What Happened to the Confederate Dead of Gettysburg? | History Traveler Episode 158

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 16. 06. 2024
  • This episode was produced in partnership with The Gettysburg Museum of History. See how you can support history education & artifact preservation by visiting their website & store at www.gettysburgmuseumofhistory...
    Many know the story of what happened to the Union dead at Gettysburg after the battle with the creation of the National Cemetery and the dedication where Lincoln gave his famous speech. But what happened to the Confederate dead? We're looking to answer that question in this episode as we explore the fate of the soldiers from the South who were killed on fields of battle in Gettysburg.
    Get your History Underground MERCH at www.thehistoryundergroundstore.com
    Set yourself up with a 10% DISCOUNT on all Origin gear and nutritional products by entering the code "history10" at www.originmaine.com!
    Other episodes that you might enjoy:
    - Gettysburg's Most STUNNING Artifact Collection (JFK, Marilyn Monroe) (EP 148): • Gettysburg's Most STUN...
    - An ULTRARARE Gettysburg Civil War Collection (EP 149): • An ULTRARARE Gettysbur...
    - The Gettysburg Address: In Lincoln's Footsteps (EP 157): • The Gettysburg Address...
    - The Easy Company Foxholes of Bastogne (EP 56): • The Easy Company Foxho...
    Support the effort to expand history education on PATREON: / historyunderground
    Facebook: thehistoryunderground
    Instagram: the_history_underground
    Help spread history and share this with a friend. And be sure to SUBSCRIBE to catch all of the latest content when it drops. Thanks!

Komentáře • 1,3K

  • @TheHistoryUnderground
    @TheHistoryUnderground  Před 2 lety +127

    If you've watched a few episodes and feel like I've earned it, be sure to subscribe so that you don't miss any new content when it comes out.
    Thanks!

    • @stevenkollars5436
      @stevenkollars5436 Před 2 lety +3

      I live in Gettysburg and am really enjoying all of your content. I have started biking around the battle fields and reading every monument to learn the history of places I’ve driven by since I was born. You have sparked my interest with the civil war and I am hoping to visit the Gettysburg museum of history here soon as the collection looks amazing! Thanks for all of the great content!

    • @papajon6715
      @papajon6715 Před 2 lety +6

      The Daughters of the Confederacy and Sons of Confederate Volunteers had at one time programs to supply CSA grave markers for those who served under the Confederacy. Dying in battle was not a requirement. Thank you so very much for your program, many families had people on both sides...

    • @FLjcollins
      @FLjcollins Před 2 lety +2

      JD- have you considered doing Geronimo's story? I was stationed at Ft. Sill in Lawton, OK and they have quite the history there. The original guard house he was kept in the basement chained to a pole in the center- the circular ware marks from him are still in the floor. He is buried there also- but the story of him, and the American Indians kept there on the "trail of tears" is pretty fascinating.
      Ft.Sill is also the home of US Army field artillery- and you want to talk about guns, guns, guns- the outside museum is pretty incredible, along with pieces we captured from Saddams Army in the first gulf War. I'm a former US Army Intel analyst (oef/of years) and I hated being stationed there, but as a history lover- the post is pretty remarkable.

    • @papajon6715
      @papajon6715 Před 2 lety +1

      I watched you episode on Bastogne fighting holes last night, then posted a link to an 101st Airborne group.
      By chance do you have the other appropriate episode numbers?

    • @TheHistoryUnderground
      @TheHistoryUnderground  Před 2 lety +2

      @@papajon6715 Episodes 56-62. There’s also Normandy content before that. You can most easily find it on the France & Belgium playlist on the channel. Thanks!

  • @veritas41photo
    @veritas41photo Před 2 lety +8

    I am a graduate (1963) of the Virginia Military Institute, where they just destroyed a statue of Thomas J. "Stonewall" Jackson. I will never go back to visit VMI. It is horrific, what they are doing to try to erase history. Shame on them, and good on you!

    • @DonAbrams-hq7ln
      @DonAbrams-hq7ln Před měsícem

      Amazing, lm surprised the Left hasn't rampaged and destroyed Hollywood cemetery in Richmond. What ever happened to
      HONOR AND HOLY GROUND,JESUS HELP US
      REALIZE ALL LIFE IS SACRED

  • @bryanbond7804
    @bryanbond7804 Před 2 lety +6

    My wife and I spent two days in Gettysburg for part of our honeymoon a couple of weeks ago.. All I have to say is wow, I would recommend anyone to visit Gettysburg at least once in their life and take a guided tour. You will not be disappointed.

  • @knan75
    @knan75 Před 2 lety +78

    After hearing what a beating the confederacy took at Gettysburg, my g’g’grandfather (who had land near Roanoke VA) hitched up a work wagon, drove to the site, searched the hospitals, and then the battlefield until he found the body of his son, Ferdinand Webb, and took him home for burial. The Webb’s did not own slaves; they hired their plantation workers.

    • @adamconnell5965
      @adamconnell5965 Před rokem +6

      We might be related... my Grandfather had Webbs in his family tree. His last name was Key and for a while it was Webb-Key. The Keys were from Virginia back when it was a colony.

    • @darcymoon2109
      @darcymoon2109 Před rokem +3

      What a waste all around.

    • @michaelreaper3580
      @michaelreaper3580 Před rokem +8

      God bless you, your family and young Ferdinand Webb RIP. I am moved to tears by your story. Thanks for sharing and thanks to all those that gave their lives in defiance of tyranny.

    • @darcymoon2109
      @darcymoon2109 Před rokem +1

      @@michaelreaper3580 Well, except confederate soldiers who gave their lives for a stupid, failed rebellion. Should have been treated like the traitors they were.

    • @markandrews2942
      @markandrews2942 Před rokem +7

      I'm glad you have that record in your family. The division that exist today hopefully will never bring another conflict. Civil war education in our nations schools should be mandatory. At 60 years I remember my parents taking me to mannases and the wilderness on our vacations . They wanted us to know early on what had happened.

  • @michaellaverty1844
    @michaellaverty1844 Před 2 lety +270

    I live in Richmond and have visited Hollywood several times. I’m unaware of this section, Gettysburg Hill. I’m out the door right now to go find it. Thanks for this Series. It has been eye opening to say the least. Well done.

    • @rogercarroll2551
      @rogercarroll2551 Před 2 lety +11

      It's to your right as you enter Hollywood where the great stone pyramid is.

    • @Labbe1989
      @Labbe1989 Před 2 lety +9

      The confederate president Jefferson Davis he is buried there his grand children are buried here in my hometown of Colorado Springs Colorado!!

    • @deanmason5900
      @deanmason5900 Před 2 lety +3

      You have a fine voice ( means a great deal to an old man who is tone deaf to many people) and you do fine work as a narrator.Some might find George Picket's pre war service in the far Northwest interesting just look " The Hog War".

    • @tkso.philly3879
      @tkso.philly3879 Před 2 lety +1

      I use to live in Richmond.I remember Hollywood cemetery,just not where.Is it in Shockoe Bottom,or Church Hill?

    • @timeandtimeagain4391
      @timeandtimeagain4391 Před 2 lety +3

      @@Labbe1989 Jeff Davis was the President of the CSA. He owned one if the largest working plantations in the south. He allowed his slaves to learn to read and write and gave them jobs as Managers to run different areas of the farm. He left land to some if them before his death.

  • @jolenewilliamson1031
    @jolenewilliamson1031 Před 2 lety +4

    WOW This series should be mandatory in all High School History classes. Not CRT. I would be willing to pay for it.

  • @castinn
    @castinn Před 2 lety +3

    JD, thank you from the bottom of my heart. Many years ago my wife and I visited Gettysburg and after visiting the Union cemetery, we went inside the main building to look around. I spotted a long counter with park personnel that could answer questions, so I went over and asked where the Confederate soldiers were buried. His answer was, "Who cares?" I staggered back and looked at the old fart. Then I left dumbfounded.

    • @TheHistoryUnderground
      @TheHistoryUnderground  Před 2 lety +2

      Wow. That’s an awful answer.

    • @castinn
      @castinn Před 2 lety +2

      @@TheHistoryUnderground I never forgot it and it has stayed with me for 20 years.

    • @DonAbrams-hq7ln
      @DonAbrams-hq7ln Před měsícem +1

      That is exactly WHY America is in turmoil today.......NO EMPATHY
      for ,...... ANYTHING. SELFISHNESS AND PRIDE
      WILL DESTROY US,GOD HELP US.

  • @roberth5767
    @roberth5767 Před 2 lety +8

    Sad to see so many gravestones damaged. My ggGrandfather (36th GA) is buried in a well kept National Cemetery in Columbus, Ohio. He survived 4 years in the CSA but barely lasted 4 months as a POW at Camp Chase.

    • @DonAbrams-hq7ln
      @DonAbrams-hq7ln Před měsícem

      They were American in the end,soALL CEMETARIES
      SHOULD LOOK AS GROOMED AS ONES IN
      NORMANDY .GERMAN
      GRAVES LOOK BETTER
      THAN THIS!!!!!!!!

  • @mickeyh53
    @mickeyh53 Před 2 lety +12

    As an Australian I’ve found this series on the battle of Gettysburg extremely informative..like most I enjoy American history but this collection took me to another level.
    🇦🇺/🇺🇸 Brothers In Arms

  • @kellycranford3592
    @kellycranford3592 Před 2 lety +80

    It's really sad that a lot of the widows and mothers never knew where their husbands or sons were buried so they never got a chance to grieve at their graves. Most died still not knowing. I don't know if I could stand not knowing where my husband or sons were. Thank you for giving them the recognition they probably never got.

    • @tomjones2121
      @tomjones2121 Před 2 lety +5

      Southerners didn't deserve to know , for more reasons then I can count , but let's just say , Hendersonville for one

    • @deanieedwards8117
      @deanieedwards8117 Před 2 lety +14

      My heart goes out to all who lost loved ones in wars..there is a special place for the ladies of the south who lost there loved ones in the Civil war. So sad that some never knew where there loved one are.

    • @barrys5169
      @barrys5169 Před 2 lety +26

      @@tomjones2121 What a horrible, evil thing to say.

    • @southwind3
      @southwind3 Před 2 lety +10

      @@tomjones2121 I'm A proud son of the SOUTH and also A veteran, you're A FOOL & very proud O'BIDEN supporter!

    • @kellycranford3592
      @kellycranford3592 Před 2 lety +22

      @@tomjones2121 wow, very forgiving of you, and you, sir, are the reason we Southerners still call it "The War of Northern Aggression".

  • @ELCADAROSA
    @ELCADAROSA Před 2 lety +177

    JD, you’ve done an outstanding job with this series.
    I don’t know if there’s any kind of special recognition or award that can be given to you, but you certainly deserve it.

    • @billd.iniowa2263
      @billd.iniowa2263 Před 2 lety +4

      There are internet awards, but there may not be a history documentary category. He'll have to travel with a kitten or learn to Rap. [smirk] :-) But I wholeheartedly agree, he deserves something. Lets all send him some coupons to fast food places!

    • @ELCADAROSA
      @ELCADAROSA Před 2 lety +9

      @@billd.iniowa2263, “fast food places”? Heck no! His quality work deserves a quality meal.

    • @lylegrant7211
      @lylegrant7211 Před 2 lety +1

      @@ELCADAROSA Agreed!!

    • @charlespiliero3709
      @charlespiliero3709 Před 2 lety +2

      neil newhall, my thoughts exactly too. what a terrible gynocidal war brought against such beautiful people by a mad man. how history is so distorted by the victors. may the confederates rise again to everlasting life in the next world to come soon.

    • @andymaciver1760
      @andymaciver1760 Před 2 lety +2

      He gets a high five and two yippee yoo's from me.

  • @johnd3152
    @johnd3152 Před 2 lety +51

    JD,
    It's a shame most people today do not realize how good we have it in this country. Both Northern and Southern soldiers put there lives at risk for what we have today. Your time and efforts are greatly appreciated!
    JD

    • @markbohn6534
      @markbohn6534 Před 2 lety +3

      HMMM REALLY,,, Well Title 28 USC 3002 15a The U.S Federal Corporation of 1871... D.C seal 1871 a Foreign Country.. Part of the 3 City State Corporations... FDR'S March 1933 New Deal Act HJR 192 and March 1933 Hitlers Enabling Act are the same thing; Taking Democracy into a Dictatorship.. See life is just a big chess board.. Your the Pawns.. Both sides are in on the game.. With HJR 192 FDR took all the peoples property and the gold or you went to jail for 10 years.. after that he made birth certificates all for trade with the banks... But you never had to pay your bills anymore,, you debt discharged them... They forgot to tell you that... O there is so much more then you will ever know... Famous Nazi Joesph Goebbles said; Tell a Lie,, Make it Big,, Tell it often... And if that doesn't work Make the Smith Mundt Modernization Act or 5736 Smith Mundt Act

    • @fluffy1931
      @fluffy1931 Před 2 lety

      @@markbohn6534 just unleash the 'kraken' ffs already & take your meds.

    • @russellking9762
      @russellking9762 Před 2 lety

      not a truer word was spoken John D

    • @Anthroid9
      @Anthroid9 Před 2 lety +5

      Southern soldiers did not put their lives at risk for what we have today. They wanted something very different than what we have today

    • @thomaswilliams8167
      @thomaswilliams8167 Před 2 lety

      Wrong! They caught because the war was a major sacrifice for the satanic government!! Each war is a major ritual of mass sacrifices. Think about it.

  • @tugboat25
    @tugboat25 Před 2 lety +14

    If you had a live audience, you'd get a very long standing ovation for your Gettysburg series. Thanks for all your work, it's appreciated.

  • @janicepounds9934
    @janicepounds9934 Před 2 lety +13

    Wonderful series!!! I had 8 direct ancestors fight in the war, 4 for the Union and 4 Confederate. All of them are respected by myself for their bravery and valor. Thank you so much for giving honor to the soldiers, no matter their side.

  • @carylosborn1808
    @carylosborn1808 Před 2 lety +16

    Hollywood Cemetery is magnificent! My husband and I have been there. Those ladies that raised that money were to be commended.

    • @TheHistoryUnderground
      @TheHistoryUnderground  Před 2 lety +3

      Pretty interesting place.

    • @DonAbrams-hq7ln
      @DonAbrams-hq7ln Před měsícem

      Hollywood should be restored to Arlington,those men should have the same burial markers as the Nazis got in France,lmho

  • @americanschweitzer45
    @americanschweitzer45 Před 2 lety +77

    JD you did an amazing job covering Gettysburg! That battle is so difficult to decide what to cover and what not! There is just so much to learn about that it’s impossible to put it into 20-25 videos! I enjoyed watching everyone you did! Well done!

  • @mercedithcompala8148
    @mercedithcompala8148 Před 2 měsíci +3

    Thank you for showing so much respect to the Confederate fallen...

  • @milepost465historyhobbies4
    @milepost465historyhobbies4 Před 2 lety +48

    I’ve been moved, enlightened and educated with every video in this series.. Thank you Sir!!

  • @kbhistoryquest9675
    @kbhistoryquest9675 Před 2 lety +39

    JD you have done an outstanding job with this series! I love to learn anything about the Civil War, and you have taught me a lot! Thank you for ending the series with the men that are sometimes forgotten and deserve to be remembered. God Bless!

  • @BigLisaFan
    @BigLisaFan Před 2 lety +66

    Thank you. I'm sure there are many others who can say more, but thank you for an outstanding series. You presented facts without prejudice to one side or the other.
    Some things I knew of, others I did not. Some were places I went to ,others are now left to explore when I return. Truly one of the best series presented. Thank you.

    • @billd.iniowa2263
      @billd.iniowa2263 Před 2 lety

      Absolutely. JD is a good diplomat. Polite to all sides.

  • @fredohnemus7685
    @fredohnemus7685 Před 2 lety +15

    Looking at the comments, seems to me nothing is unsaid that I can Think of. Outstanding presentation. Thank you.

  • @fredlist7091
    @fredlist7091 Před 2 lety +24

    I’ve conveyed my approbation several times over the course of this series and now that it’s come to an end, I’ll venture to do it again. You’ve done a fantastic job of presenting not only the civil war battle, but the people and places of Gettysburg to thousands who wouldn’t have otherwise known what a fascinating place it is. Great work and I look forward to… the next place.

    • @TheHistoryUnderground
      @TheHistoryUnderground  Před 2 lety +4

      I really do appreciate that. Hope that people continue to enjoy the channel.

  • @francisbusa1074
    @francisbusa1074 Před 2 lety +70

    Although I was a Union Army re-enactor in the 1990's, and have always been a very staunch constitutionalist, I do mourn the deaths of these brave men who stood and fought, and were willing to sacrifice their very lives for something they sincerely believed in. One cannot deny their Valor, regardless whether we agree politically. They were Americans who did their duty, even though I personally think that their cause was misguided and had to ultimately fail. Very sad and tragic.

    • @setharnold3699
      @setharnold3699 Před 2 lety +12

      Just seems there could've been another way. All those young men sacrificing their lives over what they thought was protecting their homeland.

    • @billd.iniowa2263
      @billd.iniowa2263 Před 2 lety +20

      State's Rights is still a topic of discussion to this day.

    • @davidandrew1078
      @davidandrew1078 Před 2 lety +11

      @@billd.iniowa2263 The Right to own Slaves?

    • @michaelbee2165
      @michaelbee2165 Před 2 lety +28

      @@davidandrew1078 The rights and powers delegated to the States under the Constitution. It was about WAY more than slavery. We see the results today as the Federal Government absconds with more and more rights belonging to the States.

    • @michaelbee2165
      @michaelbee2165 Před 2 lety +15

      Thank you for honoring these men as Americans and recognizing their valor in defending what they believed to be their country and posterity.

  • @Headstoneman
    @Headstoneman Před 2 lety +42

    Such a great series! I’m sad to see it end, But you ended it well! Can’t wait to see what is coming next!

  • @dennisdrumm7097
    @dennisdrumm7097 Před 2 lety +32

    Outstanding JD never seen a better presentation of Gettysburg than yours! The way you ended it with the dead known and unknown was a class act! God Bless you and good luck with your future presentations👍

  • @williamlee5705
    @williamlee5705 Před 2 lety +1

    My great-great grandfather James Lee a Union soldier is in Hollywood cemetery (grave 11161). Died in the old soldiers home in Richmond. Was captured at Manassas. Lived out his life in the south. Died in 1909 of pneumonia. Cool video man. Love your series!!!

  • @timothyblackburn2830
    @timothyblackburn2830 Před 2 lety +1

    Well done and fair, Sir. This episode is an appropriate closing of the curtain on your Gettysburg series. To visit the resting place of many brave and fear filled men and boys who were too early taken by the horrors of the Civil War is powerful.
    Many of our ancestors and those of our neighbors are interred there. Though these men fought a losing battle, are they not men and brothers to us all? To honor a brother is not to accept his beliefs at that point in our American journey but to weep at his humanity.
    Many fought for their own band of brothers and for no cause except that of the welfare of neighbors and family. Many were young or old conscripts for whom the choices were few and all equally dismal. Yet they did their best and paid the ultimate price.
    Thank you, JD for seeing this as the honorable and just way to close your series of episodes regarding thls our national catastrophe. May the victors and the defeated rest in peace knowing they are remembered eternally because of you and those like you.

  • @Archerfish1977
    @Archerfish1977 Před 2 lety +8

    JD, thank you so much for your Gettysburg series. A friend and I are heading there in just a few weeks and your videos have helped give us an itinerary for our time there.

  • @csmith5102
    @csmith5102 Před 2 lety +10

    Great series! Can’t wait to go back to Gettysburg to see everything I missed the first time.

  • @tnarggrant9711
    @tnarggrant9711 Před 2 lety +2

    This whole series was so prefect. Please consider doing the Texas revolution next.

  • @megarouge61
    @megarouge61 Před 2 lety

    I grew up in middle Tennessee and never toured a battlefield. Shiloh, Franklin, etc. all within about half hour from the house. Finally toured them years after moving to Texas.
    Amazing the vastness of the battle areas. You kind of picture smallish areas in your mind but the area encompassed by battle was extremely vast. The confederate cemetery
    at Franklin is jaw dropping! At the Stand cemetery in Shady Grove, just above my home, were several confederate graves. My brother usually makes sure all the veterans resting there
    there (Dad Included) have a new appropriate flag on Memorial Day.

  • @TheHistoryWonderer
    @TheHistoryWonderer Před 2 lety +4

    Loved the GB series JD. Well done! Ready for the next adventure.

  • @oregonoutback7779
    @oregonoutback7779 Před 2 lety +3

    Seems like a fitting end to this series. Very well done !! Couldn't help thinking as I watched, all the folk that are foaming at the mouth for another civil war. I would encourage them to watch this series and contemplate what it is they think they want to accomplish. Thank you for all you do, JD.

  • @barbaraharshman9460
    @barbaraharshman9460 Před 2 lety +1

    This is so sad thank you for sharing this series with us!

  • @ianoldham6123
    @ianoldham6123 Před 2 lety +1

    From Queenstown, South Africa I cannot even begin to tell you how much I enjoyed this Gettysburg series. Fantastically done! It was as good as if I were there myself. Thank you so much!

  • @martindriver6026
    @martindriver6026 Před 2 lety +79

    That is sad when it says "unknown" A name is very important. GOD knows his name, and he will rise again. If GOD knows all the stars by name, no doubt he knows all the names that are unknown to us. Awesome Episode. Thanks for sharing.

    • @davidandrew1078
      @davidandrew1078 Před 2 lety +7

      God hates traitors too.

    • @sherrilee230
      @sherrilee230 Před 2 lety +1

      They will become know again either in another time or something of interest sent to us to witness.

    • @michaelbee2165
      @michaelbee2165 Před 2 lety +7

      @@davidandrew1078 God loves those who trust in his SON. You don't speak for God and wouldn't deign to muster the courage of conviction and faith that these men did.

    • @davidandrew1078
      @davidandrew1078 Před 2 lety +3

      @@michaelbee2165 God is omnipresent, depending on which one you follow of course. Traitors are universally hated. Did you take 30 pieces of silver?

    • @peggyscott125
      @peggyscott125 Před 2 lety +1

      True. Those are multiple unknowns buried there in Hollywood cemetery. Too many with no way of knowing who they were. Especially under the pyramid.

  • @grin1972
    @grin1972 Před 2 lety +4

    Well, it was a fantastic series. I have learned a lot of great and interesting things. You've done a great job.

  • @davemartin4183
    @davemartin4183 Před 2 lety +1

    JD, thank you for all your hard work on the Gettysburg series. I've learned so much about it that I never knew. Looking forward to your next adventure

  • @timothymcknight9485
    @timothymcknight9485 Před 2 lety

    Just saw this final installment of your Gettysburg series, JD.
    Wonderful series of videos. Thank you for putting a whole new perspective into the stories of the battle.
    We appreciate it!

  • @XxBloggs
    @XxBloggs Před 2 lety +16

    What an amazing series this has been. Outstanding.

  • @Wreckdiver59
    @Wreckdiver59 Před 2 lety +4

    When you started this series, I knew next to nothing about Gettysburg. You turned me into a huge fan. Being able to go there and see in person some of the places in your videos was definitely a plus 😀. I've got a collection of books & maps I've been reading and using for research. I'm already planning another trip.
    So, thanks JD for putting this series together. Like you always say, "I learned something new" and ended up with a new obsession 😆.

  • @CSchnell-lj1io
    @CSchnell-lj1io Před 2 lety

    That museum you’ve been showing in this series has got to be, hands down, one of the best museums I’ve been introduced to due in fact because of your channel, definitely a bucket list place for me to visit! Keep on keeping on, wishing you and yours all the best!

  • @mrDCunningham
    @mrDCunningham Před 2 lety +2

    This was an awesome series JD. I learned so much. Thank you for the great work.👍🏻😎

  • @jared1870
    @jared1870 Před 2 lety +9

    I'm not truly convinced that you are finished with Gettysburg. Thanks for another great video!

    • @TheHistoryUnderground
      @TheHistoryUnderground  Před 2 lety +3

      Ha! It seems weird to me as well that I'm going to be doing anything but Gettysburg now.

  • @hikerx9366
    @hikerx9366 Před 2 lety +3

    Looking at all those headstones of those who were killed just shows us how the majority of these guys were just young men in their 20's and 30's. What a tremendous and tragic loss. Thanks for the tours, information and respect given to their memories. 🙏🏼

    • @JRobbySh
      @JRobbySh Před 2 lety

      The South lost the flower of its youth. Those political fanatics who spured them into war suffered almost as much forming having done so. Their sons and relative, their personal wealth, all sunk into the ground. As bad are those who ignore that because of its loss, the South remained sunk into poverty for another hundred years.They still do not think it was punishment enough. But Lincoln said it all in his 2nd Inaugural address. Slavery was sunk, too, but many will not see that.

    • @robertbates6057
      @robertbates6057 Před rokem +1

      @@JRobbySh You bring up some very valid points. Those southern politicians that pushed to secede to keep them from losing profit have hopefully received the Lords judgement. The vast majority of those poor farmer boys that paid with their lives was a tragedy. Both sides. Most don't realize that the South didn't really recover until industries and air conditioning moved to the South in the mid - late 1960s. Methinks the weight of the Reconstruction boot on the neck of the South was a little too heavy. Many want to forget that the States had every legal right to secede from the Union being independent States. Slavery was and is a horrible evil practice (yes, still exists) but was not the only reason for secession for the South nor was it the only reason northerners went to war. A war that could've and should've been avoided by both sides. I've always thought that IF the South had been allowed to secede peacefully, eventually, they would have reconciled. Slavery was already doomed due to a growing moral conscience and the trade punishment of the North would have stopped, allowing negotiation. The destruction and debt created by the War inevitably led to the selling of our liberties that we are still trying to recover to this day.

    • @bassingman9911
      @bassingman9911 Před 3 měsíci

      Best comment I've read. I've always thought both sides shared the blame and like with any war it was the youth on both sides that paid the price.@@robertbates6057

  • @crazymixture57
    @crazymixture57 Před 3 měsíci

    My family is from Texas but I was born in PA about 3 hours away from Gettysburg. Glad to see so many brave souls are back home at rest. God Bless the fallen.

  • @commanderstraker6732
    @commanderstraker6732 Před 2 lety +1

    Absolutely fantastic series! Thank you so much for all your hard work in doing this series. 🙏

  • @wesleyfinch1574
    @wesleyfinch1574 Před 2 lety +1

    Wow! Learning things I never really thought about before, as usual. Incredible job with this series. Thank you so much.

  • @icetre7436
    @icetre7436 Před 2 lety +12

    This series means so much to me. My father and I frequently visited this battlefield while he was attending the War College in Carlisle. His bachelor’s from West Point was in military history, and as his son in not only biology but in spirit, we were fascinated by this hallowed place and time. I made models of various battles and scenes to try to show my understanding, I and would offer them to him for critique. I once entered one of my dioramas in a school fair, but it was dismissed out of hand because it was too professionally made, for the likes of me.lol. What you have done has given me a far better understanding not only of the battle overall, but what what the town and its people must have experienced. What I like most about your humble presentation is that you don’t talk to us and point, but you walk and talk with us and go. It also doesn’t go unnoticed that your music is impeccable. That must be a thing unto itself. The only other battlefield that he and I visited and studied to this extent was Custer’s. I’d love to see that through your eyes.

  • @redarrow3722
    @redarrow3722 Před 2 lety +9

    Thanks, JD! Really enjoyed this Gettysburg series. Very educational and done with the utmost respect for the tragic events that unfolded on this hallowed ground.

  • @lucypearson6176
    @lucypearson6176 Před 2 lety +24

    Thank you for this series in history. There is so much I'd never learned before. And thank you for your history Channel here on CZcams.

    • @billd.iniowa2263
      @billd.iniowa2263 Před 2 lety +3

      Completely agree. I know I sure learned a thing or two. Like just now I learned that Jeb Stuart was only 31 when he died. (looked at the marker) I have pictured him much older all these years.

    • @markbohn6534
      @markbohn6534 Před 2 lety

      Nazi Joesph Goebbels said; Tell a Lie,, Make it Big,, Tell it Often... If that doesn't work.. Write a ACT.. 1948 Smith Mundt Act was to stop the lying to the People... Smith Mundt Modernization Act was to make lying to the People Lawful... 28 USC 3002 15a The U.S Federal Corporation of 1871... D.C Seal 1871.. One of the 3 City State Corporations.. D.C a Foreign Country not part of the U.S.. Queen owns the patient on the Words; United States.. Thank School Re-Education Camps for all this... There is No Government.. It's a Corporation...

  • @MeredithTB
    @MeredithTB Před 2 lety

    This series has been phenomenal. It can’t end!!

  • @rtk3543
    @rtk3543 Před 2 lety

    Quite a journey indeed, thanks for taken us along JD you did a great job.

  • @MrWisconsinLeather
    @MrWisconsinLeather Před 2 lety +7

    Incredible series....saying that I learned as much as I thought I already knew would be an understatement. Pure and simply, THANK YOU!

  • @billd.iniowa2263
    @billd.iniowa2263 Před 2 lety +4

    Thank you so much for making this series JD. You have done a great service to us the viewer, the study of history, and your country. Safe travels.

  • @geekazoid1983
    @geekazoid1983 Před 2 lety

    What a fantastic journey you've lead us on through history JD. Absolutely fantastic. Thank you.

  • @patricialenaburg6553
    @patricialenaburg6553 Před 2 lety

    It's been an absolute pleasure watching this series, loved all the extra tid bits thrown in, which most of us never knew. There is to much to comment on, but one of my favorite parts, was learning more about the civilians. This brought it on home to me, it gave a broader vision of what it was like for them. Another thing was about a question that was asked of you, and that was about how many horses died during the war. I watched your live stream yesterday, and would never thought about this, but in the long run, nothing went untouched with during that time. All I can say, is WOW! and thank you.

  • @jeffreycarroll5920
    @jeffreycarroll5920 Před 2 lety +25

    It would be nice to have a fund raising to get new headstones. Some look fairly new but others are in
    Bad shape

    • @rjay7019
      @rjay7019 Před 2 lety +3

      Trying to do that for some of our family members who's headstones are getting so old they are crumbling to pieces. It's sad to see that 😔

    • @krbulldog
      @krbulldog Před 2 lety

      The government will do it for free

  • @vickistevens423
    @vickistevens423 Před 2 lety +7

    Thank you for an amazing Gettysburg series. You brought the battle to life for us. Outstanding job! God Bless.

  • @matthewbaker7540
    @matthewbaker7540 Před 2 lety

    Excellent job JD. what an awesome series, and no need to worry that you would do it a disservice. You should be proud of what you have done and the stories that may have gone untold that you were able to tell in detail! Can’t wait to see what’s next!

  • @rubyait
    @rubyait Před 2 lety

    My favorite history channel. You always have the exact, proper tone. I have been an informal cemetery visitor for 40 years or so. I have seen many graves of common soldiers and, being in Maine, seamen. Seen Freeman McGilvery and Marcus Aurelius Hannah. Looking forward to your next project. Thank you.

  • @kathleenbrenner2889
    @kathleenbrenner2889 Před 2 lety +4

    A perfect ending to a wonderfully done series 😊 My Hubby was moved seeing General Pickett’s resting place. His Grandma was a Pickett so he is a descendant, we believe through his brother Charles Pickett. Hubby’s Grandma said the General was a Great+++Uncle

  • @Kimberly-dt4ko
    @Kimberly-dt4ko Před 2 lety +4

    Thanks for such a great series. I like that you covered the townspeople and the impact of the battle on daily life. Also appreciate that you took the time to locate lesser known battlefield sites that many of us aren't aware of.

  • @dawndickson2156
    @dawndickson2156 Před 2 lety

    Thank you for taking us along on this Gettysburg journey JD. Your coverage was a job well done. Thank you for including the ordinary citizens and their stories that endured the battle before during and after.

  • @357lockdown
    @357lockdown Před 2 lety

    Absolutely great series. Thanks so much for taking us with you.

  • @michelehurt9258
    @michelehurt9258 Před 2 lety +6

    JD thanks for the Gettsburg series. Learned more of our history.

  • @robynbohbot3709
    @robynbohbot3709 Před 2 lety +3

    Thank you so much for taking us all on your journey. I learned so much more and have a deeper appreciation for all who fought the battles. I am so glad that there were folks who respectfully buried the dead as best they could.

  • @BlueMoonShelly
    @BlueMoonShelly Před 2 lety

    You are truly amazing in bringing history to life and in capturing the sense, the feel of the very moments of which for many have been lost in time.

  • @thatguy-oz9ib
    @thatguy-oz9ib Před 2 lety +1

    This series has been fantastic. I love about an hour from Gettysburg and have grown up with it all my life. But there is still so much more to learn! Thank you for doing this series

  • @jasonpayne3363
    @jasonpayne3363 Před 2 lety +7

    I don’t know how you did all this. Just amazing the time and work you put into all this. I just can’t imagine. Thanks again for all of it. Safe travels to your next stop

  • @nathanv2882
    @nathanv2882 Před 2 lety +28

    JD,
    Thank you for doing this series. This makes me want to head back to Gettysburg. Hopefully you do another series like this again soon.

  • @sandysue202
    @sandysue202 Před 2 lety +1

    An amazing job of documenting that terrible time in our history. Thank you for what you do!

  • @BuckeyeBackyardBBQ
    @BuckeyeBackyardBBQ Před 2 lety

    Truly an outstanding series! I’m a big history nut and been to Gettysburg three times and learned more watching you the last few months then I ever did with license the battle tour guides!! Love the info on the town as well!! Wonderful work!! Keep making us all smarter ever week!!

  • @matthewwhitt9398
    @matthewwhitt9398 Před 2 lety +3

    My family and I have enjoyed this series so much!

  • @pamelaoliver8442
    @pamelaoliver8442 Před 2 lety +5

    It's been nothing short of epic, JD. From the battle sites to the civilian homes, the content with the Battlefield Trust, Addressing Gettysburg podcast...all of it..just wow. Thanks so much for taking us.
    Watching this one I cant help but think of what an absolute impossibility identifying some of them would be..not to be too graphic but their wounds weren't pretty and they weren't all buried immediately. What a ghastly task.

    • @TheHistoryUnderground
      @TheHistoryUnderground  Před 2 lety +1

      Thank you so much! And yes, can't imagine the work of digging up those bodies.

  • @roberthenry9319
    @roberthenry9319 Před 2 lety

    This segment and this whole series has been so wonderful. Please keep at it. Stay safe.
    R.Henry, M.D.

  • @michaelpocock2860
    @michaelpocock2860 Před 2 lety

    Great series - I've thoroughly enjoyed watching every episode. Kudos to you for bringing history to life in such a way that we can appreciate this thing called freedom that so many take for granted, but that was purchased with the blood of these men, and others like them in countless wars over many years.

  • @RoseGma
    @RoseGma Před 2 lety +12

    Thank you for this series. I went to Gettysburg in a high school band trip in 1980 and I loved all of the history about it. I'm so glad that you helped me learn even more. Thanks again! 😊

  • @thinktonka
    @thinktonka Před 2 lety +13

    You have done such a great job covering Gettysburg! I am planning on returning this fall because of the inspiration gained from your efforts. Thank you so much!

    • @TheHistoryUnderground
      @TheHistoryUnderground  Před 2 lety +4

      Awesome! Be sure to drop by The Gettysburg Museum of History. Awesome place.

    • @lloydwarr3488
      @lloydwarr3488 Před 2 lety

      Wouldn't have been great if a foreign super power h a d sent the southern boys new guns and unlimited supplies. Our nation's capital might have been shreveport.

  • @Fuckthathoe
    @Fuckthathoe Před 2 lety +1

    Can't get enough of civil war history, thanks for the videos!!

  • @shadowworlds
    @shadowworlds Před 2 lety +1

    I was visiting where the battle was fought when I was very young. I am an old man now but what stuck in my mind was they had a day when they fired off all those old cannons one after another. All I can say it was a amazing site to see. The noise and the smoke from the powder was intense and have alwise stayed with me. It put you back in the time when they fought the war.

  • @MiJacFan1
    @MiJacFan1 Před 2 lety +4

    Wow! Here it is, the end of the series. I applaud you, dear sir, for bringing us on this journey. I have learned so much from you, ABT, and the museum. Definite bucket listers for sure! So sad so many lost their lives fighting their brothers, just wondering if people would learn their lesson from this. Thank you, safe travels, and as you said, off to the next destination!

    • @Anthroid9
      @Anthroid9 Před 2 lety

      Tf? You gonna visit Hitlers vacation home after? The descendants of the Confederates have not learned and that is why they tried to overthrow the last election

  • @dantehill4748
    @dantehill4748 Před 2 lety +5

    I live just North East of Richmond in Hanover. This area is brimming with US history. While you were reading Gen. Picketts battle accolades, you mentioned the battle of Cold Harbor. It would be amazing to see you do a video of the battlefield here. We have several field's, buildings and cemeteries here that I think you would love to check out.

  • @lefin3730
    @lefin3730 Před 2 lety +1

    That was excellent once again, loved your Gettysburg series of videos and learned so much. Thank you for the content.

  • @Sunshine-se6yn
    @Sunshine-se6yn Před 2 lety

    So very sad and a powerful reminder of our history. Thank you.

  • @snapfitness1
    @snapfitness1 Před 2 lety +5

    I've always been a history buff but your videos have been making wish I'd stayed in school to major in history... especially American. Nice work!

  • @jamesrobinson3509
    @jamesrobinson3509 Před 2 lety +3

    Aside from slavery, I am in absolute awe at the bravery of these men to fight under horrific circumstances for what they believed in.

    • @davidb2206
      @davidb2206 Před rokem

      Fewer than 1 in 7 Confederates had any connection to slavery. It was the "elites" just like the Democratic Party today. You can Pelosi has lots of "servants." My family never did.

  • @sheilajacobs2011
    @sheilajacobs2011 Před 2 lety

    JD. what an incredible series. I have enjoyed each episode. Thank you for sharing your travels.

  • @ChrisFillmore03
    @ChrisFillmore03 Před 2 lety

    Thanks JD, glad you got to Richmond and for teaching me something new about the city in which I live. Hope you will get to explore and see all the wonderful history Richmond and the surrounding areas have to offer.

  • @lindahh798
    @lindahh798 Před 2 lety +3

    Thank you for addressing the question, "Where are the Confederate dead at Gettysburg?" I have had the honor to visit Gettysburg some years ago. I remember asking my friend the same question? I was able to see Union dead in cemetaries. I asked the same questions most likely asked by the masses. YOU cleared up a question that I asked many years ago!! Great history programs!

  • @BermudaBrian
    @BermudaBrian Před 2 lety

    What an incredible journey you took us on. I have been to Gettysburg, but I learned far more from your videos. THANK YOU!

  • @Carolbearce
    @Carolbearce Před 2 lety +1

    You have done an amazing job on this series. Thank you.

  • @crazya3466
    @crazya3466 Před 2 lety +3

    Fantastic journey thx for brining us along🖒...cA

  • @deadsweetheart1
    @deadsweetheart1 Před 2 lety +8

    There are also men buried throughout Maryland who were wounded at Gettysburg and died in hospitals not to mention the thousands that would die of disease after capture at places like fort Delaware and point lookout. Poi lookout has a mass grave marker no individual burial plots even 70 political prisoners would perish at point lookout

  • @marshasimpson261
    @marshasimpson261 Před 2 lety

    Love your series! I’m 71 and still learning! Thank you!

  • @topcat2935
    @topcat2935 Před 2 lety

    I've mentioned this before, but your use of the camera and your choice of music is stunning. Some places in this video sent shivers down my back. I am always learning something new from your videos. Thank you.

  • @itsapittie
    @itsapittie Před 2 lety +10

    Uwharrie is the name of a national forest in North Carolina. I'm guessing the "Uwharrie Boys" were from that region of North Carolina.

    • @scottfrye7882
      @scottfrye7882 Před 2 lety +4

      Uwharrie were soldiers from the surrounding areas....Albemarle, Troy, Baden, Star, Morrow Mountain.

    • @DonAbrams-hq7ln
      @DonAbrams-hq7ln Před měsícem

      Charlotte area

  • @jonathangoad2489
    @jonathangoad2489 Před 2 lety +6

    I live about 10 minutes from jeb Stuart’s birth place always excited to hear about him and the confederate soldiers

  • @mrdave777
    @mrdave777 Před 2 lety +1

    Congratulations on 250k! Your photography, videography, narration and information is phenomenal! I’m so impressed and happy for you! Keep up the terrific work!

  • @stephenhenion8304
    @stephenhenion8304 Před 2 lety +1

    I'm inspired by your true convictions to unravel our historic past. I have Grandfather's from the Revolution, Civil War, WW1 and WW2. I was too young for Vietnam!🎩🇺🇸🎩🇺🇸🎩