By the way, are YOU a GOOD PERSON? | Harvard Moral Dilemma

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 26. 06. 2017
  • Subscribe ♪ ~ ᕕ(ᐛ)ᕗ bit.ly/DanPlanSubscribe
    Do you know the trolley car riddle? Where you must choose between 5 people or 1 person on a railroad track. Well, today we're going more in-depth than any other youtube videos I've seen so far. Exploring the fat man dilemma, the doctor, and organ transplant surgeon dilemma.
    Professor Michael Sandel from Harvard University asked new law students whether morality is a real thing. He asked them whether the idea of totalitarianism is sound or do the methods in which you achieve them matter.
    Professor Michael Sandel teaches courses on justice, societal philosophy and other amazing courses you should check out. Its all online for free and all the questions I ask are from his lectures at Harvard. The amount of philosophy that's embedded in the trolley car dilemma is absolutely insane.
    Harvard Courses: justiceharvard.org
    Time:
    0:18 Trolley Car Riddle: If you were a trolley car operator, would you change your lane to kill 1 person instead of 5?
    1:16 Fat Man Dilemma: If you were outside of the trolley car and the same situation happened, would you push a fat man onto the tracks to stop the car?
    3:08 Doctor Dilemma: If you were a doctor and 5 mildly injured patients with 1 severely injured patient come, who would you save?
    3:46 Surgeon Dilemma: Would you steal five organs from one innocent man to save five patients?
    Dan Plan ♪ ~ ᕕ(ᐛ)ᕗ
    Our Discord: / discord
    By The Way Series: • By the way, The Condom...
    Our Facebook Page: / danplanb
    Our Twitter Page: / danplanb
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 11K

  • @corn8561
    @corn8561 Před 4 lety +3285

    The real question is: WHY TF DOES A HEALTHY GUY TAKE A NAP IN THE HOSPITAL

    • @tarnyowl6068
      @tarnyowl6068 Před 4 lety +318

      He’s suffering from plot convince syndrome

    • @crom5906
      @crom5906 Před 4 lety +82

      Mandatory check ups are a thing for specific jobs. Also some illnesses you only start to actually notice when it's too late. So even people who think they're perfectly fine get check ups because they might have a serious illness.

    • @Silvianyay
      @Silvianyay Před 4 lety +65

      You know how long it takes for doctors to actually get to your room it takes them like a hour you could take a nap in that time

    • @corn8561
      @corn8561 Před 4 lety +15

      @@Silvianyay lol

    • @genericname3470
      @genericname3470 Před 4 lety +14

      He could be waiting for a family member or friend who is getting checked out..

  • @-itzizumi-uwu4995
    @-itzizumi-uwu4995 Před 5 lety +8975

    Moral lesson of the video: Don't take a nap at the hospital

    • @muchdeadsheep8038
      @muchdeadsheep8038 Před 5 lety +170

      Exactly I'm never trusting doctors again

    • @uhuh5963
      @uhuh5963 Před 5 lety +26

      Ded

    • @mylucidadventures6540
      @mylucidadventures6540 Před 5 lety +63

      I mean ask the 5 and see if any of them are willing to donate they all have different problems so Likly one of them will say to themself I'm gonna die anyway least I can do is save these 4 people. That's what I would do in that situation

    • @lorekeeper685
      @lorekeeper685 Před 5 lety +25

      Doctors are not allowed to do that tbh

    • @mylucidadventures6540
      @mylucidadventures6540 Před 5 lety +12

      @@lorekeeper685 ya but this is if you could get away with Anthony

  • @fridasophiaaaa
    @fridasophiaaaa Před 3 lety +2582

    If you just need a simple push, then he's not that fat
    KILLED ME

    • @barbara174
      @barbara174 Před 2 lety +17

      love your profile picture lmao

    • @fridasophiaaaa
      @fridasophiaaaa Před 2 lety +9

      @@barbara174 LMAOOOO i love yours

    • @barbara174
      @barbara174 Před 2 lety +9

      @@fridasophiaaaa pls i love finding stays in random videos lmaooo

    • @fridasophiaaaa
      @fridasophiaaaa Před 2 lety +5

      @@barbara174 I knaurrr, it feels like we're a big fandom now lmao

    • @barbara174
      @barbara174 Před 2 lety +5

      @@fridasophiaaaa exactly LOLL

  • @KingSaysHello
    @KingSaysHello Před 2 lety +820

    So, in my psychology class, we’re learning about how humans develop ethics and morals. Let me just say I quite literally jumped out of my seat when I saw we were watching a DanPlan video as one of the videos for class.

  • @dom-xt9pt
    @dom-xt9pt Před 5 lety +5309

    **reads title**
    **chuckles a bit**
    “No.”

  • @yoonseomg9693
    @yoonseomg9693 Před 5 lety +2714

    "then i wouldn't stop at this murder, i'd keep going!" Stephen- 2017

    • @sianeds
      @sianeds Před 4 lety +10

      YoonseOmg *2020* Edit: I got 5 likes thank you so much its the most i’ve ever got on anything!

    • @cheesethehoonter2955
      @cheesethehoonter2955 Před 4 lety +1

      Sian Billington no *9999*

    • @imjustdonehaha.1813
      @imjustdonehaha.1813 Před 4 lety

      YoonseOmg i agree

    • @leafu8154
      @leafu8154 Před 4 lety

      Same.

    • @sianeds
      @sianeds Před 4 lety

      Ender King303 no it’s *1136343416643437275445765657474783878911177*

  • @ACECLAN9000
    @ACECLAN9000 Před 3 lety +138

    “If I am to chose between one evil and another, then I prefer not to choose at all”

    • @ACECLAN9000
      @ACECLAN9000 Před 3 lety +2

      Chris Qiu shhhhhh🤫

    • @icewolfwolfie173
      @icewolfwolfie173 Před 2 lety +3

      @Chris Qiu that's what he wants.. See as many die

    • @righthandstep5
      @righthandstep5 Před 9 měsíci +1

      ​@@icewolfwolfie173morality doesn't need your permission to justify it.

  • @robert8192
    @robert8192 Před 2 lety +166

    I was laughing so hard at 4:21 "You can get away with everything." and the responce was "Well, I wouldnt stop with just one murder.. I would keep going.." That had me rolling in hysterics...

    • @eudoravia7082
      @eudoravia7082 Před 10 dny

      He instantly became my fave guy 😂 he’s so real 🤣

  • @arztschwanzfurz1631
    @arztschwanzfurz1631 Před 3 lety +5846

    Imagine killing the check-up guy and none of his organs are a match

  • @crispybanana2328
    @crispybanana2328 Před 4 lety +3527

    "By the way, are you a good person?"
    Why's Hosuh here? Of course he is

  • @tartaglia.
    @tartaglia. Před 2 lety +38

    Armin Arlert once said:
    “I don't like the terms "good person" or "bad person" because it is impossible to be entirely good to everyone. To some, you are a good person, while to others, you are a bad person.”
    So therefore, we are all neither good nor bad people.

    • @kovici7226
      @kovici7226 Před 2 lety +1

      You’re not as bad as your worst decisions.

    • @citriccat142
      @citriccat142 Před 2 lety +1

      its all abt perspective. There is no true good or evil, its just the way you see things vs others see things. At least thats what I think

    • @kovici7226
      @kovici7226 Před 2 lety

      @@citriccat142 everyone has a different moral compass 👍

    • @sitrinist2842
      @sitrinist2842 Před rokem +2

      thats a stupid thing to say. just because some people view you as bad or good doesn't mean you are bad or good because of their perspective of you. you are bad or good based on your actions

  • @aldenstromberg7273
    @aldenstromberg7273 Před rokem +36

    I think that the biggest difference in the situations is that there is always an objectively better choice to save the 5 people over the 1, but in the doctor and fat guy situations, you would be making someone else's decision. If it is set in stone that you must make the decision, you can relatively guiltlessly sacrifice the one, but if the one still has agency, it feels wrong to choose for them.

    • @BioTheHuman
      @BioTheHuman Před 9 měsíci

      How can ethics be objective?
      Objective on which basis?
      Also, when you turn to kill the one person and save the other 5 you're doing the same thing as when you would push the fat guy or harvesting the organs, how can you not see it?
      what's different? Only because there is a machine between you and the victim? The point is that you're the one controlling the machine.

    • @Orphim
      @Orphim Před 7 měsíci +3

      There's the logical answer I was looking for. The difference on a lot of these is the agency of the decision. If either of your choices means someone dies but only you can make that decision, it's easy to sacrifice the one for the many. However, if you choose to make someone make the sacrifice when they should have the option to make it themselves, it's no longer an unavoidable action on your part. They had the agency to make their own decision. The fat guy could choose to sacrifice himself to stop the trolley. The healthy patient could be informed and choose to give up their organs. You don't have the right to make that choice for them. With the trolley though and you having to choose to switch the rails, only you can make the choice and someone dies either way, so the correct decision morally would be the one for the many, because you had the agency to make a move and save more lives.

    • @bahnankhayre9534
      @bahnankhayre9534 Před 6 měsíci

      But aren’t you just doing the same thing aren’t you taking the agency from the one person and basically forcing them to sacrifice themselves for the 5 people

    • @Orphim
      @Orphim Před 6 měsíci

      @@bahnankhayre9534 That's something of a fair argument, but they are not even in the position to make the choice at that moment. It's really more of an explanation of the situation and why one is more easily seen as morally bad and the other is not seen that way so easily to most people.

  • @francies6175
    @francies6175 Před 4 lety +4655

    The real question how is the one without a heart alive

    • @keks1491
      @keks1491 Před 4 lety +202

      Maybe his heart is just almost "dead"

    • @adamteashaw9441
      @adamteashaw9441 Před 4 lety +108

      The true answer is that the one who needs the heart is dead, and you can transplant their organs

    • @ake9454
      @ake9454 Před 4 lety +78

      The one without the heart needs a transplant to get a different one, he still has a heart but he needs a better one to stay alive

    • @PhoenixMilk
      @PhoenixMilk Před 4 lety +25

      Yeah and the one without a kidney can survive u only need one kidney to survive XD oof

    • @adamteashaw9441
      @adamteashaw9441 Před 4 lety +15

      @@PhoenixMilk you could have one kidney destroyed and one damaged enough to be failing, so he could have actually needed a kidney

  • @mb-pp8yz
    @mb-pp8yz Před 3 lety +9166

    Moral of the story: don't be fat because everyone will want to sacrifice you

    • @helpmeimakitkat
      @helpmeimakitkat Před 3 lety +332

      Well I'm gonna die.
      Edit: I left for three months, what the heck?

    • @CobiExter
      @CobiExter Před 3 lety +54

      same

    • @acutedog162
      @acutedog162 Před 3 lety +174

      I would kill the five people people on the track. They can learn not to be on a train track, in heaven.

    • @lilcinnamonroll9577
      @lilcinnamonroll9577 Před 3 lety +92

      @@acutedog162 yo thats what i was kinda thinking like why are you on the tracks why don't you see a trolley is about to hit you. Like don't be stupid and you'll stay safe... but whatever

    • @puffy2930
      @puffy2930 Před 3 lety +9

      Me that actually is but doesn't eat a lot now for so reason and only ate a little bit of food today: *So anyway-*

  • @Phoenixishh
    @Phoenixishh Před 2 lety +6

    0:03 that sounds like the beginning of the supernatural outro

  • @cryfier
    @cryfier Před 9 měsíci +12

    You really see how his friends try to avoid these difficult questions by humor

  • @bluejaysilverscythe7776
    @bluejaysilverscythe7776 Před 5 lety +5198

    Everyone came here with the knowledge that Stephen was probably not a good person.

    • @SkintelNKeychain
      @SkintelNKeychain Před 5 lety +157

      I like to think he kills with purpose, if he killed at all
      You know, killing bullies, KKK members, whatever else. An antihero like Deadpool, kinda
      Sorry if it makes no sense :D English is not my first language

    • @fuzzeh5001
      @fuzzeh5001 Před 5 lety +151

      @@SkintelNKeychain I think it's very clear Stephen is a good person in general. It's just his internet persona is an aggressive and rabid psychopathic killing machine 😂 and the Stephen he is in the videos also would kill people for no real reason

    • @SkintelNKeychain
      @SkintelNKeychain Před 5 lety +27

      @@fuzzeh5001 oh, no worries; i understand that's stephens persona, but i mean just in his own portrayal, haha

    • @thatoneravenclaw417
      @thatoneravenclaw417 Před 5 lety +2

      @@fuzzeh5001 oml... Fuzzeh!

    • @evermoreonline3537
      @evermoreonline3537 Před 5 lety +9

      It’s basic knowledge, like call 911 for emergencies, which way is left and right, and Stephen isn’t a good person.

  • @bleuming7199
    @bleuming7199 Před 5 lety +1755

    "This is Canada.. WHERE ARE ALL THE OTHER DOCTORS?!"

  • @jonl7855
    @jonl7855 Před 10 měsíci +6

    I had a class in university in Japan during study abroad, and it was literally reading and talking over these exact situations, and talking through it in groups and in front of the class, then the professor would discuss the author's philosophy and the 'answers' to these questions.
    Brought back memories. Thanks for the vid.
    Funny enough this video actually came out before I even went to the class, so in an alternate reality I could have seen this first, and went into the class already enlightened.

  • @dayanafidalgo8953
    @dayanafidalgo8953 Před 2 lety +6

    I'm shocked by how smart you guys are. Really! Deep thoughts... I really loved it. Brilliant minds!

  • @andrew-paulclements1502
    @andrew-paulclements1502 Před 6 lety +2081

    The correct answer is tokyo drift the trolly to kill all 6

    • @Furo6448
      @Furo6448 Před 6 lety +150

      Andrew Clements this man gets it

    • @TravisBone14
      @TravisBone14 Před 6 lety +22

      Just move the one guy over

    • @natesal5037
      @natesal5037 Před 6 lety +63

      Andrew Clements go for that Sextupile kill streak

    • @andrew-paulclements1502
      @andrew-paulclements1502 Před 6 lety +37

      Deja Vu!

    • @elainad6728
      @elainad6728 Před 6 lety +11

      Andrew Clements
      Or you could yell at them to get out of the way if you have time.

  • @howltertrash6143
    @howltertrash6143 Před 5 lety +2008

    1:12 if it is KKK, I would keep going STRAIGHT

  • @koharumi1
    @koharumi1 Před 10 měsíci +1

    0:16 I would do multi-track drifting and do my best to get a strike.
    You know the quote "got to get them all"

  • @God_3712
    @God_3712 Před 2 lety +2

    In that situation I think if I was the bystander, I would honestly just try to scream at everyone to get out of the way. Like. That's all I can do. And panic and cry afterwards

  • @cffee3288
    @cffee3288 Před 5 lety +3319

    So
    The trolley cart situation at the start
    I have an answer
    *why the hell would there be workers on an active trolley cart rail*

    • @samgoode2274
      @samgoode2274 Před 5 lety +221

      Blueberry Cheesecake
      I have an answer: I would not switch the track and would drive right over the five ppl, killing all 5 of them. Then I would stop the train after some distance and run back to the 5 guys. Hopefully the 1 guy from the other track would have come over to try and help the 5 ppl, and as I approach him, I look as if I’m scared and crying. Then when I’m close enough, I’ll stab and kill him. Then I’ll repetitively stab all 6 of them over and over as they cry out in pain begging me for mercy. Then I’ll finish all of them off, so they can’t come for revenge. This is assuming I could get away with everything.

    • @whatintheactualkentuckyfri6603
      @whatintheactualkentuckyfri6603 Před 5 lety +70

      @@samgoode2274 edgy but I totally agree with you

    • @superiorbeing8805
      @superiorbeing8805 Před 5 lety +67

      @@samgoode2274 Do you need help??

    • @constellious
      @constellious Před 5 lety +15

      @@superiorbeing8805
      It was a joke

    • @shadybean3875
      @shadybean3875 Před 5 lety +32

      Cøffee Cup u dumped morals down the drain

  • @blackbeast9920
    @blackbeast9920 Před 4 lety +4399

    Stephen: 1 persons life is less valuable then 5 persons lives
    Also stephen: how dare you value that 5 lives over 1 life

    • @chriscunningham8807
      @chriscunningham8807 Před 4 lety +44

      We don't knowmwjerher the healthy guy's organs will be accepted by the people, needing a donor. To kill one person andmchqnce six deaths seems too risky. Kill one of the people needing an organ donor and give their organs to the other four people would be the most ethical and viable decision. The healthiest person or the sickest person in the group is now the big dilemma?

    • @Dr.Clover
      @Dr.Clover Před 4 lety +5

      True

    • @CuzDino
      @CuzDino Před 4 lety +14

      For the train one/ride I'd flip the the thing on the side and hit all 6 at the same time... I'm just kidding, dont kill me FBI

    • @hylachusphobiae
      @hylachusphobiae Před 4 lety +1

      spelling please

    • @kai3522
      @kai3522 Před 4 lety +1

      ikr

  • @hello-oh5bk
    @hello-oh5bk Před 3 lety +12

    On the first one I'd pick to go for the 5, reason being that if its 5 people they'll probably all try to run away, if the 5 see the 1 they might try to help him possibly killing them aswell

    • @nicolruiz8810
      @nicolruiz8810 Před 3 lety +2

      what if no ones paying attention though or like the question said they're construction workers and possibly have really loud machines on

  • @wtf8178
    @wtf8178 Před 9 měsíci +1

    "No matter how good of a person you are, you are the villain in atleast someones life. So get yourself together and atleast be a good villain"

  • @moonkurai8188
    @moonkurai8188 Před 4 lety +755

    Moral of the story:
    Am I a good person?
    Well yes,but actually no

  • @The_Knife_Pie
    @The_Knife_Pie Před 7 lety +1791

    Dan- lets say you can get away with everything.
    Stephen- Well then i wouldn't stop with that murder.
    Stephen is a closet pyscho

    • @aldric2252
      @aldric2252 Před 7 lety +93

      The_ Knife_Pie "new video - are you a psychopath?"

    • @nobody-rw9cc
      @nobody-rw9cc Před 6 lety +56

      He is just socially conscious; if you can get away with anything... you would find a sick fantasy to live out as well. its the beast nature; if there is no consequence to you then there is no need for moral action.
      fallout for instance
      You can kill everyone and steal everything its just a game there's no real consequences. To not do a single bad thing in that game is a lot harder then being as evil as can be.

    • @jeremossy9768
      @jeremossy9768 Před 6 lety

      The_ Knife_Pie yeah me too XD

    • @Labanmad
      @Labanmad Před 6 lety

      The_ Knife_Pie Gadget

    • @dabossman5650
      @dabossman5650 Před 6 lety +1

      The_ Knife_Pie he is in all of them lol

  • @justacameraman4900
    @justacameraman4900 Před 3 lety +1

    Heres how im currently thinking of it. What ways more on your soul? the act of saving lives, or the act of taking lives. in one your not saving nor are you killing, in the other you are saving and killing.

  • @bde7864
    @bde7864 Před 2 lety

    Its a good series of lectures.
    Everyone should watch it.

  • @aurianemalvesin9524
    @aurianemalvesin9524 Před 5 lety +906

    4:23 "Lawsuit"! The only thing between Stephen and mass murder XD

  • @user-Mahhabat
    @user-Mahhabat Před 5 lety +1390

    Next question: 6 patients come in your way that we’re hit by a trolley
    Hmm what a coincidence

    • @headintheclouds01
      @headintheclouds01 Před 5 lety +9

      Ikr

    • @renithink7900
      @renithink7900 Před 4 lety +5

      0.0bWow I never thought of that XD

    • @PxndaCakes
      @PxndaCakes Před 4 lety +46

      I guess that fat guy didn't stop the trolley...

    • @ShiningDarknes
      @ShiningDarknes Před 4 lety +21

      @@PxndaCakes That was my reaction. Especially with the one being critically injured. Guess he didn't stop the trolley AND he didn't die AND the 5 guys didn't die so...the previous situation worked out way better than I could have hoped...granted they only _technically_ "survived" only to be left in a state where they still might die but hey, guess we are getting asked these questions by the devil, hear that guy loves technicalities.

    • @wingardiumlachancla9078
      @wingardiumlachancla9078 Před 4 lety +4

      I immediately thought of it, I laughed so hard xDD

  • @adamxue6096
    @adamxue6096 Před 3 lety +1

    I remember that saving whom has a color scale, I'd recon that the 5 in question are of red-yellow and the 1 is in red - black. This does help professionally to determine what to do tho that is less in regard to my moral stand point.

  • @pineappledude8814
    @pineappledude8814 Před rokem

    0:53 id aim for that center between both options derailing the trolley crashing into a building

  • @ellapaet7655
    @ellapaet7655 Před 4 lety +945

    But the real question is... why? Are they idiots? Why are they working on a active trolley rail?

    • @masterduck1676
      @masterduck1676 Před 4 lety +23

      As I said before, Daniel makes up unrealistic events because he enjoys messing with people's minds

    • @blakeevin9936
      @blakeevin9936 Před 4 lety +56

      This wasn't made by Daniel it was a professor

    • @sharifbrown3567
      @sharifbrown3567 Před 4 lety +27

      @@masterduck1676 if you don't know about the trolly problem you're too young for CZcams.

    • @masterduck1676
      @masterduck1676 Před 4 lety +2

      @@blakeevin9936 so . . . ? Daniel chose to put it in the video

    • @masterduck1676
      @masterduck1676 Před 4 lety +1

      @@sharifbrown3567 Who said I didn't know about it?

  • @paperbagcomedychannel7492
    @paperbagcomedychannel7492 Před 4 lety +1108

    Hosuh: this is Canada, where are the other doctors
    Me: *Social distancing is more important*

  • @ize1004
    @ize1004 Před 3 lety

    why was the reccommended to me again... after a year of not seeing this damn channel... i missed this so much

  • @Roald94
    @Roald94 Před 2 lety +1

    i think the difference between the questions is that, in one of them u have 6 persons involved in the situation, in the other one, theres the five involved and 1 that isnt, so in a way, its worst adding the non-involved person, versus the one where he is already in it

  • @Andionschannel
    @Andionschannel Před 7 lety +2584

    I love this contrast of funny chatting and serious and intelligent brainstorming in your videos. Paired with the cartoon style it makes them so entertaining!

  • @fluffystuff500
    @fluffystuff500 Před 5 lety +1123

    Wait, if I have time to turn, don't the workers have time to move?

    • @rscenicc29
      @rscenicc29 Před 5 lety +7

      no.no they wont

    • @Jun-cz9cv
      @Jun-cz9cv Před 5 lety +115

      They must be stupid to not hear a loud freaking train running their way.

    • @rscenicc29
      @rscenicc29 Před 5 lety +2

      But.....they dont know where its gonna go

    • @pancake7117
      @pancake7117 Před 5 lety +73

      @Klint AC I don't care, if a trolley is coming my way, I'm getting off the track regardless of whether or not it turns

    • @paloma2674
      @paloma2674 Před 5 lety +26

      No, because in the original situation, the workers are all wearing earmuffs and can't hear the trolley coming.

  • @ML-jd5hz
    @ML-jd5hz Před rokem

    Dayuunng it's been so long! And I'm getting recos of thes channel again! Like long time no see!

  • @TiredShyCreator
    @TiredShyCreator Před 2 lety +2

    "who are you and what did you do to Stephen." That's exactly what I was thinking

  • @rvqqxl1626
    @rvqqxl1626 Před 4 lety +1111

    “This is Canada..! wHerE aRe thE othErs dOctOrS!?”
    *lmao* 😂

  • @janreiafrica
    @janreiafrica Před 6 lety +279

    4:26 "Well then I won't stop at this murder, I'll keep going"
    Wise words from a Psychopath

  • @Gojxd
    @Gojxd Před 2 lety +2

    "imagine you could get away with anything"
    stephen: then i wouldn't stop there, i would keep going

  • @march.royalharness4848
    @march.royalharness4848 Před 5 měsíci

    Stephans answer at 0:23 is so facts I try to answer it that way every time.

  • @Speirylcodm
    @Speirylcodm Před 5 lety +16037

    by the way can you survive stephen?

  • @catssassin137
    @catssassin137 Před 5 lety +2338

    *1:00* i would kill the 5. If i kill the 1, i wont get xp and and no combos 😂

  • @snowys7667
    @snowys7667 Před 2 lety

    MISS HIM
    so much

  • @zerofragment3417
    @zerofragment3417 Před rokem +1

    Just because situations exist that may be more difficult to distinguish as right or wrong does not mean that there's no such thing as right or wrong.
    You already know this.
    The only way to not know this is to unlearn what is intrinsic.

  • @oshahott2532
    @oshahott2532 Před 5 lety +758

    "Let's be serious, here."
    _Organ Bucket_

  • @ioo5522
    @ioo5522 Před 5 lety +255

    “Are you a good person?”
    - No.
    Edit: uh..the f#ck?..likes? What?
    °-°
    YES! FINALLY
    :’)

    • @farhiyaabdi1378
      @farhiyaabdi1378 Před 5 lety +2

      Im a good person
      Or im i 😈😈😈😈😈

    • @yoyoyoyoidk8849
      @yoyoyoyoidk8849 Před 5 lety +1

      No I am not sorry but I already started killing 🤔😄

    • @evelynem209
      @evelynem209 Před 5 lety +2

      I’m more like a wolf in sheep’s clothing lol

  • @mrnoahj1830
    @mrnoahj1830 Před 9 měsíci +1

    Remembering that they all fell apart just makes me emo

  • @adonisparts1343
    @adonisparts1343 Před 2 lety +2

    The reason I think in the second and fourth scenarios people have more doubt in killing the one guy is because they are directly causing their deaths, in the first and third scenarios someone's going to die either way so you may as well pick the one that causes the least deaths but in the other scenarios the five people are going to die and you are directly choosing to save them by involving someone who wasn't going to die.

  • @RegaIia
    @RegaIia Před 6 lety +4855

    "Then I wouldn't stop there and kill more."

    • @SwaggerJoyce
      @SwaggerJoyce Před 6 lety +206

      *shows Yuno pictures*

    • @Cookie-tw9by
      @Cookie-tw9by Před 6 lety +95

      I find it funny that he says murder rather than something else

    • @gse547
      @gse547 Před 6 lety +16

      this is the same way the terrorist think of us when we go to their country and kill their love ones.

    • @lightryuzaki3974
      @lightryuzaki3974 Před 6 lety +6

      Me too..bcoz its hypothetical questions.

    • @jeweluzumaki3233
      @jeweluzumaki3233 Před 6 lety +3

      Lovey Dub 😂😂 I burst out laughing when I heard that

  • @flysmite1507
    @flysmite1507 Před 6 lety +1595

    "Are you a good person?"
    me: "I eat cereal with a fork"
    everyone: "Are you Satan?"

    • @milanvissers40
      @milanvissers40 Před 5 lety +79

      Flysmite how the fuck do you eat cereal with a fork

    • @KingOpenReview
      @KingOpenReview Před 5 lety +62

      That comment is emotional abuse.

    • @Jinx-iw6zb
      @Jinx-iw6zb Před 5 lety +45

      I eat cereal with bare hands

    • @potatocat8589
      @potatocat8589 Před 5 lety +16

      Flysmite same then I drink the milk with a spoon

    • @stevendunn8897
      @stevendunn8897 Před 5 lety +12

      I eat cereal with a fork as well, dry cereal with a glass of milk.

  • @sunset7689
    @sunset7689 Před 2 lety +8

    i feel like so many answers will change once the people involved are people we love like our family and friends.

  • @brownie_21
    @brownie_21 Před 3 lety

    I just a recent video of yours, wow well done I see so much improvement!!!

  • @dazaiosamu8103
    @dazaiosamu8103 Před 4 lety +2354

    Hi, just rewatching my memories before danplan isn’t the same ever again

  • @kakashihatake6176
    @kakashihatake6176 Před 5 lety +1495

    Casually taking a dude organs during a check-up

    • @no-vw9ib
      @no-vw9ib Před 5 lety +13

      @Braedon Collins shut up

    • @KTam853
      @KTam853 Před 5 lety +4

      Monica Granger it’s just a simple correction

    • @KTam853
      @KTam853 Před 5 lety +3

      Well he was asleep so idk he may wake up

    • @thegoon9876
      @thegoon9876 Před 5 lety +2

      oops

    • @WiseTree547
      @WiseTree547 Před 5 lety +4

      I know right

  • @princess-dl1gi
    @princess-dl1gi Před 2 lety

    The first that that came to my head is to push the 5 people out of the way of the trolly or tell them to look out

  • @jeshuamejia6626
    @jeshuamejia6626 Před 2 lety

    i miss these..

  • @daydreamstudios1606
    @daydreamstudios1606 Před 6 lety +667

    "This is Canada, where are all the other doctors?"

    • @xaviergalloway7025
      @xaviergalloway7025 Před 5 lety +37

      They are drinking maple syrup at Waffle House.

    • @cloudieo
      @cloudieo Před 5 lety +4

      @@xaviergalloway7025 Lmao

    • @blazewolf5495
      @blazewolf5495 Před 5 lety +2

      Lol

    • @senkusupremacy3828
      @senkusupremacy3828 Před 5 lety +7

      They are busy with all the others using the free health care to their advantage. Its the sad canadian truth

    • @brianmcm1398
      @brianmcm1398 Před 5 lety +5

      The question is answered in the first 3 words

  • @rys2147
    @rys2147 Před 5 lety +246

    "either turn right and kill 1 or stay straight and kill 5"
    Animator draws the turn as left
    0:50

    • @stock7416
      @stock7416 Před 4 lety +6

      Housa why 😂😂😂

    • @sephtis3658
      @sephtis3658 Před 4 lety +6

      @@stock7416 ITS HOSUH.

    • @imvic99yearsago62
      @imvic99yearsago62 Před 4 lety

      Kill 5 because the 1 person is working alone and if i will the first one of the 5 then the others will run

    • @imvic99yearsago62
      @imvic99yearsago62 Před 4 lety

      @Pure_Steve _1153 let the other four die because they weren't helping the human on the right! (๑و•̀ω•́)

    • @sephtis3658
      @sephtis3658 Před 4 lety

      @が 大好きビクトリア 和 アニメ *kill them all*

  • @jinx2100
    @jinx2100 Před 2 lety +1

    There is actually sort of a term for what happened in the first dilemma. The bystander effect, there was this big study into it after an incident in New York, where many people in an apartment block witnessed a woman get murdered. The killer left for a while before returning to finish the job. No one did anything to stop it because of the bystander effect. Because there were other people, there was an assumption that someone else was doing something about it. So no one intervened.

  • @immr6884
    @immr6884 Před rokem

    Love your old videos 👀

  • @sydneynahoo6887
    @sydneynahoo6887 Před 4 lety +197

    *"Well then I wouldnt stop at this murder I'd keep going"*

    • @limonkowyludz1328
      @limonkowyludz1328 Před 3 lety +6

      I know it might sound weird but if you do something this crazy (murder) then why don’t you just kill some more? You’re going to jail and ruining your life anyway so why not?

    • @Vary180
      @Vary180 Před 3 lety

      i laughed so hard at that

    • @len4129
      @len4129 Před 3 lety +1

      @@limonkowyludz1328 because if you do you'll most likely have a longer sentence in jail.

  • @ramenstuffyt6783
    @ramenstuffyt6783 Před 4 lety +585

    Why is there a guy for a checkup in an organ donors office?

    • @shl3bl3_25
      @shl3bl3_25 Před 3 lety +19

      Thay said hes in the next room

    • @rantingsfromateenagerspers499
      @rantingsfromateenagerspers499 Před 3 lety +18

      @@shl3bl3_25 That would be in the organ donor wings than. He still shouldn't be there

    • @flames4856
      @flames4856 Před 3 lety +4

      Where were all the other doctors tho? Thats what I‘m thinking...

    • @Meiaiscool
      @Meiaiscool Před 3 lety +4

      Maybe he had a surgery with this and he came up for a checkup so they could see if everything is right after the surgery

  • @_.rahu1
    @_.rahu1 Před 3 lety

    Ironic how this was recommended to me after the drama although very late since then and the original upload date of this video

  • @AmberHasAGun
    @AmberHasAGun Před 2 lety +1

    In the er, sure they focus on the people who are more injured, but they have to care for the people more likely so survive.

  • @cold.raviolis
    @cold.raviolis Před 6 lety +411

    A teacher once asked us the first question the other way around.
    So you're driving towards the one person but plot twist: the one person is someone you know and like.

    • @smolson8471
      @smolson8471 Před 6 lety +51

      That's a good twist. It makes you think even more about your values.

    • @airez3765
      @airez3765 Před 6 lety +42

      Have her die and retrieve the body
      AHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHSHSHSHAHSHAHA #Necrophilia

    • @allyarendt4886
      @allyarendt4886 Před 6 lety +13

      My teacher said that the girl was your child lol

    • @you_gullible_fucc
      @you_gullible_fucc Před 6 lety +23

      I'm going with 5 people then. Call me selfish but every human has to be selfish at some point

    • @Kana_108_
      @Kana_108_ Před 6 lety +4

      I save the one i love rather than 5 guys i don't know.

  • @cookiesandcream626
    @cookiesandcream626 Před 4 lety +368

    “A-Ah!”
    Daniel - 2017
    “Speaking of cannibalism!”
    Hosuh - 2017
    “Lawsuits coming your way!”
    Stephen - 2017

  • @SpookyTim16
    @SpookyTim16 Před 2 lety +4

    My philosophy professor had a pretty good explination as to why the answers differ. In the first case, you don't have the intention to kill. For example in the trolley dilemma: if by some coincidence the one worker manages to jump away, we'd all be glad for that. While in the second case, we want the fat man to die if we push him.

  • @sylphsylph2118
    @sylphsylph2118 Před 8 měsíci +1

    to tip a trolley you put the thing to change lanes in the middle...itll derail and youll buckle on the side fast.... for your question

  • @lemondrop1969
    @lemondrop1969 Před 3 lety +705

    there is a reason why the answer changes. when you are contemplating taking a turn choosing to kill one person or going straight and killing 5, your choices are exactly that being personally responsible for 1 death or for 5. On the other hand, when you are pushing the fat guy onto the track you are choosing between being responsible for one death or zero. Yes, 5 people are going to die if you don't push the guy but those 5 deaths are not your responsibility and no one is gonna question you why you didn't push the guy to save the 5. At the end of the day, it is not an ethical dilemma, it is simply a question of what are you willing to be responsible for? There is also the fact that working on the tracks the 5 workmen have consented to the inherent risks associated with the work and the one being push did no such thing.

    • @Slitherr
      @Slitherr Před 2 lety +34

      @David Winehouse you're not responsible, because if you were to not change the tracks then you wouldn't have proactively done an action that killed someone but if you do change the tracks then you are proactively doing something that will kill someone. So, in my opinion it boils down to whether or not you believe that the ends justify the means, because if you do, then killing is is favored when it will save more lives, but if you don't, then killing is wrong regardless of how many lives it will save

    • @somebody579
      @somebody579 Před 2 lety +41

      Just scream to those 5 people to move.

    • @pooltable1339
      @pooltable1339 Před 2 lety +7

      Also with the organ transplant one, the options change. In the first question if you do nothing all 6 die so you have to choose the lesser of two evils, but in the second one if you do nothing only 5 will die and if you save them one will die. This makes it harder to answer because in both cases you have be directly responsible for murder.

    • @pazecs
      @pazecs Před 2 lety +3

      @@pooltable1339 In the first question if you do nothing not all 6 people die? Only the five that were on the tracks which the trolly was going towards.

    • @vukkulvar9769
      @vukkulvar9769 Před 2 lety +8

      The difference between the first and second problem : 1 situation you act on the cart, 1 situation you act on the person.

  • @thegentleman2419
    @thegentleman2419 Před 5 lety +225

    as the king of Wakanda put it
    "victory at the expense of the innocent is no victory at all"

  • @Riteshkrpanda
    @Riteshkrpanda Před 3 lety +1

    I concluded same what the person said at last there is no right or wrong .....right for one is certainly wrong for other so I would do anything my moral would allow me to do or my sub concious mind in some situations cause sometimes he knows better

  • @dangelspatch6051
    @dangelspatch6051 Před 2 lety

    I did a project on Morality for school and I really didn’t wanna do it so I just wrote down a bunch of stuff from this video

  • @clownpiece6756
    @clownpiece6756 Před 3 lety +426

    I just remebered answer on last question:
    "I just transplanted one of a five patients and save four of them"

    • @imashadow699
      @imashadow699 Před 3 lety +42

      I'll Just Tell All Of Them To Seek Their Own Organs... My Job Is Transplant, not "Organs Seeker" 😅

    • @Subpar1224
      @Subpar1224 Před 3 lety +2

      Which one do you let die then?

    • @humanguy1643
      @humanguy1643 Před 3 lety +2

      For the guy needing a kidney and lung, you could get those without even killing someone, but you’d need to seal off the lungs and kidney of the other guys to save them.

    • @nvmffs
      @nvmffs Před 3 lety +6

      @@rafaelclp That's still you, not god. Just because you don't know how to throw it to get a certain result, doesn't mean it's god's doing. Make it something that doesn't include you.

    • @user-rj8yi5dd2u
      @user-rj8yi5dd2u Před 3 lety +4

      @@Subpar1224 Probably the one who needs a heart transplant

  • @topcomment8170
    @topcomment8170 Před 5 lety +673

    Him: Life is never black and white
    Me: Exactly it's rainbow..
    UNLIKE THE BLOOD IN THIS VIDEO

  • @ducktes
    @ducktes Před 2 lety +3

    1:30
    This one is easy just scream really loud to the workers, trolleys aren’t that fast

  • @unihorn458
    @unihorn458 Před 2 lety +2

    There are more differences, but one that i noticed is that the one person yoi sacrifice is needed in one scenario, but not in the other one.
    On the changing tracks problem, even if that one worker wasn't there, you would still be able to change tracks and save the 5 workers, same when treating the 5 people. On the hand, when it comes to the fat guy and the one for check-up, if they weren't there, you wouldn't be able to save the other 5 people.

  • @asamiastra6292
    @asamiastra6292 Před 5 lety +85

    Stephen: I’m a philosophical thinker
    Hosuh: who are you and what did you do to Stephen

  • @beanie.s1844
    @beanie.s1844 Před 5 lety +582

    1. Kill 1
    2. Scream “run”
    3. Save the 5
    4. Do nothing
    I’m fringing insane

  • @jayarajnr965
    @jayarajnr965 Před 3 lety +1

    Everybody: Confused
    Geralt : I would rather not choose at all

  • @NoNameOrLife
    @NoNameOrLife Před 8 měsíci +1

    its quite simple the change between first and second question in the first one you are directly involved and will guarentee a loss but in the second you could just ignore it and it wouldnt affect you in also people must remember in situations humans have been shown to quite frankly ignore much worse crimes i can completely absolve myself of any part in the 2nd question

  • @justplainweird2727
    @justplainweird2727 Před 4 lety +193

    When rewatching danplan videos like this one is just hard to believe that all this time you thought housuh Stephen and Daniel were such good friends but now Stephen is leaving because for so long he felt under appreciated

    • @isabellejoestar2455
      @isabellejoestar2455 Před 4 lety +10

      Stephen began wanting to leave Danplan around the beginnings of 2019.
      This was 3 years ago.

    • @hassanaiham2333
      @hassanaiham2333 Před 4 lety +5

      Stop commenting I know it's sad but it not nice talking about it in danplan's channel

    • @whatdoyouwant4548
      @whatdoyouwant4548 Před 3 lety +7

      @@hassanaiham2333 but the thing is that's what this channel was mainly built up on, its what people remember the channel to be about, so of course people are going to talk about it where they feel it belongs - on their old videos.

  • @sleyaraze8916
    @sleyaraze8916 Před 3 lety +2102

    "so you'd sacrifice yourself to save others?"
    *Me, who just wanted to die* 👌

  • @lucasthegreatandpowerful4810

    3:37 doctor mike is everywhere and by everywhere i mean *everywhere*

  • @Trillionaire_Steps26
    @Trillionaire_Steps26 Před 3 měsíci +2

    1:02 nah i'd turn💀💀💀

  • @blackbirdredwing8182
    @blackbirdredwing8182 Před 5 lety +221

    5:17 Shaggy is getting heated with a pitchfork on the left there.

  • @aidarich3712
    @aidarich3712 Před 5 lety +525

    For the Frist one,
    *JUST WARN THE WORKERS*

    • @aceofparts938
      @aceofparts938 Před 5 lety +16

      Cant your going very fast in highly protected trolly. You think your gonna pop your head out and yell about a Trolly that the people can CLEARLY see....

    • @aidarich3712
      @aidarich3712 Před 5 lety +1

      @@aceofparts938 true

    • @aidarich3712
      @aidarich3712 Před 5 lety +1

      @@aceofparts938 but it didn't really say it was protected

    • @aceofparts938
      @aceofparts938 Před 5 lety +1

      It's a trolly.

    • @aidarich3712
      @aidarich3712 Před 5 lety +1

      @@aceofparts938 ok, you have a point

  • @lilyella6754
    @lilyella6754 Před 2 lety

    I LOVE THESE GUYS

  • @HR-pl7yy
    @HR-pl7yy Před 3 lety +6

    Well,then I wouldn’t stop at this murder,I’ll keep going…

  • @high.on.methanol
    @high.on.methanol Před 3 lety +462

    "The bigger question is how to kill all 6 of them" The Good Place: Micheal (A demon)

    • @bade7
      @bade7 Před 3 lety +10

      AYYY THE GOOD PLACE! GOAT

    • @renadaniels3843
      @renadaniels3843 Před 3 lety +9

      Finally, I was waiting for this one😂😂😂💀💀💀

    • @roximoldovan1
      @roximoldovan1 Před 3 lety +6

      all 7 of them actually if you count yourself

    • @isaultra3405
      @isaultra3405 Před 3 lety

      Explain the reference, source ???

    • @nola9957
      @nola9957 Před 3 lety +6

      @@isaultra3405 tv show called the good place

  • @HellishSpoon
    @HellishSpoon Před 6 lety +5212

    3:50
    Simple
    Just take the organs from one of those 5 guys
    You can save 4 people
    And the other one would have died any way.
    Bam

  • @Jazzy--
    @Jazzy-- Před 3 lety

    0:20 *Multitrack Drifting!*

  • @annabukataya2172
    @annabukataya2172 Před 2 lety +1

    Only thing that makes these questions hard is that they are hypothetic( You may have ideal but you'll never know how you'll act in the real situation). Moreover it's easy to find logical mistakes in most of these questions.