Yeah Brother❤. They Demonize Us(Muslim) And Our Faith(Islam) Also Our Culture. Alhumdulillah Everything Getting better more and more people are converting Islam. It's fastest growing religion right now after all of their propaganda.❤🥰.
Bin Laden is a Western Creation of a Role model Muslim. Whereas Bin Laden meant nothing to the majority of the Muslim world. Had Bin laden followed the Quran then he would have established schools & Hospital in Afghanistan instead of armed resistance.
Absolutely blown away by this insightful interview! Professor Mohammad Khalil's deep knowledge and articulate explanations on the subject of Jihad, Radicalism, and the New Atheism are truly remarkable. This discussion is an invaluable resource for anyone seeking to understand these complex topics better. Thank you both for this enlightening exchange!
what do you think that knowledge should be? i was reading how the great islamic scholar ibn taimayya ruled that the druze should be killed as apostates. do you agree?
@@user-jv4zb6zu7w I commented to correct a spelling error, not to engage with clowns as yourself. May you forever seethe at the existence and growth of Islam. May it consume you to your core.
This is a really brilliant piece of scholarship. The best thing about this is that not only does it try to address the concerns of new atheists, Sam Haris in particular, it also tries to inform the Muslim consciousness about the subject of Jihad and terrorism.
So far - Its an excellent lecture- Prof. Mohammad Hassan Khalil: has put together most popular bias against Muslims & Islam. Now we need to see distinctions between Islamic Laws & Muslim behavior and non muslim perceptions.
@@user-jv4zb6zu7wVery well. Read the histories of Prophet Muhammad who never forced anyone or any group into the fold of Islam. Read The Treaty of Medina. The real question for today is how will fascist atheists treat people of Faith-the plurality and singularity of Faiths while imposing their Will onto Faith Families?
@@kausamsalam8543 cannot force other to accept Islam. But forced to live humiliating lives as dhimmis. They are not equal to muslims, have lower status and treated unfairly. In a western society, a muslim is equal to a non muslim. That's why u all run here
@@kausamsalam8543 i've read the treaty of medina. not a bad document for the 7th century. i know quite a bit about the life of muhammad. so you think an angel came to him to tell him the banu nadir were going to kill him? what do you think of his response when asked about the killing of the women and children of the polytheists? what do you think of case out of Indonesia were they imprisoned a buddhist woman for asking the mosque near here house to turn their loudspeaker down? "how will fascist atheists treat people of Faith" well if they are fascists, probably not too well. i've never heard of a good fascist? oh yeah. do you consider abu bark, omar, uthman and ali to be 'righty guided' caliphs?
Muslims fill European jails for sex crimes, the islamic world is full of child predators, homosexuality is rampant in islamic places like Pakistan and Saudi... denying the size and scope of the damage done by islam to muslims is criminal.
One of the best talks on concepts of Jihad that I ever heard.Thankyou so much both of you for enlightening us with the true teachings of Islam in this regard❤
Suicide bombing, which is part of violence, is also prohibited as understood from this verse: “O you who believe, do not consume each other properties illicitly; only mutually acceptable transactions are permitted. You shall not kill yourselves. God is Merciful toward you.” (Qur’an, 4:29)
It's not suicide in the sense of a depression hopelessness type of deleting yourself, a so called suicide mission or self sacrifice mission strictly in a military context is like a last resort type tactic used in certain circumstances. Of course I'm talking about strictly in a military sense not attacking civilians. Battles in centuries gone by had very high risk missions where one or two were sent into the enemy camp, it was almost guaranteed they would be killed if caught, would you call this a suicide mission?
right. but didn't muhammad on occasion break his own rules of warfare? i've read islamic scholars who have argued suicide attacks are needed do to the muslim being so disadvantaged by size and/or technology. how is it you think muslims are in favor of suicide bombing and the killing of women and children?
@@siemprestruggle9272 I think deliberately killing yourself whatever circumstances is what is suicide. Which is haram. If you fight a battle that you know you're going to lose that isn't suicide.
@@siemprestruggle9272no, i wouldnt call that a suicide mission. Thats a high risk mission. But your intention is to get out alive. If you go there with the intention to get killed and getting killed or blowing yourself up is your only mission then id say thats a suicide mission
JAK brother Paul for all your efforts. May Allah open your path to Janna as you help open our eyes into all the important topics surrounding the recent events in the holy land of Palestine.
The problem with religion is that's vague where many of the things it says can be applied to different wars/actions......which means you never know exactly which war/action it's talking about because it can be applied to multiple. How many times have christians claimed X event was the last coming of Jesus. Religion is vague on purpose.
I absolutely love your interviews. I would love to see you speak with my teacher after I took my shahadah. He has supported many new Muslims on their journeys and i think it would be especially interesting if you interview or spoke with him. I would love to put you in contact with him and see where the chips fall?
@user-jv4zb6zu7w Aḥaadiiṯ (singular: Ḥadiiṯ) are collections of men's hearsays / talks written down that have no connections to Rasuulu-LLaahi and Nabii’u-LLaahi Muḥammad ﷺ and his companions whatsoever!
@@samantarmaxammadsaciid5156 Not true. The sunnah is comprised of the Quran, the Hadith, the tafsir, and the biography of Muhammad. In Sunni Islam, doctrine is derived from these four pieces. Most Muslims in the world are Sunni.
@antichrist.superstar The sunnat you are talking is Humanity’s Ḥadiiṯ whether religious or non-religious, past or present, it's open to debate or problematic, however the Qurʼaan despite Humanity’s problematic writings / faulty copying processes so-called the Qiraa’aat (variant readings) of the Qur’aan, still the Qur’aan is unmatched because it is about the creation (Who? The Creator of all: Ar-Raḥmaan / Allaah < Al-Ilaah) / evolution (the matching self-contained processes of the formation from within of "Kun! Fa-Yakuunu = Be! Thus, he is" as Allaah is Non-Physical Infinite, for that creating Aadam with His two hands is linguistically selective representation of the dual alignment of the Creator and the selected created symbolism within the entire creation corresponding to Az-Zawj = the Pair / the Couple, initiated from Min Nafsin Waaḥidatin = from Single Self, and in turn from Ruuḥu-lQudusi or Ruuḥu-LLaahi) of the Humanity (central representation of all earthly and the spacial or the sky out of which is formed and in which the earth exists) as a singular (= Aadam in the Jannat) and as a plural in this Ad-Dunyaa = the Lower / the Nearer (Life), hence the Qur’aan being our path to the Nearer Life towards the Creator of all: Allaah, in the Aakhirat of the original Earth Jannat for Last (Final) Home as opposed to remaining in this earth of the Lower Hellish Life! And that guide that is the Qur’aan through Rasuulu-LLaahi and Nabii’u-LLaahi Muḥammad ﷺ as Allaah’s Ḥadiiṯ, being about ourselves and how we should take Allaah’s Ḥadiiṯ as our guide = Sunnatu-LLaahi! Simplicity = "Complexity within" as one = Duality!
May Allah bless and reward you brothers for all your effort, I am truly grateful for the material which inshallah will give knowledge to muslims and non-muslim in this great channel
you sholuld read the book of jihad by ibn nuhaas. he says things like this: Definition of Jihad: The linguistic meaning: • Lisan Alarab: Fighting the enemy. It involves using all effort in words and deeds. • Mujam matn al lughah: Jihad is commonly used to refer to waging war for the sake of Al-haqq (the truth) In Islamic terminology it means: Calling towards the true religion and fighting with one’s soul and wealth against those who reject it. (Al Inayah Sharh al Hidayah (Hanafi)) Jihad is fighting. (Al Sheerazi in al Muhadhab (Shafi’i) Jihad is a Muslim waging war agianst a non-Muslim who has no peace agreement with Muslims and the fighting is for the sake of the word of Allah to prevail. Jihad is also fighting the non-Muslim who attacks Muslim territory and it is also the Muslims attacking the non-Muslims in their land. (Mawahib al Jaleel fi Sharh Mukhtasar Khalil (Maliki)) Jihad is a cure for the individual and the society. It cures the individual by delivering him from the sickness of disbelief to the wellbeing of Islam. Disbelieving in Allah is the greatest disease of all and the most destructive on all humanity, while Islam is the complete cure. Jihad cures the society by eliminating the source of corruption and oppression. Leaving the disbeliever unharmed increases the disease and strengthens it and allows the cancer to spread. Therefore Islam cannot flourish and Muslims cannot live in peace unless the disease is cured. If it is possible to cure the disease by using a medicine then be it. Otherwise the infected portion must be amputated even though the amputation could cause pain and suffering for the body. But then no one could claim that the amputation cruel or inhumane. It was necessary for the survival of the body. That is precisely the role of Jihad in Islam. First the message should be conveyed through peaceful means. If the peaceful course is exhausted and it did not bear its fruits, the bearers of the truth would need to draw their swords and fight in order for the word of Allah to prevail.
Many people misunderstanding meaning Of Jihad,for example: A father who earns a living for his children and wife at the risk of live or death is called"JIHAD". A mother struggling to give birth to her baby at risk of life or death is called:"JIHAD" SO... Jihad can be interpreted as doing good deeds in the way of God truly, even at risk of death.
should arabic come up with some more words, lol. so a kaffir is both a farmer and an infidel? in the west when we talk of jihad, we clearly mean jihad of the sword. so do you support an islamic caliphate inviting nations to islam, and if they refuse you send in dai [people to proslytize] and if the nation also refuses, you attack them to spread islam? wage jihad?
@@user-hi5xq7nx2y If you read hadith then you surely know jihad is impossible today cause Women, children and non fighting men can't be harmed or taken hostages Jihad mean struggle
Excellent lecture remarkable distinctions were made: very informative. In my opinion Muslims need to follow the Quran to change their misperceived understanding of the Quran: Muslim Perceptions: in the non muslims world are based on behavior of ignorant muslims.
So far - Its an excellent lecture- Prof. Mohammad Hassan Khalil: has put together most popular bias against Muslims & Islam. Now we need to see distinctions between Islamic Laws & Muslim behavior and non muslim perceptions.
Never read his book - If he contradicts the Quran then it is his error: Quran explicitly explains terms of Jihad. Bottomline is no one scholar has the last Word: Al Quran is the Last Word. May God guide us to the Truth. @@user-jv4zb6zu7w
A reminder : Jihad it is from root JHD > JD expresses intensity, and the H is the Ideation. Another way to understand etymologically this word : J means to gather, and HD is the path. Jihad is about to focus on the Way, ignoring futilities.
In Islamic terminology it means: Calling towards the true religion and fighting with one’s soul and wealth against those who reject it. (Al Inayah Sharh al Hidayah (Hanafi)) Jihad is fighting. (Al Sheerazi in al Muhadhab (Shafi’i) Jihad is a Muslim waging war agianst a non-Muslim who has no peace agreement with Muslims and the fighting is for the sake of the word of Allah to prevail. Jihad is also fighting the non-Muslim who attacks Muslim territory and it is also the Muslims attacking the non-Muslims in their land. (Mawahib al Jaleel fi Sharh Mukhtasar Khalil (Maliki)) Jihad is a cure for the individual and the society. It cures the individual by delivering him from the sickness of disbelief to the wellbeing of Islam. Disbelieving in Allah is the greatest disease of all and the most destructive on all humanity, while Islam is the complete cure. Jihad cures the society
Thanks for lecture. I really apreciate it. But better of western muslim scholars focused on Palestine status today through politics way. Because so sad that our brothers and sisters in Palestine now struggle to eat, drink and sleep well. Bomb everywhere. Food and Aid can't enter the border. 😢😢 Our top issues must be how to ceasefire now. #freepalestine #ceasefirenow #ceasefire
Although I was at first pleased to see the emergence of the New Atheists, I was not particularly impressed with their arguments. Their books were very important antidotes to the romantic notions held by people who had only encountered liberal varieties of religion.; but, they weren't very deep thinkers and did not get to the root causes of the atrocities for which religions have been responsible . I had been frustrated by the dismissive attitudes of the left, progressives, and liberals toward the religious right in America, and hoped that the New Atheism would provide a much needed antidote to such misapprehensions, but was soon disappointed to realize that they had set their sights on Islam. Some twenty years later, with the MAGA crowd standing a good chance of winning another American election, I am more convinced than ever that it is Christian fanatics, and not Muslim fanatics, who pose the biggest threat to the world today, although the Zionist fanatics are running a close second with their talk of eradicating the Amalekites. Speaking of which, I wonder how the New Atheists are reacting to this pronouncements. They know who the Amalekites are because they routinely used that genocide as an example of God's evil in the Old Testament.
It exposes their strategic and inconsistent ‘morality.’ Their imperial-western exceptionalism and orientalist undertones reveal their Islamophobia and the blindfold they intentionally utilize on the Zionist fanatic, Christian fanatic and even the atheist fanatic
A lot A lot of people made a name and fortune for themselves, attacking Islam, unlike any religion on earth. Why is that? The perspective that if there is an exception to a rule, it calls into question the validity or applicability of that rule in general, weirdly enough, is thrown out the window whenever it's about Islam teachings and regulations. One shouldn't be sad about this reality, because it is actually helping, by the will of Allah, Islam reach people with hearts and souls ready and open to accept it. It is prophesied, and it is the proof that the only truth is the dean of Allah.
Allah reward you with goodness for your work, especially for pointing out the clear contradictions of his beliefs and statements. It's hard for me to even hear these arguments against Islam by Sam Harris (who continues to make money by bashing Islam, put into a position of influence for a reason, with media/Hollywood connections due to his Jewish mother who created tv series The Golden Girls) because I don't believe the official mainstream media accounts of certain events like Sept 11. But it is important for all Muslims to seek knowledge on topics from trusted Scholars and to not act based on one's own desires.
ثبتكم الله علي الحق يا اخوان ونصركم الله في دعوتكم لدين الله وَمَنْ أَحْسَنُ قَوْلًا مِّمَّن دَعَآ إِلَى ٱللَّهِ وَعَمِلَ صَـٰلِحًا وَقَالَ إِنَّنِى مِنَ ٱلْمُسْلِمِينَ And whose words are better than someone who calls others' to Allah, does good, and says, "I am truly one of those who submit."?
ALLAH is saying Surely those who believe and do good, their Lord will guide them to Paradise through their faith, rivers will flow under their feet in the Gardens of Bliss, in which their prayer will be, “Glory be to You, O ALLAH! and their greeting will be, “Peace!” and their closing prayer will be, “All praise is for ALLAH Lord of all worlds!”
Thank you for idiotic comment however everyone is not aware about it. without putting a laughing emoji you could you recommanded a book.@@ismailtareq3222
@@FarmanSeema there doesn’t need to be an invitation from them , just ask them nicely and openly online if they’d be willing to allow truthful intellectuals to clear the air with what’s happening on religion and why this “accordion” thing is a forceful endeavor that doesn’t take in what the majority of Muslims have to say But as American Muslims we’ve trusted the wrong people to which it has ruined our reputation to be the same as the LGBTQ people 60% of Muslim women in America are giving sides with LGBTQ which is no different than a man /woman made religion that looks over reality When they’re too afraid of the simply saying that EVERYONE/EVERY THING that exists comes from where gravity, density, and etc is all produced and given along with gasses and particles which lead back to THE WILL himself. “O you who believe! You are forbidden to inherit women against their will. Nor should you treat them with harshness, that you may take away part of the dowry you have given them - except when they have become guilty of open lewdness On the contrary live with them on a footing of kindness and equity. If you take a dislike to them, it may be that you dislike something bad Allah will bring about through it a great deal of good. (Quran, 4:19) “O believers! Wine, gambling, idols and divining arrows are only a dirty work of Satan. Avoid them wholly so that you may gain true success. Satan only wants to sow enmity and hate among you by wine and gambling and to turn you away from remembering God and from praying. So will you stop (doing wrong)?” ~ Quran 5:90-91 (Quran 26:183) - “and do not deprive people of their due and do not commit abuse on earth, spreading corruption.” (2:177) “Righteousness does not consist in turning your faces towards the east or towards the west; true righteousness consists in believing in Allah and the Last Day, the angels, the Book and the Prophets, and in giving away one’s property in love of Him to one’s kinsmen, the orphans, the poor and the wayfarer, and to those who ask for help, and in freeing the necks of slaves, and in establishing Prayer and dispensing the Zakah. True righteousness is attained by those who are faithful to their promise once they have made it and by those who remain steadfast in adversity and affliction and at the time of battle (between Truth and falsehood). Such are the truthful ones; such are the God-fearing.” “There is no compulsion in religion, the right direction is clearly distinguished from the wrong." (Quran 2:256). “O you who believe! Be afraid of Allaah, and be with those who are true (in word and deeds).” [al-Tawbah 9:119] (Quran 49:10)- “"BELIEVERS ARE BUT Brothers” “That is why We ordained for the Children of Israel that whoever takes a life-unless as a punishment for murder or mischief in the land-it will be as if they killed all of humanity; and whoever saves a life, it will be as if they saved all of humanity.1 ˹Although˺ Our messengers already came to them with clear proofs, many of them still transgressed afterwards through the land.”(Quran 5:32) Qur’an 2:190: “And fight in the way of God with those who fight with you, but aggress not: God loves not the aggressors.” (2:11)”When they are told, “Do not spread corruption in the land,” they reply, “We are only peace-makers!” (2:12)”Indeed, it is they who are the corruptors, but they fail to perceive it.” “As for those who repent, believe, and do good, it is they who will be admitted into Paradise, never being denied any reward”(19:60)(the importance in worshipping Allah is set on what you put your urges into in thoughts and actions as well) (O you who believe) . . . help one another in piety and goodness and do not help one another in sin and aggression Suratul Mai’dah (No. 5), Ayat 2 “Speak Justice” Quran (6:152) ˹In time,˺ Allah may bring about goodwill between you and those of them you ˹now˺ hold as enemies. For Allah is Most Capable. And Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful. Allah does not forbid you from dealing kindly and fairly with those who have neither fought nor driven you out of your homes. Surely Allah loves those who are fair.”(Quran 60:7-8)
@@dzvw8840 no, of course not. the non muslims are below you. they are but like cattle. lol. anyway, do you think a caliph should rule the wolrd? and if so, should he kill all the druze likewise ruling like ibn taimayya that they are apostates?
Now this is quite a complex subject and requires nuance. There's nothing black and white about it. This is the area of the Mujtahids i.e. people who are qualified in Islamic and other sciences and endowed with sagacity or have developed the ability to do Ijtihad i.e. independent reasoning and judgement. Not every Mufassir (exegete) or Islamic jurist or scholar is a Mujtahid. In fact it requires a council or a parliament of Mujtahids. The Fiqh of Jihad is different from the regular Fiqh which is mostly applicable during peace time. Remember, context is king. Even Islamic commandments, rulings and injunctions aren't exception to this rule. A lot of Fiqh develops as a result of circumstances. It's true that the punishment for theft is chopping off of the hands up to the wrist. But this rule gets suspended during tough times like famines etc. This is not a simple topic. Mujtahids are required to deal with such subject-matters. The laymen shouldn't begin to form opinions without deeper knowledge.
Very good presentation. Yet, many generalisations, lack legal-theoretical nuance. There is no consideration of necessity (ḍarūrah) and duress (ikrāh) in Islamic law. There is no consideration of necessity dictating permissibility, consideration of duress and collateral damage. Much of what was said is not as simple as the speaker may like to believe and also some scholars who permit an exception (rukhsah) to the norm ('azimah) under certain circumstances, such as dire necessity, harm principle, etc are not all foolish. This level of analysis is insufficient for such complex issues.
I wonder if CZcams will allow those with the opposing point of view to respond to this video?? Of course not, because they will be blocked and erased 😅 ،،
How many people have you seen do violent acts because of a lack of belief(atheism)? 0. Actions are not based on your lack of beliefs. How many people have you seen do violent acts because of what they believe(theism)? 100s Actions are based on your beliefs.
I pray to our One True Lord to guide us to the truth. Amen The One Creator of everything says: (111. God has purchased from the believers their lives and their properties in exchange for Paradise. They fight in God’s way, and they kill and get killed. It is a promise binding on Him in the Torah, and the Injeel , and the Quran. And who is more true to his promise than God? So rejoice in making such an exchange-that is the supreme triumph.) Surah 9 at-tawbah ayah 111 from the Holy Quran the last book revealed by our Creator Rabbuna Allah Almighty to the last of his prophets Muhammad (peace be upon them all) May our Beautiful Designer the Most High have mercy on us. Ameen
Holy Quran 3:55 ------------------ إِذْ قَالَ اللَّهُ يَا عِيسَىٰ إِنِّي مُتَوَفِّيكَ وَرَافِعُكَ إِلَيَّ وَمُطَهِّرُكَ مِنَ الَّذِينَ كَفَرُوا وَجَاعِلُ الَّذِينَ اتَّبَعُوكَ فَوْقَ الَّذِينَ كَفَرُوا إِلَىٰ يَوْمِ الْقِيَامَةِ ۖ ثُمَّ إِلَيَّ مَرْجِعُكُمْ فَأَحْكُمُ بَيْنَكُمْ فِيمَا كُنتُمْ فِيهِ تَخْتَلِفُونَ God said, “O Jesus, I am terminating your life, and raising you to Me, and clearing you of those who disbelieve. And I will make those who follow you superior to those who disbelieve, until the Day of Resurrection. Then to Me is your return; then I will judge between you regarding what you were disputing. ( And we know who is obedient to all prophets now? Muslims !!) So insha Allah momineen will be the victorious, who worship only one God.
In 1930, Soviet Marxist theoretician Liutsian I. Klimovich, in his lecture “Did Muhammad Exist?”, argued the time gap between Muhammad’s alleged lifetime and the first written sources was so huge that we cannot suppose that any of the information given in these sources is authentic; that nothing is known for sure about the historical Muhammad, and that it is even likely that he never existed. Quite consequently, Klimovich assumed that the Koran was not Muhammad’s work but the product of a whole group of authors. Muhammad was created by later historians as a myth, designed to explain the emergence of the Islamic community out of the Hanif movement. The prophet was an invention to cover up early Islam’s character as a social protest movement. In 2003, Walter Williams, in his The Historical Origin of Islam, asserted that Muhammad is the brainchild of Arabian scholar Ibn Arabi (1165-1240) who was the main individual involved in the morphing and mythologizing of the making of the prophet Muhammad; he also shows that the the Koran is a mixture of Jewish literature, put together by Jewish scholars to include the Torah and the New Testament Gospels.
What is the "combatant" status of (illegal) settlers given that their seizing of Palestinian homes is backed up by military violence? For example, if Mahmoud and Farieda were to put out the belongings and furniture of Bob and Susan from Brooklyn who had moved into their home, there is no doubt that the response of the IOF would be deadly. Similarly, settlements have been built on the soil for which Rachel Corrie was murdered. I would posit that settlers are combatants-by-proxy.
Why don't these eminent people realize that the cause of violence and terrorism is political and not religious. The verses about Jihad were referring to the wars when Islam as a new Religion was under attack by those who attempted to stifle it and nip it in the bud so to speak. In modern times Terrorist acts by Muslims were the result of a reaction against colonialism and exploitation. Those weak freedom fighters and rebels needed some 'weapon' to help those oppose the ones with arms and money and political power... So they sought the help of the Creator , cherry picking verses from the Qur'an to enlist others to fight on their side. It must be said also that there is an Islamic duty for believers to stand up against exploitation and injustice. Palestine is a prime example.
Nop , it's because of religion So you're telling me that I S I S conquered half of Iraq and Syria just because of political reasons ? No dude it was completely religious
Whoever wants for the sake of politics does not choose Sh**ria and Cali**hate for his project, otherwise he will gather nearly 90 countries against himself, as happened in Syria and Iraq 🤦♂️🤣
No sane person chooses an Islamic project for the sake of politics, otherwise the world will gather against him, like what happened in Syria and Iraq 🤦♂️🤣
You right 😅 And prepare against them whatever you are able of power and of steeds of war[456] by which you may terrify the enemy of Allāh and your enemy and others besides them whom you do not know [but] whom Allāh knows. And whatever you spend in the cause of Allāh will be fully repaid to you, and you will not be wronged. Al-Anfā 60
what is the straight path. those who worship the lord. the one god only. the crooked path was followed by folks trying to replace the one god with the opium of the secular atheists. weed alcohol cocaine Xanax. always ends in early graves for them. Elvis. Lisa Marie. grandson ben. Ann heche. Matthew Perry. Aaron carter his sister. etc
Why you read jahad in Quran in some places because the original meaning is sevice and struggle .but iin that context strive and struggle could be anything in life ,with things in life is every thing is strive and struggle so war is also a struggle and you have to strive for too to win any war. So jehaid only only means in Arabic language is strive for some thing and struggle for something that is an original meaning of the word because you slosh have to strive and struggle to win a war in that context it is stated in the Quran. This dose not mean its is named to fight is jehaid. In fact real word in Arabic for killing is Qutal . Qutal is used for wars too .see in Arabic language in one word has several meanings used in different context as well as different scenarios. So in that respect we can't pinpoint one meaning for one thing only .it had several meanings .
that is the problem with interpretation, it is open to interpretation. he and harris/ibn laden reading the same texts and drawing the exact opposite conclusions reminds me of the dress some people saw as gold and white and others as black and blue. or if you google 'right brain, left brain test' you will see an image of a woman [warning, not sure if it a haram image or not. if i had to guess, haram. lol] spinning. some people see her spinning clockwise, others counterclockwise. i like fareed, but it is always funny when muslims try that line. 'well you see things as the terrorist do' [implying you are a terrorist or at least have a terrorist mentality]. the point it the texts are clearly poorly written if two people can draw the exact opposite conclusion. if you don't want innocent women and children killed in warfare, you should condemn it WHENEVER it happens. not allow it one battle and chastise in after another. i will say this guy was at least honest enough to say you can't TARGET innocents, unlike most muslims who just say you can't kill innocents. so then the question is, does a suicide bomber necessarily TARGET innocents? and of course, who is innocent?
The quran is not open to interpretation. This is what you non muslims fail to understand. You try to tell us how our religion is supposed to work or whatever. We do not want you to come and tell us what the quran is or is not. You wanna learn? Fine. Otherwise shut up
The texts are in Classical Arabic. English translations are not the Quran. It’s easy to misinterpret if you don’t have a strong grasp of Classical Arabic (the Arabic of 1400 years ago) For this reason, scholars have discouraged laypersons from seeking legal answers from the Quran unguided as comprehension of the text requires expert interpretation and contextualization. In fact, most Muslim sects agree that verses of the Quran can only properly be understood when read in light of other Quranic verses and the Prophetic model, as well as the interpretations and legal implementations of the ulema (learned scholars) In our religion Ijtihad (independent reasoning of the text) is for the ulema (learned scholars) not the layman. The folks you mention aren’t allowed to have an interpretative opinion, their opinion (regardless of what it is) is invalid. Those trained in Ijtihad can have legitimate differences or opinion. This is why you’re not at war with nearly I/5th of the planet [2 billion Muslims don’t do their own Ijtihad (interpretative reasoning)] Both you and the religiously illiterate fanatical extremists approach the religion with the same mentality. This is why you share and promote their false radical interpretation. We consider you no different than a person who reads a medical book, then thinks they can perform brain surgery. Nay, believes they’re qualified to teach brain surgery (&) refute the medical community.
@@anushirvan6670 are you talking to me? anyway, can scholars through ijtihad forgo hadd punishments? a muslim once told me a qadi ruled a woman had been pregnant since before her husband left for jihad 14 months ago [maybe longer]. is that 'reasonable' to you? what do you think of the great islamic scholar [mentioned in the lecture] ibn taimayya saying the druze should be killed as apostates? so if the koran is so dangerous when translated, why put out all these translations and distribute them?
I wonder if CZcams will allow those with the opposing point of view to respond to this video?? Of course not, because they will be blocked and erased 😅 Islamic scholars do not know such a thing as civilians. Rather, the term is a belligerent infidel (who has no covenant) and a covenant infidel
Yes they right jihad is not what you understood the real jihad what they have understood when prophet said come to jihad his deciple came with sword and weapon and quran has cleared it many times and I would say you guys are sophescating jihad
what? torture is prohibited? i suppose if you are using the word only in the attempt to extract information. clearly, torture is prescribed in the koran see 24:2 for example. and of course you have rajam [stoning] in the hadiths.
@@TruRedCRIME legal or not, that is the definition of torture. tor·ture /ˈtôrCHər/ noun the action or practice of inflicting severe pain or suffering on someone as a punishment or in order to force them to do or say something.
@@user-jv4zb6zu7w No As per the definition you yourself posted, it clearly states that torture is when there is a motive to get thr subject to say or do something Penalising is not torture, may it be physical or monetary.
If anyone, including Paul, thinks that an academic who is teaching at a western university in 2024 has complete freedom to speak about this topic then you are very very naive.
Admin you discussed religious wars. but cleverly you are ignoring the verse on war with Jizya tax which is mentioned in surah tawba verse 9:29. please explain the verse honestly from traditional famous tafsir. do not apply arguments like the mutazilites on the verses of the creator. Reply please admin
What do you want to know about the Jizya tax? But first, just out of curiosity what country do you live in and what percentage of your income is taxed by that country? I take an interest in taxation issues.
In the verse it says: fight them UNTIL.. It is simply saying how long should the fighting last. It does not say "go and attack". The Goraun already says: "fight those who fight you and do not transgress."
@@adnanbosnian5051 Different people have different interpretation in modern time of this verse. but i think according traditional interpretation fight with them untill establish muslim rule over the whole world. example rashidun chilapath ruled persia,rome, egypt. ottoman & abbasi empire use this verse same away. sorry for my bad english
Equating Ji'had 🤧🤧with Terror'ism was the biggest achievement of western Media and Hollywood 😢
Yeah Brother❤. They Demonize Us(Muslim) And Our Faith(Islam) Also Our Culture. Alhumdulillah Everything Getting better more and more people are converting Islam. It's fastest growing religion right now after all of their propaganda.❤🥰.
tbf Islamophobia actually promote islam. sometimes their propaganda is so ridiculous, people start learning the real islam.
Bin Laden is a Western Creation of a Role model Muslim. Whereas Bin Laden meant nothing to the majority of the Muslim world. Had Bin laden followed the Quran then he would have established schools & Hospital in Afghanistan instead of armed resistance.
rather be feared than loved by ku far degenerates
@@anyq_CS Agree but heart ❤️ feels pain... When they equate our teaching humanity with Voilance 🥲
Absolutely blown away by this insightful interview! Professor Mohammad Khalil's deep knowledge and articulate explanations on the subject of Jihad, Radicalism, and the New Atheism are truly remarkable. This discussion is an invaluable resource for anyone seeking to understand these complex topics better. Thank you both for this enlightening exchange!
❤absolutely CORRECT
May Allah increase knowledge of these Islamic scolers ❤❤❤
what do you think that knowledge should be? i was reading how the great islamic scholar ibn taimayya ruled that the druze should be killed as apostates. do you agree?
scholars*****
@@snakejuce what do you think the scholars should know? what do you think of the world renown scholar al-munajjid's take on jihad [of the sword]?
@@user-jv4zb6zu7w I commented to correct a spelling error, not to engage with clowns as yourself. May you forever seethe at the existence and growth of Islam. May it consume you to your core.
Aameen
I was always looking an answer to this accusation. Ummah needs more men like you.
INSHA Allah
This is a really brilliant piece of scholarship. The best thing about this is that not only does it try to address the concerns of new atheists, Sam Haris in particular, it also tries to inform the Muslim consciousness about the subject of Jihad and terrorism.
ALHAMDULILAH.
So far - Its an excellent lecture- Prof. Mohammad Hassan Khalil: has put together most popular bias against Muslims & Islam. Now we need to see distinctions between Islamic Laws & Muslim behavior and non muslim perceptions.
do you support the imposition of sharia under a caliphate? if so, how would atheists be treated?
@@user-jv4zb6zu7wVery well. Read the histories of Prophet Muhammad who never forced anyone or any group into the fold of Islam. Read The Treaty of Medina.
The real question for today is how will fascist atheists treat people of Faith-the plurality and singularity of Faiths while imposing their Will onto Faith Families?
@@kausamsalam8543 cannot force other to accept Islam. But forced to live humiliating lives as dhimmis. They are not equal to muslims, have lower status and treated unfairly. In a western society, a muslim is equal to a non muslim. That's why u all run here
@@kausamsalam8543 i've read the treaty of medina. not a bad document for the 7th century. i know quite a bit about the life of muhammad. so you think an angel came to him to tell him the banu nadir were going to kill him? what do you think of his response when asked about the killing of the women and children of the polytheists?
what do you think of case out of Indonesia were they imprisoned a buddhist woman for asking the mosque near here house to turn their loudspeaker down?
"how will fascist atheists treat people of Faith" well if they are fascists, probably not too well. i've never heard of a good fascist? oh yeah. do you consider abu bark, omar, uthman and ali to be 'righty guided' caliphs?
Muslims fill European jails for sex crimes, the islamic world is full of child predators, homosexuality is rampant in islamic places like Pakistan and Saudi... denying the size and scope of the damage done by islam to muslims is criminal.
this is a wonderful lecture, thank you Paul and many thanks to Prof. Mohammad
One of the best talks on concepts of Jihad that I ever heard.Thankyou so much both of you for enlightening us with the true teachings of Islam in this regard❤
MASHALLAH
The truth about jihad cannot appear on CZcams for sure because it will be banned and deleted 🙁
Suicide bombing, which is part of violence, is also prohibited as understood from this verse: “O you who believe, do not consume each other properties illicitly; only mutually acceptable transactions are permitted. You shall not kill yourselves. God is Merciful toward you.” (Qur’an, 4:29)
It's not suicide in the sense of a depression hopelessness type of deleting yourself, a so called suicide mission or self sacrifice mission strictly in a military context is like a last resort type tactic used in certain circumstances. Of course I'm talking about strictly in a military sense not attacking civilians. Battles in centuries gone by had very high risk missions where one or two were sent into the enemy camp, it was almost guaranteed they would be killed if caught, would you call this a suicide mission?
right. but didn't muhammad on occasion break his own rules of warfare? i've read islamic scholars who have argued suicide attacks are needed do to the muslim being so disadvantaged by size and/or technology.
how is it you think muslims are in favor of suicide bombing and the killing of women and children?
@@siemprestruggle9272 I think deliberately killing yourself whatever circumstances is what is suicide. Which is haram. If you fight a battle that you know you're going to lose that isn't suicide.
funny how the worst places to be christian are all Islamic lands
@@siemprestruggle9272no, i wouldnt call that a suicide mission.
Thats a high risk mission.
But your intention is to get out alive.
If you go there with the intention to get killed and getting killed or blowing yourself up is your only mission then id say thats a suicide mission
JAK brother Paul for all your efforts. May Allah open your path to Janna as you help open our eyes into all the important topics surrounding the recent events in the holy land of Palestine.
Aameen
Very interesting, Baraka Allahu feekum
God bless you both
You too
What an excellent podcast. I look forward to seeing more of from this esteemed scholar
Thank you very much for bringing such high quality content, this interview was very educational
Jazakh Allah Khair
Its actually amazing how our scholars hundred of years ago were discussing these issues way before 9/11 even happened.
The problem with religion is that's vague where many of the things it says can be applied to different wars/actions......which means you never know exactly which war/action it's talking about because it can be applied to multiple.
How many times have christians claimed X event was the last coming of Jesus. Religion is vague on purpose.
@@scottholder4431 The Bible has changed the Quran has not, how about you read it without assuming with little knowledge
@@abdullahnadeem1823 The meaning of the quran changes to match what science has already learned.
@@scottholder4431 Ok buddy, keep assuming. Doesn't look good on you
@@abdullahnadeem1823 LMAO! You can't prove me wrong.
May Allah reward these brothers ameen. May Allah forgive and accept us ameen.
Thank you, Paul, for delivering such an insightful and engaging lecture., and of course, a heartfelt appreciation to Prof. Mohammad as well.
Great presentation for an interesting subject. Thank you BT.
I’m from the US and I want to thank Brother Paul and all the Blogging Theology team for all their work. May Allah bless all of you!
Masha Allah! Very important video! Jazak Allah Khair. May Allah(SWT) grand all of you Hannah, amen.
Aameen
I absolutely love your interviews. I would love to see you speak with my teacher after I took my shahadah. He has supported many new Muslims on their journeys and i think it would be especially interesting if you interview or spoke with him. I would love to put you in contact with him and see where the chips fall?
Masha ALLAH
MASHALLAH
MASHASATAN
Thank you 😍
May Almighty Allah Bless and Reward Both of You in this Life and in the Hereafter.
Deception - all over.
Ameen
One of the most enjoying episodes thanks dr Paul Williams and professor Mohammad Hassan Khalil
Thank you!!
Innocent people are victims of violence. Killing innocent people is prohibited and condemned (Qur’an, 17:33; 6:151; 25:68).
but allowed in the sunnah. the hadith in the 19th book of muslim, 4321.
@user-jv4zb6zu7w
Aḥaadiiṯ (singular: Ḥadiiṯ) are collections of men's hearsays / talks written down that have no connections to Rasuulu-LLaahi and Nabii’u-LLaahi Muḥammad ﷺ and his companions whatsoever!
@@samantarmaxammadsaciid5156
Not true. The sunnah is comprised of the Quran, the Hadith, the tafsir, and the biography of Muhammad. In Sunni Islam, doctrine is derived from these four pieces. Most Muslims in the world are Sunni.
@antichrist.superstar
The sunnat you are talking is Humanity’s Ḥadiiṯ whether religious or non-religious, past or present, it's open to debate or problematic, however the Qurʼaan despite Humanity’s problematic writings / faulty copying processes so-called the Qiraa’aat (variant readings) of the Qur’aan, still the Qur’aan is unmatched because it is about the creation (Who? The Creator of all: Ar-Raḥmaan / Allaah < Al-Ilaah) / evolution (the matching self-contained processes of the formation from within of "Kun! Fa-Yakuunu = Be! Thus, he is" as Allaah is Non-Physical Infinite, for that creating Aadam with His two hands is linguistically selective representation of the dual alignment of the Creator and the selected created symbolism within the entire creation corresponding to Az-Zawj = the Pair / the Couple, initiated from Min Nafsin Waaḥidatin = from Single Self, and in turn from Ruuḥu-lQudusi or Ruuḥu-LLaahi) of the Humanity (central representation of all earthly and the spacial or the sky out of which is formed and in which the earth exists) as a singular (= Aadam in the Jannat) and as a plural in this Ad-Dunyaa = the Lower / the Nearer (Life), hence the Qur’aan being our path to the Nearer Life towards the Creator of all: Allaah, in the Aakhirat of the original Earth Jannat for Last (Final) Home as opposed to remaining in this earth of the Lower Hellish Life!
And that guide that is the Qur’aan through Rasuulu-LLaahi and Nabii’u-LLaahi Muḥammad ﷺ as Allaah’s Ḥadiiṯ, being about ourselves and how we should take Allaah’s Ḥadiiṯ as our guide = Sunnatu-LLaahi!
Simplicity = "Complexity within" as one = Duality!
@@samantarmaxammadsaciid5156 are you a koran alone muslim? if so you are in the great minority.
May Allah bless and reward you brothers for all your effort, I am truly grateful for the material which inshallah will give knowledge to muslims and non-muslim in this great channel
Woow, very good presentation. Jazakallah brothers
excellent lecture
I love reading books, that are readable.
you sholuld read the book of jihad by ibn nuhaas. he says things like this:
Definition of Jihad:
The linguistic meaning:
• Lisan Alarab: Fighting the enemy. It involves using all effort in
words and deeds.
• Mujam matn al lughah: Jihad is commonly used to refer to waging
war for the sake of Al-haqq (the truth)
In Islamic terminology it means:
Calling towards the true religion and fighting with one’s soul and wealth
against those who reject it. (Al Inayah Sharh al Hidayah (Hanafi))
Jihad is fighting. (Al Sheerazi in al Muhadhab (Shafi’i)
Jihad is a Muslim waging war agianst a non-Muslim who has no peace
agreement with Muslims and the fighting is for the sake of the word of
Allah to prevail. Jihad is also fighting the non-Muslim who attacks Muslim
territory and it is also the Muslims attacking the non-Muslims in their land.
(Mawahib al Jaleel fi Sharh Mukhtasar Khalil (Maliki))
Jihad is a cure for the individual and the society. It cures the individual by
delivering him from the sickness of disbelief to the wellbeing of Islam.
Disbelieving in Allah is the greatest disease of all and the most destructive
on all humanity, while Islam is the complete cure. Jihad cures the society
by eliminating the source of corruption and oppression. Leaving the
disbeliever unharmed increases the disease and strengthens it and allows
the cancer to spread. Therefore Islam cannot flourish and Muslims cannot
live in peace unless the disease is cured. If it is possible to cure the disease
by using a medicine then be it. Otherwise the infected portion must be
amputated even though the amputation could cause pain and suffering for
the body. But then no one could claim that the amputation cruel or
inhumane. It was necessary for the survival of the body. That is precisely
the role of Jihad in Islam. First the message should be conveyed through
peaceful means. If the peaceful course is exhausted and it did not bear its
fruits, the bearers of the truth would need to draw their swords and fight in
order for the word of Allah to prevail.
Many people misunderstanding meaning
Of Jihad,for example:
A father who earns a living for his children and wife at the risk of live or death is called"JIHAD".
A mother struggling to give birth to her baby at risk of life or death is called:"JIHAD" SO...
Jihad can be interpreted as doing good deeds in the way of God truly, even at risk of death.
should arabic come up with some more words, lol. so a kaffir is both a farmer and an infidel?
in the west when we talk of jihad, we clearly mean jihad of the sword. so do you support an islamic caliphate inviting nations to islam, and if they refuse you send in dai [people to proslytize] and if the nation also refuses, you attack them to spread islam? wage jihad?
Nope.
That's an incorrect and dishonest interpretation created by the liberals.
We shouldn't do that.
Even when you read hadith books, you often come to jihad in war and battles 😉
@@user-hi5xq7nx2y Yep, but modern warfare is not jihad. This is the part people fail to understand.
@@user-hi5xq7nx2y If you read hadith then you surely know jihad is impossible today cause
Women, children and non fighting men can't be harmed or taken hostages
Jihad mean struggle
Assalamu Alakom 👋 All Friends Brothers And Sisters Familys May Allah Protect You All Ameen 🤲
Excellent lecture remarkable distinctions were made: very informative. In my opinion Muslims need to follow the Quran to change their misperceived understanding of the Quran: Muslim Perceptions: in the non muslims world are based on behavior of ignorant muslims.
So far - Its an excellent lecture- Prof. Mohammad Hassan Khalil: has put together most popular bias against Muslims & Islam. Now we need to see distinctions between Islamic Laws & Muslim behavior and non muslim perceptions.
Well observed Sir!
was ibn nuhaas an ignorant muslim? i thought he was a great scholar. have you read his book of jihad?
Never read his book - If he contradicts the Quran then it is his error: Quran explicitly explains terms of Jihad. Bottomline is no one scholar has the last Word: Al Quran is the Last Word. May God guide us to the Truth. @@user-jv4zb6zu7w
@@user-jv4zb6zu7w what did he say?
MashaAllah 😊
MASHALLAH.
MASHASATAN
A reminder : Jihad it is from root JHD > JD expresses intensity, and the H is the Ideation. Another way to understand etymologically this word : J means to gather, and HD is the path. Jihad is about to focus on the Way, ignoring futilities.
In Islamic terminology it means:
Calling towards the true religion and fighting with one’s soul and wealth
against those who reject it. (Al Inayah Sharh al Hidayah (Hanafi))
Jihad is fighting. (Al Sheerazi in al Muhadhab (Shafi’i)
Jihad is a Muslim waging war agianst a non-Muslim who has no peace
agreement with Muslims and the fighting is for the sake of the word of
Allah to prevail. Jihad is also fighting the non-Muslim who attacks Muslim
territory and it is also the Muslims attacking the non-Muslims in their land.
(Mawahib al Jaleel fi Sharh Mukhtasar Khalil (Maliki))
Jihad is a cure for the individual and the society. It cures the individual by
delivering him from the sickness of disbelief to the wellbeing of Islam.
Disbelieving in Allah is the greatest disease of all and the most destructive
on all humanity, while Islam is the complete cure. Jihad cures the society
Even when you read hadith books, you often come to jihad in war and battles 😉
،
@@user-hi5xq7nx2y Don't have time to give you some lessons, but right, Salaam and Islam don't mean peace or submission.
Maashaa Allah,, paul williams,,, ❤❤❤ you my brother ,,for the sake of Allah Subhanah wata,allaa
It’s the opposite for me, I feel Quran and Allah through it, are too generous and too forgiving. Very merciful
As soon as America 🇺🇸 left Iraq 🇮🇶 and Afghanistan 🇦🇫, all the suicide bombings stopped. Makes you think 🤔.
Alhamdulillah...
Ассаламу Алайкум ВарахматуЛлахи вабаракатуху. Из Москва.
Thanks for lecture. I really apreciate it. But better of western muslim scholars focused on Palestine status today through politics way.
Because so sad that our brothers and sisters in Palestine now struggle to eat, drink and sleep well. Bomb everywhere. Food and Aid can't enter the border. 😢😢
Our top issues must be how to ceasefire now.
#freepalestine
#ceasefirenow
#ceasefire
Good. Truth is only god
Although I was at first pleased to see the emergence of the New Atheists, I was not particularly impressed with their arguments. Their books were very important antidotes to the romantic notions held by people who had only encountered liberal varieties of religion.; but, they weren't very deep thinkers and did not get to the root causes of the atrocities for which religions have been responsible .
I had been frustrated by the dismissive attitudes of the left, progressives, and liberals toward the religious right in America, and hoped that the New Atheism would provide a much needed antidote to such misapprehensions, but was soon disappointed to realize that they had set their sights on Islam.
Some twenty years later, with the MAGA crowd standing a good chance of winning another American election, I am more convinced than ever that it is Christian fanatics, and not Muslim fanatics, who pose the biggest threat to the world today, although the Zionist fanatics are running a close second with their talk of eradicating the Amalekites.
Speaking of which, I wonder how the New Atheists are reacting to this pronouncements. They know who the Amalekites are because they routinely used that genocide as an example of God's evil in the Old Testament.
New Atheism is dead, yet for some reason Muslims are the only people still talking about them. I don't hear anything about them, at all anymore.
@@thedude9941 I hear about Sam Harris from time to time. Don't pay much attention to him though.
It exposes their strategic and inconsistent ‘morality.’ Their imperial-western exceptionalism and orientalist undertones reveal their Islamophobia and the blindfold they intentionally utilize on the Zionist fanatic, Christian fanatic and even the atheist fanatic
A lot A lot of people made a name and fortune for themselves, attacking Islam, unlike any religion on earth. Why is that?
The perspective that if there is an exception to a rule, it calls into question the validity or applicability of that rule in general, weirdly enough, is thrown out the window whenever it's about Islam teachings and regulations.
One shouldn't be sad about this reality, because it is actually helping, by the will of Allah, Islam reach people with hearts and souls ready and open to accept it. It is prophesied, and it is the proof that the only truth is the dean of Allah.
👌🏻
"Jihad, Radicalism, and the New Atheism" interesting grouping.
Can you make a programme with some of your experts what exactly happened and still happening in all over Kurdistan?
IMO, the hearts of Harris, Dawkins, Maher, Hirsi Ali, Petersen, Shapiro and co have been blinded and hardened by Allah.
❤❤❤
Allah reward you with goodness for your work, especially for pointing out the clear contradictions of his beliefs and statements. It's hard for me to even hear these arguments against Islam by Sam Harris (who continues to make money by bashing Islam, put into a position of influence for a reason, with media/Hollywood connections due to his Jewish mother who created tv series The Golden Girls) because I don't believe the official mainstream media accounts of certain events like Sept 11. But it is important for all Muslims to seek knowledge on topics from trusted Scholars and to not act based on one's own desires.
يَا مُقَلِّبَ القُلُوْبِ ثَبِّتْ قَلْبِي عَلَى دِيْنِكَ
ثبتكم الله علي الحق يا اخوان ونصركم الله في دعوتكم لدين الله
وَمَنْ أَحْسَنُ قَوْلًا مِّمَّن دَعَآ إِلَى ٱللَّهِ وَعَمِلَ صَـٰلِحًا وَقَالَ إِنَّنِى مِنَ ٱلْمُسْلِمِينَ
And whose words are better than someone who calls others' to Allah, does good, and says, "I am truly one of those who submit."?
Assalamu’alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh
السَّلاَمُ عَلَيْكُمْ وَرَحْمَةُ اللهِ وَبَرَكَاتُهُ
ALLAH is saying
Surely those who believe and do good, their Lord will guide them to Paradise through their faith, rivers will flow under their feet in the Gardens of Bliss,
in which their prayer will be, “Glory be to You, O ALLAH! and their greeting will be, “Peace!” and their closing prayer will be, “All praise is for ALLAH Lord of all worlds!”
I truly hoped that Paul will talk about atheists that criticize Woke culture in US like Helen Pluckrose, Peter Boghossian and James Lindsay
“Were all mankind to come together and wish to produce the like of the Qur’an, they would never succeed, however much they aided each other”. (17:88)
When is Mr.Paul going to appear on Hamza's Den?
Who cares what anyone thinks or says about Islam. Muslim, I am to the core.
Of course, do not impose your religion on people and force people because they are not Muslims.
Freedom for Palestine
Share this amongst Muslims bros!
Just give me the minhaj(Islam Iman and Ihsan) of the Salaf. And a cold glass of ahlusSunnah wal jamaah 🥰
Can you recommend me book on marriage and nikah brother paul.
Nikah is marriage so its like saying can you recommend a book on marriage and marriage 😂
Thank you for idiotic comment however everyone is not aware about it. without putting a laughing emoji you could you recommanded a book.@@ismailtareq3222
Why aren’t brothers like this going on russel brand and Joe Rogan streams as well?
They don't have the courage invite
@@FarmanSeema there doesn’t need to be an invitation from them , just ask them nicely and openly online if they’d be willing to allow truthful intellectuals to clear the air with what’s happening on religion and why this “accordion” thing is a forceful endeavor that doesn’t take in what the majority of Muslims have to say
But as American Muslims we’ve trusted the wrong people to which it has ruined our reputation to be the same as the LGBTQ people
60% of Muslim women in America are giving sides with LGBTQ which is no different than a man /woman made religion that looks over reality
When they’re too afraid of the simply saying that EVERYONE/EVERY THING that exists comes from where gravity, density, and etc is all produced and given along with gasses and particles which lead back to THE WILL himself.
“O you who believe! You are forbidden
to inherit women against their will.
Nor should you treat them with harshness,
that you may take away part of the dowry
you have given them - except when
they have become guilty of open lewdness
On the contrary live with them
on a footing of kindness and equity.
If you take a dislike to them,
it may be that you dislike something
bad Allah will bring about through it
a great deal of good. (Quran, 4:19)
“O believers! Wine, gambling, idols and divining arrows are only a dirty work of Satan. Avoid them wholly so that you may gain true success.
Satan only wants to sow enmity and hate among you by wine and gambling and to turn you away from remembering God and from praying. So will you stop (doing wrong)?”
~ Quran 5:90-91
(Quran 26:183) - “and do not deprive people of their due and do not commit abuse on earth, spreading corruption.”
(2:177) “Righteousness does not consist in turning your faces towards the east or towards the west; true righteousness consists in believing in Allah and the Last Day, the angels, the Book and the Prophets, and in giving away one’s property in love of Him to one’s kinsmen, the orphans, the poor and the wayfarer, and to those who ask for help, and in freeing the necks of slaves, and in establishing Prayer and dispensing the Zakah. True righteousness is attained by those who are faithful to their promise once they have made it and by those who remain steadfast in adversity and affliction and at the time of battle (between Truth and falsehood). Such are the truthful ones; such are the God-fearing.”
“There is no compulsion in religion, the right direction is clearly distinguished from the wrong." (Quran 2:256).
“O you who believe! Be afraid of Allaah, and be with those who are true (in word and deeds).”
[al-Tawbah 9:119]
(Quran 49:10)- “"BELIEVERS ARE BUT Brothers”
“That is why We ordained for the Children of Israel that whoever takes a life-unless as a punishment for murder or mischief in the land-it will be as if they killed all of humanity; and whoever saves a life, it will be as if they saved all of humanity.1 ˹Although˺ Our messengers already came to them with clear proofs, many of them still transgressed afterwards through the land.”(Quran 5:32)
Qur’an 2:190: “And fight in the way of God with those who fight with you, but aggress not: God loves not the aggressors.”
(2:11)”When they are told, “Do not spread corruption in the land,” they reply, “We are only peace-makers!”
(2:12)”Indeed, it is they who are the corruptors, but they fail to perceive it.”
“As for those who
repent, believe, and do good, it is they who will be admitted into
Paradise, never being denied any reward”(19:60)(the importance in worshipping Allah is set on what you put your urges into in thoughts and actions as well)
(O you who believe) . . . help one another in piety and goodness and do not help one another in sin and aggression Suratul Mai’dah (No. 5), Ayat 2
“Speak Justice”
Quran (6:152)
˹In time,˺ Allah may bring about goodwill between you and those of them you ˹now˺ hold as enemies. For Allah is Most Capable. And Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful. Allah does not forbid you from dealing kindly and fairly with those who have neither fought nor driven you out of your homes. Surely Allah loves those who are fair.”(Quran 60:7-8)
@@Israel-IS-Socialism "But as American Muslims we’ve trusted the wrong people " like who?
Why bother? Do you have a need to seek approval from non-Muslims? That's what we call a colonized mind.
@@dzvw8840 no, of course not. the non muslims are below you. they are but like cattle. lol.
anyway, do you think a caliph should rule the wolrd? and if so, should he kill all the druze likewise ruling like ibn taimayya that they are apostates?
Now this is quite a complex subject and requires nuance. There's nothing black and white about it. This is the area of the Mujtahids i.e. people who are qualified in Islamic and other sciences and endowed with sagacity or have developed the ability to do Ijtihad i.e. independent reasoning and judgement. Not every Mufassir (exegete) or Islamic jurist or scholar is a Mujtahid. In fact it requires a council or a parliament of Mujtahids. The Fiqh of Jihad is different from the regular Fiqh which is mostly applicable during peace time. Remember, context is king. Even Islamic commandments, rulings and injunctions aren't exception to this rule. A lot of Fiqh develops as a result of circumstances. It's true that the punishment for theft is chopping off of the hands up to the wrist. But this rule gets suspended during tough times like famines etc. This is not a simple topic. Mujtahids are required to deal with such subject-matters. The laymen shouldn't begin to form opinions without deeper knowledge.
Very good presentation. Yet, many generalisations, lack legal-theoretical nuance. There is no consideration of necessity (ḍarūrah) and duress (ikrāh) in Islamic law. There is no consideration of necessity dictating permissibility, consideration of duress and collateral damage. Much of what was said is not as simple as the speaker may like to believe and also some scholars who permit an exception (rukhsah) to the norm ('azimah) under certain circumstances, such as dire necessity, harm principle, etc are not all foolish. This level of analysis is insufficient for such complex issues.
“Had we not been muslim, we would still be calling for this war”
11:05, 19:22, 23:50
27:57, 30:45
31:33
35:05, 36:41
37:15
41:10
I wonder if CZcams will allow those with the opposing point of view to respond to this video?? Of course not, because they will be blocked and erased 😅 ،،
Man könnte sagen, die Liebe ist die erste und älteste Religion; Alles andere ist nur ein Abklatsch, ein Schatten davon.
🍀☀️🌍👍👽
I've been following this for some time and I saw how dishonest and bad faith Sam Harris is.
But man it's even worse than I thought.
He is an AIbot…like Zuckerberg.
Sam Harris is a Zionist extremist his anti Islam/Muslim is based on Palestinian and Israeli conflict he talks Palestinians like they are subhuman.
Was not crusade inquisition and Hershey jihad❤
wonder if CZcams will allow those with the opposing point of view to respond to this video?? Of course not, because they will be blocked and erased 😅
Let's remember that the US dropped two atomic bombs on the people of Hiroshima and Nagasaki
#boycottindia
#indiaout
Please stand with your Bangladeshi and
Maldives brothers 😢
India is doing the same that Israel does to Palestine
What's the conflict between India and Bangladesh?
52:02
💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝
ISLAM WILL SURELY PREVAIL!
the question is : does zaydan have 3 ucls in a row?
How many people have you seen do violent acts because of a lack of belief(atheism)? 0. Actions are not based on your lack of beliefs.
How many people have you seen do violent acts because of what they believe(theism)? 100s Actions are based on your beliefs.
I pray to our One True Lord to guide us to the truth. Amen
The One Creator of everything says:
(111. God has purchased from the believers their lives and their properties in exchange for Paradise. They fight in God’s way, and they kill and get killed. It is a promise binding on Him in the Torah, and the Injeel , and the Quran. And who is more true to his promise than God? So rejoice in making such an exchange-that is the supreme triumph.)
Surah 9 at-tawbah ayah 111 from the Holy Quran the last book revealed by our Creator Rabbuna Allah Almighty to the last of his prophets Muhammad (peace be upon them all)
May our Beautiful Designer the Most High have mercy on us. Ameen
arabic İmperialism lol
Holy Quran 3:55
------------------
إِذْ قَالَ اللَّهُ يَا عِيسَىٰ إِنِّي مُتَوَفِّيكَ وَرَافِعُكَ إِلَيَّ وَمُطَهِّرُكَ مِنَ الَّذِينَ كَفَرُوا وَجَاعِلُ الَّذِينَ اتَّبَعُوكَ فَوْقَ الَّذِينَ كَفَرُوا إِلَىٰ يَوْمِ الْقِيَامَةِ ۖ ثُمَّ إِلَيَّ مَرْجِعُكُمْ فَأَحْكُمُ بَيْنَكُمْ فِيمَا كُنتُمْ فِيهِ تَخْتَلِفُونَ
God said, “O Jesus, I am terminating your life, and raising you to Me, and clearing you of those who disbelieve. And I will make those who follow you superior to those who disbelieve, until the Day of Resurrection. Then to Me is your return; then I will judge between you regarding what you were disputing.
( And we know who is obedient to all prophets now? Muslims !!)
So insha Allah momineen will be the victorious, who worship only one God.
In 1930, Soviet Marxist theoretician Liutsian I. Klimovich, in his lecture “Did Muhammad Exist?”, argued the time gap between Muhammad’s alleged lifetime and the first written sources was so huge that we cannot suppose that any of the information given in these sources is authentic; that nothing is known for sure about the historical Muhammad, and that it is even likely that he never existed. Quite consequently, Klimovich assumed that the Koran was not Muhammad’s work but the product of a whole group of authors. Muhammad was created by later historians as a myth, designed to explain the emergence of the Islamic community out of the Hanif movement. The prophet was an invention to cover up early Islam’s character as a social protest movement.
In 2003, Walter Williams, in his The Historical Origin of Islam, asserted that Muhammad is the brainchild of Arabian scholar Ibn Arabi (1165-1240) who was the main individual involved in the morphing and mythologizing of the making of the prophet Muhammad; he also shows that the the Koran is a mixture of Jewish literature, put together by Jewish scholars to include the Torah and the New Testament Gospels.
Wonderful. Yet neither of those opinions hold weight. Good try though.
What is the "combatant" status of (illegal) settlers given that their seizing of Palestinian homes is backed up by military violence? For example, if Mahmoud and Farieda were to put out the belongings and furniture of Bob and Susan from Brooklyn who had moved into their home, there is no doubt that the response of the IOF would be deadly. Similarly, settlements have been built on the soil for which Rachel Corrie was murdered. I would posit that settlers are combatants-by-proxy.
Why don't these eminent people realize that the cause of violence and terrorism is political and not religious.
The verses about Jihad were referring to the wars when Islam as a new Religion was under attack by those who attempted to stifle it and nip it in the bud so to speak.
In modern times Terrorist acts by Muslims were the result of a reaction against colonialism and exploitation.
Those weak freedom fighters and rebels needed some 'weapon' to help those oppose the ones with arms and money and political power... So they sought the help of the Creator , cherry picking verses from the Qur'an to enlist others to fight on their side. It must be said also that there is an Islamic duty for believers to stand up against exploitation and injustice. Palestine is a prime example.
so when a muslim state violently executes an lgbt person, that is not inspired by religion?
Nop , it's because of religion
So you're telling me that I S I S conquered half of Iraq and Syria just because of political reasons ? No dude it was completely religious
Whoever wants for the sake of politics does not choose Sh**ria and Cali**hate for his project, otherwise he will gather nearly 90 countries against himself, as happened in Syria and Iraq 🤦♂️🤣
No sane person chooses an Islamic project for the sake of politics, otherwise the world will gather against him, like what happened in Syria and Iraq 🤦♂️🤣
Suicide is haram. Full stop.
For Allahs sake, things are different 😉
Sam Harris had not changed.
Jihad & Terrorism are two entirely different things---two ends of the spectrum!
You right 😅
And prepare against them whatever you are able of power and of steeds of war[456] by which you may terrify the enemy of Allāh and your enemy and others besides them whom you do not know [but] whom Allāh knows. And whatever you spend in the cause of Allāh will be fully repaid to you, and you will not be wronged.
Al-Anfā 60
His book name was "The End of Faith" in 2004. 😂😂😂😂😂😂What a joke 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
🆕 country name that I came up with!! Ad-dawlah Al-Jihad Al-Jizyah At-taqiyyah Al-Islamiyyah
i see new atheists as no different to child social media influencers who people take from even though they have no knowledge
what is the straight path. those who worship the lord. the one god only. the crooked path was followed by folks trying to replace the one god with the opium of the secular atheists. weed alcohol cocaine Xanax. always ends in early graves for them. Elvis. Lisa Marie. grandson ben. Ann heche. Matthew Perry. Aaron carter his sister. etc
In islam jihad means thrive and struggle in anything or in life too .
Infact quttal is fighting in wars .
First and foremost, fighting. This is the first thing that comes to mind, and I am an Arab, and I am telling you this
Even when you read hadith books, you often come to jihad in war and battles
Why you read jahad in Quran in some places because the original meaning is sevice and struggle .but iin that context strive and struggle could be anything in life ,with things in life is every thing is strive and struggle so war is also a struggle and you have to strive for too to win any war. So jehaid only only means in Arabic language is strive for some thing and struggle for something that is an original meaning of the word because you slosh have to strive and struggle to win a war in that context it is stated in the Quran. This dose not mean its is named to fight is jehaid. In fact real word in Arabic for killing is Qutal . Qutal is used for wars too .see in Arabic language in one word has several meanings used in different context as well as different scenarios. So in that respect we can't pinpoint one meaning for one thing only .it had several meanings .
No
“New atheism “ is still the same atheism it’s always been through liberalism and etc
Even atheists would disagree 😂
that is the problem with interpretation, it is open to interpretation. he and harris/ibn laden reading the same texts and drawing the exact opposite conclusions reminds me of the dress some people saw as gold and white and others as black and blue. or if you google 'right brain, left brain test' you will see an image of a woman [warning, not sure if it a haram image or not. if i had to guess, haram. lol] spinning. some people see her spinning clockwise, others counterclockwise.
i like fareed, but it is always funny when muslims try that line. 'well you see things as the terrorist do' [implying you are a terrorist or at least have a terrorist mentality]. the point it the texts are clearly poorly written if two people can draw the exact opposite conclusion. if you don't want innocent women and children killed in warfare, you should condemn it WHENEVER it happens. not allow it one battle and chastise in after another. i will say this guy was at least honest enough to say you can't TARGET innocents, unlike most muslims who just say you can't kill innocents. so then the question is, does a suicide bomber necessarily TARGET innocents? and of course, who is innocent?
The quran is not open to interpretation.
This is what you non muslims fail to understand.
You try to tell us how our religion is supposed to work or whatever.
We do not want you to come and tell us what the quran is or is not.
You wanna learn? Fine.
Otherwise shut up
The texts are in Classical Arabic. English translations are not the Quran. It’s easy to misinterpret if you don’t have a strong grasp of Classical Arabic (the Arabic of 1400 years ago) For this reason, scholars have discouraged laypersons from seeking legal answers from the Quran unguided as comprehension of the text requires expert interpretation and contextualization. In fact, most Muslim sects agree that verses of the Quran can only properly be understood when read in light of other Quranic verses and the Prophetic model, as well as the interpretations and legal implementations of the ulema (learned scholars)
In our religion Ijtihad (independent reasoning of the text) is for the ulema (learned scholars) not the layman. The folks you mention aren’t allowed to have an interpretative opinion, their opinion (regardless of what it is) is invalid. Those trained in Ijtihad can have legitimate differences or opinion.
This is why you’re not at war with nearly I/5th of the planet
[2 billion Muslims don’t do their own Ijtihad (interpretative reasoning)]
Both you and the religiously illiterate fanatical extremists approach the religion with the same mentality. This is why you share and promote their false radical interpretation.
We consider you no different than a person who reads a medical book, then thinks they can perform brain surgery. Nay, believes they’re qualified to teach brain surgery (&) refute the medical community.
@@anushirvan6670 are you talking to me?
anyway, can scholars through ijtihad forgo hadd punishments? a muslim once told me a qadi ruled a woman had been pregnant since before her husband left for jihad 14 months ago [maybe longer]. is that 'reasonable' to you? what do you think of the great islamic scholar [mentioned in the lecture] ibn taimayya saying the druze should be killed as apostates?
so if the koran is so dangerous when translated, why put out all these translations and distribute them?
I wonder if CZcams will allow those with the opposing point of view to respond to this video?? Of course not, because they will be blocked and erased 😅
Islamic scholars do not know such a thing as civilians. Rather, the term is a belligerent infidel (who has no covenant) and a covenant infidel
Jihad has a law... Study or research about jihad...
Yes they right jihad is not what you understood the real jihad what they have understood when prophet said come to jihad his deciple came with sword and weapon and quran has cleared it many times and I would say you guys are sophescating jihad
what? torture is prohibited? i suppose if you are using the word only in the attempt to extract information. clearly, torture is prescribed in the koran see 24:2 for example. and of course you have rajam [stoning] in the hadiths.
Thats a legal punishment for sinning. That's not torture.
@@TruRedCRIME legal or not, that is the definition of torture.
tor·ture
/ˈtôrCHər/
noun
the action or practice of inflicting severe pain or suffering on someone as a punishment or in order to force them to do or say something.
@@user-jv4zb6zu7wcutie pie
As he stated, it's a punishment
Not getting him to say anything
@@TheRockeyAllen right. but inflicting pain as a punishment is the definition of the word torture.
@@user-jv4zb6zu7w No
As per the definition you yourself posted, it clearly states that torture is when there is a motive to get thr subject to say or do something
Penalising is not torture, may it be physical or monetary.
If anyone, including Paul, thinks that an academic who is teaching at a western university in 2024 has complete freedom to speak about this topic then you are very very naive.
RIP Islam
Admin you discussed religious wars. but cleverly you are ignoring the verse on war with Jizya tax which is mentioned in surah tawba verse 9:29. please explain the verse honestly from traditional famous tafsir. do not apply arguments like the mutazilites on the verses of the creator.
Reply please admin
What do you want to know about the Jizya tax? But first, just out of curiosity what country do you live in and what percentage of your income is taxed by that country? I take an interest in taxation issues.
Traditionalism means hadithers and we know Hadiths are not reliable Quranic verses of war and peace are about self defense
@@jalander8817 Listen this verse not just about jizya. its also about aggressive war. please read the verse
In the verse it says: fight them UNTIL..
It is simply saying how long should the fighting last. It does not say "go and attack". The Goraun already says: "fight those who fight you and do not transgress."
@@adnanbosnian5051 Different people have different interpretation in modern time of this verse. but i think according traditional interpretation fight with them untill establish muslim rule over the whole world. example rashidun chilapath ruled persia,rome, egypt. ottoman & abbasi empire use this verse same away. sorry for my bad english