Filmed When Israel Took Action To Make Peace With The Palestinians 1964
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 10. 2023
- As a very young documentary filmmaker in 1964 my boss, who made me a partner in his film company in 1965, was actively involved with Israel and its efforts to make peace with the Palestinians. He directed this film with the hope that it would show friendliness and humanity and that that would help to reduce tensions and prevent Israel Palestine wars.
In 1963 the situation between Israel and the Palestinians, particularly regarding Hamas and the Gaza Strip, was different from the later decades.
Hamas did not exist in 1963. Hamas was founded in 1987, during the First Intifada (Palestinian uprising). In 1963, the main Palestinian political entity was the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), which was established in 1964. The PLO's main faction was Fatah, led by Yasser Arafat.
The Gaza Strip was under Egyptian control. After the 1948 Arab-Israeli war, the Gaza Strip came under Egyptian military administration, though Egypt never formally annexed it. Israel did not occupy the Gaza Strip until the Six-Day War in 1967.
In 1963, the broader Arab-Israeli conflict was still very much in play. The Arab states, including Egypt, Jordan, and Syria, did not recognize Israel's right to exist. The official stance of most Arab nations was one of non-recognition and non-negotiation with Israel. The PLO's founding charter in 1964 also called for the liberation of Palestine and did not recognize Israel.
There were no significant public peace initiatives between Israel and the Palestinians or between Israel and the Arab states in 1963. The situation was largely characterized by mutual distrust and a lack of formal diplomatic relations. The major turning point in peace negotiations would come after the 1967 Six-Day War and especially after the 1973 Yom Kippur War, leading to the Camp David Accords between Israel and Egypt in 1978 and the Israel-Jordan Peace Treaty in 1994. The Oslo Accords between Israel and the PLO in the 1990s marked a significant step towards peace with the Palestinians, though many issues remained unresolved.
If you found this film of meaning, I ask you to support my efforts to present more films from my archive. There is much more that I could show audiences who might be interested. Please click the Thanks button below the video screen.
Thank you
David Hoffman filmmaker
Whose Land Is It Any Way? - czcams.com/video/cfkUE5Q0K04/video.html
At least the video you're promoting is somewhat neutral.
Whose land are you on right now? Native Americans so when is white America handing that land back?
If Israel lays claim to land from 2000 years ago, surely North and South American indigenous people's, the first peoples of Australia and New Zealand should get their land back too. If it's a US principle that Israel should get the land they claim is theirs back, this principle must be universally applied.
@DavidHoffman: I thank you for the impartial videos you've posted on the subject. could you please post something about the Oslo peace accords and the assassination of Mr. Yitzhak Rabine? hopefully this will reduce the polarization, and prove to people from both sides of the divide, the Peace between Israel and the Palestinians was very tangible one day! thanks in advance.
@@jooj9420 And that's very important indeed. I agree. People (myself included) really need to take a deeper look from all perspectives. What we're fed by news channels is always biased (unless you purposefully get your news from from anywhere that might be remotely neutral & objective). The aim is hatred or some intellectual form of dismissal toward "the other side", and it largely succeeds.
There are a out a million Israeli settlers living in Palestine with no respect for Palestinian authority. The news calls this a war with Hamas. So, the two state solution only applied when there was a balance of power.
David, thank you so much for this. I’m a Muslim woman in Canada and I’m praying so hard for peace. You are a remarkable man David Hoffman. You help us to understand.
It's not working, pray to a different god.
I am praying too. It as got to stop.
The One G-d is experiencing inner conflict apparently
@@moshdee456 u should have some respect
I love the Jewish people . I love the Arab people . Dont they know that they have so much in common? I wish both peace and respect. Both are precious human life .
but you dont know islam, I think a lot of these militant problems come from islamic doctrine, like quran 9;29 kill those who do not believe in allah or let them pay jizia tax (this an everlasting islamic "truth")
yeh like the same holy sites - that's kinda the problem isn't it?
They're literally cousins lol.
@sirialexa9001 They both come from the lineage of Abraham . One from Ishmael and the the other from Israel . Two brothers one father .
@@supertrooper6011 And the same paternal lineage From Abraham . One brother Ishmael and the other Israel .
Our differences are beautiful and should be celebrated, but until our shared humanity and rights are recognized, I don't see much changing.
@DonnellxxOkafor So it as not worked in your or my DNA most of us are mongrels.
Love older style docs like this. Reminds me of 6th grade when I was an "AV boy" and learned how to loop a projector and watch films like this. The good old days had problems but nothing a lens couldn't bring into focus.
I was "AV" too, high school - early 80's.
reminds me of a time when I thought sensible people were in charge (I was probably wrong)
This touched my heart. I wish we could just get along.
It's easy to get along if you don't move into my house uninvited.
Not happening.
@@tf5pZ9H5vcAdBp Well it’s time to move on and find a solution because that’s not going to change ever
It has to stop .
@@tf5pZ9H5vcAdBp And if you dont kill my kids that are having a party . It has to stop . NO EXCUSES !
🙏♥️🌍🕊
I can't stop crying after the last few days of war again. Peaceful solutions, will it be possible after centuries? The question is who are we?
Thank you, David . A special film indeed. I saw the other one a few days ago, but the tears were flowing.
Thank you so much for releasing another one of your wonderful gems! I will watch this as soon as I can. Have a great afternoon, sir!✌🏼🙏🏼😊
It's a beautiful film indeed, but you have the year wrong, when you write you worked on it in the early 60's. The year should be 1979, after the Camp David accords, when Israel gave up on Sinai in exchange for (uncomfortable) peace with Egypt. Also, the festivities shown at the start show a sign that reads: "Hurray for Tel Aviv 70". Tel Aviv was founded in 1909.
I'm writing this and sirens are sounding over the town in the North of Israel where I live and an end to this insanity seems further away than ever.
Interesting & beautiful film, informative description! Thank you
David✌
Mr Hoffman your film makeing and arcives are Amazing 💚
Those Children Are Grandparents Now.....
Interconnectedness ✨️
Thank David Hoffman, I always enjoy the film clips or documentaries you upload. in light of what has happen and going on in Israel my heart goes out the innocent people of Israel. 😢🙏
✌️☮️ Thanks for sharing this with us David Hoffman film maker 🎥🎞️🙂 the children at the end was sweet.awww
An innocence before celebrity culture and mass media arose, even killers
can have a kind of immortality. Kudos to David for another video we hopelessly wish the world would watch and learn from.
Thanks for these very relevant to the times videos David. Very educative.
Universal peace to all, one day it will happen. I dont realistically believe it will happen in any of our life times with the current human mind set but it will happen. A bright day that our future generations will definitely share.
And Eli Wallach's narration is 💯❤
I am optimistic . I think we have to accept peace or we are all up crap creek without a paddle .
Interesting to hear "Night Fever" bt The Bee Gees playing in the background
Timely.
Everyone knows whats right and whats wrong. Life is but a test. Dont lose your soul because you are so stubborn and defiant of righteousness.
This conflict will never be solved.
It's been 1400 years, but I think the end is in sight. That violent superstition cannot survive in the age of the internet.
@@marktrain9498foolish its the internet that created this problem
@@thewildcardperson no it's not. It was the Balfour declaration of 1917, dumbass.
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 free Palestine & gaza you must free it from its terrorist groups as its leaders!🙏🌎✌
Thank you for another good video
Very sad. What is wrong humans.
The more things change, the more they stay the same
🕊
You guys got Eli Wallach to narrate this.
Awesome!
An occupying power cannot be offering peace deals, it needs to end the occupstion.
❤
I'm weird David. I'll settle for everyone forgiving each other and healing!
I read I think or heard once; 'an eye for an eye leaves both people blind!'. Or something very close to that...
Ask anyone well versed in history. This whole vengeance thing has been tried literally to death!
Forgiveness is something we haven't tried too much of! 🤷🏻♂️
Call me crazy but maybe a new approach is a better solution than tried and true failure with too much death and destruction all the way around for anyone to be happy with!!!
Once heavy artillery and missiles are flying right or wrong become secondary to life lost in my opinion! ❤️🩹🕊️🙃
Forgiveness is a powerful lost art that can bring peace to the most vengeful. It isn't always easy, but it is always worth it.
My belief is that this simply is not in human nature, and that we will always rally behind leaders who say what the people want to hear, and when humanity is divided into groups, and us vs. them mentalities, it's awfully easy to justify just about anything. I think this is just going to get even worse with the internet and algorithms over time, as corporations profit from us feeling angry, and engaging more, leading to more profits. It's a very depressing view, but sadly I believe it to be the truth :/ I wish this wasn't the case.
@@claudia-Silva thank you Claudia! I knew I must have read it somewhere! It sounded too good to be mine! Next time I have to write the good stuff down! 😁❤️🩹🕊️
I very much enjoy your post. Vengeance is no decent motivation in life. Your post has much goodness to contemplate.
@@KytexEdits love what you're saying. Also, what if we feed the algorithms a whole lot of pathways toward peace!
Where are the Palestinian people? How have their lives been improved by the peace deal.
Most of the Palestinians came to Israel as immigrant workers from Jordan.
They literally have themselves to blame.
free palestine
@@claudia-Silvayes the Israelis are peaceful people unlike Hamas /Pally people
2018.
31,558 Palestinians injured and/or killed, 130 israelis injured and/or killed. What more are you asking for/about? What do you want to know? A whole country with superior power attacking 2 million people living in a prison. They're not allowed electricity, food, or water. What are you expecting? Going along with it?
You corner a human somewhere and keep applying pressure, you think that human will tolerate and accept? No. They'll retort with a reaction you've never seen before! That's exactly what's happening!
Thank you David
Thank you sir for sharing everything you share✌👍👍
This video doesn't seem to match what's in the description.
I’m not sure what you mean. These people are talking about their future dreams and peace, and it’s an old film from the 1970’s.
@@BlackSeranna The description says he made this film in 1964, but it obviously was made way after that. Also, this film has nothing to do with the Palestinians. It's an appeal to donate to the UJA-Federation. The words "Palestine" or "Palestinians" aren't even mentioned. I think he uploaded the wrong video for this description, or vice-versa.
❤
✌️💗 for My friends, Family and All in Israel.
"Isreal hoped for peace with Palestinians", why don't you just give us the land we were promised by the queen, and we can be friends uwu
can fix religious zealots though... they choose religion over science and this is what you get.
Science without morality brought us eugenics and Holocaust
Thank God atheists countries weren't the biggest killers in the 20th century! Oh wait
Thank you for sharing this.
Thank you David Hoffman.
✌️ ☮️ 🕊 🏳️
David Hoffman, such an amazing individual. A tremendous filmmaker, who has a distinct style with telling a story. David stories are unbiased and reflect actual events. David style is always non-judgmental with undertones of peace and kindness. What a tremendous filmmaker. I cherish all your works and feel your voice is very important. May peace, kindness and love follow you through all your days…
I think this was filmed in 1982 when Israel gave back the Sinai. "On the Brink of Peace". Looking back decades later most ironic title ever. They'll never have peace because of the fanatics on both sides and the innocent civilians are usually the victims.
Read the description please. This was filmed in 1982.
David Hoffman filmmaker
@@DavidHoffmanFilmmaker As of me typing this comment, the 1st line in the description says: "As a very young documentary filmmaker in 1964, I worked on this film."
I understand the confusion and I apologize. The film was made in 1982. I began working in the company in 1964.
David Hoffman filmmaker
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 To free Palestine & gaza
you must free it from its terrorist groups as its leaders!🙏🌎✌
@@DavidHoffmanFilmmaker you didn't have to explain it to me I watched the whole thing I will be sharing this with most of my friends thank you
Thank you for posting it but it’s not from the 60s. One of the men in the video says he came to the US in 1975
It was made in 1982 as the description says.
David Hoffman Filmmaker
These vidoes should get more views Helping people understand. Lets all do our part to share the videos with a united heart.
Interesting stuff. Thanks for archiving and sharing all that you do.
Free Palestine.
May God bring peace in Israel. God bless. 🙏
God delusions is the reason for the war!
It is a beautiful film. And it’s history that should not and cannot be lost ESPECIALLY at this moment in time in Israel 🇮🇱🙏🏻
Have you seen tantura?
"Hope", how lethal?
As long as Israel hoped to make it a Jewish only state it can never be said that they 'hoped' sincerely for peace. The culmination of Israeli politics of today with mainstream violent settler extremists in powerful positions it can be said with quite a lot of certainty Israel never hoped for peace , they hoped for total control.
It is not a Jewish only state. Arabs both Muslim and Christian live and thrive and are around 20%. of pop.
Jewish is just the requirement to immigrate . There are Druze and Bedouin and Christian communities throughout Israel
The word peace is been in Israel's news everyday since it's had news the word shalom means peace✌ may you be well on this side of the globe on this side of the globe you are still my brother no matter what
@@yochevedbrachasimon4979 It is a religious Jewish state with TWO different sets of laws for Muslims and Jews. A Arab Muslim do not have the same rights as the Jews. LOL An Arab Muslim can not come to Israel and claim citizenship because his her family lived there. A jew can. An Arab Muslim can not criticize the Israeli govt but a jew can. IDF or Israeli army actively works with Jewish armed extremists to evict Arab Muslims frm their homes to spread illegal settlements. There are countless such examples. It is a Jewish state with apartheid laws.
@@mrcomenttoe2009 Thats good then stop illegal spread of settlements.
It's a Jewish majority state. Not exclusively Jewish . 20% are Muslim and have full rights and army exceptions.
There will never be a world without religion. You could eliminate all of Christendom and islam and new religions will pop up. Hardcore atheist are religious about their atheism for example.
So interesting. Love watching the video to learn more.
pls remade these films to reflect current context
Why? This is a time capsule.
I think Israel is under different management now….
All the kids in this movie are now old people , maybe some dead and peace in Israel is these days farther than ahything . And the new situation is much to be blamed on Netanyahu who iresponsibly grew the tensions in the last years. Unfortunately. I am not jew but grew up in Bucharest in a jewsih neighbourhood . Studied languages and piano with jewish teachers and they where the best . Also everybody was ( how I was to discovere later ) much above the average citizen in terms of culture . My father being a doctor and also a very cultivated person was somehow fast integrated in this community and had great relations with everybody and the social life there was unique in it's ways . Unfortunately in 72 everything came to an end as 90 per cent of the families moved to Israel , as the socialist state took money from Israel for each jew going away . And we moved in a different house in a working people new neighbourhood as my parents bought one of this newly built apartments . Nightmare for me .The shock of a primitive society in which I had to adjust and survive . Fortunately there where also some german ethnics around and soon we had another micro society that was a reasonable ''survival kit ''. Guess I never really adjusted to my own country real level and ways of living due to my childhood in a different environment . Interesting . I miss the jewsih Bucharest that cathegorically had it's charm . Now that part and streets have been either demolished by Ceusescu and what;s left is in ruin . I still like to walk around on '' memory lane'' when I go there .
I was in small claims court and no one sodomized any defenseless women no matter the size of the parcel of land being contested. Have you seen the graphic images coming out of Israel?
We tried everything for peace. We removed Israelis ftom Sinai and in 2005 from Gaza. Gaza was part of Egypt before 1967, but Egypt wouldn't take it back ad part of the peace treaty. Egypt keeps the Gaza border closed no matter what because they don't want Hamas terrorists .
Do you blame them? I dont
Survivors that survived the holocaust only two do what was done to them they turn around to do two others. I remember studying this in middle school I was so into this story and so moved by Anne Frank. It was a big thing to me and for this to be happening today I’m so disappointed, on the children they left behind I know they would be so disappointed in them as well. What are you doing?
4:22 brave, hopeful young mother. Back when we thought the Arabs of Palestine only wanted land
Salaam, Shalom ☮🌍🧤💌
Am Yisrael Chai from 🇨🇭!
💙🇮🇱💙✝️✡️❤️🇨🇭❤️
He means pacification not peace.
Lol. Can you go back a little bit? why start from 1964?
Let's start at 1948 then)))
Judging from the cars, this film looks more like late '70s / early '80s. Also the disco music at 11:38.
Where do you want start? Jews lived tbere first.
Before WW1 Palestine didn’t exist, it was ottoman Syria. Jews and Arabs always lived in tbe British mandate of Palestine but they can’t get along hence a 2 state solution. Muslims tried to exterminate the Jews and lost
@@focumQuariumI agree, let's go back 1400 years ago. Better yet 1550-1400 bce. That should solve the problem))
Two beautiful peoples but share abstract cognitive dissonance. It's an uncomfortable state of mind when someone has contradictory values, attitudes, or perspectives about the same thing. It creates an atmosphere and vibe that is constant and grows exponentially. It can no longer be ignored. It also permeates the minds of outsiders who look inside Israel and have limited knowledge of the historical-to-present state. It causes people to take sides based on face value.
maybe the title needs improvement
👍😊❤✌🌎😊👍
❤️❤️❤️🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🙏🙏🙏🙏
עצוב ששכונת התקווה לא השתנתה בכלל משנות ה50 למרות כל התרומות
Haunting words, " If This is The Price for Peace"....I pray for my friends, families, and All those who Need protection from The Evil if Terrorism. 🇮🇱✌️💗
If you're American I'd recommended you search up illan pappe, norman finkelstein, gabor mate and what their words are on this apartheid
Its simple Wanna peace go back to 1967 borders
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 to free Palestine & gaza you must free it from its terrorist groups as its leaders!🙏🌎✌
Free palestine ❤ 🇵🇸
From what exactly? Deadly ideology?
Gay people and women have no rights in Palestine. Women are not allow to attend school. They can stay occupied 🇮🇱
Free Palestine? So they can rape women and children? Kill innocent babies? Get fked
@@olegloginov2953 Free Palestine from Israeli oppression. It was their land until the British took it and gave it to Israel.
Free Palestine from radical Islamic ideology
This is like saying, hey, we violently oppressed you and now this is our land...please don't fight back and just "know your place"...
A respected filmmaker, using disgusting propaganda constantly...
I detest the violence right now, but to even say that any denial of human rights is "peace", while promoting a zenophobic apartheid state
As a Irish American my heart is with the Palestinians, the Israelis taking Palestinians homes away, forcing Palestinians out and moving in is disgusting. This is outright thievery and against all that is good. Slowly over decades the Israelis have taken more and more. They behave like pigs. This film is nothing more than propaganda. Netanyahu is a criminal and far right asshole. I grew up with Jewish friends, almost all my friends are Jewish and they do not approve of how the Palestinians are being treated. American Jews I love Israeli Jews not so much.
AGREE
LOL. You didn’t even watch the film. The title is misleading. You trolled yourself.
Free Palestine 🇵🇸🕊🙏 7:22
fun fact the native "palestinians" were workers from the british mandate their homes and family trees were hundreds of not more than a thousand miles away meanwhile any jew there has been there since they rediscovered their own ancient ruins when muslim rule finally lifted in the 1800s as the arab world began to nationalize allowing jews to also nationalize and return to israel with jewish families in jerusalem to haffa dating back to the kingdoms within israel today
idk how this was forgotten but even with saying "free palestine" the origins of that saying implies wiping out israel and theres no palestine state it was always syria jordan and egypt to divide israel up
Free Palestine
🇺🇲🙏🇮🇱
On day one Israel was landlocked. It was originally smaller than New Jersey, so how would Israel keep the young choosing to live there. Even now young people don't want to live their lives in a war zone. Over the last 75 years Palestine has just gotten smaller, with no U.N. involvement. It's obvious what the plan was all along. The disconnect for peace in Palestine arrived with weapons. This is a speciality of the U.S. The U.S. subsidized the fuel of hatred and still does $3.8 Billion. 💰
Ok my father was a peace keeper for the Irish fusiliers at the start of the troubles in the Palastine / Israel area . He said even at time Palastinians were lead by religious extremists and they did not want ANY non Muslim people living in that area . They got rid of so many non Muslim empires before this ever happened. And the religious leader of Palastine was very close to Hitler during the Second World War
During his time in Palastine . My dad heard " Irish , British; American infidels go home . " My father was only too happy to do so . And he also said " Europe's Jews will not get special treatment from them . If they dont like us , they definately will not like them. "
@@ErikReichUh, Israel is built on stolen land. Israeli Jews are colonizers.
Peace after stealing lands? Nice propaganda
Peace is not propaganda . It's a way of life . And it's the only way for the world . That's not propaganda THATS FACT
Israel has Define the word propaganda for so many people around the globe
never forget
Jerusalem the land of the Israelites 5000 BC do you want to talk about early lands come on man
Peace with Thieves…
so we just going to take your land but hey lets be peacefull lmao
I think this film aged like milk... LOL
Can you imagine a world with no man made fairytales that teach hatred to your fellow man. A world without religion!
Some fools would find something to argue over anyway . For example I am a better Atheist than you . I am a Marxist Atheist and you only follow Dawkins . What ever philosophy you follow keep it to yourself to a certain degree. And learn toleration of others
🌎🌎🌎🌎🌎The world will defeat Hamas and all jahadi any radical terrorist groups that act in terrorism...
⭐⭐Knowledge can end War