Your KDP Account May be at Risk - Here's Why
Vložit
- čas přidán 30. 06. 2024
- 🎥 New to KDP? - Start Here: bit.ly/3i3f78K
🎥 KDP Coloring Book Playlist: bit.ly/3NkGjP3
➡️ Creative Fabrica Special Deal: bit.ly/3XLaKoc
KDP account suspensions and terminations appear to be on the rise and there is one particular reason that seems to becoming more coming common. We look at the 3 most common reasons for getting a KDP account terminated, look at the one factor that's becoming more common and some important advice on how to protect your account. Publishing KDP low content and medium content books is a great way to build a passive income which makes protecting your account a priority.
🛠️ Tools and Resources I use:
🟢 Helium 10 (20% off and 10% off Deals): bit.ly/334S3A3
🟢 Gumroad Shop for Keywords and Interiors: paulmarles.gumroad.com
🟢 Canva: bit.ly/paulcanva
🟢 Publisher Rocket: bit.ly/2ThC390
🟢 Book Bolt (Use paul20 to get 20% OFF): bit.ly/3jY7K2L
🟢 Vecteezy: bit.ly/3z6AApA
🟢 Tubebuddy: www.Tubebuddy.com/paultube
00:00 Introduction
00:58 Duplicate Content
05:04 Incorrect KDP Categories
07:31 Trademark Infringement
08:18 USPTO Check
08:33 Google Reverse Image Search
📝 Sign up for Newsletter: paulmarles.com/
On this channel I have many free videos on how to create and publish KDP Amazon books and build an online passive income using your computer from home to create a second or full online income. Check out the New to KDP Publishing playlist here: bit.ly/3i3f78K
DISCLAIMER: This video and description contain affiliate links, which means that if you click on one of the product links, I’ll receive a small commission. This helps support the channel and allows us to continue to make videos. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Thank you for your support! The examples in this video are for illustration purposes only. It is your responsibility to check the terms and conditions and license agreement of any software or graphical element you use or download from third party vendors.
EARNINGS DISCLAIMER: This video is for educational purposes only. There is no guarantee that you will earn money using the techniques and ideas in this video. This is not financial advice or investment advice. While it is possible to minimize risk, your investments are solely your responsibility. It is imperative that you conduct your own research. I am merely sharing my opinion with no guarantee of gains or losses on investments. Your level of success in attaining the results claimed in this video will require commitment, hard-work, experience and knowledge. We have taken reasonable steps to ensure that the information in this video is accurate but we cannot represent that the website(s) mentioned in this video are free from errors. You expressly agree not to rely upon any information contained in this video.
About this video - In this video I look at the 3 most common reasons for getting your KDP account terminated and what you can do to prevent it happening.
Paul I just wanted to say a huge thank you to you, your videos changed my life. I stumbled onto one of your videos in April 2021. At the time I had no idea about low content book publishing. I followed your advice and I have now published 300+ books and earn between $1500-$2000 a month. This is the first PURE passive income I have ever had in my life. No costs whatsoever, as I havent used ads. I have also learned so much about design and actually got my first design job a couple weeks ago!
Thank you, thank you, thank you
Please can you send me the link? I have been surfing the net for sometime now on how best to start with kdp amazon, my thoughts are everywhere, too many contents yet I haven't found some good help,I could do with a little guide from you.
How did you start?
Canva? Book bolt? Did you pay for all the high monthly subscriptions? Are there some free good sites one can use?
Wow, that's great to hear. Congratulations and well done on taking action and building an income and turning it into a job as well! And thank you for letting me know. Well done. 👍
@@nwankwoclemmy2651 try looking up Monique Hinton and especially Jungle Scout. Hi to has great useful info. Her info is spread out a little more than jungle scout. Jungle scout in my opinion is very straight and to the point. He shows you step by step with behind the scenes type of info. Very informative. I hope this helps you.
@@elizabethmakua-travis4009 thank you.
Any update or this is a paid comment?
I also have this problem!!!!
During a recent audit of your account, we found content and/or activities that are in violation of our Terms and Conditions. Therefore, we are closing your account effective immediately.
Been binging your channel tonight as my roommates and I are discussing putting together a bunch of our art(okay, mostly their art, they keep me around because I'm good at ideas) into lower content style books like notebooks and whatnot for the heck of it(our rent is getting raised in January, so we're trying stuff). Just wanted to thank you for the tons of information you've got up on CZcams.
That sounds like a great idea. 👍
Very interesting information compared to a year ago. I take it the KDP platform has changed so much! Thank you for the update!
Thank you so much Paul. I will definitely keep this in mind. Have a great week. ☕👏🏼😁
Thank you, and you too.
Paul! Thank you very much for taking the time to make this very useful video! It does clarify things a lot!
You're welcome. Glad you found it helpful.
You offer SO MUCH value in your videos. I'm about five videos in of your great content. Thank you for the information. I've subscribed.
You're welcome and thank you too.
Appreciate the heads up and useful info. Thank you!
You're welcome.
Thanks for the information, very much appreciated.
You're welcome. 👍
I just ran across your channel, I absolutely love your content.
Thank you. Glad you find it helpful.
Thank you so much for your always incredibly informative content. Love how you go into detail and your explanations are always in a very calm and good pace, which helps me even better to understand and take all the information in(English is not my 1st language). Also the listing of your former videos in the description is super helpful, so I can concentrate on a certain topic. My favorite content creator, thank you!🫶
Thank you. Glad you've found the videos helpful. Thank you for watching.
Thanks once again for the very useful tips given and appreciate very much.
You're welcome. Thank you for watching.
Hi Paul. Great videos and learning so much. Having just started I do find the categories problematic. Not sure why KDP doesn't have a stationery option?
Thanks for your videos Paul! Can you do a video on why does my books appear as "Out of Stock"?
Paul Marles ❤❤❤❤
Thank you for the advice .. I love it
You're welcome. Glad you found it helpful.
Thanks Paul,I am grateful
You're welcome.
Very helpful, much appreciated. Thank you
You're welcome.
This is really helpful to reduce our chances of being suspended or banned by Amazon KDP! Thank You So Much for the valuable advices! 🌷🌿
Glad it was helpful!
@@paulmarles HELLO PAUL, I'm having problems in the process of editing images downloaded from Creative Factory & vecteezy, it seems that for Windows users Affinity Designer works differently. maybe you could record another video using one of those programs you mentioned in the video "Gravity designer, Inkscape" or even Affinity Designer for Windows, this time you would have to do it in a detailed step by step.
I was able to get my account reinstated after it was terminated, but mine might be a bit of a different story. I do all of my homework on trademarked terms and copyrights before I use anything in the title, metadata data, images, etc and make sure I have the rights to use whatever I am using for the purposes I am using them for. I also make sure to document I have those rights, or that no trademark exists in the terms I am using. And I document this by taking screenshots, saving documents, etc.
ok I know that sounds like a lot of tedious and time consuming work, but it helped me out in a massive way and here is my story. On Tuesday night my account was terminated for a trademark violation, but because I had done all that tedious work I was able to submit proof that no such trademark existed. My account was reinstated Friday morning and today I got my royalties reinstated, and acknowledgement from Amazon that my account was closed in error, and automatically published the title in question.
Again I know my situation might be a different one to many that are out there, but it does help in a lot of ways to do your homework ahead of time to ensure you are not violating trademarks or copyrights (and if you are unsure, don’t use them, I have not published things before because I wasn’t entirely sure). If you do have the rights to images, etc, be sure you document it and have it ready just incase you need to prove it. And also stay on top of your catalog and constantly check that you are not in violation of trademarks or copyrights. Just because a phrase you use today isn’t trademarked or copyrighted today doesn’t mean it could be in the future and could put you in trouble of violation!
Sorry that was a long winded explanation of my situation, but I thought it was worth sharing. Yeah my method might seem excessive, but it saved me from losing my account entirely.
Thank you for sharing. That's excellent advice and well done on getting your account back. It certainly does pay to be thorough.
Thats great advice for us newbies.
I'm wondering how I can trademark or copyright my own artwork
Thanks for your valuable content! Which editing platform from the once you mentioned would you recommend for a beginner?
The one I mainly use is Affinity Designer. If you learn one you can very easily then use all the others.
Always on point 😌
Thank you. 🙂
Thank you very much for your guidance.....🌷🌷🌷🌷
You're welcome.
Thank you for the advice Captain and i wish you the best Q4
Hey Algerian Eagle, nice to hear from you again. Glad you're still around wathing my little videos. Thank you.
THANK YOU!
You're welcome. Thank you for watching. 🙂
I like you man, positive and professional , good luck.
Thanks Paul for all the valuable information you share. I truly appreciate it.
You're welcome. Thank you for watching.
Thanks 👍 Really helpful your videos, sir.
Kurt
You're welcome. 👍
New subscriber here, thank you for beginners playlist ❤️
Thank you too.
Thank you
Really appreciate all your videos! Just a quick question? Do you put a copyright page in any of your low or medium content books?
No, I don't do that.
Thanks!
You're welcome.
Thanks for your insightful work. Excellent stuff, Paul. I'd value your wisdom around using 'nominative' use of trademarks. For example, we create content like 'Alfa Romeo's of the 1960's'. In it will be period adverts, road tests and buyers guides previously published, but we curate those and add expanded and educational insight into that content by producing written commentary on that content, with forewords and introductions from marque experts etc. etc. We do not wish to contravene KDP policy and will not be using 'Alfa Romeo' logo's (save for design evolution and commentary of same) and we will have a disclaimer pointing out this is 'not an endorsed Alfa Romeo product' etc. Are there any resources that will help us 'do the right thing' here and avoid trouble?
Hey Paul thanks for the advise, only wish I'd come across this sooner. I recently had my account suspended for reasons unknown, still waiting to hear back from KDP. I'm new to all this and have been very careful with my content I'm assuming the Categories are wrong.... categories seem to be problematic and a bit confusing at times. Hopefully they will cut me some slack being a newbie....
Hi. Sorry to hear that. I hope they reinstate your account.
thank you
You're welcome.
KDP does'nt have enough relevant categories for coloring books. I got harassed and have uncategorized all my coloring books
Yes, it can be a problem.
Nice info. Sir
You're welcome.
Very important video, thank you for making it!! So I am creating a book, the name is trademarked but to something that is not related to books at all, can I still use the name? Or I need to find a new name?
You need to to look at the category the trademark is in. Personally, I wouldn't risk it.
Thank you so much sir
You're welcome.
We used to be able to use Canva images. Their license used to actually mention it was ok to use their images commercially in books. Can you please explain how this has changed? I did watch the video now up on Canva, but I'd love you to do a video on this as well explaining it.
Yes please, i need also a Video to it!
Thanks
You're welcome.
Thanks Paul... it's good that I understand real facts now after watching this video that why my kdp account has been terminated... even if I never sold a single low content or medium content book.. after watching some other CZcams videos about adding upto 10 categories... I started to request Amazon to add more categories to all of my books... After watching your video I feel that might be reason for my account getting terminated... But still I don't know the actual reason.. I've sent email also to Amazon to know the reason.. but still no reply... Anyway... Thanks again Paul for educating... 🙏
You're welcome and very sorry to hear you got your account terminated.
I have some guided journals with cover variations. Is there a way to do this so all variations are an option on the same page?
No, there isn't an option for that in KDP unfortunately.
Not an option for sale on the same page but if you use A+ content you can show the variations.
thank you for video,can i make to kdp account in the same ip,with different information?
nope
Wish I'd seen this sooner.
thanks
You're welcome. 👍
With Warhol copyright case now in courts all this may be subject to change, it would seem.
One more thing we see in the KDP forums everyday is "keyword stuffing" the titles. KDP is getting heavy-handed with titles like "The Ultimate Coloring Book for Boys & Girls - Thing 1 Thing 2 Thing 3 Thing 4: Fantasy for Children Ages 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 - large format - over 100 pages (Ultimate Books Series)." KDP will give you a warning that you have to reply to after fixing the title, or they ban your account. A more review-friendly title would be "Coloring Book: Thing 1 Thing 2 Thing 3 Thing 4." That's it. Put the rest in the description. Also, if you do get your account closed, don't create a second one. That results in a permanent ban. If your account gets closed, you have to respond to their emails (check your junk folder) and sort out the issue. Hope this helps. Good luck.
Thanks Paul! I have 2 medium content books /same interior one in color one in BW Different covers of course. I should be okay if I lost in the description BW or Color interior so people know their the same ?
I would avoid doing that. If someone buys both books thinking they are different or have different interiors then it will just lead to a complaint. Amazon may also detect them as being duplicates which can cause a problem.
@@paulmarles okay Thank you!
Hello! As for the copyright part, can I make my own illustration of existing characters or that counts as copyright infringement? :) Thank you!
That would count as trademark infringement as you are still using someone's intellectual property.
Nice one 🌹🌹🌹
Thank you.
Can you make a video on how to edit and update a template you downloaded from creative fabrica?
I'll put it on my list. This video may help: czcams.com/video/930JhGEsHcg/video.html
thank you for all this information but i want to ask like how many books can one publish on amazon kdp before you can get paid?
You get paid in the second month after you;ve mad a sale.
Hello Paul thank you so much for all your advises, so if have a coloriage book and i make the same book bit i just translate the title in 3 languages it's ok or no?
No, that would not be ok. It would cause an issue with duplicate content.
I literally just had my account terminated today! I opened my email to find my account was terminated. I was doing a lot of low content books, planners, and gratitude journals. I have put in an appeal with a deeper explanation other than "misleading title".
I'm sorry to hear that. It seems to be happening a lot lately.
Were you punished for a "misleading title" whether real or not? That's harsh.
Just. Happened to me same reason
Hi Paul, thank you for this information!
I just created a ton of low content books. They are children’s write and draw story book paper. I have a multiple books, they all have different covers but the same interior. And on Amazon I have an image of the books cover and the interior. Is this something that amazon would terminate my account for?
also, i saw something about trademarks. i have a registered business name and a logo i created. And i have been putting that on the back of my books. Is that allowed?
Thank you so much for all the videos you post. They are all extremely helpful!
If it's the same story then that may casue an issue. If a customer bought one of your books and then bought another thinking it would be different then that is where the issue would be. Yes, you;re allowed to put your logo on the book.
Can I use any “creative commons image” for my book covers, without getting into trouble with Amazon?
Can I publish more than one sudoku journal if the content were generated/created uniquely for each journal ?
Yes, you can.
This just happened to me 😝 All cover artwork is mine so I wasn't sure why. Only one title said not available oos. Hope it's back soon as I had just had my first 3 sales. Waiting for the reply from KDP
Congratulations on your first sales! 👍
Please is it adviseable to focus on "All Department" when doing research,or focus on "Books" for research?
Yes, definitely.
Thank you for this video. If I do a book of prompts to be used by a child in a no/low content book and the child writes his thoughts following the prompt to give to a mother or father, could I get my account deactivated for duplicate content since the prompts (created by me) would be the same for a book to mother and a book to father?
That would be possible. The reason is that if you imagine someone buying a book for a child and one for a parent, if I understand correctly that's what you're doing, and find they both contain the same prompts then they would probably complain to Amazon and that's when the problem arises.
Paul, I have a question: Would it be wise to make 1 book in the niche but in different lenguague? For example in Spanish and German besides english? Because my mother lenguagues are spanish and German.
Yes, you can do that. It's often a good idea although most sales will come from the US.
Love the content! I just posted a book and I know people who have placed orders, however, my reports are not updating. How long does this usually take to update?
I think it only updates when the book is delivered.
@@annabellak.2864 got it! So just to reiterate, once the customer receives the book then the order reports will update on my end?
@@jasminegwen5060 I've found this now: "Paperback orders will show in your reports after the order ships." But I think it was a longer time when my friend ordered, that's why I thought they wait until the buyer receives it. 🤷
@@annabellak.2864 GOT IT! Thanks so much.
@@jasminegwen5060 You're welcome.
hey, Paul. I am curious if the person gets banned account is it forever or is it still possible to recover it later and continue publishing? Thank you.
It's forever unfortunately.
Hi, i wonder is possible to make one medium content book, but translate to different languages and offer only on the language marketplace? Would that lead to account closure or some other penalties?
That would probably be ok but one can never be 100%.
I did a factory reset of my phone that I'm working with on amazon kdp, can I login to my account after factory reset without problems?
Yes, I can't see a problem with that.
I wish I saw this last week! My account was actually banned yesterday😢
Very sorry to hear that. Seems to be happening to a lot lately.
Can you reopen after a ban?
If a single word is listed in the trademark search, can I use it? I searched a word and there are multiple live trademarks of the same word so Im not sure I understand how that is possible. They are all different companies.
It depends on the word and what goods and services it is classified in. You see multiple listings because they are trademarked in different categories of goods and services
Hello. I published a lined journal and I used the manuscript from your gumroad site. KDP emailed me advising that I should put page numbers in the interior. May I know how to do it? You have a tutorial about it? THANKS!
That's unusual, not come across that recommendation before. You could do it by opening the interior in the free version of Canva and adding the page numbers.
Hi, I wanted to know if there are any legal risks if images are modified/generated with artificial intelligence using platforms like Midjourney or similar. If a derivative content is produced (perhaps from an image purchased from stock), are there any issues?
Thank you for your answer.
I'm afraid I'm not a trademark lawyer so the question about deriviative content I can't really answer. I think it would depend on how much the image has been changed. With regards AI, using a paid for MidJourney account gives you commerical rights. Then there is the issue of trademark, so if you create an Ai version of Spiderman for example it is still going to be breach of trademark. As for copyright there have been no legal rulings, as far as I'm aware, that any images breach copyright. However, these are really early days and who knows what rulings will be made in the future.
and is it true that you can't add books with titles that are already available on amazon but are generic phrases like Christmas Activity Book for Kids Ages 3-5. Does every title we launch on Amazon have to be unique?
Same question
I have 2 word phrase that I want to use in one of the keyword boxes. These words are just part of the English language. One of the words has been used as a company name. The two word phrase does not come up as copyrighted. The one word is used in many different company names. I want to put the 2 word phrase in one of the keyword boxes. Will that caused me a problem?
It depends on exactly what the words were. For instance, if the company name you're thinking about is Disney, for example, then no, I would advise against it. If the two word phrase is not trademarked and neither word is a well known brand name then it would probably be ok but without knowing the specifics it's impossible to say.
If you know, Are the photos of Sesame Street & Elmo considered as copyright?
Yes!
Does duplicate content apply to authors adding their books to multiple boxsets?
No, that shouldn't be an issue as you're not passing it off as a different book but just the same book in a collection.
last month i got 3 sales i started my kfp journey since 25th of july but this month i got only 1 sale yet 🥺 i am very worried. i have no keyword tool but i researched a lot day by day to search better keywords from self publishing titans but still got no results
My account makes me put a category I cannot bypass it any advise how I can?
I draw so I have been designing my own character to use for my KDP books
That's a great approach to take. Create your own original covers and interiors. 👍
Can u make sales without amazon ad as a new publisher
Yes, you can.
Hi Paul
Today I received email from Amazon that my kdp account has been closed due to violence of guidelines. But I don't know how to find errors can you tell me how to find violation of guidelines?
If the email doesn't tell you which guidelines were violated then you can email KDP support and ask them.
I want to ask does account get hacked?
Can you use AI software to generate coloring pages for KDP books?
It's possible. I've not really researched it or tried it yet.
I see a lot of non official pokemon and legend of zelda books making a lot of money, i don't know what's happening there since Nintendo is extremely protective of their brands, so it seems some people get a pass on copyright infringement.
I almost got banned for making a little red riding hood vintage from public domain, but using pokemon is fine 🤔.
Yeah the amazon bots on there are ridiculous. I think it may be a date thing. If uploaded before a particular date it may not have gone through a bot. But anything uploaded after a certain date the bot shuts down your account straight away. Or maybe they have not used detectable keywords.
I agree with S Ivenov. 👍
I’m currently working on a short novel, my cover art was designed by my son, so I’m good there. I ran my title and sub title through the trademark search and found nothing. I’m excited to get this published. I want to purchase my own ISBN, however, we are on a fixed income. Do you have any suggestions for very low cost (under $100 or less) ISBN services?
The only service I know of is Bowker. The price also depends on which country your in quite strangely.
@@paulmarles thank you.
Please how does the trademark search works?
Can I make a word search book based off a cartoon without infringing on copyright and trademarks?
It depends on the cartoon. If it is someone else's creation then it would be trademark and copyright infringement. You would be making money of someone else's intellectual property.
Hi Paul,
Today my account has been closed temporarily due to violation of guidelines.
But I don't know how to find errors
Can you tell me how to find errors in my book to avoid account suspension?
Amazon said this is due to title
But I had 4 books in a review.
Now I don't know how to find errors?
Can title cause violation of guidelines???
Yes, they've said the problem is in the title and that can indeed cause a violation of guidelines depending on what the title is.
@@paulmarles how can titles cause violation?
Can you explain
I only used keywords in titles.
Can you explain?
Sir,
please give me some ideas about Pricing the books.
Take a look at the prices of other books in your niche. That will give you the best idea on what to price your book.
Alright will try that...Thank you for such a brilliant ideas in your videos sir...I've seen all your videos, they are very informative..Thanks for sharing them.
Hi. I recently created a workbook on anxiety - a version for men and then a version for women. The content is the same inside except I changed any gender pronouns. The covers are different. Would this cause an issue? It's also not low content.
If it is aimed at two different markets then it may be ok but one can never be 100% certain.
Hi, Paul! I have my account terminated because of trademark. I would never think that the phrase "five minute journal" is a trademark))) I thought only proper nouns like Adidas, Disney are trademarks, and it seems you can't even use them in keywords. So does it mean that a publisher can't use these phrases even in its content? So do publishers need to check every phrase in every sentence for trademark?
And now I have a question to authors on Creativefabrica. There are plenty of templates for 5 minute journals. So it turns out that we need checking even after buying templates from sites??
Hi, sorry to hear you had your account terminated. If used in written content I'm sure it's fine. It would also depend in what context. The issue is targetting a trademarked phrase to make sales i.e. in the tilte, subtitle, description and keywords. You would be marketing, branding a book based on another entity's intellectual property. I'm not a trademark lawyer but that's how I interpret it.
@@paulmarles thanks for explanation!
@@paulmarles So, is that because they used the same title?
The comment doesn’t say but I assume so. But, as they correctly say, it can be because of using a trademark in your 7 keyword boxes.
@@paulmarles i would agree
I received account closed. It may because of using Winnie the Pooh images from EH Shepard and all characters released in late 2021 into the public domain. I’ve experienced messages and communications from customer reps who
seem to have problems with grammar and contextual use of English. I do feel there can be a disconnect in discussion of issues. Or i send a response and then someone sends a response saying they are still waiting for my response. Discouraged and looking for other means or platforms for publishing my work.
I'm sorry to hear you've had your account closed. I know other people who publish on Ingramspark which may be something to look at. I hope you manage to reolve the issue with KDP, I know it can be a very frustrating process.
@Joselyn Lukow Very true. I
Any issues were passed from one customer rep to another. And many were very nice people whose first language was not English so in terms of copyright issues involving public domain, i’d get the same answer For example, quotes from Shakespeare infringed on someone else’s rights. We’re you reinstated? I’m going with Sharice’s advice; lay low and collect money every month from current catalog.
So much❤🖒
Mine got shut down, reason number 1 not my fault and reason #2 still not my fault, every reason was for published book that was published more than 6 months ago.
Please expantiate on this
What reasons?
@@paulmarles they said I had published a book that was misleading the customers they gave me a book name, and when I told them the book was published several months ago, they said sorry we had made a mistake it was this book, and named another book I had published, when I told them that book got published several months ago and that I have not been online since September of this year they said sorry but we are sticking with our decision and closing your account.
May I use some quotes of famous people and writers.
Within the pages of a book Find words without the fear of copyright
No, not all quotes.
Can I buy trademark? I mean I want to use specific word like disney.
They're not going to sell you the world, at most they couldn't give you the rights to use that word in one specific application, given that you're already selling hundreds of thousands of copies every month in a similar niche.
A company may provide a license for you to use their intellectual property.
My account just got terminated for misleading content! Any advice?
The only thing you can do is contact KDP support.
Kdp is a nightmare. My 15 years work are just gone. Termination is now the brilliantly word for them. Anti-world.
Mine is already terminated 😭
Sorry to hear that. It's happening more of late.
I saw a dude had like 7 art of war books. All made money. Was wonderin how he did that.
I haven't looked into the tradmarks on that. Some publishers get away with trademark infringement for a while but can catch up with them.
2 years of hard work gone with a simple click , bay bay kdp
Sorry to hear that.
Did amazon give you a specific reason?
I always edit my interiors and covers. I almost got booted for trying to make 1 book in English and Spanish, they said I was copyrighting but forgave it. I won't try that again.
Ok, that's interesting. Thank you for letting me know.
You should explain why governments use taxes on their own people, and you would end up with the same explanation
Thank you
You're welcome.