Ranking Main/Best Vocalists Of 3rd Generation Kpop Girl Groups | Who's The Best? (Unbiased)
Vložit
- čas přidán 17. 05. 2024
- 0:00 Wendy, Rosé, Jihyo, Wheein... Who's the best and why?
0:49 Lower register, low notes
4:52 Belting technique
11:27 Riffs and runs; vocal agility
14:03 Upper register; head voice, falsetto
15:43 Closing thoughts
Subtitles available!
#RedVelvet
#TWICE
#BLACKPINK
#Mamamoo - Krátké a kreslené filmy
Ranking Lead Singers Of 3rd Generation Kpop Girl Groups
czcams.com/video/UKk7pl2WF6s/video.html
You may like this one too! :)
Can you do a video of taeyeon of girls generation. Vocal analysis of her . I think she is the best vocalist and emotional singer in kpop and one of pop. Please..
Can I please have the song to 7:43 please
why wouldn’t u include yuju…
@@Mayrabonulla1975 Tears- So chan wee
@@christianernest4780 THANK YOU SO MUCH 🙏
Whee In - The legit ACE of K-pop, Vocals & Performances both included...
Ace of Kpop - I'm totally agree !
That’s why she’s my bias. Certified MooMoo since 2014
Ace!
@@randomramyeon4209 2017 and I still don't have a bias x)
@@randomramyeon4209 nice.. I've been a Moo since 2015 or 2016
Wheein just have the prettiest voice I've heard. Her voice perfectly fits in ballads and r&b which are my favorite genres
sameee
yes, I agree
She actually has a wide range
She is quite known for her techniques too
@@sadhnashirin9083 yeapp… people don’t understand that that makes you a best vocalist..
@@nameme7801 quite diplomatic Hun? I see
Don't worry
I'm convinced that wheein is the best
All my doubts are cleared
Thanks to you 😉
I'm just so proud of both Wendy and Wheein, because there was a time when ppl didn't mention them when they talked about good vocalists, and for the longest time i always only saw Yuju and Solar being talked about and they were undermined, but finally ppl with actual vocal pedagody knowledge have been coming out and giving us the facts and now people recognize them as the queens they are. The top 1 and 2 most developed vocalists of the 3rd and 4th gen. And i know many people prefer Wheein's tone which is completely fine, but Wendy's clear tone and her ability to switch it up according to the song she sings just blows me away. She's very versatile so she just takes the cake for me.
What you said is true that now people actually gaining knowledge about good vocals and as solar is my bias, yuju is now been shown some recognition for her vocal.
Before people used to talk about wendy and solar mainly, but now wheein and yuju are been recognised as well.
@@deepakbohora4972 oh I'm sorry, when i read my comment again it kinda sounds like I'm saying Solar and Yuju don't deserve the recognition, when that's definitely not the case. I actually didn't see much talk about Wendy, except among Reveluvs, and though she was recognized as one of the best, when i watched the ranking videos, they always placed her behind Yuju and Solar just b/c she wasn't belting 24/7 like they did. ppl were always like "Yuju has the best highnotes" "Solar is just the best b/c of her power belting" and this is also why Wheein was overlooked, cause she wasn't a power belter like Solar. But I'm saying that ppl with knowledge on vocal pedagody know that belting isn't everything, and there are much more other factors to consider in singing, and even then Wendy and Wheein's technique when belting is better. So yes, they are now being recognized as top 1 and 2. And unfortunately Yuju has actually regressed. All those years of constantly hitting G5s and F5s did a number on her vocal chords and now she can't even support C5, and her resonance is not present, so she's not on par with any of them at the moment, she's now around Jihyo's level, but in her prime she was above MMM members and just below Wendy. She's been making more stylistic choices recently, but she is improving her lower register, and hopefully in the future she will heal and improve her mixed and regain her resonance
me when i lie:
True
@@santuup7126 and what part of this sounds like a lie to you?
Wendy is the best 3rd Gen vocalist and MAMAMOO as a whole is best girlgroup in Vocals. My multi stan heart Twice X BP X RV X MMM
agree
Agreee
I think is the best are Red velvet and Mamamoo, Red velvet have a really good technique for singing.
Wendy is the best vocalist of the 3rd generation 💙
yesss 🥰
@@judithmonixx2245 I don't know why yall say Red Velvet are on equal with Mamamoo? 3 out of 4 Mamamoo members are main vocal material and in Red Velvet only WENDY is an amazing vocalist. Seulgi is technically weaker than Wheein and Hwasa, Joy is also weaker than Wheein and Hwasa and Irene and Yeri are literally weaker than Moonbyul who is a MAIN RAPPER so imo from which angle they are on same level with Mamamoo in vocals? it's true that Mamamoo is the BEST 3rd gen girl group in terms of vocals and in Red Velvet only Wendy is the best 3rd gen vocalist.
When you said Wheein's name I thought you were saying "Queen" haha. She's a queen though that's true
omg I was gonna say that
it's funny that you say that bc the caption says Queen when he says Wheein 😁
Queen of vocals so it must be...I mean Wheein.
Yooooooooo same here
I thought it too😳😌❤️
There's something about Wheein's voice, her voice has a healing effect but I feel pain at the same time. I don't know how to explain it, but yeah..
yess omg, i was just talking about this with some people but its like her voice in a weird but good way harmonize with itself. There is a term for it that we used in choir but i forgot. whenever people have a voice like that you can actually feel 2 emotion passing through when they sing. Wheein is definitely one of them
@@tonga1999 whoa.. that's cool
That's pretty much why she is the most preferred idol voice for ballads from her generation and her ballads always chart high on Korean charts.
bittersweet maybe? i get different feelings for different songs she sings, sometimes sweet, healing, calming, sometimes angst and pain
THISSS
I must say Mamamoo as a whole group has the best vocals. They can sing live and even when with MR removed they sound way better than the studio version.
They literally put those mr removed channels out of business
Sometimes the Mr. Remove is there so we can hear their voice without background music lol
Looking the comments make me feel touched
My baby Wheein is not overlooked/underrated anymore TT
Not on this channel!
Thank you ❤️️
Definitely not underrated anymore after the Hip era. Our greedy puppy deserves all the attention ✨
SHE DESERVES THESE LOVESS✨
She never was underrated.
Wheein is the only idol to be listed in the top 5 vocalist in SK. She really has the voice that Korea adores
do you have a link to that list? Thanks!
As she should omg her vocals are no joke I mean wow.I stopped breathing during many mamamoo performances!!!
@@joysotic488 iirc it was a 1theK list and wasn’t really accurate.
I can’t find the list but I’ve seen moos bring it up more times than I can count. 😓
Mmm? I'm sorry but if there is an idol in that top 5 it should be Ailee or even Lee Haeri (Davichi). No doubt Wheein is really good but not top 5.
I’ve listened to rose, wendy and wheein’s solo album and I just prefer wheein’s tone and style. I don’t know how to explain it, but wheein has a healing voice which brings out emotions. I support and like all of them since they’re all great.
I find that Wheeins voice and music style is easier to listen to and suits any mood I’m in
wheein have a solo album?
@@nicolaszzrlo yes!!! It was released on April 13th
@@nicolaszzrlo yes, she released her solo album, Redd
@@nobodyk8 thanks i'm gonna listen
Wheein is one of the most skilled performers in K-Pop and Wendy is the best vocalist from a K-Pop girl group imo
Wheein voice could make feel things. She's amazing
Exactly!! So many times I have gotten emotional and had goosebumps listening her 😔❤
@@justk1k049 and just watching this vid, I feel like crying just by hearing Wheein's voice.
Her anymore by jungkey snatched wigs really
@@sadhnashirin9083 ikrrr and that song was topping charts when it came out. I really like one ost she sang it's called Shadow (from yellow) her vocals in that gives me goosebumps fr. Check that song out too if you haven't !
@@justk1k049 I have checked out her whole discography
It's simply amazing
Even her guides are amazing ( I really like the rainy season guide she sang)
She's truly a gifted person
I really want a full ballad album from her 😭
Wendy has such ease in all of her registers, minimal strain.
true
Altho Wendy is clearly technically the best vocalist of the 3rd gen I have always preferred Wheein vocal tone. That girl has something unique that I can’t describe. I never get emotional when I listen to music but Wheein can move me without me knowing it.
Ohh my goshh me tooo
the girl has such a beautiful voice color rbw really hit the jackpot when they got wheein
Yess
Two jackpots - now they have Swan too.
@@ccaz7403 thats right 😂. Swan is really promising for 4th gen. Just a lil bit more of polishing. I hope rbw will continue to provide purple kiss of vocal coaching.
Wheein voice is carried with emotions and she delivers the feeling very amazingly. She has z voice I would like to listen to endlessly such a pleasing tone she has
Wendy is best vocalist and mamamoo is powerhouse vocal girlgroup of 3rd gen in SK. Rose and jihyo has a awesome and unique voice tho. No hate to other girl groups. Let's spread love
Wheein must be made of CD’s the woman is talented 😭
I go for Wheein's vocal. Her control and technique are both amazing.
Exactly her voice is insane
She can sweep the charts without promotions and that's her power
same, I have disregarded this evaluation.. Wheein is clearly better than Wendy.. She was ranked top 5 in whole Korea for a reason
@@sadhnashirin9083 do you guys even know what vocal technique means? Well I do agree that WheeIn and Wendy are kinda close but WheeIn is better in terms of live vocals..
@@nameme7801 dude I myself am a wheein biased moomoo so I'd obviously want her to be the best
But I just wanted to tell you that the rankings posted by 1thek were *top5 sweetest vocalists* 🤷 and not based on technique
@@sadhnashirin9083 But really, if you are talking about vocal techniques. Wheein is legit better than Wendy... Singing plainly is easy but the with perfect runs, upper registry and falsetto(this is what vocal techniques are), wheein is definitely better than Wendy.. In addition, Wheein knows how to control her breathing, since her vocals are for breathy she is still doing better job than Wendy.. Wendy tends to get out of breath when she's singing.. That's how you evaluate a vocal technique
Wheein, Rose and Wendy are my faves from these groups. But Wheein is overall for me best vocalist.
@Sugaシ yeah I said for me
Rosé ♥️♥️♥️
Same!!!
Same!!
who is your favourite in twice?
Jung Wheein's voice versatility is something else, she can sing whatever genre of music it is. She's just so amazingly talented. She can harmonize to anyone, she can sing any music, she's the best vocalist in korean music industry for me. Jung Wheein Ace of Kpop
Now listen wendy from psycho-zimzalabim(bridge)-butterflies
My ace of kpop wheein
SM rarely let Red Velvet perform their bsides, unless in their solo concert. If you listen to them, you'll know Wendy's agility is also out of this world
agreed!
yes...to me wendy still has better agility than wheein although its nothing too gresat
Up
exactly!! Wendy and Wheein are the QUEENS of vocal, plsss
True
Wendy and Wheein is on another level👑
I love Wheein's voice. It's one of my favorite kpop voices. Mamamoo Vocal Queens
i know wendy has the best technique but i adore wheein’s voice, the airiness of it, it’s so moving. i’m moved by anything she sings.
You read my mind
Bestie, i really don’t think she has the best techniques… Best is when you are special and no one could copy your vocal techniques.. Wendy’s techniques are plain to be honest, WheeIn has more colour into her voice and her vocal techniques such as her runs are one of the best in the industry which no ones can copy.. I bet Wendy can’t copy those techniques of her
totally agreed! Wheein’s voice is so honey thick but light and air-ey. It is so soothing and relaxing to listen to :’)
@@johnyap1508 Techniques are just techniques, the creator of the video wasn’t trying to say that WheeIn is a worser vocalist as compared to Wendy, he’s just stating that Wendy has better technique. Technique isn’t something that is plain or not, it’s just technique. Technique is meant to help in better projections, better support, etc. Technique is learnt, anyone can learn it, and of course, anyone can copy it. It’s like mathematics - with enough practice, anyone can learn to properly apply the rules of math and be able to solve more complicated math problems. Similarly, vocal technique just helps the vocalist better apply, in order to enhance the voice, i.e. better control, better support and better breathing. vocal technique and vocal colour are separate. I personally prefer WheeIn’s vocal colour, but as a trained vocalist myself, I will have to admit that Wendy does have just slightly better vocal technique. As for vocal WheeIn’s vocal runs, anyone with good technique can sing the same way, in fact, anyone with enough practice can imitate the notes produced, what cannot be copied by most is vocal colour. But vocal actors are very good at mimicking vocal colour. A good example of this is Chuther (check her out on youtube, she’s quite impressive), she has mimicked Mamamoo’s voices if you’d like to check that out.
But yes, I hope you get what I’m trying to explain:)
@@ally2009 sorry too long, I didn’t read.. 🥲
what I like about wheein is even I don't understand the lyrics I can still get emotional by her voice ❤
Solar of mamamoo was right when she was once asked who's her favorite 3 vocalists and one of them is Wendy
It would be funny and sweet if Solar said that Wheein was one of her 3 favorite vocalists and Wheein heard that.
@@brianlittrell797 lol I think wheein knows she will alway be part of solar's angel line in her heart
Who are the other two that she named?
@@natemm9385 I'm also curious to know who are the other two favorite vocalists that Solar named as her favorites.
@@brianlittrell797 the other one I can't recall her name but the third one also can't recall her name but I think she's from a group called apink and she's the leader or the eldest of that group
Wendy's voice is very relaxing and soft while you can mostly feel pain when listening Wheein. Both are very soulful voices. I just love Wheeinnie's vocal tone more. But that could be because I listen her more than Wendy though. No suprise those 2 are the top. I wish we get a duet.
Wendy sounds so relaxed on every note in her mixed voice.
All are good on their own tone or style but.........
Wheein and Wendy hands down. But I listen to Wheein more. Her voice is like the gates of heaven. I love how she uses her voice like an instrument. High low silky/honey smooth. I have earganisms listening to her. I can listen to her all day. I literally had Butterfly on replay on the way home from work this morning. Just beautiful.
Wendy has a heavenly falsetto imo, you should listen to Psycho, she sounded like an angel singing but, I believe in Wendy and Wheein supremacy
Wheein's technique is what sets her apart from other vocalists in her generation and the entire kpop industry. She is an all-rounder, not to mention that she can hit notes flawlessly while dancing and at the same time hyping the crowd.
"Once you WheeIN you can't WheeOUT."
Wendy is the best vocalist of her generation for a reason.
WOW WHEEIN´S VOICE IS ANGELICAL
okay ik you had to choose but it's so painful to limit Mamamoo's "main vocal" with Wheein😭
Between Solar & Wheein I think Wheein was the best choice because between all the member she have the most healthy and the best technique, meanwhile Solar have a powerful voice but her technique is not good as Wheein’s
@@user-ib2gq9wp6e yes true but Solar and Hwasa are both better than Jihyo so they still deserved. But to choose only one from mmm yeah Wheein was the right choice (but that said if he chose solar/hwasa the ranking wouldn't be different), but still
@@andrea-kg6pg I mean it's true mamamoo is a group composed of ABSOLUTE vocal queens, but it wouldn't be fair to the others if you add the other members of MMM because this is a 1 on 1 on 1 on 1 vocal analysis, obviously you have to choose one in Mamamoo's three vocalists. But I absolutely agree that all Solar, Hwasa, and Wheein are fit to being main vocalists, heck maybe even Moonbyul can be a main vocal if she was showcased and trained to sing more cause she has a great tone.
Totally agree with you, and I have to say Hwasa and Solar are even better than Jihyo and Rose...
@@Neo-od9uw Byul said once that her vocal coach thought that she was going the be the Main Vocalist when they were still trainees, if it wasn’t for RBW changing her position she would be capable to show more, but at least Byul is now confident with her singing. Mamamoo is really a group formed only by Main Vocalist
Wheein 👸
Her riffs and runs are
✨ out of this world ✨
Wendy best vocalist in 3rd gen
Mamamoo best vocal gg in 3rd gen
In my opinion, Wheein has the healthiest lower register in kpop her control is amazing .Checkout butterfly her vocally charge bside her low notes is just chefs kiss. She also has the best falsetto in the world the girl is insane for effortlessly transitioning from her real voice to head voice followed by her gorgeous falsetto and literally ended it with that agile C6 high note. And for agility? why are yall contradicting in the comments lmao girlie literally hit those high notes while jumping she never misses those notes yep jung wheein trained like a fucking military.
they're allowed to share their opinions, the people who commented about the agility, gave their explanation and most of them are content creators who also have knowledge on vocal pedagody and know more about Wendy than mr. no other fan. Also, on the Mamamoo video he made, Wheein topped every category except head voice, in which he placed Hwasa on top, but ppl in the comments were sharing their opinions that they think Wheein should top that category as well, so what's wrong with that?
@@chrissyalapo-calg9748 you're literally everywhere go plow some grass
@@toothlessnoteeth6549 thanks for the advice ;)
It's such a shame they didn't include videos of Wheein's whistle note and dolphin voice on WooHoo
And her live high note on anymore when they changed the notes to 2 range higher on the spot 😞
Agreeee Butterfly is such a beautiful song and especially listening to the live version she did without G.Soul I cried on how well she did his part not even exaggerating I was literally tearing up listening that "Now I'll forget you " line OMG her voice holds so much feels. Also the Falsetto part I would've given it too Wheein too it's more smoother and softer also when she does it while harmonising with members it just blends so perfectly. Her voice is what plays at heaven's gates ❤😔
Wendy is the better vocalist, but wheein is able to tell a story with her voice and moved you to tears
And Wheein's dancing is awesome. And such a beautiful face too.
well Wendy's singing has that effect too, i know you made this comment without listening to Wendy's ballads
Exactly why I like her voice it is embraced by emotions and much rawness like it is talking to ur soul
Wendy tell's a story as well.
Exactly wheein's voice is so unique
I just like Wheein's voice, delivery, and technique best tbh. I have never heard somebody sing like she does, it can't be replicated.
For me, THE ACE OF K-POP
JUNG WHEEIN..
She has that uniqueness,emotional touch as well as duality in her voice which captivates us
Wheein's tone, her versatility and her overall stability make her one of the best vocalists in Korea not only kpop. There is a reason she was the only idol listed in the top 5 female vocalists in Korea. Wendy is a very technically amazing singer. This video made me appreciate her vocals more since I'd never really paid attention before. She is really good. Although my heart still lies with wheein, her voice is just next level and can bring anyone to tears.
I firmly believe that Wendy is the best, objectively. But Wheein's singing will always be my favorite... Every time she sings she moves my heart to the core
for me wendy can be the best belter along with taeyeon from SM and wheein got really unique voice in kpop
I always prefer wheein's vocal tone. I dont know how can ı describe but she has a different aura at her voice which includes so many emotions.Her voice suits any type of songs well.
Sana katılıyorum Wheein herşeyde iyi dans,rap,vokal,resim, okçuluk, işaret dili, görsel zekâsı yüksek ezberi kuvvetli . Hatta bir video var Wheein neden Kpop'un Acesi diye
That clip of Wheein with her runs in Queendom is absolutely magical
red velvet was actually the first kpop group i ever got into and it was bc of wendy; her part in psycho just blew me away and after getting more into the group, i really appreciated her skills.
her well-rounded ness makes her the best in my opinion
Sameee
yes. bcs of psycho song, now I'm a part of reveluvs :)
Also their bsides... wendy 💙
Same tho
her G5 in psycho is so etherial
Wendy and Wheein are both absolutely amazing vocalists but there is just something about Wheein in particular. Her voice is just so mature but at the same time so angelic and smooth. It sounds unreal and heavenly :))) all members of MAMAMOO and Wendy for sure are my fav vocalists of the 3rd gen. HANDS DOWN. PERIOD
Wheein for the win..Wheein is the ace of kpop by the way
i mean theres a reason why people call wendy "the finest vocalist of the 3rd gen"!
I already knew who would win. But it was good to hear more from Jihyo, as I'm not a Twice enthuasist and I don't know much from them
As a ONCE, thanks! But he didn't mention about Jihyo's connected HEAD VOICE up to the Bb5 in I Can't Stop Me and I'm kinda unsatisfied haha
@@jeongzz3817 Yeah. Jihyo most likely to win over Rosé on upper register too lol since she actually showcase that she can connected with her head voices.
the wendy stans wil always trynna make jihyo look bad but she has actually a good voice
@@santialmeida3148 More like every Kpop Stans ever lol. People are underestimate Twice vocal line way too much even tho they are pretty decent for Kpop standard and there are a much worse vocalists than them…
@@santialmeida3148 Jihyo is average compared to Wendy. Especially when you are used to the agility of Wendy's voice, Jihyo's messy runs don't cut it e.g the 'oh yeah' at 11:31. I'm saying this as a Little Mix fan, who dabbles in kpop.
Although my personal choice is Wheein's voice, I fully appreciate Wendy's capabilities ☺️ This list is the most accurate I have ever seen! Well done 😁 Watch mamamoo's latest MV everyone ☺️ #WAWbyMamamoo
Mamamoo is a group with amazing singers. Their live technich es out of this world.
We know Wendy's the best girl group vocalist in 3rd generation of kpop. She all rounded, she definitely knows her instrument and how to utilize it. The way she projects a note, belt, head voice, is all very technical.
I knew Wendy was going to win because this discussion has been had a billion times already. I just ultimately prefer Wheein because she's a better performer and her voice is better utilized in the songs she's given in group activities. Wendy is just okay in K-Pop and I think she would do better in several other genres. There are a lot of idols who would really shine in other genres or even just doing a different concept. Like, I enjoyed IZONE's Nako in the group but she would do really well in Babymetal, as Suzuka's voice has changed a bit since reaching adulthood and the group could use a new infusion of vocal sweetness.
This is based on vocal technique tho . Doesnt matter what songs they sing lol
I love Su metal's voice now
@@dandelion6403 Su's mature voice is my favorite rock vocals currently. 🥰 I'm so happy she hasn't been forced to sound the same as she did when she was 14.
@@ReapTheWhirlwind Oh god, I can't imagine 20y/o babymetal songs sang in their 12 y/o voices. 😳 I bet that would be creepy.
Saying 'wendy is just okay'?? Wow. Clearly ypu are being biased. You don't know how wnedy performs because you are a moomoo.
Wheein ace of kpop 💚💚
If anyone wants a chill album to listen to with heavenly vocals I highly recommend checking out Redd by Wheein. I promise you won't be disappointed
ofcourse WHEEIN , MAMAMOO is the queen voice of GG idol.
Wendy's voice brought me to kpop. After I heard her singing Jessie j's "Who you are", I was instantly sold. Before I realized it, my tears were falling. The way she sings bring comfort for me.
My ranking: Wheein, Wheein, WHEEIN, WHEEIN
1.WHEEIN ALWAYS WHEEIN! QUEEN WHEEIN!!!!!!
Wendy is the best for me!!! She is freaking multitalented. Respect her so much💙💙💙
Yeah... I still go crazy about Wheeins voice. That girl has soul. Its just amazing how her voice sets the tone in the room. Its just so pleasant.
I agree for the most parts but I definitely disagree the agility aspect, Wendy should be the first if u heard more of their bsides in RV you’ll know. And I’m abit sad you didn’t add clips from her solo live performances, esp the one she performed why can’t you just love me with live band. But overall good content, keep it up!
tru..the why cant u stop me runs were divine
@@johnlloydquitain8116 ur too quick to call him biasef watch ur mouth there
Umm no Wendy have hit or miss moments more than wheein
Yes
@@keedababy7872 PREACH🙌🙌
Wendy's voice is the definition of perfection to me. I love her.
personally, jihyo and wheein are two of my favorite kpop vocalists. although i definitely can admit that wendy is more technically skilled than jihyo, as well as (arguably) wheein, and wendy's vocals are absolutely immaculate like that girl is seriously on another level. but there's just something about wheein and jihyo's vocals that just draws me in, their tones are so pleasing to me lmao
💖
Wendy's lower notes are better and warmer than Jihyo's despite Jihyo having the 'richer' tone. Also, Jihyo's rich tone goes away when she does high notes and it sounds a bit shrill. Wheein's rich tone is consistent.
@@hsnrb9959 i never denied that wendy had better technique than jihyo??? i literally know, i just said that i prefer jihyo’s voice lmao
@@queen.captain.crunch I was more talking about tone, not technique. Because usually the standout point about Jihyo's vocie is her tone, but it's not that consistent or strong, especially in early cute Twice songs. However, Wheein who has a darker/richer tone also, is consistent with her tone.
And Wendy who known for having a brighter or even boring tone can still get a richer and nicer tone than Jihyo with her low notes. She can change her tone from bright to dark much better than Jihyo can adapt her darker tone to bright songs - she ends up sounding shrill and losing her uniqueness, because her tone is not that strong to begin with
@@hsnrb9959 okay but i still prefer jihyo’s tone. that’s my own personal preference and opinion. it’s subjective. so i don’t really know why you’re trying to argue but sure
Like Solar mentioned before Wheein has a healing voice and Solar said even though her own voice is appreciated and called powerful she has always adored Wheein's voice saying it makes the listener feel emotions more.
Wendy is one of kpop's most agile idols these days, only that part I disagree with
Oh no honey, her runs are not good. I still remember her horrible Shake That Bass runs. Wheein is definitely better in this area..
@@laramiaizz like all people in the world she has bad days, but it doesnt mean that she is like that all the time, and she was in the beggining of her career and was very nervous as she said sometime ago. I can see that u dont know her music and song, cause if you knew you wouldn't say that, you can check another great analysys of her in the site kpopvocalanalysis.net, they are teachers and guarantee her runs and riffs skills, like they said, she is not perfect and have some pitch issues time to time, but she is one of the most agile idols in industry
@@Natasha_bazooca_mommy I think she can improve tho, she's an amazing Vocalist, she just needs to challenge her vocal agility more and she'll be super untouchable
@@youtubeisntallowingmetocom9062 agreed, even having some good runs in some bsides, she needs more challenges
@@laramiaizz looool Shake that Brass was like 6 yrs ago of course she improved, have you listened to her album? the agilities on Why Can't You Love Me issa proof
Wheein just have the most beautiful voice I've ever heard among international and korean singers
I opened this video already knowing that wendy and wheein would be at the top, they are amazing in the vocal aspect, nobody can beat them
Wheein's voice is just flawless. Her voice suits all genres, she's the ACE!
Bout Wheein’s low register check her LIVE version of her song Butterfly you’ll be amaze. Everyone Wheein’s the Ace of K-Pop
I really want to see Wendy in broadway or musical kind of performances. For me, shes a very versatile singer that really can fit into any genre. Hope to see her more in solo projects especially musical gigs.
Wheein can do whatever she wants with her voice and it sounds amazing. She's so unique.
Wheein is known for being versatile
Whenever vocal tone and technique is talked about, she can never be missed
Her range is insane really!!
Wheein's voice melt your heart ears all. She's just so amazing her skills are in another level
I believe Wheein is an angel in her past life.
i can listen to wheeins vocals all day and not get tired, she is just a very clever vocalist. all these vocalists are just very unique and its hard to rank them i just feel like everyone would go with what they like the most which is the most reasonable way to rank them
Jihyo got so much potential. If she ever go solo, I might give her a chance (I just start listen to Twice so I don't really know much about them individually yet)
Wheein is my all time favourite vocalist
Jihyo is full of potential,but many years of hate and underestimation made her become unsecure and her singing got affected a bit
@@justaboy343 oh. I feel so bad for her ☹️. I really hope to see more of her one day.
@@nekocloud25 she's getting better on the early months, she just needs a fan presence to feel secure
Jihyo's run at 2:32 during the 'oh yeah' was messy af. For 10 years training, and 5 years after debut, I wouldn't expect such a sloppy run. It seems like JYP's vocal training is lacking, and idols should continue with vocal lessons even after debut. Her tone is unique which is why lots of us see potential in her, but after all this time idk
@@justaboy343 no, it's a lack of continued vocal lessons after debut. The 'pre debut' training period isn't enough, especially for JYP singers. Perhaps Twice being overworked, JYP put post- debut vocal lessons on the back-burner
Wheein has cute and innocent face but her voice is beyond your expectation
Wendy might be superior in techniques.But wheein is an ace.she is in another level.but they both are really talented
It's a crime that blackpink is that popular whilst having the less talent.
i'm so proud of wheein, she's the unique of the list that isn't from big3, rbw have really good vocalists, all mamamoo is talented and have unique and perfect vocals, they are the best
No debate. Wendy is the best vocalist in 3rd generation 👑
But the rest of them also good 👍🏼
OMG Jihyo's solo singing clips are rare and from few years ago I hope we can see her shine through her vocals more..I really want Jihyo to sing Jazz I thing this the best for her in my opinion...
Twice has rare solo vocal performances..I wish they would send Jihyo, Nayeon & Jeongyeon to competitions like Immortal Songs or any singing shows like The Call etc..
Check out her Melody project from a year ago, her voice brought tears to my eyes. (Don't get it confused with her performance project from a few weeks ago though)
I know that it will be always Wendy and Wheein in the First and Second ranking. I really like Wendy’s technicality but I cannot discredit that Wheein is a close second- damn her vocal color. The friendship between these two groups are superb. 🥰
WHEE IN my baby, i love your voice, is so so so sweet and calm
Put them all on a stage tho and wheein eating them all up ngl
If they're perform with 3 member of mamamoo,
Stop trying to set her up by diminishing the others
@@mindovermatter4785 yess🙌
Nah if they're alone, Wendy eats them up alive, put the entire Mamamoo on the stage and they'd be eating them alive
So basically:
1 wendy-no surprise she's an almost perfect vocalist minus the runs/agility but still above avarge, most powerful and versatile
2-powerful but stylistically softer then wendy, great control with runs/agility (the only thing Wendy doesn't excel at)
3-not as powerful but still a very full voice can fall under the slightly above average tier
4-rosè very unique and stylistic, she's a tonal singer, technic falls under the average tier for a main vocalist but she's still very good
Wendy’s agility is still pretty decent, I’d honestly say that they are slightly better than Wheein’s but thats up to discussion.
Wendy only has some issues when she’s in her mix, Wheein has some issues with the jaw but i’d say even w/ that she’s still amazing
Hoho, wendy's riffs and runs ARE the best in kpop and has always been greatly commended by professional singers, locally and international. Just listen to her album. Her songs are FULL of complicated techniques.
@@onikukamisama3063 lol best riffer in KPop is definitely Ailee Wendy isn't even better than wheein in this area
@@badbada3003 the fact that you feel the need to reply to every comment that says Wendy's agility is better, shows that you're insecure and biased.
@@chrissyalapo-calg9748 what's wrong with that? Pls explain the vocal fact to me instead of accusing people for being biased
It's funny that everyone agrees that Wendy is technically but everyone prefer Wheein. I prefer Wheein's voice and technique because it's closer to human realm.
I prefer Wendy😊
@@chrissyalapo-calg9748 Chrissy are you not tired of camping under Wheein comments? This is obsessive behavior
@@mindovermatter4785 I’m allowed to share my opinion thank you very much😊I only replied b/c they said “everyone prefer Wheein” when that’s not true, there are others who prefer Wendy, like me. And again I’ve literally only replied to 2 or 3 comments. Nothing against Wheein at all, I think she’s a wonderful vocalist and dancer, and I have not said anything bad about her even once. This comment section is obviously full of Moomoos but I’m repping Luvies.
@@chrissyalapo-calg9748 I can see that.She have a clear voice and I'm Wendy biased btw so I'm here for you.
@@chrissyalapo-calg9748 uhmm maybe because the comment meant to compliment wheein? Everyone has their own opinion you don't have to debunked just because he or she mentioned the term "everyone". Hyperbole exists
Wendy is amazing but Wheein will forever be my favorite vocalist 🥺 (it's subjective ofc)
(from what I heard) Wheein is the one with best technique in Mamamoo, even if Solar always get the spotlight, she gives her 200% and tends to push a lot of times... So Wheein has the healthiest technique
Still Jung Wheein Ace Of Kpop, how versatile her vocal, soft, breathy but she can control it so perfect, and wide support vocal range until her whistle is so on pitch, her tone is good for any genres, her control is great, her vocal is stable even she's dancing with perfect, presicion, and detailed dancing, thats so amazing, and she can belt and do the whistle without moving her neck, so her healthy voice is support her range even higher, her falsetto oh god, shes perfect. She can play drum, piano, she is lyricist, composers, choreographer of some of mmm song, how multitalented she is! ACE OF KPOP INDEED!
You forgot about Mc ddak 😂
@@edev6070 lmaoo, mc dduk and ddak legend😂
Wendy and Wheein can really sing from those 4! No hate to other 2...✌️
13:19 If Wheein can melt AOA Jimin's heart of ice, then she is one of the best singers the Kpop industry has ever seen
lmao
Literally 😂😂
Jajajaja not wrong there
Here I am laughing at 1.39 am
Wendy sing high notes effortlessly 😳
I agree with the other comments except wendy's agility. DANG, HAVEN'T YOU HEARD HER ALBUM? Her agility in why cant you love me and when this rain falls are the smoothest, most clean runs and fast i've ever heard in kpop. You can't underestimate her agility.
I believe the video maker was basing on live performances, not studio polished recordings. It's pretty easy to tell that vocal agility is not her forte (well, none of these singers are).
@@poetryrunsdry she sang it live with a live band and during her insta live and nailed all her runs, it's obvious that he didn't check out her solo work yet, after all, he did just start getting into RV and in this list, Wendy is the only one who is semi-agile, the others are below her
In summary:
1. Wendy (Red Velvet)
2. Wheein (Mamamoo)
3. Jihyo (Twice)
4. Rosé (Blackpink)
@So supporting BLACKPINK means being toxic nowadays Rosé is the “weakest” between those 4 vocalist and everyone knows that. That doesn’t mean that she’s a bad vocalist
@Lovely Rosé is just not a good vocalist.
@Lovely♡ just gotta accept facts
@♡BLACKPINK will never be in my area♡ bruh rose is a good vocalist, it wasnt even a hate comment lol
I never said she sucks
@♡BLACKPINK will never be in my area♡ she supports quite an octave though the support quality isnt that full, her nasality is reduced around A4 area, she has showed a connected head voice, there are improvements since debut
If not talking about it that much she has a nice vocal tone
I'd say Wendy is the best 3rd gen gg vocalist but Mamamoo definitely has the best 3rd gen vocal line. Wheein, Solar and Hwasa together are better vocalists than Wendy, Seulgi and Joy together.
As a Reveluv I agree
I agree..Mamamoo even has better vocal line than TTS but ofc Taeyeon is the best individual vocalist out of them..
yess!!! and i think dreamcatcher too, i barely see their vocal line being recognized
sadly they are always left in 3rd gen groups when they actually are 3rd gen group :(
@@luzbiz9668 it's probably because they only have 1 good vocalist, as far as I know
@@MarcosVinicius-zz8pv thats siyeon!
but the lead vocal, yoohyeon, has a little mix cover (secret love song) and she did amazing!
she has good lows and belts, her runs and falsetto are so good :)
Most of the comments keep saying that Wendy is technically better because of her technique but y’all don’t know how emotional and soulful her voice is. She shows great emotion and damn I’ve cried listening to her sing . It’s not just her technique ability that makes her so great it’s the power in her sound and expression combined that make her THE best.
I agree. She is the first kpop soloist I just keep listening to. I love Wheein and she is amazing, but Wendy really gets me everytime.
Oh I agree. Like Water makes me tear up everytime I listen to it.
exactly! man, wendy's voice is like that soulful singer who punch you with their voices right in your face! it's excites the audiences!
at least that's what im getting from Huff n Puff by rv! 😅 'Knock Knock Baby!!'
not to mention her ballad songs from Like Water album! one of the examples, The Road, it's just SO GOOD. the fact that she's able to deliver with storytelling-like, although, she's not the one who wrote the lyrics, says alot about her soulful singing!
People haven't heard the covers she did on sketchbook then😌
@@fairy6245 I agree!!! 100!!
Just because Rosé and Jihyo aren't strong vocalist as Wendy it doesn't nesserily mean they're bad vocalists y'all. They're all main vocalists for reason. Love all of them, extremely talented ❤️
lmao yes, jihyo is almost a above avarage vocalist since she starts support C5
@@slaypa I'm laughing so hard when I see that people are telling that Jihyo and Rosé are 'jokes' next to Wendy. Wendy is a goddess, but both Jihyo and Rosé are great vocalist and no one should deny that.
@@AB-yk2pq i mean both of them is still a great vocalist rather than most of main vocals on 4th gen
@@slaypa I feel like 4th generation is already mess....
@@slaypa I don't have any knowledge about singing technice but I saw many opinions that there are only few 4th gen vocalist who are average/above average, and no actually good vocalist. Is that true? D: