“Evidence That This Policy Is Already Working!” Rwanda Bill Drives Asylum Seekers To Ireland
Vložit
- čas přidán 25. 04. 2024
- Ireland’s Deputy Prime Minister has claimed the Rwanda bill is causing asylum seekers to flock into the Republic of Ireland.
The Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration) Act 2024, passed on Tuesday, is Rishi Sunak’s controversial deportation plan which will send illegal asylum seekers to the African country if they enter the UK.
While no planes have currently been sent to Rwanda, Number 10 announced that the first flight has been ‘booked.'
Michael Martin, the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs, said the policy’s deterrence is forcing asylum seekers into Ireland as they are “fearful” of staying in the UK.
TalkTV’s Jake Berry is joined by former Labour adviser Stella Tsantekidou and political journalist Zoë Grünewald, to discuss the effectiveness of the Rwanda bill.
Click here for more from TalkTV talk.tv
If you need any help visit: talk.tv/helplines
#rwandabill #ireland #migration #asylumseekers #immigration
They're ECONOMIC MIGRANTS NOT REFUGEES!!! THEY'RE NOT FLEEING PERSECUTION!!
The English hating immigrant commentator would love to see our nation flooded with benefit parasites
If they facing persecution they would go to first place that is safe and they would take there paperwork as they would also want there family members to be safe. The person would be scared and would want the truth out they also would want to expose the bad leaders and they would give information on why they facing persecution who is doing it.
@@sakhter4044 They come to a Christian, St Georges flag waving country that speaks English as they mostly do. They think we stand for Christian values of love, unity and a sharing of the Christian faith. They see the cross of St George which is also their Patron Saint and assume we have Christian values. It is only when they get here they realise that we have conned them as we no longer have Christian values do we? Our current policies are are much, much closer to those of 1930's Germany, you must agree on that surely?
The way to stop them is to tow them back. If their boats are no good put them on retired ferries and these two ladies can be figureheads. Thats how tolerant
@@sakhter4044because you would know what it’s like being persecuted. You would know exactly what it feels like fleeing, torture, rape, starvation, censorship, war and much more because you obviously have first hand experience.
Maybe don’t give out nonsense advice on a topic you have exactly 0% understanding of. You’ve never been in that situation or anywhere near it so how do you have any basis to give advice to these people?
The British people have had enough.
ABSOLUTELY 👏
Let those pay and keep them in there house this lady can take a few if she feels strongly that goes for all of them
Tell your gouvnement yo stop creating problems for other countries so that people will not move😂😂😂😂
Irish too.
@@sarahmurphy-nf4yl it's awful the way the Irish people are being treated 😕
Absolute rubbish from these two ladies they’d let every illegal immigrant in.
Ask them will they handle these men when they have a sexual emergency?
Ladies 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Yes they wud...but bet they wudnt be welcoming them enough to put them up in their own homes
Let these ladies pay and house them also many others as they feel so strongly don't keep putting on the taxpayers who should have a choice
Let the 1stnimmigrants camp in their back yard.
Am sorry this woman is talking rubbish
How did Stella become a Labour advisor 😂😂
TWO women talking rubbish
Dont be sorry. She needs to hide from the public. What an embarrassment for her family.
@@user-dq6nj1zv9h Did you notice the con artists switching position?
Britain is a tolerant country. But I thought we were institutionally racist. Dianne Abbott used to say that 30 years ago. Now what does she say?
Australia defended themselves on their own
Why is this woman even speaking about our country? we give citizenship away far too easily!
Watch question time audience ( this nation is packed to the rafters with indigenous people who want to flood the UK with benefit parasites) and Wes Streeting agrees with the audience--LOL
Let her pay will she do that why does she have a right go make the decision for all the uk public.
First strategy of the failing Communist; Deny it all, nothing to see here, what are you talking about? Are you crazy? Hey this guy is crazy!
What language is she talking? It sure ain't English!
@@maxkite4170 What is it then? It sounds like English to me.
THESE WOMEN ARE BOTH UNBELIEVABLY NIEVE
Maybe they are like the women looking after the sex starved men in Calais ?
They not if they had to pay out of there own pocket and house them they would soon shut up
Not naive just obtuse
That's the problem too many naive people trying to make laws and policies and they are not worldly wise.
That's being kind!
CHARITY SHOULD BEGIN AT HOME. THERE IS HUNDREDS OF HOMELESS PEOPLE IN THIS COUNTRY WHO SHOULD BE PRIORITIESD .
Your post deserves loads more thumbs up
@paulinelongley Yes there is hundreds of homeless people in Britain but the govt is to blame not the migrants
And Ireland 🇮🇪
@@johnmcmahon5145 Yes it's the governments fault for allowing high levels of legal immigration, not stopping the boats and for allowing economic migrants to claim refugee status, when we don't have enough homes. But the migrants who come illegally by paying people traffickers, throw away their identification and play the system are also to blame. This is not only at the cost of the British and Irish but also genuine refugees.
@@noelfleming3567 Same problems in Ireland too isn’t there
We are Proud of you. This is what Australia did. We DONT have your issues now. This WOMAN is Spanish or something. Its Not her Country. Poor Irish people.
Haven’t you just increased your legal immigration from 80,000 per year to 100,000 per month? Any illegal immigration would push you right over the edge.
Australia dont belong to europeans..give their land back and go home ur also illegal immigrant to the land u dont own
I live in Australia. Just last month we had a boat arrive in the north of a west Australia with would be asylum seekers that were mainly from Pakistan. This is despite that for the 10+ years everyone knows that anyone arriving by irregular means will not be granted leave to settle or remain in Australia. We are told this happened because the change of government cut funding and took their eye off the ball in border control. This could cost them the next election.
Meanwhile the government is trying pass a bill whereby nobody will be granted any visa to enter Australia if they come from Iran, Iraq, Russia, South Sudan or Mozambique. This is because these countries will not take failed asylum back despite them having served sentences for very serious crimes and therefore being a risk to the safety of Australians. Surely any governments duty of care is firstly owed to the people that elected it?
Immigration departments need politicians and leaders with relevant skills, knowledge and GUTS to protect their country.
She's Greek ..
@@Kualabear02 Illegal immigrants will not be granted asylum. The massive increase is Labor's substitute for open borders which is what they really want. Hopefully they'll be out of office soon and the numbers will be reduced to earlier, manageable, levels.
France 🇫🇷 is a safe country and they prefer UK benefits
Yes sure,,,,lowest so called ‘benefits’ of any western country,Fact..But you’ve been convinced otherwise by the usual suspects because it feeds your own ignorance and prejudices.
The overwhelming majority of migrants/refugees stay in continental Europe. The UK ranks 14th* for the number of migrants/ refugees received amongst European countries. *Source FullFact
Yes that makes sense as France spends 30% gdp on benefits the uk 18% gdp on benefits ….
I heard one say to a reporter that France is " no good UK good " ! 😮
that’s not true. similar benefits in France, if not better. Globally non native English speakers learn English, so they Generally seek an English speaking country to go to.
The acceptance rate in the UK is 61% and in France... 23%.
90% of them are not fleeing anything
be the grub would you eat frogs and snails
Cats are fleaing.
@@kopynd1France eat both so…
Stella would accept every person trying to ILLEGALLY enter into YOUR home, but not HERS.
I’m an immigrant living in England, I went through a rigorous immigration process, filled out extensive paperwork and waited in line to come to this beautiful country, I also paid a lot of money for the entire transaction including the initial NHS fee of £1,200.00 pounds, it cost me a total of £4 thousand pounds, I was granted a visa entry and a biometric card that states “not allowed for public funds.” It’s basically a permit to work and pay taxes, which I’m totally fine with such rules. Now we have grown Islamist men who jump the cue and come into Britain illegally not paying one penny into the British system and falsely claiming political asylum, upon arrival they get free housing free food, cash allowance and free healthcare while waiting for their case to be heard comfortably in a hotel that taxpayers pay for. This is not only insane, but unfair to immigrants like myself who play by the rules.
Pathetic! 🤦🏻♂️
You are so right so you can imagine how we natives feel about it.
U can go home then if u dont like...stop acting like u realy care
@@nr8782 - I play by the rules, I’m a qualified professional who actually contributes to the British economy and society. I actually care about the place I’m living in, I don’t want to see this country being filled with low skilled individuals who are shoving their Islamic religion down our throats. You in the other hand don’t seem to be bright enough to grasp the reality of illegal immigration. I bet you are not even British. 🇬🇧 🇩🇪
@@nr8782wrong, British abroad past and present also care,
@@nr8782If they didn't care or have any sense of decency they would've hopped on a boat! Don't be rude to someone who came here through the correct channels and they have EVERY RIGHT to have a say because they actually PAY and CONTRIBUTE into our system!!
The absolute ignorance of you!!!
This man wiped the floor with these women. They are WRONG and he is RIGHT.
Who cares where they go as long as they are gone
facts
Because inflicting the problem on someone else, doesn't solve it.
And people who are willing to risk the dangers of the channel will not be put off by a 200 to 1 chance of going to Rwanda
@@alexedwards6509 i live and own other property right on the edge of the cliff where they land i have seen newspapers actually reinact them landing by getting local Roma to pretend they are the immigrants because the real ones were all young men who bunked off quick and had no women or kids
The French likes us because we let benefit scroungers come here
The Irish care.
Put this Italian woman on the first flight.
She's the Greek Shola.
@@mehcolshe is Gobby Greek
She is Greek
Not British for sure !!!
I thought she was Romanian
Why has Talk Tv host got TWO lefty women migrant lovers on here ???
These two are not even English
It highlights the folly of female suffrage
Let them pay and house them the british don't want to pay many are struggling these ladies want right and choices for migrants why not the same for British citizens.
Hey angry Riot Grrrrl feminist mod who deleted my comment:- say hello / miaow to your seventeen cats for me 😻
If Ireland want this too stop they need to rigorously back England in turning back the boats in the channel and pressure them to do it
Can't believe adults are making these decisions. It's whack a mole.
The Irish need to stop dodgy people flying into Dublin from EU on dodgy passports
they will be smuggled into the UK from Ireland,they will make more money than they do from drugs
Exactly back thd uk send them to the e u leaders house Where's merkle and the many others ship em send them there
@@sakhter4044 and tge EU need too do tge same, turn them back immediately
IRELAND HAS NO ROOM FOR ANYMORE FOR GODSAKE, GET REAL
Get rid if these two idiot commentators
Well as the French have said, not our problem. They're obviously fleeing persecution here so you can have them. Leave the EU and start acting like our neighbour instead of our enemy and we could fix this issue as the British isles, leave the ECHR stand with us in the global stage and lead the way on this.
Scotland's next for the invasion.
What about d Dublin agreements time to ship them back to Belfast that's how they get into Ireland through northern Ireland
@@noelfleming3567 hahahaha, nothing to do with the Dublin agreement, do you know what it is???
When did France ever cooperate with Uk or Uk cooperate with France? These two women are off their rockers!
Ireland is in the EU but we’re still inundated with refugees. So no point in cooperating with Brussels 😅😅😅
Send them back through d Dublin agreements
IREXIT. IRELAND NEEDS TO LEAVE EU.
They are only determined to come here because of the finance we provide, the homes we provide. No longer tolerant when our NHS needs our support, our own people need support, but we have no money for that because we are giving it away.
Wherever Islam goes, blood flows
Yes 💯
Without the lies, Islam dies.
What the colonials did in the past ! Don’t mock Islam ! U made those wars there the whole history knows this !
@@hiraa..091islam/mooslems arabs, are the Biggest colonials in the whole of History, spain, Indonesia, north africa, Turkey, Bosnia, Albania, the Holy lands, prooves this...
learn from Poland
Totally agree with you. Poland shut its borders. Shows which government has their brains
situated in the RIGHT PLACE .
£1.8m per illegal immigrant is the final cost to send them to Rwanda. It beggars belief that this government is so inept at everything?
@@Hugohackenbush 🤣
Don't believe the £1.8m figure, they have worked that out with the initial total costs of the scheme and factored in only 300 migrants.
What utter nonsense these two are speaking. We are sick of these illegal immigrants gaining our system whilst we ignore our own folk who are struggling.
EU made the decision to have open borders. EU can deal with the problem they made. The British has spoken, when they voted for Brexit.
I 100% agree with that,shenghen zone was meant for Europeans to travel freely between member states ,but the incompetents who run the EU allow the whole of Africa and the Middle East to travel wherever no id no papers no passport what a fcking shambles.they keep saying France and Germany take more illegals than U.K. ,we didn’t agree to open borders why should we pay the price they should all be returned asap
Does she not know we have an agreement with France? We agreed to pay them millions to stop the people from leaving .
France does to UK what Turkey does to EU, " Blackmailing"
I often wonder, if these people who ‘fight’ for the ‘rights’ of the illegal immigrants, have any illegal immigrants occupying their spare bedrooms, and are financing them with their own money?
That would show genuine compassion, and commitment to the cause. Giving them a right to speak out.
If they are not willing to use their own money, to fulfil their own beliefs, don’t expect the tax payer to either.
It's because their careers depend on them! You won't hear publicans advocating for tighter alcohol controls!
What a load of rubbish British people don't want any small boats in Britain should only take care of the British people period
Rwanda looks very nice?
I hope soon, it looks very busy.
We are the only country in the world that allows immigrants tell us ,it's okay to flood the UK with benefit seeking parasites and the Labour MP Wes Streeting agrees--LOL
@@capabilitybrown2323it is a criminal country used by your gouvnement to shade blood of the innocent in kongo😢😢😢😢
I really wish they would stop talking about ‘fleeing war zones’. If that were the case, we would help. But it’s not
Poor Ireland
that foreign women should be in rwanda not here
Bring them to our beautiful rwanda...then can live hre happly..whats in uk anyway apart from exploiting and loot....and land robing
@@nr8782 Rwanda will only accept 5000. You should get on to your government and see if they'll take-in a million people. But these migrants don't want to go to Rwanda, the only reason why they want to come here is because they are given free housing, rent paid by the government almost immediately, free healthcare immediately, free schools, bills paid by the government, free money, etc. Our system for the poor in this country is given to them off-the-bat, they know this, that is why they come here.
Take Them Back soo Simple..had enough
When people go to war. They leave their leave their families behind. When their flee war their take their families with them. Or send women and children first!
WE
Exactly. But all you see on these boats in men between the ages of 18 and 40. At an around 80/20 ratio.
I totally disagree with this woman, we have a duty to protect our country.
This foreign woman seems to know what’s better for this country, than our own people do. What a loudmouth. These young people unfortunately have got us into this abysmal situation.
Ireland should be happy getting more doctors and engineers, surely.
What a load of Sunak spin get rid of him
We are full up send em bk
These woman are ridiculous. We voted to leave someone tell them they lost their argument 8 years ago get over it
Why are we listening to opinions of foreigners
No its anti illegal migration.
Look at these women throwing the indigenous people under the bus. SHAME
Saw this irish guy interviewing an illegal in Ireland. He was flown to London, then " taken to Ireland by ferry". All without a passport. This guy wouldn't say who was taking him. But it wasn't a trafficker. He didn't even know where he was going. An interpreter told me that every single illegal tells him that they are all promised a free brand new fully furnished house each, if they agreed to get on the waiting dinghy. And they aren't paying. There are no trafficking gangs, they don't exist.
wth? dinghy run by migrants? by Irish? by who? Some Manchester Muslkms csme over to counter protest.
Wasn’t that long ago varadker stoop up in the Irish parliament saying we are no longer Irish but European 😮this is there goal no sovereignty just a block with no borders 🙄
Varadkar was wrong ,we are Irish, he and his cronies are the outsiders,traitors
The only open border Ireland has is with the UK, not the EU
If only. Last time I checked, Nigeria and Algeria weren't in the EU.
Meanwhile cancer victims & seriously disabled are treated like criminals. This is utterly disgusting and inexcusable.
*Britain is no longer sovereign, cope* 😂😂😂
You don't know that? It could work very well. Yes it would be perfect. Send them all immediately!!!!!
You’re wrong we don’t care. We’re not a caring bunch of Brit’s.
Stop talking about the EU..all these illegal economic migrants loved to come to the UK..
The immigrants are fleeing England but the boats are still coming across the channel so it’s not a deterrent.
They fleeing as England is in war here you can see these migrants true colours they are liars there's no persecution or anything they just want free benefits and british passport when they get that they will remember there homeland visit and spend all there benefits building a house in homeland taking a councils house in uk win win solution for the migrants but lose situation for the british tax payer who has been made to pay.
All these English cities today are now minority white indigenous British.
London in 1961 had a 98% White population today thats dropped to just 35% White British
Birmingham in 1951 had a 99% White population today thats dropped to just 40%
Manchester in 1961 had a 98% White population today it's dropped to just 47% White British
Leicester in 1961 had a 98% White population today it's just 40% white with a majority 44% Asian population
Bradford in 1971 had a 95% white population today it's dropped to just 50%
Luton in 1961 had a 96% White population today it's dropped to just 32%
Liverpool in 2009 had a 91% white population today thats just 70% and decreasing more at an alarming rate
Go to Ireland which is less populated than France and a TEN mile crossing instead of 22+ .Simples.....and no border patrols.
THAT LABOUR WOMAN STELLA SHOULD LEAVE
one flight and it's starting to work, wouldn't believe everything you read.
We haven’t had one flight Yet , what are you talking about ??
@@user-dq6nj1zv9h Exactly my point.🤣It's all lies. If there's no flights taking off, then how come everyone is now going to ireland. of course they're still coming here, looking for votes is all they're are doing.
No silver bullet but there are 30mm cannons....
Single men go to war alone..where are the women and children ???
They are coming to Europe to make war ! All planned by the WEF.
These are our replacements when our men go to war in the Eastern European country which has nothing to do with us.
The British people don’t want them.
If every british boat saved the French people from the sea called French police coast guard and took them back to French beach, they would stop coming cos what would be the point of reaching a 12 mile line to go back to france. All roads, back to France all, boats and lorries people back to France
1:35 - She's so kind. They could erect tents in her garden. I'm sure her neighbours won't mind if they're as nice as her.
More bullshit and lies
Is that french woman being racist towards Rwanda .And is france racist because immigrants are fleeing france
Passing the buck on to Ireland 🇮🇪 Ireland is full!
not really , EU which includes Ireland should police its borders externally , they came from the EU not Britain
You EU guys need to start policing the external border , problem solved
@@boofuu314580% of migrants entering the ROI arrived from Northern Ireland having originally travelled from GB. The only open border Ireland is with the UK (NI land border). Ireland is not in the Schengen area but in a common travel area with the UK
@@Deranged316 you are in the EU , they arrive via the EU , external borders of the EU is why you having these arriving , it needs sorting at SOURCE
@@Deranged316 you could always pay us 500m to do absolutely nothing like we do France
We could ask for our 500 million back since we would be doing their job that we paid them to do. How much buys a good relationship with France?. I d give them nothing bar boats and passengers back. Every time back you go.
Boats with children?
Not many of those. Nor with women.
Ireland should have a word with the French.
Yet another reason not to vote for Labour.. look at the attitude of this ex Labour advisor!!!!
The Irish supreme court ordered the UK unsafe to send them back, its not they all of a sudden want to go to Ireland, its that its now law to not send them back
Sorry but you should have British 🇬🇧 people on your show don’t know who that woman is but not a British patriot
There needs to be an EU perspective to this issue, since it is a party to this problem.
WE SHOULD BE LOOKING AFTER THE BRITISH PEOPLE FIRST
If france doesn't stop them we need to make france pay
Those ladies arrogance oozes from them. I don’t think they have this country’s best interest at heart. Also people’s tolerance is being tested now. We are all feeling that we are being walked over.
Rwanda is starting to work......
They'll return if they get bored of Ireland, then try a different story that has been tested with success.
It's not an exam. There's no teachers watching over them to ensure they're not copying.
Money Laundering ???
Where are they going to go? GO HOME!!
Trying to pay for an extra 300 to 500 people a day coming in ongoing is unsustainable simple as. shouldn't we be spending that money on securing our borders, bigger hospitals and all services to cope with the growing population we've got..
The French government would return every illegal migrant the same day and fine the UK for their negligence .
BS
If this Gov letting in illegals then Brexit was for what? Shutting boarder for legals then letting in illegals ?
I'm from Ireland. Your Rwanda plan is working because more of them are coming here since it passed in your parliament. At least your Government is trying to do something to cut the numbers unlike the useless Government we have. But the people are fighting back as seen in the videos online.
How the comments section has changed from wat it used to be. All the so called do gooders that used to encourage them here aren't doing so now. Wats the matter do gooders? Overpopulation is actually starting to affect your lives now with no housing, school places etc? Just like others warned you?
yes it made my bllod boil when some early twenties do gooder was one minute complaining about rent then in next breath calling people racist who points out their problem
And let’s just blame everything on global warming while I thought they were fleeing persecution
These two are just so thick.
Perhaps the lady that thinks we shouldn’t be able to control our borders would keep her doors unlocked . I doubt it . Boundaries are there for a reason. For some reason those in charge are scared to enforce them. It can’t go on forever. Boundaries are important. When children aren’t given loving boundaries their adult lives become a mess. We can already see the difference between countries that have strong boundaries and those that don’t have any.
The Egyptians charging the Palestinians to cross their borders 😂😂😂😂
Europe must be mad
They are not all fleeing war zones ffs
But as soon as Rwanda take 200 then the government is screwed because they have already said there not taking anymore than that
No they haven’t, an official in Rwanda said last week , the numbers Are UNlimited
They are not being "persecuted" in *France.*
These people are liars.
No it is not a deterrent
A lot of boat people coming to UK have been refused asylum elsewhere in Europe, so UK is their last chance as we are a soft touch.
I really have no problem with immigration I know many people from South Africa , Poland, Romania who reside here in the uk - they work they pay into the system they adapt our ways (to a point they don’t need to completely erase their identities) however the illegal immigration situation at the moment is worrying . They don’t integrate into society now it’s literally them against us . Close the borders and deal with the hundreds of thousands we’ve had come over in the past couple of years. Either grant them asylum or refuse and send back - it’s not hard . If we don’t act now it’s going to go past the point of ever being able to save the uk
They are not stopping at first country they enter, they want to come to UK illegally via boats...
This policy will work. These asylum seekers will STOP IMEDIATELY when they see people shipped to Riwanda. And remember, if they are legitamate asylum seekers they WILL be allowed entry into England so there shouldn't be a problem.
She is not even British no wonder she is against it
Can't stand that Stella woman.. WTH does TALK TV have her on?
80% of applications are refused. These people are opportunists!!
COURSE IT IS STOP HOTELS STOP FEEDING THEM STOP HOUSING THEM PROB SOLVED
Absolute rubbish, I don’t think the Rwanda bill is responsible for this!!
Pass the invader anyone?
Ireland wins!
If the EU police its external border problem solved