COMMANDOs VS NDUs
Vložit
- čas přidán 1. 08. 2024
- We got a hold of 3 ex-NDUs and Commandos in the ultimate physical challenge to find out once and for all who truly is the most elite of the elite!
Which team are YOU on?
#ForHonourAndGlory or #NothingStandsInOurWay?
Watch more to find out who truly is the BEST OF THE BEST!
Huge thanks to Onyx MMA for sponsoring the location!
Commandos
Timothy
Jess: jxphxel_
Si Kang: apple.paii
NDUs
Chance: webbchancealexander
Ryan: ryanrllee
Luther: pereiraluther
next video asa vs storeman
Lmao 😂😂 ya
Lol I think asa get to be in air con more than store man, stores usually not air coned
Neither of them will show up bro, half MC half medical appointment
@@RukiaHayashi huahahaaaa
RSO, IMH, 3 months mc, pes f
In a nutshell, one sneaks from the jungle to fight the enemy and the other sneaks from the sea to fight the enemy
Both suck
@@wzh7726 lol, says the person who knows nothing. I doubt you can even survive the qualification test.
Actually not quite. These days the lines are somewhat blurred. Both units are trained in unconventional warfare and they both can be inserted through land/air/sea. There are many CDOs with diver badge and some are also US SEALs trained, NDUs have many people with airborne badges too (including SEALs badge). A simple display from both units on their uniform are the "typical" 3 badge, Airborne, FreeFall and Diver.
CDOs just spend more time on land while NDUs spend more time in sea for their usual training. If there is a ship you want your troops to check on, you would usually send NDUs in, since they are "closer" or have ships, etc ready. While if it's a building, you might send in CDOs with Heli rappel. Though it can also be a joint ops, since they are all trained in it.
@@DragonX2X7 lmao, piece of cake for me
@@wzh7726 Do you even know the physical requirements? If it's so easy, why aren't you in the military?
The first ndu guy has good banter LOL
I like the term used by ndu, never show our strength with ppl around but keep in tight as long as focus is beyond 100% on the next best course of action and see the other people view inside out, from any level..so that that will be the beacon in any situation.
The last challenge is really dangerous lol
Thanks for the Laughs
Rescue.. Padi
"Auntie look at yall, peoples girlfriend lookg at us" that caught me off guard
Both Elite Forces Be it Commando or Naval Diving Unit choose The top cream of the Crop.
The guy in the first part in the ndu side yea why is his leg half grey?
so which one is more respectable ?
A guardsmen here, as the top 3 most difficult in the saf glad to know even armor is more famous than us
i suggest their navy beret add a red stripe across maybe at the tip to show that they are the sea COMMANDOs
Aiya, 1 of the earliest NDU= Col How; is both Naval Diver n Airborne and also a medical doctor, in charge of NDU Medical Centre in Sembawang Camp.
SOC vs ProCom next
Next up challenge between kopitiam cook versus restaurant cook, hehehe
Wheres my Guardsmen at!
Important to keep focus on even small bit of details when others can't see it with the naked eyes..no matter commando or ndu, to be both has the met the target but it also depends on what situation you are in, at times, many of us takes little things for granted, n one more thing, treasure health to the max, n put it to good use.0
I can’t begin to describe my envy & jealousy now lol
Medics versus Signaller …
All Must still pass BMT and After that POP posted to the Units.
Where is SOF and the police STAR (SWAT) . Aren't they elite as well ?
SCDF vs police
27th June 2021
Why not just make NDU beret red as well? Then no need to fight anymore right? But as for Guards...
Different operations mainly and NDUs are under Navy. They however have joints ops stuff.
why ndu no malay?
Don't call us the NDUs man. NDU stands for Naval diving unit. Naval Divers are not refered to as Naval Diving unitS
Haha no need compare la, logistics is still the best. Look at the Ukraine war, Russian army so strong kena bogged down by logistical issues cannot advance properly. There is a saying " soldier win battle, logistics win war" and "“amateurs talk about tactics, but professionals study logistics.”
soc vs procom next
(ex-ProCom NSF here) I second this!! But tbh SOC confirm have the edge. Procom 's training is mentally and physically tough, but SOC is on another level. Just from our route march which is at most 12KM, SOC's is way longer
Imagine basing your identity off two years of conscription even after ORD omegalul
The extras are support units. Redundant and waste of resources.
Don't need to fight. Toughest are scdf. Everyday need to save people from real fire and accidents. Those are true and proven warriors. Commando and ndu has the rights to talk only after going through wars.
when the last time they went to war or real life situation? We fire fighters everyday deal with accidents.
The SCDF may not be able to successfully complete the Commandos and Naval Diving Unit courses. Engaging in real life saving only on a daily basis does not necessarily make one tougher than individuals who have undergone specialized training in an elite unit. The Special Operations Force has demonstrated its capabilities through events such as the 1991 SQ hijacking. While few of my friends from the SCDF have shared their training with me, their training is not even 20% as demanding as what our unit endures . They have also acknowledged their inability to handle the rigorous courses offered by the NDU or Commandos
End up also never really do real ops unlike spf and scdf. Lol
Not necessary to do la for elite force. Ops for them usually overseas one sg like playground for them ntg serious to the point need engage the elite forces
SQ117 Highjack case proves a point. Before that real ops, the elites didn't have any "real ops" too but they perform very well in the highjack case. IIRC, it was done and dusted in 30sec, to the point that US SF got in contact with them to learn.
That is what the trainings and exercises are for, don't forget our troops regularly train with other counterparts from overseas, some of which have done real ops.
SPF and SCDF, "ops" are quite different too, akin to comparing apples to oranges. Closest maybe SPF's SOC to CDOs?
@@shiokfalafhel5709 i mean you’re comparing elite SAF and navy units to regular SCDF and SPF units 😂, and yet they still do much more in the real world. SOC and CDO are probably similar, train here train there, go overseas train but rarely given the chance to do anythg which is good. it shld stay that way
@@DragonX2X7 the sq hijacking were singapores actual special forces, and i really doubt us sf wanted to learn seeing that all 4 men were high on drugs and only had knives
@@j.l.s6574 Yea I knew those forces were from the SOF, in fact that hijack case happened before they were being officially recognized by the SG Gov. My point being, the training would have been as realistic as possible before being involved in the actual ops. The SOF troopers proved that point when they were called into action with that hijack case.
So far I have yet to read any reports of those hijackers being "high on drugs", however with the intelligence gathered, SOFs knew they were armed with knives, etc but could NOT confirm if there were any other weapons hidden, etc. They could have hide 9mm pistols, etc, it's not that hard to hide them if they wanted to.
The US SF invited SOF due to them securing the whole aircraft in 30 seconds. Speed and efficiency was part of them many reasons they (SOF) were invited over to share.
I feel for the owner in a way. I also was a softie and maybe still am. I understand her feelings but what hurts me more is how people used this soft
Ndu malays can join ?
cannot cause no halal kitchen
Ka kui kui tan dua lui?! 😅😅😅
just join the kengmando
Eh Onyx
Guardman also elite infantry
Guardman also elite
The Elite Special Forces of the United States 🇺🇸 Military such as Delta force or Naval Seale combined is a hood Example.
The nowadays "Commandos" are not so tough as the old days 70s to Mid 80s Commandos la. The last batch of commandos that have to run the 10 Km with battle order is 2nd Coy during their BCT and pass out with Red Berets.
Aiya no need compare lah...
Wow they are all good lookin
but would be crying if they trained with indonesian or atleast malaysian commandos 🤣🤓
@@patriot4786 Kampong boy , you are extremely naive ! Have you went through Singapore COMMANDOS , NDU , SOF or SOTF training or why do know that they will cry training with Indonesia or Malaysia kampong's commandos ? Singapore's soldiers repeatedly came up top in US RANGER ,NAVY SEALS and SAS courses , you sure Indo and Mala kampong's villagers better than them ? I am sure you never even went through army training at all , just merely a keyboard's general and military expert ! 😄😄😄😄😄
@@user-wc4jr2op8b those "kampung" commandoes are far lot tougher than these singaporean commandoes who undergo training in the city and swim with lifevests 🤣🤣.. and its only in singapore where u find commandoes whith geeky glasses 🤓🤣.
@@patriot4786 Again I have to say you are extremely naive! You don't seemed to know Singapore's train soldiers in different continents including Taiwan, Thailand, Brunei, Australia, America etc ? Trainees swim with life vests that's the proper training procedure adopted worldwide, anything wrong ! Commandos cannot wear glasses? Don't you know even fighter pilots and US SPECIAL FORCES do wear glasses ? You are just wasting my time childish little boy 👦!
@@patriot4786 lmao. Do you even know any real life Indo/Msia CDOs? Have you talked to them before and they told you from first hand experience. ASEAN have many combine exercises and some of the Singapore NSFs are involved too. IF ANY of Singapore's NSFs ARE crying, we would have heard it by now as some of these exercises are heavily covered by public media.
If your country cannot even handle COVID19 properly, let alone in a war time situation where things/buildings/etc are breaking down every moment. In peace time, most of the resources are available, in war time, not so much. Even with most of the resources available, if you can't do a decent job, how are you expected to do any better when half of those resources are unavailable (during war time).
Why is "crying" the first thing that come into your mind? Is it cause that's what you'll do when you train with Indon/Msia CDOs?
KIDS talking
my brother is in navy and he will protect singapore
Don't fight guys, air force commandos the best
Where the malay man at? F i malay
Dart > them 🤣
Real ops vs cosplaying
Different operations. Specialize in different skills. Have you personally been through any of those trainings? A good example would be Rappelling, since they are all trained in it. Don't think there are any competition in rappelling that are DARTs vs CDOs vs NDUs, etc.
When shit hits the fan, they called in the "cosplayers" (Singapore Cable car incident for example). Another incident I've heard was someone(s) illegal (from overseas and might be armed) hiding in Pulau Tekong (of all places he or they chose to hide), SPFs was activated for the search and soon after the army (heard very little information about it, wasn't sure if it was 1 person or few people). After 4 (?) days of coming up empty, rumors were that Commandos (CDOs) might get activated soon to assist in the search. I'm sure if CDOs are activated, some of them would be the NSFs batch (NSFs are more than trained to be able to handle that level of threat). Well things got settled before the CDOs got activated, so I guess the "cosplayers" weren't needed.
Main idea: different skills, different experts. When your car stops working, you don't go to a hospital looking for a doctor to fix your car (while some Doc do know the basics) and vice versa, you don't go to your car mechanic when you are very sick.
I guess you are one of those without military training, acting like they know better.
Eh where the malay?
There are, few though. Personally met at least 2, read about another 1 and saw 1 in one of those NS videos.
Where ah?
The ego overflowing from some of these guys is quite nasty but entertaining I guess.
Wanna join Indian military someday
Taliban better
@@rudrakshpillai4836 karle ja join
No we don't want
@Kasish Savitha cuz of the gurkhas from nepal, a special breed of soldiers that fight so well, due to their insane oxygen capacity for endurance from staying in mountains, that if other countries fight them, they come from the sky with their rifles and kukris able to slash shoot and kill every single enemy to the death
Lol
The ndu tattoo guy trash talk so much. But he like the weakest of all 6 LOL
Tattoo add extra stats
That tattoo guy has something to hide(inside his little self-confidence) of him
@@119aaron Hmmm so are you saying Special Forces (SF) around the world all have something to hide? Tattoos are fairly common in the SF community (military as a general too). There are some tattoos that the moment certain people sees them, know that they are from the US Marines, etc.
Put GGK or Kopassus there to see how a real commando look like
Stop joking please ! Only a fraction of what so called GGK and KOPASSUS have involved in limited fighting experience mainly in UN mission ! Nothing to boost , they are not GREEN BERETS , NAVY SEALS or SAS but just a bunch of low educated kampong villagers ! Do you know SOF or SOTF ? Even take a look at TAIWAN and KOREA SPECIAL FORCES , you can see how far away are the SEA kampong goreng pisang's villagers .By the way can they pass a simple English test ? 🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭
@@user-wc4jr2op8b pfffttt if GGK and KOPASSUS are sent to UN missions.. I have never seen a singaporean contingent sent to MALI or CONGO for UN peacekeeping ops. Maybe they would be bringing their maids over there because conditions are too harsh for them 🤣. Indonesian and malaysian soldiers have been sent to dangerous UN peacekeeping missions since the 60s.. I've never seen singaporean contingents sent there. 🤓
@@patriot4786 As I have said you are extremely naive! Empty vessel make the most noise , keyboard's warrior speak light expert ! Israel 🇮🇱 never sent soldiers for UN mission but Mala and Indo's kampong soldiers are just shit infront of them and you better go and check and see whether Singapore involve in UN mission or not . Remind you my friend went for US RANGER COURSE couple years ago and there were 3 persons from the world class GGK and KOPASSUS but embarrassing they couldn't get through the course 🤭🤭🤭 ! By the way have you went through military training? GGK or KOPASSUS 😄😄😄 ?
@@patriot4786 There are a tons of things you have never see but exists. Have you seen ultraviolet rays (UVs) with YOUR OWN EYES, infrared, X-rays, gamma rays, radio waves, microwaves, sound wave, etc, I could go on. Your ignorant doesn't mean things didn't happen. "Seeing is believing" should have a BIG ASTERISK sign behind it.
Go do a simple google search, Singapore troops are involved in some UN missions and some of them are even in command of some units, etc. They have those badge presentation, etc at the end of their service and those are the KNOWN ones.
Even with the US "black hawk down" accident, not all the troops involved are Msia's CDOs (GGK), some are attached, but most are from the mechanized infantry (from what I've heard from some Msian).
Battle of Mogadishu (1993) - United Nations Operation in Somalia II:
19th Battalion, Royal Malay Regiment of the Malaysian Army[34]
11th Regiment, Grup Gerak Khas of the Malaysian Army (few GGK operators during rescue the Super 6-1 crews)[34].
Read it clearly, 1993, that was some 28 years ago, a number of them would have retired by now. There are a few other cases, etc but they are few and far between.
Peacekeeping missions in itself means that the danger of the operations are limited and mostly known risk. Credits where it's due, so don't go claiming credits where it's not due.
@@user-wc4jr2op8b Well said!!
I know of many who went through US Ranger too, just didn't ask them about the GGK or KOPASSUS, they mainly shared about their experience there and how it is compared to SG Ranger course. A bunch of humble people.
Our neighbours watch this video, sure laugh. Be humble. You guys are only NSFs.. our neighbours special forces are full time regulars whose training are even tougher than Commandos than NDUs. If in doubt, watch their videos in youtube. Strawberry generation pampered servicemen how to win? Think
What is on youtube are just tip of the iceberg. Those guys and many like them are actually very humble if you ever meet them in real life.
While these guys are indeed only NSFs they are already much better than the "average joe". Even normal NSFs are already better than the average joes who are civilians, at the very least they have some military knowledge and depending on their roles in the military can act according in war time.
Based on your comments, you are really looking at things on the very surface (just like people who don't have much military knowledge). Who do you think trained these NSFs? Do you think Singapore hired Msia or Indo or ASEAN's Special Forces (SF) to train these guys?
These NSFs still carry the name of CDO or NDU and thus still able to do what they are trained to do, they can still handle some scope of the operations. Full Timers (partly due to being full time), are trained more in depth and wider, thus able to handle a wider variety of operations. Even full timers are NOT always in training, during their careers, they spend some time on administration, training (learning new skills), being instructors, etc. All full time SFs skills are comparable. Do you think the instructors would give these trainees an easy time considering they bear the "same name" as them?
Troops take time to train, you cannot expect civilians to be combat ready in a night's time.
It's called "Strawberry Generation", not "strawberry nation", every country would have "their versions" of it. You need new blood even in the military. How many of your country's new generation are joining the military and how many ended up going into SFs? Singapore at the very least have a relative steady influx of new blood.
I saw the Msia's entry level SF training (youtube video), the one in the forest. I wouldn't say it is tough, that level of training is at the very least, expected. Besides this video isn't about the types of training CDOs and NDUs went through too, it's just a friendly physical competition. Some people (or athletics) who have ZERO military training but are into cross-fit might be able to win them too, since the things tested are mostly physical stuff. It's not like the test are parachuting/combat diving/rappelling/ etc.
both still lose to gakha
Wth is gakha
gurkha*
Gurkha forces they are Nepali people who volunteer for the British forces and and one of the most fittest ones
@@deweshgoenka6111 dont forget they have an evolutionary advantage. Due to living in the mountains, they have a mutation allowing greater oxygen efficiency due to lower oxygen concentration on the mountains. And when they are put in a normal oxygen environment, their oxygen efficiency is even greater.
@@userjKNfe- who are you referring to? I'm pretty sure you are wrong, sometimes things are not as simple as it may look.
The amount of toxic masculinity… SMH
If this is the calibre of Special Forces now Singapore is FUCKED
u talk so much u cfm chao geng one LOL
imagine being proud of what unit you are in the Army. i see 6 clowns