Emmy winning singer reacts to The Warning “Black Holes” live (2017) + (2019) [Miki’s Singing Tips]

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 11. 09. 2024
  • Uninterrupted Videos:
    The Warning "Black Holes" 2017 ( • The Warning - Black Holes )
    2019 ( • Black Holes - The Warn... )
    Join my VIP (Very Important Performers) Singing Group - bit.ly/3zcmdAu
    Join my VIP (Very Important Pianists) Group - bit.ly/3y38qKV
    For just $29.95 for the first month and $40/month thereafter, you get a full library of self-paced lessons, one on one feedback from me, a monthly live webinar AND a fun group of peers to keep you motivated. Can't wait to be your teacher!
    __________
    I now take special requests for my reaction videos! For $15 to Paypal ambugalard@msn.com, subject line "Vocal Coach Reacts," you can jump to the front of my request line, and I'll react to your favorite artist/performance next! (Make sure to include the artist/performance you'd like me to review in your payment)
    PATREON:
    Want exclusive access to an extra reaction video every week? Want your requests bumped to the front of my reaction queue? Now I have a Patreon where you can get all these benefits! / michaltowbervocalcoaching
    NEW SERVICE: I will evaluate your singing and give you personalized exercise recommendations. Send an audio or video recording, and $40 to Paypal ambugalard@msn.com, subject line "Evaluate My Singing!"
    SINGING STRAW: Use my affiliate code "Miki" for 15% off your purchase through the end of the year, and 10% off after that: lddy.no/ager
    MY SINGING COURSE:
    It was two years in the making, but I am so proud to say, I finally finished my complete singing course and it’s now available at www.udemy.com/.... It’s almost 6 hours of material, and it’s for all ages and skill levels. If you’d like me to be your teacher, but can’t commit to regular private lessons, now you can learn with me at your own pace and at a fraction of the cost.

Komentáře • 72

  • @kevinthetruckdriver353
    @kevinthetruckdriver353 Před 2 lety +38

    *Black Holes* is not about breaking up from a relationship. It's a song about a person, *who's begging for help* as they're *failing from their addiction.*
    Dany is singing the undertone voice every time they play *Black Holes* live. Which is very rare..
    Pau wrote this song when she was 13 years. Heard is was about an family friend who was slipping from their addiction.

  • @Dave_Marks
    @Dave_Marks Před 2 lety +38

    Nice! Pau wrote this when she was 13! She has an incredible voice that because drumming is so intense she doesn't get to use as often as she should.

  • @greggordon7230
    @greggordon7230 Před 2 lety +77

    I'm standing directly in front of Pau,maybe 3 feet away,in the Whisky video. I can tell you for a fact that there wasn't a dry eye in the place when she finished. You honestly have to experience them live to truly understand their power, it's not the same as in the videos. I've been going to concerts for 50+ years and have never felt like this band makes me feel at a live show and I've seen them 3 times,it's almost a spiritual experience! Flying to LA from Ohio for the 3rd time to see them again! ⚡⚡⚡

    • @TheUnderdogDe
      @TheUnderdogDe Před 2 lety +6

      It might also help if she had some experience with people with strong addictions ( _or being one herself_ ). 😉

    • @terryandrews7271
      @terryandrews7271 Před 2 lety +4

      Good for you buddy, It's not supposed to be jealous of your neighbor but I am. Have a great time I know you will⚡⚡⚡⚘⚘⚘

    • @rexwave4624
      @rexwave4624 Před 2 lety +10

      I’m a convert. 15 feet from the stage, dead centre in Toronto. The power is intense. The songs are amazing. I’ve seen Deep Purple and Led Zeppelin at the heights of their powers. This is the first time I’ve heard anything to compare.

    • @greggordon7230
      @greggordon7230 Před 2 lety +5

      @@rexwave4624 I saw them 3 times in May on their headlining MAYDAY TOUR and I'm seeing them again on July 13th with Halestorm & The Pretty Reckless 🤘🎶🤘
      I've been following them for over 8 years now and they never cease to amaze me!
      ⚡️🥰⚡️🥰⚡️🥰

    • @rexwave4624
      @rexwave4624 Před 2 lety +4

      @@greggordon7230 , lucky guy, I’d love to see them on the TPR/HS tour. Both of those bands are great. TPR will have to rock to follow after TW! I hope TW will get full use of the sound system.

  • @lonelywind3511
    @lonelywind3511 Před 2 lety +41

    She starts smiling when people in the audience start singing with her. Always nice to have people appreciate a song you wrote. This is on their first full studio album XXI Century Blood. As noted, the Dakota Bar version is easier to see when Dany and Ale both come in.

  • @glenallencox966
    @glenallencox966 Před 2 lety +12

    As a 62 year old in my 33rd year of recovery from drug and alcohol addiction I tear up every time I hear this song.
    LONG LIVE PAULINA VILLARREAL and her SISTERS aka THE WARNING!

  • @professorg9424
    @professorg9424 Před 2 lety +51

    A 13-year-old Pau writing about the horrors of addiction. Amazing insight. From what the girls have said they have never experienced any of the things they write about (except maybe Animosity). They're well-read and socially aware. And Pau pours her heart into every performance of this song.

    • @holydado
      @holydado Před 2 lety +12

      When I’m Alone is another personal song.

    • @TheUnderdogDe
      @TheUnderdogDe Před 2 lety +6

      From what I understand a friend of the family struggled with addictions, so in a way, they kind of had some experience with the subject.

    • @professorg9424
      @professorg9424 Před 2 lety +4

      @@holydado And one of my very favorites!

    • @paulsink9861
      @paulsink9861 Před 2 lety +5

      We also found out after Choke had been out awile its what Dany went through in real life.

  • @vincentcortilli4896
    @vincentcortilli4896 Před 2 lety +25

    I battled depression and addiction, song hits me hard

  • @carlnietoweise4653
    @carlnietoweise4653 Před 2 lety +20

    Every time I hear this song I'm amazed by how gifted these three are ,that they can feel things completely out side of their lives. Having been there, I HOPE no one else goes through lonely, hopelessness of addiction in any form! That line " and the venom starts to swallow me whole" is so on point! I still get teared up even after all these listening's and I'm not the only one as I've seen grown burly men reaching for hand kerchiefs. These ladies are truly special!

  • @jluisg622
    @jluisg622 Před 2 lety +10

    Pau one of the best Rock drummers, composer, pianist, singer, a complete musician

  • @timnye718
    @timnye718 Před 2 lety +13

    Great reaction! This was actually a song about addiction. It is a very dark song and how Pau can come up with these amazing lyrics at such a young age (She was about 13 when she wrote this) is mind boggling!

  • @Frisco40
    @Frisco40 Před 2 lety +22

    I hope thiis song helps you students more or even increase their interest. Paulina is an exemple of talent, bur also of dedication. I really like her insights.

  • @KansaSCaymanS
    @KansaSCaymanS Před 2 lety +14

    As mentioned below, Pau wrote this song about addiction based on either something she read, or a family acquaintance, depending on which story you’ve heard. Not sure why Roy requested these two performances rather than the more popular one from the Dakota Bar, but appreciated your reaction and analysis nonetheless. 😎

  • @NoSmokingDogs
    @NoSmokingDogs Před 2 lety +24

    The first performance (at UVM) was a little rough but as usual the girls powered through it. It's always a surprise when a reactor doesn't use the gold standard performance for this song, that being the one from the Dakota Bar. The Whiskey performance had OK audio but not as good as the Dakota Bar. That being said, it appears your focus on this video was to compare the 2017 performance to the 2019 one to see how their voices have developed over those years. It will be really interesting to see if they perform this at their upcoming Troubadour shows.

  • @elgonwilliams7624
    @elgonwilliams7624 Před 2 lety +5

    The empathy their lyrics exude is what impresses me. Even if they don't have first-hand experience they are aware of the pains others endure. Also, it's amazing the power they can create without the drums. Of course, Pau is using the percussive sound a piano offers.

  • @robertkrawitz8237
    @robertkrawitz8237 Před 2 lety +16

    The 2019 performance was definitely a friendly and knowledgeable crowd. If I remember correctly, this was essentially a private concert that was auctioned on Kickstarter (I wasn't Warned at the time, and I don't live anywhere near LA, not that the latter ever stopped people from going).
    I don't remember which concert it was, but there was one performance where Pau stopped singing during the final chorus for a few bars so she could hear the audience singing.
    At the Dakota Bar performance, Pau was smiling much of the time, which isn't exactly what the song is about. I suspect that the audience reaction was so powerful that even though she was singing it was evident what was going on, and she was soaking up the moment.

    • @TheUnderdogDe
      @TheUnderdogDe Před 2 lety +3

      I believe she stop for the crowd at Foro Didi but it was hard to hear them in the video.

  • @iNsTaNtpUdDiNhEaD
    @iNsTaNtpUdDiNhEaD Před 2 lety +10

    Nice reaction. If you want to see Paulina out there by herself on stage, check out her performance of "Escape the Mind", the title track from their debut EP. This was performed at an early morning outdoor assembly at their school. Pau was 13. This was just before their trip to the Berklee College of Music in Boston. The video is titled 'THE WARNING - ESCAPE THE MIND / ORIGINAL SONG @LICEO'.

  • @danieljodrey8863
    @danieljodrey8863 Před 2 lety +5

    I hope by now you are becoming something of a fan Miki.
    These ladies are everything I want in a musical group. Talented in the extreme. Passionate to the core. Absolutely fearless in attitude. Intelligent songwriters and insanely proficient on their instruments
    💖🔥💖🔥💖
    Love your shows.
    I LOVE THIS BAND !!
    ✌💖🎼

  • @fredrickpinckney1092
    @fredrickpinckney1092 Před 2 lety +8

    Whenever there are multiple videos available of them performing a song I am often puzzled by the selection chosen by folks who recommend to reactors, and this is definitely one of them. But I'm happy you get to hear this nonetheless.

  • @gill2105
    @gill2105 Před 2 lety +14

    Love the song, but you did make me wonder how much they might change the arrangement and performance in another 10 years. I'm sure it will still be awesome though. Very cool analysis Michal thanks !

  • @robertoalejandroorozco3503

    They just released dates for their Mayday Tour

  • @rhagnvald
    @rhagnvald Před 9 měsíci +1

    "is just Paulina with a keyboard".... Ale: "I am nothing to you? :("

  • @abjbusti8586
    @abjbusti8586 Před 2 lety +9

    Thanks for the great reaction as usual. This song is a tear jerker 🤘😭🤘

  • @edgarzambrano9636
    @edgarzambrano9636 Před 2 lety +15

    I love this song!!!

  • @acesema22
    @acesema22 Před 2 lety +8

    One of my favorite song..brings me to tears everytime!😥💓👍

  • @MaddogJones
    @MaddogJones Před 2 lety +20

    I think the live performance at The Dakota Bar was the best recording however I like that this one was chosen as it shows a couple things that make The Warning so good. One, of course is that Pau is such an amazing musician not only on the drums but as a vocalist and pianist. Two Pau had a couple gaffs with remembering the lyrics, she didn't melt down and stop playing, she didn't make an awkward facial expression no, she powered on and continued like nothing happened. A true pro...
    The Warning has stated that they try to write their song as ambiguous as possible while still trying to maintain a cohesive theme or story so the listener can get whatever message they feel from their songs. Having said that Paulina wrote this song at the age of 13 after reading a story in the newspaper about addiction and the affects it has on the people the addict has in their life. These girls are wise beyond their years and so friggin' talented!!!

    • @TWBiker
      @TWBiker Před měsícem

      Check out the versions at either the Pepsi Center in Mexico City were the UK private concert to see an updated version. The Pepsi Center is a tearjerker

  • @tunanorth
    @tunanorth Před rokem

    "I surrender in my defeat"..... That line gets me every single time. Let me get a tissue, and then recommend that you check out their latest CZcams releases from their CDMX show last summer. They just keep getting better!

  • @HarrymegamanDJ
    @HarrymegamanDJ Před rokem +2

    This is a beautiful song and Pau is doing it great. She has such a good voice for singing this. It´s interesting to see how the other girls already have begun to find their stage moves. Ale behind Pau, she is constantly moving and she already has the steps for the dance she still does all the time. She never stands 100% still, and this si what makes my eyes move in her direction. No matter how good the other girls are, Ale steals your interest. Three sisters with different personalities but one soul, they give the band that special touch.
    The clip from the Whisky is better when it comes to the sound. Pau smiles in the beginning but it´s not because she isn´t moved by her song. She smiles because she notices the crowd is singing with her.

  • @terryandrews7271
    @terryandrews7271 Před 2 lety +2

    She is fearless And a great performer, Best of both worlds

  • @ronjones1077
    @ronjones1077 Před 2 lety +3

    I admire this groups message and dedication. This style of music is not one I am drawn to, but I can still appreciate the talents involved. Your reaction is on point and I just wanted to hear something out of character for me.

  • @agustinmanyari
    @agustinmanyari Před 2 lety +3

    Miki 😊🙏🏻 great great great reaction as always 🤘🏻 Black holes is so beautiful, lyrics are powerful and Paulina’s performance is stellar 🔥⚡️

  • @jrpikasso13
    @jrpikasso13 Před 2 lety +4

    THIS IS MY FAVORITE REACTION OF URS MY FRIEND✌😍 GREAT ASSESSMENT OF THIS LAST PART OD BLACK HOLES👍 DANY IS IN MY EARS AND EYES A GREAT LEAD SINGER OF THE WARNING, SHE PLAYS GUITAR AND BELTS THE VOCALS AT THE SAME TIME AND IS A GUINNESS AS IS PAULINA AND ALEJANDRA THEY ARE THE WORD ⚡THE WARNING⚡ THAT KEEPS ON GIVING US THEMSELVES🎸🥁🎤🎶 LUCKY US👍

  • @moriner892
    @moriner892 Před rokem

    It's interesting that in a recent interview Pau revealed that she was a huge Shakira fan and the person she would most like to meet.

  • @vili7783
    @vili7783 Před 2 lety +4

    Hello coach Miki! Nice reaction!
    .....

  • @jnetzahuatl
    @jnetzahuatl Před 2 lety +5

    Buena reacción!! Pues por más que me esfuerzo, no escucho semejanza entre la voz de Paulina y Shakira🤔😉, definitivamente las tres han crecido vocalmente. The Warning: poderoso trío de rock. Saludos 🇲🇽🇲🇽🇲🇽

  • @16ploog79
    @16ploog79 Před 2 lety +5

    All great but the Dakota Bar version from 2018 is the best.

  • @SDsailor7
    @SDsailor7 Před 8 měsíci

    I think it would be nice if the reactor would re visit this song at the performance that she gave at the concert at the pepsi center in Mexico city this year and it was performed with a string arrangement and also the song Breathe was performed right after black holes.
    not a dry eye in the house not even Pau could contain herself.

  • @gmespia
    @gmespia Před 2 lety +5

    Such a great song but then again, which TW song is not great?

  • @joaquinantoniogarciagonzal3395

    EXCELENTE REACCIÓN

  • @bobbarber2070
    @bobbarber2070 Před rokem

    You really need to react to Revenant off the new album, Error. Her vocals in that song are incredible!!

  • @janoriega67
    @janoriega67 Před 2 lety +6

    I was there... just saying :-)

  • @noebrunn6242
    @noebrunn6242 Před 2 lety +4

    I🖤TW🤘

  • @cuesphyx1820
    @cuesphyx1820 Před 2 lety +5

    Hello..im curious..hope u wont be offended to my question..Many vocal coaches reaches to everyone globally.. how can they teach if their accent/ennunciation/pronunciation is different FRom there student.?

    • @cuesphyx1820
      @cuesphyx1820 Před 2 lety

      Many vocal coaches disregard my question... Really no respond...

    • @TheUnderdogDe
      @TheUnderdogDe Před 2 lety

      @@cuesphyx1820 I don't think that a vocal coach could care less about accent/enunciation/pronunciation since they mostly teach how you breathe, store your air, to get the most out of your singing. In other words, they can teach someone to sing/growl in any language as long as they know what sound you want to produce.

    • @MichalTowberVocalCoaching
      @MichalTowberVocalCoaching  Před 2 lety +3

      I don’t try to change my students’ accents, I want them to embrace what makes their voice unique. Sometimes we tweak vowels for resonance, but other than that there is no preferred singing accent.

    • @cuesphyx1820
      @cuesphyx1820 Před 2 lety

      Thanks coach for the reply.... Just to add.. some listeners, and as for me prefer to understand the lyrics that the artist are singing that's why i came up to that question.. anyways...thank you..

    • @cuesphyx1820
      @cuesphyx1820 Před 2 lety

      @theunderdog.. it's really the job of vocal coaches... But my question is 'how' (pertaining to my previous comment)... But thank you.. coach replied and im ok with it..

  • @gsg1959
    @gsg1959 Před 2 lety +1

    The song is about addiction

  • @canuck2011canuck
    @canuck2011canuck Před rokem

    Yes , they are that good .

  • @robertbyrd4796
    @robertbyrd4796 Před 2 lety

    I thoroughly enjoyed your reaction. I have thought that Pau has a smooth, smokey, raspy sound to her voice like some of the Jazz singers in the 40's. All three are really good vocalists. I do understand why Dany is the lead singer other than because she is the oldest and Pau plays the drums.

  • @TUBBYMAXX
    @TUBBYMAXX Před rokem

  • @contaaleatoria3848
    @contaaleatoria3848 Před rokem

    Yeah, there's a bit of shakira in her voice! A it became a meme about her "paukira"😂😂 have a lot of videos of her singing shakira songs imitating Shakira's voice and letting that tong tension way more perceptive! and even pics of her lying in shakira's name in the hall of fame, just like shakira did in the past 😅

  • @krash66
    @krash66 Před 2 lety +7

    Thanks for the cool insight! After listening to them on repeat for years now, I can tell you my observations. Dany has a "brighter" tone (pitch? timber? not sure the correct term) to her voice than Pau. Pau is more of a "Broadway Belter" type of a voice. Ale has a more soulful tone and not as powerful as her sisters (She reminds me of Chrissy Hynde from The Pretenders). And you will also notice that Pau has a natural rasp and a lisp on her "S's" that Dany and Ale don't. It may be because Pau's teeth are a bit crooked and they didn't want to interrupt her natural singing progression and performance with Braces. Their mother is a dentist, so I am sure this must have come up, at some point. Perhaps Invisalign in the future, just for her oral health? Anyway, their harmonies are great because of the similarity AND the slight differences in their voices.

  • @rexwave4624
    @rexwave4624 Před 2 lety

    Miki, how can Pau and Dany improve their pitch control?

  • @padme2804
    @padme2804 Před 9 měsíci

    It`s about an alcoholic person don´t know if it was a family.

  • @mkourgo8645
    @mkourgo8645 Před 2 lety +3

    😎🇲🇽🤟

  • @davenorman8251
    @davenorman8251 Před 2 lety +1

    You probably should have done the Black Holes, Agua Fria, Dakota Bar or Foro Didi or maybe all of them at once. Pau is a musical genius...you should react to her first song Escape the mind at the School show czcams.com/video/wtRLmnQ9-Cc/video.html Thanks

  • @raulvillasenor9360
    @raulvillasenor9360 Před 2 lety

    Reaction to show me the ligth live ..

  • @SirCamsmorethanalot
    @SirCamsmorethanalot Před 3 měsíci

    WTF!!!!!!!! You take up 2/3rds of the screen!!!!!! WHY? Why not have the more reasonable reverse situation!???? You reviewers all do it except for a couple of in tune ones. STOP IT! Reactions are OK but feature the band FFS!