Allah (swt) made Br. Imran who guided me to the deen, idk where would i be without Allah's guidance. May Allah bless this Amazing brother for all his great work in the Deen for the Youth.
@@axis2312 bro, he was disgraceful, what don't you get. He was using the name Badr 313 in relation to the noble Sahabah who sacrificed their everything at Badr. An absolute disgrace to attempt to tie that to materialism. His advert for it spoke volumes, fast cars, bed with roses (sex), living it up in Dubai (a shaytanic place). All for what? Copying the Andrew Tate and others, copying their stupid style of machoism, making money off the lost youth by trying to put an Islamic wrapper on it. It was pathetic. He should hide his face in shame.
These people always say obey ...obey the corrupt rulers over Muslims , obey the kufar killing Muslims...what is this . Astagfirullah. May Allah help us. We make Dua and act.
I didn't understand that from the video. Basically he said duaa is a sunnah of the Prophet SAWS that we should follow. Himself is boycotting France. Duaa is action, boycot too.
@@markward3981 well perhaps this is where the problem is with what you're saying and the many Muslims who regurgitate your line of reasoning. the problem is you still haven't made the distinction between the opinion of knowledgeable Muslims and Quran and Sunnah. that which comes from the Quran and Sunnah must be obeyed. but as for the opinions from the knowledgeable, that can have discussions and disagreements. my advice is refer to the Quran and Sunnah as opposed to just airing out your disagreements and frustration with people.
UK salafi dawah bubble has been burst. Now that Saudi & UAE has stopped funding that najdi dawah & more focusing on funding individuals like Farris. More and more ppl will leave Salafism and follow traditional Sunni Islam again.
@@zahin2986 “Some people have the disease of criticising all the time. They forget the good about others and only mention their faults. They are like flies that avoid the good and pure places and land on the bad and wounds. This is because of the evil within the self and the spoiled nature.” - Ibn Taymiyyah
@@almercishie2901 disease nah I liked anime as well time to leave childish thoughs . Most genre of anime Pushes kufr agenda AOT ain't different and Eren smh .
Here's what I feel is Br. Imran's point regarding protests (with some of my thoughts): Don't be the one who ✅ Goes to a protest from 2 - 6 hours ❌ Doesn't wake up for tahajjud to make salah and dua for victory like the Prophet did and Allah commanded (recommended in the Quran) ❌ Doesn't stay between salaahs to make dua for victory like the Prophet did and Allah commanded ❌ Doesn't go to a masjid the 20 minute walk away to make salah like the Prophet did and Allah commanded. If this was the case the protesters are also going to the masajid, would the masajid still be empty? How can we have an impact if we're not doing what the Prophet ASWA did and Allah commanded first and foremost and we're jumping to protests before that? P.S. Loved this. I loved seeing the unity. The ummah is coming together Alhamdulillah!
These things are not mutually exclusive and thus this is a straw-man argument. And Saudi or Gulf scholars saying not to protest because Saudi and Gulf governments do not generally allow various types of protests don't necessarily apply to the West, where the governments specifically allow protesting and even encourage them as a means of seeing what the people want.
Good points But here is a thought .do you think everyone at the time of prophet made dua the same way? They spend the same energy and efforts or it varied??? Does the iman of each and every muslim in medina the same or it varied? Does the importance of actions can be brushed aside just because masses may not be following sunnah in terms of making dua?? When i read seerah i see all kind of muslims, some steadfast, some shaky, some confused and then there were munafiqoon, i believe societal structure will always reflect this composition and insisting on not trying to do actions just because you dont see results should not be the criteria *Also those in battle field are consistent because of duas and quran there s nothing else that hold their hearts and assuming otherwise is reckless
@@asmazohaib85 Salaam - Thank you for the thought, please please please watch the full video it's extremely refreshing and addresses some of your points. What I said doesn't negate that they were all the same or undermining the importance of actions, dua is an action, sabr is action, resistance is an action, protest/boycott is an action. There is always a direct result. Allah always accepts the sincere dua and the time of the response is with Allah's hikmah. I would also point to the words of Salahuddin Al Ayubi RahimahuAllah wa Radiallahu Anhu, when he passed by a group of his soldiers up in tahajjud he would say "It is through this consistent [qiyaam/tahajjud] that we are given victory". Do we want to have victory like salahuddin Ra? I thinks he's more of an expert of freeing Palestine than anyone alive today. May be we aught to try what he said works and focus on a lot more. Allahu alaam - just my refelctions. I would also suggest you watch The Thinking Muslim Podcast with Dr. Tariq Swaydaan - very very powerful and fearless, especially coming from a person in the Gulf which many may not expect. It left me very optimistic in this generation Alhamdulillah.
@@ABFYI23 walikumassalam brother i watched the whole section, and i pointed out that not everyone would be making duas the way brother s referring to, since people vary in their spirtuality and they did vary at the time of prophet too, also doesnt mean there s absence of dua and certainly not among people who are actually battling at the very moment, it s obvious that their only survival instinct and their spirit is based on making dua doing azkar and connecting to quran. I do know brother acknowledges Palestinians resilience and iman but i did feel he differentiated them from those in battlefield (just a feeling i guess). Ofcourse i do think that khabri ahadith where we r told that rulers would be the devils in the image of human doesn't abstain muslims from accounting rulers. It should be as vital as making dua, because for me display of an "open kuffer" is not mere denouncing islam with words but it s also usury, allying with west, making hypocritical remarks(as pointed that there r leaders who took part in protest but they said they rnt going to severe ties with israel) and i gather this understanding from several ayah of quran where Allah swt talk about those who decide as per their wishes abondoning the hukm of Allah swt or where Allah swt scolded Jews that u take certain part of the scripture and reject certain parts. For me the very essence of quran is to be applied in full context it cant be abondoned on desire and if a ruler do so than thats a public display of rejection of hukmullah which i understand is different than a ruler who is tyrant and violates my rights or exploit my wealth!!! I will try to watch the podcast u refer to in sha Allah. JAZAKAALLAH ul khair
@@asmazohaib85 JazakiAllah khair for the shedding more light on it. I would very much agree with that perspective especially with the point on hypocrisy and accountability. Waiyaakum
He said democracy is permissible or not. Of course it is not permissible. It allows people to change laws in accordance with desires. Democracy is valid only in terms of selection of a suitable Khalifa, but then all laws implemented must be laws of Allah SWT. Like no riba institutions in the land, or no alcohol shops in the land, or no open zina allowed.
@@miladprive5163out of genuine curiosity do you take from ali dawah and mohammed hijab? Because the knowledge coming from them is also 0. In the negatives from ali
Brother Imran has changed a lot in the last 2 years for the better. I might disagree with some things he has said in the past but this was a wonderful podcast Brothers Dilly and Imran
The Ruling on Demonstrations By Shaykh Nasir al-Fahd Question: What is the ruling on demonstrations? What are the evidences for its permissibility? And what are the evidences for its prohibition? Answer: The issue of demonstration is a long one, and I will summarize my words regarding it by saying: Some of the brothers that said that demonstrations are permissible researched in the Sunnah after evidences for this, so they mentioned for example the famous hadith of Abu Hurayrah regarding the neighbor[1], something which is these days referred to as "rousing the public opinion", the source for this hadith is in Sunnan Abi Dawud. And also they use the hadith of Abdullah bin Iyas bin Abi Dhubaba where women complained (in front of the Prophet [SAW]) regarding their husbands (i.e. a female demonstration)[2], and this is also narrated in Sunnan Abi Dawud. But all of this isn't necessary (to prove it's permissibility), because the rule is: "Nothing is legislated in this Religion except what Allah has legislated, and nothing becomes forbidden except what Allah has forbidden." So the rule is regarding worship ('ibadah) is that of tawqif (i.e. not permissible to exceed beyond), so there's a must to provide an evidence for it. And the rule regarding customary things ('aadaat) is that they are in general permissible. So whoever forbids something is asked to provide an evidence (dalil) for it, this is the fundamental rule (asl) regarding this. So whoever permitted demonstrations and holds to this fundamental rule, then he is of no need to bring forth any evidences, because nothing is haram except what Allah has made haram. And even if one brought forth evidences to prove this, then it's being generous. So what's left for us is to see what those that forbid demonstrations have for evidence, then afterwards we can answer them and let the issue be finished (over with). The most famous evidences that they have are three: That it is an innovation (bid'a), that it is imitating the disbelievers, that it is forbidden as a means to block an evil (sadd al-dhara'i) which leads corruptions (fasad). 1) With regards to their argument that it's a bid'a, then this is false (batil). Because bid'a is in matters pertaining to worship ('ibadah), not customary things ('aadaat). And thus there isn't any need for redundancy of words to show that this argument is void. 2) With regards to their argument that is imitating the disbelievers, then this is also false. For history is filled with people gathering and marching and demanding something. And go back to the history of Uthman (RA) and go back to the history of al-Basrah and al-Kufa in the latter half of the first century (hijri), and see how plentiful these sort of demonstrations were. This isn't to prove that its something legislated or permissible, rather it is evidence that it isn't from the issues of imitating the disbelievers. 3) And regarding their argument that its something that leads to corruption (fasad), then this is not correct. Because we see it taking place everywhere and there is no corruption that takes place like which they claim will come about. Rather great benefits (masalih 'adhimah) have come through it, like the overthrowing of the Egyptian taghut (i.e. Mubarak). And his overthrowing - even though it didn't bring forth a Islamic governance - eased the injustice and tyranny, and it brought forth some justice that weren't there during his (i.e. Mubarak) time. This is a quick summary regarding this issue, and Allah knows best. ___________________________________________________________ The source for the Fatwa is "Fatawa al-Ha'iriyyah", a compilation of fatwas by the Shaykh from inside the prison of al-Ha'ir, KSA.
We make dua and we also make donations, protests and boycotts. In my opinion we are obliged to also take action. For us in the West protests puts pressure on the governments and the Israeli governemt fears boycott. With the leave of Allah we will be successful. We should strive and do whatever we can. It is a strange comparisons some brothers make.
Why do some people who call themselves salafis have a self-righteous approach and assume that they are the only ones who pray, fast, have tawheed and make lots of dua and other Muslims don’t. Of course, the general message that you should pray and make lots of dua is correct. However, Muslims should be doing this regardless of the Palestinian/Gaza issue. Also, the Prophet ﷺ and the Sahaba made lots of Dua and they fought in the way of Allah and Allah Gave them victory.
That itself is an assumption of a persons intentions, wheres the husn ath than? Theres facts and assumptions, the facts are, majority of people at these protests dont pray 5 times a day. Yet they’re going out to seek aid of a government who's motives are clear and wont change. In a time where no government will stand, aid can only be saught from Allah. The ummah needs quality muslims following the quran and the sunnah the way the sahabah understood it
@@MrSizzleDrizzle Yes, I agree I shouldn’t have used the word assumption. What I actually meant was that there are some salafis or some Muslims even who sometimes act as if they are on the Haq and everyone else is off it.
Because their starting point is that our condition is indirectly proportion with our collective level of Iman... In other words, if the mu'mineen were "true believers" they would succeed... They discount the fact that a mu'min takes a proactive role within their localities/society's/community's, etc. This outlook is a remnant of the Quietism of the Wahhabi/Al-Saud alliance of the 20th century... It is not something that is necessarily done on purpose or with a nefarious intent, it could very well be that they truly believe this is the way forward... (do consider that this is the methodology they have imbibed from their respective scholars (usually Saudi scholars)).
Because when you ask those ones who protest, they say it themselves. "Brother I know I don't pray but we need to protest to bring awareness". I heard it with my own ears from many. Hijabless women also and free mixing. It's a mockery to the deen and it's an insult to Allah, thinking he's not watching you
@@obaid5761 I haven’t seen or heard Muslims at the protest ever say that they don’t pray. Could you please provide any articles or videos etc. I’m not into protesting but to say that it doesn’t bring any awareness is false. If it makes headline news, then that is awareness. As for hijabless women and freemixing, then you will get that as soon as you leave your house.
Learnt a few hadeeth and ayah and he’s better then everyone else. Pure wasteman he’d rather bump he’s Muslim brothers and take the mick out of the badry sahaba and think his brothers are actively thinkjnf about standing next to homosexuals. What a muppet.
He literally stated that he takes account of himself before anyone else yet you’re slandering him by assuming he thinks he is better than everyone else? Okay cool maybe you don’t like him personally for whatever reason but be fair brother.
Showing strength to the enemy is a huge virtue, there are 7 days in a week and protest is held maximum 3 days usually 1 to 2 days of the week you have rest of the week to do dua for longer hours if you can't do it on the day you decide to go protest! The huge number of participants in the recent protest shows the strength for the support of the Palestinians, and I'm pretty sure it rocked the politicians boats! 500 thousand people coming out is no joke the politicians won't take it lightly and this is why we can see they sre trying to ban it! You may not see a ceasefire yet but there are changes happening even on a miniscule! Lets not go if the prophet ( may peace and blessings be upon him) went on a protest or not he sure didn't go on a podcast to discuss matters! Times are different and you need to adapt with time so long as it doesn't go against the Sharia!
The assumption that the ummah is not making dua is so self righteous and absurd.. And reminds me of the hadith that says that the one who says the ummah is finished - he is the one who finished them.
There are also battles the Rasul ﷺ lost even after making duas. It's all in the hands of The Most High. This dude seems to think dua is directly related with real world effects, to the point where your dua is answered the very next hour. The Muslims have been making dua for 80 years for falasteen, that shouldn't stop them from having a proactive role.
At the end of the day Imran said protests are okay, but dua is better. We say dua is of course the best, but protests and boycott is the minimum we can do for our brothers and sisters dying in Palestine because our 'leaders' are useless. At least he did not make takfir, or call the people protesting deviants or innovators, like the madkhalis do.
@@misterbk1791 what? Women alone? Where did this come from? Who is talking about women alone? He is talking about homosexual men at the protest, you are talking about women alone. Need to clean your minds. And what is minimum then? You have made dua, and everything else you can do solo. You cannot say anything to rulers because according to madkhalia ruler is infalliable. So what else can you do besides either fight, boycott or protest? Do you even think before you speak?
@@briancordero7674of course. We can either boycott, fight, or protest. We can’t really fight as the ‘Muslim’ armies are controlled by taghuts, let’s try to do anything else to save our Muslim brothers and sisters in Palestine.
@@-------....___do you genuinely believe protests and boycotting will actually work؟ because this is the same routine every single time israel attacks for the past however manh years. Why the hell do you think this time will be any different? Isnt that madness expecting different result by doing the same thing over and over again?
@@AK-ot4ybI already explained. The only reason Israel stop killing them is because of protests across the world and boycott. People, muslims and non-muslims, trying to force their governments to step up, whilst 'muslim leaders' were making deals with Israel. Stop asking stupid questions. Or did you think they stopped killing before because of your masters in the gulf?
He's not wrong. Dua is important and we shouln't neglect it BUT he's being too black and white. This is the problem with these guys, he can believe what he wants, you can't just blanket that over everyone. . and this assumption that people who chose to protest are not making dua is judgemental and honestly silly. He's encouraging somwthing good by saying all these silly things inbetween like "make dua make dua.." followed by "lets assume for a second that the protest is not bidah .." or "Im not judging anyone" and then makes judgements about people pritesting. Thats off putting.
Most young duats are black and white because it doesn’t need much wisdom and intellect to copy and paste daleel. Knowledge and wisdom are 2 different things and one needs to have a clean heart to correctly apply the knowledge. Otherwise it is tasting honey without the sweetness.
Well, I disagree with Imran on his khurooj stance, but at least he saw the the nonsense of the madkhalis against Libya. The madkhalis did the same with Egypt and tried to the same with Qatar.
@@sj4695the madkhalis only care about one Hadith; obey the rulers, cannot criticize them, cannot rebel against them. Then the same say it’s okay to do all that to other countries and leaders like Egypt, Qatar, Libya, Turkey, Gaza etc. Highest level of hypocrisy.
Ibn Abbas reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “None of the people rebel against the ruler by as much as a handspan and die but that he will have died a death of ignorance.” Source: Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 1849 Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Muslim عَنِ ابْنِ عَبَّاسٍ عَنْ رَسُولِ اللهِ صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ لَيْسَ أَحَدٌ مِنَ النَّاسِ خَرَجَ مِنَ السُّلْطَانِ شِبْرًا فَمَاتَ عَلَيْهِ إِلَّا مَاتَ مِيتَةً جَاهِلِيَّةً 1849 صحيح مسلم كتاب الإمارة باب وجوب ملازمة جماعة المسلمين عند ظهور الفتن
Points that Imran Ibn Mansur could not answer: 1. The early muslims protested against the kuffar of Quraish - protested against the shirk and lifestyle (the order) they were committed to. 2. Why are you assuming muslims are not already making dua? (no husn-ad-dhann for muslim ummah) 3. Why did Allah give victory to the muslim ummah previously when there was corruption and people were still committing sins? 4. Why is there a disproportionate blame on the muslim laity compared to the hukaam who have the ability to help?
@@k1003944 and what he said was incorrect. Al Hamdulillah we know the correct Salafiyah ways, duaa and taking action. Duaa alone will not suffice. A pot of gold will not descend from the heavens if I made duaa for 100 years. However I can find it if I took the action to look for it. This is the sibgha/fitra/sunnah of Allah in this dunya. You are trying to confine Islam in a monastery, this is not the wassatiya deen.
I don't understand the argument, when one is marching (walking) he can make dua in his mind so doesn't it become 2in1? Also these protests are raising huge awareness and to dismiss it as mothing is confusing. Anyway, I can't talk about whether protesting is halal or haram since I don't have the shari expertise.
Only Allah really knows, but brother Imran has always struck me as a very sincere brother. Has he made mistakes and questionable decisions? Well he is a human being so of course he has, but seeing his extremely humble origins giving da'wah as a young man with 'Ali and noting how much he has done for the youth in the UK, it is nearly impossible to convince me (and many others) that he doesn't genuinely want the best for the ummah in the UK and globally. May Allah bless and forgive him as well as brother Dilly.
I thought I was gonna have more respect for Dawah Man when I heard he agreed to come on Dilly’s podcast. However based on a few clips I have seen of him reugitating the same nonsense (as well as having a filthy mind in regards to who you may be next to in a protest), I suppose that this podcast only reaffirmed my thoughts of him.
He was referring to the brothers that go and protest with LGBTQ+ people who call for a ceasefire. Have good thoughts about your brother. Especially in these dire times.
Their starting point is that our condition is indirectly proportional with our collective level of Iman... In other words, if the mu'mineen were "true believers" they would succeed... They discount the fact that a mu'min takes a proactive role within their localities/society's/community's, etc. This outlook is a remnant of the Quietism of the Wahhabi/Al-Saud alliance of the 20th century... It is not something that is necessarily done on purpose or with a nefarious intent, it could very well be that they truly believe this is the way forward... (do consider that this is the methodology they have imbibed from their respective scholars (usually Saudi scholars)).
Mankind was [of] one religion [before their deviation]; then Allāh sent the prophets as bringers of good tidings and warners and sent down with them the Scripture in truth to judge between the people concerning that in which they differed Allah sent the books for mankind to judge between eachother ie to rule by, so how can these so called salafis say that changing the sharia is minor.
Wallahi brothers say what you want about imran but Allah used him as a means for me to start understanding the deen properly and practicing it for that I am forever grateful. I hope and pray to Allah that we see a reunion from dawah man and Ali dawah, the real ones know they started off dis ting together😂❤ in sha Allah they reunite one day and make a video together would love to see that.
So their logic is that do not go against the Hukam and even if they are doing evil and are in Fitna do not raise your voice and do not protest. So stay calm and watch the Saudi concerts and enjoy Lahul... This is the logic?
The point is that it sounds like brother Imran assumes duaa is not being done. But to be fair, he is just saying to make duaa and going into depth about the topic.
no hes reminding the muslims just like Allah commanded in the Quran. a lot of people in these comment section are assuming bad things about the brother when all he's doing is mentioning Quran and hadith. and I agree with him protesting wont do nothing Dua will.
He is completely wrong. The Sahabah fought battles in the way of Allah SWT. Could they have just made dua and Allah SWT responded? Allah SWT helped them in the battles, but they also fought and died for Allah SWT. Who made more dua and dhikr of Allah SWT than the Prophet PBUH? And was his life very easy? No. The Prophet PBUH remembered Allah SWT all day and all night, and still had to do governance, politics, religion, battle etc. all in Allah SWT's name. Dua is worship, one of the highest forms of worship. But action must be accompanied with it. If for example you are looking to get married, or looking for a job, yes of course you make dua for Allah SWT to help you, but you have to be proactive as well. You need to apply for jobs, make sure you get correct qualifications etc. You cannot just sit at home and make dua and expect Allah SWT to hand things in your hands. You make dua, you try your best, and then if Allah SWT wills it, you will get it. The madkhalis just want you to pray at home, make dua at home, then don't bring Islam outside the house.
I dont understand why cant you make ducaa as priority and also protest not for the sake of protesting but just not to empty the scene for the zionest and thier lovers to spread their narrative?!
Sorry but Imraan is a charismatic charlatan who has very unlogic and problematic positions. Someone with good firasa sees through him. He is sugarcoating Madkhali positions. Also his conscious exaggeration in speech are communication tactics and he is aware of this. He needs to stop the act and act authentic and be himself. Its almost as if you can sense some hints of megalomania. Despite this, may Allah accept his good duas for palestine if he makes them for his brothers and sisters.
Totally agree. He is a disguised madkhali. Just as madkhalis say don't protest, don't raise a voice against their rulers, just stay at home and pray and make dua and just look at yourselves, don't talk about the ummah or any problems.
Not to argue the point of protests being permissible or impermissible but He mentioned that the Prophet Muhammad pbuh made dua. But was that dua not coupled with the action of fighting or did he just say Khalas Allah can kill them in 1 strike because I did my job of dua. Even if the protestersor the Ummah at large were negligent in making dua does he not think that the Palestinians themselves are not making dua day and night.
Don’t think so, when he went to the rulers, he was very uncomfortable. Absolute obedience to secular individual rulers is a trait of the madkhalis and he still has it
My only criticism was that he hid and ducked away from speaking on the rulers. He didn’t want to go near it which was expected, but most of what was said by Imran was correct
If that is imrans stance (to not speak against the rulers), what is the issue? What will him speaking agaisnt them really do? Ive seen other speakers speak against the rulers and what does that achieve? I havent seen anything positive come about from that.
@@AK-ot4yb Well maybe if enough people speak against them, enough people wake up from this trance of the madkhali absolute obedience, we may get to put better leaders in. Your solution, like the madkhalis, is just to stay quiet.
@@-------....___ where from the quran and sunnah has this been mentioned and promoted؟ What is the basis of your revolutionary talk؟ Or is the quran and sunnah just useless theory that we dont need to stick to؟
@@AK-ot4ybwhere in Quran and Sunnah is it allowed to have multiple leaders and countries. As for speaking against tyrants, there are many Hadith. There is Quran to always speak truth. Also, there are many examples of Sahabah criticizing and rebelling against rulers. But back to my question. Quran and Sunnah where multiple leaders are allowed. Don’t run from the question now.
@@AK-ot4ybyou have said Imran not speaking against the rulers is his stance. That means he is applying hadiths that were meant for Amir, KHALIFA, Imam, onto taghut secular multiple leaders. Where is this in Quran and Sunnah.
He is not a sheikh, he is not a scholar, he is not teacher, he hasnt even finish his student of knowldge package according to him himself in thwir podcast with his friends...so inviting youtuber and ask question about umma and fataw is weird and wrong
Imran gave a good showing of what Salafiyyah truly is. I'm happy you uploaded this (and hope your uploaded it on good faith rather than trying to mockingly group him with those Spubs cult) so the people can see the Haqq of calling to Qur'an & Sunnah. Genuinely interested to hear what anyones reservations are regarding what Imran has said in this clip? What do you oppose? Or are you just naturally prejudicing him?
I don’t really see anything wrong he’s said regarding these protests. Did it work in Iraq? 1 million people protesting did nothing. Dua is the believers most effective weapon.
These are my thoughts after listening to the duat who say protesting is useless / taking the means is useless. The issue of over-emphasising dua over the practical means and steps towards change is that it comes across as if dua and taking the means (protesting, writing to MPs, engaging in politics) are MUTUALLY EXCLUSIVE (meaning they can't coexist). When in reality, they are intertwined. When these issues are spoken about (palestine, current affairs in the ummah), the emphasis should be split between the 2 - rather than allocating the entirety of a khutba / lecture / energy / narrative to only dua.
I completely agree with you! May allah bless you. I'm actually bored of muslims like him tbh mr chat toooo much but can never actually cash these cheques. Were literally living in a time where everyone's mask has dropped off and we're seeing everybodys true colours.
Dua is the greatest weapon we have. if all that energy that went into the protests was to go into Dua Allah will give us victory. and like he said I personally seen on utube protests where haram is taking place... free mixing etc how is that going to solve anything. when did Allah or the prophet tell you to protest?
@@Mikesco10 when there are means to take, you take them. Dua gives barakah to means. And in this situation - there are many means to take. Don’t strawman protests by saying because there’s free mixing therefore it’s useless. The entire point of a protest has a righteous goal. You wouldn’t strawman a job, travelling in public, even Hajj and umrah, or any other part of life by saying because there’s women involved and/or haram elements therefore it’s useless.
@@zeeshanahmed5624 habibi going to hajj is a pillar of Islam protesting is not. no one told you to go protest. and plz explain how protesting is a mean to change whats going on.
@@Mikesco10 If you genuinely want to know how protests help: use common sense, think and research about the implications it has in terms of media, attention to the palestinian plight, unity with muslims and non-muslims for a righteous cause and pressure on governments resulting in political / policy change. Resarch the teams involved which organise the protests and the work that they do. Many means are linked and protests are a very effective tool for accelerating all the things listed above - and its entirely legal.
@@-------....___ I think the general point here is trust in Allah azawajal is better than taking matters into our own hands, protest is for self contentment and awareness, never a solution
@@Muwazabdulkalimbut who trusted Allah SWT more, us or the Sahabah. Sahabah spoke out against oppression, Sahabah fought against enemies. They didn’t just sit at home and leave everything to Allah SWT. That is not how this works. If I want a job, I will not just sit at home and make dua. I will go study, get a degree, apply etc. and will continue making dua. But actions have to accompany dua. Do you guys even think about what you are saying?
Imran is showing growth because he is starting to realize that you can't grow as a Muslim having a stubborn interpretation in Fiqh, and it being based on the vast knowledge of Ahl Sunna which is available by researching these type of issues.
Q. When the Meccan Quraysh persecuted and oppressed the Muslim community year after year and chased them out from their homes and land and proptery, did the Prophet (pbuh) ever withdraw from commercial or social relations with them or did he continue as normal from Medina?
Iyad ibn Ghanam reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Whoever has advice for the ruler, let him take his hand and give it privately. If he accepts it, then he accepts it. If he rejects it, the duty upon him has been fulfilled.” Source: al-Sunnah li-Ibn Abī ‘Āṣim 1098 Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani عَنْ عِيَاضِ بْنِ غَنْمٍ قَالَ قَالَ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ مَنْ كَانَتْ عِنْدَهُ نَصِيحَةٌ لِذِي سُلْطَانٍ فَلْيَأْخُذْ بِيَدِهِ فَلْيَخْلُو بِهِ فَإِنْ قَبِلَهَا قَبِلَهَا وَإِنْ رَدَّهَا كَانَ قَدْ أَدَّى الَّذِي عَلَيْهِ 1098 السنة لابن أبي عاصم باب كيف نصيحة الرعية للولاة 2/523 المحدث الألباني خلاصة حكم المحدث صحيح في تخريج كتاب السنة
And where in Quran and Sunnah is it allowed for Muslims to have multiple countries and multiple rulers? The Hadith you are quoting is for Amir/Khalifa/Imam of the Muslims.
@@-------....___ Exactly 💯. And where is it allowed, after the establishment of Medina and liberating Mecca , for thousands of Muslims to permanently live in the land of disbelievers, near kufar , ruled by them who are at war with Muslims.
@@-------....___ the ahadith are not only for the khalifa Narrated by Ana’s bin Malik: Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "You should listen to and obey, your ruler even if he was an Ethiopian (black) slave whose head looks like a raisin." And the Khalifa has to be from quraysh it’s from the conditions of being a Khalifa and there’s other indicators that it is not only for the “khalifa”
@@khaledfatile9932 Yes, and this hadith says nothing about 'multiple leaders'. Stop being jahil. I wrote in my comment it is for Khalifa/AMIR/IMAM of the muslims. Did you not read it? It means the leader of the ummah, you can even call him a king if he is a king, but singular. Abu Bakr RA said it is forbidden to have two Amirs of the muslim. Reply back when you have something to actually say.
We have to make dua and zikr, no one is saying we shouldn’t, it’s more important. But we also in addition to this should do things like boycott and protest (within means). Ever heard of the Hadith of tying your camel, and hating evil with your words as well as actions? Why does it have to be binary? It’s these stupid arguments which divide us.
Ibn mansur your answer Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him): “Whoever dies without having fought for the sake of Allah or having had the intention of doing so, has died following one of the branches of hypocrisy.” (Saheeh Muslim, no. 3533)
Wait wait wait, how the flip is protesting a bidaa , protesting has got nothing to do with any type of worship infact its got nothing to do with the deen , its just asking for human rights ,
Very shortsighted He bypasses the whole point completely the prophet ﷺ didn’t just make dua and stay in his house. He made dua and mobilized the efforts he could to gain victory. Also he makes a mistake about a person making dua in the battlefield. People in the west are not in the direct battlefield they are in another environment with other halal possibilities to work for the cause of Allah in supporting our brothers and sisters in Palestine. And every person I have seen who is concerned about Palestine has been making dua. To think badly of them or start accusing them they don’t make dua is a bit inappropriate. Also a ruler who commits kufr akbar and nullifies his Islam no longer enjoys the full rights the prophet ﷺ told us to give to a Muslim ruler. As the rulings for a murtad munafiq and Muslim differ in Islam and we can’t misplace those rulings by giving rights which belong to a Muslim to a murtad. Misplacing ahadith and applying them on the wrong reality is a major catastrophe which enables the enemies of Islam to enjoying rights and comforts which Allah and His Messenger ﷺ negated from them. Lying about the religion by abusing the nusus is a major crime and also a reason for lots of oppression to occur and because people don’t see the fault in the matter they will forever be fooled and never change the wrong they did wa Allahul musta’an
Imran Ibn Mansour needs to be careful with his statements regarding the Book of Allah. He claims that nowhere does Allah mention Democracy being either permissible or impermissible. Well, the definition of Democracy is 'a way of governing, which depends on the will of the people.' This is clearly contrary to Islam, and it is, in fact, Major Shirk and disbelief in Allah ta Ala. Allah mentions in Surah Yusuf 'Innal hukm ila lillah'. Indeed, the right of ruling/judgment/legislation is only for Allah. And elsewhere 'Wa la yushrik fee Hukmi'i ahad' and He (Allah) does not accept partners in His Hukm (ruling/judgement/legislation).
“What benefit is there of me talking about rulers” but he’s perfectly fine talking about the civilians and the ummah and saying it’s our fault and misquoting an ayah from the Quran and applying it to us but doesn’t do the same for these rulers when they’re the ones that have the real power to make change.
unfortunately Muslims are weak in Eemaan, involved in shirk, bidah, sins, not repenting enough, and yet we expect Allaah to respond to our dua's. Time of trials and tribulations Prophet peace be upon him performed Qunut for a month. May Allaah azza wa jall have mercy on the ummah Muhammad peace be upon him and forgive our sins, may Allaah azza wa jall give victory to Palestine and disgrace the evildoers. Aameen
I don't follow brother Imran coz I have always felt he is a wild character. But I think he is right about dua vs protests. You're just side by side with many non mahrams around you and having really less gap between each other in protests. And many protests have Palestinian national songs like "dammi falastini" which is haram for us to listen to. And by protesting you're begging kuffar for hours. Why not beg, cry and plead as much to the Greatest, the Almighty who is on our side? And not sure why Dilly thinks a lot of muslims are doing this already. None of you would know someone who is making dua for hours, but you would all know someone who has been to a protest. Most muslims like brother Imran said never even heard there's a dua in a time of war. Some muslims going to these protests can't even name 2-3 of the MANY times that Allah has said dua is accepted.
Well ..... I think Mansur did a good job expressing his feelings and how we should always protect ourselves before action but ........ the guy interviewing Mansur didn't contribute anything to the discussion either, so it is as you've described ... he's clearly probing the brother. He needs to be manhaj checked
Salafiyyah in terms of following the aqeeda and the akhlaq of the first 3 generations i 100% subscribe to that , but the salafyia of making tabdee of anyone who disagrees with u , or bootlicking goverment and calling anyone who criticises rulers a khariji then i dont belong to that type of salafyah
61:9. He is the One Who has sent His Messengers with ˹true˺ guidance and the religion of truth, making it prevail over all others, even to the dismay of the polytheists. Allah sent his messengers to make his religion prevail over all other religions, our problem today is most of the sects and groups intentions aren’t to make Islam prevail but to make their group or scholars or rulers prevail. This is why we are so divided.
True but Dilly was talking about the protests that HT do towards the embassies that are Muslim only and follow shariah when it comes to free mixing and calling for a correct solution. Not the general left leaning ones that you see on the tv or youtube with 100,000 people
Barak'Allahu Feek Dawah Man, i can see bunch of lay people in these comments or Kids with emotions ( following there desires). There's no victory without Qur'an and Sunnah. I'm in German here 99% of the people who are cursing Muslim leaders day and night can't even perform their 5 daily prayers and how can they help our Muslim brothers and sisters through Qur'an and Sunnah. Lets go back to Qur'an and Sunnah and we'll surely have victory. How can you be sinning openly as Muslim and you want the victory from Allah Azzawajal?
I must say I am not a fan of Imran and although I don’t agree with all his stances, in this podcast he spoke a lot of sense. May Allah swt forgive us all.
Imran is missing the point, Dua and Amal is the Prophetic way. Amal without Dua is deficient and Dua without Amal is deficient. If he agrees that protesting is not a bidah, what's he talking about? I think this brother would benefit from learning what a continuum is. The protest that seeks unlawful violence or rebellion is the protest that is not allowed and not every protest belongs to that category. This simplistic thinking is sad.
When You look at it br imran makes sense its better to stand in salah than protest, beg Allah but most of us cant even turn up for salah and we expect victory.
@@khairt1731 I wasn't talking about boycotting. My point was regarding protesting its a waste of time no outcome and numerous sinning involved like free mixing missing salah disorder. Etc etc better to gather together in salah and beg Allah.
@@ammar6937 yea speaking out with no benefit, people have been protesting for years but homes and land is still been occupied daily palestinians prisoned n now gaza still being attacked like i said it's better to gather in salah and let's all return to the deen n Allah will give us victory. Insh Allah
@@LPlays7 are you sure theres no benefit... That's like saying people making dua is no benefit since they're still being bombed... Alot more people have woken up to the whole situation and there intentions of the leaders around the world... To say there's no benefit is extremely ignorant
To assume he's hurting the ummah is a very BIG statement without proof, I would advise to only listen to these videos and not comment if ur not a student of knowledge. And that goes for anyone and not just you, you can say something that doesn't seem big now but on the day of judgement it's the size of a mountain. Be very cautious of what leaves your mouth brother. جزاك الله خيرا
I'm assuming (please correct me if I'm wrong) Ali Dawah uploaded this. What do you gain Ali or anyone from Spubs files from this rather nebulous upload? Other uploads had a clear critical position of Spubs, but this upload is quite ambiguous. Are you endorsing Imran, are you grouping him with Spubs (which he has no affiliation with as stated previous many times) or is this a separate agenda? I love the work of Spubs files because it rightly calls out those fanatic Spubs and their cult. But this one is left ambiguous and ambiguity is what the devil's playground as the saying goes.
Brother Imran, is making was the only thing that the prophet did? Then why do we see so many battles, both offensive and defensive during the prophet’s life time. The people who go to the protests has a higher probability that they are making Duas in their private than those who do not go to. I think you are trying to demotivate people from going to protests by saying to make Duas for 5/6 hours. Because it is in line with the government policy. Allah isn’t punishing Palestinian for their sins, it’s more likely that Allah is testing us as to what we are doing to help them. By the way I am not against making Duas for anything and anyone. But I Do think that it became an excuse for many lazy ones. May Allah guide us to the right path. Aameen.
Imran speaking Haqq Nd in accordance to the Sunnah and our Scholars, even if the majority do not like it. Us Muslims expect victory but they shun the Sunnah that will help them to attain it.
No one is saying we shouldn’t do dua, in fact it’s the most important action. But why can’t we boycott? It’s coz it will also affect jahill and munafiq leaders in ‘Muslim’ countries like Saudi and UAE?
Fear Allah, you know what he meant if you understood and made effort to understand what Allah ordained. if in todays situation resistance is the solution than make dua for Allah to strengthen you to walk the talk. Make duas to walk the talk that’s what he meant. May ﷲﷻ guide us all, wahan is the disease ummah is inflicted with and it’s rooted deep. Love of duniyah and hate for death. the Rabbi Annī massaniya-ḍ-
We don't need to speak about the rulers and call them names. However some brothers will defend their actions to the core. That's where some of us have problems. It's important to differentiate between ruling in a Halal way and Haram.
Allah (swt) made Br. Imran who guided me to the deen, idk where would i be without Allah's guidance.
May Allah bless this Amazing brother for all his great work in the Deen for the Youth.
Ameen❤
😂
Ameen. he’s helped gangsters become students of knowledge
Ameen ya rabb!
I changed my mind on Imran, I see growth. May Allah bless him
I see backpedaling
@@tiktokasylum5186 I'm not saying he's fully there yet, but alhamdulillah he seems to be maturing. Maybe he has regrets Allahu alam
Get me a Badr club membership
@@redx11x nah never that! LOL
@@axis2312 bro, he was disgraceful, what don't you get. He was using the name Badr 313 in relation to the noble Sahabah who sacrificed their everything at Badr.
An absolute disgrace to attempt to tie that to materialism. His advert for it spoke volumes, fast cars, bed with roses (sex), living it up in Dubai (a shaytanic place).
All for what? Copying the Andrew Tate and others, copying their stupid style of machoism, making money off the lost youth by trying to put an Islamic wrapper on it.
It was pathetic. He should hide his face in shame.
Well done Dilly. And respect to Imran he seems a genuine guy that is slowly becoming wiser
Do dua and nothing else?
A muslim does dua and then proceeds to act, why is this man trying to destroy brain cells ?
These people always say obey ...obey the corrupt rulers over Muslims , obey the kufar killing Muslims...what is this . Astagfirullah. May Allah help us. We make Dua and act.
I didn't understand that from the video. Basically he said duaa is a sunnah of the Prophet SAWS that we should follow. Himself is boycotting France. Duaa is action, boycot too.
@@markward3981 well perhaps this is where the problem is with what you're saying and the many Muslims who regurgitate your line of reasoning. the problem is you still haven't made the distinction between the opinion of knowledgeable Muslims and Quran and Sunnah. that which comes from the Quran and Sunnah must be obeyed. but as for the opinions from the knowledgeable, that can have discussions and disagreements.
my advice is refer to the Quran and Sunnah as opposed to just airing out your disagreements and frustration with people.
UK salafi dawah bubble has been burst. Now that Saudi & UAE has stopped funding that najdi dawah & more focusing on funding individuals like Farris. More and more ppl will leave Salafism and follow traditional Sunni Islam again.
Animated pfp.
What are you on? Salafism is traditonal sunnism
@@zahin2986 “Some people have the disease of criticising all the time. They forget the good about others and only mention their faults. They are like flies that avoid the good and pure places and land on the bad and wounds. This is because of the evil within the self and the spoiled nature.”
- Ibn Taymiyyah
Good point
@@almercishie2901 disease nah I liked anime as well time to leave childish thoughs . Most genre of anime Pushes kufr agenda AOT ain't different and Eren smh .
Here's what I feel is Br. Imran's point regarding protests (with some of my thoughts):
Don't be the one who
✅ Goes to a protest from 2 - 6 hours
❌ Doesn't wake up for tahajjud to make salah and dua for victory like the Prophet did and Allah commanded (recommended in the Quran)
❌ Doesn't stay between salaahs to make dua for victory like the Prophet did and Allah commanded
❌ Doesn't go to a masjid the 20 minute walk away to make salah like the Prophet did and Allah commanded. If this was the case the protesters are also going to the masajid, would the masajid still be empty?
How can we have an impact if we're not doing what the Prophet ASWA did and Allah commanded first and foremost and we're jumping to protests before that?
P.S. Loved this. I loved seeing the unity. The ummah is coming together Alhamdulillah!
These things are not mutually exclusive and thus this is a straw-man argument.
And Saudi or Gulf scholars saying not to protest because Saudi and Gulf governments do not generally allow various types of protests don't necessarily apply to the West, where the governments specifically allow protesting and even encourage them as a means of seeing what the people want.
Good points
But here is a thought
.do you think everyone at the time of prophet made dua the same way? They spend the same energy and efforts or it varied??? Does the iman of each and every muslim in medina the same or it varied? Does the importance of actions can be brushed aside just because masses may not be following sunnah in terms of making dua?? When i read seerah i see all kind of muslims, some steadfast, some shaky, some confused and then there were munafiqoon, i believe societal structure will always reflect this composition and insisting on not trying to do actions just because you dont see results should not be the criteria
*Also those in battle field are consistent because of duas and quran there s nothing else that hold their hearts and assuming otherwise is reckless
@@asmazohaib85 Salaam - Thank you for the thought, please please please watch the full video it's extremely refreshing and addresses some of your points. What I said doesn't negate that they were all the same or undermining the importance of actions, dua is an action, sabr is action, resistance is an action, protest/boycott is an action. There is always a direct result. Allah always accepts the sincere dua and the time of the response is with Allah's hikmah. I would also point to the words of Salahuddin Al Ayubi RahimahuAllah wa Radiallahu Anhu, when he passed by a group of his soldiers up in tahajjud he would say "It is through this consistent [qiyaam/tahajjud] that we are given victory". Do we want to have victory like salahuddin Ra? I thinks he's more of an expert of freeing Palestine than anyone alive today. May be we aught to try what he said works and focus on a lot more.
Allahu alaam - just my refelctions. I would also suggest you watch The Thinking Muslim Podcast with Dr. Tariq Swaydaan - very very powerful and fearless, especially coming from a person in the Gulf which many may not expect. It left me very optimistic in this generation Alhamdulillah.
@@ABFYI23 walikumassalam brother i watched the whole section, and i pointed out that not everyone would be making duas the way brother s referring to, since people vary in their spirtuality and they did vary at the time of prophet too, also doesnt mean there s absence of dua and certainly not among people who are actually battling at the very moment, it s obvious that their only survival instinct and their spirit is based on making dua doing azkar and connecting to quran. I do know brother acknowledges Palestinians resilience and iman but i did feel he differentiated them from those in battlefield (just a feeling i guess). Ofcourse i do think that khabri ahadith where we r told that rulers would be the devils in the image of human doesn't abstain muslims from accounting rulers. It should be as vital as making dua, because for me display of an "open kuffer" is not mere denouncing islam with words but it s also usury, allying with west, making hypocritical remarks(as pointed that there r leaders who took part in protest but they said they rnt going to severe ties with israel) and i gather this understanding from several ayah of quran where Allah swt talk about those who decide as per their wishes abondoning the hukm of Allah swt or where Allah swt scolded Jews that u take certain part of the scripture and reject certain parts. For me the very essence of quran is to be applied in full context it cant be abondoned on desire and if a ruler do so than thats a public display of rejection of hukmullah which i understand is different than a ruler who is tyrant and violates my rights or exploit my wealth!!! I will try to watch the podcast u refer to in sha Allah. JAZAKAALLAH ul khair
@@asmazohaib85 JazakiAllah khair for the shedding more light on it. I would very much agree with that perspective especially with the point on hypocrisy and accountability. Waiyaakum
He said democracy is permissible or not.
Of course it is not permissible. It allows people to change laws in accordance with desires.
Democracy is valid only in terms of selection of a suitable Khalifa, but then all laws implemented must be laws of Allah SWT. Like no riba institutions in the land, or no alcohol shops in the land, or no open zina allowed.
Yeah I think he doesn’t disagree with your statement.
wrong. democracy is haram . the prophet ﷺ didn't do democracy, it comes from kuffar
Brother Imran showed great maturity in that podcast. The conversation showed a clear distinction between him and the bootlicker madkhalis.
He just waffles and spoke no sense as usual proving he is the same ignorant madkhali and a fraud promoting harram scam
He is still a bootlicker, though yes not to the madkhali degree
why do you assume that he is also a bootlicker? on which manhaj is he?@@-------....___
@@Colloneld it’s obvious when he came onto the rulers.
You should fear Allah, you will be asked about your slander on the day of judgement@@-------....___
I am personally incapable of taking Dawah Man seriously
What did he say wrong?
@@zakisenseithe knowledge is 0 from dawah man
@@zakisenseihe made mistakes in the past which these people cannot overlook I think
@@miladprive5163out of genuine curiosity do you take from ali dawah and mohammed hijab? Because the knowledge coming from them is also 0. In the negatives from ali
@@AK-ot4yb Did Ali Dawah hurt you in the past? Why you so emotional and upset?
Brother Imran has changed a lot in the last 2 years for the better. I might disagree with some things he has said in the past but this was a wonderful podcast Brothers Dilly and Imran
Really no need for the explicit description of homosexual acts. Or for the animated shouting by Imran.
But when Hijab does it it’s okay 😂😂
The Ruling on Demonstrations
By Shaykh Nasir al-Fahd
Question:
What is the ruling on demonstrations? What are the evidences for its permissibility? And what are the evidences for its prohibition?
Answer:
The issue of demonstration is a long one, and I will summarize my words regarding it by saying:
Some of the brothers that said that demonstrations are permissible researched in the Sunnah after evidences for this, so they mentioned for example the famous hadith of Abu Hurayrah regarding the neighbor[1], something which is these days referred to as "rousing the public opinion", the source for this hadith is in Sunnan Abi Dawud.
And also they use the hadith of Abdullah bin Iyas bin Abi Dhubaba where women complained (in front of the Prophet [SAW]) regarding their husbands (i.e. a female demonstration)[2], and this is also narrated in Sunnan Abi Dawud.
But all of this isn't necessary (to prove it's permissibility), because the rule is: "Nothing is legislated in this Religion except what Allah has legislated, and nothing becomes forbidden except what Allah has forbidden." So the rule is regarding worship ('ibadah) is that of tawqif (i.e. not permissible to exceed beyond), so there's a must to provide an evidence for it.
And the rule regarding customary things ('aadaat) is that they are in general permissible. So whoever forbids something is asked to provide an evidence (dalil) for it, this is the fundamental rule (asl) regarding this.
So whoever permitted demonstrations and holds to this fundamental rule, then he is of no need to bring forth any evidences, because nothing is haram except what Allah has made haram. And even if one brought forth evidences to prove this, then it's being generous.
So what's left for us is to see what those that forbid demonstrations have for evidence, then afterwards we can answer them and let the issue be finished (over with).
The most famous evidences that they have are three: That it is an innovation (bid'a), that it is imitating the disbelievers, that it is forbidden as a means to block an evil (sadd al-dhara'i) which leads corruptions (fasad).
1) With regards to their argument that it's a bid'a, then this is false (batil). Because bid'a is in matters pertaining to worship ('ibadah), not customary things ('aadaat). And thus there isn't any need for redundancy of words to show that this argument is void.
2) With regards to their argument that is imitating the disbelievers, then this is also false. For history is filled with people gathering and marching and demanding something.
And go back to the history of Uthman (RA) and go back to the history of al-Basrah and al-Kufa in the latter half of the first century (hijri), and see how plentiful these sort of demonstrations were. This isn't to prove that its something legislated or permissible, rather it is evidence that it isn't from the issues of imitating the disbelievers.
3) And regarding their argument that its something that leads to corruption (fasad), then this is not correct. Because we see it taking place everywhere and there is no corruption that takes place like which they claim will come about.
Rather great benefits (masalih 'adhimah) have come through it, like the overthrowing of the Egyptian taghut (i.e. Mubarak).
And his overthrowing - even though it didn't bring forth a Islamic governance - eased the injustice and tyranny, and it brought forth some justice that weren't there during his (i.e. Mubarak) time.
This is a quick summary regarding this issue, and Allah knows best.
___________________________________________________________
The source for the Fatwa is "Fatawa al-Ha'iriyyah", a compilation of fatwas by the Shaykh from inside the prison of al-Ha'ir, KSA.
So basically not a single one of the 2 billion muslims on this earth are following islam properly, cus no one dua being accepted. Including his.
According to him the Palestinians aren’t praying enough.
For PLSTN issue, protesting very useful.. Cuz that is a part of to win opinion media...
We make dua and we also make donations, protests and boycotts. In my opinion we are obliged to also take action. For us in the West protests puts pressure on the governments and the Israeli governemt fears boycott. With the leave of Allah we will be successful. We should strive and do whatever we can. It is a strange comparisons some brothers make.
Wow u really thik that they fear 1%muslim population in america boycotting
Why do some people who call themselves salafis have a self-righteous approach and assume that they are the only ones who pray, fast, have tawheed and make lots of dua and other Muslims don’t. Of course, the general message that you should pray and make lots of dua is correct. However, Muslims should be doing this regardless of the Palestinian/Gaza issue. Also, the Prophet ﷺ and the Sahaba made lots of Dua and they fought in the way of Allah and Allah Gave them victory.
That itself is an assumption of a persons intentions, wheres the husn ath than?
Theres facts and assumptions, the facts are, majority of people at these protests dont pray 5 times a day. Yet they’re going out to seek aid of a government who's motives are clear and wont change.
In a time where no government will stand, aid can only be saught from Allah.
The ummah needs quality muslims following the quran and the sunnah the way the sahabah understood it
@@MrSizzleDrizzle Yes, I agree I shouldn’t have used the word assumption. What I actually meant was that there are some salafis or some Muslims even who sometimes act as if they are on the Haq and everyone else is off it.
Because their starting point is that our condition is indirectly proportion with our collective level of Iman... In other words, if the mu'mineen were "true believers" they would succeed...
They discount the fact that a mu'min takes a proactive role within their localities/society's/community's, etc.
This outlook is a remnant of the Quietism of the Wahhabi/Al-Saud alliance of the 20th century...
It is not something that is necessarily done on purpose or with a nefarious intent, it could very well be that they truly believe this is the way forward... (do consider that this is the methodology they have imbibed from their respective scholars (usually Saudi scholars)).
Because when you ask those ones who protest, they say it themselves. "Brother I know I don't pray but we need to protest to bring awareness". I heard it with my own ears from many. Hijabless women also and free mixing. It's a mockery to the deen and it's an insult to Allah, thinking he's not watching you
@@obaid5761 I haven’t seen or heard Muslims at the protest ever say that they don’t pray. Could you please provide any articles or videos etc. I’m not into protesting but to say that it doesn’t bring any awareness is false. If it makes headline news, then that is awareness. As for hijabless women and freemixing, then you will get that as soon as you leave your house.
Dua but also Action
He don't believe in tying his camel.
What is the practical action? That will lead to results?
@@AK-ot4yb 6 months and no one answered your question lol. they have no response
Nothing wrong with what he said and it’s nice how he differentiates between Salafis and so-called salafis who have excessive ghuluw for the hukaam
What did he differentiate he is a bootlicker and they are shoe lickers
@@abdullahassaffahLOOOOOL 😂
I'm 💀🤣
And you are a mouse hiding behind the keyboard......@@abdullahassaffah
Their not salafis , the correct term should be mutasallif..and yes , they are khawarij
Learnt a few hadeeth and ayah and he’s better then everyone else. Pure wasteman he’d rather bump he’s Muslim brothers and take the mick out of the badry sahaba and think his brothers are actively thinkjnf about standing next to homosexuals. What a muppet.
He literally stated that he takes account of himself before anyone else yet you’re slandering him by assuming he thinks he is better than everyone else? Okay cool maybe you don’t like him personally for whatever reason but be fair brother.
More of these types of discussions are needed. Good rationale conversations where 2 may differ on a topic. This is the way
Imran did an applauding job, nothing I can criticize him on. I'm sure he said "Democracy permitted or not" for the sake of argument.
Showing strength to the enemy is a huge virtue, there are 7 days in a week and protest is held maximum 3 days usually 1 to 2 days of the week you have rest of the week to do dua for longer hours if you can't do it on the day you decide to go protest! The huge number of participants in the recent protest shows the strength for the support of the Palestinians, and I'm pretty sure it rocked the politicians boats! 500 thousand people coming out is no joke the politicians won't take it lightly and this is why we can see they sre trying to ban it! You may not see a ceasefire yet but there are changes happening even on a miniscule! Lets not go if the prophet ( may peace and blessings be upon him) went on a protest or not he sure didn't go on a podcast to discuss matters! Times are different and you need to adapt with time so long as it doesn't go against the Sharia!
The assumption that the ummah is not making dua is so self righteous and absurd.. And reminds me of the hadith that says that the one who says the ummah is finished - he is the one who finished them.
There are also battles the Rasul ﷺ lost even after making duas. It's all in the hands of The Most High.
This dude seems to think dua is directly related with real world effects, to the point where your dua is answered the very next hour. The Muslims have been making dua for 80 years for falasteen, that shouldn't stop them from having a proactive role.
At the end of the day Imran said protests are okay, but dua is better.
We say dua is of course the best, but protests and boycott is the minimum we can do for our brothers and sisters dying in Palestine because our 'leaders' are useless.
At least he did not make takfir, or call the people protesting deviants or innovators, like the madkhalis do.
Protest is an attempt to change the Munkar with the tongue.
@@misterbk1791 what? Women alone? Where did this come from? Who is talking about women alone?
He is talking about homosexual men at the protest, you are talking about women alone.
Need to clean your minds.
And what is minimum then? You have made dua, and everything else you can do solo. You cannot say anything to rulers because according to madkhalia ruler is infalliable. So what else can you do besides either fight, boycott or protest?
Do you even think before you speak?
@@briancordero7674of course. We can either boycott, fight, or protest. We can’t really fight as the ‘Muslim’ armies are controlled by taghuts, let’s try to do anything else to save our Muslim brothers and sisters in Palestine.
@@-------....___do you genuinely believe protests and boycotting will actually work؟ because this is the same routine every single time israel attacks for the past however manh years. Why the hell do you think this time will be any different? Isnt that madness expecting different result by doing the same thing over and over again?
@@AK-ot4ybI already explained. The only reason Israel stop killing them is because of protests across the world and boycott. People, muslims and non-muslims, trying to force their governments to step up, whilst 'muslim leaders' were making deals with Israel. Stop asking stupid questions. Or did you think they stopped killing before because of your masters in the gulf?
He's not wrong. Dua is important and we shouln't neglect it BUT he's being too black and white. This is the problem with these guys, he can believe what he wants, you can't just blanket that over everyone. . and this assumption that people who chose to protest are not making dua is judgemental and honestly silly. He's encouraging somwthing good by saying all these silly things inbetween like "make dua make dua.." followed by "lets assume for a second that the protest is not bidah .." or "Im not judging anyone" and then makes judgements about people pritesting. Thats off putting.
He needs to stay in his box 😂 I agree he is black and white
Most young duats are black and white because it doesn’t need much wisdom and intellect to copy and paste daleel. Knowledge and wisdom are 2 different things and one needs to have a clean heart to correctly apply the knowledge. Otherwise it is tasting honey without the sweetness.
Imran was good in this podcast ngl
Well, I disagree with Imran on his khurooj stance, but at least he saw the the nonsense of the madkhalis against Libya. The madkhalis did the same with Egypt and tried to the same with Qatar.
Salam, What happened in Libya Qatar and Egypt? My knowledge of middle east geopolitics is poor. Barakallahu feek
@@sj4695the madkhalis only care about one Hadith; obey the rulers, cannot criticize them, cannot rebel against them.
Then the same say it’s okay to do all that to other countries and leaders like Egypt, Qatar, Libya, Turkey, Gaza etc.
Highest level of hypocrisy.
Ibn Abbas reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “None of the people rebel against the ruler by as much as a handspan and die but that he will have died a death of ignorance.”
Source: Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 1849
Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Muslim
عَنِ ابْنِ عَبَّاسٍ عَنْ رَسُولِ اللهِ صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ لَيْسَ أَحَدٌ مِنَ النَّاسِ خَرَجَ مِنَ السُّلْطَانِ شِبْرًا فَمَاتَ عَلَيْهِ إِلَّا مَاتَ مِيتَةً جَاهِلِيَّةً
1849 صحيح مسلم كتاب الإمارة باب وجوب ملازمة جماعة المسلمين عند ظهور الفتن
@@Anonymous-jj8yw The Hadith is talking about rebellion and not criticizing the rulers.
@@Anonymous-jj8ywshow me from Quran and Sunnah that the leaders of today are legitimate.
Points that Imran Ibn Mansur could not answer:
1. The early muslims protested against the kuffar of Quraish - protested against the shirk and lifestyle (the order) they were committed to.
2. Why are you assuming muslims are not already making dua? (no husn-ad-dhann for muslim ummah)
3. Why did Allah give victory to the muslim ummah previously when there was corruption and people were still committing sins?
4. Why is there a disproportionate blame on the muslim laity compared to the hukaam who have the ability to help?
If protests aren't beneficial, then imran needs to go to palistine and fight on the frontline Asap!!!!
May Allah have mercy on the one who knows his place. May Allah guide Imran. Ameen.
May Allah ease our brother Dilly’s heart. This conversation must have been painful for him.
Imran was reasonable. He didn't say anything absurd. Watch the whole thing.
@@k1003944youre a delusional wahabi
@@k1003944 Why did Ibn Tayyimyah protest?
@@k1003944 and what he said was incorrect. Al Hamdulillah we know the correct Salafiyah ways, duaa and taking action. Duaa alone will not suffice. A pot of gold will not descend from the heavens if I made duaa for 100 years. However I can find it if I took the action to look for it. This is the sibgha/fitra/sunnah of Allah in this dunya. You are trying to confine Islam in a monastery, this is not the wassatiya deen.
@@m_shakes watch the full podcast.
I don't understand the argument, when one is marching (walking) he can make dua in his mind so doesn't it become 2in1?
Also these protests are raising huge awareness and to dismiss it as mothing is confusing.
Anyway, I can't talk about whether protesting is halal or haram since I don't have the shari expertise.
Only Allah really knows, but brother Imran has always struck me as a very sincere brother.
Has he made mistakes and questionable decisions? Well he is a human being so of course he has, but seeing his extremely humble origins giving da'wah as a young man with 'Ali and noting how much he has done for the youth in the UK, it is nearly impossible to convince me (and many others) that he doesn't genuinely want the best for the ummah in the UK and globally.
May Allah bless and forgive him as well as brother Dilly.
I thought I was gonna have more respect for Dawah Man when I heard he agreed to come on Dilly’s podcast. However based on a few clips I have seen of him reugitating the same nonsense (as well as having a filthy mind in regards to who you may be next to in a protest), I suppose that this podcast only reaffirmed my thoughts of him.
Really he said nothing bad . In the end he added do protest as you like .
Watch the whole thing
He was referring to the brothers that go and protest with LGBTQ+ people who call for a ceasefire. Have good thoughts about your brother. Especially in these dire times.
Yeah. I have seen him talking about men penetrating other men on other topics as well. Don’t know why he keeps bringing that up.
Their starting point is that our condition is indirectly proportional with our collective level of Iman... In other words, if the mu'mineen were "true believers" they would succeed...
They discount the fact that a mu'min takes a proactive role within their localities/society's/community's, etc.
This outlook is a remnant of the Quietism of the Wahhabi/Al-Saud alliance of the 20th century...
It is not something that is necessarily done on purpose or with a nefarious intent, it could very well be that they truly believe this is the way forward... (do consider that this is the methodology they have imbibed from their respective scholars (usually Saudi scholars)).
Mankind was [of] one religion [before their deviation]; then Allāh sent the prophets as bringers of good tidings and warners and sent down with them the Scripture in truth to judge between the people concerning that in which they differed
Allah sent the books for mankind to judge between eachother ie to rule by, so how can these so called salafis say that changing the sharia is minor.
Wallahi brothers say what you want about imran but Allah used him as a means for me to start understanding the deen properly and practicing it for that I am forever grateful.
I hope and pray to Allah that we see a reunion from dawah man and Ali dawah, the real ones know they started off dis ting together😂❤ in sha Allah they reunite one day and make a video together would love to see that.
What's so bad about what imran said
So their logic is that do not go against the Hukam and even if they are doing evil and are in Fitna do not raise your voice and do not protest. So stay calm and watch the Saudi concerts and enjoy Lahul...
This is the logic?
The point is that it sounds like brother Imran assumes duaa is not being done. But to be fair, he is just saying to make duaa and going into depth about the topic.
no hes reminding the muslims just like Allah commanded in the Quran. a lot of people in these comment section are assuming bad things about the brother when all he's doing is mentioning Quran and hadith. and I agree with him protesting wont do nothing Dua will.
😅😂😂😂😂😂 speechless
He is completely wrong.
The Sahabah fought battles in the way of Allah SWT. Could they have just made dua and Allah SWT responded? Allah SWT helped them in the battles, but they also fought and died for Allah SWT. Who made more dua and dhikr of Allah SWT than the Prophet PBUH? And was his life very easy? No. The Prophet PBUH remembered Allah SWT all day and all night, and still had to do governance, politics, religion, battle etc. all in Allah SWT's name.
Dua is worship, one of the highest forms of worship. But action must be accompanied with it.
If for example you are looking to get married, or looking for a job, yes of course you make dua for Allah SWT to help you, but you have to be proactive as well. You need to apply for jobs, make sure you get correct qualifications etc. You cannot just sit at home and make dua and expect Allah SWT to hand things in your hands. You make dua, you try your best, and then if Allah SWT wills it, you will get it.
The madkhalis just want you to pray at home, make dua at home, then don't bring Islam outside the house.
I dont understand why cant you make ducaa as priority and also protest not for the sake of protesting but just not to empty the scene for the zionest and thier lovers to spread their narrative?!
He said it's fine!
Omer r asked in khutba, how you people correct me when I am wrong? They showed him their sword, by this.
Its called man up and take self accountability.
It all stemmed from the masses thats are a bigger harm than the minority
Totali agree with him
Sorry but Imraan is a charismatic charlatan who has very unlogic and problematic positions. Someone with good firasa sees through him. He is sugarcoating Madkhali positions. Also his conscious exaggeration in speech are communication tactics and he is aware of this. He needs to stop the act and act authentic and be himself. Its almost as if you can sense some hints of megalomania.
Despite this, may Allah accept his good duas for palestine if he makes them for his brothers and sisters.
Wtflip? Dude, why are you using unnaturally complicated words for, it feels so ironic that you seem to be doing exactly what you are accusing him of
Explain his unlogic and problematic positions? Please explain. You sound like a scholar labelling people charlatan.
What is this about ch ?
Totally agree.
He is a disguised madkhali. Just as madkhalis say don't protest, don't raise a voice against their rulers, just stay at home and pray and make dua and just look at yourselves, don't talk about the ummah or any problems.
@@-------....___ watch the podcast then talk .
Not to argue the point of protests being permissible or impermissible but He mentioned that the Prophet Muhammad pbuh made dua. But was that dua not coupled with the action of fighting or did he just say Khalas Allah can kill them in 1 strike because I did my job of dua.
Even if the protestersor the Ummah at large were negligent in making dua does he not think that the Palestinians themselves are not making dua day and night.
Is he shifting from the madkhalis madness and leading to a more balance position?
Don’t think so, when he went to the rulers, he was very uncomfortable. Absolute obedience to secular individual rulers is a trait of the madkhalis and he still has it
What made you think he was madkhali in the first place. Spubs people refuted those who dont follow their shaykh which includes Imran and more.
@@RaihoSan Madkhalis hold rulers and their scholars above Sahabah. So does Imran from the looks of it.
My only criticism was that he hid and ducked away from speaking on the rulers. He didn’t want to go near it which was expected, but most of what was said by Imran was correct
If that is imrans stance (to not speak against the rulers), what is the issue? What will him speaking agaisnt them really do? Ive seen other speakers speak against the rulers and what does that achieve? I havent seen anything positive come about from that.
@@AK-ot4yb Well maybe if enough people speak against them, enough people wake up from this trance of the madkhali absolute obedience, we may get to put better leaders in.
Your solution, like the madkhalis, is just to stay quiet.
@@-------....___ where from the quran and sunnah has this been mentioned and promoted؟ What is the basis of your revolutionary talk؟ Or is the quran and sunnah just useless theory that we dont need to stick to؟
@@AK-ot4ybwhere in Quran and Sunnah is it allowed to have multiple leaders and countries.
As for speaking against tyrants, there are many Hadith. There is Quran to always speak truth. Also, there are many examples of Sahabah criticizing and rebelling against rulers.
But back to my question. Quran and Sunnah where multiple leaders are allowed. Don’t run from the question now.
@@AK-ot4ybyou have said Imran not speaking against the rulers is his stance. That means he is applying hadiths that were meant for Amir, KHALIFA, Imam, onto taghut secular multiple leaders. Where is this in Quran and Sunnah.
Dawah 'does that make sense' Man
It is now Imran "Does That Make Sense" Ibn Mansur - he has now scrapped Dawah Man
He is not a sheikh, he is not a scholar, he is not teacher, he hasnt even finish his student of knowldge package according to him himself in thwir podcast with his friends...so inviting youtuber and ask question about umma and fataw is weird and wrong
Imran gave a good showing of what Salafiyyah truly is. I'm happy you uploaded this (and hope your uploaded it on good faith rather than trying to mockingly group him with those Spubs cult) so the people can see the Haqq of calling to Qur'an & Sunnah.
Genuinely interested to hear what anyones reservations are regarding what Imran has said in this clip? What do you oppose? Or are you just naturally prejudicing him?
I don’t really see anything wrong he’s said regarding these protests. Did it work in Iraq? 1 million people protesting did nothing. Dua is the believers most effective weapon.
Ok I didn’t see the part regarding Libya. Gadaffi was a kafir tyrant who deserved to be overthrown. Calling him a ruler is a massive error
In this podcast nothing wrong was said.
These guys are embarrassing need to stop making videos after learning one hadeeth
@@abelo2305he's talking about Khalifa haftar
These are my thoughts after listening to the duat who say protesting is useless / taking the means is useless.
The issue of over-emphasising dua over the practical means and steps towards change is that it comes across as if dua and taking the means (protesting, writing to MPs, engaging in politics) are MUTUALLY EXCLUSIVE (meaning they can't coexist).
When in reality, they are intertwined. When these issues are spoken about (palestine, current affairs in the ummah), the emphasis should be split between the 2 - rather than allocating the entirety of a khutba / lecture / energy / narrative to only dua.
I completely agree with you! May allah bless you. I'm actually bored of muslims like him tbh mr chat toooo much but can never actually cash these cheques. Were literally living in a time where everyone's mask has dropped off and we're seeing everybodys true colours.
Dua is the greatest weapon we have. if all that energy that went into the protests was to go into Dua Allah will give us victory. and like he said I personally seen on utube protests where haram is taking place... free mixing etc how is that going to solve anything. when did Allah or the prophet tell you to protest?
@@Mikesco10 when there are means to take, you take them. Dua gives barakah to means. And in this situation - there are many means to take.
Don’t strawman protests by saying because there’s free mixing therefore it’s useless. The entire point of a protest has a righteous goal.
You wouldn’t strawman a job, travelling in public, even Hajj and umrah, or any other part of life by saying because there’s women involved and/or haram elements therefore it’s useless.
@@zeeshanahmed5624 habibi going to hajj is a pillar of Islam protesting is not. no one told you to go protest. and plz explain how protesting is a mean to change whats going on.
@@Mikesco10 If you genuinely want to know how protests help: use common sense, think and research about the implications it has in terms of media, attention to the palestinian plight, unity with muslims and non-muslims for a righteous cause and pressure on governments resulting in political / policy change.
Resarch the teams involved which organise the protests and the work that they do.
Many means are linked and protests are a very effective tool for accelerating all the things listed above - and its entirely legal.
Why Allah reduced salah prayer in war
Since these protests contain haram free mixing, is this not enopught to say these protests are haram?
There is free mixing in 'muslim' countries, and of a worse kind than in a protest.
Are those muslim countries haram?
Exactly
@@Muwazabdulkalimwhat exactly. Imran has gone to give dawah at speakers corner. Is there no free mixing there?
@@-------....___ I think the general point here is trust in Allah azawajal is better than taking matters into our own hands, protest is for self contentment and awareness, never a solution
@@Muwazabdulkalimbut who trusted Allah SWT more, us or the Sahabah. Sahabah spoke out against oppression, Sahabah fought against enemies. They didn’t just sit at home and leave everything to Allah SWT. That is not how this works.
If I want a job, I will not just sit at home and make dua. I will go study, get a degree, apply etc. and will continue making dua. But actions have to accompany dua.
Do you guys even think about what you are saying?
Imran is showing growth because he is starting to realize that you can't grow as a Muslim having a stubborn interpretation in Fiqh, and it being based on the vast knowledge of Ahl Sunna which is available by researching these type of issues.
Q. When the Meccan Quraysh persecuted and oppressed the Muslim community year after year and chased them out from their homes and land and proptery, did the Prophet (pbuh) ever withdraw from commercial or social relations with them or did he continue as normal from Medina?
the muslims at that time were not in a concentration camp
@@jj-yi1ne Agree with you bro.
Iyad ibn Ghanam reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Whoever has advice for the ruler, let him take his hand and give it privately. If he accepts it, then he accepts it. If he rejects it, the duty upon him has been fulfilled.”
Source: al-Sunnah li-Ibn Abī ‘Āṣim 1098
Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani
عَنْ عِيَاضِ بْنِ غَنْمٍ قَالَ قَالَ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ مَنْ كَانَتْ عِنْدَهُ نَصِيحَةٌ لِذِي سُلْطَانٍ فَلْيَأْخُذْ بِيَدِهِ فَلْيَخْلُو بِهِ فَإِنْ قَبِلَهَا قَبِلَهَا وَإِنْ رَدَّهَا كَانَ قَدْ أَدَّى الَّذِي عَلَيْهِ
1098 السنة لابن أبي عاصم باب كيف نصيحة الرعية للولاة
2/523 المحدث الألباني خلاصة حكم المحدث صحيح في تخريج كتاب السنة
And where in Quran and Sunnah is it allowed for Muslims to have multiple countries and multiple rulers?
The Hadith you are quoting is for Amir/Khalifa/Imam of the Muslims.
@@-------....___
Exactly
💯.
And where is it allowed, after the establishment of Medina and liberating Mecca , for thousands of Muslims to permanently live in the land of disbelievers, near kufar , ruled by them who are at war with Muslims.
@@-------....___ the ahadith are not only for the khalifa
Narrated by Ana’s bin Malik:
Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "You should listen to and obey, your ruler even if he was an Ethiopian (black) slave whose head looks like a raisin."
And the Khalifa has to be from quraysh it’s from the conditions of being a Khalifa and there’s other indicators that it is not only for the “khalifa”
@@khaledfatile9932 Yes, and this hadith says nothing about 'multiple leaders'. Stop being jahil.
I wrote in my comment it is for Khalifa/AMIR/IMAM of the muslims. Did you not read it? It means the leader of the ummah, you can even call him a king if he is a king, but singular.
Abu Bakr RA said it is forbidden to have two Amirs of the muslim.
Reply back when you have something to actually say.
@@-------....___ the Khalifah can’t be Ethiopian
i listened to him for 5 mins and went to next video
That may be your issue pal
That’s not good from your side, at least watch all of it then make up your mind.
We have to make dua and zikr, no one is saying we shouldn’t, it’s more important. But we also in addition to this should do things like boycott and protest (within means). Ever heard of the Hadith of tying your camel, and hating evil with your words as well as actions? Why does it have to be binary? It’s these stupid arguments which divide us.
Real G Imran
Ibn mansur your answer
Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him): “Whoever dies without having fought for the sake of Allah or having had the intention of doing so, has died following one of the branches of hypocrisy.” (Saheeh Muslim, no. 3533)
13:10 rah ting
Wait wait wait, how the flip is protesting a bidaa , protesting has got nothing to do with any type of worship infact its got nothing to do with the deen , its just asking for human rights ,
Very shortsighted
He bypasses the whole point completely the prophet ﷺ didn’t just make dua and stay in his house. He made dua and mobilized the efforts he could to gain victory.
Also he makes a mistake about a person making dua in the battlefield. People in the west are not in the direct battlefield they are in another environment with other halal possibilities to work for the cause of Allah in supporting our brothers and sisters in Palestine. And every person I have seen who is concerned about Palestine has been making dua. To think badly of them or start accusing them they don’t make dua is a bit inappropriate.
Also a ruler who commits kufr akbar and nullifies his Islam no longer enjoys the full rights the prophet ﷺ told us to give to a Muslim ruler. As the rulings for a murtad munafiq and Muslim differ in Islam and we can’t misplace those rulings by giving rights which belong to a Muslim to a murtad.
Misplacing ahadith and applying them on the wrong reality is a major catastrophe which enables the enemies of Islam to enjoying rights and comforts which Allah and His Messenger ﷺ negated from them. Lying about the religion by abusing the nusus is a major crime and also a reason for lots of oppression to occur and because people don’t see the fault in the matter they will forever be fooled and never change the wrong they did wa Allahul musta’an
Tie your camel bro, and trust in Allah SWT.
Imran Ibn Mansour needs to be careful with his statements regarding the Book of Allah. He claims that nowhere does Allah mention Democracy being either permissible or impermissible. Well, the definition of Democracy is 'a way of governing, which depends on the will of the people.' This is clearly contrary to Islam, and it is, in fact, Major Shirk and disbelief in Allah ta Ala. Allah mentions in Surah Yusuf 'Innal hukm ila lillah'. Indeed, the right of ruling/judgment/legislation is only for Allah. And elsewhere 'Wa la yushrik fee Hukmi'i ahad' and He (Allah) does not accept partners in His Hukm (ruling/judgement/legislation).
imraan has no logic
“What benefit is there of me talking about rulers” but he’s perfectly fine talking about the civilians and the ummah and saying it’s our fault and misquoting an ayah from the Quran and applying it to us but doesn’t do the same for these rulers when they’re the ones that have the real power to make change.
It was a good podcast . Watch it full then comment.
Have tawakkul in Allah but remember to also tie your camel..
12:52 😂
13:25 😵💫
16:53 💀
"I'm not here to judge no one" - starts judging immediately.
unfortunately Muslims are weak in Eemaan, involved in shirk, bidah, sins, not repenting enough, and yet we expect Allaah to respond to our dua's.
Time of trials and tribulations
Prophet peace be upon him performed Qunut for a month.
May Allaah azza wa jall have mercy on the ummah Muhammad peace be upon him and forgive our sins, may Allaah azza wa jall give victory to Palestine and disgrace the evildoers. Aameen
they dont do shirk. wahabi aqeedah is wrong
@@jj-yi1ne situations are like this bcuz of ppl like you.
@@jj-yi1ne stickl to the Qur'aan and Sunnah.
I don't follow brother Imran coz I have always felt he is a wild character. But I think he is right about dua vs protests. You're just side by side with many non mahrams around you and having really less gap between each other in protests. And many protests have Palestinian national songs like "dammi falastini" which is haram for us to listen to. And by protesting you're begging kuffar for hours. Why not beg, cry and plead as much to the Greatest, the Almighty who is on our side? And not sure why Dilly thinks a lot of muslims are doing this already. None of you would know someone who is making dua for hours, but you would all know someone who has been to a protest. Most muslims like brother Imran said never even heard there's a dua in a time of war. Some muslims going to these protests can't even name 2-3 of the MANY times that Allah has said dua is accepted.
Facts Dua is the 1st
He's arguing it's the only thing, tie your camel.
Against oppression stopping it is first...
Well ..... I think Mansur did a good job expressing his feelings and how we should always protect ourselves before action but ........ the guy interviewing Mansur didn't contribute anything to the discussion either, so it is as you've described ... he's clearly probing the brother. He needs to be manhaj checked
Salafiyyah in terms of following the aqeeda and the akhlaq of the first 3 generations i 100% subscribe to that , but the salafyia of making tabdee of anyone who disagrees with u , or bootlicking goverment and calling anyone who criticises rulers a khariji then i dont belong to that type of salafyah
61:9. He is the One Who has sent His Messengers with ˹true˺ guidance and the religion of truth, making it prevail over all others, even to the dismay of the polytheists.
Allah sent his messengers to make his religion prevail over all other religions, our problem today is most of the sects and groups intentions aren’t to make Islam prevail but to make their group or scholars or rulers prevail. This is why we are so divided.
i don't think he said anything wrong but only that he is calling to his own cult
He hasn’t said anything wrong regarding the protests
True but Dilly was talking about the protests that HT do towards the embassies that are Muslim only and follow shariah when it comes to free mixing and calling for a correct solution.
Not the general left leaning ones that you see on the tv or youtube with 100,000 people
Barak'Allahu Feek Dawah Man, i can see bunch of lay people in these comments or Kids with emotions ( following there desires). There's no victory without Qur'an and Sunnah. I'm in German here 99% of the people who are cursing Muslim leaders day and night can't even perform their 5 daily prayers and how can they help our Muslim brothers and sisters through Qur'an and Sunnah. Lets go back to Qur'an and Sunnah and we'll surely have victory. How can you be sinning openly as Muslim and you want the victory from Allah Azzawajal?
And why wouldn’t they curse the ‘leaders’?
What does 5 prayers have anything to do with leaders?
Are you madkhali?
@@-------....___ How old are you? Don't be a keyboard warrior... this is not an attitude of a Muslim.
I must say I am not a fan of Imran and although I don’t agree with all his stances, in this podcast he spoke a lot of sense. May Allah swt forgive us all.
12:53 😂 why does you're imagination go there bro ? what is wrong with this guy lool very graphic 😂
Hahah so true
He’s right
lol too funny its like he gets excited
Imran is missing the point, Dua and Amal is the Prophetic way. Amal without Dua is deficient and Dua without Amal is deficient. If he agrees that protesting is not a bidah, what's he talking about? I think this brother would benefit from learning what a continuum is. The protest that seeks unlawful violence or rebellion is the protest that is not allowed and not every protest belongs to that category. This simplistic thinking is sad.
Kau sorg lah ter paling sunnah. Kau sorang doa. Org lain x doa.
When You look at it br imran makes sense its better to stand in salah than protest, beg Allah but most of us cant even turn up for salah and we expect victory.
When it comes to Salah Speak for YOURSELF dude.
Boycotting is from the sunnah and its in the seerah
@@khairt1731 I wasn't talking about boycotting. My point was regarding protesting its a waste of time no outcome and numerous sinning involved like free mixing missing salah disorder. Etc etc better to gather together in salah and beg Allah.
@@LPlays7is protesting not a form of speaking out against oppression?
@@ammar6937 yea speaking out with no benefit, people have been protesting for years but homes and land is still been occupied daily palestinians prisoned n now gaza still being attacked like i said it's better to gather in salah and let's all return to the deen n Allah will give us victory. Insh Allah
@@LPlays7 are you sure theres no benefit... That's like saying people making dua is no benefit since they're still being bombed... Alot more people have woken up to the whole situation and there intentions of the leaders around the world... To say there's no benefit is extremely ignorant
May Allah guide him .... this guy makes some great points regarding duaaa but also his thinking is what hurts our Ummah.
Why don't you save us then? Why are you in your room behind a keyboard? Come save the ummah
To assume he's hurting the ummah is a very BIG statement without proof, I would advise to only listen to these videos and not comment if ur not a student of knowledge. And that goes for anyone and not just you, you can say something that doesn't seem big now but on the day of judgement it's the size of a mountain. Be very cautious of what leaves your mouth brother. جزاك الله خيرا
I'm assuming (please correct me if I'm wrong) Ali Dawah uploaded this. What do you gain Ali or anyone from Spubs files from this rather nebulous upload? Other uploads had a clear critical position of Spubs, but this upload is quite ambiguous. Are you endorsing Imran, are you grouping him with Spubs (which he has no affiliation with as stated previous many times) or is this a separate agenda?
I love the work of Spubs files because it rightly calls out those fanatic Spubs and their cult. But this one is left ambiguous and ambiguity is what the devil's playground as the saying goes.
at this point the salafis are all blending together. madkhali or otherwise they're all a disgrace, as Hijab has alluded to before
@@NewSmithsonianstop exaggerating
Br Imran was on point in this podcast not gonna lie.
@@abelo2305 exaggerating? do you even know what that word means?
ty for proving my point lol
“The salafis are all blending together” really? What salafi besides madakhilah are saying this?
Imran didn’t say anything wrong
And Muhammad Hijab he literally praised you in the beginning of the protest and you post this fear Allah
I don't think it was hijab who uploaded this video.
imran praised mohammad hijab on this podcast, so for the whoever is running this channel what is the purpose of sharing this video?
Such a shameful title. Change it. Brother Imran spoke the haq!
Brother Imran, is making was the only thing that the prophet did? Then why do we see so many battles, both offensive and defensive during the prophet’s life time.
The people who go to the protests has a higher probability that they are making Duas in their private than those who do not go to.
I think you are trying to demotivate people from going to protests by saying to make Duas for 5/6 hours. Because it is in line with the government policy.
Allah isn’t punishing Palestinian for their sins, it’s more likely that Allah is testing us as to what we are doing to help them.
By the way I am not against making Duas for anything and anyone.
But I Do think that it became an excuse for many lazy ones.
May Allah guide us to the right path. Aameen.
Imran speaking Haqq Nd in accordance to the Sunnah and our Scholars, even if the majority do not like it.
Us Muslims expect victory but they shun the Sunnah that will help them to attain it.
No one is saying we shouldn’t do dua, in fact it’s the most important action. But why can’t we boycott? It’s coz it will also affect jahill and munafiq leaders in ‘Muslim’ countries like Saudi and UAE?
We should just pray. One day everything will change.
Nah man that not what he said.See the whole podcast.
Free mixing protestsing is haram LOL @@zahin2986
@@thedon8384
Tawaf around the kaba...
Fear Allah, you know what he meant if you understood and made effort to understand what Allah ordained. if in todays situation resistance is the solution than make dua for Allah to strengthen you to walk the talk. Make duas to walk the talk that’s what he meant. May ﷲﷻ guide us all, wahan is the disease ummah is inflicted with and it’s rooted deep.
Love of duniyah and hate for death.
the Rabbi Annī massaniya-ḍ-
Boycott Iphones
We don't need to speak about the rulers and call them names. However some brothers will defend their actions to the core.
That's where some of us have problems. It's important to differentiate between ruling in a Halal way and Haram.
Nobody should take from Dawahman, he’s not of high credentials or ever been recommended by anyone senior in the west.