Doctor Who Refuses to Acknowledge Gender Choice Challenged by Trans Woman | This Morning
Vložit
- čas přidán 16. 07. 2018
- Subscribe now for more! bit.ly/1JM41yF
Dr David Mackereth was fired from his job of being a doctor after 30 years for refusing to acknowledge people’s preferred gender. David says his right to say what he believes is under attack, but transgender model Munroe Bergdorf thinks David needs to accept that society has changed.
Broadcast on 17/07/2018
Like, follow and subscribe to This Morning!
Website: bit.ly/1MsreVq
CZcams: bit.ly/1BxNiLl
Facebook: on. 1FbXnjU
Twitter: bit.ly/1Bs1eI1
This Morning - every weekday on ITV from 10:30am.
Join Holly Willoughby and Phillip Schofield, Ruth Langsford and Eamonn Holmes as we meet the people behind the stories that matter, chat to the hottest celebs and cook up a storm with your favourite chefs!
Dr Zoe and Dr Ranj answer all your health questions, stay stylish with Gok Wan's fabulous fashion, be beautiful with Bryony Blake's top make-up tips, and save money with Martin Lewis.
www.itv.com
www.stv.tv - Zábava
"You can have your own beliefs but don't impose them on other people." The irony.
I was thinking the same thing... always playing victim
Clown
Yes ,…What about the EX-lgbtq community and their Rights Tolerance Parade Flag Support etc ? How come they always non or under reported Ah it’s not in your agenda nice 👍🏼 NOT!
I was thinking the same
The gender we are when we are born thats the gender we are when we die...
We seriously need more doctors like this man!! It's disgusting that this doctor has lost his job!!!
I would like to know what are his views on gays
@@hauntyoo his said his a Christian so probably the obvious, but who really cares.. live and let live.
@@lukeluke429 live and let live, until they get YOUR children.
@@halometroid yeah spot on.. untill is correct because live and let live is a 2 way path, the very second anyone attacks you and/or especially the kids then they have waived their rights and you have the full right to defend yourself and your or anyone's kids appropriately. Live and let live is not a submission.. and it's not a right to harm. So live and let live too involves the protection of harm to all those around us!
Much love
@@halometroid live and let live until the LGBT get your children. I'm totally happy to let the Christians get my kids, at least they won't be traumatized for life and I'll probably have grandkids some day
This is so dumb, a doctor losses his job for stating what is medically correct. How ridiculous is that!!
What do you expect? We live in an idiocracy. 🙄
No he lost his job over imposing religious beliefs over being a medical practitioner, which is what he was. If you want to talk about ideology before medicine, that is exactly what he did…
Except it's not! Go back to school kid the adults are talking about stuff you have no clue about! 🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️
World is going mad
@@user-uh6yr4te2i Adults know that science say that gender can't be changed.
"Don't impose your beliefs on other people". That person in the dress should take their own advice.🤣🤣🤣
How is she imposing her beliefs on him? I do not understand this statement.
Man in the dress you mean
@@jramsey9690he’s forcing the Doctor to accept what he Factually knows is incorrect. He was fired because he didn’t go along with the silliness… that is forcing him to accept something that is not true.
@@johnwright6311 you think this is silly, I think this is dangerous. We are expected to go along with the fantasy of delusional people and to teach our children to lie.
You mean the man imposing his beliefs that we call him a woman that is imposing duh
Cant believe they fired the doctor over this ! What a joke of a world we live in .
Scary power of the socialist filled left party. They run the media and can get rid of anyone they need and or paint a bad picture of them
he deserved it
For real this world is losing its mind.
@@subduedvibes4159 he was disrespecting that other guy what do you expect?
@@lanroom2896 yeah, that other *guy*
Poor doctor, he dedicated his life to medicine ending up facing these bollocks 😢
It’s true what you said but the irony of how you said it 😂
Give this doctor a hero medal. We need more doctors like this man.
Hero for what? Basic facts?
Yes…that is medal-worthy in 2024
Hero because he stood up for truth and was prepared to lose his job because of it....time we all stood up for truth and stopped letting the Munroe's of this world browbeat us@@FenriZz
WOOOOOOWWW! She actually said “you can have your own belief but don’t impose that on other people.” The irony is mind bending….
I heard that and was like WOW 😮😮😮
He*
I had to rewind to listen again
He*
I don't see any irony. Just a hot stinking pile of hypocrisy.
One doctor not afraid to speak the truth. Hero!!!
and then the bastards sack him! no respect anymore, the man was not once being hurtful just speaking his opinion.
❤
Truth is relative based on your beliefs and experiences
They want to silence those who stand for what they believe because it goes against what they believe
@@Rilez616
there should be a petition to get him reinstated or at least give him compensation
Can't believe how the doctor is told over and over he can't impose his belief's. Yet he has the minorities belief imposed on him. The hypocrisy is disgusting. This is atrocious, even the presenter is telling him to join them and become a liar.
To those who fired that doctor for this shame on all of you
This Doctor is a legend. He's stuck solid. Well done mate!
It’s a fact men aren’t women
No he is not. He is racist
And he did it with respect!
@@shodan2002 And women aren’t men either 👍
Hei is indeed a legend. Society trumps science except when we need it to find a vaccine or cure for a disease. Then science is king 😢 SMH
We need more doctors like him.
❤
Please please please UK people. Get this man his job back. One day when that dude in yellow will need his prostate checked. I hope he goes and looks for a doctor specialized in UROLOGY
If you are born male you are male, if you are born female you are female no matter how many bits you chop off or implant I commend this doctor he should be re-hired and be apologized to and compensation for loss of income
Yes! Wish i cd find a doctor like him.
I admire that Doctor. I believe in biological science!! If I was having a serious operation, I would prefer to have an honest person like this doctor operating on me! God bless you sir!!
It’s funny how a actual doctor who has studied and practiced this for more then half his life with a she boy who has no medical background this is a absolute joke
The joke is that the doctor isn't using what he studied or any scientifical facts. He's solely using his religious beliefs and opinions. Gender dysphoria is extremely research and there's litteraly proof of its existence which speak volumes when he decides to believe in something that has 0 as his main argument
As a biologist, I can tell you it is mind numbing.
rigth?? just a fukeeeng joke. she-boy just being a clown in front of aundience
The presenters need to be sacked. Someone should start a petition to have them sacked.
That's a broken society for you. The he-she thinks he/she has the medical right. Shocking
Pray more doctors will take a stand like he did. So sad the world we live in. Praying for our children and moral doctors like this!
It's a scary world we're in. Very sad
Did she really just say "You an have your own beliefs, but don't impose that on other people"...as she tries to impose her beliefs on him...wow!!!!!!!!!!
*HE
@@simpleenglish1 *it.
Once you try to change your gender to me you're now an "it." You've lost he/she and now you're an "it." Pronouns are "it/that."
He did, these type of damaged men have had too much airtime. Time for the sane humans to stand up and put an end to this dangerous cult.
That's not a she it's a HE!!!!!!!
Not only that. She said he should lose his job because of his beliefs. The Bible says this would happen. People are approving of something as silly as gender swapping but you can lose you’re job if you are Christian. But if you are Jewish or Muslim then nobody can say anything to you
Well done to that doctor. A man that has stood by his beliefs.
The black man to the right of the doctor needs to be told he is wrong by his friends and family so he can begin to get better from his mental sickness.
It's almost like medicine is based on science and reality, not feelings.
😀
Feelings play an important part in medicine. That is why we have pointless procedures or procedures that prioritize the less pain possible.
Exactly, and people are scientifically born *MALE* or *FEMALE*. They dont just *FEEL* that they were born with the wrong gender.
@@RandalfElVikingothat type doesn't reduce facts
@@ronron5888 Of course not, but medicine is built in the fact to do the best for the patient.
Good doctors would tell you the thing they prioritizes the most are morals: they could tell you the best solution for you is to cut your leg, but if that is not what you want they would try their best to give another solution based on your feelings using facts and logic or try to convince you to cut your leg.
Like Dr. House said: "You rather have a doctor that ignores you while you get better or a doctor that takes your hand while you are dying?" That is the most pragmatic view of medicine and if a doctor loses a patient of course would drain his emotions too. They seem distant, but they also have feelings to be considered.
I'm with you doctor 100 percent
She says 'You can have your own beliefs, just don't impose them on other people."
But, it's okay for her though.
The doctor with dignity. We need more of him.
That dude in yellow dress is so disrespectfull
😂😂😂
😂😂😂
😂😂
His aggressive responses was not very lady like!
You are disrespectful for calling her a dude.
Well done,Doctor. My son is a medical doctor and his thoughts exactly. Kudos to you. That "woman" only wants her opinion to count.
@@mokoensn That's why I put it in inverted commas
I’m a medical student and I strongly believe this as well. People have the right to believe whatever they want about themselves but some of us have to stick to reality. Like it or not your genes dictate your gender. You can identify as whatever gender you like but you can’t force others to identify you the same way.
I would call this a man, because God made him a man and he needs therapy for inner peace not catering to his whims and desires.
Wrong!! Man
correction - THE MAN WANTS HIS OPINION HEARD.
He says what most others deep down believe. Fair play to him.
what others? russians there ?
I know someone who transitioned from female to make in it's ruined her life completely. She absolutely regrets it and feels she shouldn't have been encouraged by the medical profession to transition .She has become a recluse. This is an extremely dangerous ideology. I am so thankful for the brave souls who stand against it.
„You can believe what you want but you can’t impose that on other people“ - dude in yellow dress
Meanwhile forcing the doctor to believe what he believes.
Totally agree….. telling the doctor to ignore science and reality
Lol yup
Bunch of devel crazy people period
Telling this man don't believe in God but believe what they saying a man is a woman and a woman is a man make ot
Clown
as a real woman, I trust this doctor with my life and my children life. he grounds his beliefs in Christ. the entity of absolute truth. what a legend
Agree with you but please, you are not a 'real woman' you are a woman, there is only one type of woman. The thing in a frock is a man today tomorrow and for ever. If it's bones are dug up in 500 years archaeologists. Will proclaim IT'S A MAN! and they don't even have a fraction of medical knowledge compared to the Dr above. Don't play the game that AGPs want you to play. You are a woman, always. ❤
You wouldn’t even know she was trans unless it was said. Are you crazy? A doctor should help anyone regardless or they shouldn’t be a doctor. She’s still a HUMAN. Don’t dare fucking speak for god either, you aren’t god and can’t speak for the higher power!!
He should believe in God,and that Jesus (As)is one of his prophets
I hate the now you have to say real woman like I wish I could just say man not real man or any of that bs
Just say "woman"
Well done Doctor!!!
Cant believe a doctor got the sack for being truthful and being a Christian, DISGUSTING 😢
A doctor with honor. As a woman I am getting sick of these nuts trying to cancel me and all women, if we just ignore this evil and stop giving them the attention they are getting, maybe they will stop this nonsense and go away.
The doctor is the only one who makes sense and with wisdom and the one qualified to make intelligent reasoning based on facts.
lol logical fallacies always make sense to stupid people. There's like 1000s of specialists in the Medical field and this guy's specialization is Christianity. I can't even believe what I'm hearing. Until a "Doctor" makes a human from raw materials, they're literally just poking at stuff and making observations. Guy says believe more than a pastor.
I’m Muslim and I would love for this guy to be my doctor. May Allah guide you and bless you for being strong against this immorality
I'm catholic and I appreciate you for speaking out..thank you.
@weneedangels1632I'm Catholic and I agree
All his training and time spent educating himself WITH SCIENCE AND FACTS
This is an insult to this doctor
Yes sir. I too agree
@We need angels that's because you don't know the faith and just believe what u have been told
This poor Dr having the sack for being truthful.
The man on a dress! What a joke!
She actually chose Society over Biology. It's like Choosing what someone said (which you've never seen or heard before) over what you can clearly see as a fact. The delusion is off the roof.
Yep HE did
Respect to the Dr speaking facts can’t say the same for the other one.
Thing*
@@ilck-ym-blals7385 more like *scum
My thoughts exactly.
may God continuously bless this doctor
God is imaginary. Transgender people exist.
There is no god so dont bring fairytales into this.
@@BCCmma64bangIndeed our existence IS a accident by your logic .. WE just happen to exist
@@rijusnar1994 Our existence can be explained by science. Those that say a god is behind our existence are making an assumption based on zero evidence. Oh we can't explain it properly therefore it must have been a god.
@@BCCmma64bang so science know why WE exists ?
Science IS evolving and its a human construction. Even guys like Newton or Georges Lemaitre ( the Guy who théorize the Big bang) who were great scientists believe in a creator.
Science lead us to a more positivism ( Auguste comte) in how WE perceive our society.
It never explain the why of our existence.
I applaud you Doctor .
He says "you can have your own beliefs but don't impose it in other people". Isn't that's what their doing now, especially to kids for some reason
This is really sad. I hope he becomes successful and is able to live his life as he is such a respectful man, bless him and is just telling the truth.
❤
I am a Muslim and pray this doctor goes to heaven and is blessed in this world and the next.
No such thing hun...
@@omar-fy7cr Says who? a mere human being with an opinion? baseless accusation non factual reply in other words irrelevant.
@@PeterBornAgain says Allah, non muslims don’t go to heaven unless Allah permits them so.
@FATMA NAQVI,MAY YOU RECIECE ALL THE BLESSINGS THIS LIFE HAS TO OFFER,AS WELL AS THE NEXT,YOU ARE A PERSON OF INTEGRITY, THATS PLAIN TO SEE.WE NEED MORE PEOPLE LIKE YOU AND THE DOCTOR
First he should accept Islam. Otherwise no chance for him to go to Paradise unfortunately
This doctor should come to South Asia to practice. Any reputable hospital will accept him
The he-she says to the doctor you can believe it but don't impose it on others but that is exactly what she is doing to him, trying to force his/her beliefs on the doctor. These people drive me crazy - good for the Doctor for standing his ground - yes, the world is changing and not for the better, but you don't need to lose your faith in yourself or your beliefs.
As a doctor, he couldn't call him a female. Medically, he's a man ! It's hard not to get upset knowing this well-spoken educated physician was fired for great mortals
Or morals
Good for you doctor! How refreshing to see a man of integrity. It's so rare these days
I believe in that doctor.
Believe in Jesus Christ, repent, and start your new life with Him TODAY!🙏✝❤
@@OlssonMathias shut
@@z--KAISER why are you telling me what to do, you have no authority over no one!
@@OlssonMathias Anyone*
@@OlssonMathias get that Jesus bullshit outta here noone asked for it. You sound like my bible thumping Grandma
You can try to change your gender but you will always be what you were from birth
Thank you doctor for standing up.
Well that was a fair interview? Three against one?
and the way the three of them talk about the doctor as if he wasn’t even there… it’s totally disrespectful, they don’t even pretend that it’s a fair interview
It's to show there so open minded and not get any backlash or hate
😂
After Queen Gate they want to show how supportive and supposedly inclusive they are
No one watches there rubbish no more
The doctor has more sense then the lot of them
@@sophierahman2247so open-minded that their brains have fallen out.
The man in the dress made a good point. "You can have your own beliefs but don't try to push them on other people" makes sense bro try it out for a minute.
Exactly 😂the man in the dress
😂😂😂😂rudeee😂😂😂
@@Agnes.shines reality! Lol
Not the man in the dress 😂😂😂😂😂
"The man in the dress"😂
Alternatively there's a "fellow in the frock"..or "bloke in the bra"😅..
This man has character and have a backbone. Bravo! The doctor is amazing and a super hero.
5:46 "we have to have a conscience to practise medicine"
monroe: "no" there it is!
Why is that guy in yellow so pissed off that the doctor is standing his ground and beliefs...this is crazy world right now
They were horrendous bullies to that poor man...😢
😥I know! 😥
True 😢
Amen Dr you are absolutely right, thank you and God Bless you 🙏
Never did I think id ever hear the words "Christian" and "Common Sense" in the same sentence.
Stand your ground doctor god bless you
bless his soul
God
God will provide for the doctor
@@purplelove3666
❤
I used to identify as a bird because I always wanted to fly. Unfortunately I never left the ground.
Identify as flying instead of walking. Problem solved! 😅
I identify as a turtle but I can't live underwater, I want my rights
I identify as someone who is twenty years younger, but my body keeps looking old - dam.
I identify as GOD and I say homotransolagy is WRONG!
Bill Murray identified as a sailor and he lived the dream in What About Bob..."I'mmmmmm sailinnnnngg"
Apart from anything else, it would be DANGEROUS to treat or operate on a person as the opposite gender. Real harm could be done.
The doctor studied and worked so hard to earn a degree as doctor of medicine. The transgender woman however spend a lot of money for his makeup, dresses and transitioning but his efforts were just in vain!
Well done Doctor. You speak for all of us.
not for me
@@l8ersk8er64 Lie to children about science & anatomy by yourself then. We want no part of it.
@@l8ersk8er64Sorry, they meant everyone with working, functioning brains.
What's weird is he believes in God 😂 God and transgenders are equally ridiculous
The gentleman is clearly so frustrated but is doing such a good job of keeping calm
“Your playing god” coming from the person who wants them to change their GOD GIVIN gender 😩 I cant
This was five years ago. We now realise that 'assigned' is the wrong word. 'Observed' is a more accurate word.
Couldn’t imagine the frustration of being talked over like this
Dr the world is with you
No actually it's NOT with him. The World is Society!! "Love not the world nor things that are IN the world..."
No, it is not!
Yup, society is rejecting these cross dressers by a large majority 💪
@@gloriaf6971 😂😂 bless 😂
I just wanna go back in time and use phone booths because, new technology is destroying everything. Or horse and buggy.
Doctors are actually told to do no harm to people! This Doctor stands by that.
How about mental harm? That doesn't count? You are such a hypocrite.
@@jramsey9690 feeling better now?
Im so admired by this Doctor's decision not to compromise his beliefs and faith in God, you're awesome and I hope there are more doctors like you out there, let the devil and his demons work for his evil job.
Religion and doctor practices shouldn't mix that's for sure. Let science and medicine be science and medicine. Let religion be it's possible faulse idols.
Just because a person might identify as being a bird it doesn’t mean they can suddenly fly 🤷♂️
On the contrary just bc u believe you're a woman doesn't mean u are
@@misskat8548 yes that's exactly what he was implying lol
Brilliant
Dumbest example
Excellent!
God bless that doctor
Here here
I just commented that too
So the guy in drag says, "Have your own beliefs, but don't impose it on other people."😂😂😂
While trying to force him to call a guy in a dress a woman 😂😂😂
No amount of hormone drugs and surgery can make you function successfully as the opposite gender. All you become is someone on drugs for the rest of your life, who's been cut up and altered by the surgeons knife.
I'm immensely sad for all these confused people. And concerned about what might happen to them should the drugs suddenly no longer be available ...
I don’t care what these people do to mutilate and destroy their own bodies what makes me angry is how they are going after babies and children now.
...you may be right, but how about you prove that statement? How many transgender people do you know personally? None, I bet.
“You Can have you own belief but don’t impose that on other people”
Hearing that a from a trans person is kinda wild to hear😂
So agree.
They just love trying to trap people by asking them, "oh what about people who transitioned" "and then the moment they answer they have a person who transitioned right beside them - this is there way of pressuring someone to give them the answer they want.
I honestly thought when I read the title I thought they were calling him "Doctor Who" LOL 😂😊
Now if only all medical professionals were as honest as him.
Huge respect for this brave doctor from a Muslim ❤
It seems the west is becoming degenerate and perverted. It's because Christianity is not as strong as it used to be, and the result is we are seeing more perverts like the one in the video. Stay strong in your faith and don't let the unbelievers win.
Same
Thank you my brother from a Christian
Whoever fired him needs to be fired 😂
God damn. I feel so bad for this doctor, I hope he gets to open his own clinic someday
Good Doctor - who believes in his true science , religion and belief's . This is the kind of human one must aspire to be , One who upholds truth in all aspects of life .
WHo says he's "right" or "true"? He's a bigoted because of his so-called "religion."
She's literally trying to tell him he cant be a doctor based on his beliefs THAT ARE TRUE 💀
*He's. The thing in the yellow dress is a man.
If this man gets sick, he'll be lucky to go to a doctor like this who understands that men and women aren't always treated the same way.
"why don't you just say yeah yeah, tick a box and save your job"
Because the truth matters, Eamonn. It's the only thing that matters, in fact. I don't want to live in a society that has deceived itself so much that it no longer recognises the difference between truth and falsity. What is the truth you might ask? Well, in this case, the truth is that there are two sexes - male and female - and one cannot become the other. Ever!
If u didn't accept your original self don't force me to accept your false .simple. Well done Dr 👏
She says don’t push your beliefs onto other people yet that is exactly what they are doing. Push their beliefs on gender on to other people 🤔
ABSOLUTELY NOT. All that's being said is to leave transgender people be, to be able to be themselves.
If they want me to accept who they are...they need to accept who they were
“You can have your own belief but dont put them on other people” lmao bruh he fucked up his own argument. The DR is 100% correct in what he said to the guy in the dress.
So it's ok for that "women" to trash his religious and scientific beliefs then. How very hypocritical.
"84% of young trans people are either self-harming or attempting suicide." Direct quote from this video from the ladyboy. That statistic is alarming in itself. It's safe to say they are depressed. But if you take the word "trans" out of that sentence, the only thing that changes is the amount of young people. There are many forms and causes of depression, which is a huge contributor to someone who wants to harm themselves and/or take their own life. If a person suffers from depression, they are usually prescribed medicine to help them cope with the chemical imbalance in their brain. Trans or not, if you're depressed, you're depressed. These "trans" people are not getting the help they need. They are in a dark and fragile state of mind and the last thing any of them need is a doctor who enables this mind frame and agrees that gender re-assignment is the answer above all else. Gender dysphoria is a mental disorder and should be treated as such. Hormone Replacement Therapy and genital mutilation is not the answer.
He can’t oppose his beliefs on people but she can!? Good man for standing for his beliefs and his religion.
That is a sad state of affairs when doctors are being fired over this foolishness So who's going to help THEM when they need help from a medical advisor if they're All fired did THEY stop to think about that 🤔🤔🤔
That guy in yellow is a mess, doctor you stand your grounds. Don’t let this confused (MAN)force you to do anything evil.
The guy in the yellow is very handsome 👀😂😂
@@sapatiahkiong5326 😂
Thanks so much
@@sapatiahkiong5326 shes a women stupid
@@sapatiahkiong5326 The work done on that man is very convincing, as it is in many cases!
3 men and a woman having a conversation. One of the dudes thinks he’s a female. He’s not. One man was fired for telling the truth that men can’t be women, ever. He’s right. What a world.
"You can have your beliefs but don't impose it on other people." Look at the mirror.
Geez. What are they gonna do when a "female" has testicular cancer??? It is crucial to know the biological gender in the medical field.
This man is very honorable. May the LORD bless him greatly. I'm an 18-year-old college student, who has lost so much because of my faith in Christ, and every time I become discouraged, the LORD shows me something like this man's faith and yet again, I am encouraged to continuing contending for the Truth of the Gospel and the Biblical faith.
God bless you.
Amen, stay strong, you are not alone.
It is a well-established fact that the human species is composed of two distinct genders, namely the female and the male. These genders are determined by the presence of two chromosomes, XX for the female and XY for the male. It is important to note that these chromosomes are immutable and cannot be altered.
The female gender is characterized by the presence of only the X chromosome, which is carried by the egg. Conversely, the male gender is capable of producing both the X and Y chromosomes, which are carried by the sperm. It is this combination of chromosomes that ultimately determines the gender of the offspring.
In order to determine the gender of a newborn, a midwife or doctor will examine the genitalia. If the newborn has a vagina, it is classified as female, with XX chromosomes. If, on the other hand, the newborn has a penis, it is classified as male, with XY chromosomes.
It is imperative that readers understand the gravity of this subject matter. The biological makeup of an individual is a fundamental aspect of their being, and cannot be altered or changed. It is therefore of utmost importance that individuals accept and embrace their biological gender, as it is an immutable aspect of their existence.
Thank you! My thoughts exactly 💯 😕
Well said😊
Amen
100%
@@cheetajet320 fractal information is only false in the trans community and your ideologies.
Wow. A doctor got fired for something he (he and the entire world) was taught in school, medical school and in society…
He’s stating that you can’t impose your views on other people. Priceless.
You know when someone has a weak argument by how much they interrupt the other person.
The doctor was honest, kind, and gentle but he stood his grounds and got his point across.