Is The Immigration Department Corrupt, Or Not? (Adakah jabatan imigresen korup, atau tidak?)
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 09. 2024
- Most of us know about immigration staff asking for bribes. This is not new.
Last June, Tourism, Arts & Culture Minister Tiong King Sing exposed corruption at KLIA
He said that uncovered corruption among some officers and the chronic abuse of power at the country’s borders.
So, what has happened since that incident? More cover ups or will corrupt officials be punished?
YB Tiong set an example for other ministers to emulate.
Source:
www.malaysiaki...
Please support my work on:-
★ Patreon: / mariammokhtar
★ Website: www.mariammokh...
★ Facebook: / rebuildingma
★ Twitter: / mariamadmrlgen
★ Instagram: / rebuildingm
..
Credit notes: Thank you FB friends, Patreon sponsors, Fahmi Reza, Zunar, alternative newsmedia, MalaysiaNow, CZcams videos, Malaysiakini, FMT, The Star, NST, Astro Awani, Berita Harian, Utusan Malaysia, Reuters, Channel News Asia, Reuters, Suara Rakyat Malaysia for their pics/video clips/articles, if used.
The videos from CZcams, if applicable & used, are for illustrative purposes only and to emphasize a particular point.
Rebuilding Malaysia strives for complete accuracy, but mistakes do sometimes arise. If you spot any, please leave a message here.
Thank you very much for daring to speak out. You the heroine of Malaysia
When I was a teenager, Malaysia custom and police was corrupt.
I am now 75yrs, Malaysia custom and police still corrupt. 😂
75 years ago they wore shorts. Now they wear pants or cargo pants with more pockets to assist the up to date operations. More $$$$$!!!!!
@@Chu-vg2yu 🤭👍🤣🤣🤣
Yes, I do the same, the lasttime it was 20sen and 1ringgit now.......
I think it will last forever. Benda yg Halal & Tak Haram mah….! Should lanjutkan sampai…..😅
Corruption is a necessity. You have 75 years of experience. You should know.
The trouble with Malaysia today is that the worst thing happened to these corrupt officers were just relinquish their post. Hardly anyone is going to be reprimanded and sentenced in jail.
CORFUPTION BECAME RAMPANT AFTER NAJIB's1MDB SCANDAL. AFTER THAT MANY UMNO POLITIVIANS HAVE BEEN ARREST N CHARGED FOR BEING INVOLVED IN VARIOUS CORRUPTION CRIMES. SOME BASTARD FROM PAS EVEN LEGALISED CIRRUPTION AFTER RECEIVING 90 MILLIONS FROM NAJIB
Remember that RACIST MOST CORRUPTED mamak kutty madey the moment he sit as pm OPEN THE CORRUPTION DOOR WIDE n this is the current situations in Malaysia CORRUPTED TO THE CORE IN EVERY DEPARTMENTS.
czcams.com/video/Wfk2nFrMSlM/video.htmlsi=CgkFNiQXL1NHxcrW
I was shocked when ministers attacked Tiong for exposing the corrupted officials.
I am quite shocked all the guns are pointed at Tiong. Because they wanted to cover their own race, Just like Bossku. They claimed he was innocent! No wonder we are behind Singapore.
@@peterhou how about zahid? he is not even true malaysian
i have seen this in Kota Kinabalu where the policemen come and collect a bulging envelope of money every saturday from the penghulu in charge of the Filipino settlement where there illegals and snuggled contraband like liquor and cigarettes .
This was in the 1980s .
In the Gombak industrial area there are raids on factories and in construction sites where illegal workers are supposedly apprehended but strangely they are back at work the next day .
I never knew that our Malaysian justice system could process these arrest so speedily .
Kak Marian, you know I know and most people know , but its so sensitive to mention . If only we can stamp out corruption, hatred and bias treatment, this country will be a roaring tiger of South East Asia . Sadly government comes government goes. No one has the political will to upright them .
Agree no more
Corrupt to the core.
Which not corrupt? None.
It’s a social stigma..corruption and malpractice. It’s a disgraceful Malaysia..well known throughout the world
I don't know if they are corrupt or not but one thing I am pretty sure, it is amongst the most unfriendly gomen agencies there is.
Thank you, puan. Our beloved country is world famous for this. Even the foreign workers know. What else is new?😂😂😂
We are world leaders in corruption.
Puan Mariam Mokhtar,
You are well informed of Malaysia and we believe you have an added advantage of observing the Malaysian Political Situation from a distance abroad. ✅
Pls rephrase your Topic to
'Is ONLY the Immigration Dept Corrupted?' 😎
Done at 8:02
Perhaps you missed it...
@@MariamMokhtarRebuildingMsia Thanks 😀😀😀. 👍
czcams.com/video/Wfk2nFrMSlM/video.htmlsi=CgkFNiQXL1NHxcrW
No corruption, no Malaysia, lagi mau tanya.
Yeah....every Malaysian knows what is "mcmmn nak settle" ...
Most (if not all) government departments are corrupt. My late father used to say only those who work closing/opening the gate for the train to pass through does not have a chance of corruption.😂
Minister Tiong is a Malaysian hero.
I can prove that the immigration department is one of the most corrupted department.
I have gone through a few high court cases vs immigration department and the latest high court case against the Malaysian police for not investigating on my police reports against corrupt immigration officers.
Most foreigners would keep silent but the corruptions is so deep that I would like to bring all their corruptions to the Malaysian public attention. In the past, the immigration can threatened with retaliations well as can always denied because there is no one to challenge them in the Malaysian High courts and no hard evidences of all their wrongdoings.
You have proven to be very brave, as a Malaysian, dared to speak up publicly as in this video. But you will be richly rewarded and highly regarded for your integrity. God bless and protect you.
tiong kaki mabok
I have numerous time travelling between Singapore and Malaysia by flights or road transportation. When encountered both immigration they have different attitudes, dedication and alertness. Singapore immigration officers are far more a cut above as compared to Malaysia officers.
It's not really true. Several years ago, I had seen one China lady, and she asked Sg,ICA staff, for assistance. She spoke in Mandarin to the non Chinese ICA staff. The ICA staff brushed her aside, I felt sorry for her bad experience here.Changi airport ICA staff should be trained in at least three major spoken languages like English, Mandarin, Malay or Tamil.
@@choonhockong8215 That I believe depends which part of China they came from if they from 3rd or 4th line cities their characteristics have typical communism mind set with unrealistic and authoritarianism attitude. Those who from Peking, Shanghai and others 1st line cities they are more friendly and understandable because of multicultural experiences.
czcams.com/video/Wfk2nFrMSlM/video.htmlsi=CgkFNiQXL1NHxcrW
That goes w/o saying
Corruption is the way of life in Malaysia, from the very junior to the highest-ranking official.
Wow, you are the brave one who dares to speak up.
Malaysian will never ever end with corruption!! If menteri2 so corrupt.. what do you aspected?
Expect nothing then no disappointment -- it is what it is, sad but true😢
Some of these shameless leaders we have in our country 😢
anti corruption is only a 'talk' in election campaign lah....😆😆
I too have seen a police officer having a drink with the illegal leader of contraband cigarette sellers. The illegal even had the courtesy to put his hand on the shoulder of the officer perhaps to show that he was under his payroll. It angered me to watch such situation knowing that the officer should have arrested the criminal and put him in prison if he had any dignity and pride as a law enforcer.
True! Nothing can change if we talk more than action..it has become a culture. Is going bad to worst if we do not eradicate corruptions. Of course it will not be easy task to have 0 corruption but at least we should try bringing corruptions to as low as possible.Once the great late LKY said, corruptions will bring down the country.
Well said Madam. Tq🙏🙏🙏
Malaysia's immigration department and PDRM were the most corrupted departments, from the top officials till the general labours also corporated to "earn their living".
Because they know most tourists don't want hassles.
It would shock Me if the body isn't corrupt.
If the immegression dept is clean, Malaysia will not be facing such massive labour shortage and hish cot of imported labour.
Corruption is deep deep rooted over there. That’s why money always no enough.
Of Cause Mam...The Is Absolutely No Denying True Facts...🔥
Not just that. When this abuse and corruption goes on and on, the minorities are blamed for giving the most bribes when the minorities are the most targeted. The need to advance ourselves and safety by bribes just to be on a level playing field.
Thanks ..You hit the nail on the head .Like you said ,the question should be ,which enforcement arm of the government is not corrupt .Thank you for standing up for the truth .
corruption is not new in malaysian goverment adminstration.. dont deny it
What abt those who are readily GIVING ! Stop the givers from giving then there'll be no takers!😂
❤Yes Pn MM is right on the dot, true, clear and well argued, 'get rid of corruption'. ❤🎉🙏👨👩👧👦🙏💐Big thanks to Pn MM❤
There is corruption from high up to bottom. Its not only construction site, even the scrape metal shop we happened to past by , we saw a police can stil in front of the shop until an jndian lady came out & past some money to the poliman inside the car. When enqire from the lady,she said they came every once a while to asking for money. Then there is the coffee shop near by. the owner said those government official( b it police(man & woman) or immagration officer & even from bandar raya demand money or else they come back latter to cause trouble. This was the culture instill by Dumbo under all PM. As such Dumbo in the past, still Dumbo at present. What Dunbo Baru, more like Bang -Bang Baru or Kak-Kak baru. This Dumbo will never change, be it this monkey or that monkey. There r all monkey of leeching decent.Sad to say. Born a leech will always a leech even if they call themself Leeches Baru.
Immigration officials must be investigated and Tiong too must be investigated. The 3rd party agent appointed by the airlines and the airlines too need to be investigated as well as MAHB and CAAM. The issue here is systemic corruption, misconduct and no-conduct. Same as in all public institutions in Malaysia. Let's be clear, corruption exist in almost all countries in the world but here, it has become an acceptable norm.
Haha if investigated thousands will be dragged in.
What a clown demand. Who will investigate? On whose orders, this commentator's? Laughable. Miriam surely is just amusing herself out of her boredom with a single incident she picks up and recounts that all of us already know. A serious clip would have been to do some work and ask how many undocumented migrants there are among the 7 Million (Mahathir's figure publicly stated few years ago), and then tell us what they have to go through in their daily lives. Surely its hardly beyond her capacity to get some locals, since she apparently lives overseas, to speak to just a handful of such migrants and get the full facts. Millions undocumented paying thousands annually, comes to Billions annually. Over how many decades? Makes 1 MDB look like just a casual tea party. The cost of procuring a permit are known in the street, how come she doesnt bother to educate herself? Minister says too many immigrants, vastly surplus to requiremnents? Really, are these fellows all so utterly clueless and incompetent? So, if they are surplus how is it they are finding work and working, constantly aware they better have some cash on them to pay whenever they are picked up by the police? Anwar, sonorously asleep on the wheel past 11 months, may be the only person who believes he has eradicated corruption, yet he gets away with such astonishing statements, by the whole system putting a steel wall around it all, with him as lead in-charge of the fantasy tale. So, Miriam, please do some serious work, not this coffee at 11 fun time episode.
You right murugan. Minister has the right to intervene if tourists complain.
@@jimcysiah4193 I never said the Minister is right to intervene.
@@nedumurugan2350 minister has the right
Almost all people who frequently go abroad, especially the Chinese, have experienced difficulties and corruption by the Malaysian Immigration Department，this already a cultural😅
Brazen corruption as civil servants behave like King of the Roads as welding whatever power little they have to threaten & bully ..
Sudah pasti banyak yang kaki makan suap.
I had seen and witnessed in late 80's. At check point Johore to Singapore, I was at 3rd position on left row. A local chinese woman accidentally pushed her passport through the passport tray inlet shelf.. however it was unintentionally dropped on top of others. She tried to explained.. without further ado the officer got angried and asked "hey you siapa..kuat ka"..the officer dumped her passport to the thrash bin without further asking any why? The woman cried.. begging..I left the counter and the rest was history knows. Very sorry for that.
not all Sporean are saint
@nikoyameh..I believe you were saying Malaysian side right? I know it’s stressful dealing with general public. But that didn’t warrant cruelty, mistreatment and arrogance towards anyone. Malaysians are supposed to be friendly and welcoming be it foreigners or ones own countrymen or countrywomen. It’s the lowest of the low to think one has the power to destroy
Those officers are really very arrogant!!!
What do you think? Ada ke tak ada? Baru2 ini ada bonus lagi!!!
OF COURSE, ABSOLUTELY!👌NO DOUBT!
From the top to bottom is corrupted😂😢🙏
You absolutely RIGHT
this happen everyday..
This is how the PENDATANG TANPA IZIN. CARA MEREKA TERLEPAS DARI TANGKAPAN
Most of the government departments are corrupted due to the facts that past government including PM were corrupted. Macam mana nak jalan lulus jikalau Pemimpin jalan bengkang bengkok. It may take a reformed government at least 20 years to make them walk straight unless like China, corrupted civil servant punishable like drug dealers and that may surely end corruption fast.
I am a victim of the traffic police in Johor.
More examples: This is part of the core that is rotten. PMX is quiet on this. Buat bising bila kempen tapi sekarang ni rasuah masih berluasa......Mr. Anwar...hang kat mana?
He has to deal with the deep state / kuasa terpendam now. Let him consolidate a stronger base before he can deal with this issue. Each of us has a role too, like MM
I know. You know. Everyone knows.
Tiong's case? It's case closed because digging deeper into it would only embarrass all Malaysians and damage the country's reputation internationally.
Arrogant and rude immigration dept. Encountered last week.
Tiong is doing a very good job bongkar semua kerja perasuah di KLIA...big clap he save the country from corruption. He is like PMX, honestly fight corruption.Sarawak hero..a very brave Politician...he is fighting hard to see that the polis department also must be strictly checked and balance.❤❤❤❤
It is an eye opening issue sis. Not all officers are corrupt, some are so helpful but those who involve use the sentimen that we locals hv on foreigners. For example we locals dont want to easily give foreigners business opportunities, jobs or status so we are happy if the foreigners hv to pay this, pay that, taxes ect...ect...but where does the money flow into? So these corrupt officers will make the process not that simple unless they pay certain amount of money.
SO TRUE. SO BRAVE. PN. MM IS SO RIGHT. THANK YOU FOR SPEAKING UP ABOUT THIS ISSUE, PN MM. WISH-PRAY THOSE IN POWER WOULD SUPPORT HER EFFORT TO ERADICATE CORRUPTION, AND MANY OF US WOULD SPEAK UP TOO.
Terimah kaseh Mariam. Candid reporting will always be appreciated.
We are famous throughout the world for corruption, as per the international corruption index? Never changed, never change and never will change.
When ones does his job, he get criticism way above anything; so those criticize him must be heavily involved.
...obviously they are deeply involved. Those who barked the loudest are always the most corrupt & dirtiest. Even the blind can see that!!🤦🏻♀️
@@shirleytan1575 , so true. Even the blind can see.
Malaysia is said to be the purest and cleanest country in the world. 'Hidup Malaysia' NEGRAR KU'' HIDUP ORANG ORANG DI KAMPONG KAMPONG MELAYU, CINA & INDIA!!!!!!
Pn Mariam, I really salute you for speaking out. These we know have been their way of life for decades & it's not easy to weed out these bad habits. I found that the authorities should assist the rakyat instead of sucking their hard earned money. All in all it's come down to the seriousness of our government to stamp out corruption. Sad to say it is still a long way to go.
I think you said it all especially your conclusion. Just asked yourself this question When investor bring investment out of the country bcoz of corruption who would loose their jobs ? How are the illegals in this country enter the country ? PM shd tell us the outcome of investigation as a result of Tiong's allegations.
This round is Pakistanis delivery...
Minah's celebration
Mamat's
Mourning days 😂
Auction sales
Not good for Anwar's administration if they fail to clear this matter. Message is business as usual.. With his latest mega budget all the menteris will be mega happy... Mega bonus... This is how to keep the Unity government together. Corruption. When civil servants see their bosses with big bonuses... What say you...
Some high ranking government servants caught and were send to other states which still hold high rank.. that's what was told by low ranked officers.what a waste to rakyat money.
Must send past pms n their ministers to jail sooner. Must go after d departmental heads sooner. A Banglar migrant worker in kl said 5rm pun mau!
We vote new Govt, But no action to stamp out corruption.
Majority business men forced to paid 'kopi' money links to government departments even small shop like restaurant need to paid 300 to 400 monthly.
Thanks..sadly as pointed out..Malaysia is a disgrace
We are still waiting for the KLIA case...
A bangladeshi guy says he was barred from entering msia at klia. He was deported. He came back thru thailand border . The imigration allowed him in subject to fee .
Cerita rasuah ni memang terlalu senang untuk Kita kenal bilamana dalam sesebuah Negara rakyatnya Ada yang terlalu miskin dan Ada juga yang terlalu Kaya, apatah lagi bilamana kuasa digunakan untuk menyuburkan rasuah..
The civil services has a reputation that most if not all Malaysians are aware of. We complain, gripe and debate about it extensively but nothing much can be done to reverse this trend for as long as people are hungry for money. Conscience has never and will never triumph over human greed. The ex PM is in prison but has it waken up those actively pursuing riches by whatever means? The lure is too strong to most of them. That is the weakness of the human race, irrespective of race, religion or creed.
Little napoleons has their own procedure even when you just apply for electricity their is so much black tape even you summit all documents as requested, they have the reason for not approve unless ?????
Need to change all top management and managers. I had experienced this corruption.
Corruption is our Malaysian way of life?
No! It's killing the citizens of the country and tourists are damn afraid to visit.!! SICKENING !! 😂
Top to bottom many are corrupt 😢
Yes. Malaysian side. I was on my way to Singapore. That woman had done no wrong. The officer could had asked why rather throwing the passport into the trash. This was fact infront of my eyes. This is history to recall. Please.
I know you're telling the truth😂😂 been there done that 😂😂
Same as monopolies, it a form of corruption too !
I sokong your views!
Nothing is easy.If you are a good person,you dont want money not due to you.
corruption in malaysia is here to stay, is not the government , is the people in politic who has the power
Wanna know the truth? Interview the China Dolls. They have lots to disclose. Also ask yourselves why so much of contraband liquor and cigarettes still in the market.
Although i know permanent residence is not a right, my Singapore wife of 40 years with 3 malaysian children still have to apply for yearly social pass. Have filled hundred of forms. Got scolded by immigration naploleans. Once at ministry of home affairs got 1 hr free lecture of how singapore is bad bully.he also scolded wife for bad malay... no give money so no PR
The allegations against Tiong was the most shocking and ridiculous, it will send you hopping!
This thing has been quiet as at to date.....meaning there is too many vested interests in this immigration department. There should be a follow up on the case just can't leave it settle down quietly. This is not the so called noble Madani Government by DSAI.
1.5 Million PATI in Malaysia or maybe more (Believe the related ministry also could not give the accurate numbers)
So what do you think??? How they can survive? Majority of my neighbors in Sg. Buloh are PATI. Are immigration officers are blind or not doing their job?. In the first please how did they get in into our country????.
You think MPs in the Parliament want to debate, discuss or resolve this PATI issue. I don't think so. PATI is already in our blood stream. We can't drain them. Now they use our facilities, they took over local's semi-skill jobs. Worse thing, billon of ringgits annually drain out of our country.
WHAT I CANNOT BRAIN, FOR THE PAST 20 YEARS, ALL PMs & HOME MINISTERs FAILED TO RAISE THIS PATI ISSUE IN THE PARLIAMENT..
The whole blardy orchard corrupt lah🤬, like someone said….only the gatekeeper of railway crossing not corrupt 🤗
Thanks for sharing, puan!
Tiada angin dahan pokok tidak bergoyang
No action taken against corrupt govt officials and head of group.
well…Malaysia is the most corrupted and dis gusted country in the whole world…what are you complaining for???
Mariam, go join BERSIH or ask BERSIH to have a protest unless the government gives the answer to the rakyat.
Almost many of d Government depts are corrupted.Why? firstly "kepala senget bawah pun senget", many top of d government is corrupted so d bottom macai, 2ndly no body dares to check and investigate d corrupted officers becos d former is protected or covered by d top , 3rdly d root of d poison is from mainly BN.
PN. Mariam your analysis the corruption going on in our country are really facts hopefully under MADANI government will apply REFORMACY for a new page to the country of Malaysia.
The bane of many Govts are the fight against corruptions which are always futile. Nevertheless, looking at it positively corruption does serve its purpose by making many troublesome bureaucratic procedures smooth and fast way of doing things. As the saying goes " If you can't beat them, join them"...🤣🤣🤣
I think laws are there to guide society. If everyone wants to avoid bureaucracy by bribery no wonder there’re corruption..the problem is feeding the ‘needs’
Just found your video presentation. Greetings from sunny Singapore
Only political talks on corruption but no political willi to😮 eradicate. Corruption is the leakage in economy. What a waste !!!
Police take home pay rm1600... So how... Bangla workers get paid more
Bangla already camsiong sama polis😂 you help me, I help you 😂🤣🤣
@@HRoslanyou scratch my back I scratch yours 😂😂😂😂😂😂 win win situation!
corrupt plus morally corrupt
You are always the BEST❤
RAMAI PELANCUNG TANPA PERMIT MASUK DENGAN BEBAS SEJAK ZAMAN MAHATIR KUTTY,,,,PALING RAMAI IALAH TOURIST ROHINGYA, SEBAB COFFEE MONEY IS LEGAL,,,,SALUTE MARYAM
I like! even when I mistakenly thought that you were a fake in Oxford.
DSAI promised he WILL eradicate corruption. Instead he is setting them free. Any more hope for Rasuahland?
DSAI is still practising UMNO politics with a new twist.
Peniaga OKU yang hendak membuka gerai di pasar malam pun menjadi mangsa diminta rasuah oleh 2 polis peronta. Sebabnya, sebatang besi gerai tiba2 terjatuh mengenai badan kereta peronta yang melalui tempatnya. Polis tersebut membawa OKU ke tempat tersembunyi daripada pandangan orang ramai dan para penjaja. IC milik OKU dirampas, polis mengugut OKU bayar RM100. OKU cakap tiada duit, polis enggan melepaskan ICnya. Sangat sedih OKU terpaksa kosongkan dompetnya demi mengenyangkan polis itu. Kemudian OKU dilepaskan setelah menerima RM100 hasil titik peluhnya kepada polis yg korup. Nak adu siapa? Semua pihak berkuasa pun sama, terlibat dalam rasuah. Semua pun Islam agamanya, apalah..
Ask Tiong..he Will give perfect answers..👍👍👍😆😆😆
Beautiful pronunciation
Enunciation
Thanks Mariam 😊
Corrupt everywhere by minister n top govt civil service what shame they brought to our belove country. Anti corruption of civil service not abuse of power but walk the talk, maybe the complain also do like that.
The ultimate question then 😮
Do we still have any more MARUAH left to talk about Maruah ?
"Fake people have an image to maintain. Real people just don't care.". 😜
God bless Malaysia.
Corruption is their core business which they are good at for decades. So, no one could ever stop them from doing this traditional, easy-earned-money family business. That's why most Malay politicians felt insulted and offended when their comrades (especially the Malay comrades) were accused or caught by other people ( especially from other races for corruptions) ! They are trying to tell people of other races not to interfere into the Malays' traditional core family business or else actions would be taken against them and not the currupted ones!
well well well…what are you complaining for??? malaysia is the most corrupted country in the whole world…malaysian will be forever poorer and poorer…soon SGD 1 will become RM6 😂😂😂