The Most HATED Man in Scotland? Meeting the Mannie, First Duke of Sutherland. Ep. 209.
Vložit
- čas přidán 4. 08. 2022
- I climb the 1,300-feet high Ben Bhraggie in Golspie, Sutherland, to meet the infamous monument of The First Duke of Sutherland, known locally as 'The Wee Mannie'. Why is he the most hated man in Scotland? He was responsible for the controversial Highland Clearances. Find out why so many people want to destroy the monument and see his 185-year old statue replaced.
If you miss our narrowboat journeys, subscribe to our realtime narrowboat cruising channel 'Britain by Narrowboat' here 👉🏻 / britainbynarrowboat
Catch-up on every vlog from the beginning here:
• Every Foxes Afloat Vlo...
❓Got a question? Check out the FAQ's on our website:
www.foxesafloat.com/faq-s
★ Support our channel in one of the following ways:
📺 Get EXCLUSIVE content as a Patreon or CZcams Member:
CZcams - / @foxesafloat
Patreon - / foxesafloat
💰 Donate using Paypal:
paypal.me/foxesafloat
👀 Follow Colin's Naturist lifestyle on his Patreon channel:
/ nakedfox
🎁 Treat us to something from our Amazon Wish List!
www.amazon.co.uk/hz/wishlist/...
🛒 Foxes Afloat Merchandise:
Grab yourself a Foxes Afloat mug or t-shirt from our online store:
foxesafloat.myspreadshop.co.uk
Colin has a gallery where you can browse and buy his photographs in a digital image format or a framed print:
www.foxesafloat.com/gallery.
If you shop with Amazon, save this link and we'll get a small commission every time you buy using the link. You won't pay a penny extra:
Foxes Afloat Amazon store: www.amazon.co.uk/shop/foxesaf....
⚑ Follow our adventures on social media:
Twitter: / foxesafloat
Facebook: / foxesafloat
Instagram: / foxesafloat
📷 If you'd like to know what equipment we use to produce our vlogs, below are links to them. If you buy from these links we will receive a small commission but you won't pay a penny extra.
Video Recording:
Sony FDR-AX-700 Camcorder: amzn.to/3aLxj68.
DJI Mavic 2 Pro Drone: click.dji.com/AAUkyEcEGBe0kGd...
DJI Osmo Pocket: click.dji.com/AJXM1L1X3pZFKDS...
Insta 360 One R Twin Edition with 360 degree and 4K wide angle: amzn.to/34kluCF
GoPro Hero 7: amzn.to/3pnsjZp
Sound Recording:
Rode VideoMic Pro+: amzn.to/3aLxI8E
Rode Wireless Go: amzn.to/34LdyaV
Rode Procaster Microphone: amzn.to/2Mevm85
Rode Deadcat Windshield: amzn.to/34JuYVu
Accessories:
DJI Osmo Mobile 3 Gimbal: click.dji.com/ACB51coEOkuobGd...
Geekoto 79 inch Tripod/Monopod: amzn.to/3ryT3b5
Neewer 47.2 Inch Camera Track: amzn.to/34Jv2Ve
Drone Landing Pad: amzn.to/38BUz3D
Jaws Clamp Mount for GoPro7 Hero: amzn.to/3rw3hsU
SanDisk Extreme 128GB microSDXC Memory Card: amzn.to/2WPBqpi
SanDisk Extreme Pro SDXC 128GB Memory Card: amzn.to/3ppc1PF
Download the music from our vlogs at;
Artlist: artlist.io/Colin-345821
Epidemic Sound: www.epidemicsound.com/referra...
This week's tracks were;
'On The Way' by Ian Post.
'Fortitude' by Lance Conrad.
'Memory and Forgetting (Piano Version)' by SPEARFISHER.
'I Promise' by Ian Post.
'Barrio Bandolim' by River Lume.
#DukeofSutherland #Mannie #BenBhraggie
Your interloper in the outtakes was seriously funny, some people don’t take the hint, or think he was lonely 😀
Once again some seriously good cinematography of which I am hugely envious of your abilities, well done.
I just about laughed until I cried with the outtake of the man photobombing you!
Thanks for making my day a bit better!
Just so educational and professional. What would my week be like without you two. See you next week .
My knees probably won’t ever let me do that climb, so thanks, Colin, for doing the heavy lifting and bringing us all along. Have a lovely birthday coming up. Might we see a photo of the view from up there in next year’s calendar?
Your born and bred highlander from that neck of the woods has never forgiven nor will ever forget. That would be my SIL who was born in Kildonan parish (inland from Helmsdale) and whose family still live in Golspie. The parish church far up the glen is twinned with a community church in the Kildonan area of Winnipeg, Canada which was named by families from the clearances who settled in the Red River Colony. In one of those quirks of fate my husband and moved from Scotland to Winnipeg in the 1980s and lived there for 3 years.
The future can be changed, but history can’t. It should be remembered and lessons learnt from it.
Colin, that was wonderful. Your photography is amazing. The history is so interesting and you were exactly right. We cannot go back to right the wrongs of the past but we can remember and LEARN from our past mistakes.
I am Scottish and have ancestors who were affected by gowers and sellars actions but I would rather people see his statue up there and learn about the history.
Also look at how he is immortalised - in stone with no one beside him, just a lonely old sod on a hill. Very fitting for the greedy ______ he was and what he inflicted on our People.
Alba gu brath 🏴
Despite a lot of viewers suggesting I am not allowed an opinion... I totally agree with you :) x
Well what an incredible video. Colin your knowledge is encyclopedic. When I see the beautiful countryside of Scotand I feel so proud to be Scottish. I realy enjoyed this one and again feel entertained by you both. This is better than BBC standard IMHO. I hpoe you have a Happy Birthday Colin and I wish you all the best. (21 again lol). I could never do that walk now because I am getting to old. But you enable people like me who can't do this stuff any longer to see and experience it through you. A great public service. Keep well and safe. James.
Aww, cheers James 👍🏻❤️
As a hiker and biker, I felt I was with you all the way up. BEAUTIFUL. I fell out of my chair belly laughing at the look on your face with the man photo booming your video. LMGAO!!!!!!!! snort LOL
Fabulous Colin. Stunning views and interesting history. Quite agree that we should keep history and learn from it. Thank you. Good to see Shaun, missed him not being up there with you. Said Hello to Dylan as we passed his special place this afternoon. See you soon. Take care.💕🐾xxx
Loved the vlog today - beautiful scenery as well as a very interesting story. Thank you for all the hard work that you put into your research. All the work that you put into each vlog shows and is appreciated.
What a wonderful video! Thank you for going to such effort to share this. 💕
Happy Birthday 🎂 Colin on Monday Lovely video and the history lesson was spot on.Golspie is a beautiful place.
Very informative and agree with view on history..
He thought he did people a favour by killing them, scaring the hell out of children watching their parents and grandparents beaten up and cruelly mistreated , by driving the people from the place they grew up, the land they worked for generations... and all this for making even more money than this man already had.... I don't believe for a minute he or anybody else believed in this 'good Samaritan story'. He terrorised the area and there's a lot of blood on his hands.
It's a stunning place, Bonnie Scotland in her Sunday attire. However, the monument- I don't think he deserves one but that's just my opinion. Everyone has their own.
I had wondered if I'd miss the narrowboat and those goings on, and the answer is not a bit 😊 Obvious Scotland has been good for the both of you. Happy Birthday Colin!! ❤ p.s THAT MAN at 13.00.....
I have never laughed so much 🤣No seriously what was that guy doing, standing behind you, must have realised you were filming. 😂
My family (the MacRaes) were one of those who were cleared from their homes, so it was cool seeing the statue of the man who started it. If you get the chance to go to the West coast - check out my family's home in Kintail - Around Mallaig - and Eilean Donan Castle! According to my family tree, I'm a direct descendant of Duncan of the Battle-Axe, who became Constable of the Castle. Unfortunately, after the 1745 uprising, the Castle was blown up - only to be restored in the early 20th century to a wonderful condition!
When you talk about those "new villages". A few miles up the road from Dunrobin are the remains of a clearance village - one of those villages. It is perched on a desolate windswept plot of land covered in gorse where crops would have been feeble and flocks and herds would struggle to survive. It is on the edge of a cliff meaning that getting to the sea to fish would have been dangerous. Sutherlan's factor would still expect rent to be paid on it though. If you get a minute, do visit
Are you talking about Badbea?
I, for one, appreciate your view on the subject matter (both literally and figuratively) in the view. A statue is just that, a carved lump of stone depicting a person or event. It is objective. It's the person viewing that statue that has a subjective view. And everyone has their own point of view on the matter. And for statues like this, it IS a historical item, reflective of the era in which it was erected. One doesn't destroy or remove history when things like statues are removed or destroyed; one cannot change history, even if it doesn't conform to a person's view of the current world.
Enough dwelling on that. The drone shots were absolutely spectacular, as were your shots from the top, and it's a wonderful bit of researching history. One would almost think you were born there :)
💙💙💙 Just love you boys!!! The Vlog was beautiful Colin thank you. You know what comes next, give Ottis a huge hug please. 💙💙💙
Enjoyed the history lesson very much
and what a great view from the top
wishing you a very happy birthday Monday
First, Happy Birthday, Colin! Hope you have a great day!
Agree with preserving history. Here is the U.S., we've suffered through people that are out to destroy our history by destroying monuments and statues.
I just found you guys! In one day, I find you, follow your travels with silver fox, hear your dad die, your dog cross the rainbow bridge, and a new boat. I laughed with you, cried with you, I share your mental health issues as well. Now, your in Scotland lol. I have quite a bit of catch up to do and in order would be good too. Thank you boys. I am loving living through you. For now, I can’t stop watching all the beautiful countryside you film. History and calm, beautiful, green. Gosh it’s wonderful. Thank you
Well hello 👋🏻 We do have a playlist with all our vlogs in order 👍🏻
Spot on about history as those who refuse to learn about the past are doomed to repeat its mistakes.
Hallo Foxies!! great vlog as usual. im so glad that you are doing well and you're all feeling better - Colin with mental health and Shaun with the tick bite! Lyme is no joke. akso I was thinking about your vlog about regretting your life changes - Before i moved us to Des Moines I asked my kids if they thought we could be happier there vs where we were. Chris, who was newly diagnosed with ASD said "we can't run away from things that make us unhappy because it will always be with us, but it would be ok to be unhappy someplace else for a while". i thought that was pretty well said. Anyway keep being happy, healthy, and keep having fun.
That was a great video. I was visiting Golspie and the matriarch of our family (93 years old at the time) and I had a long conversation about the statue of the Duke. She was among many living in Golspie who wanted it to remain standing because it makes it hard to forget the history of the Clearances. Then she told me about one of my 3rd great grandfathers who was cleared from Strathnaver with my ancestors. He watched as his home was burned down when he was a boy. The family fled to the coast that evening. I had no idea that had happened to our family before that day. Wish I had gone on the climb to see the view. Next time!
Awww man, best vlog yet…….totally agree with your thoughts on remembering history👍🏻 loving the Foxes new adventures btw #foxesrock
Absolutely love how much you guys are embracing the beauty of Scotland as well as digging into the history. Glad to have you both in oor wee country 💙
Well done.... When I toured Scotland in 1998, our tour directors made an unplanned stop at Dunrobin. Our bus driver stayed at the bus while we were touring the site; he just frowned, waved his arm in the general direction of the castle and said, "Sheep! This all came from sheep!" And there might have been a few swear words in the mix as well...........
Colin, I absolutely LOVE your videos! I know they take a LOT of work, you make them very interesting and informative. I appreciate what you both do so much! Thanks!!
That was brilliant Colin. Thank you. The Clearances affected so many thousands of people and are a questionable blight in Scottish history, but a history that, along with everything else, should be remembered. You may be interested to read about our island history in the West. If so,maybe a read of Calum’s Road. A more recent event that brings to life the effects of those clearances 😊
Have you read John Prebble's 'The Highland Clearances' ? he has quite a lot to say about this guy, Patrick Sellars, and the effects it had on the crofters etc.. Try visiting Croick Church for instance (if you haven't already) and read the story about the messages scratched into the windows.
Yes! Recently too.
Colin, your skill as a filmmaker and broadcaster come shining through in this video. Well done, indeed, sir! Thank you... I truly appreciate you guys. May every good thing be yours!
Brilliant! So thoughtful. One of your best. Thanks!
Colin thank you for doing Scotland proud keep up the good work
Wow, guys. Your production values are going through the roof! Beautiful photography, and the history lesson was brilliant. Thank you! ❤
Our pleasure!
Yes that's what drove my wife's ancestors to emigrate. Initially to Nova Scotia in Canada and then onto New Zealand after several years - apparently they didn't like the Nova Scotian weather....
Happy birthday Colin , you are a lovely couple always make me smile Xx
Great video Colin. Thanks. Half of me wants to knock this truly evil man off of his perch but the other half says leave him up there so that we are reminded of his crimes for generations to come. These large estates which still abound in Scotland need to be taken into public ownership for the benefit of ordinary working people with no compensation as they were effectively stolen in the first place and I really hope that the Scottish Government will have the courage to do so.
Great video… I love Colin’s “teaching”… the historical facts and documentary type videos. He does such a great job of them. Would love to see more of your homestead too! Thanks guys ❤️
This was Devine! Thank you for the walk and history lesson 🎀
Great episode. Read the book"Set Adrift Upon the World".
My 5th Great grandparents were burned out of Kildonan in 1815 and resettled in Winnipeg, thanks to Lord Selkirk's expeditions to Prince Ruperts Land (present day Manitoba).
The Emmigrant statue has a facing mirror image in a park in Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada, along the Red River of the North.
Great video, thanks for “taking us along”! Cheers from Colorado!
Thanks again for a wonderful video and thoughtful discussion of a very worthy subject. There are few people who are entirely good or bad. We’re all a confused noise with a complicated blend of vice and virtue. Remembering (even celebrating) the good should be balanced with remembering and educating about, the bad.
Woohoo! Thank you for showing us those killer views. I felt as though I were there looking over the beautiful countryside. Keep finding amazing places to take us to. Love your channel immensely! 🤗❤️
We have climbed Crough Patrick, the Holy Mountain or Ireland several times, and the last stage is steep, and just when you think it isn't ever going to end, the sky ahead comes, and then the chapel as you reach the end. Magic.
What a wonderful life your having, much joy and happiness
Dear Colin have a very great Birthday 🎂🎉
Granny from Logan Utah
I so look forward to your videos each week. Thank you for taking us with you to these beautiful places. You are a joy to watch and listen to .I learn something interesting each week You and Shaun are wonderful . Like the T shirt , may get me one if I can figure out how to get it. Happy Birthday Monday Colin Love you guys .Thanks again
Hey Colin.... Really enjoyed your "history" lessen this morning (LA LA Land time - PDT), regarding the Duke. Drone footage was great. The views from the top of the hill, were really spectacular.
Cheers......
Thanks for taking us along on this adventure!
Interestingly there is another statue of the Duke of Sutherland just outside Stoke on Trent. He used to own the Trentham Estate. The monument is a significant local landmark but most people in the area now have little idea of who he was or why it was built. As such there has never been a popular call to remove it.
Happy birthday Colin for Monday.
Lovely scenic area. I think you are right, we can't change history, but we really do need to start learning from it. Great vlog. Cheers.
Love the way you explain history in the sympathetic, explaining both sides, and not judging, brilliant. The views are excellent, happy birthday for Monday 🎊🥳 Nicola 🧜🐳🌟
Great video. History, good or bad, enriches us to know where we come from and the potential of being better than our ancestors. ❤
Happy birthday for Monday Colin blessings from Queensland Australia
Another Queenslander here, Irena. Isn’t this the most wonderful channel to watch , with Colin and Shaun.
@@jackiestewart5062 definately. Always interesting.
Cool vlog. Love the narration about the local history. Also, beautiful drone footage!
Great video guys, and nice to see a balanced view of the Wee Mannie.
There's a rumour that the workers erecting the statue built it so that it faces out to sea rather than facing the land he owned, out of spite towards him.
lovely views again of your new stomping ground. Thank you for the sensible reminder about history, that we should learn from it, that we cant change it but as long as we do something positive moving forward, we can move on making the changes for the better, for everyone. thanks guys x
I love all the vids you guys put out but have missed the historical stories, enjoyed that! We do need to remember history how it was so future generations keep learning from the mistakes not repeating them!
Love your defense of history! Thanks so much for the incredible views you showed us, and for your balanced presentation of a very controversial figure.
Another delightful outing! I was intrigued by the little ponds on the hilltop.
Hello Gents after watching for such a long time I am near to where you are we were Kirkwall today and will be Invergordon tomorrow. Thanks to you we saw The Falkirk wheel and doing a cruise on the Loch Ness
Back on top form with the history lesson, keep them coming. Out takes , so funny.
Thank you! Thank you! thank you! I watched on my laptop and will watch again on the 50" TV screen later. The views and photography and videoing were so crisp and clear and breathtaking. I would have been tempted to stay the night. I bet you can touch the starts. It is hard to describe with words to say thanks I am sure I will never get to see first hand but this is as good. Happy Birthday on Monday. We will be going to the Atlantic Ocean off the coast of South Carolina, specifically, Cherry Grove, North Myrtle Beach. Because water is our calming place, as well.
From one Leo to another…..HAPPY BIRTHDAY COLIN! 🎉🎂🎁🎈🥳
Thank you for the lovely views and sharing . The end was so funny 😂 you crease me you two do . Loving it . Can’t wait for the next one lol . And happy birthday for Monday . 🎂🌼🌸🌻 have a fab day 😄
Superb vlog thank you! The scenery is beautiful - so pleased for you both and Otis of course xx
Thanks for the vlog, I always enjoy your historical tours.....thanks again.
Amazing thanks really enjoyed watching! Really nice views! Never been this far up! The monument was cool and I really like the drone footage
Have a wonderful happy birthday Colin, it's fun seeing your vlogs and it's always done in a professional way good seeing the jeep Shawn and Otis. xx
As always, so interesting & such amazing photography. Thank you!! 👌
The views in this blog are amazing! Thanks for sharing them.
You're photography is wonderful! Thanks for taking us on the hike, the views are fabulous
So heartening that this was such a balanced and compassionate piece about the Sutherland Clearances.
Happy Birthday Colin!! Thanks for the history lesson.
Happy Birthday Colin!!🎉🎊🎈🎉🎊🎈
I have been enjoying your adventures so much. I have loved your narrow boat adventures, and I am loving your new Scottish adventures. The history of the "off the beaten trek" sort of places that you and Shaun have been covering have been really interesting. I loved the train episode.
Awesome, thank you!
There’s Sean and Colin one of the best things about your channel I get to learn a little bit of history on a time i’m finding history very fascinating I do agree that the statue should be left alone to teach the future generations of what happened but also I could sympathize with the people who were displaced to me that is a very very tough conflict well thank you for listening to me have a great day and I can’t wait until the next Vlog
Brilliant vlog, we stopped at dornoch last year, amazing area, thank you for doing this I could look at this monument from the caravan decking but as you say you need to be fit to do it and I have Sean,s knees lol, great to see the statue close up keep up the good work
Thanks Colin! This was fab 💖💕
Thanks! That was beautiful and interesting!!!!
very interesting fantastic views thank you for taking me there virtually
Lovey video. Beautiful cinematography! 🔥❤️
That was BRILLIANT, Colin! Such beautiful views! I always love it when you feature the history of the places you visit. The guy "photo bombing" you at the end was hilarious! Stay well! Big hugs to you & Shaun & a big cuddle for Otis! ❤ 🐕 ❤
Colin... Excellent lesson and perspective about not erasing history. You have schooled me today. Thank you. You are an inspiration to all humankind. There are far too many "monuments" in USA that stand for the same abuse of people. Many were vandalized, and all are in controversy over the American "leaders" that held slaves and were ultimately responsible for massacres of the native americans. I don't want to see those people in monuments anywhere. Perhaps the statues should be dismembered, and their heads laid sideways on a concrete slab with a plaque that tells their story and who they tortured. They can be made into "piggy banks" where people can throw coins into wishing wells and the money can go to the modern day descendants of the oppressed.
After having a bad couple of days. Today even worse. Feeling low and emotional. It's so lovely to watch you both doing this brilliant vlogs.
Happy (early) Birthday !
YES, he should be remembered for the things he did to the people.
A Plaque on the statue base, should be affixed to tell of his actions.
It might have been better, if he had offered them shepherding jobs, if he wanted them to better themselves !
Take care, and enjoy your birthday !
Stu xx
WOW! WHAT AN AWESOME HIKE! THANK YOU COLIN, THE VIEWS ARE UNBELIEVABLE!!!
Wow, what gorgeous views! Back in my younger days I would have tried that hike. But now with my dodgy knees I'd need a lift or a tram to get to the top. Even on the easy trail. I'd have to sit with Shaun and watch. Plus, I'm not fit at all.
such a minefield of a topic, you handled it well, however, i would still pull it down, but replaced with a beacon or similar to signify the spirit of the area, and its past.
Have a fantastic Birthday Colin. Thank you for taking us on your hike.
Beautiful day for a hike! Love the views from the hilltop. Happy Birthday, Colin. Have a great year. 💖💖💖
Happy Happy Birthday!! Love your move to Scotland. Great blogs. Stay well and happy
Great video. Love learning the history and seeing the scenery.
WOW those are stunning views of the country side. Love the history lessons you provide Colin.
Hi guys can’t wait to watch this, my daughters best friend is a descendant of the Clan Sutherland, I’ve been there also. She went and lived there for a couple of years abt 11 years ago to go back to her ancestry. I’ll have to send her a link to this. Her father ( lovely man is a Sutherland) the name is here in WA. I saw you were there a couple of episodes were. There’s a village of my name nearby also. Thx guys. 💕💕🙋♀️🙋♀️
Bravo, great piece. You all are the best.