOutdoorsman
    @MrAvidOutdoorsman Před rokem +1

    Another benefit of not screwing around with all those safety features is that you could load single rounds if needed if your mag breaks

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +2

      Good point. Gotta love Kommifornias idea of safe handguns 😂

  • @wintersoldier4335
    @wintersoldier4335 Před rokem +1

    no issues with mine so far....you can actually insert the mag just halfway near the mag release button and actuate the safety to on/off easily.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      Nice. Mine works much better after replacing a few things. All in all it’s been a great range plinker. Thanks for watching

  • @wolfman2702
    @wolfman2702 Před rokem +10

    In the unlikely event you are attached by a flock of clay pigeons I guess the .25ACP would be the eay to go, but I prefer the .22 LR.

  • @daviddavey1727
    @daviddavey1727 Před rokem +3

    For the cost difference between the .25 and .22, there isn’t that much difference in performance! .22 is better than a sharp stick!

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      Very true. I’d take either over a sharp stick. 22 is so much less expensive to shoot. We ended up getting a CMMG 22LR conversion kit for an AR, and it definitely sees the most range time thanks to ammo prices.

  • @hermanmunster4949
    @hermanmunster4949 Před rokem +3

    I bought the Phoenix HP25A "just because" and I was not expecting much from it other than convenient to carry along in the tackle box or when hiking. I took it to the range and was quite surprised at how well it functioned and that it was quite accurate with respectable groups. By the way, Hitler carried a 25 ACP Walther PPK.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +1

      I definitely enjoy mine. I scheduled a video to post tomorrow morning of my range trip with my Phoenix HP22A today. It has its issues, but regardless I like it. I have considered getting another to see if perhaps mine just gives occasional light strikes. I haven’t had a single issue with my HP25A other than ammo availability, and price 😝

  • @withoutprejudice8301
    @withoutprejudice8301 Před rokem +2

    There is a mod to override the magazine lock.

  • @Lex5576
    @Lex5576 Před 9 měsíci +1

    If the gun is going to be used purely as a defensive weapon, and not to be fired all that often, then .25ACP is probably the better choice. But Dear God! A box of them is going for $40+ in my area as of December 2023. I can polish off a piss load of premium, hot .22LR for $40 vs 50rds of .25ACP.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před 9 měsíci +1

      Made my day. I don’t get why the little suckers are so expensive, and I love my 22LR bulk packs.

    • @Lex5576
      @Lex5576 Před 9 měsíci +1

      @@2A_CaliGuy I misspoke when I said $40 a box. They’re actually $30 a box here in North Carolina….. still the price of two boxes of 9mm target loads.

    • @SCH292
      @SCH292 Před 9 měsíci

      Just think of these calibers as.."one packer". Lol. You buy one pack a year or in YEARS. You shoot that one pack whenever you feel like it and once you done with it? You done with it. Maybe after x amount of time passes by you might remember and buy another one packer.

    • @gregb6469
      @gregb6469 Před 7 měsíci

      @@2A_CaliGuy--Supply and demand.

  • @newshaman7251
    @newshaman7251 Před rokem +1

    Phoenix arms .25 cobra model was one of the best semi autos I ever owned.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      The cobra reminds me more of the baby browning then the HP22/HP25. So the question remains!!! If you could only pick one ☝️ which would you take the 22, or the 25?

  • @mikem.2078
    @mikem.2078 Před 2 měsíci

    You live in California? If you send / receive a firearm for repair, do you have to go through an ffl? Or direct usps? Gets pricey?

  • @sniffmoneyArmsAndAmmo
    @sniffmoneyArmsAndAmmo Před rokem +3

    Those guns are definitely CA compliant lol good review and I'd definitely trust the 25acp over the 22 in a defense situation....I do have the 22 version it didn't like CCI standard velocity ammo or CCI Stingers but ran the CCI mini mags just fine so that's all I've been running in it....good job testing kool vid

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +1

      Speaking of mini mags that’s what I used in all 9 guns for the velocity test. Barrels were from 1.75 inch to 18 inch.

    • @sniffmoneyArmsAndAmmo
      @sniffmoneyArmsAndAmmo Před rokem

      @@2A_CaliGuy ok kool I gota go check that vid out 👍🏼

  • @Onlyist
    @Onlyist Před 3 měsíci +1

    The only complaint I have is that your elbows weren't quite to the table when shooting the 22 but they were definitely on the table when shooting the 25 so that little variant might have changed how many the 25 went through

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před 3 měsíci

      😝 that’s a valid point. We should make a tape line for the next test. Thanks for watching, and I appreciate the honest opinion!

    • @Onlyist
      @Onlyist Před 3 měsíci

      @@2A_CaliGuy keep up the great content

  • @davidmurphy619
    @davidmurphy619 Před rokem +1

    Pallidan had. The right idea. Have Gun Will Travel was a look into a rare west point grad who somewhere between sanfrancisco hot tubbing and boots on the ground professional troubleshooter and sometimes killer had the sensitivity to help all applying but when they got the best of him and disarmed him .. he had his derringer hidden under his belt buckle ... I learned early... Uncle Ringo showed me where we bury the rustlers on Arizona ranches up north. I got a rep as a trick shot and out of the marines I was guarding Kissinger and Chase as they had returned from China Accords ... It was not on the roster but I kept a 25 auto in my pocket and the armory I had at my disposal I rarely touched unless asked. And if it was really serious the pretty wooden gun case swings open and it's LAWS rockets and such ... But nothing lives on that quarter million acres ....unless I let it ... Get it ?

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      Richard Boone. So if you could only pick 1 would you take the 22 or 25

    • @johnmoore8067
      @johnmoore8067 Před rokem

      Get me some of that shit you are smokin bro.

  • @cntrshot1
    @cntrshot1 Před 11 měsíci +1

    So, I have had one of these for a while and I carry it mainly due to extraneous reasons as opposed to I prefer it over other pistols and I'll say with full honesty that it's **not bad**.
    Don't get me wrong for the price range you can get better guns that are more reliable and powerful such as rock island armory's model 206 revolver chambered in .38 special. But this does what it needs to, especially after the safety modifications to alleviate the cumbersome manual of arms. Especially whenever you throw the remington trash ammo out the window by just using it all up at the range and you carry it with CCI minimags or stingers.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před 11 měsíci

      I actually want a RIA 206 😂. I have since I first held one at a shop. They oddly haven’t come back in around here in quite some time

  • @stevenmiller184
    @stevenmiller184 Před rokem +1

    I believe this is the only gun currently chambered in .25 auto. I love my .25's, I have a Beretta 21a in .22 and in .25, The .25 is FAR more reliable. My Colt Junior in 25, never has failed. My Beretta 950b and 950bs in .25 are pretty reliable but the size of the pistol creates a problem with the slide hitting my hand (ouch) and interfering with the cycling of the firearm. A pocket gun like the Phoenix is not a gun you are going to put 300 rounds daily through at the range, most people MIGHT fire 50 rounds a month. This makes the cost of the ammunition almost irrelevant. Availability of .25 IS a problem, I find that the thing to do is, when you see it... buy it. You may not shoot it today, but it will be there when you want it. All the "Safety" crap is ridiculous.. making a gun that fussy makes it less safe. Is this gun a Double/single action? It appears to be single action only. Can it be kept "Cocked and Locked" or is the safety a decocker? No last round hold open, it appears.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      No last round bolt hold open without mod. Safety isn’t a de-cocker. Single action only. I agree when it comes to ammo for stuff I own when I see it I get it unless I’m well stocked!
      .
      Thanks for watching. I’d like to get a Beretta 21A

  • @rwdchannel2901
    @rwdchannel2901 Před rokem +1

    .22LR can be carried a lot of places people wouldn't be comfortable carrying any other caliber. If I went to a gym to exercise I would want a NAA mini revolver in .22 magnum with folding grip on me if I was to bring a handgun.

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      I’d like to get an NAA, and would definitely want both cylinders so I could run 22LR, and Mag. Thanks for watching.

  • @kings-bay-2902
    @kings-bay-2902 Před rokem +1

    I have had the 25 acp for f years now , weekly I shoot at the range where I live it is a good gun , I carry this daily

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem +1

      Good to know they hold up well. From what I’ve heard from a good amount of people they see to last. Aside from a few people that ignored the velocity limits on ammo, or installed the recoil spring incorrectly after cleaning I haven’t heard many negatives about them. Plus the price was great!

    • @kings-bay-2902
      @kings-bay-2902 Před rokem +1

      @@2A_CaliGuy I am not trying to take over Ukraine with this gun , I am
      Carrying it to defend myself , and to have fun at the range ! It had been a great gun for me !

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      @@kings-bay-2902 made my day 😃.

  • @raymondpexton5440
    @raymondpexton5440 Před rokem +1

    As cheap as the gun is I just fixxed the safeties so everything is normal except the hammer block safety

    • @2A_CaliGuy
      @2A_CaliGuy  Před rokem

      After fixing the issues mine had I’ve been enjoying it at the range. Great little plinker. I shoot the 22 more then the 25 simply because ammo availability.