Sorry but using all of those synthetic materials to create the seat and back pretty much destroyed any historical value that this interesting chair had. Chip board, foam and plastic leather!!! 😭
I loved what u did for all the wood pieces 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 and it does look so much better than what it did before; but the chip board seat & foam etc isn’t in keeping with the rest of the chair! Having said that, it’s great that you’ve given it more life.
An ultimate guide into "How not to treat an antique!!!" When I saw you applying PVA glue for the cracks etc, I knew you were up to no good at all from that point onwards, unfortunately you proved us all right. Also when you didn't bother dealing with [filling with wood dust and [brown/hide] glue putty] into millions of nail and tack holes left behind from reupholstering over the years, I again suspected that there was something sinister awaiting us on the menu for the seat and back-rest - 18mm OSB really, yuck! Choice of fabric & colour was the most distasteful cherry on top for that poor antique had the utter misfortune to endure in her late years. What a shame.
Viele beschweren sich über die Art der Restaurierung, aber dieser Stuhl ist ein Massenfabrikat aus der Zeit um 1910 und würde in gutem Originalzustand höchstens 100,- Euro in Deutschland kosten. Eine fachgerechte Restauriert wäre vier mal so teuer, darum ist diese Art, aus dem Stuhl wieder ein Gebrauchsmöbel zu machen, vollkommen in Ordnung.
But in the video title it says "Restoration of Antique", not "Making an Old Mass Produced Chair Functional Again." And the fact that something was 'mass produced' 120 years ago doesn't make it worthless, it had a unique history, which has now been destroyed.
@@Gattobuono Antik bedeutet lediglich, der Stuhl ist über hundert Jahre alt. Das ist aber kein Kriterium für eine besonders hohe Qualität. Wenn man diesen Stuhl komplett in der alten Technik und mit dem passenden Material restauriert, dann sind die Kosten für die Arbeit wesentlich höher, als für einen perfekt erhaltenen original Stuhl aus der selben Manufaktur. Wenn man etwas nicht ausschließlich als Hobby für sich selbst macht, dann muss man Wert und Aufwand in Relation setzen.
Whether the intention is resale or hobby: why the bother if the end result is a mash up of antique wood (and antique it is, regardless of its market value at the time) and completely unrelated plastic? I don't know the rules of the antiques market, nor the rules of formal restoration; moreover, every content creators have their style, fair enough. This content though simply feels a bit cheap to me in both intention and execution, compared to others.
Работа проведена грандиозная, но нешлифованный яхтенный лак, нанесенный кисточкой, и неверно сделанная каретная стяжка сильно портят конечный результат.
Столько упираться, восстанавливать, а потом вырезать из Двп сидение и спинку, да ещё и поролон... Это не реставрация, а так себе , ремесленный ремонт. Получилась не аутентичная, антикварная вещь, а базарская поделка. Начали за здравие...
Plywood and foam does not replace springs and horse hare, and it should be leather and a proper floral pattern fabric preferably embroidered. but you did ok on the wood. I prefer to spray lacquer giver a finer finish.
В каком укромном месте он так сохранился)))) стуличи и правда германческий... все на нагелях... хоть бы один шип-пас). Жаль.... лучше бы сохранить пружины.
La restauración de la armaxon de la silla sin igual. Pero: La mataste con ese tapizado sintetico. Sugiero muy amablemente la lleves a un tapicero y le ponga la sentadera y respaldar como era originalmente. 😁😁
For all you complaining about how he resorted the chair and the music, you can restore a chair of your own and post it to CZcams and mute this video, so no one has to read your negativity.
The comments section doesn't exist solely for people who think that everything anyone does on youtube is wonderful. It's a place to give feedback. And the criticisms of this appalling 'restoration' are entirely valid. They give the 'restorer' an opportunity to be objective about his work and hopefully improve it in the future.
Great work, but take some advice. No matter how good the content is, poor music choice can kill a video. The music for this video was the completely wrong choice. Try something more serene/classical. Many viewers watch this type of content for its calming effect.
Peccato... bastava restituire a questa bellissima sedia il suo valore iniziale seguendo quello che c'era sotto l'intervento di copertura più recente. Molle e imbottitura fatta a mano. Distrutta...
Sorry but using all of those synthetic materials to create the seat and back pretty much destroyed any historical value that this interesting chair had. Chip board, foam and plastic leather!!! 😭
yeah no, that isn't a restoration just a complete stripdown and rebuild with new parts
Очень жаль это чудом сохранившееся изделие, это не реставрация. Если это увидят мастера, они зарыдают.
@@Bluecolord ... and I didn't even mention the terrible glossy rough varnish on the wood!
It would have deserved a traditional upholstery.
Do you think you should have kept the old horsehair or looked for a new one?
And this is how the beauty of an emblematic piece is destroyed. I had never seen a tutorial on how to destroy old pieces.
I loved what u did for all the wood pieces 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 and it does look so much better than what it did before; but the chip board seat & foam etc isn’t in keeping with the rest of the chair! Having said that, it’s great that you’ve given it more life.
I was interested in your work, however that monotonous music made it impossible for me to concentrate.
If the music bothered you so much why not mute the video?
@@diamondperidot Because then you don't hear the sound of the work .... obviously.
Такую вещь, взял и испортил😢
An ultimate guide into
"How not to treat an antique!!!"
When I saw you applying PVA glue for the cracks etc, I knew you were up to no good at all from that point onwards, unfortunately you proved us all right. Also when you didn't bother dealing with [filling with wood dust and [brown/hide] glue putty] into millions of nail and tack holes left behind from reupholstering over the years, I again suspected that there was something sinister awaiting us on the menu for the seat and back-rest - 18mm OSB really, yuck! Choice of fabric & colour was the most distasteful cherry on top for that poor antique had the utter misfortune to endure in her late years.
What a shame.
High gloss finish is not a good choice. This beautiful chair deserved better.
Видимо, автору не доводилось раньше ремонтировать старую мягкую мебель. На CZcams много видео, где показано, как выполнить такую работу правильно.
А как правильно?
Wow it came out great. I liked the great details in the work done.
Viele beschweren sich über die Art der Restaurierung, aber dieser Stuhl ist ein Massenfabrikat aus der Zeit um 1910 und würde in gutem Originalzustand höchstens 100,- Euro in Deutschland kosten. Eine fachgerechte Restauriert wäre vier mal so teuer, darum ist diese Art, aus dem Stuhl wieder ein Gebrauchsmöbel zu machen, vollkommen in Ordnung.
But in the video title it says "Restoration of Antique", not "Making an Old Mass Produced Chair Functional Again."
And the fact that something was 'mass produced' 120 years ago doesn't make it worthless, it had a unique history, which has now been destroyed.
@@Gattobuono Antik bedeutet lediglich, der Stuhl ist über hundert Jahre alt. Das ist aber kein Kriterium für eine besonders hohe Qualität. Wenn man diesen Stuhl komplett in der alten Technik und mit dem passenden Material restauriert, dann sind die Kosten für die Arbeit wesentlich höher, als für einen perfekt erhaltenen original Stuhl aus der selben Manufaktur. Wenn man etwas nicht ausschließlich als Hobby für sich selbst macht, dann muss man Wert und Aufwand in Relation setzen.
Whether the intention is resale or hobby: why the bother if the end result is a mash up of antique wood (and antique it is, regardless of its market value at the time) and completely unrelated plastic? I don't know the rules of the antiques market, nor the rules of formal restoration; moreover, every content creators have their style, fair enough. This content though simply feels a bit cheap to me in both intention and execution, compared to others.
the finish is a bit rough I would have oiled it and sanded a bit more.
Работа проведена грандиозная, но нешлифованный яхтенный лак, нанесенный кисточкой, и неверно сделанная каретная стяжка сильно портят конечный результат.
Impecable !!
Amazing!!!!
Beautiful job!🌷🌷
Outstanding work 👏👏
It looks great and you did a wonderful job restoring it as well!!!!
I enjoyed your video so I gave it a Thumbs Up
Maravilloso!!!. Saludos desde Uruguay.
Столько упираться, восстанавливать, а потом вырезать из Двп сидение и спинку, да ещё и поролон... Это не реставрация, а так себе , ремесленный ремонт. Получилась не аутентичная, антикварная вещь, а базарская поделка. Начали за здравие...
As always you do a great job with your restorations. I always look forward to your videos. A hug straight from Minas Gerais -Brazil.
Можно сказать, что всё шло хорошо до момента появления банки лака😢😮...потом ещё и osp...поролон🤪
Стул теперь блестит, будто соплями измазан🤭
You have a light touch when using a rotary tool. I was hesitant to see you use it, but it worked! That wood was really dry. You did a good job.
Plywood and foam does not replace springs and horse hare, and it should be leather and a proper floral pattern fabric preferably embroidered. but you did ok on the wood. I prefer to spray lacquer giver a finer finish.
not gonna lie we had some comfy chairs apperently for the time being
Cila ve döşemeye kadar her şey güzel gidiyordu ….😢
Surprised, the wood survived.
Хорошая работа. Тем не менее, стул потерял всю историческую ценность из-за сиденья😢
Спасибо❤
Был красивый мягкий стул. Автор из него сделал корявую табуретку. Гвоздолуп.
Você e gênio parabéns 👍🌟👏
Спросите где был куплен стул. Квиток, найденный под кожей, на русском языке
В каком укромном месте он так сохранился)))) стуличи и правда германческий... все на нагелях... хоть бы один шип-пас).
Жаль.... лучше бы сохранить пружины.
Был куплен у родственников, чей дед привёз стул из Германии после войны.
La restauración de la armaxon de la silla sin igual.
Pero: La mataste con ese tapizado sintetico.
Sugiero muy amablemente la lleves a un tapicero y le ponga la sentadera y respaldar como era originalmente.
😁😁
Niestety część miękka czyli tapicerska jest okropna. Natomiast część drewniana wspaniała!
Sorry, but you should use natural leather, similar fabric to the original and less shine. This is not a restauration
🎉
Absolutely brilliant best wishes from uk England 👌
I am pretty sure these guys have no some college or university background.
With all respect these are NOT carpenters job.
Великолепно!!!👍👍👍
For all you complaining about how he resorted the chair and the music, you can restore a chair of your own and post it to CZcams and mute this video, so no one has to read your negativity.
I have restored museum furnitur for years. This is a disaster and the music is crap. BTW I don't to monetize my work in YT.. 😅
The comments section doesn't exist solely for people who think that everything anyone does on youtube is wonderful. It's a place to give feedback.
And the criticisms of this appalling 'restoration' are entirely valid. They give the 'restorer' an opportunity to be objective about his work and hopefully improve it in the future.
Здравствуйте, некоторые детали надо было заменить, а то очень дряхлый и ветхие.
Airline Lufthansa
güzel iş👍
Very nice restoration
симукляр ( simulacre )
Great work, but take some advice. No matter how good the content is, poor music choice can kill a video. The music for this video was the completely wrong choice. Try something more serene/classical. Many viewers watch this type of content for its calming effect.
Работа хорошая. Но я думала в конце сиденье перетянут как полагается с пружинами и набьют. Но тоже неплохо.
I watched this without volume on. The sound of sanding AND the music.....no. Too much noise. It distracted from your work
Get rid of that annoying music. It spoilt the whole video for me.
Mute
Mute the video
@@diamondperidot Thanks brainiac!
Peccato... bastava restituire a questa bellissima sedia il suo valore iniziale seguendo quello che c'era sotto l'intervento di copertura più recente. Molle e imbottitura fatta a mano. Distrutta...
That poor chair looked like it has been through rough punishment. Looks great now. ✨️🪑✨️👍
oh, wow that is so amazing....awesome job..
Ужас!!!
Халтура.
Тебя к реставрации вообще допускать нельзя. Это не твоё, займись чем-нибудь другим.
Que feo barniz.