The Modes Ranked by Brightness

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 12. 09. 2019
  • Comparing scales and tonalities by their relative brightness can be a far more objective and useful way to conceptualise music. The seven modes of the major scale offer a fantastic range of brightnesses to choose from. In today's video I'll be working my way through the modal sprectrum and demonstrating some classic examples of modal writing as I go, including 'Uptown Funk', 'Mad World', 'Yoda's Theme', 'The Force Theme', 'Wherever I May Roam' and plenty more.
    And an extra special thanks goes to Daniel Long & Paul Peijzel, the channel’s Patreon saints! 😇
    SUPPORT ME ON PATREON: / davidbennettpiano
    My analysis of the Locrian mode in 'Dust to Dust': • Does Locrian Create Au...
    Why is major "Happy"? by Adam Neely: • Why is major "happy?"
    Leonard Bernstein on Modes: • Video

Komentáře • 2,1K

  • @nickmendens76
    @nickmendens76 Před 4 lety +1337

    As a non musician I find your Star Wars references to be pivotal to understanding

    • @chad2687
      @chad2687 Před 4 lety +22

      hahaha mood, even as a musician it helps ;)

    • @hailstunes
      @hailstunes Před 3 lety +38

      mandalocrian

    • @robbiehorn7690
      @robbiehorn7690 Před 3 lety +5

      ItzBroccoli I appreciate you and your pun more than I appreciate my loved ones

    • @misguided_ghost
      @misguided_ghost Před 3 lety +2

      @@hailstunes hahaha! that’s genius

    • @bonbonpony
      @bonbonpony Před 3 lety +4

      Now I wonder where's Sith music on this scale :J

  • @rohanm8526
    @rohanm8526 Před 4 lety +1389

    No need to apologise for doing "technical" videos - lots of us are interested and can follow. They're the only ones I watch, so thanks for this.

    • @Ignasimp
      @Ignasimp Před 4 lety +21

      Yes more technical videos please!

    • @lonewaer
      @lonewaer Před 4 lety +16

      I didn't find this too technical or hard to follow. Obviously I'm gonna forget everything, notably which intervals to alter in order to get which mode, which is the whole point, but this spectrum and explanation look like very useful, short, resources for untrained composers -also obviously it's better to be trained. Also now there's kind of a challenge, too…

    • @ryanlea750
      @ryanlea750 Před 4 lety +1

      Yeah technical videos, i play harmonica and have been playing long enough that this makes sense. And need to understand more of it. You will not find videos that are like this for the instrument, though people are doing it.

  • @andrewdevine3920
    @andrewdevine3920 Před 4 lety +2416

    Binary Sunset is actually in the Midichlorian mode.

  • @bonecanoe86
    @bonecanoe86 Před rokem +369

    The modes as weather:
    Lydian: A very sunny day, almost too sunny
    Major: A pleasantly sunny day
    Mixolydian: A mostly sunny day with a few clouds
    Dorian: A mostly cloudy way with a few breaks for the sun to peak through
    Minor: Completely overcast, light rain
    Phrygian: Heavy, cold rain is falling
    Locrian: The rain is how hail.

    • @jackthesmoltangerine
      @jackthesmoltangerine Před rokem +30

      Aka, the seven types of weather in Michigan

    • @namibia584
      @namibia584 Před 11 měsíci +26

      Super Locrian: A flooding

    • @ferudunatakan
      @ferudunatakan Před 10 měsíci +6

      @@namibia584Lydian augmented: Toooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo sunny day

    • @chaoticlife3670
      @chaoticlife3670 Před 9 měsíci +13

      Lydian augmented: oh we're.. on the sun

    • @MrPromethium0157
      @MrPromethium0157 Před 9 měsíci +3

      @@chaoticlife3670 Aka Mild LA summer day

  • @jakubciecwierz9380
    @jakubciecwierz9380 Před 4 lety +2981

    *Locrian mode* : is unusable because it's too dark
    *Black metal bands* : this must be it!

    • @akumayoxiruma
      @akumayoxiruma Před 4 lety +111

      Björk loves it, and so do I. It is so fun.

    • @LautloseLebwerwurst3000
      @LautloseLebwerwurst3000 Před 4 lety +140

      One could guess, yes. But a lot of extreme metal (if not atonal) actually uses phrygian or phrygian dominant rather than locrian.
      SOAD however has a couple of songs in super locrian on their first album (I know they're not black metal but at least somewhat metalish)

    • @LautloseLebwerwurst3000
      @LautloseLebwerwurst3000 Před 4 lety +43

      I guess the reason is what David has already mentioned, namely that tendency of the phrygian scale to make downward melodies sound so natural and at the same time dark and tense. Which I suppose might be the case because phrygian still has the perfect fifth over it's tonic which the locrian mode doesn't have, therefore there's no interval between the locrian model's tonic and any other scale degree that makes you think "wow this must be the tonic, it just sounds so natural to end there".
      The superlocrian however is basically the 7th mode of the melodic minor scale, even if you end on it's second degree, it still doesn't sound majorish as it does with the regular locrian. So if you end on the melodic minor tonic and move a semi tone down, this shift into a darker side of the scale doesn't feel as forced as it does with locrian. At least that's what I think, though there's definitely ways to make the locrian work, but the super locrian is easier to handle if you're not am experienced composer in my opinion (even though it doesn't have the perfect fifth either)

    • @jakubciecwierz9380
      @jakubciecwierz9380 Před 4 lety +3

      @@LautloseLebwerwurst3000 Thanks for your remark. I am currently trying to create kind of dark/sad melody but I haven't figured how to apply it into my song yet and I am searching for advices in music theory and it is a bit complicated. Thanks for comment anyway :)

    • @LautloseLebwerwurst3000
      @LautloseLebwerwurst3000 Před 4 lety

      @@jakubciecwierz9380 Do you have a chord progression and/or lyrics to that melody? If so, why don't you send it and I will try to give you some ideas on how to write a melody over that progression? I think if you're new to music theory a little input from others can be helpful to get a better overview of the options one has when composing

  • @danielmanicolo6794
    @danielmanicolo6794 Před 4 lety +6024

    Locrian mode only useful for song about the joys of grave digging...

    • @aaronmedeiros848
      @aaronmedeiros848 Před 4 lety +183

      Its execution is difficult, Pink Floyd has of Locrain and extreme dissonance in the song the controls for the heart of the sun.

    • @clemensmoeller4549
      @clemensmoeller4549 Před 4 lety +82

      The only places I've heard it sounding normal is in some metal songs. The shortest straw by metallica seems to be in locrian for large parts.

    • @danielamdurer1779
      @danielamdurer1779 Před 4 lety +41

      @@aaronmedeiros848 Isn't that actually Phrygian?

    • @joesmee997
      @joesmee997 Před 4 lety +25

      Clemens Moeller even then the tonic is played with a 5th so it’s not pure locrian

    • @clemensmoeller4549
      @clemensmoeller4549 Před 4 lety +28

      @@joesmee997 Yeah that's true, sorry I forgot about that. The song just came to mind because they use a lot of b1 and b5 notes. Powerchords (fifths) on electric guitar are often just used to make single notes sound "bigger". Guess that's why I didn't immediately notice it to be the fifth of the tonic, instead of a note that makes E sound stronger. But you're right, thanks for clarifying.

  • @danno9299
    @danno9299 Před 4 lety +138

    me: i need to do this essay
    also me: mode tier list

    • @Alberto-ny7kf
      @Alberto-ny7kf Před 3 lety +4

      @@checkYVELLUAP sorry but phrygian and mixolydian is B minimum

  • @anrylstudios
    @anrylstudios Před 4 lety +1117

    Me: looks at C Major
    Also me: let us brighten it by only sharpening c
    *ACCIDENTALLY CREATES C# SUPER LOCRIAN*

    • @thegreatestshenfan6484
      @thegreatestshenfan6484 Před 4 lety +79

      *_S H I T_*

    • @daddywhetz
      @daddywhetz Před 4 lety +85

      I laughed so hard at this. It also made me felt nerdy af hahahaha

    • @ItsMeVolatility
      @ItsMeVolatility Před 4 lety +21

      I love this comment. Gave me a good laugh

    • @lewisbean4250
      @lewisbean4250 Před 3 lety +27

      Hey sharpen the first note of Mixolydian and tell me how it goes!

    • @tiles2048
      @tiles2048 Před 3 lety +16

      Accidentally creates D melodic minor

  • @figgsboson
    @figgsboson Před 4 lety +306

    Thought the thumbnail said "moral spectrum" at first and I was like yea I guess bruno mars is an okay guy

  • @ChrisKennedyChris
    @ChrisKennedyChris Před 4 lety +448

    Here's a couple fun things:
    The scale degrees that are altered to get brighter and darker aren't arbitrary - they are based on the circle of fifths. With C as the center, the notes you flatten as you get darker:
    Mixolydian - Bb
    Dorian - Eb
    Aeolian - Ab
    Phrygian - Db
    Locrian - Gb
    Ok.. so let's keep going around the circle. We just flattened G to Gb. What is a 5th down from G?
    C
    Hmmm, ok, so let's flat the root, I guess?? This will be next level darkness!
    Cb Db Eb F Gb Ab Bb
    Let's respell that enharmonically...
    B C# D# E# F# G# A#
    Also known as...
    B lydian!!
    Ergo...
    The difference between lydian and locrian is one note: the root note! I guess you could call it the Circle of Modes or the Lydian-Locrian Singularity.
    🤯
    Now try following the circle of 5ths to "brighten" lydian and see what you get.

    • @txcy8941
      @txcy8941 Před 4 lety +25

      What I've noticed while messing with this is we can do the same trick with flattening the root for any of the modes:
      If you start with C Super Locrian, flattening the root creates B major.
      If you start with C Locrian, flattening the root creates B Lydian as you mentioned.
      If you start with C Phrygian, flattening the root creates B Super-Lydian aka B Lydian augmented.
      If you start with C Aeolian (C Minor), flattening the root creates a scale with the intervals 3H-H-W-W-H-W-H. I don't know what this is called and I couldn't find anything about it online, so maybe someone here can help me figure out what to call it. It is similar to the B altered/super-locrian scale, but the 5th and 6th degree are raised a half-step. It sounds mysterious, but not as dark and creepy as B altered. Following the pattern as we have gone form major to Lydian to Super-Lydian, would this be B Super-Super-Lydian? B Hyper-Lydian?
      Let's keep going. If you start with C Dorian, flattening the root creates a scale with the intervals 3H-H-W-W-W-H-H. B Triple-Super-Lydian? It sounds pretty similar to the previous one.
      Next, C Mixolydian. Flatten the C and we get the intervals 3H-W-H-W-W-H-H. We're 4 modes above Lydian now, and this one sounds really interesting and different from Triple-Super-Lydian, because we changed the third degree. It sounds really bright now and the first 4 notes make a really cool pattern.
      Finally, C major. I suppose the pattern stops here because we already have a B in the scale, so lowering the C to a B no longer creates 7 intervals. In other words, starting with B major, if we try to sharpen everything, we can't because sharpening the 7th just gives us the root.

    • @ThePredatorYT-kl9dr
      @ThePredatorYT-kl9dr Před 4 lety +17

      Chris Kennedy Actually...
      C mixolydian: F Major
      C Dorian: Bb Major
      C minor: Eb Major
      C Phrygian: Ab Major
      C locrian: Db Major
      C Lydian: G Major

    • @Wind-nj5xz
      @Wind-nj5xz Před 3 lety +7

      @@txcy8941 Similarly, you can also use that same logic to go darker, since the only difference between lydian and locrian is the root and so is the only difference between super locrian and major, you can go darker by flattening the 7th in super locrian just like mixolydian flattens the 7th in major, that would give you a scale called ultra locrian, if you flatten the third just like dorian does compared to mixolydian, you get ultra locrian bb3, and if you flatten the 6th just like aeolian does compared to dorian you get ultra locrian bb2 bb6, and that's as dark as you can go really because if you kept going you'd have a bb2 wich would just give you the root

    • @anthonyspare
      @anthonyspare Před 3 lety +2

      wowzers, you have opened a new gate for me.

    • @lolwhatever7307
      @lolwhatever7307 Před 2 lety +9

      Damn, this comment just completed my modes puzzle

  • @olonowak663
    @olonowak663 Před 3 lety +109

    Expert: Locrian is unusable, it's too dark and unsettling
    Me: *cries in metal*

  • @verchojanskij
    @verchojanskij Před 4 lety +479

    What I really like about this way of puting the modes on a darker-brighter scale, is that dorian is perfectly in the middle. So you can say that Dorian is Gray ?
    It also happens to be my name, that's why I like to point this out.

    • @nuncanadie331
      @nuncanadie331 Před 2 lety +5

      😄

    • @LFiles48
      @LFiles48 Před 2 lety +9

      @@nuncanadie331 "Dorian can also create a sense of bittersweet sadnes".
      Touché, David (it's my first name too)

    • @richardrichard5409
      @richardrichard5409 Před 2 lety

      Birds Of A Feather....

    • @pablojlascano8322
      @pablojlascano8322 Před 2 lety +8

      another peculiarity of dorian mode: a palindrome, exact same structure from top to bottom, bottom to top...

    • @abbesatty9498
      @abbesatty9498 Před rokem +8

      @@pablojlascano8322 Yeah, every single one of the 7 modes mirrors another mode except the Dorian, it's like, "Nah, I'm fine, I will just go and mirror myself".

  • @MemeSnack
    @MemeSnack Před 4 lety +1022

    "Mad World is in the key of F"
    *Oh yeah, it's all coming together.*

  • @gregoryhenry8464
    @gregoryhenry8464 Před 4 lety +176

    From the bottom of my heart, thank you for adding examples when you talk about the scales.

  • @notsilvi
    @notsilvi Před 4 lety +457

    basic people:
    minor is sad!!! major is happy!
    me: *laughs in Polish traditional music*

    • @rize12dz37
      @rize12dz37 Před 3 lety +2

      oooh hi silvi

    • @notsilvi
      @notsilvi Před 3 lety +3

      @@rize12dz37 hiii

    • @zaczus
      @zaczus Před 2 lety +2

      oj, tak!

    • @jorgek92
      @jorgek92 Před 2 lety +15

      Cumbia is mostly in minor and it is danceable and happy

    • @hergergy
      @hergergy Před 2 lety

      what a surprise to see you here!

  • @AndrusPr8
    @AndrusPr8 Před 3 lety +86

    Locrian is fantastic to use of you want to compose battle music since its so tenseful!
    The only problem I find myself is constantly going home since my ear tries to leave to another scale instinctively

    • @bigbirdmusic8199
      @bigbirdmusic8199 Před rokem +3

      From my understanding a diminished triad can resolve to I think 3 or 4 different keys depending on whether or not its a dim7 so that makes sense

  • @EllisThings
    @EllisThings Před 4 lety +1464

    I sharpened all the notes so Db major is the brightest scale. No wait...

    • @clipsmasterproductions7479
      @clipsmasterproductions7479 Před 4 lety +30

      EllisThings lol 😂

    • @otemachi4317
      @otemachi4317 Před 4 lety +26

      Make it efficient, make it halftone up.

    • @rabbitguy337
      @rabbitguy337 Před 4 lety +11

      EllisThings E makor

    • @uilium
      @uilium Před 4 lety +5

      Hey, that's not righ... No wait....

    • @filipilif
      @filipilif Před 4 lety +52

      Db has 5 flats, if you sharpen all the notes you get C# major - obviously it sounds the same but the technicality itself is funny :)

  • @stefan1024
    @stefan1024 Před 4 lety +137

    Bernstein freakin' out to the Kinks made my day! :D

  • @rageprod
    @rageprod Před 4 lety +371

    You forgot the best use of dorian: epic and inspiring sounding fantasy music.
    Rohan and Gondor's themes (LOTR) are some good examples.

    • @fennglordd6365
      @fennglordd6365 Před 3 lety +10

      Dorian has a nice antiquated flavor and it is a palindrome. The bottom half of a Dorian is a mirror of the top half

    • @gknipe
      @gknipe Před 2 lety +54

      Some of the LOTR score is in Lothlorian mode.

    • @catherinereason5374
      @catherinereason5374 Před 2 lety +4

      @@gknipe ok funny guy

    • @jojoyear
      @jojoyear Před 2 lety

      Ugh. 🤮

    • @c3nturin896
      @c3nturin896 Před 2 lety

      just the end of "exist" from avenged sevenfold made me really consider this mode more because of how great it sounded.

  • @leemurray9330
    @leemurray9330 Před 3 lety +2

    Ukulele player here and OH MY GOODNESS this is the actual best explanation of the way modes work I've ever seen. I finally understand it.

  • @lividphysics1237
    @lividphysics1237 Před 4 lety +384

    Watching Bernstein sing The Kinks really threw me off.

    • @zebratangozebra
      @zebratangozebra Před 4 lety +16

      Kinks had some great stuff

    • @matteframe
      @matteframe Před 4 lety +24

      Watching a bunch of 10 year olds getting excited about it made me sad for children today who don't even learn music theory in an average school.

    • @fearitselfpinball8912
      @fearitselfpinball8912 Před 3 lety +3

      I know. It’s funny how Bernstein plays a few bars and is like - see nothing mysterious here - just good old Mixolydian mode! (Sounds absolutely appalling and nothing like the kinks)...
      This is where theory, in reducing a problem down to it’s most fundamental components fails miserably. (Which I find fascinating).
      It’s like trying to understand why humans fall in love by starting with an X-Ray Machine. Science is on his side and Bernstein’s got the bare bones of the problem but in reality, most of it has escaped him.

  • @Brillemeister
    @Brillemeister Před 4 lety +95

    You've inspired me to attempt writing a song in Super Locrian. Nice going. God bless

    • @Masdylon
      @Masdylon Před 4 lety +7

      It's just the altered scale. You can use it over any dominant chord in any song and it will work. Jazz players have been doing it for decades.

    • @jonadabtheunsightly
      @jonadabtheunsightly Před 3 lety +5

      Bonus points if you can pull off a convincing parade march in super locrian.

  • @johnbobbypringle
    @johnbobbypringle Před 2 lety +18

    I have been playing piano for 20 years and only found out about modes last night when my friend doing a bachelor's in music told me about them. He didn't understand it very well and was seeking my help but after he showed me a small bit, I was able to help him understand it by applying my knowledge of the major and minor modes to them. I feel like I wrote a hundred new songs today. I'm watching this video now and it's just overwhelming. How have I missed this? Has it been a secret?

  • @sskuk1095
    @sskuk1095 Před 3 lety +29

    Locrian music: *exists*
    Metal musicians: Why do I hear boss music?

  • @Zurbagan001
    @Zurbagan001 Před 4 lety +41

    It is the best explanation of scales I have ever seen.

    • @Th3Cr0ss1ng
      @Th3Cr0ss1ng Před 4 lety +1

      You should also check out Signals Music Studio, Jake Lizzio does a really good job too

  • @objectivitycave11
    @objectivitycave11 Před 4 lety +51

    As some one who
    Doesn’t understand theory at all.. thank you. This made
    Sense

    • @robinchesterfield42
      @robinchesterfield42 Před 4 lety

      Now I'm sitting here trying to figure out how many songs I've known forever are actually in modes with names I've never heard of until now, and WHICH ones they're in... I mean, my dumb un-musically educated brain is just like "Duh, song had half-step instead of full step! Song must be minor!" a lot of the time. :P

    • @objectivitycave11
      @objectivitycave11 Před 4 lety

      @@robinchesterfield42 when johnny comes marching home is dark. check out the locrian scale.. it is one of my favorite melodies for living in this satanic kingdom of lies, rape and murder

    • @jonnybuijze1770
      @jonnybuijze1770 Před 3 lety

      This reads like slam poetry

  • @SillyWillyFan47
    @SillyWillyFan47 Před 4 lety +45

    Your brightness / darkness image perfectly encapsulates how we feel about the different modes.
    Love your Synesthesia-like use of *light* to illustrate *sound*

  • @OneRadicalDreamer
    @OneRadicalDreamer Před 3 lety +36

    I'm a musical newbie and I've been slowly learning my scales, but lordy you are a fantastic teacher! Being able to visually, metaphorically and audibly present it all so concisely is a real treat!

  • @victorhugotoledocofre1366
    @victorhugotoledocofre1366 Před 4 lety +182

    Mr. Bernstein's final speech left me hanging on a cliff and wanting for more

    • @DavidBennettPiano
      @DavidBennettPiano  Před 4 lety +33

      go watch the whole lecture! It's linked in the description.

    • @leocomerford
      @leocomerford Před 4 lety +9

      Here you go: czcams.com/video/EWtUCAYV3so/video.html . (While we're at it, here's the whole of "What is a Mode?" together in a playlist: czcams.com/video/UGTT_VK2kVY/video.html .)

    • @scriabinismydog2439
      @scriabinismydog2439 Před 4 lety +3

      Ah, the Bernstein lectures are the greatest I've ever watched.

    • @StratMatt777
      @StratMatt777 Před 4 lety +1

      @@leocomerford Thanks, Leo!

    • @felipemeirelles1816
      @felipemeirelles1816 Před 4 lety +5

      It was a Locrian end, urges for resolution

  • @laurenzpelster2499
    @laurenzpelster2499 Před 4 lety +274

    This Dorian "i-IV" might be my favorite combination of two chords. Also found in Earth Song by Michael Jackson or Breath by Pink Floyd.

    • @deliusmyth5063
      @deliusmyth5063 Před 4 lety +9

      Do you like the theme from The Good, The Bad and The Ugly?

    • @DavidBennettPiano
      @DavidBennettPiano  Před 4 lety +52

      It's 'the dorian vamp'... basically the whole dorian scale summed up in two chords!

    • @deliusmyth5063
      @deliusmyth5063 Před 4 lety +5

      David Bennett Piano I always think of Dorian in terms of the chords: Heard It Through The Grapevine, She's Not There, Walk On By etc ( and disco, of course!).

    • @kkzj72
      @kkzj72 Před 4 lety +1

      Good Times

    • @AlexKnauth
      @AlexKnauth Před 4 lety +5

      And I really like how that Dorian "i-IV" is used in the Rohan theme from LotR, and Rey's theme from Star Wars

  • @jukes4499
    @jukes4499 Před 2 lety +14

    Thank you so much for this. Other videos just talk about how a mode is constructed. Knowing what their actual uses are is truly empowering as a musician. Now I know *why* a song would use notes "outside" the key it's in.

  • @SpartanLaserCanon
    @SpartanLaserCanon Před 2 lety +15

    Melodic Minor always created mysterious and wonder kind of vibes no matter when it has been played lol.

  • @ClassicalGuitarcia
    @ClassicalGuitarcia Před 4 lety +26

    What’s amazing about this is that the brightness scale directly correlates to the whole/half step patterns of the scales. the scales with retrograde step patterns are exactly the same distance away from the center (Dorian) as their inverse scale eg. locrian/Lydian, Phrygian/Ionian, mixolydian/aeolian. Dorian having no inverse being the neutral scale

  • @ClipofTheDayy
    @ClipofTheDayy Před 4 lety +165

    All the way on the right is the : Whole tone scale.

    • @babykano69
      @babykano69 Před 4 lety +16

      Major pentatonic is the brightest, prove me wrong

    • @chrisjfox8715
      @chrisjfox8715 Před 4 lety +1

      Conan Obrien

    • @yarlodek5842
      @yarlodek5842 Před 2 lety +1

      The whole tone scale could either be absolutely horrific like a slow decent into hell, or like that music that plays before a character has a flashback. It just depends on if you play it ascending or descending.

  • @kubaj8397
    @kubaj8397 Před 2 lety +177

    Lydian: Dreamy, Wonderful
    Major: Happy, Uplifting
    Mixolydian: Nostalgic
    Dorian: Melancholic
    Minor: Sad
    Phrygian: Evil
    Locrian: Dark

    • @RohannvanRensburg
      @RohannvanRensburg Před rokem +38

      Interesting how different people interpret that.
      Could just as easily be:
      Lydian: Mysterious, whimsical
      Major: Safe, happy
      Mixolydian: Adventurous
      Dorian: Regal, sombre, proud
      Minor: Melancholic
      Phrygian: Exotic, otherworldly
      Locrian: Tense, foreboding

    • @legato29
      @legato29 Před rokem +9

      @@RohannvanRensburg This is exactly how I interpret them too (especially mixolydian=adventure).

    • @piadas804
      @piadas804 Před rokem

      Locrian is evil because of diminished tonic

    • @ninj-as7710
      @ninj-as7710 Před rokem

      What about the blues scale?

    • @RohannvanRensburg
      @RohannvanRensburg Před rokem +2

      @@ninj-as7710 Just sounds like blues to me 😂

  • @alberto23
    @alberto23 Před 3 lety +12

    This video is superb... Even brighter than a Lydyan augmented mode scale. Amazing good examples of the modes also. Thanks!

  • @hiiambarney4489
    @hiiambarney4489 Před 4 lety +153

    The audacity to play binary sunset TWICE without it's melodic resolution... I had to unsub twice... Which means I'm subbed now... GOD DAMN YOU!

  • @aaronclift
    @aaronclift Před 4 lety +41

    I would love to see a followup video in which you discuss the brightness/darkness of the melodic minor modes such as Dorian b2 and Lydian Dominant. P.S. That Leonard Bernstein demonstration of Myxolydian mode made me smile.

  • @loyalegan9501
    @loyalegan9501 Před 2 lety +8

    Honestly I just love how you make all of this so clear and then illustrate how it works in practice, its effects, etc. Love it!

  • @guitarob
    @guitarob Před 3 lety

    This is brilliant. For years I've been trying to visualise what all these scales mean and you have done it in one video. Thanks so much for this and for all your other fascinating videos too.

  • @elietheprof5678
    @elietheprof5678 Před 4 lety +42

    You can also look at it on the circle of fifths:
    Lydian: root note + the next 6 fifths upward of the root
    Ionian: root note + 5 fifths upward, 1 fifth below
    Mixolydian: root + 4 fifths upward, 2 fifths below
    Dorian: root + 3 upward, 3 below (symmetrical)
    Aeolian: root + 2 upward, 4 below
    Phrygian: root + 1 upward, 5 below
    Locrian: root + 6 below
    Super Locrian: pattern is broken

    • @NagoyaHouseHead
      @NagoyaHouseHead Před 2 lety +2

      Wow, so the Dorian really is the the most balanced mode !

    • @thisisnotmyname4700
      @thisisnotmyname4700 Před rokem

      Can someone please explain this to me?

    • @thisisnotmyname4700
      @thisisnotmyname4700 Před rokem

      Nevermind, got it. 😊

    • @smaradav_
      @smaradav_ Před rokem +1

      @@thisisnotmyname4700 actually I'm still not getting it hah so if you could explain that would be fantastic!

    • @thisisnotmyname4700
      @thisisnotmyname4700 Před rokem +1

      @@smaradav_ Haha I had to revisit as I was confused again. Ok so they are saying that the 'scale' you use for each mode is as above. Pick any key then count. Say C. Lydian will have C, G, D, A, E, B, and F#. Just following the fifths around the circle. Does that make sense? That is the same as saying C, D, E, F#, G, A, B. Or saying Lydian is raised fourth.

  • @Xplayer007
    @Xplayer007 Před 4 lety +491

    But what about super-ultra-hyper-mega-meta-lydian? :P

    • @DavidBennettPiano
      @DavidBennettPiano  Před 4 lety +147

      I was actually thinking about this when I was writing the script! If I made the spectrum long enough for that scale though it wouldn't fit into the dimensions of a youtube video!

    • @rarebeeph1783
      @rarebeeph1783 Před 4 lety +56

      tfw so bright you have sharpened octaves

    • @toodsf1
      @toodsf1 Před 4 lety +13

      Pretty difficult to compare when S-U-H-M-M-Lydian doesn’t repeat at the octave, basically a 48-note scale 😂. Can’t belong to any key either.
      I think it’s mostly a harmonic tool, nothing to stop ya using it like a scale tho I guess ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

    • @MaladyKayjo
      @MaladyKayjo Před 4 lety

      Xplayer007 that would be sickening

    • @littlefishbigmountain
      @littlefishbigmountain Před 4 lety +7

      Jayjay McFly
      I believe Jacob Collier coined the term

  • @Ihatemyusernamemore
    @Ihatemyusernamemore Před 2 lety +5

    Here's how I categorize the modes, according to the kind of impression I believe that mode is best for conveying generally in compositions, obviously there's exceptions to all of them
    Ionian- Euphoric
    Dorian- Chill
    Phrygian- Intense
    Lydian- Transcendent
    Mixolydian- Dreamy
    Aeolian- Epic
    Locrian-Murky
    I also visualize major modes as men, minor modes as women, and locrian as something that's half human half beast, this is more arbitrary but it helped me visualize them when I was learning the modes years back

  • @janesmith9628
    @janesmith9628 Před rokem +2

    I loved this. Not only a great visual explanation showing the spectrum, but fantastic to hear the examples. Thanks !!

  • @charlesreynolds2694
    @charlesreynolds2694 Před 4 lety +25

    The Locrian mode or its chord the “minor 7 flat 5” is used all the time in Jazz just not necessarily in pop and rock. It’s normally used in a 7-3-6 progression and you can also use the “Locrian natural 2” scale over the 7 as well for a “brighter Locrian sound” lol!

    • @moses9647
      @moses9647 Před 3 lety +2

      I often consider the minor 7 flat 5 as a negative harmony chord sub for the V7. Or perhaps a Locrian modal interchange. In either sense I think it'd be rare to find a song rooted firmly in Locrian mode, even a jazz song. But I'm slowly transitioning from classical to jazz so there's still lots for me to learn

  • @kenhymes4900
    @kenhymes4900 Před 4 lety +4

    When I teach modes for pop composition and part writing, i call Ionian Bright Major, Dorian Bright Minor, Mixolydian Dark Major, and Aeolian Dark Minor. Aside from the increased use of harmonic minor since the 90s, these four modes and interchange between them cover the vast majority of progressions. Great channel, so much theory writing and presentation is just impractical and... theoretical. You are consistently on target about what's going on in an applicable fashion.

  • @emoakland5339
    @emoakland5339 Před 3 lety +5

    I thoroughly enjoyed your videos on modes. You’ve presented modes in a practical way that is easy to understand. Thank you very much.

  • @bsharpmajorscale
    @bsharpmajorscale Před 3 lety +21

    Never did I think I'd hear Leonard Bernstein sing "You Really Got Me."
    Also, is part of the opening of JJBA Part 4 (Great Days) in Dorian?

  • @dougsteeleguitar
    @dougsteeleguitar Před 4 lety +27

    You rock. Trent Reznor uses a lot of Mixolydian for vocal lines, and I like to think of dorian as 'cool blues'. It's so nice that you gave a shoutout to another CZcamsr. You're all class!! Subbed.

  • @luisd.alfaro9362
    @luisd.alfaro9362 Před 4 lety +5

    Magnificent explanation. First time I see the relationship between the modes and their practical uses.

  • @sneekinaboutom9450
    @sneekinaboutom9450 Před 3 lety

    What a superb video! Thank you very much indeed! I'd say this is the best video on modes I have come across on CZcams...

  • @jamesh4521
    @jamesh4521 Před 3 lety +1

    Your explanations digging into the why of things, like with the 7th degree of Mixolydian (or even this video as a whole) make you the best source for understanding theory that I've ever found. Thank you for all the great videos!

  • @ianisaacs2340
    @ianisaacs2340 Před 4 lety +5

    The most helpful resource I have ever found on modes! Thank you

  • @darinahing4450
    @darinahing4450 Před 4 lety +4

    Great video David, this approach to the modes is really helpful in thinking about how to express musical moods in actual notes.

  • @EROKOJR
    @EROKOJR Před měsícem

    This is BY FAR the best explanation of the modes I've ever heard. Thanks so much 🙂

  • @majorse000
    @majorse000 Před rokem +2

    Lydian Augmented: why am I in heaven?
    Lydian: nice but sounds kinda off
    Ionian (also known as major): The scale that you learn in school
    Mixolydian: Ionian's cooler brother
    Dorian: in the middle of the spectrum
    Aeolian (also known as minor): sadness intensifies
    Phrygian: help
    Locrian: standing in the shadow
    Super Locrian: "What do we say to the god of death?" "Thank you!"

  • @awsinger1
    @awsinger1 Před 4 lety +4

    I get shivers down my spine when you explain these things!

  • @jlbenj01
    @jlbenj01 Před 4 lety +9

    Just subscribed. I loved the way you broke it down and how sharps and flats affect the moods of the modes. Up to now I’ve used the white note hack and transpose it back to the root. But this I can remember and will surely use.

  • @fabiangutierrez339
    @fabiangutierrez339 Před 4 lety +443

    Hello, I'm some non-musician who thinks only in terms of closed-minded "happy" and "sad." Here are my conclusions:
    Lydian Augmented - Oh my God I'm drunk...
    Lydian - Actual Happiness
    Ionian - Empty Happiness
    Mixolydian - Kinky
    Dorian - Sentimental
    Minor - Kinda Sad
    Phrygian - Completely Depressed
    Locrian - Psychotic
    Super Locrian - I feel like killing somebody...

    • @KickenItOldSchool
      @KickenItOldSchool Před 4 lety +20

      I think you nailed it except for Phrygian is actually more brooding, but it does depend how the song is using it

    • @kylieisaloser144
      @kylieisaloser144 Před 4 lety +13

      kinky lmfao

    • @matteframe
      @matteframe Před 4 lety

      Lol nice

    • @blazicgd
      @blazicgd Před 4 lety +2

      “Hmmm kinky!”

    • @redhotlizard2636
      @redhotlizard2636 Před 4 lety +5

      I guess that would make Super Locrian bb7's description "Full Blown Psychopath."

  • @boomieboo
    @boomieboo Před 3 lety +3

    I LOVED this lesson. It was so clearly explained and illustrative. Thanks so much for doing it!

  • @martynkentfrancis
    @martynkentfrancis Před 4 lety +3

    Really useful quick reference and easy to understand guide. Best explanation of modes I’ve heard 🙏

  • @yvanspijk
    @yvanspijk Před 4 lety +14

    Great video once again! I love the way you explain things. Looking forward to your next video!

  • @megaFIKUS
    @megaFIKUS Před 2 lety +1

    This is a great explanation of modes, actually helped me finally starting to understand them and their uses, examples helped a lot as well, well done!

  • @SamuelPeckman
    @SamuelPeckman Před 4 lety +2

    You have thrown light on this subject. Thank you.

  • @belguitars7102
    @belguitars7102 Před 4 lety +4

    Fantastic video outlining a framework I was not aware of, this really helps me to conceptualise all the modal interaction, brilliant, keep up the great work!!!

  • @bsul03420
    @bsul03420 Před 4 lety +9

    An excellent perspective on the modes - many thanks, David.

  • @stevenewsome7294
    @stevenewsome7294 Před 6 měsíci +1

    The way you approach music is tremendous and inspiring. It helps unlock other avenues of expression. I apply these concepts to guitar. Thank you for sharing your gift

  • @wavelength3856
    @wavelength3856 Před 3 lety

    Superb video; I absolutely love the way you play relevant music to the point you're trying to make and painstakingly note which notes are used and where so that laymen like myself can understand what's really making a note or chord "pop' in a certain way. Thanks!!

  • @thomasbrindle7308
    @thomasbrindle7308 Před 3 lety +7

    Thank YOU SOO MUCH DAVID!! This makes things SO much easier to understand, after ive been learning the wrong way for ages!

  • @EugenePanfilov
    @EugenePanfilov Před 4 lety +3

    Oh, now it all makes sense and seems like I'm starting to understand (or even remember) most of those modes. Thank you SO much!

  • @scottall71
    @scottall71 Před 4 lety

    Love your technical music videos! You have laid out all of these music concepts in a great way using practical examples (excellent Star Wars references!) As a guitarist of over 20 years, never was able to understand how these modes & scales are used. I mean, playing straight pentatonic major your entire life can give some enjoyment, but you are really showing the incredible world of sound in your presentations.

  • @neilblack6265
    @neilblack6265 Před 2 lety

    Clearest description I have ever heard of the modes and relations to Major / Minor. Thank you

  • @baronmorris
    @baronmorris Před 4 lety +4

    Brilliantly explained. Thank you so much. ♥️

  • @rjmarlow8229
    @rjmarlow8229 Před 4 lety +3

    This video was so interesting and helpful. Thank you!

  • @cosmosinspiredproduction6850

    This was great! I had really no conception about any of these modes and now I understand that they are modes that are outside of the classic major and minor scales. Even better, I now understand how they fit into a spectrum that is super easy to understand. Thank you!

  • @ClueFinderDirtDigger
    @ClueFinderDirtDigger Před 4 lety

    This has never made more sense to me than it does right now. Thank you so much for your detailed explanation. 😍

  • @benjiantoniomarcano4956
    @benjiantoniomarcano4956 Před 4 lety +6

    Incredible video, as a musician who missed out on a lot on music theory during school, this video really helped me learn a basic knowledge of modes that I've been missing for a long time. Thank you so much, keep making these videos!

    • @DavidBennettPiano
      @DavidBennettPiano  Před 4 lety +3

      You're very welcome! At my school, modes were taught in a very dry manner... 100% theory, 0% application or examples!

  • @emilianocarlucci2428
    @emilianocarlucci2428 Před 4 lety +6

    Great video! Real life exemples let us understand better the sound of modes. Thanks again

  • @hi_im_ALLYSE
    @hi_im_ALLYSE Před 3 lety

    This might be the most useful breakdown of the modes I’ve ever seen. Thank you!

  • @musikheller3452
    @musikheller3452 Před 3 lety

    I think for a long time I havent seen such a good and proficient (as well as didactically as technical) video about music theory and modes in specific! Bravooooo!!! And thanks mate!

  • @jacobkilstrom
    @jacobkilstrom Před 3 lety +9

    Mixolydian and dorian is my favourite scales while composing music! I think other scales than the common minor and major should be used more often.

  • @on_certainty
    @on_certainty Před 4 lety +4

    this explains why a song i'm writing sounds too saccharine when i go from phrygian to major suddenly, but i now realize that it will work as an ending release!

  • @erikjohnson2976
    @erikjohnson2976 Před 4 lety

    Absolutely fantastic overview of modes; in face, the best I've ever come across. Many thanks, sir.

  • @alexwalli
    @alexwalli Před 3 lety

    Man thank you so much for this! Looking at modes like this is incredibly useful and so easy to use at the same time as you just wander around the circle of fifths while staying on the tonic. I never could wrap my head around modes. All this altering the starting point on the scale nonsense... Finally something that makes sense! Beautiful!

  • @tomostinato2918
    @tomostinato2918 Před 4 lety +11

    Modes simplified. Brilliant!

  • @sc6155
    @sc6155 Před 4 lety +31

    "So hello and goodbye to the Locrian mode." lmao 😂

  • @rowennahandy6292
    @rowennahandy6292 Před 4 lety

    Thanks for this video! The idea of a spectrum of darkness-brightness makes so much sense. It's so helpful to have those musical examples.

  • @stephencolemusic
    @stephencolemusic Před 2 lety

    One of the best videos on modes that I’ve ever seen!

  • @billjohnson6300
    @billjohnson6300 Před 4 lety +3

    Great lesson! Thank you David.

  • @alogentforbin7190
    @alogentforbin7190 Před 4 lety +82

    very excited to find out what super locrian is

    • @oneeyemonster3262
      @oneeyemonster3262 Před 4 lety +7

      it's just the 7th mode of the melodic min scale...loc b4...
      the ion #4,#5 is just the 3rd mode of the melodic min scale.
      YOu can go like this...Push UP from A min towards A MAJOR.
      b3, b6, b7
      b3, b6 Harmonic min G#
      b3 Melodic min F#, G#
      b3 #4 Melodic min #4 D# F# G#
      b6 Harmonic MAJOR C#
      b3, b5 b6 Harmonic min b5 Eb, G#
      b2, b3 b6 Harmonic min b2 Bb, G#
      b3, #4, b6 Harmonic min #4 D#, G#
      b2, b3 Melodic min b2 Bb, F#, G#
      b3, b5 Melodic min b5 Eb, F#, G#
      Ion #6 That's the A # note.
      A MAJOR C#, F#, G#
      You can also reverse the process...Push DOWN from C MAJOR towards min
      Use the 5 BLACKs on the keyboard to guide you.
      b6 = Harmonic MAJOR
      b3 = Melodic min
      b3, b6 = Harmonic min
      b3, b6, b7 = Natural min
      b3, #4
      b3, b5
      b2, b3
      b2, b3, b6
      b3, b5, b6
      b3, #4 b6
      it'll give 70-ea different MODES ( INTERVALS) 7 notes scales...variations.
      They had to term them something....I wasnt alive or greek at the time.
      I personally dont care what you term it..as long you know what the intervals
      are....Think of me as an eskimo..that dosnt speak, greek, english, german. french. chinese, spanish, french, italian...ect

    •  Před 4 lety +1

      It's just the altered scale. You can think of it as all tones of the major scale flatted, except for 1. There you go.

    • @oneeyemonster3262
      @oneeyemonster3262 Před 4 lety

      @
      you could go like this too.
      Aeo Maj7 = harmonic min
      dor maj7 = Melodic min
      phry maj7 = harmonic min b2
      mix maj7 = ionian
      loc Maj7 = Mix #2
      The only different between dorian and aeo is maj6 or b6
      dor b2 maj7
      dor #4 maj7
      dor b5 Maj7
      aeo b2 maj7
      aeo #4 Maj7
      aeo b5 Maj7
      if you play Harmonic min b5 and Melodic min b5 ( b6 and maj6)
      it's the Full diminished WHOLE/Half
      it;s 4th mode is Lydian dominant b2 or dorian b2, #4 ( Both)
      b3 and Maj3
      Which is FULL DIMINISHED HALF/WHOLE.
      Becuase it's SYMMETRICALS.
      or inverted 4th/5th
      Play the BOTH over the SAME ROOT. lol
      or if you start with the full dim whole/half..
      You could play the lydian dominant b2 ...with b3 and maj3
      over the 2. 4, b6, 7 chord degree
      or if you start the with full dim HALF/WHOLE
      you could play the harmonic min b5/ with maj6
      b2, 3, 5, b7 or 3, 5, b7, b9....note/chord degree...lol
      The N6 harmonic min b2 or melodic min b2 will make more sense..
      from A min.....i could play A lydian b3 ( possible dimished)
      A min....C dim in C# min/E MAJOR
      once in C# min....play D7 E7 into A min again.lmao
      That's applying the (N6)
      or D maj7 E7 F# min/A Major
      A harmonic MAJOR = D min/dim E7
      A Harmonic min = Dmin/dim E7
      Or you could had played...
      A min B dim C# dim into D min ( melodic min)
      But what if I DID NOT TELL you that... and simply played into
      the D min chord....
      or even do this,
      Amin, Bb maj7, B dim CMaj C# aug D min, Eb MAj E dim F Maj F# dim
      G Maj. G# dim into A min ????? lol
      G7 ( mix #4) A7 ( mix b6) into D min
      if you play Mix b6 with maj7 its just A HARMONIC MAJOR :-P
      or after you play the D min chord..You could had just play
      the Eb Maj7 chord to C MINOR
      G7 into C MAJOR or C min...works.
      but it's going to make all the sense in the world
      how you can basically play whatever chords over all 12 note degree
      and still be in C MAJOR/Amin.lol
      All 12 notes WORK.

    • @GodFirstnl
      @GodFirstnl Před 4 lety

      Haha had the same

    • @oneeyemonster3262
      @oneeyemonster3262 Před 4 lety +1

      @@GodFirstnl it's just the loc b4...
      all that means is jazz head playing it 1, b4, b7...omitng the b5.
      Then stacking the b9 on top... or 1, b4, b6 ( augmented)
      You could just play the phry b4...if you wanna play the 5th..fukkk it just play both ( modulate) so you'll have the tritone as a passing/option note.
      or you could just play the Mix #2, #4...alter them bicthes like this
      1, 3, 5, b7 or 1, #2, 5, b7....or 1, #2, #4 or 1, #2. #4, 6 or 1, #2, #4, b7
      You also get this loc b4, bb6, bb7 :-P
      This way the C# MAJOR (VII) will make sense to ya when you play A7 into D min..Then C # Maj , Bb min, G min C7 into F MAJOR...in What a wonderful world by Louis Armstrong.
      You could play the G min as G7 it'll just be the IV ( mix #4) of D melodic min ..Play G7 into C7 into F MAJOR..( II, IV, I) The II chord had been alter to a dominant or Major.
      The beatles did it all the time.. It donst have to be jazz
      Just in a different KEYs
      When you play STAIRWAY to HEAVEN..the second chord in the song.
      The G# AUGMENTED is borrow from A melodic min...or notes
      from the G# loc b4..The b3 is stack on top

  • @andirichards7149
    @andirichards7149 Před 4 lety

    Well done! Thank you for the examples with the different scales!

  • @joeyaliofficial
    @joeyaliofficial Před 2 lety

    Great vid man. This really helped me get a better understanding of the modes.

  • @FlavorsomeMusic
    @FlavorsomeMusic Před 2 lety +3

    I have been using quite a bit of phrygian because I loved its darker, more metal sound, but I didn't understand exactly why it sounded considerably darker, and I never understood any of the other modes. Now I understand modes and I can even "create" my own. Thank you for this precious information. =)

  • @joansalazar5884
    @joansalazar5884 Před 4 lety +5

    One interesting thing is that, when you flatten or sharpen a note to move between modes, you are always flattening or sharpening a note from the tritone, it doesn't matter in what mode you are. And if you are in locrian and you flatten the lower note of the tritone, you will end up with Lidian. Same, if you sharpen the upper note of the tritone in lydian, you end up in locrian . The modes are like a circle!

  • @whatchrisdoinmusic
    @whatchrisdoinmusic Před 11 měsíci

    Amazing video content! Great perspective and examples on the modes!

  • @jw0w757
    @jw0w757 Před 4 lety

    This was very useful and informative! Showing references and examples helped a lot as well! Thank you so much!

  • @BenedictGS
    @BenedictGS Před 4 lety +18

    this is my personal memo from my understanding circle of fifth and mode and scale
    C lydian ~ G major
    G mixolydian ~ C major
    Flydian ~ Cmajor
    A minor~C major
    This feels like magic

  • @Dack105
    @Dack105 Před 4 lety +449

    Your flattening/sharping of presumably random notes in the scale to get each new scale is not a great way of explaining it. If you sharpen the second note of a major you don't get a brighter sound.
    The way you're ordering the modes is by their construction. Each of the seven modes is built on a series of 5ths.
    Lydian is a series of 5ths ascending from the tonic ( [C] G D A E B F# )
    Ionian (Major) is 5 ascending, and 1 descending (F [C] G D A E B)
    Aolian (Minor) is 2 ascending, and 4 descending (Ab Eb Bb F [C] G D)

    • @wickedmonroe
      @wickedmonroe Před 4 lety +8

      True

    • @amj.composer
      @amj.composer Před 4 lety +3

      Well said

    • @austinmoser5056
      @austinmoser5056 Před 4 lety +33

      Just like if you were to sharpen the 7th degree in minor, your would get harmonic minor which is way darker than minor

    • @faustobrusamolino6345
      @faustobrusamolino6345 Před 4 lety +7

      The other way of finding a scale brightness in relation to another one is to play all the major scale modes, until completely internalizing them, and then create your own darkest to brightest sequence simply by using your ears.

    • @beatrixwickson8477
      @beatrixwickson8477 Před 4 lety +18

      Except they aren't random, the notes being altered is the circle or fifths. Starting from C Lydian, lower F#, then B, then E, then A, then D then G to get Locrian. The question I have is how do you compare two scales with the same brightness? Dorian, Double harmonic and Neapolitan Major all have the same brightness but sound very different. So is there a subtler distinction in brightness or another continuum upon which to arrange them?

  • @andy_hawkins
    @andy_hawkins Před 3 lety

    David, your videos are completely brilliant, thank you!

  • @cmenacez8748
    @cmenacez8748 Před 2 lety

    This video’s answered a question I’ve been asking myself for a long time. Thanks!!!