My Opinions On All of Ash's Companions
Vložit
- čas přidán 10. 09. 2024
- Ash Ketchum and his wonderful group of friends have impacted us Pokemon for years and will continue to impact fans for years to come. Ash Ketchum has been going on his journey for many years now and with every new generation of Pokemon we are introduced with a new companion. These new companions have influenced Ash drastically whether it be good or bad. Some of them have also ether made the Pokemon great or they made it absolutely horrible which I will get into later. With all this talking of the Ash’s companions I decided I want to give you guys my opinions on all his companions he has met all the way up till Alola. Note, I will only be covering his companions from the core Pokemon anime and not from any of the movies. I also have not seen all of the movies and if I did every single companion he has met from a 2 hour film we would be here for a long time. So I will be keeping it strictly to the Pokemon anime. Alright, you know what’s going down, let’s hop into giving my opinions!
Pick up Your Family Eeveelution and Which Starter Shirts Here:
www.teepublic....
Follow me on Twitch: / mysticumbreon
Check out our community discord: discordapp.com.... or this one if the first one doesn't work / discord
Follow me on Instagram: mysticumbreon_
Follow me on Twitter: / mysticumbreon94
Support me on Patreon: / mysticumbreon
Patrons who have donated: JDinis, Aanvik, The4thgengamer, Coolindude, Jasmin Skoplijak, Tyree Awantaye, Savannah (my secretary), Poketuber, The Sith'ari, Kepheus, ChikoritaCheezits, SpikeSP, Flyjubilee, JesseTheRuby, Frostfang5412, Daniel Leon, and Diane Wierzbicki, and Lady Krimzen, Derpy Poster, Dylan Clough, and Miguel Poissant. Pub Sparky Wynx, Gasnort, Pal491, Ryan Turk, Lightningwolf4r, TheLazyLeo, AwesomeLego
“Dawn just felt like she was there” - are you telling me the only female companion who actually managed to share the spotlight alongside Ash Ketchum and wasn’t sidelined halfway through the show, who had a misplaced overly confident beginning, had a depressive stunt in the middle, and a massive comeback growth in the end, WAS JUST THERE?
Damn, didn’t realize people couldn’t read well written subtle changes, even though it was episodes where Dawn’s confidence was tested and where she had to learn about things, and had numerous mental breakdowns.
That was infuriating goodbye.
John Sacapano yeah ngl that kinda pissed me off a bit
serena as well to be fair
@adam cecic Dawn was a better written character than May, not to mention her comradery with Ash and the fact that the both of them shared the spotlight.
@adam cecic Felt the same way about May and Iris, so I guess each to their own :D
@adam cecic I hated Iris too but her character that we haven't really seen as a companion before made me like her a little bit and I think she is a bit underrated
I always thought that it was ironic that Max always stopped Brock from from getting with girls whereas Bonnie did the opposite with Clemont lol
At least with Bonnie she tries to find a girl for Clemont because she cares.
J_ Surge_95 Max is an annoying twerp.
I thought it was cute as all hell when Bonnie tried to hook her brother up, said brother's reactions just being icing on the cake. Max, on the other hand, I, to this day, want to feed to the nearest Ursaring. Brock is a man among men and a poster boy for what women should expect, even if he is a bit flamboyant.
@@Balorak146 Here let me help you. Ursaring! Lunch!
@@Balorak146 we stand brock
Dude, Dawn was like the best one of Ash’s companions. She had a huge impact on him and even gave him a new battle style, the counter-shield, and whether or not you ship them it’s obvious they adore each other. Plus, she did develop a lot. Her journey from an overconfident newbie to a more mature and incredibly skilled coordinator was a great thing to watch.
True,she was amazing
She was a nice girl from start to end though wasnt she?
Dawn should be more appreciated than Serena tbh
@UNKNOWN 2.0 yes
@UNKNOWN 2.0 fuck you wahaha
I feel like Mystic rushed through the Dawn section. There’s a lot more that can be said about her character development. She’s basically the closest the anime ever got to having a female protagonist. But then again it’s just his opinion on her.
Pikachu i honestly agree with you
DragonKing 57 I just thought it was weird Mystic didn’t have much to say. As I’m pretty sure he’s seen the DP anime, so he’d know about her character development. But then again maybe he just can’t remember the DP anime that well.
Pikachu or maybe he didn’t forget anything and that’s all he thinks about her?? remove the overconfident to humble character development and Mystic’s opinion on Dawn is 100% correct, but I still love her and I also think she’s much better than Serena despite the fact that she’s always the second best to Serena to 90% of fans for some reason
plaid locks I love Dawn so so much, she’s my number one Pokegirl just because of her personality and character development, but I wouldn’t blame the fans for choosing Serena first.
Serena is a refined version of all the Pokegirls, she and Dawn are very similar in terms of their personal growth and personality. As for the romance aspect, it’s obviously a callback to the romance with Misty, while her deciding on what she wanted to become is based on May.
She’s all of the Pokegirl’s best qualities- so how they feel is justified. But to me, Dawn will always be top, because out of all the female characters, she was the only one who truly shared the spotlight with Ash.
DP wasn’t just Ash’s journey, it was Ash and Dawn’s with Brock in the background. That’s why in movies, in posters, songs, they’re always side by side, because they’re a team
I almost thought you were pukicho ofmg
I love how he just didn’t mention Dawn and Zoe’s final contest battle, like it is in my opinion one of the best battles in the whole series
THANK YOU. I loved that battle so much, it was definitely on par with the big Ash vs Paul battle.
After watching that battle I've learned that there is "no need to worry" eventhough you have lost by a tiny chance in life that there is always another turn. Love Dawn ❤️
@@SSRDawn do u love her before her devolpment or after?
@@jakeriese4862 At first i thought of her as a typical pokegirl.. But then i saw the difference in the midway through the season and i fell for her😍
@@SSRDawn u mean how she became depressed cause of Contests or her resolve to get herself back on track? Also, what is the "Typical Poke Girl" to u?
Honestly Ash And Dawn had one of the best friendships among his companions. They really learned a lot from each other and they even had there own thing with the high five.
Plus you're making sound like Dawn didnt develop at all. She started off very overconfident and kept on losing and losing and got depress until she started to improve and humble herself aswell.
Edit: An honestly. I find Misty and Iris to basically be the same exact character. Only that Misty got nicer overtime.
Miles Sharpe Faxx Sinnoh in general was the best for the Pokémon anime IMO.
Dawn's development was made in parallel to Ash's, at least his journey (you know, cause his development resets with every region)
And yeah, Iris was made to be exactly like Misty. I believe it was told through different sources that if it wasn't for the dub edits, including them adding these pokeshipping moments, Misty would've been a worse character than Iris.
@@supersonicmario56 Yeaaaah. That's the reason so many people think they love each other or something just because 4kids kept changing the dialogue like that at the time.
I'm actually disappointed that Iris ended up being as irritating as she did. She was soooo different in terms of of design from the rest of the pokegirl that came before and even after, this cool looking jungle Tarzan girl who love dragon type. But the anime writers completely fucked it up.
Iris was Misty 2.0 and I hate both of them due to the Tsundere genre as a whole
@@MrSonicHedgehog I don't think tsunderes are bad, it's just the abundance of them that's pushed in anime and manga for the sake of having them in there (and the stupid cliches that come with them).
It's even more annoying that despite peoples' complaints about them, they still demand for a "violent" girl (while crapping on the genuinely nice girls for being "bland"). I guess they're masochists . . . .
May, Dawn, and Serena are based on the video game female player characters in their respective generations.
May did last longer.
And Serena got the best moments
Dimunn Pa bebet cap
That is not true. Serena is nothing like her game character at
blackstar1 blackstar1 Serena’s game counterpart was way better than her in the anime
Paul to this day is the most well written character in the Pokémon anime. He challenged Ash not just to his abilities of a trainer, but his entire ideology. Ash's entire way of battling with Pokémon were tested with Paul and his win at the Sinnoh League as well as the two finally understanding each other remains one of Pokémons strongest moments.
no..gary was the best rival..paul whose paul?..never heard of him and I watched al of shinnoh..hes so forgetable
@@razkable Gary was pretty good.
But if you don't remember Paul after watching Diamond/Pearl that's like not remembering Gary after watching the first series. Except Paul shows up more often
Paul SUCKS. Imo at least.
We need Paul and Ash to journey the next region tbvh... the contrasting styles and banter will be legendary
LISTEN! It's not Ash Fault he's so bad! The Anime-Makers aren't BRAVE Enough to let him ever capture a Legendary Pokemon or become a Champion. Even though that's STUPID! If you become a Champion, that's not the End! You're not the best because of just that! There are several Champs! Like this comment if you think that should Change!
Me: "Wow, can't wait to see what he has to say about Dawn..."
Mystic: "She was just kind of... there."
Me: Leaves.
I mean... Dawn has the best friend relationship with ash, passed through a depressive period after losing and asked herself if she had any talent and overcome her limitations... way better than May, IMO.
I liked Dawn too she was really cool
Both may and dawn are the best companions (after brock)
Bro opinions are opinions
Serena is my favorite girl companion especially cause she stepped up and actually kissed Ash although maybe a bit too late lol
No
May is better
Dawn didn’t go through character development? Did you even watch the Sinnoh series? Lol
I know right? He apparently hasn't watched the Alola series either. It's actually boring and atrocious.
kayokango have you watched ultra adventures and ultra legends
@@radslimecostsadime7670 I think you're the one who didn't watch Sun and Moon series
I feel like most of these opinions he has are going off not watching most of the characters' respective seasons in awhile. Most are the same vague statements people think about the characters when they haven't watched them in years, but he hasn't reached the point where he rewatches them and sees what parts were better or worse than he remembered.
Are you saying she did? What it was?
Compare Dawn at the beginning of the series, who was always freaking out and got depressed easily, to the character at the end of the series who actually understood that there was no need to worry about things. And we got to see her gradually evolve between the two.
Also Iris was good.
Saberian Dream Also whats with it with May and Drew shipping am I the only one that sees how much of an asshole he is all he ever did was belittle her Ash and May are the best couple. Drew and Serena make more sense they have the same style and I feel are more comparable Serena is just a fangirl. Misty and Tracy are better for eachother cuz they never fight and they see eachother often. Drew called May weak and a coward even after she saved his life yet he still talks down to her i mean “SHE ONLY SAVED YOUR FUCKING LIFE YOU UNGRATEFUL ASS!” Dawn and Zoe I ship for real gay and lesbian ships should be more common through anime. And Dawn and Zoe r just so good for one another.
Saberian Dream What do u think about contestshipping I think its probably reaching on a whole nother level for real theirs nothing their Drew is essentially May’s Gary. I hate that May never got a female/friend rival that she met at the grand festival her rivals were a drag queen and a snobby douchebag.
Yeah, I've been watching the Pokémon series on twitch, and Iris isn't all that bad.
@Snow Cone same. And a plus for me, since she is from a village, she is more natural and her bond with nature and Pokemon is really great. Iris is the most wild pokegirl imo.
Iris was annoying
Dawn/Brock are number 1 best companions with Paul bring the best Rival. Although....my heart still belongs to May.
I LOVE May! Brock is awesome, Dawn is cool, Somebody PLEASE kill Iris, and Serena... OK, I guess.
I found my people 😂
May Is Awesome!
dawn gary tracey for me...brocks love gag got old..but hes great in small spurts
Didn’t May won as best Pokégirl now?
nobody taking avout trip hahahaha
I think you need to check yourself when it comes to Dawn's impact on the battling style of the anime aka Ash himself
Lmao he said she didn't have character development. Lol he needs to re watch the series and pay close attention to her attitude at the start if the series vs towards the end and tell me she hasn't developed.
i think your right
Yea no female companion has influenced Ash's battling strategies other than Dawn. Which makes his battles fun in sinnoh because he puts contest moves in his battles too.
right bro....Serena is just a girl who likes ash..he wanted to speak about x and y...also he didnt watch series fully so
*C O N N O I S S E U R*
Cilan, you will never be forgotten.
Also, I just wanted to show off the fact that I can spell Connoisseur.
Yes, you spelt Connoisseur right, yet you misspelled Cilan. So close, yet so far away.
"It's evaluation time!"
I always found Cilan to be just as hilarious as Brock was at times.
Sad that so many people don't even get a chance to see the hilarious side of him because Majority will just skip the Black and White anime episodes and go directly to X and Y.
I actually enjoyed the intros the Black and White anime had. I disliked how X and Y repeated the original opening and never made it stand out. Why give yourself a new intro when you can just remix the older one. (oh wait... because Pokemon X and Y was just a reboot of Red and Blue... but with French Doggies and Mega Gen 1 Pokemon added to the Mix.) What's Sun and Moon... Gen 1 but with a Hawaiian setting. Sword and Shield... Let's chop half the Pokedex out of our game but give everyone variations of some of our favorite Pokemon. That's sadly why I honestly feel like Black and White was when Pokemon was at it's peak. The anime I prefer more than the games, but I wish people would just give it a chance and watch it from the perspective of someone who was new to the anime. I find Iris more tolerable than Misty because despite her frustrations, she still cared for Ash in her own way. (Plus, she didn't steal Scraggy from Ash, like Misty stole Togepi from him... that Togepi was his, she stole it from him)
@@goldenyoshistar1 I liked Cilan. He was better than iris by far, pretty hilarious at times, kinda the brains of the group, and he was a good cook, which is actually kinda fitting considering he uses words describing food, aroma and cooking in his conversations
@@goldenyoshistar1 that togepi also saw misty when it hatched, so of course it would want to go with misty. It's called imprinting
1:05 Misty
1:47 Brock
2:49 Tracy
3:22 May
3:56 Max
4:18 Dawn
5:18 Iris
5:48 Ceilin
6:14 Clement
6:31 Bonnie
6:56 Serena
*Serena
You forgot the sun and moon crew
marioandsonic fan for a reason
*Clemont
@@justdex721 sun and moon is pretty great, if you got time, go watch it.
I love Dawn, Brock, May, and Misty. (:
Misty, May and Dawn are the holy trinity
@@nova_9 Got that right.
How dare you forget Serina
Ahh born in the 90s were we?
ADD IRIS TO THAT SENTENCE BITCH
May was my favorite growing up
Saberian Dream May is better for Ash Misty and him would be very disfunctional and They always made fun of eachother May almost never belittles him . Ash
@@saberiandream316 If you said "who" to TheBoltMaster, he is obviously saying May is still his favourite.
@@shadyboy5090 may belongs with drew tho
Inflixer How? Drew is a fuckin self centered ass hole who spent most of the time belittiling May and putting her down he doesnt deserve her. May finds him irritating and I dont think her parents would be too fond of him Norman would slap the shit outta him. Ash and May belong together.
Roses Die Ribbons last forever”
@@shadyboy5090 May does not crush on Ash unlike Misty and Serena.
As a Alola fan. I think DP had the best girl companion in the series . Dawn’s growth as a coordinator and as a character easily eclipse any of the companions (yes even that of Serena). Ash and Dawn basically have this close sibling like relationship.
I’ll take you to the distortion world if you think otherwise
So ur saying may didnt have character development
y e s. thank you. people who say serena had the best character development must’ve not watched dp cause dawn’s character arc puts serena’s to shame
Specifically, their relationship is like a best friend one or as expressed in their duet pokemon high touch "partners".
Misty says "hi".
yes i agree with you (as dp fan, and i also fan of alola and bw)
I think Dawn has one of the best character developments. I even started off hating her in the beginning, but she ended up being my favorite companion.
hyejoo olivia hye ❤️❤️
Omg I absolutely hated Dawn as a kid. Now after rewatching the sinnoh anime, she's like fighting for my number one pokemon best girl lol
i honestly dawn was my favorite pokegirl too and she still on my number 1 spot even when serena came out (because i skipped the xy for some and annoying experience i got)
@@angelicaph483 same Dawn is my number one with May as a close second but the number one will only be Dawn. Serena is overrated because of Amourshipping. Some fans just saw a girl having a crush on the main protagonist and simply makes her superior over all the other pokegirls who were more developed and have a much better character than her
4:31 Dude, she started off as a girl who was overconfident in her skills of a Pokémon Contest participant, which makes her stumble halfway through, and then learned from her mistakes, only for us viewers to see her rise again. That's not being there... That's learning people how to react in a situation like this.
I like Iris. I think Ash and Iris had a big rivalry because they act the same. Everyone hates on black and white, But it's my second favorite series. Diamond and Pearl is in front because of Dawn, Brock, and the rivalry between Ash's Infernape,
And Paul's Electivire. Diamond and Pearl Ash has my favorite team: Pikachu, Infernape, Buizel, Staraptor, Gliscor, and Torterra. But, I can also not forget the hilarious scenes when Ash's Gible would hit Piplup with Draco Meteor. I miss Diamond and Pearl, and can't wait for the game remakes to come out.
Black & White did start having detailed animation onwards
Yeah i liked Iris
Thank God I am not the only one who Loves Iris and actually likes the Black and White Series.
Problem with Iris to me is that she was a jerk for no reason. Misty was justified because Ash was a newbie. By B/W, though, he was a quarter-finalist in the Sinnoh League, had beaten the Orange League and the Battle Frontier, and qualified for three other leagues. Iris was pretty much a newbie. To be fair, Ash didn't really defend himself, not properly. He didn't bring up all of that stuff at all. And then he became an idiot
@@saberiandream316 Honestly, the same goes for Trip too, as well as a couple others. Though Ash doesn't help himself.
In my headcanon, he took a long holiday, the last step of which was to Unova, and by that point he'd forgotten a little bit. Makes more sense to me that way.
The thing about Serena though... she basically was a fangirl of Ash. Misty at least stood up to Ash in a way that made him stronger. Most situations Serena goes through, Ash has already been through with Misty, so those moments feel like a rehash. If Misty were to have kissed Ash at the end of the Johto Saga, it would have felt more earned than Serena's Kiss.
She was also a forced retcon of Ash's past, shoehorning her into the Anime for BS reasons other than being the XY Female Protagonist.
It's not that I hate her, it's that she wasn't given a proper explanation for her existence as someone who knew Ash. It felt forced and I didn't like that. Serena is a great character on her own, but forcing her to have known as a kid was a bit much, especially since people auto-shipped her hard with Ash because of that.
It didn't feel earned at all. Though points for Serena for actually going for it.
RedDragonForce2 it feels like Amourshipping was the biggest thing that was given to her that people remember about her but honestly it was pretty one sided and kind of forced IMO
Dumb argument. You didn't watch XY.
Jimmy Agera there’s a video that highlights all the things Serena did that was already done by other female companions. If you have to repeat this many events in Ash’s life with a single girl, then it’s forcing romance and doesn’t feel earned. Want me to link the video so you can see for yourself how forced Serena’s crush is?
@@RedDragonForce2 Yes please link me that.
Debunking should be easy enough.
Highlighting those events done by other companions? What does that prove lmao? Even then I find every companion unique. I could argue Dawn was a copy paste of May but nah they are unique in their won way.
Serena still experienced things others didn't. So did Dawn and May and even Misty.
Jimmy Agera sorry, took me a bit to find the right video. Had to try like 5 different searches.
Here you go: czcams.com/video/nCgmjLfsv5o/video.html
Note: These are merely a few, and Serena’s ends up combining more than one moment in certain instances, such as her Ash Cosplay was combined with Ash inhaling spores and was sick, which is another thing repeated from an event when Misty was traveling with Ash.
*Ash does something stupid*
Iris: "That was dumb."
Fanbase: "YOU SUCK!!"
*Ash does something stupid*
Serena: "He's so cute."
Fanbase: "BEST GIRL EVER!!"
They are racist
Lets end racism by hanging the ceo of racism
I mean that's basically how it is.
I actually quite like Iris. There, i said it.
Everybody is different
#skewedpriorities
May is my favorite. She felt like she was her own character instead of just a companion. Plus she had the best design.
WAIT...
Clemont: Electric-type gym leader
Sophocles: Electric-type trial captain
Clemont: Smart
Sophocles: Smart
Clemont: Hates running
Sophocles: Hates running
COINCIDENCE?? I. THINK. NOT.
CLEMONT (maybe Bonnie too) AND SOPHOCLES OVA CONFIRMED???
! Kalos fan
It really is too bad Alola didn't get any OVAs or special episodes, whatever you wanna call them, because they had so much opportunities. They could have shown Kiawe training with Oliva to become a Kahuna, they could have shown Lana and her dad trying to find Manaphy, they could have shown Lillie and her family searching for her father.
What's extra annoying is the fact that Sinnoh, Unova and Kalos all got two OVAs. But given the fact the entire cast will probably return in the Pokémon 2019 anime, it's likely they wanted to save those potential stories for then, which means we'll hopefully still get to see them!
Well i mean Clemont had so much equipment and inventions in his bag that i sort of symphatise with him running slowly
But sophy straight up nids to workout lol
@@alpha-sama In Journeys they are coming back
Brock’s my favourite and I’d say the Sinnoh series is my favourite
Brock, Dawn, and Paul are all equally my favorite characters, and Sinnoh is definitely the best series hands down! I don't think they'll ever top it.
Agreed.
yeah. gen 4 fan here @@weebgod9162.
Gen 4 rocks even without mega evolutions
Yep sinnoh definitely is the best
Mystic for some reason Miisty wanted to kill Ash for a bike
Me they're 1 million dollars
Pokedollers are based on japaness Yen,so it's actually about 9,000 U.S dollars.
@@user-vm9xz4kv9z geez, Japanese are charging an arm and a leg. Good bikes are usually only $150 at least.
@@user-vm9xz4kv9z It would actually be 110,137,500.0000 yen. Like where did you
get 9k from?
Really though... how did you even come up with that number?
@@KingYoshiGoD Google...?
Bonnie is best character under 10, she is kind cute, and unlike max actually grows as a person
I agree.
Max could learn from her
The Tyrunt episode from the Anime still makes me tear up. We see a lot more of her compassion and love for Pokemon than we do with Max
I still cant forget when she calmed down zygarde that made me weep😢
Literally, or figuratively
I ship Ash with Dawn so hard because Dawn is like the female equivalent of Ash in many scenes of "Pokemon Diamond & Pearl".
UNKNOWN 2.0
Yeah
I feel like Iris is the most similar to him tho not Dawn
PersephoneRose yeah she is more similar but her and ash have no chemistry. i think ash lowkey liked serena he was always kind of extra to her. idk if you watched miraculous ladybug but xy ash to serena is lowkey like adrien to marinette.
@@Jana-tp6yo Ash doesn't treat Serena any differently than he treated Iris.
I personally think that dawn is more of a best friend to ash
Dawn is literally the reason I want fusion moves in Pokemon. Come on game freak!! The pledges and the few other moves shouldn't be the only ones
Yes you right, fusion moves are so cool,
i'm sure that we can all agree that brock it top tier
Tbh i don’t really like Serena.I feel the only reason people like her is because she liked Ash.She wasn’t strong (having only 3 pokemon and only one being fully evolved). And she wasn’t the best in contest.Sure she changed her look but i feel like just because she cut her hair and changed her clothes shouldn’t make her any more enjoyable.In my opinion i found it kinda annoying how she just obsessed over Ash.And people talk about Black and white ash while Kalos Ash didn’t even know Serena liked him after 3 seasons.Even Bonnie knew and she’s like 5.
Nothing but facts. Amourshipping is EXTREMELY overrated imo. Not gonna down anyone for liking it, but serena just came off as bland and mostly just there, and outside of her outfit change, had no real major development or character outside of her crush on ash. Lots of wasted potential really.
When will people learn that it's neither the size of your arsenal or how powerful it is, it's how you use it that counts. Look at Ash's current roster. 2 unevolved Pokemon (Rowlet and Meltan) 2 middle stage (Pikachu and Torracat) and one fully evolved. 5 Pokemon and yet before Meltan showed up to be captured, Ash had just the 4 and beaten all the Grand Trials. Seriously, y'all need to do better with your arguments
MrSonicHedgehog what does this have to do with Serena?
Dawn is my absolute favorite Pokegirl. She's cute, funny, and makes me smile from just LOOKING at her
Yep, she's my Pokemon waifu ❤
She's 10.
@@Mufflin So? Age isn't really much of an issue in the Pokemon world
My Pokémon waifu is Serena. She's very beautiful 😍
CupcakeDancerTheSecond - Link of the Wild fbi open up
Ty Giordano What does that mean? For me, Serena is pretty.
Misty was my fav.Her relationship with ash was unique from others.
Phenom Gaming true!! She was also the female companion that traveled with him the longest 💛
YESS!!!💖
She is my fav too
Love that tomboyish mermaid:)
Oh no😅 Dawn, Serena only
@@whereisezraa5825I love your opinion ❤❤
Serena is my favorite companion, but my favorite group is Sinnoh (Dawn, Brock, and Ash) they all just work so well together, but individually definitely Serena.
and cant forget bonnie omg she is so iconic
@Jana 😂😂
Even though her character development is circular? Or that her character in general is poorly constructed?
LittleAl016 it isn’t poorly constructed, it shows greatly how at first she had nothing to strive for and she just traveled to leave her house and then when she finally found something that she wanted to do how she failed at first but it didn’t stop her because she’s strong. Sure she had her moments of weakness like when she cried, got upset at times, and she cut her hair, but it goes to show you that she isn’t weak she has a lot more emotion inputted into her character than a lot of others and she’s more human-like than the others. When she discovered a dream and set off to fulfill it she was a really hard worker to get to that point and she got to the finals and she worked so hard to get there. She was a great character and she fit into the xy plot perfectly.
@@Jana-tp6yo "Cutting her hair" is actually a pretty weak point to make, even if you understand why she did that, because everything else that happened afterwards would have happened anyways had she not done that. And regardless of the writers' intentions, it makes her come across as excessively dramatic, unwilling to accept that things won't go her way, and possibly desperate for attention. At the least, it's not related to her character at all.
And she had "nothing to strive for" UNTIL Ash came into the picture. Why is she so special that she needed Ash as a reason for basically everything she does when, a), none of the other female travelling companions needed Ash as a reason for literally anything, or b), neither of her other two official counterparts (or three, if you count her Masters counterpart) even needed someone who clearly isn't romantically interested in them to do anything with their lives? Especially when there's zero interaction between Serena's game and Adventures (and Masters) counterparts and Ash's?
She could have been replaced by almost any other girl in the X and Y anime, including those from the X and Y games (and I say "almost" because there's at least two girls who wouldn't work as Ash's travelling companions due to their own character) and it would have gone pretty much the same way as it did, presently. Same if the player avatar character in the X and Y games who didn't get chosen to represent the player didn't show up in the main story.
And honestly. Every female travelling companion, before and after her, came across as more human than her. Especially when you consider that they weren't introduced in manners similar to self-inserts, nor did they come across as boring as such. Same can be said for her other official counterparts, especially Yvonne Gabena (who is literally a better-written version of Anime Serena).
Yeah, I grew up watching the Gen 5 anime dub, so there is bias here, but may I ask, am I the only one who actually really liked both Iris AND Cilan in the anime? Just to rub it in here's why
Iris: She's not the stereotypical female anime character you'd expect to see compared to the others, and I actually like her team more than Misty's because 1. Dragons are cool and 2. She actually has some form of variety. But really, she's so unique compared to the stereotype that's been shown off with characters like May, Dawn, and Serena. Also, I think the lack of shipping evidence is actually a good thing, because shipping is overrated.
Cilan: There's only two reasons to not like him. 1. He replaced Brock, and 2. He goes on and on about that conniseur (I have no idea how to spell that) stuff. But put it this way. It's a lot less annoying than hearing "THE FUTURE IS NOW THANKS TO SCIENCE" every freaking episode. I also like how he has the guts to use less popular Pokémon on his team, like Pansage and Stunfisk. On top of that, most of Ash's male friends aside from Brock are honestly kinda forgettable for me.
Interesting opinions there I grew up watching black and white too and yeah I prefer clemont than cilan if we're comparing those 2 plus I feel like ash and clemont have a brotherly relationship which Ash acting like the big brother I think that is cool. I find cilan ok and funny.
I am mostly ok with iris yeah sure she can be annoying but she definitely shown some character development there I did like her battle against Drayden which illustrates my point.
i liked iris and cilan too as my 3rd (iris in pokegirl category) and 2nd (cilan in male companions after brock) and i agree in your opinion
We all know the Sinnoh trio was the best
Disagree, As a trio XY was- oh wait... XY has no trio.
Jimmy Agera Clemont and Bonnie have absolutely nothing on Brock. Dawn and Ash pushed each other to get better in contests and battling and it worked. Serena’s motive was to get in Ash’s pants.
Green
Apparently her Pokémon showcases and her earning princess keys throughout Kalos in order to try and defeat the Kalos Queen in a Pokémon performance means nothing to you. Oh well, not my problem.
The Giant Bacon Bird of Death There’s nothing wrong about what I said, she literally started her journey because of Ash. She lost a performance and cut her hair, that’s not development that’s bad writing. Serena's final scene features a line where she talks about becoming stronger so that she could be a more attractive woman for Ash. It’s not wrong to like someone, but if you like them from the very start and only wanna better yourself to impress them then that’s a clear motive.
Green
I get what you’re saying, but I still don’t agree with it. You could argue that Serena cutting her hair was bad writing, but how is that bad writing, yet Lillie being mean to her mother isn’t? What makes that bad writing is that Lusamine is actually a very nice mother in the anime, something she wasn’t in the games, and yet Lillie has to be such a whiny brat to her. And the way she changed into her Z-Powered forme when there was no reason to like in the games, that was also bad writing. So why only criticize and hate on Serena?
I love may the most
She was my childhood crush to be fair
Nep Neppers Ash and May would make a cute couple they make the most sense Fuck Drew hes a spoiled little fuck. Misty Dawn Iris and Serena dont compete with May.
Ash and May forever
@@shadyboy5090 Misty and Serena don't compete? You're on some, my guy.
BrownieKuma72 Serena x Drew would be a compatable pair their both tools
@@shadyboy5090 have you heard of "opposites attract"? Misty and ashes dynamic was amazing. People who do. Care for her are usually casual anime fans who are not too fond of tsunderes. Serena is legit the only person ash actual has "some type" of romantic interest in. What's toxic about a series supported ship? Because it goes against your own headcanon ship? Talk about petty. And you also completely lost me after that drew comment. You are just a biased fanboy, at this point, so why should I bother continuing to reply to you?
Nice mine to. I used to image my own adventures with may.
And well back then, i wasn't only thinking about battles. If you know what i mean :P
I think Dawn gets too little credit. Yeah, I think May's personal journey and development was more provoking, but I think that's because she was introduced in the same generation that contests were introduced. She was able to appreciate a brand new aspect of Pokemon battles and displays along with us.
Dawn on the other hand, is a bit underrated, because she is well versed in contests prior to becoming a coordinator herself, because the knowledge she attained from her mom. However, since she had that prior knowledge, this made her extremely cocky and unwilling to learn from others outside of her mom. This is an aspect that May lacked, because May was cooperative and willing to learn from others from the jump. She learned from Ash, Drew, Brock and other experienced coordinators every chance she had, because she had no prior knowledge. Dawn on the other hand, was humbled when her way backfired consistently and resulted in her bottoming out in a way that May never did. She had to completely reimagine herself and learn from the strengths and weaknesses of others.
Lana segment: Shes so shy and cute
Me: Huh. Have you read the manga? SHES SCARY AS FREAK IN BATTLE MODE
and also:
Anime: Idk how to describe it
Game: NEBBY GET IN THE MOTHER FRICKIN BAGGG
so much dislike for iris :( i enjoyed her in the games and anime
i like all of ash's companions but my top 4 female companions are Lillie, Serena,Dawn and Iris
@Merciless Freak to each their own
My favourite female compains (not included alola)
Dawn
Serena
May
Bonnie
Misty
Iris
My favourite male compains (not included alola)
Brock
Tracy (funny enough my moms name is Tracy)
Clement
Cilian
Max
That’s my list but I would have swapped misty and Bonnie.
Yeah as other people said Dawn really had better character development than most companions including Misty and May.Also the thing I really like about Dawn is that she didn't really have one of those awkward shipping moments with Ash and lastly ending episode of diamond pearl was one of the saddest ones ,so.
But when they said bye they had their high five and if you thought it was sad then you go it's sad cuz they went through alot and you felt it
It's pretty obvious that may had the best development
@@eveegirl2878 hehehe for me may is boring from the start. I really not a fan of May's character.
@@SSRDawn May is actually very similar to dawn ngl. The both mu favourites but dawn is better
@@gonefist Awesome.. Dawn is my Favorite too💙
May was always a big inspiration to me, idk how to explain but she's always been what I've wanted to be. She made me want to be a Pokemon Coordinator/Proformer! She's by far my favorite, Serena and Lillie are a close second and third but May will always be my favorite
May is my fav I watched hoenn more then 15 times a year and I am lieing I ship may and drew don't hate me
She is my least fav,she got some mons she didn't deserve
Iris is a dragon master in training and didn't know regular Charizard wasn't a dragon type... Gurl, there aren't that many dragons you should know them xD
Also you have to give Dawn props for not taking a back seat to Ash in the DP series, she was there front and center for the movie posters and even the promotional stuff in Japan. Heck she was actually featured in a Commercial with Ash. I would also say she was the one who had the best friend relationship with Ash. Ash was at his peak in DP and a lot of his neat tricks came from Dawn's contests. Not to mention Dawn was probably the person who has helped Ash train the most.
Serena for me was just ship bait. She literally only went out on her Journey for Ash... I don't know I guess I just didn't like the obvious crush on Ash? Sure she had this big character development but did she have to take up like 2 seasons of nothing? Also kinda lame those beauty pageants weren't even a thing in the games. ;-;
Thank uu i fully agree with this!! Dawn was the closest of the female companions with ash and they helped each-other grow and train each-other in a thought of way and iris is overhated!! She's a super cool dragon master with a dragonite and she can communicate with dragon type Pokemon on an amazing level which i think should go much more appreciated!! i also agree that serena was thought of more ship-bait, she does have character development but the whole crush on ash thing was way too obvious
Girls best to worst:
-Dawn
-May
-Mallow (I can't really describe why she's so high on my list but she just has such a cheerful aura that I just love!)
-Misty
-Lana
-Bonnie
-Lillie (I don't really have an opinion on Lillie. She's just okay.)
-Serena (I know I'm gonna get hated for this but in all honestly, I don't really get what's so great about her.)
-Iris
Boys best to worst:
-Brock
-Clemont (I thought his character was somewhat refreshing for the anime which made gen 6 all the more enjoyable.)
-Kiawe
-Tracy
-Cilan
-Sophocles
-Max
Good video, bro! Companions have always been an interesting topic for me and it's good to see there's still some diversity among the fandom (like you not hating Cilan or me not liking Serena). I wish everyone reading this a nice day!
Finally someone who's not overhyped on sarena. Only good thing on her is her one sided crush with ash. While her character development is just bland and boring. May was the one who started that contest thingy while dawn is that one girl that surpasses the og. And serena just like copied their homeworks she just changed it a bit. People just get overhyped by that girl when she's clearly not even the best.
@@Mogushima Well mate opinions are opinions also most of her (even Mystic himself pointed that) about her development about *finding a dream* not the contests, if you really watched the XY saga you'll know that her development was about finding her own way and look out for something, something that actually ended well with the final message of the XYZ anime to find our own ways, and something that ironically Ash was going through right know in Journeys, I mean i can get if you don't like her, opinions are opinions but hey im just telling you why others including me love her, and that's your comment about.
@@lonelysatoshi2482 So? She still ended up going to contests. We've seen that thing in May and dawn before and that makes serena's character arc bland and boring asf. If y'all think serana had the best character development then y'all probably sleeping on diamond and pearl. Dawn's development puts searena's to shame. Mystic is just ignoring it. Well opinions are opinions and at least you're not a toxic amourshipper compared to the others I give you that.
Misty,Dawn and Serena are my favorite pokemon characters.
I know may started the contest but Dawn made best contest and her feeling that her contest was making ash weaker soo yeah she is better than may and dare I say misty I am gonna get soo hate for this
GALAXY NOVA u brave for this lol but I defo agree, May too me is kinda devoid of a personality, at least Dawn has her bitchy/diva moments, that help her get humbled and become more positive. May is honestly just kinda there, while she has her own emotional moments, most of it is just her crying, which while very sad to see (much sadder than Serena’s meltdown btw) that’s kinda all she does, she occasionally has her moments but it’s way rarer than Dawn, and that’s why imo Dawns better than May (and Serena as well tbh because even though Serena is cute, having a crush on ash isn’t a personality trait)
My top 3 Ash’s female companion:
1. Iris
2. Dawn
3. May
And forth would be Serena.
I don’t understand why so many people hates Iris. Her friendship between Ash was incredible, and their chemistry played very good together.
Yes, sometimes she was annoying, but does it make her bad character? No, if you ask me.
Dawn and May had the best growing as a character. When May started her adventure, she didin’t like Pokemon at all.
But later she had an amazing ship with her pokemon, like Eevee and Blaziken. And she had been one of the most famous trainers in the whole world.
Dawn was just a little kid, who didn’t know much about being a trainer. But later she growed to one of the best coordinators in the Sinnoh.
Best Wishes anime is the most nostalgic to me, I’ve watched it too much times..
Cilan was so annoying, I hate his nature (or mature??)
I apologize if something in my writing went wrong, I don’t have the best english...
Iris and Cilan were like the worst to me but I respect your opinion. And hey at least you didn't put overrated sarina no. 1 I give you points for that.
I like May and Mallow the most.
My favorite companions from least to favorite
15. Iris
14. Sophocles
13.Lana
12.Cilain
11. Tracy
10.Max
9. Kiawe
8.Mallow
7. Misty
6. Clemont
5. Bonnie
4. May
3.Dawn
2. Brock
1.Serena
I forgot to add Lillie she would be between Mallow and Misty on my list.
May is definitely my first favorite pokemon character from the anime. She was probably my first female character crush 💀
txritino omg she’s my fav too
Same
Mine too
Mine tooo
..she is love ❤️❤️
She's definitely cute. I personally find all of Ash's companions boring, except for my man Brock.
Misty and Brock are my favorites! The original three travellers were iconic!
I totally agree with you on Serena. She is best girl
Sara Hardwick Hell nah more like most overrated girl. She’s a really weak trainer and theirs not really much to her beyond her crush on Ash she comes off kind of bland to be honest. And even then I don’t ship them cuz of how forced it is.
Shady Boy that’s your stupid opinion.
Sara Hardwick Agreed 👍
Sara Hardwick Agreed 👍
@@shadyboy5090 i totally agree with you serenea is overrated as fuck
My favourites are Dawn and Serena. Oh and obviously Brock
Same!
Giratina awesome
Same❤️
@Merciless Freak If you're gonna insult her, at least use some points what made her bad. Overrated is such a pretentious statement.
Dawn goes through more character development than Serena tbh.
Serena is kind of overrated.
TheBlazeMaster well duh.
No shit Sherlock...
No. She had a lot of character development. But you have to watch the entire Sinnoh anime to know this.
and may goes through more development than dawn
My opinions:
Girls:
Serena is my favourite.
Dawn and May are my second favourite.
Lillie and Bonnie and Mallow are my third favourite.
Misty is close to be on my third spot but now she's on fourth fav along with Lana.
Iris might be my least favourite of them but I still like her.
Boys:
Brock is my favourite.
Clemont is my second favourite.
Kiawe is my third favourite.
Cilan is my fourth favourite.
Tracey is... Forgettable...
Max annoys me but I don't hate him.
I'm not a big fan of Sophocles.
You forgot soph
@@certifiedoutcast264 Ummm.. No. Sofockles is mentioned.
@@husariuspl117 Sophocles
@@MrSonicHedgehog My mistake. Now it's alright.
I love May, max , bonnie, and clemont
May was my fave. Just curious, but does any one else like the gen 5 anime with Iris and Cilan?
They would give a breath of fresh air if the writer are competent (they aren't). Like, they managed to mess with N's story too.
I did
That feel when Iris is my favorite of the main female travelling companions and everyone hates her. Bonnie is my favorite overall though
Same, I love Iris but she gets way less credit then she deserves
Since i was born in mid-late hoenn,misty,may,,max,dawn,and brock are my fav
I was born in 92 so I love misty :3 everyone else sucks
The OofMan I was born during the Battle Frontier so I watched DP and onward but I hate Sun and Moon a lot. On another note I did go back and finish watching The Hoenn anime.
Gabe Silva yea ima do that too
TheBlazeMaster lol pls stop with this.. The kids who whine about kanto but think black and white is the best gen are just this generations’ gen wunners.
Anyone else remember when N travelled with Ash and gang for a few episodes? That was cool.
' 8 o8iionion mk
One of the few good parts about BW.
Iris was actually likeable to me. She’s my 2nd favorite female companion right behind Misty. Sure many people got annoyed with her “what a little kid” catchphrase but she was still a breath of fresh air. Iris proved herself to be a strong trainer because she always puts up a great fight in all her battles, she’s brave because of how she climbed up a clock tower to rescue the Gible she captured, has a good skill of finding good food in the wild & specializes in dragon types which we all know is one of the best typings. It’s also good that she has variety of typings in her team even though she wants to be a dragon master. Excadrill fits her team very well because it is part steel type so she has defense against ice and fairy types which are the 2 weaknesses of dragons. Overall in my opinion Iris was amazing & she was a perfect Misty clone. Fight me haters ;)
I actually love Iris.! She is the least sexualized pokegirl (besides Lana), and she had this "Tribal" feeling about her, sure she was little annoying sometimes, but so was Ash, Misty, May, Max, Dawn, and even Serena.! So I don't get the hate.
Mixer Joy I am a Boy. I love all companions but if I were to pick less likeable characters than Iris it would be Tracey and Max. No offense to their fans. All of them still have their own amazing sides and deserve respect so spread love and not hate.
+Migs Pogi The companions I like less than Iris are Cilan (I really like him but less than Iris), Bonnie (At first she was kinda annoying in a adorable way, she actually became good when Squishy showed up), Sophocles, Max and Tracey.
+Saberian Dream That's true. I don't hate B&W but if I had to pick the weakest series I will choose B&W. And yeah I find Iris Cute too. :)
@@saberiandream316 I had Crush on may lol.😂 I always wanted Iris to be in real life cuz she is my type of girl, and Dawn has a complete character arc.. When she had her loosing streak she became depressed but had a smile on her face she took a little break and came on top with better performances.! I love her.❤ and obviously love Misty and Serena too, rn I really have a huge crush on Lillie lol.😅😂
My friends: WE SHIP ASH AND DAWN
7 year old me who had a crush on Dawn: Uhhh of course......
I mean who didn't let's be real
Yeah dawn was hot!
YES I FOUND MY PEOPLE 😆
Dawn suck overrated
@@jlf6235 Yes!
Don’t agree with you about Iris. The B&W anime had a lot of problems that I put solely on the writers. Complaining about her Drilbur when she chooses to be come a Dragon master is like complaining to an Ice Pokemon master why they choose a Squirtle when they started.
Iris got along great with all kinds of Pokémon, and their is a good story in B&W how she met Drilbur then became a great battler, and then met Drayden. After that meeting she choose to work toward being a Dragon master.
I mean, Misty is a water pokemon trainer but her signature pokemon is arguably Togepi -a fairy type.
@@antifagoat6591
And Togepi isn't even a Kanto pokemon.
Agreed!! Iris is also skilled in finding good food in the wild & brave for saving the Gible she caught from falling off a clock tower. I’d say she deserves praise because she can do amazing things that the other companions cant do
Ash's companions from best to worst
Dawn and Brock
Serena
Clement
Cilan
May
Bonnie
Misty
Tracey
Max
Iris
I can't rate Alola yet until the series is finished
supersonicmario56 most of the girls in Alola are so annoying. The one that are traveling with ash. But Lillie and her mom are cool
@@truearea53 So far, Lana's my favorite. She's adorable, but for the love of Arceus, don't piss her off . . . .
Here's my ratings: Lillie has amazing character development. Mallow's backstory is kinda tragic. Lana is cool and adorable. Remember when she encountered a kyogre? Kiawe was a rival figure to ash hes awesome. And sophocles was cool in the games but am i the only who thought he got nerfed in the anime like Iris? Still a better character than iris and cilan tho.
Dawn was the best companion
@Merciless Freak so 8s serena
Is
She was my favourite but now she's my second favourite. So Yeah... She was.
Yup she is gooooood
brock man...hes amazing...cook lovesick stupid...
I don't get why people hate clilen, iris, and max and love misty. Also is anyone going to say anything about the fact that misty hit brock with a log because I find it unjustified. Also I can't spell many words correctly.
Because misty is the best and because Cilan Iris Max all deserve to be hated. Misty was an OG character so that means that most OG fans like me like the original companions meanwhile new gen people are mostly Serena fans and whatever Alola companions they like and the in between like may and Dawn but hate max because he pretends to be a know it all and also his voice is very annoying. Iris is just mean to Ash she always says he is an idiot and barely supports him any times and also she always makes a big deal out of nothing ma while Misty and Ash did have their fights but they always forgave each other really fast because they were such great friends and they had been through a lot together and also Misty liked ash. Cillan on the other hand is boring AF! He's always like omg I'm a fishing conisour omg I'm a movie conisour omg I'm a boring character in Pokemon conisouer! He literally had no character development at all because he apparently is a conisuer of everything in the universe.
William Maya I felt that some of Misty’s anger toward Ash was justified; she had plenty of experience with Pokémon, Ash was a bit of a dolt, and Pikachu zapped her bike. That and she has a functioning brain. Not too sure why she was mad at Brock, but I’m assuming it’s for his most memorable trait.
Oh and I guess the logs weigh next to nothing in Pokémon, as 10 year olds seem to throw them around like nothing.
honestly, i don't care much about anime Iris. But the game? oh boy, she's amazing
@Jancy Varghese Iris is a amazing champion especially compared to aleder
Jancy Varghese
Guess what bud? Misty didn’t do jack much in the games either aside from being a gym leader and Gen one had terrible blury rendered sprites so you’re not one to talk. Oh, and if you reply to me calling me a “newgenner” or whatever that just makes you a hypocrite.
Dawn have a great chestrisy with ash during the diamond and Pearl
Dawn, Cynthia, Garchomp and Brock are still the only characters id ever sleep with
Dawn and Brock are still my favourite companions. Sinnoh was my childhood :)
Iris and Misty are literally just the same character
Idk why everyone hates her. She’s just a black Misty. Look at her behavior and features and Misty’s and it’s the exact same.
@LadyJ 22 it's more like nostalgia and one gets more screen time being in a more perfered season
She called ash a kid a lot (even with stuff he genuinely didn't know like cursed body), which was annoying, almost all of her team disobeyed her (tho excadrill had a legit reason), and her Axew, Never, EVOLVED!! Even tho a) we know he wants to become a haxorus and b) that's precisely what Iris is supposed to b helping him become, not small and annoying as heck. He's cute, and his relationship with scraggy- was good, but that's all the props axew ever gets.
Except that misty got nicer and is not a hypocrite calling ash a little kid
May is the best female companion in my opinion
My top 3
Serena
May
Dawn
I respect you highly now
My top 3
Dawn
Misty
May
I respect you very much
Second
FlameFlamedramon VA sometimes she makes no sense tho. In the beginning, she said she didn't like Pokemon but then catches a couples episode later without any explanation besides that its cute. Like what up with that
Am I the only person in the universe that doesn't understand the love for Serena?
Serena knew Ash since they were little and after Ash saved her when they first meet she fell in love with him ever since lool
Ooh if you are talking about why people love serena well... let's just say it's mostly because we love her and Ash together lool
@@maganhassan2627 so basically you love her for a reason that doesnt relate to pokemon at all. good grief
wait what? what the heck are you on about??
Magan Hassan basically you’re saying you like Serena because she has a crush on Ash which doesn’t acc relate to the show at all. it’s your opinion though and we r all allowed opinions so
Dawn literally had the most character development of the female protagonists
Facts
@@p3mcthedoor32 im sorry but no i think may had so much more development id say dawn is the second most developed female protagonist
the true facts
My favorite companions for Ash Ketchum are Serena and dawn
I agree.
Yes I love Diamond and Pearl Series and Pokemon XY series
Agreed man
Dawn? Ok. Serena? Eww!
@@LittleAl016 same dude
"he[brock] recently got a mega steelix, and a comfey!"
Me: -and a girlfriend-
Who is also a rock type trainer!
Dawn exists ya know.
@@silentspirit8923 so, what I'm getting from this is Olivia.
My ranking of ash’s companions
1.may
2.brock
3.misty
4.dawn
The only ones that matter
gligar7000 ikr :)
Thank you for being the only person that doesn't think Serena is automatically the best for just liking ash
Blockgaming She’s the best because she goes through a damn story arc, which is more than most can say.
And that’s the facts
WARNING. THE FOLLWOING MESSAGE IS A RANT FROM A WEIRD SALTY FANDOM FANATIC. YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED!
Am I the only person who loves Max? I like his character development, and his rude know-it-all personality was developed into occasional sarcasm. (Though I realize people dont see the sarcasm, my point still stands) I get moments of rudeness and stuff, but there are episodes and sections of movies that really show his development. (Like befriending a deoxys in that 2 part episode, saving a ralts, befriending a shuppet, etc etc jirachi) I remember seeing an arguement about the shuppet episode thing saying "Max is so bratty, he ran away from his sister and played a trick on them that could've killed them" However it wasn't considered that he ran away because May had said she never wanted a brother like him (geez man that's harsh) and he also said something like "My sister really likes this torchic so you cant have it" when faced alone with team rocket. It shows that he does care about them even though other characters may not return those feelings. My last point is short and sweet, he's just a kid. Every kid has those sarcasm moments, especially around the age he appears to be in the anime
Sorry for my rant, but as Ive been seeing more and more people thinking negatively of Max, I really just want to make a statement. Even if it doesnt go far, I'd be happy to hear I changed at least a single person's mind.
I think Max is a cool character. He actually reminds me of Max from Dragon Tales
His bratty attitude can be savage sometimes and it was lit. Damn he pulls brock's ears when he's trying to hit girls. I like him even more than Bonnie.
Personally, I really liked the interactions between Ash and Dawn; the way they both supported and complimented each other.
All of the companions had good points but you're right abour Max probably having the least.
… I think you've already done one on Ash's rivals, haven't you? (Paul is the best though)
BW was trash, and nearly completely killed my interest in the anime after I started watching it again since I loved the Gen5 games so much. Iris had a lot to do with it, as did Ash regressing into being completely inept.
Thank god XY/Z and SM brought some new life to the series, despite how controversial the latter is.
BW is the worst anime series for pokemon, Sun and Moon is up there maybe one of my top three.
I prefer the game Iris way more though.
@@duykhangtran4406 Game Iris is fine. My issues with her only apply to her anime incarnation.
I'd have had Ash win in Sinnoh, and then do a proper reboot of the series starting with either a new Ash in a separate continuity, or a whole new character entirely, starting out on their journey after being inspired by Ash, the new Champion of Sinnoh.
SM is like black and white but its executed well they make ash look like a kid again but dont make him a full idiot and doesnt know anything like b&w
One of my favorite My opinion videos by far.
Same here.
@@Wildcatt1999
You both have Incineroar profile pics!
“Dawn felt like she was there and had no character development.”
Lol, Mystic. I believe you’re getting Dawn mixed up with Serena 😛😛
looks like your auto-correct replaced MISTY with SERENA
@@Rainbocrescendo no it was definitely Serena
@@gitap7869 i agree... defintly serena
@@gitap7869 are you crazy? Serena had the most development of any character, with Lillie second. Dawn went from a cocky to confident. That's about it. Serena went from being a shy young naive girl who is stuck in her life and wants to escape to being a strong confident woman who wasnt afraid to make tough decisions.
I wan't to hear why Serena, I mean i literally see no argument in the whole comment section why supposedly she has no arc when she has the best development of the whole bunch alongside Dawn..
Say what you will about Iris in the anime...
*But Axew*
*no no he's got a point*
I wish they had made Axew evolve at the very least into a Fraxure. It was established pretty early that it did want to evolve, yet it was treated as a baby by the writers for the entirety of the series.
My companion ranking :
1. May and Max
2. Misti
3. Dawn
0/10 Not enough Serena or Mallow
@@Someone-sq8im you are an idiot
Why max is at number 1
May is my favorite no matter what....
Where's Serena
THE FUTURE IS NOW THANKS TO SCIENCE
BOOOOOOOOOM!
I’ll use my *FRYING PAN*,
AS A *DRYING PAN*
What about a NUKING PAN!
@@justarandomsovietofficerwi2023 then you have better chances of survival
Nothing beats
A jelly filled dounut
Pokémon XY and XYZ will always be my favorite few seasons of the series, but Serena is definitely one of the weaker points of the series. As a character, she’s pretty good, but they just focused way too much on the shipping aspect for my liking.
Serena and May are tied for my favorites. Gen VI seasons were my favorite of all.
Ace of Schrades Although May is cool, but I think she digs Drew. And I can’t argue that Serena is the best. But your opinion is respected.
I just feel Serena had the best development of character through all 3 seasons of Kalos.
As for May, I have had a crush on her since I was 10. One of my KH OCs is loosely based off of her.
Lol actually may and serena are the prettiest
@idk maybe memes ;D lol that's right
May's lower eye in the jpeg that you're using in the thumbnail is really freaking me out.
needs lazy eye correction surgery.
With your thoughts about Iris:
I feel the exact same way but with Serena instead of Iris but I cant even say without getting attacked because shes so popular. Nobody attacks you for disliking Iris but people would have attacked you for disliking Serena.
My favorites are Brock, dawn, May and Serena
Bonnie was literally the best companion when she sang her special song to calm Zygarde
I cried
True though.
i was screaming: ''YOU OWN A POKEMON THAT IS LEGENDARY''
I didn't like Bonnie but I completely forgot Max existed. Fully agree Max is the worst.
Azure Blackbird Bonnie has earned my respect and proved that she’s the best sibling. But Max on the other hand, is so annoying.
:0 how dare you talk about max that way
I totally agree! I totally ship Ash and Serena.
Misty is fine and iconic and all, but I dunno...I was never a fan of hers. I didn't dislike her or anything and she definitely had her moments. But overall, she wasn't ever that interesting to me.
Brock was, is and will always be great.
I feel like my opinions on the companions are a bit more controversial. Because I actually kinda liked Tracy. He wasn't as good as Brock, no, but he brought a whole new perspective onto the Pokemon world. Not everyone needs to be focused on Pokemon training to have passion for something in this world. Sure, you have your occasional professor, but Tracy's interests extended further than researching Pokemon. I found him rather interesting.
May I just...never liked. I personally saw her as whiny and bratty and she would sulk every time she lost. I don't feel like she ever got THAT much development. Max either, for that matter. The fact that his character never REALLY went anywhere is kind of the biggest reason, I think.
Dawn I loved. She's probably my favorite of Ash's female companions. Her, her Pokemon, her contest performances...everything was always so much fun to watch with her. And I liked her rivals a bit more too, for the most part.
Iris...well, back to the controversial thing. While I wouldn't say Iris was something I particularly liked, I did tolerate her presence and enjoyed what she brought to the table. One of the things that won me over with her was her relationship with Excadrill. It was a complicated relationship that developed over time. And I appreciated the fact that Excadrill wasn't a Dragon-type. It shows that even though she wanted to be a Dragon master...she didn't let that blind her from blooming friendships with other Pokemon companions. Her personality was annoying and grating at times, yes. However, I enjoyed her quirkiness from time to time and she was fun to watch battle. Coupled with the new animation style, a change that I absolutely loved, I rather enjoyed Iris's presence.
Cilan is a character I really loved. I always have a fondness for the intellectual type of character, and that's exactly what he came across as. There was absolutely nothing I didn't like about him. He's my second favorite of Ash's male companions, right behind Brock.
Clement was fine...but I didn't really enjoy him all that much. I thought his tech gimmick got old pretty fast, although I admit that I did look forward to seeing what machines he would build. Though the question of "how" and "when" he builds the machines always distracted me.
Bonnie was also just...fine. I didn't particularly like her, but I didn't dislike her like I did Max. But I did find her gimmick of trying to get a girlfriend for Clement was pretty funny at times.
Serena is a fantastic character. I appreciate how much character development she got and I appreciate her crush on Ash...because it wasn't reciprocated. I feel like they handled it very well. I just wish that her development started a bit earlier in the series. For the longest time, she was just one of the most pointless, annoying characters. However, when she got to her first showcase and lost...that's when I changed my mind on her. That is absolutely one of the most memorable episodes of that season because of the sudden 180 I did on her character.
I...don't care about any of the Alolan companions. I find them all kind of boring and generic, honestly. Well, except for Kiawe. He's kind of fun and he does put a new twist on the male companion archetype in that he teaches Ash instead of just doing things for him, but he has moments where I roll my eyes and just mumble "really?" I have seen it all the way through the end of the Lusamine arc and I'm just not hooked by anything. I am particularly spiteful of Lillie. I hate what they've done to her character. Though I admit, regarding Lillie, I think I'm just too biased. Lillie is one of the few things I loved about the SM games. She had such a perfect character arc that they could've recreated...and instead give her some weird NEW and unneeded change to her character arc that is so much less interesting to me really irks me. I'm not fond of the animation style either. I preferred the style of Unova and Kalos to this one...although I do like it a bit better than the original style.
Digizel the Bui saying May didn’t get development means ur blind
Totally agree with you, For me Ondine is super cool, if not just I think they should have created two characters in sun and moon, instead of five, for example we mix Lana, Lilie and Sophocles and we mix Mao and Kiwi and we get two characters interesting with multiple facets, not boring basic archetypes.
TheBlazeMaster an opinion or not obviously she got development and that’s a fact
@@eveegirl2878 May literally got the most development of all the pokegirls and i like that she started off as a whiny brat that would constantly complain to a kind girl and almost never argued with ash in battle frontier
Clemont was the best male traveling companion, he and kiawe, are amazing
Clemont, is blank as fuck Bonnie was way better
Kade Sutherland I don’t agree, he was Brock 2.0
I don´t want Brock in Galar, In my opinion, Brock was a mentor figure for Ash/Satoshi and he already knows what he needs to know (that would be too much gen 1 exposition and that already is a problem sometimes). Also gen 5 was a soft reboot of the franchise, Cilan and Iris were parallels of the gen 1 companions but way more annoying because of some bad habits and designs (Cilan looks too much like Richie Rich and I would prefer to see Iris with her design from the games and as the Champion) . I prefer a new male companion that can have a small friendly rivalry like what happened with Citron/Clemont in XYZ (I liked that Citron not only saw him as a friend but also as a rival/trainer that he had to fight as a gym leader and as a trainer recognizing another´s trainer strength) .
In the game, Iris is the 8th gym leader, in here, she just begin her journey but she can still be lest annoying righ?
@TheBlazeMaster deepen on weither you play black or white. I played white and Iris is the gym leader
@TheBlazeMaster yep. But not in the sequel
@TheBlazeMaster yes.
May is my best girl
She had my favorite Pokémon of all time, Blaziken
I was like 6 when I saw the anime and I fell in love for the first time
Blaziken is also my favourite pokemon of all time.