Pentatonix - God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen - Reaction - Cool version!
Vložit
- čas přidán 2. 07. 2024
- This one was a bit of a revamp of the original! The tempo was a bit more upbeat compared to the original version, it seemed to me. I really liked this one!
When I was in high school. I was in Acapella choir. I had a Halloween party with some of my fellow singer friends. We trick or treated that night, and one lady seeing teenagers said, you need to work for your treat. So we sang her a Christmas Carol that we had been rehearsing for our Christmas Concert. She was super pleased at hearing us and gave us high praises (and chocolates). You talking about carolers knocking on your door and singing triggered that wonderful memory.
Just as there’s room in rock for a variety of bands & sounds, the same is true in a capella. Home Free is a more country flavor while Pentatonix is more pop. They are both amazing and add so much to the growth and popularity of a capella music. There is room for all these amazing groups and their differences just give us more to enjoy! Thanks for reacting to them both.
Voice Play is the Drama Dept & Voctave is the Choir! 🤗
@@shilohauraable great addition! So true!
PTX and Homefree's beatboxing is a bit different because Kevin from PTX didn't learn traditionally through music teachers, so there are techniques he may not use but because of his music background as an instrumentalist he has a great sense of rhythm and creativity when creating sounds. The inhales allow him to keep going constantly for minutes which I always find amazing.
Nobody learns Beatboxing “traditionally through teachers”. It hasn’t even been around long enough for there to be much of a “tradition”. Kevin probably has more formal music training than any beatboxer ever since he’s a classically trained saxophonist and cellist. All of the beatboxers for the most popular Acapella groups like HomeFree & Voiceplay are very good, but Kevin is on a different level. He’s considered by people from the beatboxing world (outside of acapella) to be one of the best ever.
@@joel2421 I get what your saying but the beatboxer from homefree spent 19 years developing his craft as an adult studying music, while Kevin also focused on other studies (pre-med) in less time. But yeah both are amazing. I believe the homefree beatboxer won awards for it.
@@FayolaOnline The Homefree beatboxer did not win any awards, people keep saying that and I keep asking them for verification and they never have any. Kevin is classically trained on two completely different instruments that aren’t even in the same family. Maybe you don’t understand how rare that is, but it’s insane. Adam Rupp is a multi-instrumentalist with a Bachelors Degree in music, and formal training on the trumpet but although he is very talented he’s not in Kevin’s class as a musician. He’s not in Kevin’s class as a beatboxer either. I’ve been listening to Hip Hop since day one and have heard all of the great beatboxers live. Dougie Fresh, Rahzell, Buffy from the Fat Boys, I’ve seen them all. I have also watched many of the Beatbox World Championships, although doing two minute routines is very different from being a vocal percussionist supporting a group. Kevin can create and hold a groove like all of the greats I named. The next time any of these other vocal percussionists supporting acapella groups do that will be their first time. Nota is the only one of the new groups I’ve seen that can groove like PTX, but they don’t really have one dedicated beatboxer. Take 6 could groove their asses off but they also never had a dedicated vocal percussionist. Adam Rupp is one of the best beatboxers in the world who support a vocal group, but he’s not on Kevin’s tier.
@@joel2421 I know Kevin is on another level with his musicality. He's a beast. I'm not sure where I heard about the homefree guy winning an award, I'm not really a homefry fan but maybe I got it from their fanbase.
Add to the fact that Kevin is the only chelloboxing musician in the world. He's the human 808. Look it up and his name shows up. Home free and Voctave are outstanding, but Pentatonix is one whole other level. They brought Acapella into the mainstream and revolutionized Acapella.
It's not Christmas but listen to their official video of their original Coffee in Bed or their mashup up of New Rules x Are You That Somebody then comment on Kevin's beatboxing. 😊Just two examples of his magical unicorn status. Every song doesn't require crazy beatboxing. I appreciate PTX because they are always happy to individually take a step back to let the group shine. Appreaciate your sincere and honest reactions.
Loved ur reaction & ur PTX (and Home Free) journey! You really owe it to yourself to watch the official video of this one, even if you don’t react to it, it’s edited so well and captures the whimsical fast pace arrangement. Merry Christmas 🎄
Definitely, again, I wish he had done the official video on this one. Still a great reaction!
This version is one of my very favorites. The vocal gymnastics 🤯. Merry Christmas and thank you for your thoughtful reactions.
Thank you so much! PTX is so unique. Your joy is contagious. What a wonderful way to end a very long week. You made it all worth it!!! Please keep spreading your love. It means so much to so many! Blessings and hugs! Patti
Been waiting for this. One of my favorites. While their live performances are always outstanding, on this particular song I prefer the official video because the focused camera work highlights each members contribution and solo parts better. Talk show camera coverage just doesn’t cut it, ever.
I just had the pleasure of seeing them live last night. They are the real deal! I love your reactions. You are delightful.
Thanks Alyn! I'm so jealous!! I hope you had a GREAT time!
Great song. Nice reaction.
Side note: on the side,when you have a moment, you NEED to see the original video from this. It will blow your mind. Things that could never be done in a live version. It also looks like a Grammy winner. Just check it out. You'll be glad you did! ☺️
Maybe they still had a lot to do before Christmas, so they decided to speed-sing through this one. That's a feeling I can very much relate to, particularly now, after having been home sick for a couple of weeks...lol
Jokes aside, this was yet another beautiful arrangement and a feast to the ears.
As I've heard a few songs from both PTX and Home Free, I think I start to pick up a few differences in their style, allthough vocally they are very much on the same level, but not necessariky alike. If I close my eyes and picture the two groups, the picture I get from PTX is a somewhat lively, flashy, colorful one. When I picture Home Free I get a bit more down to earth, almost astute, the-guy-down-the-road feeling. Somewhat like I picture Hollywood vs Texas...lol I dunno. Anywho, I'm always loving your reactions, Chris. They make my day(s) :-)
Enjoy the weekend and stay safe!
Just as amazing live!! Enjoying your PTX reactions🤗
It is very PTX to start off in a traditional way, then really mix it up. 🎄
I see you commented on you feel so far that home frees beat boxer is the best WELL look at their original song "love again" kevins beat boxing is incredible si if that does not convince you then look at Kevins version of "Down" he plays all the instruments and does insane beat boxing
I think the audio was better on the Kimmel one.
As to beat boxing in PTX songs, I am not sure what you have heard so far, but the beat boxing on songs like "Hallelujah" "Amazing Grace" and a few others do not showcase that particular talent.
There are many where his talents shine.
Merry Christmas.
In my opinion there is also a great rendition from Geoff Castellucci of this song. He is the bass singer of a acapella group called Voiceplay, which I highly recommend. Although his solo work is not completely acapella. (link: czcams.com/video/l8Sxh5E2u_g/video.html ). Voiceplay is the most theatrical of these three acapella groups. Like their version of "You're a mean one Mr. Grinch" (link: czcams.com/video/8fbJ03HhgIU/video.html ).
When you are ready to a non Christmas song by Home Free, listen to Man Of Constant Sorrow. It really showcases the beatboxing and their individual talents.
To start, NO ONE beats Kevin in percussion and sound effects! Kevin is genius! To continue, Home Free has a country feel; PTX does music that utilizes classical, jazz, and r and b!
Love your reaction!! waiting for more Pentatonix reactions :D
I like the official video better. You will feel Avi's part.
We just saw them in concert Thursday…Sooooooo good!! Of course… They did this one I think, The Prayer, one Scott co-wrote and played on piano with Kevin on cello I think titled Thank You.. soooo good!
Thank You is one of the best songs ever! Scott and his boyfriend wrote it together last year reflecting on how the other helped get them theough2020. So much love and emotions! Amazing!
Now you need to listen to another a cappella group called Voiceplay, they are the third leg of the Trifecta of the best in a cappella. They are considered the theatre kids of a cappella, they did a cover of The Oogie Boogie song from the movie, The Nightmare Before Christmas. It's really fun to listen to, they aren't always in theatre mode and have other songs that are awesome like, Wayward Son, Man in the Mirror and many others. Give them a try. Most people like all three groups that subscribe to reactors, I very rarely compare them as they are all different in how they approach their music. It's just ear candy, eargasms and amazing music.
Hey Teri! Yes, several have asked to include Voiceplay, so I will definitely dive in soon!
@@larryshair I would suggest starting with Voice Play's Hoist The Colors or their WICKED medley. Two of their most recent amazing videos. Then pass thru the rest! VP has had the most member changes of the a capella groups, but the bass (Geoff), beat boxer (Lane) & Eli (does amazing everything) have been steady members. And they often have other amazing artists join them in their madness! 💖
Can't wait to see your reaction to their Bohemian Rhapsody cover.
Home Free's beat boxer might be good, but can he beatbox while playing the cello and chewing gum at the same time?
You are aware that Avi always backed up Kevin in the beatboxing? Particularly any "wind sounds" for example and backed him up on the kick or high hat when Kevin needed to take a breath?
Hello Larry. You commented on the faster pace at the very beginning and I thought "Yes .......and wait for it......it gets very fast". Oooo would I love PTX at my front door singing Christmas Carols, what a happy thought. PTX is very creative on all their videos and arrangements. This is a great arrangement. You should also react to the official music video of this for the videography as well. The sounds they make are just fascinating in addition to the vocal mastery. So much more for you to react to. I sent quite a few recommendations in previous comments.
Thanks Meg! Yes! I kept your list for future reference :)
This is heard in the 2018 Grinch movie
Think you’ll be looking for a while, Chris! Great artistry, - very enjoyable reaction - again 🎄
You should listen to Mary did you know. Both Home Free and Pentatonix have done their version of that song and it shows the differens between the groups
Yes! I did the reaction and it should go live on 12/23! Stay tuned :)
If you’re going to react to a group you should probably do the studio version as it is the way it was intended to be heard. They do sound good live most of the time but it’s still not the same. Especially if your going to compare them to another group. PTX has superior range and technical skills imo but to each their own. Merry Christmas.
Don't forget the "official version."
Not a fan of the comparisons between PTX and other acapella groups. They have different styles and strengths. Otherwise, good reaction.
Ear candy always. Please watch their video on the side if you can too. It's clever. An excellent choice for really experiencing Kevin's amazing beat boxing, aside from his solo videos, is their video of an original entitled Coffee in Bed. You might change your mind after listening to that and his solo work. Regardless, both groups are amazing just different styles. I love PTX's upbeat creative style and am not as fond of the country genre however, I've tons of friends who prefer the good old boy's down to earth sound. You can't lose. Thank you for the reaction.
You have liked Avi Kaplan the original bass in PTX. Look him up on CZcams for his video's . His newest video is First place I go.
Opening a can of worms with listening to such a VAST output by Kevin and Home Free's percussion with such a limited output by comparison. IMHO
I'm disappointed you don't like Pentatonix's arrangement. As a church singer and long-time Christmas music lover, I love their creative arrangements, and I think they still are able to keep the essential quality of the songs they cover while also throwing in some surprises. But everyone has their own likes and dislikes.
lol, I really loved it! I'm not sure what I may have said to make you think I didn't like it
anyone else wating for more NF?? (especially from his new Mixtape or just his Music videos)
Much more to come! We're almost done with the Christmas content, then onto more!
Need to react to Take My Heart. Stripped down just voices no beat box. Amazing truly Amazing.
You should react oh holy night by Ted Neeley, he Is just amazing
I have to say I'm a true believer in Kevin's style of beat boxing. He has more ear pleasing sounds than Home Free's beatboxer. Kevin has more of a technical sound more like percussion than HF. I am biased because I absolutely love PTX. I can't get into the country twang of H F. More PTX please.
You've missed a couple of their Xmas videos, like Where are you Christmas, Deck the Halls and Sweater Weather. And this song was more impactfull on the official video versus a studio live version.
Thanks for the Christmas cheer.
Thanks Ehci! Blessings to you and your family this Christmas season!
Please try Mary Do You Know , Home Free I think you will love it
Mary did you know
Done! It should go live on 12/23! Stay tuned!
Agree with many of the other commenters - it's better to do the official music video first, then the live versions. And the second one here, from Jimmy Kimmel, is much better in terms of sound mixing and balancing. Shame you didn't listen to it as well. Also, you've reacted to tons of their videos - surely it's time to learn their names? I'm surprised, for someone who clearly knows something about music, that you prefer HF's beatboxer. In terms of sound, that's a matter of taste - I can't get into HF at all, for instance. But Kevin is by far superior to his HF equivalent in terms of technical skills as well as range of genres. And finally: why compare to start with? I don't understand this urge a lot of people have to compare groups that do rather different things. Just sit back and enjoy the diversity - you don't actually have to choose!
The one you didn't watch was a lot better imo.
I think that Jimmy Kimmel's show has a better sound system. I've heard PTX on different shows, but the ones that have a host with a musical background always seem to have better quality 🎤 's. Most of the day time hosts do not.
Might as well do a glee reaction too, theirs was released in 2010
I don't mind having your ideas and opinions about what's going on Larry😄. I think you're
very smart and knowledgeable
Thanks so much!
there's a reason you don't post a video of 'Home Free's' performance on Jimmy Kimmel . . . . huh?
Yes! Like the five of them go off into creative wonderland in the middle of the song, like a guitar solo.
Getting wound up with HomeFree just because both are a cappella does no-one any service. They aren't even in the same GENRE!
He should really listen to Voctave.
The Rachal Ray version looks like the audio and video were not matched up well. It's different than the studio version, but not well matched up. The Jimmy Kimmel version is better.
Interesting that you did not comment that this is a LIVE version. Your comment that is dissing Kevin in favor of Home Free's beat boxer is your opinion but ridiculous IMO. Are you comparing LIVE vs LIVE or Live vs studio or official video?
I think you got something wrong/backwards @ 7:34. You are obviously having a harder time saying it than they are at doing it. 🙂 Great reactions and subscribed.
Home free released a new video today
What Christmas means. A little bit motown and a whole lot of good. Couldn't wait to get home from work to listen
Faster tempo song - LOL you have no idea.
Typical... Mitch hits a high note and the camera jumps to Kirstie! I don't think Home Free have covered this. Also I think the Kimmel version is better and the official video is great.
Yeah, I was annoyed at that camera work. Someone should have given the camera person a heads up - though I think I've seen that a couple other times in other TV performances. You'd think the producers would know and plan ahead. But - WE know who sings which parts and can enjoy the fact that the group is getting good exposure!
Have you seen the Grinch 2018?
The movie? Yes, if you're talking about the Jim Carrey version?
No That's 2000
This is a bit rushed. Prefer the official version where all voices are heard more equally.
I betcha you lost several subscriptions due to your comparing the two groups.
Folks here are being rather polite about it, but I can guess it irritated several people. Not because you like one group more than the other, everyone has their favorites, but because you decided to compare the two groups (with PTX being the less respected by you)...on their own video. Had you said you personally like the beatboxer of HF over PTX on one of HF's videos, it would have been fine.
That's a bit of a faux pas in the a cappella scene. But you live and you learn. And now you know.
I must admit that I did not find this "hurried" at all. In fact, I thought the speed change was integral to their "upgrading" of the song. It kept it from being plodding and boring.
Why would you come on to a Pentatonix video and negatively compare them to Home Free? Makes no sense. The two bands are not in competition and it was rude of you. You took what could have been a fun experience and pissed people off for no reason. Unsubscribed.
Hi Vids! I would recommend you watch my recent reactions of them. Also, please comb through the comments and you may find your statement is pretty rare, but I getcha.
Tho I couldn't disagree more regarding your comment about home free being better than Kevin beatnoxing, each to their own. I guess I prefer a band with a wider range like ptx that cam handle with ease virtually every genre and song, home free I find limited to being a country band primarily. And I dislike country. Lol but I'll also say I let ptx record speak for itself. Outselling, most award winning and most popular acapella band out there still today, esp after winning sing off but record label passed, how much have they kicked themselves over that choice? To me and I think most ptx is on a plane higher than any other acapella band out there, with superior vocals, beat boxing, range and creativity. Even the artists whose songs they covered were blown away such as Brian may snd Paul Simon. I read in an interview pith Brian that had Freddie lived long enough he'd have loved their version of bohemian rhapsody and would have been Freddie's ringtone had he a cell phone. Lol
I think you love to here yourself talk.
That's what I love about the internet. People are able to voice their opinions and not have to do it face to face due to the embarrassment of it all. Imagine walking up to a stranger and saying that. I guess it's nice to have the comfort of hiding behind a screen and keyboard when saying stuff, I guess. There, now you can say that I love to see myself type lol!
Stop pausing video
You should be more concise in your comments and interrupt less