Why Elementals "Isn't There" Anymore in Modern

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 7. 09. 2024

Komentáře • 78

  • @AmmiO2
    @AmmiO2  Před rokem +57

    Let me know what you think of the "less scripted" style of this video.

    • @vernonmeidlinger870
      @vernonmeidlinger870 Před rokem +7

      Love it! Makes it feel more like you have an organic relationship with this deck

    • @Zalzabar
      @Zalzabar Před rokem +1

      Honestly I prefer the pace of your speech in this then a lot of your videos. Feels less like I'm being rushed through.

    • @treederrpah6503
      @treederrpah6503 Před rokem

      I really liked it

    • @johnreese5739
      @johnreese5739 Před rokem +1

      You should definitely do more of these videos. The guide to every deck in every format videos are very good primers and can certainly give a fairly good analysis of the decks but a more in-depth video like this is also very interesting. It's kind of like a mix between your matchup videos and your normal guides. It also has a lot of different areas you can explore and I'm sure must be more fun to make sense you can sort of go back to your video essayist roots

    • @CommandoANG3L0
      @CommandoANG3L0 Před rokem

      Is there a deck list for this eldritch evolution version? I just want to play it at my LGS.

  • @sithdragon3333
    @sithdragon3333 Před rokem +69

    Rip Elementals, you were not fun to play against

    • @danw.1250
      @danw.1250 Před rokem +1

      As a Merfolk player, I can confirm this.

  • @AlejandroMartinez-ji1xe
    @AlejandroMartinez-ji1xe Před rokem +22

    I am glad that you aren't scared of doing anything besides a guide to every deck. Keep making bangers! One question though, what are the advantages between elementals and 5 color zoo? From the lists I seen, Zoo is a more aggressive deck that benefits from Scion of Draco being in play with, with beaters like Territorial Kabu and Mantis Riders and some lists play Shardless Agent and Bloodbraid Elf for value. How do they match up against each other or Zoo isn't just significant enough in the meta?

    • @AmmiO2
      @AmmiO2  Před rokem +4

      Elementals and Zoo aren't comparable. Zoo would be better compared to decks like Burn and Death's Shadow. Zoo is quite bad imo. It's not doing anything better than other aggro or tempo decks and is worse in multiple ways.

  • @thesvengallideck
    @thesvengallideck Před rokem +8

    I found this channel thanks to your “x deck in y format” videos. Short and bite sized videos theyre great. But im even happier to learn that youre also well able to explain thibgs in longform detailed videos. Cant wait to see more!

  • @ryanstudham640
    @ryanstudham640 Před rokem +18

    This is an excellent video.
    I wonder what a deck built entirely around Eldritch Evolution and cards like Scion of Draco or Scornful Egotist would look like.

  • @evanbowenfilm
    @evanbowenfilm Před rokem +3

    Consistently putting out so many bangers, I love seeing you branch out. I'll watch any type of video you try, you clearly understand magic really well and I appreciate you sharing your knowledge

  • @Head0.25s
    @Head0.25s Před rokem +4

    I like this type of content, I'd love to see a video like that for Rhinos,
    A good name for this type of video imo is "Super Primer"

  • @stevenpoche6988
    @stevenpoche6988 Před rokem +1

    Damn, you're actually a really good speaker just in general. I assume you still had some notes or whatever but this flows really well for a 40 minute "less scripted" video.

    • @AmmiO2
      @AmmiO2  Před rokem

      I had some notes and thoughts about what I wanted to say, and did a "practice run" before recording. I still heavily edited it though.

  • @Clonekiller66
    @Clonekiller66 Před rokem +2

    gonna spam this video to everyone at my LGS and RCQs who still played the deck post Y'orion ban.
    Many 4c Blob players were playing like 77 cards in the main without Y'orion. It was dumb.
    I hope this deck rots away for good so I never have to deal with it again.

  • @ComposerMathieu
    @ComposerMathieu Před rokem

    I'd love to see more of these sorts of videos. A deep dive into a deck and all its quirks. This was really great!

  • @guavapuree
    @guavapuree Před rokem +4

    How tf do you keep coming through with this QUALITY

  • @slowrollmtg
    @slowrollmtg Před rokem +1

    Love the long form content - glad I discovered this channel.

  • @AwkwardlyBrutal
    @AwkwardlyBrutal Před rokem

    I know it's not really relevant anymore but eladamri's call is amazing with orvar, as it allows you to in response to archon of cruelty grab your silver bullet. You might not like it in the initial 80, but when you look at it as a full 95 that one interaction shores up your matchup against the best deck in the format.
    Also Endurance itself is still a 3 mana 3/4 with reach. If you don't have an omnath in hand playing it on turn 4 to disrupt dragon rage channelers during their combat can be very effective. While it's not as back breaking as it is against dredge, that is still a very nice disruption tool that also survives against bolt. But if they're burning a unholy heat in order to keep their attacker, you're reducing their damage and setting their graveyard back in midgame where it would be used to either fuel further murktides or give DRCs their punch.

  • @marklyniuspayabyab5457
    @marklyniuspayabyab5457 Před rokem +2

    But it just won the Prague modern tournament with over 1000 people so I guess it's still good right? 😉

  • @kazen16
    @kazen16 Před rokem +3

    Elementals has such a great list of card but it has become abit slow for modern standards. It kinda lost its utility when yorion is removed… they always got great card support in most sets but most are late game cards… its very odd

  • @Umbelbumbel
    @Umbelbumbel Před rokem +1

    Still baffling to me how you don’t have more subscribers

  • @Dracomandriuthus
    @Dracomandriuthus Před rokem

    I'm going to disagree on the Endurance take. Endurance isn't in elementals to be pitchcast. It's in elementals to be hardcast. It's a wall against burn, it blocks every creature in Murktide and delays Murktide, it's a way to reset your OWN graveyard in matchups that are so grindy that decking becomes an issue...

  • @OneLastJellyGuy
    @OneLastJellyGuy Před rokem

    Great video bro! more of this would be perfect

  • @Calispeedboi
    @Calispeedboi Před rokem

    Well this really changed with the one ring

  • @Joelthelobo
    @Joelthelobo Před rokem

    This title made me cry bc I just bought into 4c over the past 4 months

  • @maxbooth179
    @maxbooth179 Před rokem

    This type of Elementals deck is an adaptation of a control deck. It has cut Counterspell effects and now it's finding out why control decks run those. They deal with combos and specific problem cards without needing to run a suite of hate cards maindeck and a tutor effect to fetch them. The downside is you sometimes can't completely tap out on your turn for a greedy risen reef.

    • @AmmiO2
      @AmmiO2  Před rokem

      Essentially, there are 2 versions of Omnath pile (not counting 60 vs 80). One is the classic Elementals list, the other is closer to UW Control splashing for W&6, Expressive Iteration, and Omnath.

  • @mrgnami
    @mrgnami Před rokem +1

    RespectTheCat does not agree with this video :D
    btw allways good content.

  • @seanstuart6115
    @seanstuart6115 Před rokem

    Your a really good mtg data source. 🎉

  • @erickchristensen746
    @erickchristensen746 Před rokem +3

    This is why I play Historic.
    Screw Standard and all the hellfire "Top 3 Meta Deck" bullshit that comes with each rotation.
    I love my dinosaurs, elementals, older dragons, and just generally older cards that im always improving with each new set cuz that's how the game used to be played and intended to be back in the older days.
    Now everything is "Pay this most absolute broken combo" crap.

  • @lukebarrett1105
    @lukebarrett1105 Před rokem

    With the new Nissa finding success in the meta, do you think that is what it needed to become more relevant?

    • @AmmiO2
      @AmmiO2  Před rokem +1

      New Nissa is good but she doesn't fix the deck's problems.
      If I were to play the deck, I'd play the Eldritch Evolution version I described.

    • @mrmarklin
      @mrmarklin Před rokem

      @@AmmiO2 what about the version that won at a 1000+ prague event, is that version good enough?

    • @AmmiO2
      @AmmiO2  Před rokem

      Not IMO. The deck is of course still powerful but I think it has too many bad matchups and Blood Moon is a major problem.

  • @SymmetricalDocking
    @SymmetricalDocking Před rokem

    This was fantastic!

  • @Lunamowon
    @Lunamowon Před rokem +1

    Hey ammi. What's your opinion on izzet prowess? Literally so many people at my lgs play the deck and it's rly good. Why do you think it's not a top 2% deck even?

    • @AmmiO2
      @AmmiO2  Před rokem +1

      IMO Prowess is just worse than Burn. You have to fight Burn on 2 angles, whereas Prowess you only need removal or blockers.

    • @Lunamowon
      @Lunamowon Před rokem

      @@AmmiO2 very interesting. I don't get why so many ppl at my lgs play it then. When noone plays burn. Im guessing it's because burns kinda boring

  • @ArchaonDruchii
    @ArchaonDruchii Před rokem

    Would you mind sharing your decklist you said you enjoyed playing around 37:00 minutes? I know you said it was too inconsistent, but if you say it was fun, I'd like to try it.
    Maybe I could find a way to improve its consistency as well. I'd certainly like to try.

    • @AmmiO2
      @AmmiO2  Před rokem

      4 Abundant Growth
      1 Atraxa, Grand Unifier
      4 Brought Back
      4 Eldritch Evolution
      1 Elesh Norn, Mother of Machines
      4 Fury
      4 Leyline Binding
      4 Omnath, Locus of Creation
      4 Prismatic Ending
      4 Risen Reef
      4 Scion of Draco
      4 Solitude
      4 Teferi, Time Raveler
      4 Wrenn and Six
      LANDS
      2 Boseiju, Who Endures
      1 Breeding Pool
      4 Flooded Strand
      1 Hallowed Fountain
      1 Jetmir’s Garden
      4 Misty Rainforest
      1 Sacred Foundry
      2 Snow-Covered Forest
      1 Snow-Covered Island
      1 Snow-Covered Plains
      1 Steam Vents
      1 Stomping Ground
      1 Temple Garden
      4 Windswept Heath
      4 Wooded Foothills
      1 Zagoth Triome
      SIDEBOARD
      2 Boseiju, Who Endures
      3 Chalice of the Void
      3 Destroy Evil
      1 Endurance
      1 Iona, Shield of Emeria
      1 Ixidron
      1 Necroplasm
      1 Progenitus
      1 Sire of Insanity
      1 Terastodon

  • @laytonjr6601
    @laytonjr6601 Před 5 měsíci

    Ixidron looks like a Yu-Gi-Oh card xD

  • @ryanask6320
    @ryanask6320 Před rokem

    GOD DAMN IT!!! I JUST SPENT 2,000 ON THAT DECK

  • @noobie7727
    @noobie7727 Před rokem

    Where are you from? The way you say mana drives me bonkers and i assume its regional

    • @AmmiO2
      @AmmiO2  Před rokem +1

      Apparently I'm a region of 1.

    • @noobie7727
      @noobie7727 Před rokem

      @AmmiO2 oh my. I dont mean any ill will by asking. I was watching and everytime you said it my brain made me say mana the way i know it 😅.

    • @AmmiO2
      @AmmiO2  Před rokem

      @@noobie7727 Of all the things I imagined I'd be known for when I started this channel...

    • @noobie7727
      @noobie7727 Před rokem

      @AmmiO2 thats pretty funny honestly. I like your content ive seen i just cant keep my mouth shut about that sorta thing. I hope to see more about bad card design and degenerate combos

  • @mrmarklin
    @mrmarklin Před rokem

    Perhaps u could go 5 color and put the scam package in

    • @AmmiO2
      @AmmiO2  Před rokem

      Elementals would love to play Grief, but there aren't enough black spells to run it.

  • @nicholaskempf4924
    @nicholaskempf4924 Před rokem +2

    There is no O in MANA

    • @AmmiO2
      @AmmiO2  Před rokem +1

      I use preferred pronounce.

    • @nicholaskempf4924
      @nicholaskempf4924 Před rokem +1

      ​@@AmmiO2 Force of Negation in response! 😅
      P.S. Great video

  • @gringotopies12
    @gringotopies12 Před rokem +1

    +algorithm

  • @ncuco
    @ncuco Před rokem

    Ice fang againt hammer time isnt bonus because hammer makes creatures loose fliying

    • @AlejandroMartinez-ji1xe
    • @IcePopAddict
      @IcePopAddict Před rokem +1

      Inkmoth Nexus can activate its 1 Mana ability to regain flying.
      “If the equipped creature gains flying after Colossus Hammer became attached to it, it will keep flying.”

    • @nunya8089
      @nunya8089 Před rokem +1

      Usually hammer will flash in the hammer after blockers

    • @AmmiO2
      @AmmiO2  Před rokem

      Hammer can flash in equipment via Sigarda's Aid after no blockers are declared (e.g. onto Ornithopter) or activate Inkmoth again to re-give it flying.

  • @smugs7921
    @smugs7921 Před rokem

    Hope this deck dies completely and stays dead