An elevator that actually goes sideways

SdĂ­let
VloĆŸit
  • čas pƙidĂĄn 25. 06. 2017
  • I've filmed a paternoster lift; I've filmed the strange Genoa elevator that sort-of goes sideways. So when I got an email from Thyssenkrupp, an elevator company, saying "come and see our Multi elevator that actually goes sideways", I wasn't going to turn it down.
    Full disclosure: Thyssenkrupp paid for my travel to Germany, but that's all they did. I'd got in touch with them last year asking to see this when it opened; their PR firm replied, offering to fly me out. They had no editorial control over this, and didn't get to see it before it was uploaded!
    More information about Multi: multi.thyssenkrupp-elevator.c...
    Thanks to Michelle Martin (@mrsmmartin) for help editing the interviews!
    đŸŸ„ MORE FROM TOM: www.tomscott.com/
    (you can find contact details and social links there too)
    📰 WEEKLY NEWSLETTER with good stuff from the rest of the internet: www.tomscott.com/newsletter/
    ❓ LATERAL, free weekly podcast: lateralcast.com/ / lateralcast
    ➕ TOM SCOTT PLUS: / tomscottplus
    đŸ‘„ THE TECHNICAL DIFFICULTIES: / techdif

Komentáƙe • 3,7K

  • @TomScottGo
    @TomScottGo  Pƙed 7 lety +5852

    Feel free to argue whether I should have made the title "elevator" or "lift" here. (No, this isn't a sponsored video: pull down the description for more about that!)

    • @christkv
      @christkv Pƙed 7 lety +113

      Frankly as an engineer the more moving parts the more things can break. Seems like an expensive maintenance nightmare.

    • @pellaken
      @pellaken Pƙed 7 lety +142

      It is a turbolift, therefore even as a Canadian, I say you should use "lift"

    • @eriknakamura
      @eriknakamura Pƙed 7 lety +83

      Tom Scott You say elevator in the video so the title should be elevator too. Just for consistency.

    • @henryb3066
      @henryb3066 Pƙed 7 lety +57

      I'd say that you should've said lift but knowing how little the word is actually used in the English speaking community (only in Great Britain) and that your audience is statistically primarily outside of England elevator is the most common term and most successful in getting your message across.

    • @Throckmorpheus
      @Throckmorpheus Pƙed 7 lety +51

      Plus, it dosen't only only elevate, soooo...

  • @eliwatson7936
    @eliwatson7936 Pƙed 4 lety +8382

    “Magnetic linear induction motor” I can’t be bothered to take the stairs, I’ll just take the *vertical railgun*

    • @zaicol850
      @zaicol850 Pƙed 4 lety +399

      I wonder if the elevator music in this thing will be actually "Only my Railgun"

    • @florianvahl5494
      @florianvahl5494 Pƙed 4 lety +228

      Technically more like a coil gun, but you got the spirit.

    • @londongrace5784
      @londongrace5784 Pƙed 4 lety +47

      BFG enters chat

    • @v12tommy
      @v12tommy Pƙed 4 lety +13

      linear synchronous motor actually

    • @D3nn1s
      @D3nn1s Pƙed 4 lety +9

      U made me giggle :)

  • @quagliumquagnarr3853
    @quagliumquagnarr3853 Pƙed 6 lety +7994

    Trains are the original sideways elevator.

    • @junglefett
      @junglefett Pƙed 5 lety +462

      Elevators are just vertical trains.

    • @QuasiELVIS
      @QuasiELVIS Pƙed 4 lety +172

      @@junglefett More like vertical cable cars.

    • @Tensho_C
      @Tensho_C Pƙed 4 lety +47

      @@junglefett trains are horizontal elevators

    • @customisbababy
      @customisbababy Pƙed 4 lety +6

      Quaglium Quagnarr would like but you have 666 likes

    • @qeelevators2960
      @qeelevators2960 Pƙed 4 lety +4

      1,000th like!

  • @ImQueenElizibeth
    @ImQueenElizibeth Pƙed 3 lety +1282

    Late to the party but the idea of a company just being excited to share their product with you instead of forcing you to endorse it is really refreshing.

    • @Nietabs
      @Nietabs Pƙed 2 lety +9

      I wish more of the rest do the same.

    • @Jacob-Sophia
      @Jacob-Sophia Pƙed rokem +28

      It seems kind of hard to justify an elevator sponsorship plug though

    • @ExperimentRender
      @ExperimentRender Pƙed rokem +13

      Sponsored by ThyssenKrupp VPN!

    • @rf6530
      @rf6530 Pƙed rokem +3

      TK should also have tried to have refreshments for the poor workers of their Turin plant that burned alive insted of some, let's say, safety shortcuts.

    • @Uruz2012
      @Uruz2012 Pƙed 4 měsĂ­ci +1

      The whole video is literally an ad for Thysenkrup elevator company and how they have tech others dont

  • @juxtaposition9424
    @juxtaposition9424 Pƙed 4 lety +816

    When I imagined a sideways elevator, I imagined something that takes you to separate rooms in a _really_ long horizontal building

    • @mrjakobt
      @mrjakobt Pƙed 4 lety +72

      It will be able to do that. This is just for demonstration purposes.

    • @candrafamily2109
      @candrafamily2109 Pƙed 3 lety +6

      🚂

    • @terry2295
      @terry2295 Pƙed 3 lety +2

      my thoughts exactly

    • @taylorboys3791
      @taylorboys3791 Pƙed 3 lety +6

      Like a assembly plant, where the line for cars are over a mile.

    • @COD5haxors
      @COD5haxors Pƙed 3 lety +12

      We shall call it Side-vator;)

  • @lukakresoja5297
    @lukakresoja5297 Pƙed 5 lety +3631

    The elevator buffer will reduse the fall from _fatal_ to *_serious injury_*

    • @adammcfall5133
      @adammcfall5133 Pƙed 4 lety +458

      Between dying or losing a leg, I think I rather lose the leg.

    • @user-df7px1tg4b
      @user-df7px1tg4b Pƙed 4 lety +271

      @@adammcfall5133 I'll rather die

    • @nicorohde7058
      @nicorohde7058 Pƙed 4 lety +49

      @cumquatrct3 Not a good idea

    • @kenetickups6146
      @kenetickups6146 Pƙed 4 lety +1

      Ke Gao same

    • @Crustee0
      @Crustee0 Pƙed 4 lety +38

      Assasin Patates no, its already a feat to be able to jump in a situation like that, but even if u could it would be just like jumping on a non moving elevator

  • @tbotalpha8133
    @tbotalpha8133 Pƙed 6 lety +153

    for some reason, the fact that a building exists solely to test elevators makes me really happy.

    • @IdotKid
      @IdotKid Pƙed 6 měsĂ­ci

      elevation

  • @GonkDroid0923
    @GonkDroid0923 Pƙed 3 lety +921

    It is amazing how Tom Scott can fit an entire documentary in 4 minutes

    • @adamthomas1222
      @adamthomas1222 Pƙed 2 lety +21

      I know right, any of these other educational CZcamsrs will stretch this out for almost 20 minutes

    • @eklhaft4531
      @eklhaft4531 Pƙed 2 lety +17

      @@adamthomas1222 Some bad documentaries would make it 40 minutes plus repeating every clip and every explanation at least 5x.
      Edit: And wouldn't even show the good bits.

    • @99Gara99
      @99Gara99 Pƙed rokem +5

      This video if from a time when youtube videos had to be around 4-8min

    • @gonkdroid8279
      @gonkdroid8279 Pƙed rokem +1

      GONK

  • @Poincianaa
    @Poincianaa Pƙed 4 lety +1782

    0:40 Wow that's almost at the build limit

    • @furrettheferret9562
      @furrettheferret9562 Pƙed 4 lety +24

      Raptor _TX so what will happen when they reach the limit?

    • @alyx1a
      @alyx1a Pƙed 4 lety +252

      @Blathers The Owl if you're on java nothing will happen, if you're on bedrock you'll get spammed with text

    • @Mullac
      @Mullac Pƙed 4 lety +32

      H3mispher3 You all have a good taste in video games I see?

    • @glipk
      @glipk Pƙed 4 lety +3

      What's that

    • @VoxelMusic
      @VoxelMusic Pƙed 3 lety +125

      If the elevator fails there is a block of water at the bottom so no worries.

  • @lammy1234567890
    @lammy1234567890 Pƙed 7 lety +5275

    This was actually commissioned by a certain W. Wonka

    • @napoleonibonaparte7198
      @napoleonibonaparte7198 Pƙed 7 lety +17

      lammy1234567890 Best comment

    • @HarryRobins
      @HarryRobins Pƙed 7 lety +36

      Willy Wonka? More like Silly Plonker!

    • @karlkastor
      @karlkastor Pƙed 7 lety +104

      There's no certain way of knowing, which direction we are going.

    • @anatoleh1
      @anatoleh1 Pƙed 7 lety +101

      Does it fly out of the shaft when yo press a special button? :D

    • @misteryman526
      @misteryman526 Pƙed 7 lety +38

      Actually, I figured Starfleet had commisioned it. It's basically a Turbolift

  • @paintedeevee4581
    @paintedeevee4581 Pƙed 7 lety +285

    "... should reduce a free-fall drop from fatal to just severe injures says Tom with a slight chuckle.

    • @airport862
      @airport862 Pƙed 6 lety +11

      I'd rather pass on the severe injury. Thank you.

    • @jonathandpg6115
      @jonathandpg6115 Pƙed 6 lety +3

      right kill me instead

    • @vnleao
      @vnleao Pƙed 6 lety +3

      I think the damage reduction is likely precisely the amount required by the lawyers before they found a good legal loophole to protect themselves with

  • @SubsonicNoise
    @SubsonicNoise Pƙed 2 lety +54

    Tagentially related, but also in germany: A random train station in Berlin has an elevator that goes up from the platform, sideways over the rails, and then down the other side. I went on it coming home from a party and just kinda stood there afterwards processing what happened lmao

    • @simoncroft9792
      @simoncroft9792 Pƙed rokem

      Tom has done that one too see PeopleMover video

    • @GerhardMack
      @GerhardMack Pƙed rokem +16

      Schmid Peoplemover and he did a video on this too.

  • @renewings
    @renewings Pƙed 3 lety +541

    We are one step closer to recreate Willy Wonka's Chocolate Factory.

  • @dariuspumma
    @dariuspumma Pƙed 4 lety +3403

    Everyone: You cant build an elevator that goes sideways
    German engineers: *Are you sure about that?*

    • @foximacentauri7891
      @foximacentauri7891 Pƙed 4 lety +106

      You mean *Ar yuo sure abaut tat?*

    • @sopheakheng3230
      @sopheakheng3230 Pƙed 4 lety +60

      You mean hold my beer?

    • @victorselve8349
      @victorselve8349 Pƙed 4 lety +191

      @@sopheakheng3230 what do you mean hold my beer?
      A German engineer can design that with one hand

    • @tlonigamer421
      @tlonigamer421 Pƙed 4 lety +71

      *_YOU UTTER FOOL! GERMAN ENGINEERING IS THE WORLD'S GREATEST!_*

    • @donny4358
      @donny4358 Pƙed 4 lety +21

      Tlonigamer *GERMAN ENGINEERING? IM SORRY, JUST KIDDING IM NOT, BUT MY GERMAN SCIENCE IS SUPERIOR!!!*

  • @MicroBlogganism
    @MicroBlogganism Pƙed 7 lety +270

    The Lift Trilogy is complete

    • @Kitsu_o7
      @Kitsu_o7 Pƙed 7 lety +58

      Next stop:
      Spinoffs and reboots

    • @metropod
      @metropod Pƙed 7 lety +11

      MicroBlogganism we need six axis movement so we can finally have a true turbolift.

    • @DragonMaster1804
      @DragonMaster1804 Pƙed 7 lety +23

      For the sake of human lives, I really hope there are no lift spin-offs.

    • @scharliescheen3109
      @scharliescheen3109 Pƙed 7 lety +6

      where is mu merchandise and blurays? i want a pop figure!

  • @smallmailman3992
    @smallmailman3992 Pƙed 4 lety +154

    Finally, my dreams of entering the choclate factory of a genius madman with little people as workers is one step closer to reality.

    • @Juli-lf5kc
      @Juli-lf5kc Pƙed 3 lety +1

      They still need to create a new continent.

  • @lukel.6582
    @lukel.6582 Pƙed 4 lety +129

    Sponsored! You can't trick me Tom, I will not buy elevators for the many story building I'm definitely going to construct.

    • @nes999
      @nes999 Pƙed rokem

      I know of people who are brand loyal to certain elevators and refuse to rise one not made by certain companies.
      Me? I'm far too lazy too care. I don't value my life that much.

    • @Fifsson_
      @Fifsson_ Pƙed rokem +1

      @@nes999 wait actually like who the hell does that?

    • @nes999
      @nes999 Pƙed rokem +1

      @Fifsson_ Most famously Tom Griswold of the Bob and Tom show. However, I've known two separate lawyers in the Chicagoland area who are also equally brand loyal.

    • @apveening
      @apveening Pƙed rokem

      @@nes999 As you say you have known them, I guess that lasted until the elevator/lift of their preferred branch crashed with them in it.

  • @slabo9035
    @slabo9035 Pƙed 5 lety +951

    Five years later:
    *walks into turbo lift”
    “Bridge”

    • @Roalethiago
      @Roalethiago Pƙed 4 lety +12

      4y, and i hope your prediction is right hahaha

    • @andrewrivera8651
      @andrewrivera8651 Pƙed 4 lety +2

      Yes!

    • @Darkhandrob
      @Darkhandrob Pƙed 4 lety +13

      @@Roalethiago Let's make it 5y again, because of current events.

    • @shiningarmor2838
      @shiningarmor2838 Pƙed 4 lety +10

      @@Darkhandrob We've still got 47 years until we even reach Warp 1

    • @Darthybuddy
      @Darthybuddy Pƙed 4 lety +4

      1 year down. 4 to go.

  • @squareplayn
    @squareplayn Pƙed 7 lety +347

    These lifts can also accelerate incredibly fast with a super high top-speed. Way faster than the humans riding it would be able to handle. The main part of this system is actually developed by ProDrive, Eindhoven. I had a tour there, they have a really interesting factory. Super small, yet super efficient, automated and suitable for many many different products. Doesn't look like a factory at all, they even have research in the same building as it. I'd imagine they'd be more than happy to give you a tour and show you the way main part is built and developed (spoiler, it's very interesting).

    • @15Redstones
      @15Redstones Pƙed 7 lety +5

      Victor Titov actually there are already towers for that, and Tom made a video about the one in Bremen. It's actually a lot simpler than this.

    • @slaughterround643
      @slaughterround643 Pƙed 7 lety +3

      Nyll Nyll Was that a joke about the German accent or did you misspell wary?

    • @hebl47
      @hebl47 Pƙed 7 lety +26

      Actually, humans can handle any speed if travelling in an enclosed space. It's the acceleration that we feel, not speed.

    • @wolframstahl1263
      @wolframstahl1263 Pƙed 7 lety +4

      Sqare Play'n, that sounds like video material for Tom, I for one would love to see him showcase that. Have a like and comment for visibility, maybe we'll learn some more!

    • @dragoncurveenthusiast
      @dragoncurveenthusiast Pƙed 7 lety

      Hebl von Heblowitz I was about to comment the same.

  • @sebastianhjdbejyu
    @sebastianhjdbejyu Pƙed 3 lety +144

    German engineer, elevators that go in all directions: Check.
    Next step: Teleportation, other engineers: impossible ... German engineer: I'm here, now here, now over here ....

    • @BJ-nj1st
      @BJ-nj1st Pƙed 2 lety +1

      Thyssen Nerds: Lets recreate the Turbolift from Star Trek.

    • @thesteelrodent1796
      @thesteelrodent1796 Pƙed rokem +1

      technically these are only 2-dimensional, but there are some warehouse systems that are able to move stuff 3-dimensional. It will be some time before we get systems like that for humans

    • @Edward256
      @Edward256 Pƙed rokem

      This is only the start. Turn this system into a type of cage and surely it can do all six directions at a six-way junction.

  • @DarwynVE
    @DarwynVE Pƙed 4 lety +15

    0:57 Ive never wanted 60fps video more in my life

  • @41-Haiku
    @41-Haiku Pƙed 7 lety +433

    "It's June 2018, and I'm once again in Germany to show you an elevator. This one is powered entirely by 99 luftballons."

  • @TheQwampa
    @TheQwampa Pƙed 7 lety +1438

    In which June will you show a space elevator?

    • @ncc74656m
      @ncc74656m Pƙed 7 lety +53

      You beat me to it. :D I figure 2027 or so. :P

    • @MrMisanthrope_
      @MrMisanthrope_ Pƙed 7 lety +13

      spider silk, we have our eye on you

    • @wolframstahl1263
      @wolframstahl1263 Pƙed 7 lety +20

      And what elevator will come in June after that?

    • @NighteeeeeY
      @NighteeeeeY Pƙed 7 lety +15

      spider silk? ^^ carbon nano tubes are laughing at you ;)

    • @supersonictumbleweed
      @supersonictumbleweed Pƙed 7 lety +3

      It's all about a combination of both nanotubes and silk, really.

  • @1999Cheker
    @1999Cheker Pƙed 4 lety +57

    Funfact: the tower also has the highest visitor platform in germany

    • @Tore_Lund
      @Tore_Lund Pƙed 2 lety +1

      Is it open to the public, or are they not running a tourist attraction?

    • @1999Cheker
      @1999Cheker Pƙed 2 lety +9

      @@Tore_Lund it's open to the public from Monday to Sunday. But You have to pay to go up

    • @lukebarkermusic
      @lukebarkermusic Pƙed 2 lety +1

      @@1999Cheker That's a good way of making some extra income from a testing facility. Looks really cool, I've love to visit some day!

  • @malikrath9503
    @malikrath9503 Pƙed 4 lety +41

    Thyssenkrupp is trying to build a Cube.

  • @funny-video-YouTube-channel
    @funny-video-YouTube-channel Pƙed 6 lety +918

    The Germans build the Elevator Simulator tower :-)
    Great invention. This type of flexible elevator will enable really tall buildings with multiple connections to other buildings.
    It will also enable more elevator cabins in one building, so that there can be maybe 10 elevator rooms floating between levels in a circle. It would probably be more efficient too, if the elevator has to travel fewer levels, before the passengers get out.

    • @valy5684
      @valy5684 Pƙed 6 lety +7

      Yeah, who else would do something like this? Can just be us Germans

    • @jort93z
      @jort93z Pƙed 6 lety +25

      also it would allow more than one elevators in one shaft. You could just shift the elevators out of the way when people are getting out so the next one can pass right through to the next level.

    • @harthenry
      @harthenry Pƙed 6 lety +32

      I think the real time savings will be the lift can "step aside" and let people in/out of the lift. This way, other lifts can continue to move up and down the shaft. The most time consuming thing about an elevator is getting people in and out of the cabin -- this eliminates that issue.

    • @yggdrssil00
      @yggdrssil00 Pƙed 6 lety

      elevator tower isnt new, i could see one from my home in penang. its really tall.

    • @mralistair737
      @mralistair737 Pƙed 5 lety +12

      connecting adjacent buildings is really tricky and rarely worthwhile. the advantage of this is really that you can have multiple cars in the same shafts at once.. if you are building a 100 storey tower, you can easily end up with wasting tons and tons of space on lift shafts with only one car in them. since you mutliply the area of a lift shaft (say 4 m2 ) over 100 floors, that's a lot of wasted space

  • @eprot6170
    @eprot6170 Pƙed 3 lety +28

    Me seeing this tower every day on my way to school: I know this somewhere...

  • @bowlchamps37
    @bowlchamps37 Pƙed 3 lety +13

    Fun fact: The farthest you can watch from the top of that tower in Rottweil, Germany is actually the land and forest I own.

    • @maiky4946
      @maiky4946 Pƙed 2 lety +8

      Weird flex but ok.

    • @its_sammm
      @its_sammm Pƙed 2 lety

      I live 16 kilometers from the tower! Where is your land approximately?

  • @stoborking
    @stoborking Pƙed 7 lety +460

    *2018*
    *Tom Scott:* And now it is June 2018 I am going to ride Willy Wonka's lift.

    • @TheGamingSyndrom
      @TheGamingSyndrom Pƙed 7 lety +1

      That Guy xD

    • @zionj104
      @zionj104 Pƙed 6 lety +3

      That actually sounds realistic.

    • @lehzy5669
      @lehzy5669 Pƙed 6 lety +3

      June 2019 would be Harry Potter's Ministry of Magic lift.

  • @WilliamBoothClibborn
    @WilliamBoothClibborn Pƙed 7 lety +1565

    All we need now is a chocolate river. Then we can start going full on Willy Wonka.

    • @jayzo
      @jayzo Pƙed 7 lety +63

      My local river's pretty brown. I know it's not chocolate and it's *definitely* not safe to consume, but it's a start.

    • @karlkastor
      @karlkastor Pƙed 7 lety +10

      There's no certain way of knowing, which direction we are going or which way the river's flowing.

    • @aaaaa359
      @aaaaa359 Pƙed 7 lety

      afxinfinitee You live in Mississippi?

    • @Mankorra_Gomorrah
      @Mankorra_Gomorrah Pƙed 7 lety +4

      The river has to be in a giant tube that is filled with LSD laced air above the chocolate river in order to be fully accurate.

    • @christianwetzel2199
      @christianwetzel2199 Pƙed 7 lety +3

      it doesn't fly, does it ?

  • @johnwang9914
    @johnwang9914 Pƙed rokem +4

    Remember that such an elevator can have multiple cars per shaft and can divert out of the shaft when picking up or depositing passengers so the other cars in the shaft can continue moving past it. Also, such elevators are what's described in science fiction, such as Star Trek's turbo elevators and such elevators could also move between buildings hence they are also PRT's.

  • @WokerThanThou
    @WokerThanThou Pƙed 4 lety +1

    Fwiw, saw this idea used a couple of times fictionally in the original Star Trek (1960s).
    While two of the actors did dialog, the indicator light in the background window showed each floor being passed would also go sideways showing each exit being passed on that level.
    Nice to know it's actually going to be a thing now.

    • @patricktho6546
      @patricktho6546 Pƙed 4 lety

      Star Treck is mostly science fiction (now partially reallity) rather than fiction.

  • @Cyranek
    @Cyranek Pƙed 7 lety +1758

    I'm not an engineer, but there's a part of me that elevates horizontally when I watch videos like this.

  • @mvl71
    @mvl71 Pƙed 5 lety +538

    _Not unnaturally, many elevators imbued with intelligence and precognition became terribly frustrated with the mindless business of going up and down, up and down, experimented briefly with the notion of going sideways, as a sort of existential protest, demanded participation in the decision-making process and finally took to squatting in basements sulking._
    (about the Sirius Cybernetics Corporation's _Happy Vertical People Transporters_ )

    • @ausbare140
      @ausbare140 Pƙed 5 lety +12

      I wonder how many people get that reference

    • @jonathanschaffer5758
      @jonathanschaffer5758 Pƙed 4 lety +4

      @@ausbare140I know about the Sirius Cybernetics Corporation

    • @smorris12
      @smorris12 Pƙed 4 lety +24

      Holy Zarquon, are they still in business?

    • @Niribu
      @Niribu Pƙed 4 lety +6

      42.

    • @polaroid5551
      @polaroid5551 Pƙed 4 lety +18

      @@ausbare140 Actually, anybody who has read the Hitchhikers guide to the galaxy and remember all the humour

  • @shotime95
    @shotime95 Pƙed 3 lety +5

    As a child I had so many nightmares where I'd be in an elevator that would suddenly move sideways/stop mid-way in the shaft and open the door/do weird things with floor numbers/keep moving upwards past the top floor, etc.

  • @felix30471
    @felix30471 Pƙed 3 lety +11

    I love how every German you interview has a very German English.

  • @LuddeVinje
    @LuddeVinje Pƙed 7 lety +236

    Theres a lift in Oslo that moves diagonally if you need something for next year.

    • @lompstem
      @lompstem Pƙed 7 lety +6

      there is also one on the tube at Greenford station!

    • @lompstem
      @lompstem Pƙed 7 lety +2

      and one on the melenium bridge in London

    • @scotiabricks
      @scotiabricks Pƙed 7 lety +2

      also the eiffel tower but that is more of a cable car

    • @metropod
      @metropod Pƙed 7 lety

      Ludvig Oftedal Vinje those things are evil. Two were ordered for the brand new 34th street-Hudson Yards station on New York's #7 line. The problems they gave delayed the station from opening for an entire year.

    • @AlRoderick
      @AlRoderick Pƙed 7 lety +5

      There's also the self leveling lift cars in the St. Louis Gateway Arch that run to the observation deck at the top, but in reality that's more a small angled train than an elevator.

  • @ian1064
    @ian1064 Pƙed 7 lety +490

    this is higher than the highest building in the Netherlands :(

    • @nicolastaub8857
      @nicolastaub8857 Pƙed 7 lety +194

      Isn't it even higher than the Netherlands itself ?

    • @eduardvaniersel7535
      @eduardvaniersel7535 Pƙed 7 lety +1

      not quite

    • @r0nas22
      @r0nas22 Pƙed 7 lety +255

      Ian Witten The Netherlands doesn't need high buildings. The people will get high enough without them.

    • @anatoleh1
      @anatoleh1 Pƙed 7 lety +21

      Their highest buildings are the walls that block wind I guess xD

    • @SpektralJo
      @SpektralJo Pƙed 7 lety +2

      No, you have the Gerbrandytoren

  • @NathanJamesJerritze
    @NathanJamesJerritze Pƙed 2 lety +3

    tom has seen a lot of elevators
    what an uplifting experience

  • @philippfolkerts6120
    @philippfolkerts6120 Pƙed 3 lety

    For each and every one of your videos, you have the best closing lines EVER❀

  • @niallw547
    @niallw547 Pƙed 7 lety +174

    So basically we're just waiting for someone in dubai to buy them

    • @mxtsy381
      @mxtsy381 Pƙed 7 lety +7

      afaik, some companies already bought them. Not just Dubai, also Hamburg and somebody in scandinavia

    • @foximacentauri7891
      @foximacentauri7891 Pƙed 4 lety +1

      @@mxtsy381 a whole new generation of buildings are approaching.

  • @EoRdE6
    @EoRdE6 Pƙed 5 lety +12

    This is actually highly impressive when you consider the operational implications of such a system. It's like comparing Personal Rapid Transit (PRT) to a traditional subway. This allows elevators to share a single elevator shaft and not block each other's progress, they can "pull off" like exiting a highway at the desired floor and stop, while allowing other elevators to continue past. Almost like adding sidings and crossovers to a single track railway. This could have big implications for future elevator design, currently tall buildings need such a large number of elevator shafts it becomes impractical and takes up enormous floor space on the lower floors

  • @leonghk12
    @leonghk12 Pƙed 4 lety +34

    i've seen a lift that can move in any direction, i believe its called a forklift.

    • @ZaHandle
      @ZaHandle Pƙed 4 lety +1

      can it do a barrel roll?

    • @jnwms
      @jnwms Pƙed 3 lety +1

      @@ZaHandle do you mean an aileron roll

    • @MonkeyJedi99
      @MonkeyJedi99 Pƙed 3 lety

      But what if you're not moving forks?

    • @caroleast9636
      @caroleast9636 Pƙed 3 lety +1

      There’s already a lift that can go sideways. It’s known as an "order picker" and is used in large storage buildings.

  • @apersunthathasaridiculousl1890

    “Elevator that moves sideways”
    Me: so? A train?

  • @Halefall
    @Halefall Pƙed 7 lety +894

    now, this could make for some very interesting new skyscraper shapes. It just needs bold enough architects (which I'm sure are plenty) and very wealthy investors, who might be more difficult to find. But I bet this'll be eventually used somewhere in Dubai.

    • @andymcl92
      @andymcl92 Pƙed 7 lety +161

      "Oh, what way are you going?"
      "Up and left."
      "Rats, I'm heading to the right! I'll just wait for the next one."
      "Sorry, is this where John Smith's office is?"
      "No, this is floor B34. His is on floor D34. Just jump in a lift and it'll take you down to B23, along the link archway to the right tower, and up."

    • @MrMisanthrope_
      @MrMisanthrope_ Pƙed 7 lety +13

      i was thinking a sideway lift would be impractical in use. You give a really good point. but I m afraid that the only point I can think of.

    • @amduser86
      @amduser86 Pƙed 7 lety +72

      well, it actually allows more cabines in one shaft. this means, that you have a fast lane and a slow lane where there eleveator cabines can park. this leads to more space efficient desgin of sky scrapers. furthermore there is natural limit, of how high one can build an elevator due to the weight of the elevator cable itself.

    • @NabsterHax
      @NabsterHax Pƙed 7 lety +8

      +amduser86 If you watched the video you'd know this elevator doesn't use cables.

    • @Halefall
      @Halefall Pƙed 7 lety +66

      NabsterHax I think that's precisely his point

  • @nickbaron8299
    @nickbaron8299 Pƙed 7 lety +96

    Tom Scott: Elevator/Lift review channel

    • @Werdna12345
      @Werdna12345 Pƙed 7 lety +14

      Which explains Mat and Tom's frequent need to sit down at a park bench ;)

    • @fireops
      @fireops Pƙed 7 lety +14

      This lift reminds me a lot of the turbolifts from Star Trek actually.

  • @prva9347
    @prva9347 Pƙed 3 lety +5

    Very interesting, thanks. I've always wondered why "Star Trek: The Original Series" turbolifts, which go sideways as well as up and down, weren't being designed in the 20th century, when some things apparently more difficult have now been developed e.g. hyposprays, tricorders, wearable tech.

  • @julianrobbel4118
    @julianrobbel4118 Pƙed 4 lety +1

    At the trainstation "Berlin Rummelsburg" there is also an elevator, who goes sideways to cross the rails. It goes up, then moves sideways and then on the other side it goes down. It is old, but fancy.

  • @shivaargula4735
    @shivaargula4735 Pƙed 5 lety +17

    A good application of this would be for buildings with a very high volume of people, you could have separate "up" and "down" shafts, with a horizontal connector at every major floor so dozens of elevators can continuously keep running all on the same set of shafts.

    • @GerhardMack
      @GerhardMack Pƙed rokem +2

      This configuration would also save a lot of floor space while still being faster than 8 elevators. You could also have some floors with more access points for elevators such as the ground floor where more people get on/off.

    • @Edward256
      @Edward256 Pƙed rokem +3

      Elevators in parking and multiple lanes so that there is always an elevator available at a moments notice. Just like in movies, or more notably, Star Trek.

  • @hawky225
    @hawky225 Pƙed 5 lety +286

    So basically, a rudimentary 21st century version of Star Trek's turbolifts.

    • @cmhughes8057
      @cmhughes8057 Pƙed 4 lety +5

      I was going to say that but you beat me to it. :)

    • @theexchipmunk
      @theexchipmunk Pƙed 4 lety +5

      yes. it is after all kraut space magic.

    • @danieldaniels7571
      @danieldaniels7571 Pƙed 4 lety +5

      I was thinking more of a Wonkavator

    • @mtenterprise4347
      @mtenterprise4347 Pƙed 3 lety

      Yes but not supersonic

    • @elrey2032
      @elrey2032 Pƙed 3 lety +1

      Looks more like the lifts from the Borg Mothership

  • @Diesel_ep
    @Diesel_ep Pƙed 3 lety

    Love ur vids continue the great work

  • @fabriciotorres6634
    @fabriciotorres6634 Pƙed 9 měsĂ­ci +1

    Now I understand why in really tall buildings elevators go up to half the building and then you have to change đŸ‘đŸ€— thanks, Tom!

  • @francoisotten1276
    @francoisotten1276 Pƙed 7 lety +147

    I wonder what the energy consumption of such an elevator is compared to that of a standard elevator.

    • @fresheFresse
      @fresheFresse Pƙed 7 lety +45

      They will be probably about equal if the energy is recovered when going downwards. the only difference then is the efficiency of the motors.

    • @corbinlegrand
      @corbinlegrand Pƙed 7 lety +30

      I wonder what happens in the event of a power failure. I know they mentioned the emergency brake, but curious if there are any other safety systems in place to avoid the cushion at the bottom.

    • @ThegamingZerii
      @ThegamingZerii Pƙed 7 lety +32

      as far as i know, the elevator should automatically stop in case of a power outage. Also, the energy from cabines going downwards is recovered, so the elevator can sustain itselfe until every cabine is at the bottom

    • @balthasar5302
      @balthasar5302 Pƙed 7 lety +14

      They also have got a battery supply for this case.

    • @acbthr3840
      @acbthr3840 Pƙed 7 lety +34

      there is also induction that occurs from the energy of the elevator falling down the shaft. If all safety systems were to fail, the magnets on the car would actually induce an opposite magnetic field in the track as it fell, slowing the elevator's top speed considerably, and making a buffer at the bottom fairly safe to impact into.

  • @samteinert106
    @samteinert106 Pƙed 6 lety +882

    So it's basically like a giant one of those fancy vending machines that move the ice cream in to the bin...

  • @voidi4725
    @voidi4725 Pƙed 4 lety +2

    Just the sheer complexity in the tiniest part of that elevator convinces me that we already are in the future and take it for granted

  • @bearb1asting
    @bearb1asting Pƙed 4 lety

    Tom, you are an amazing source of knowledge.

  • @cjezinne
    @cjezinne Pƙed 5 lety +78

    Dubai: "We'll order 10..."

  • @jr.jackrabbit10
    @jr.jackrabbit10 Pƙed 6 lety +58

    "I've pressed every button except one."
    Which direction does it make the elevator go, Mr. Willy Wonka?"
    "Up!"
    "........oh"

  • @HD-uf8cl
    @HD-uf8cl Pƙed rokem

    I have been riding on Thyssenkrup elevetors all these years and finally saw their test facility this time.

  • @razordu30
    @razordu30 Pƙed 4 lety +29

    “The system needs to be just as failsafe.” Cues shot of elevator doors opening in middle of elevator shaft.
    (Yes, I know it’s a test shaft.)

    • @Tore_Lund
      @Tore_Lund Pƙed 2 lety

      No just use 2D maglev: no need for tracks, the car just hovering 10cm away from the wall.

  • @storyls
    @storyls Pƙed 5 lety +80

    Cost factor is the main issue from what I can see. A standard elevator is a largely stupid simple design. This one is not.
    It certainly will have customers but those will be quite rare

    • @jojoposter
      @jojoposter Pƙed 5 lety +34

      Well its for large towers only. I think the maximum height for a conventional elevatior is around 100-200m (guessing here). So anything higher then that would need multiple plateaus where you would need to change the elevator to go further.
      linear actuation does not impose such limits. The other stuff is extra candy thrown top because you get that "for free" due to the new drive.
      Im assuming someone thought about how they could give the linear drive more usecases ^^

    • @MetalheadAndNerd
      @MetalheadAndNerd Pƙed 4 lety +18

      Paint it gold and we know in who's tower it will be soon installed.

    • @garageghost6038
      @garageghost6038 Pƙed 4 lety +31

      @@jojoposter on top of that, you could run more than one cab in one shaft, as the cab can just side step at each floor to let people out, while other cabs can pass it.
      This is especially useful for large towers where one cab per shaft can severely slow down the process. So this is indeed best suited for large towers.

    • @haroldbalzac6336
      @haroldbalzac6336 Pƙed 3 lety +5

      @@MetalheadAndNerd imagine bringing politic into this

    • @pineappleroad
      @pineappleroad Pƙed 3 lety +1

      @@garageghost6038 interestingly enough there is a different system (which has been around for longer than this to my knowledge) that they came up with which has 2 cabs in the same shaft which are independent to each other, but it works similar to if there was only one can in the shaft

  • @P0LYBiUS7
    @P0LYBiUS7 Pƙed 4 lety +234

    3:00 - Payload: 630 kg (8 passengers)
    Good luck, America!!

    • @foximacentauri7891
      @foximacentauri7891 Pƙed 4 lety +24

      Oof

    • @karstenschuhmann8334
      @karstenschuhmann8334 Pƙed 4 lety +31

      I traveled in a Portuguese elevator it said 240kg or 6 persons. There were two of us, both about 105kg.

    • @purpleapple4052
      @purpleapple4052 Pƙed 4 lety +36

      @Whuts Uhp you can be malnourished and obese at the same time

    • @poika22
      @poika22 Pƙed 4 lety +65

      @@karstenschuhmann8334 240/6 is 40kg. Where was this elevator? a kindergarten?

  • @lewisfilby2394
    @lewisfilby2394 Pƙed 3 lety

    It is 2021 and this video has been recommended to me once again, and I happily watched and enjoyed again.
    What does the algorithm actually do?
    Maybe next year it will find me something new...

  • @janpenner2002
    @janpenner2002 Pƙed 4 lety +2

    Hey Tom, could you please do an episode about rollercoasters? Those are so technically interesting! From the design of the trains to the design of the track shape to safety systems, lifts or launch systems. Actually, some rollercoasters use those exact Linear Synchronous Motors (LSM) or Linear Induction Motors (LIM) or hydraulic or pneumatic launch systems to launch rollercoasters, a little like the fighter jets are launched from Aircraft carriers.

    • @alaeriia01
      @alaeriia01 Pƙed 8 měsĂ­ci

      He's scared of them.
      Well, he _was_ scared of them.

  • @ginsengjin
    @ginsengjin Pƙed 4 lety +15

    The repairs on that would be astronomical for a building owner.

    • @ctakitimu
      @ctakitimu Pƙed rokem

      Maybe it's modular so you can swap out failed parts?

  • @jsd4574
    @jsd4574 Pƙed 7 lety +106

    Is that not a horizontallator? A latteralator?

  • @tissuepaper9962
    @tissuepaper9962 Pƙed 4 lety +8

    "admin, he's doing it sideways"

    • @gezuppi
      @gezuppi Pƙed 4 lety

      phoon but an elevator

  • @kylebrake1806
    @kylebrake1806 Pƙed 2 lety

    I love your videos!

  • @001thefish
    @001thefish Pƙed 7 lety +40

    This is my favourite elevator channel.

  • @markheaney
    @markheaney Pƙed 5 lety +7

    The buffers are not intended to stop a free falling elevator cab. The buffers are there in case the elevator control system malfunctions and the car travels at contract speed (normal speed) past the terminal floor (top floor or bottom floor). The safeties are on all cabled elevators to prevent the free falling of the cab. Every modern elevator also has both a normal backup system to prevent the elevator from traveling past the terminal floors along with an emergency system as a sort of backup of the backup. Also, the newest elevator machines have two independent braking systems to hold the car at a given floor. Elevators are very safe.

    • @k9foru2
      @k9foru2 Pƙed 7 měsĂ­ci

      At least in the USA they are designed to reduce a fatal fall into horribly injured, Elevators in the US are required to be inspected and tested and a regular test is loading it to max weight and driving it at max speed into the end stop at the bottom of the pit.

  • @PunmasterSTP
    @PunmasterSTP Pƙed 3 lety

    This video elevated my expectations of what those things can do!

  • @heroj6322
    @heroj6322 Pƙed 9 měsĂ­ci +1

    Fun fact: Linear Induction Motors are can also be found on some rollercoasters to launch the train

  • @donatj
    @donatj Pƙed 7 lety +58

    You should do a video on the elevators in the St. Louis Arch. They rotate as they go up. Really interesting mid century technology.

    • @QuasiELVIS
      @QuasiELVIS Pƙed 4 lety

      Sounds kind of sickening.

    • @AaronOfMpls
      @AaronOfMpls Pƙed 2 lety +3

      Yah, they're swivel-mounted so they stay level no matter what angle the track is at, from near-vertical at the bottom to near-horizontal at the top.

  • @DrToonhattan
    @DrToonhattan Pƙed 7 lety +24

    It's a Turbolift! Can't believe you didn't do that reference.

  • @jonistan9268
    @jonistan9268 Pƙed 3 lety +2

    Also seems convenient because you can have more than one cabin per shaft. But I'd suggest putting floor selection outside of the elevator if you do that so the cabins can be organised in a way to let you through before the ride otherwise cabins might get in the way. I'm also guessing this uses way more energy than a conventional elevator. It's moving a cabin up alone vs moving a cabin up and a weight attached to it down i.e. just speed changes and overcoming friction plus a bit of lifting maybe.

  • @Kalvinjj
    @Kalvinjj Pƙed 3 lety

    Interesting how it uses a heck lot of the concept of maglev trains, and inherits both their advantages and shortcomings in quite the same way.
    Regarding safety, requiring power to keep mechanical locks released is quite simple and well understood, definitely not worried about that.

  • @Fs3i
    @Fs3i Pƙed 7 lety +342

    The German accents! Ahhh! (Greetings from their region, I actually saw the tower multiple times)

    • @niklaspilot
      @niklaspilot Pƙed 7 lety +26

      Fly Ju mien se tschermen ekzents?! :D
      (Nur Spaß, komme aus Hamburg ;) )

    • @abeedhal6519
      @abeedhal6519 Pƙed 7 lety +3

      Why the self hate Fly?

    • @yetanothertubeuser
      @yetanothertubeuser Pƙed 7 lety +33

      Everyone hates their own accent.

    • @Theorimlig
      @Theorimlig Pƙed 7 lety +55

      Many non-native english speakers dislike hearing other people from their country speak english with anything less than perfect fluency and pronunciation. It's a thing.

    • @ProudToBeNoob
      @ProudToBeNoob Pƙed 7 lety +60

      Fly Honestly, in the world of engineering the German accent is the most trustworthy and reliable sounding one you can have.

  • @marvinletsche1253
    @marvinletsche1253 Pƙed 4 lety +163

    The tower is like 25 kilometer away from me i now have to go there

  • @leonardochapman4736
    @leonardochapman4736 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    Nice! I never knew you came to my hometown! (Sheffield) and on my birthday month!

  • @linden6352
    @linden6352 Pƙed 4 lety +1

    This is perfect because say you're on floor 39 going up and there is an elevator full of people going from 0 to 54, the elevator full of people can just go on by while one pulls in to pick up the guy on 39. This reduces stops.

    • @patricktho6546
      @patricktho6546 Pƙed 4 lety +1

      And allowes for more transport on less footprint. Therefore worth it for high buildings

  • @jmpattillo
    @jmpattillo Pƙed 7 lety +4

    If you are ever in St. Louis, Missouri be sure to have a look at the elevator/train that goes to the top of the Gateway Arch. It has a very unusual design.

  • @KyleLi
    @KyleLi Pƙed 7 lety +134

    I'm planning on making a chocolate factory that I'm eventually going to pass on to a new owner by inviting them with special unique tickets and I'm looking for an elevator just like this!
    I'll take 12.

    • @Klyskada
      @Klyskada Pƙed 6 lety +1

      Kyle Li 12 elevator shafts or 12 of the elevator itself?

    • @stanpatterson5033
      @stanpatterson5033 Pƙed 6 lety +8

      If he means Ooompa-Loompas, I'll volunteer. I'm 6'3", but I can hunch down if necessary.

    • @serraramayfield9230
      @serraramayfield9230 Pƙed 6 lety

      Nice reference :)

    • @velocibadgery
      @velocibadgery Pƙed 5 lety

      @@Klyskada yes

  • @georgieippolito9924
    @georgieippolito9924 Pƙed 4 lety

    mrmattandmrchay would love this! only if its machanical of course. my personal favorite is the old otis lifts because of the cool motor room it has

  • @-sturmfalke-
    @-sturmfalke- Pƙed 3 lety

    The good thing about this elevator shown in the video is that you don't need one elevator shaft for each one, because there can be more than one in each shaft. Cool!

  • @kylenetherwood8734
    @kylenetherwood8734 Pƙed 7 lety +74

    It should be called a shift lift.

  • @michaelantista3284
    @michaelantista3284 Pƙed 5 lety +38

    This is how the "turbo-lifts" in Star Trek will eventually work!

  • @WANTED91x
    @WANTED91x Pƙed 4 lety +3

    There is an "sideways-going elevator" in 73776 Altbach in Germany, it's called Schmid-Peoplemover 🙂

  • @baileygoodsell3012
    @baileygoodsell3012 Pƙed 3 lety +13

    The “EL” in elevator means to elevate or go up. So If an elevator moves sideways it shouldn’t be able to be called an elevator. Would it be a horevator?

    • @R3lay0
      @R3lay0 Pƙed 3 lety +5

      So a vertical transport cabin is only a elevator half the time. The other half it's a descentor.

    • @baileygoodsell3012
      @baileygoodsell3012 Pƙed 3 lety +1

      Big Brain time

  • @nenagarcia2912
    @nenagarcia2912 Pƙed 5 lety +3

    omg tom scott..i subscribed to you today, and in less than an hour, you've made me feel so much better about my fear of elevators. thank you, im honestly really glad.
    it's cool to look forward to a future with safer elevators. what's funny, is, my fear of elevators drives me to have dreams of different elevators and i've seen some like this in my dreams.

  • @user-yg2up4lg3r
    @user-yg2up4lg3r Pƙed 4 lety +13

    1950's: We're going to have flying cars in the 2000's!
    2000's: Here's a an elevator that goes sideways.

  • @v12tommy
    @v12tommy Pƙed 4 lety +2

    I'd be curious about the power consumption compared to a cable too, since the cable has a counterweight, so it isn't actually lifting the weight of the elevator, just the people inside it.

    • @sebastianlabusch465
      @sebastianlabusch465 Pƙed 3 lety

      It will surely consume more power to go up, but if the design is smart, it can feed power into the grid while going down.

  • @JL-pc2eh
    @JL-pc2eh Pƙed 3 lety +1

    I was at this tower before and used such an elevator. It was incredible fast and you didn't even feel it moving.

  • @alphaadhito
    @alphaadhito Pƙed 7 lety +18

    Krupp is also making elevator? Wow, if i ever see that. _Ze legendary Krupp Stahl_

    • @ArgoIo
      @ArgoIo Pƙed 7 lety +18

      Yeah, pretty much any elevator I have ever used here in Germany was made and serviced by Thyssenkrupp.

    • @scharliescheen3109
      @scharliescheen3109 Pƙed 7 lety +1

      Lorenz Zahn i live in germany to, most common in my region is 'Dralle AufzĂŒge'

    • @thriceandonce
      @thriceandonce Pƙed 7 lety

      Scharlie Scheen A regional thing, perhaps? I think they have more elevators in the West of Germany (geographic West, not historical) than elsewhere.

  • @danh5637
    @danh5637 Pƙed 4 lety +40

    Her laugh at 1700 steps. That famous German sense of humour!

  • @davidmelenhorst3300
    @davidmelenhorst3300 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    you should check out the elavator in the new townhall in hannover, germany. It goes in a curve, very epic

  • @joefreemanwilliams3570
    @joefreemanwilliams3570 Pƙed 4 lety +1

    As a bonus, you can use the LIMs to launch them super fast for a surprise roller coaster ride đŸ‘đŸ»

  • @shotgunboy10
    @shotgunboy10 Pƙed 7 lety +11

    "computer, deck 12"
    *turbolift noises*

  • @InspektorDreyfus
    @InspektorDreyfus Pƙed 5 lety +162

    0:33 What a voice! 😼 This should be Siri or Alexa or the Starship Enterprise Computer.

    • @littleone103
      @littleone103 Pƙed 5 lety +19

      Sirexa.

    • @lolmassimo
      @lolmassimo Pƙed 4 lety +12

      Every Germans women voice but they can't get rid of that weird accent so it's wasted..

    • @lolmassimo
      @lolmassimo Pƙed 4 lety +11

      "One sousand" "Forst it waas werry"

    • @4O4Hime
      @4O4Hime Pƙed 3 lety +29

      @@lolmassimo Let me hear you speak another language percectly fluently like a native speaker.

    • @mrjack08722
      @mrjack08722 Pƙed 3 lety +5

      @@4O4Hime Alot of people cant speak another language like a native speaker. Its not uncommon.

  • @jimfilms6688
    @jimfilms6688 Pƙed 4 lety +5

    “Linear induction motors are also *synchronous*
    *rollercoaster brain activated

  • @davidjames579
    @davidjames579 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    Tom, you're going up in the world.