The Sound of Auschwitz Birkenau
Vložit
- čas přidán 19. 11. 2018
- This is my work about the Auschwitz-Birkenau Memorial in Cracow.
Following my “The Sound Of” project, this is my own interpretation of the sounds of this horrible place, full of negative feelings and strange emotions.
This is actually my attempt to describe how the experience in a museum could be more powerful and engaging if lived in an immersive way throughout sounds, images and suggestions.
Hearing the child cry is what really hurts me. Just imagining what the children felt...
@@dwz5397 Nope, children weren't immediately killed. Just the weak, old, pregnant, etc.
@@BladedBear Jesus Christ.
I visited this place during the month of may (full spring). There were NO sounds of birds there, even though there were trees all over the place. The grounds are forever haunted. You can FEEL the doom in the air.
It was heartbreaking the doom it’s so hard to grasp the enormity of it all .😪
I visited Bergen Belsen in the Spring of 2019, and you are right. There were no bird sounds at all.
Yeah what a shame 250,000 people died of typhus a wartime disease. I’m sure you visited The site in Russia were 200 million Christians were killed in World War II though as well right
Shut up.
The sounds are haunting in this place of death and survival,may the world never forget the cruelty and depravation that went on in Auschwitz.
I’ve been watching this kind of stuff all night when your depressed and can’t feel anything I watch this and feel things again how can you not
Yeah. I read "The 900 Days" about the siege of Leningrad. It's
an ice bath wake up reminding us of how easy we have it.
@@WayneLynch69 you should also read finding zasha
Bless all those souls♥️
Should have left the music out to be honest
Completely agree. It ruins the video
The music minimizes the horror of Auschwitz and should be erased.
That’s what I was thinking
No. Music was played while the Jews were forced to stand in line for their death most of them immediately upon arrival.
The music was not necessary, but was well chosen I think. I would imagine for arrivals it was a very confusing and disorienting situation, as well as obviously horrifying. After being in a train for days locked up with no light or air people might have noticed blue skies as well as the screams and dogs. It is part of the bewilderment. I would imagine many just went blank. The music gave a sense of fatalism that faced the victims - especially children - a situation unimaginable and impossible to understand or control.
Hearing the children scream and cry really got to me. 😔
I've been studying the Holocaust for a few years, and "the deeper", that I dive into the work of the accounts of those who survived, academic scholars....etc. The one burning question that haunts with the most intensity is; " How can there possibly be a god that would allow mankind's hatred to run so far out of control?" Answer; there isn't any god, or gods, it's all a massive socially constructed sets of mythology. That the Western World took, basically, as a set of morals, divinely inspired lessons, if you will, to teach, as well a means to suppress the fear of death.
Can you guide me like where should i start for the holocaust study..? I want to do a research work on it.
Shmah Yisroel Adonai Elohaynu, Adonai Echod.
May the memory of 6 MILLION of my people always be a blessing. Amen.
For millions it was the last earthly sounds they heard. R.I.P.
This is absolutely dreadful sounding. It sounds like a night in a haunted house.
Extremely powerful. Even with the incredible amount of documentation, it’s appallingly easy to self-protect by going numb, even for the most sensitive of audiences. Appealing to 1-2 of the 5 senses like this brings the human element, the unimaginable tragedy, roaring back. It’s hard to listen to, but it gives me hope that even though we’re losing our living, breathing resources to the inevitable march of time, we’ll still be able to carry their stories forward to future generations.
I've visited Auschwitz and Birkenau 4 times now, and it never gets any easier. It definitely has an atmosphere of death and dispair about it, that's for sure.
A true fan, nice, me to several times
Thanks for this. The sounds tell 23 million stories... without the need for narration.
23 million...?
IT brings tears in my eyes.In 2016 i visits this place in Ozwichim in Poland.I was heartbroken .
Just listening to this is terrifying. It sounds like supernatural phenomenon occuring.
Though I never visited this place but I can feel how much negative vibes be present in the air and how spooky would the surrounding will be where millions of people have died.
Other camps, places and situations, not only Auschwitz, were involved in those "millions" of deaths.
Some Say Its Reaaally Haunted Because At Night You Can Hear The Screams Coming From The Gas Chambers
That is fucked up to say Hayley I hope you are disappointed in yourself.
I appreciate this. Thank you.
This should never have happened , those responsible should go to hell for what they done to those poor innocent people
What if there is no Hell?
This is why in the u.s. we must never give up the 2nd amendment.. hitler banned jewish people from owning firearms.. if knowing human nature people trust politicians ..people will get treated the exact same way.. look at stalin.. mao.. and many other tyrants..
Very powerful and heartbreaking! Hearing the sounds of children crying broke my heart.. this was a horrible place to be.
Very disturbing and sad 😔
That place was full of horror for so many people who were taken there!
Thank you🙏 Danilo.
Ouch, 2023 still hits hard and still unimaginable 😢
This here is the thing of horror movies .. imagine really being there and these screams being real😨🥵
Imagine being so used to the screams that you can sun bathe on the grass relatively unphased. That’s the horror of auschwitz (I say auschwitz specifically because they had the selection process I don’t know which others were similar to auschwitz)
RIP to all those who perished...😢..may you see the lord n his father.
Musical sounds indicate the most horrible and dreadful situation prevailing throughout the whole camp.
RIP 🙏🙏🙏
Man's inhumanity to his fellow man is horrifying. The U.S., Soviet Union and others have done the same in other ways. Man is the worst infestation on this planet. Destroying every living thing around him including each other. How evil and unforgivable. R.I.P. -To the innocent victims at the hands of their fellow man. 💔
Yeah the US extemination of the natives.
Soviet with gulags.
@@omeganexus5449 Indeed 👍
I so wanna go see that in person.
I love hearing people scream- but this video makes me Feel something that ive never felt before and like- i cant describe it? Like a hatred scared guilty feeling- my happiness left when i heard the screams..
What??
Very powerful
Very good. Just missing the train whistle perhaps 😔😕😏?
The music, you forgot it. The orchestra which has played military marches every day.
Incredible
This is exactly why in the u.s. we must never give up 2nd amendment.. the politicians disarm you then you see the results..
Powerful 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
I'm pretty sure there was no background music.
Its difficult to replicate the sound of terror of an efficient machinery of mass murder-- but I suspect the dog barks at the beginning - perhaps with shouting of insults the blows of clubs , canes and whips accompanied by the mass screams and cries of panicked victims reacting to the sheer terror, but frequently it must have been the victims forced to go to their deaths in silence being told to hurry as the coffee or water would get cold and being ordered to undress and tie their shoes together
The sounds are as bad as the visuals. This brought me to tears but I can´t seem to give the video a thumbs up. Great job on your production and I did subscribe to your channel. God bless
I've already heard it with all the sound and everything anyways they didn't leave sound off in my education
Damn the sound of Zyklon B being poured down the hatch was creepy.
Rest in peace
Man's inhumanity to man. The tears of heaven are still crying.
What a terrible waste of human life!
It was. Thats why I don't like to think about it. Its way too sad.
And It has been repeated in history
@@omeganexus5449 yes very sad but true,life is for living not killing we are all the same under the skin.when the rich(stupid)wage war,it’s the poor who die.you cannot kill a race of people just because of race,religion jealousy.etc
I visited Dachau Concentration Camp it was awful those poor people i dont understand why it couldn't have been stopped
For all the rightful reasons..a thing I must do b4 my times up..
🙏🙏🙏😭😭😭🙏🙏🙏
Auschwitz had music?
I would go insane if I've to spend a night there
Do not trust politicians all they want is power..
Literally Canada and the Biden Administration. Time for the next American Revolution!!!
And yet that Oskar Groning who went on trial and his '90s showed no remorse and even when Irene Weiss a survivor of that camp testified, she said he just looked down in his watch like when is this going to be over he had no remorse he did not care of course he said I was just doing my job none of that was my responsibility. She said she wanted to ask him, did you throw up when you heard the screams of women children & the elderly?? HE MAY HAVE BEEN IN HIS 90'S BUT HE HADN'T CHANGED AT ALL. HE WAS STILL ICE COLD WITH NO SOUL AND A FROZEN HEART NO EMPATHY AT ALL 😨🥵
Yes, I watched that clip. It was disturbing. The least he could have done was look into her eyes and say "I'm sorry..I got caught up in the hate campagin. I bitterly regret it." But no, he's clearly an unreconstructed Nazi bastard.
The more I listen the more I feel HORRIBLE for these men, women and children who died a terrible death. Absolutely EVIL what these Nazis did to them
Poor souls. Rip
0:17 that man is Witold Pilecki. A certified badass who volunteered to be sent to Auschwitz to gather intelligence and form a resistance movement
27.01.2021 #memory 🕯️🙏
#NeverAgain
#NeverForget
Thanks for your response and I agree; never again.
I fully understand the innocent victims can not forget what happened to them but they must forgive if healing is to take place.
@@seventh_adam4410 Thank you and ; #NeverAgain
Diana...your name makes me wonder... Are you a Polish jew? Did your family get affected during the Holocaust?
I visited these places a week ago and I have to admit that it wasn't fun being emprisoned by the $$. Block 11 was just horrific to witness.
Why do people kill there videos by playing music over them?
Imagine how Anne Frank felt 😭😱😭🙏😭🙏😭🙏😭🙏😭🙏.
Ann Frank & 5,999,000,000 others. God bless The Land of Zion/Israel. Shema Israel🇮🇱📜📖🕯🕊🇮🇱
If those sounds don’t make you cry….you have no soul I suspect.
You should re upload with no music cuz they didn’t play stupid music at the time it’s not a movie 🎥
That music ruïnes it.
The evil ones burn scream for death in the eternal furnace
RIP
🥺😥
#WeRemember
This sound experiment is little strange . The sound of Auschwitz is .....silence .
I was trying to enjoy the Musical sound of Auschwitz but a dog kept barking.
The Hebrew screams tonight
That place is even to evil for hell it self
FAMILIES FOR BRZEZINKI FIRST CLASS .......
The wonderful German people hard at work making the world a better place.
Babylon is the same, severed in both Iraq wars. Been to over 25 Concentration camps in Europe... It is the same .
El infierno en la tierra.
Somebody should have invaded Germany when they first heard of these camps
The Allies knew about them as early as 1944 and they did nothing about it until 1945. Also, many weren't in Germany, but rather occupied territories
@@Kaiserin They knew that the best way to end the suffering was to win the war
@@jimmyjazz1570 Lol? They could have bombed the camps, railroads, trains, etc. They could have effectively halted the process as soon as they knew about it, preventing anymore transports for a while, possibly giving enough time for them to liberate by 1945. They did nothing, they hold blame for it.
PRZERAZAJACE ............ !!!!!!!! NOOOOOOO oooooooooooo.........
Let’s hope and pray to God that the Author of those last words is wrong. We should be learning from those dark years . If it wasn’t for the Second World War, we mightn’t have the the Nuclear war hanging over our heads
PER NON DIMENTICARE
Disgusting
Why Nazi is bad ?
🇮🇱🙏🇮🇱
What good does it do to bring this all up again and again? Whats to be accomplished by this? These are my ancestors your talking about. The Germans were and are a great people today and many did not support him even among the military they were not nazis in heart. Its a part of history that needs to be erased. So stop making videos like this; digging up the past that needs to be forgotten. Love and forgiveness to all.
It should always be remebered, so that it won't happen again
Hey ever hear the saying history repeats itself..may we NEVER FORGET..ever think about the generations wiped out and the ones left do you think they want it forgotten..heck no
As with the Atlantic slave trade which STILL has its effects today, the holocaust also has its effects today amongst the Jewish people. So no, it shouldn’t be erased. It must always be remembered. And you arguing it shouldn’t proves how tone deaf you are.
The crimes committed can never be forgotten, if you were born during or after the war , you have no responsibility for what happened, but leave no doubt there are Germans as well as other nationalists from other countries who support what happened, therefore reminder is necessary
@@Li-rw1ih I'm glad you mentioned the slave trade and I'm glad you mentioned the generational effects it has. Just like the Holocaust. Psychologists estimate at least three generations, to heal the toxic effects upon the subsequent generations. I'd urge the OP to watch the clip of the woman who regularly woke up her husband screaming - she was back at the camp. Look into the eyes of the Holocaust survivor - have you noticed they are _broken_ ? That sadness ruined everything for them. The capacity for joy was taken from them and it affected their ability to parent. It fostered a sense of impending doom and mistrust which taught their children to live their lives the same way. We do what we see our parents do.
Please read the work of Gunter Grass who was called the conscience of Germany. The awful truth is that the Holocaust was carried out with the complicity of the German people who had been taught to hate. Watch the anti-semitic publicity campaign films pushed by Goebbels and co, in the decade leading-up to WW2. Watch the still photos of Jewish women being raped on the streets of Eastern Europe - the youths casually knocking-over women and laughing. Grown men doing nothing to help. You can see the women's distress it is horrifying.
My mother, now in her late 70s, a white British woman ( not the type of person you'd call "woke", believe me ) used to go to bed frightened for black children trying to go to school in the newly desegregated South in the U.S.A. She'd been listening to the radio and worrying for them. Even though she lived in a fairly racist society herself. She probably _was_ a racist, but thought what was happening in the U.S. was _taking things too far._
You sound young, when you're a little older, you'll realise all of this wasn't so long ago. It's outrageous that the barbarisim of the Holocaust happened in 1940s _civilised_ Germany. Building the train tracks..."Work Sets you Free" the _planning_ of it all. Or black children being burnt alive in an 1963 Alabama church. Watch Oprah's friend Iyanla talk about being spat at by "white folks" as she was trying to enter a mixed educational establishment. Not so long ago and could happen again tomorrow. In England, Polish workers do not have an easy time of it because of Brexit etc.
At this moment in time, Germany is probably less racist than my own country of Great Britain. So I'm not being smug, but with respect, the fact that this type of film makes you feel bad as a German / Eastern European doesn't negate the necessity of learning these lessons. Could all happen tomorrow.
It just sounds like drill music