Indian Election Results: Regional and International Implications
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 09. 2024
- » Let’s discuss the recent Indian election results and explore their far-reaching impacts on both regional and international landscapes. This session will dissect the political shifts within India, analyze the ripple effects across South Asia, and evaluate the global reactions. Join us for to connects the dots between electoral outcomes and geopolitical dynamics, offering insights from experts on what the future holds for India’s domestic and foreign policies.
● Discussants:
» Umar Cheema
Investigative Journalist
» Tahir Mehdi
Election Expert
» Bilal Gillani
Election Expert
» Dr. Qamar Abbas
Executive Director, Sanober Institute, Islamabad
Professor (International Relations)
● Moderator:
» Ahmad Ijaz
Writer, Election Expert
First decent objective discussion of Indian elections in Pakistan. And also frank acknowledgement that there is not enough empirical knowledge of Indian polity within Pakistan. I am sure the reverse is true too in India.
Indian think tanks and strategic experts study Pakistan with an open mind. Studying Pakistan with a biased mind will be detrimental to the security of the Indian State.
All election experts gather to discuss India while the Pakistan government bans the largest political party in the country. The timing of this premiere can not be more ironic lol
Tujhe Kaya be tu our gourav arya dono ko nawaj ko gali dena hai
Muslims discussing hindutva. What an irony. Far from reality 😂
Banna ruplbilc speaking India's domcricy 😂
BJP has gained Orissa Arunachal Pradesh
And gained significant voting percentage in Southern States of Tamilnadu, Kerala , Telangana,
Tamil nadu 000000😂😂
What about Manipur
@@mohakroy821 Zero seats but 11% vote share in TN.......In Kerala, The BJP vote share grew from 13% to 16.68% ANd they got 1 seat........Please have patience
and lost UP the largest province jaha se main hu 😂😂😂😂
I request TEAM BLACK HOLE to have a session regarding the condition of Pakistani Hindus....
Half knowledge is dangerous thing. Unfortunately no one in Pakistan knows and understand India.
Lol...they are banning their largest party PTI😂😂😂😂😂
If BJP loose some seats because of politicians like #Kejariwal aur #Soren were in jail. they why Congress alliance got Zero in #Delhi aur gain nothing much in #Jharkhand.. Grow-up uncle use facts not Fake Narrative.. 🤣🤣😅😅🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
Jokers of a failed democracy discussing indian election 👏👏
Pakistanis discussing BJPs decline 🤣
😂😂😂😂
Pakistan Army Chief is Pakistan Election Commisioner...😅Pakistani people are happy with this 😅
Now I know why pakistan like congress to win indian election, Rahul should become pm of pakistan 🤣🤣
*These People should Carefully Discuss What happening in Pakistan rightnow. PTI Banned and Imran Re Arrested is a sign of Lawlessness in Pakistan*
It is understandable that when Pakistanis (Muslims) discuss Indian polls, they do it through Muslim prism, but Indian elections are not just about muslims. There are several factors at play that may make the Indian scenario too complex for Pakistanis to understand. The important takeaway of the elections for the Pakistani audience is that the Indian National Congress President, Mr Kharge and other opposition leaders were present at the oath-taking ceremony to congratulate the NDA leadership!
Why dont u guys discuss ur own country's recent sham election....
PAKISTAN TVs never ever dare to discuss Pakistani Democracy with reference to the so-called Establishmnet Army's involvement. Rather, they love to discuss or learn Indian democracy 😅 Very Funny..😅Please make a video on Pak Army's Hand in Pak Election and democracy destruction.😅 We love to ❤ watch 😅❤😅
How to manipulate elections with ballot paper, we have seen in the recently concluded elections in Pakistan.
India is deeply concerned about the deterioration of American democracy.
We urge the Biden administration to uphold the highest standards of democracy.
The USA should practice what it preaches to other countries.
Don't just see the percentages but see the number of seats they are contesting. BJP contests in way more seats than Congress or any other party. Congress usually has alliances with regional parties where it doesn't has presence like in Tamil Nadu and so. BJP on other hand establishes its offices, campaign and contest for seats in every corner of the country.
Because they have adani money
24/7 Pakistan people talking on india
Can someone explain the steps and policies of the BJP government that are influenced by Hindutva or are discriminatory based on religion? India has a secular constitution, and no government can deviate from it.
Before watching I can say BJP bashing karke apnay aap ko Khush karengay 😅
😂
Clarification on 12:00 for sc/st parliament constituency are reserved. Votes are cast by all. They don't have separate electorate.
😂keep making program on india while your Pakistan going down every day
Pakistan AKA Indian Muslim majority state separated based on the 1946 election. Now there are 250 million Muslim AKA as a 5th front for Pakistan votes only to defeat BJP even after equally benefiting from all the BJP government schemes without any negative discrimination for being a Muslim. Pakistan is an euphemism for Indian Muslims who are loyal to the ideology of Pakistan that Muslim cannot be ruled by the Hindus. To defeat consolidated Indian Muslim votes against the BJP, it needs to be consolidating Hindu voters fragmented based on caste and regions by using the Pakistan factor. Pakistan election minority have zero influence.
Wire 😂 low lvl converted muslim channel
One thing I would disagree with Umar Cheema is that: Yes Poverty is prevalent in India but millions of Indians did came out of poverty in recent years. Also he is saying that govt schemes are ideas of political parties. No. India has always been a socialist country. Even if India gets more middle class,it will remain as Socialist country. Something are related to your culture and India is a partly collectivist society. You can't alienate socialism from Indian society.
Others have merged in the India alliance..what would you expect..the only shocker for BJP was UP
Indi alliance
The biggest take away for you Pakistanis from the recently concluded Indian elections is, unlike your country, our army or for a matter of fact any Institution does not influence this process. In your country, if one has to bluntly put it, though you have a so called election, the government is selected by the army ignoring the voice of the people. The last election in your country is a case in point.
pakistanis please remember that there are approx one lakh masjids in whole of India.
other than the BJP hatred and suppression of muslins point in India no other new thing, 15 years ruled by single man that mean people love him,
is he qamar cheema or qamar abbas?
From India, I can say democracy wise, there is no comparison between India and Pakistan .
In India , democracy is deep rooted which is not at all the case for Pakistan.
In Pakistan, Pakistan Army is running the country ,not any elected government.
@23:15 - Jammu and Kashmir India ka bohot important part hai. Thanks a lot Sir for accepting 🙏🙏❣❣
24% Minority the Pakistan me aaj kitne % Minority bache hai Pakistanis me itna bta do pakiyo
I really love the experts who have nothing to offer except some generalisations and stereotypes. What else can we expect from these empty brains !!!
At the end of the day no political party or its candidate had disputed the Indian election results or complained of Dhandli. The winner rejoiced while loser was gracious in defeat but generous in congratulating the winner!! No hard feelings but business as usual......in the parliament again. That's the beauty of Indian democracy!! IEC Zindabaad!!
Voters anger work in election process not in selection process. 😂
Woh kya jane BHARAT ko.
Jo sirf jane BHARAT ko.🙏🧘
I'm Hindu Dalits & Bjp supporter, kaafi aacha discussion hua sunkar accha laga ki pakistan mai bhi intellectual thinker hai.
You are wrong about media. You are only focused on Hindi media or English media but Indian states has own official state languages. Most people watch news in their own languages . How BJP gonna control regional media? Newspapers are also in regional languages.
many people in pakistan say there was never a true election after 1970 in pakistan, but still there are experts on subject ?
Pakistan should first see the situation of their minorities 2% only .
There are untouchables in pakistan. They are called Kammi-Kameen. Can someone throw some light on their predicament please?
Country with sham election doesn't know what is democracy.. proud of India conducted the election..
I'm moderate by nature.. but when comes to Pakistan .. India need a harder line policy .
Abe apne country ka analysis bhi to karo voting ,counting or govt making
Seems like elections and Democracy are not a very popular or well understood concept in Paxstan. Look at the attendance and even those who were there were half asleep. I think political and military conditions have left them totally disinterested/disheartened in such a concept over time.
1:45:26 kasmiri is right Pakistan need to care itself 😊
why BJP lost so many seats:
1. Modi lost a lot of political capital by pushing much-needed but unpopular policies like Agri Reforms, Agniveer, GST, Labor reform (ask any unbiased experts, these policies are so much needed for Indian economy, people been talking about it for decades but no one dared to push it, Modi did and lost a lot of political capital)
2. Arrogance and complacency from BJP party and voters
3. Sidelined RSS machinery by BJP
4. 10 years of anti-incumbency
5. BJP's washing machine policies in which politicians from other parties were coerced to join BJP
6. Opposition's improved planning and outreach
7. Foreign media interference and negative propaganda against Modi
8. Electoral bond issue
9. Negative sentiments due to opposition suppression like the freezing of congress account and Kejriwal's arrest
10. Consolidation of anti Modi votes..........
Why is the hall so empty tho
The "Islamic" republic of Pakistan is taking about "Mazhabi aazadi" in India, irony of the irony itself. Look at your elections, look at your largest political party which you banned & look at your "fauji" democracy. India's democracy is working very well with free an fair elections. And yes, no one is persecuted in India. Live in your own lala land.
Really impressed by the thoroughly researched presentation.
😂😂😂 Pakistan 😅
India ke hindu sirf muslim ke khelf bolna ka liya he hindu h culture bo liberals wala he follow karta h ajjkal 😂
India has already irradiated multidimensional poverty!! And no one dies of hunger as government still provides free rations ever since Covid!!
Black hole mai yeh discussion hona chahiye ki Pakistan mai election kyu hote hai ?
Don't worry BJP will rise again
A indian i proud of my leader Ambedker and Jawaharlal Neharu ❤
This is one of best platforms from pakistan
I am a Hindu and supporter of BJP. But appreciate your honest opinion and intentions. Dr pervez hoodhbhoy is a true hero. Salute.
Excellent,balanced and very objective analysis by the experts on vibrant Indian General Elections.General Elections of India has proved all critics outside India particularly in the Western democracies wrong.India is very diverse not only geographically but also culturally as well.Inspite of all differences there is something which is for stronger,deeper & sentimental which unite it as a Nation and a strong country🤔🤗🌹💐
What a joke! Islamist are discussing state of democracy!!!😂
India has been manipulating the mass through bollywood since the inception of Tv. During congress era in late 80's Ramayana tv serial was introduced to panper the agitatied mass going through financial depression. Again in Congress era 2003-04,I think a movie was made on Gujrat riot from Parsi perspective. This is not a unique phenomenon.
Nice study
A failed democracy with layering of artificial religion is talking about India .....irony with joke😂😂....
Good discussion.
Absolutely great discussion. Impartial and well researched . Few key observations.
1. Muslims are NOT persecuted in India. A robust civil society activists ensures it.
2. In welfare schemes like free toilets, housing, gas, water connection, loans BJP went out of the way to make sure Muslims benefits. Muslims themselves openly agree that they took max advantage. But still even 1% didn't' vote for the BJP. This will have a negative reaction in the coming days. There's already a statement "jo hamare saath hum uske saath".
3. Another start reality is a famous truth about Indian voting behaviour. "Indians don't cast their votes, they vote for the caste". In UP the failed caste arithmetic went against BJP.
4. Ayodhya loss:- Ayodhya is a city in Faizabad district. This is not a reserved seat. The SP took risk of giving ticket to SC candidate which turned the tables in BJP.
5. Thinking Pakistani must revisit their opinion of Modi, BJP , RSS and hindutwa. You guys are fed leftist propoganda of left dominated Indian and western press.
6. The most influential opinion maker Prof Dr Parvez Hoidbhai only invites hard-core Marxist to his Black Hole discussion. Never a RW or independent analyst from India.
6. Pakistan Experience Shehzad Shaikh too follows and invites left liberals.
Both these ideologies are politically irrelevant and since our Pakistani brothers and sisters believe it as a gospel truth.
Unless your intellectuals engage BJP, RSS, RW and independent thinkers you will continue to get biased inputs and reach wrong conclusions.
The F___ Jilani has understood what are SC and ST seats. Only the candidates in these have to be SC or ST. The voters are all the voters of that constituency regardless of their caste.
Good discussion
antonyms of pakistan : democracy , freedom , education
Sir, an Election expert is called a Psephologist.
guys bjp does not represent Hindus, they worked for corporate lobbies, most of voters don't vote based on religion here, the policies of BJP are not good overall for people growth and hence it's a message was sent to look at their policies such as tax, PSU, job creation, crime rate, crushing of opposition using ED, not focusing on Manipur issues, dividing society based on religion and caste etc..
Is the audio spotty?
There are numerous issues in your own country..Try to concentrate on that..
Whatever the Regional parties were there in this elections , their success can be attributed to their strong presence local state and local self government, they were premised more funds frome center and fighting their cause in loksabha . Bjp Government didn't pay adequate attention to their economic needs .
You are 100% right sir.
If u r a pakistani no matter u talk in English or urdu… Zahil hamesha zahil hi rahenge…
Congratulations to all makers
Pakistan me army jung haarne ke alawa sb kaam krte hain 😂
A good discussion overall where there is acknowledgement that Pakistan needs to see and analyse India from a different prism. Some points to ponder over here:
1. This election was a true reflection of what the Indian population thinks. The election machinery here is robust despite all the allegations of foul play.
2. As one of the observers rightly said, Muslims are not a homogenous entity in India and therefore to have the notion that they are all oppressed is absolutely not correct. Otherwise, there wouldn't be so many Muslims in India's public life.
3. In Pakistan, there is scant regard for India's concern for cross border terrorism. Even now, there are repeated attacks in the Jammu with a clear Pakistan imprint. Kargil war happened after Vajpayee went to Lahore, Mumbai 26/11 happened when we were talking peace. Uri and Pathankot followed. The onus is on you to establish the faith. Any other government in India is also unlikely to change the current policy regarding Pakistan.
why these people discussing indian election don't they realise that thair own country has failed to do any election fairly
Wow Pakistani democratic electoral experts are giving lectures to India 🇮🇳.. sitting in the Banana republic... lol😂
Very nice and thoughtful discussion 👏
तू मेरी खुजा मैं तेरी ।
Sindh hamara hai leke rahenge
kya be?😂😂😂
You people are living in 21st century, but can't think beyond religion 👎👎👎👎👎
Cheema Indian election is the show, but he talk another way.
Pakistanis would like Modi to go down and congress to gain since they think it is in their interest
It's a good initiative to educate the Pakistani citizenry on what's goin on in neighboring country particularly with respect to governance, democracy, election , in short a the way life going on .
1. Bada mulk , badi democracy,
. What were expectations
. What were results
. What Pakistani can learn from Government formation
Speaker 1 : border closed , discussion end about india
Social message through election .
Unique election, huge electorate 5.5m. EvMs , over 100 cr. Voters
New voters 18 million. Elections over 7 phases, over one month , changes in election process according to need , dynamic .polling booth process is automated, no internet in evm , 543 seats 412 general, 81 seats for sc/st . 28 states 8 UT , big states turnout 67% male female equal , Pakistani 10% difference . Alliances etc.
To be honest, this was really great discussion.....and in my opinion reason was that guests didnt give any predtrmined, biased answers about topics they dont know....and i really appreciate that .........its impossible to know india, its vast country.............vey diverse....... even BJP didnt understood it, thats why they lost.......they were looking at India from their typical North Indian hindi point of view.... they lost regional toch.
Wow .. the intellectuals of pakistan need to learn more about democracy still u will not know how diversity of india works wonderfully and under one supreme book ..that is indian constituency
We dont follow any other supreme book specially asmani kitab
Pakistanis lecturing others on democracy, free and fair election 😂😂😂
Pakistan wants Rahul and not Modi
Pakistani elites and Muslims are worried about Indian Muslims despite seeing them inferior.
Religion ke naam pe desh banaya aur chalaya aur failed but still same attitude.
One may not agree with the views but atleast they don't show hatred for Hindus. A rare thing from pakistan
Discuss your own situation first😂
Southern Indian states are economically more prosperous, and the populations therein are better educated on average. However, Hinduism is a North Indian faith. Hindu scriptures are penned in Sanskrit, a language from which most North Indian languages originated. Superficially, many customs and conventions of South Indians appear similar, but I don't think that they are related to Hinduism. Tamil is an extremely old language through which the South Indian cultures found expression in both theological and societal domains. In fact, in Tamil Nadu, people are quite antagonistic to Hinduism and its ritualistic fervor derived from the Vedas.
Hehe
This analysis either hid or failed to recognize that BJP's vote share in urban areas grew by 6.4%. In Rajasthan, Congress's vote share remained the same as 2019. Congress won 11 seats because of internal rift and battles with BJP in Rajasthan. In UP, Yogi was kept in the dark when deciding for ticket distribution, and Dalits were influenced by Congress's fake propaganda that BJP will amend the constitution, which is ironic because Congress's 2024 poll manifesto states, "2. The Congress guarantees that it will pass a constitutional amendment to raise the 50 per cent cap on reservations for SC, ST and OBC."
Bhai network connection to acha laga le
Result system fails every time in Pak after elections, that's how Gen Faiz brought Imran Khan in '18 , which Munir countered in '24 in favor of Sharifs