واقعآ غزل ناب است از استاد بزرگوار.سرآهنگ بزرگ. اما نعیم نظری خوانده نمی‌تواند. بهتر است که همچو آهنگهای اصلآ نخواند. ولی استاد تاری خان یکی از بهترین طبله نوازان جهان است.
look indian or pakistani tabler player can play whit afghani but in afghanistan we dont hafe a singer like they can sing whit indian or pakistani tabla player,
@sarmalim LOOL i like the way you said he copies Ustad Sarahang "word for word beat for beat and even coughs at the points he cough" your absolutely right, even though i have no idea who this guy is ... the only reason i watched this clip is because my Ustadji is playing tabla along with this person singing. If you say this guy isn't an ustad, he is disrespecting USTAD's not only Ustad Sarahang.
@2009mercedes I do not think the ability to play is based on ones nationality. I can understand what your saying if you mean the styles of music are different in different parts of the world.
@1nd1anb0y86 I couldn't agree with you more. He should at least, like you said tell Tari Khan Saheb and other Indians and Pakistanis that he is just imitating a great Ustad. They are under the impression that this guy is the master and creator of all this perfect music, as a result they address him as an ustad not knowingly. Most Afghans, on the other hand know it, but they either don't care as long as he sounds good, or they have not distinguished between "knowledge and imitation"
That is true indian or pakistani tabla player they cant play with afghan. They are good and pro in classic music but not light songs. I saw farhad jan darya video, pakistani tabla player couldnt play with him.
@1nd1anb0y86 I understand how you feel. Ustaad Tari Khan is a great Guru. He has had many students including yourself and my own son. But this guy shamelessly imitates the late Ustad, Sarahang, so perfectly that, in fact, Tari Khan is playing Ustad Sarahang, not knowingly. Even Ustad Zakir Husain would enjoy playing with him. Thank you for acknowledging my frustration with naim.
The way Ustad Ji is sitting has no connection with the Singer and plus he is not accompanying but rather trying to impress the crowd. I prefer the Tari khan that played for Mehdi hassan the Tabla complemented the ghazals very well and the laggis were excecuted perfectly and and appropirately
@sarmalim Yeah I understand what you mean brother. And no problem, I just wanted to let you know this guy who is imitating the late Ustad Sarahang should atleast show some respect of whose ghazal he is singing.
Let me simplify this for everyone, what everybody is doing is comparing apples to oranges. Afghans can only play with afghans and Indian and pakistan can only play with themselves. That's the best way to put it to rest.
@KabulPalang, I agree with u about Ustad Tari Khan, but naim is a poor carbon copy of the Great Ustad Sarahang. Once you define the word "Ustad", you can see that there is not a single genuine quality of an Ustad in him. He should feel ashamed for leading people to believe that he is an Ustad. The first definition of Ustad is "teacher", and this man knows nothing to teach. He imitates Ustad Sarahang and sings his compositions word for word beat for beat and even coughs at the points he cough.
یکی از غزلهای نایاب استاد محترم ♥️👌
واقعآ غزل ناب است از استاد بزرگوار.سرآهنگ بزرگ.
اما نعیم نظری خوانده نمی‌تواند.
بهتر است که همچو آهنگهای اصلآ نخواند.
ولی استاد تاری خان یکی از بهترین طبله نوازان جهان است.
جهانی سپاس از هر دو استاد بزرگوار ❤
Ustad Tari saheb is outstanding as always. Certainly the most enjoyable tabla master to listen to, by far!
عالیست!
Beautiful Song!
Exactly
I guess you mean baaaaadddd in a good way. Ustad Tari Khan is amazing and clearly his enjoyment is showing in the video. Well done both!
Are you out of your mind? Tari Khan is one of the best tabla player in the world.
Ustad Tari Khan is one of the best tabla player from Pakistan^^ not india.
um.....im just askin, is rupak and mogholi the same thing?
نام خدااستاد نظری
look indian or pakistani tabler player can play whit afghani but in afghanistan we dont hafe a singer like they can sing whit indian or pakistani tabla player,
I am sorry to say that he did not sing Jane Kharabat in this mahfil, but I will upload other clips from this mahfil,.
I will upload more clips from this mahfil soon.
tari ji is just so inspiring. I wish i could play that well.
Shame on you.
U know nothing about Tableh
@sarmalim LOOL i like the way you said he copies Ustad Sarahang "word for word beat for beat and even coughs at the points he cough" your absolutely right, even though i have no idea who this guy is ... the only reason i watched this clip is because my Ustadji is playing tabla along with this person singing. If you say this guy isn't an ustad, he is disrespecting USTAD's not only Ustad Sarahang.
And he was indian...
@2009mercedes what do you know about this tabla player? nothing..
post more pleaseeeee
@2009mercedes I do not think the ability to play is based on ones nationality. I can understand what your saying if you mean the styles of music are different in different parts of the world.
can any one post the lyrics please
@1nd1anb0y86 I couldn't agree with you more. He should at least, like you said tell Tari Khan Saheb and other Indians and Pakistanis that he is just imitating a great Ustad. They are under the impression that this guy is the master and creator of all this perfect music, as a result they address him as an ustad not knowingly. Most Afghans, on the other hand know it, but they either don't care as long as he sounds good, or they have not distinguished between "knowledge and imitation"
That is true indian or pakistani tabla player they cant play with afghan. They are good and pro in classic music but not light songs. I saw farhad jan darya video, pakistani tabla player couldnt play with him.
@1nd1anb0y86 I understand how you feel. Ustaad Tari Khan is a great Guru. He has had many students including yourself and my own son. But this guy shamelessly imitates the late Ustad, Sarahang, so perfectly that, in fact, Tari Khan is playing Ustad Sarahang, not knowingly. Even Ustad Zakir Husain would enjoy playing with him. Thank you for acknowledging my frustration with naim.
@2009mercedes I dont need any info about the tabla, i am a tabla player .
The way Ustad Ji is sitting has no connection with the Singer and plus he is not accompanying but rather trying to impress the crowd. I prefer the Tari khan that played for Mehdi hassan the Tabla complemented the ghazals very well and the laggis were excecuted perfectly and and appropirately
@sarmalim Yeah I understand what you mean brother. And no problem, I just wanted to let you know this guy who is imitating the late Ustad Sarahang should atleast show some respect of whose ghazal he is singing.
Let me simplify this for everyone, what everybody is doing is comparing apples to oranges. Afghans can only play with afghans and Indian and pakistan can only play with themselves. That's the best way to put it to rest.
Stuff's too easy for Ustad Tari Khan Saheb. It's good though.
the man does not know who Ustad Tari Khan is..hahaha..wow.
talkhan khor wa shaftal khore kharkos kate gap zadanet , binamus ,
@KabulPalang, I agree with u about Ustad Tari Khan, but naim is a poor carbon copy of the Great Ustad Sarahang. Once you define the word "Ustad", you can see that there is not a single genuine quality of an Ustad in him. He should feel ashamed for leading people to believe that he is an Ustad. The first definition of Ustad is "teacher", and this man knows nothing to teach. He imitates Ustad Sarahang and sings his compositions word for word beat for beat and even coughs at the points he cough.