The Anarchist Wild Ride - Hearts Of Iron 4 La Resistance
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 06. 2024
- New merch: isorrowproductions.com/
Use discount code isorrow for 5% off on ironside
Ironside Click here to customize your own PC
ironsidecomputers.com/
isorrowproductions.com/
/ discord
Twitter here:
/ ispuuuv
Instagram
@uuuvstuff - Hry
Prussia: an army with a state
Anarchists: people with not-a-state
Army without a State
Brits: a navy with a state
Kid Rock: Devil without a cause.
Militaires Sans Frontières: Army Without Borders
JustGuy47 BOSS
The idea of an anarchist core is very funny to me.
"This region is the rightful territory of the [gestures vaguely around] people!"
Graknorke thanks i spit out my drink because of this
Lmao
this but unironically
Yeah, thats why they have this coring mechanic
The idea of an anarchist army is very funny to me as well.
as is the idea of invading and suppressing other countries to spread anarchism.
Just an observation, I love how wide a net the "Non-Aligned" ideology is. It includes Military Juntas, Presidential Dictatorships, Absolute Monarchies, and Anarchist autonomous regions." Talk about strange bedfellows.
Almost like the ideology system of HOI4 is trash except for hosting a three-team deathmatch.
It's basicly anyone who is not Conservative, Liberal, Socalist, Communist, Marxist, Fascist or National Socalist
I think the best way to view them is Any Ideology not aligned with the big three(Fascism/Other Nationalistic Dictatorships, Statist Communism like Stalinism or Maoism, or democracies/republics). Hence why they are the "Non-Aligned" ideas
@@Zorro9129 Its almost like you need to think a bit and notice its divided based on the "ideology" allignement to the big three WW2 sides :D
Fascists, Democracy, Communism and surprise surprise, the ones that did not give a fuck aka "non-alligned" xD
The HOI4 ideologies model which faction they would lean towards, not politics. Paradox are lazy shits
I am extremely disappointed that the "left" isn't on the left side of the focus tree
Paradox believes Horseshoe theory.
they fought for the left in the civil war, until they broke away from republican Spain and were crushed by nationalist and republican forces. historically anarchism is more left then right.
Well, Anarchism is the farthest left
Technically the focus tree is true, with Democracy being on the right side (center-left)
@@krasnamerah1926 democracy is a right wing thing
when compared to anarchism
But when compared to Monarchism, it's left wing
Global defence council session:
Person 1: So what do we do about Czechoslovakia?
Person 2: Let's make them a puppet!
Person 3: Ok a bit weird but what do we call them?
Person 4: Kingdom of Bohemia!
Council : *visible confusion*
monarchist anarchism
Kings are anarchist, aren't they?
*_Feudalism intensifies..._*
WIIZZPL anarcho-royalism is the ideology where you choose a king without a line of succession, and you choose the next monarch through civil war, then you get forever war economy and the most well trained military in history
@@kappachungusdaniels nevee heard of anarcho-monarchism?
iSorrow: The anarchists live in the forest
Vietcong: The trees in Europe speak Spanish?
Napoleon intensifies
You again.
Avery the Cuban-American I think the french would agree on that xD
Why do I see you everywhere?!?!?!?
You’re the new Justin. Y
"Okay, what shall the first action of our anarchist commune be?"
"*imperialism*"
*CLAPPING ASS CHEEKS*
Simon Science It’s not imperialism in thicscontext since their goals is to make the whome world under no government,so it’s kind of a united earth
@@jumperwilli7770 too bad he didnt even connect the borders from spain to germany because of late game existential dread
Imperialism is when war brrrrrff
@@jumperwilli7770 soooo... Imperialism?
I'm pretty sure British/USSR/America were "liberating" everyone as well
The Kaiserreich timeline is willing itself into our own.
break da chains bois
Soon comrades
@@Mantis42 every man a king
@@generalfred9426 Huey Long is cool too, it's a shame that KR lumps him in with some real losers. I think the Syndies could use a man like him
Mantis42 SUrF uP dUDe
Anarchist Spain!
*George Orwell nuts enormously*
Dude even tried to transfer over to the CNT militias but the Socialists wouldn’t let him
"I thought we were an autonomous collective"
"You're foolin' yourself! We're livin' in a dictatorship!"
‘I was handed the sacred sword Excalibur by the holy Lady of the Lake... and THAT is why I’m king’ - ‘now listen here , watery tarts chucking out blades weapons isn’t a valid system of government.. REAL power comes from a mandate of the masses not some damp bint throwing swords out to every singe John Arthur and dick that comes past
A self-perpetuating autocracy in which the working class-
Now we see the violence inherent in the system! Come and see the violence inherent in the system! Help, help I'm being repressed!
Now what kind of government decides leadership based on ladies in lakes handing out swords? It's no way to run a government I tell you.
A dictatorship of the proletariat!
Tutorial for braking spain:
Step 1: Wait
The end
One constant of Spain is that it never fails to break itself.
Instructions unclear, ended up with an anarcho-carlist-bundleofsticksist republic
Basically any Paradox game
@@Zorro9129 Same with China. Over 2,000 years of civil war.
Braking
"This clown car is small but many people can fit in it"
Teacher : *is gone for 5 minutes*
The whole class:
Thatcher : *is gone for 5 minutes*
Workers of the world: Unite!
@@alekseylamanov nani
IGNITE ANARCHIST UPRISING
I like to think they use pencils as guns and chairs as battering rams and desk as tanks and erasers as grenades
A whole scene just played in my brain with "dead" students killed by an automatic chair
Fun fact: Soviet means council.
Yeah. Global Council annex Council. COUNCILS.
There's this guy named ISP, he marches to Moscow. He calls it driving into Moscow. Funniest shit I've ever seen.
flyingkoopa45 trucking to Moscow
First two pitches: C#4 and G#4
Plink D#7
Jesus has returned
He has risen
HE IS RISEN
The Return of the King.
i don't get it?
The Dislikes are from the enemies of the Rat Kingdom
Also... *W E W A N T B A N A T*
nice
*RATBOY OF THE RAT REALM*
Nope, just portuguese.
Unga dunga BANAT!!
Hail Banatannia
HOI4, a game where anarchists, monarchists, non-aligned guys, despotists, authoritarianists and theocracies are considered one and the same form of government.
Point of order, it’s mildly infuriating that the fascist side of the focus tree is on the left and the republican side is on the right
Its probably intentional game design for the memes
It does align with geography, with the Nationalists in the west and the Republicans in the east.
JS500Y Republicans when the war started also had right-wing democratic people with them, so it wouldn't make sense for them be all the way to the left either way
@@gamerito100 Yeah, but relative to, ya know, fascists, a fuckin Neocon looks red.
“It’s been a couple minutes”, * leaves *
AxxL i’m male
@@AxxLAfriku what?? Are you trying to get on a subreddit?
Wer where u wen revolutionary corsica fall
I was in rusia spreading anarchism wen fon ring
corsica split three way
no
What?
@@Illegal_man-gi5gp it's a meme of guy with bad english who tweeted something similar to this but for when club penguin died
Simos6Jipros ok thanks
@@simos6jipros154 No it's not, it's originally from a 4chan post in 2012 about Heath Ledger, then made popular with John Lennon
This video made me vaguely remember a dream where I was playing a game and it said "press up on the dpad to simp"
Did you press it?
I bought a History Boys cap, to keep the sun out of my eyes, and it didn't work.
The sun was still in my eyes as I lay on the floor having been pushed over by a bully for wearing a History Boys cap.
Wait, is Kingdom of Bohemia is your puppet? Does that means ANARCHO-MONARCHY?
Yes
Yes, the people are the one monarch
Monarcho-Communism
Actual thing on reddit. Basically Absolute Monarchy but with a civil war every time the ruler dies. So apparently The Byzantine Empire was anarchist. You may now puke
Oxymoron
Wow this new anarchist world conquest can only be topped by Banat Dreadnought only in Vic 2 do it ISP
“The Spanish Empire is the most resilient power in the world. It has been trying to destroy itself for nearly two hundred years, and yet it still stands.”
-professionally misquoted from Otto Von Bismarck (who never said it anyway, but it’s still pretty good)
Can you show me an example of the spanish empire trying to kill itself pls?
@@carlosvillamayorbeorlegui5858 the common civil wars is what it refers to
i think that should be china
It's my personal headcanon that when the Anarchists make their way to Russia, one of them says "That was for Makhno, *bitch."*
And it will forever remain your fantasy.
ah yes non aligned ideology the ideology which includes monarchies, juntas and the blessed anarchism
i love hoi4
Well none of those are aligned with fascism, communism or democracy
@Dylan B Anarchist were literally communists you do know that right.
Isolationists.
@@JUGOstalgic the game actually adress that in the focuses text basically hearts of iron 4 serpate anarchism from communist by basically saying the miltarist authorian one party state communism creates is false and barbaric and anarchist spain plays out the dream idea of anarchism there is no goverment every thing is a volentary alliance of never ending city and town states with govermental research and miltary actions taken threw council from each town community and state seprared into specialitys so theres no poltician class at all everyone literally ahs a say but it is the sunset invansion of hearts of iron in terms of belivablity as societys with such choastic disparity in law always deloves to choas crime and degenracy with horrid industry raiders of fallout count as a example of what anarchism really does
Wilma Perkins You don’t really know what Anarchism is dude.
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarchist_schools_of_thought
"There is one nation I have yet to do"
Portugal: Am I a joke to you?
i’m pretty sure he did portugal in his review
EVERY MAN A STATE
*EGOISM INTENSIFIES*
I’ve been reading “homage to Catalonia” in preparation of this video.
Based and Breadpilled
Anarchy G A N G
Every state a core? Global Defence Council?
This is the Command and Conquer prequel I never knew I wanted.
As an anarchist I found this very tasteful
The only thing making me consider this DLC lol
Haha state go wither
Anarchist Spain is basically paradoxes way of making a world conquest game
Who needs helmets when you have the mother anarchy
She does love her sons.
I see you are a man of culture as well
As an Anarchist this is beautiful :')
I really hoped u would play as the anarchist, nobody else even tried them.
Video idea: Every person independent
Stirner would approve!
*E V E R Y M A N A K I N G*
Hey, isp you might not care but i really enjoy your videos on everything basically,your videos,jokes and all of the above, you are one of the best not only hoi4 youtubers but youtubers ever on youtube, thank you i sorrow for entertaining all of us for these many years!.( plus your laugh is stupid funny)
We must teach them of our peaceful ways..... by force!
Iron Side intro went so fast that I couldn't clap
Need to re-watch
I still don't know why the hell Paradox gives the anarchists such a shitty flag. Especially when during the Civil War they have a actually decent flag
Im here so early that that second guy named ISP didn’t have a channel
I feel this is the *wrong* format
working on a name s yes
The fact that anarchists are considered non-aligned, and thus puppets will be autocracies, is just a bit confusing...
the fact it lets you have puppets at all is confusing.
The idea of a large scale "Anarchist State" with a formal military, expansionism, a centralized economy, and an intelligence agency is certainly an... idea. I... guess the centralized economy thing could be representative of the efficiency increases of worker-owned industry???
Paradox probably needs to look into Anarchism and CNT-FAI a little bit more in HOI5. I get that they need to be both fun to play and be able to be represented by the game about warring states, but like wow.
I feel like the ironside intro changes every time.
Because it does
No shit Sherlock
Not everytime. But quite frequently yes.
Soviet Anarchist : lets rise up and aid the GDC
Soviet army : ignore em they cant do anything
Anarchist : Walks to the Funny Soviet meme place
Soviet army : HOW IS THE POSSIBLE "confused Slavic noises"
As an anarchist, almost every thing he said about anarchism is basically true.
"weather is pretty nice lately"
me, living in minnesota, where it just went from 60° and sunny to blizzard in 24 hours: yeah haha... nice...
Individualist anarchism and collectivist/syndicalist anarchism (like they had in Spain) is very different. No not everyone becomes “their own state” look up syndicalism.
@thunder key None of that will ever work. Hierarchies are burned into our monkey brains.
@@G-Mastah-Fash yeah but its fun while it lasts, like pirate republics or fiume
@thunder key I think it's about removal of unnecessary heirarchies.
The intro gets faster every video
As an anarchist, this makes me happy.
When did you first know you had mental health issues? Thinking of you during this difficult time. X
@@ryanmaginn1717 haha state go brrr
Robert Hymes At least he doesn't dream about going back to be a caveman society
we allow you to be on this council, but we do not grant you the rank of anarchist
I have stopped playing HoI4 about 5 months ago, but your videos on it are still super entertaining.
What happen to Orwell though?
I am pretty sure he Is advisor for Commie UK
@@patrikkalus5567 I know but he fought in the Spanish Civil War so I was hoping he got a mention with this update.
this should be called " Creating 2b 2t in Hoi4"
Why? Please take the time to learn the basic definition of anarchism.
@@betaplain297 have you ever have fun ever?
You did this video on my birthday thank you Sorrow love your videos as well.
Thank you for making so much content daddy isorrow, we really appreciate it
*The Anarchist wild ride*
So I see the Bernie Bros have finally started thier uprising.
600K you play as Paraguay in South America and try to have fun
I've got my $500 donation refunded, haven't you?
*NO REFUNDS*
He endorsed Biden today so yeah, it's time
"No healthcare? Alright comrades, let's get this bread"
Picks up Conquest of Bread
I honestly consider the earlier months of Anarcho-Syndicalist Catalonian existence to be such a uniquely hopeful, yet momentary blip of human coexistence and solidarity in an age where oppression appeared infallible and insurmountable.
Which I suppose in the case of the factionalised, Soviet influenced Republic, and Anarchist Catalonia, it was.
No doubt part of the blame for the failure of both can be put onto the lack of French/British support for the Republicans, combining with the Stalinist factions limiting the revolution under Soviet influence, essentially ensuring that the Catalonian blip of a genuine strive towards equality and liberty(admittedly soured with potentially justifiable anger towards the wealthy and powerful, but resulting in scores of deaths)served as an interregnum, sealing the fate of the region, and Spain generally, under Fascist dictatorship. And in it’s modern sense, semi-enslavement to capitalist neoliberalism paired with a parliament that is centralised, completely inefficient, and divided into fragments. Which I suppose is a horrible metaphor for Spain as a nation state, more generally speaking.
In regards to Spain, I still hold out a little hope. Especially with the increasing desire for Catalonian independence showcasing the continued oppressive flaws of Spain, and revitalising the hopes and feelings stirred in Catalonians amongst the initial Barcelona rising of the SCW.
I still almost feel hopeful for the future. I don’t know why. I mean, if the last 150 years of equalitarian, Marxist, Anarchist, and Socialist uprisings and suppressions are anything to go by, I really shouldn’t be. But whatever. Not really sure why I posted this comment on an isp meme video
Nothing is quite so unique and wonderfully hopeful as farmers being terrorized by roving fighters and syndicatalized workers running their factories like private businesses.
@@Zorro9129 NOOOOOOOOO NOT THE OPPRESSIVE BOUGIE FARMERS!!! NO YOU CAN'T TOUCH THE QUASI-FEUDAL LORDS WHO EXPLOITED POOR PEOPLE!!! THAT'S BAD!!!
@@cjstrashvideoemporium6484 Do you watch ben shapiro?
I agree, it was a remarkable episode. Though it's often glossed over rather optimistically (in particular, the collapse of industrial production in Catalonia tends to be looked over). In particular, you might be interested in this overview of the rather tyrannical and counterproductive nature of the FAI. econfaculty.gmu.edu/bcaplan/spain.htm Basically, I figure a full anarchist society would have had to "de-stateify" FAI on some level, if not disband it. Still a metric fuckton better than Franco's Carlists, Jose Antonio's Falangists, Mola's "assorted Fascists", or the "Spanish Lenin" playing a useful idiot to Stalin.
Though as for "semi-enslavement", the situation's bad but it's not that bad; I think people seriously underestimate what slavery is (and ironically often wind up touching on the rhetoric of slave apologists like Calhoun). That doesn't mean the modern economy is perfect by any stretch of the imagination, and a wage offer on the job market is a poor way to judge human worth, but at least open enslavement is taboo or has to hold out.
I guess I am also hopeful for the future (though I am likely far more conservative-liberal and capitalist). And I also find myself quite interested by many of the recent experiments. In particular, the Rojava- for all of its flaws- has been able to sustain itself and win in a deeply unenviable situation and neighborhood. To say nothing of El Alto and others.
So I guess "cautiously optimistic" sums up much of my opinions on the world at present.
"Do you watch ben shapiro?
"
I know it's not directed at me, but I admit I am.
"NOOOOOOOOO NOT THE OPPRESSIVE BOUGIE FARMERS!!! NO YOU CAN'T TOUCH THE QUASI-FEUDAL LORDS WHO EXPLOITED POOR PEOPLE!!! THAT'S BAD!!!
"
I'm not going to say that you can't touch the farmers or their system (indeed, eminent domain is still a thing, as is using it for redistribution), but a lot matters on HOW and WHY you touch them.
"[T]he fate of the peasant owner and tenant farmer in the communities occupied by the CNT-FAI militia was determined from the outset; for although a meeting of the population was generally held to decide on the establishment of the collective system, the vote was always taken by acclamation, and the presence of armed militiamen never failed to impose respect and fear on all opponents.""
"...the partisans of collectivization acted according to their own revolutionary opinions. They respected neither property nor persons. In some villages collectivization was only possible by imposing it on the minority.'"" - Higino Noja Ruiz.
The problem of course is that not only is this awkwardly state-like and coercive, but it's hard enough to curb abuses on that scale in any system (and I include my own Neo-Liberal/Neo-Conservative Capitalist Murica in it). And it can also be a terrible stain on future endeavors, in the same way that you could make a good argument for executing the Monarch and Consort for crimes against the people (in the case of Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette in France or Tsar Nicky II and Alix in Russia), but the method was often farcical and not conducive to justice or accountability..... even before they started slaughtering the kids.
That said, that goes back to FAI's bizarre thing as a sort of "Anarchist State-Non-State", and the fact that the Bolsheviks were totalitarian from the onset while Robespierre and a few others glorified "terror" via a state. While I disagree with CNT-FAI, the misdeeds made by members of them pale in comparison to most of the other major factions by faaaaar. Especially the Nacionalistas/
And PS: Bourgeoise are generally city dwelling property owners by definition (which kind of annoys me given how this term is mutilated). The closer term to the farmers you use would be gentry.
i Almost stopped procrastinating. thank you for the upload
Wow this is super unique. Probably the most unique and fun focus tree in the game. Paradox needs to do more whacky shit like this.
The amount ISP doesnt understand Anarchism is truly glorious
most people don't tbf
I don't think even anarchists understand anarchism
7:17 so anarchist spies are basicly *simps*
This feels like the strategy version of Disco Elysium
1:11 isorrow is the chosen one to create the real life Shogunate of America
It’s so funny to me that Paradox seems to have no idea how anarchism works.
Nah, they just give their audience the most ridiculous scenarios possibles and they take it
Well they did actually designed it nicely.
You know anarcho-communism and anarcho-syndicalism aren't just chaotic messes, people do organise in communes and syndicates.
Space Commie Those are already a mess in what they do nowdays, it would be a disaster for them to manage a territory as big as Spain xD
Because it dont work
Yeah its even worse in reality
I still wait for 15 minute long video of ironside intro
We love you isp
“It seems to be piercing through Switzerland”
I see isorrow is a man of culture
Bread conquering time
The only successful anarchist revolution lmao
This Corsican independence went as good as the historical one...
You know quarantine is getting to ISP as he’s playing HOI again
4:27
That is a very red Spain.
please... ISP... stop calling it an anarchist state... you're killing me here bro.
I like your uploads hope you never stop uploading
12:42 isp predicted the future
Does playing as the anarchists mean you're gonna have a super long post 1945 game? I'm not sure of my computer can handle it
A Totalitarian Anarchist State would be epic
Anarcho-statism is the patrician ideology
Italy: "Sees Spains focus tree"
Italy: "Cries in spagetti"
In our darkest hour, a hero must rise.
IRONSIDE PITCH BOI, WE NEED YOU
We have the 'History Boi' and other stuff, but I'm still waiting for Map (or maybe a litlle mad?)Lad one.
Ignacy I don’t know if this an ironic request but Map is kinda like not going to happen because iirc ISP said he didn’t want to touch the term Map and combine with with Lad, because the rising popularity of the Definition of Minor Attracted Person
Not only is this a meme, but this is the unironically the superior timeline
This is the worst timeline actually
I like the Idea of an anarchist war, just Larry and his bros decide to go with guns into Germany for the shits and giggles. Then somehow It spreads and the next thing you know a bunch of people decide to join in and bam you got the biggest capture the hill game in history.
Invading France as Spain, the ultimate around the maginot
Why wont you do a paradox country roulette mega campain?
4:39 An anarchist state isn’t a thing. The point of Anarchy is to bring down the state
Judging by your name and pfp, you may be the expert here.
Anarcho-Communist
Truly intriguing.
@@thorstenbohms4206 Communism is a economic system where the means of production are collectively managed, it don't need of states, and it is no necessarily hierarchic, contrary to capitalism. Obviously Soviet Union isn't a good example, it's a form of authoritary socialism, the marxism-leninism, opposite to libertarian communism/anarcho-communism
This kind of goes to the question of what a state is, and what a government is. Which is where I think it gets complicated. States are coercive, make no mistake about it, but they also tend to be a mixture of semi-organic and semi-artificial creation.
But I guess I'll just settle for calling it a "polity."
@@paolherledan4917 "Communism is a economic system where the means of production are collectively managed, "
Ehj, more or less agreed though there's a lot of dispute about that.
"it don't need of states, "
Which raises the issue of how the collective management would be, and what would order it. Even if we postulate a grassroots management by the private (or at least non-dependent) individual (maybe by grassroots) that management would have to be done in some collective forum. Which isn't surprising. Neither that such collective management is closely related to (even if we argue that it is not necessarily) a state. Which is one reason why the CNT-FAI in Catalonia started to resemble a state within a state with FAI as its "ruling party."
"and it is no necessarily hierarchic, contrary to capitalism."
Which assumes that capitalism is inherently hierarchic, which is particularly ironic since the earliest form of it emerged from the sort of free fairs cobbled together (most famously in Europe but also elsewhere, ) by subsistence farmers, craftsmen, and to some degree traders (though those came later) in order to trade their goods or services. Often to each other rather than via employment. So the 1 woman cottage industry crafter would often sell their wares to the farmer from the next county over in exchange for old coins to invest or (more commonly) goods that could be "invested" like wildlife or tools.
Now, that doesn't mean these were non-hierarchical (indeed, if they ever were it wasn't long before the local gov't authroties muscled in for their cut and the more successful or fortunate powers that be started amassing resources and dictating terms), merely that it is not inherently hierarchical since capitalism is primarily about possession of private property and the trade of capital for profit.
" Obviously Soviet Union isn't a good example, it's a form of authoritary socialism, the marxism-leninism, opposite to libertarian communism/anarcho-communism
"
Quite so. And while I do not claim to adhere to either, it doesn't take me a huge amount of time to realize that we're on the same side, at least re: despotism.
"for the past 150 years, Spain has not felt too good" - ouch
Looks like a baguette and *insert Spanish food * party
Feel da boin of the fires of proletariat revolution
HOI4 heavy tanks and rocket arty only
ISorrow: *supposedly goes Anarchist*
Also iSorrow: Invades various countries, puppets some, maintains a state
“I pulled a sneaky on ya”
Isp: the weather sure is nice lately so use this to keep the sun out of your face
Us: don’t worry quarantine does that for us
How does this video get recommended right after I looked up depression?
because anarchism is the cure !
I'm glad paradox is adding other leftist ideologies other than marxism-Leninism
Says weather is nice, me who’s been in a tornado warning and rain forced all worms to surface, yea it kinda is.
You are on this council, but we do not grant you the rank of council