loved this video. I’m half Japanese and am fluent in both Japanese and English, but most Japanese people couldn’t tell u the different between when using で and に happy that i learned something about my native tongue today 😊
From what I understand, I know that で indicates that the word before it is a participant/instrument in the action, while に indicates that the word preceding it is the _target_ of the action.
So concise! The exceptions for ある、いる and すむ are what confused me so much. Now I just remember those take に because they're special/show existence and I'm (mostly) good. Existing is special, almost like... traveling through time? So に makes sense! (I make up stories like this to help myself remember.)
Thank you, I finally understand the difference between the two 🙏 The teacher at school didn't explain anything when teach で and に so I was confused for a very long time 😅
This means Japanese understood a connection between space and time when the language was invented. Anything relating to spacetime uses "ni" -- existence, moving between two distinct locations and referring to specific times. "de" describes what's happening at a location or at a specific time, but not what time it happens. And not motion that happens between two distinct locations. In this way, "de" is similar to "ga" and "ni" is similar to "wa" in that place or location is similar to a topic -- it's prerequisite background information a group needs to know before having a conversation about what's happening there.
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS!! I always get the particles mixed up and this helps me to clarify these two. Hopefully I can commit this to memory ;u; (Found your shorts yesterday and have found them really useful!!)
Wow, this is so useful! I haven't really studied particles too much since I'm currently working my way through learning kanji (currently know about 200 kanji, this is gonna take a while 😅). But I'm definitely saving this video in my playlist to watch again in the future so I can better understand the Japanese sentence structure. You're a great teacher! 👍😃
で is not restricted to certain verbs, it can also apply to be a means to do something or modify 用言, which can be verbs but also adjectives and nouns + copula. で tells us the boundary or limit of an action or state of being that is happening, which can be physical or metaphorical. One example for it being a limiting term would be: 世界で一番おいしいラーメン. In which we limit the ramen to being the best in the world. Saying that it only applies to certain verbs does more harm than good especially to people new to the language, and will be especially confusing when confronting natural Japanese. Ni can also be explained way easier. It indicates the target of an action, which can be a place, to which you can go to or you can be at. And if you say that it describes a target and not just a place you can also apply this knowledge to the reru/rareru & seru/saseru constructions to avoid further confusion.
I love your videos and this explanation is amazing, ありがとうございます! But how exactly does に differ from へ when using the motion verbs? Like would 銀行へ行きました and 銀行に行きました be equally acceptable and mean the same thing, or is there a difference? Again, love your content, お疲れ様でした!!
When speaking に and へ are usually interchangeable. When I speak, I don't use へ. But when it comes to lyrics or poems, people show a vague destination, for example, 明日へ(it's a title of a song). Tomorrow is not an exact place, so in that case, へ is used. But when we don't speak like that, so when we speak, I think に is more often used.
You could say that… but for example あ、あそこに猫がいるよ!oh, there’s a cat there! あ、いなくなっちゃった! oh, it’s gone! the time when there was a cat there could be very short 🤔
I learnt that it had to do with the action. If you're doing something and just happen to be in a specific place, you use で, but when the place is necessary for the action, you should use に. That way of thinking works in your examples, but am I right?
How about へ ?? It also indicates the destination? Is it right? For example, can we say that わたしはしごとへ いきます。I have seen this kind of sentence that my Japanese teacher have used. Where can we use へ if not ? What is the difference between に and へ? I often confuse whether to use particle へ or に when I want to say about destination. Thank in advance sensei.
@@SpeakJapaneseNaturally oh, OMG,thank you for responding me,of course take your time. I am living in Japan about around 16 years and I am still struggling with language,so it will be very helpful for me to get the explication and to can use it correctly. Thank you again very,very much! I appreciate a lot.🎀
I'm still learning so please correct me if i'm wrong (cmiiw). I usually try to "extend" the sentence so i can add subject+は(wa) and it sounds right, then the other one should be が (iirc you can't use the particle は more than once in a sentence). Exp: 本+?+あります in my mind if i try to add a subject, it becomes (私は)+本+が+あります. Another usage of が if i remember correctly (iirc) is that, when you have 2 subjects in 1 sentence (by combining 2 seperate sentences), you use は for the 1st subject and が for the 2nd subject. Exp: 今母は朝ごはんを食べています。だから、父は新聞をよんでいます。2 sentences with は particle each, when combined, because the 2nd subject is a different subject, the は becomes が. So: 今母は朝ごはんを食べていますから、父が新聞を読んでいます。
こんにちは、先生。 ご説明いただきありがとうございます。 What could be the difference between へ and に? Both describe the destination. For example the beautiful and talented Misia sings the wonderful song 明日へ。 "" czcams.com/video/jqd0wnW_HCI/video.html "" 明日 means tomorrow so I think 明日へ means something like..." In direction of tomorrow ". Can we say 明日に instead of 明日へ? またね。🤗
に and へ are interchangeable. But in speech, we use に more, and in lyrics and poems, へ is often used. It is said, へ is used when you're heading to a certain direction, and に is used when you approach a certain place and attach to it. But as I said earlier, I use に when I speak☺️
I started learning Japanese a few months ago. And finally I understood the difference between the two. ありがとうございます! It really helps a lot.
😄👍
Yes... I got it right! 😁
1. に
2. で
What I observed is that "de" can be more like "at, through, or via" compared to "ni" which is kinda more like "in," a destination/location marker.
Thank you for your lessons, and I want to tell you what a pleasant voice you have. Very smooth and calming.
Thank you, Bill san!!😊✨
ありがとうございます!I just started learning Japanese and I’m not this far yet, but this will be useful later!
loved this video. I’m half Japanese and am fluent in both Japanese and English, but most Japanese people couldn’t tell u the different between when using で and に
happy that i learned something about my native tongue today 😊
Thanks for sharing!!✨😊
You're the BEST!! Seriously. Clear, concise, super helpful.
Thank you!! I'm glad to hear that☺️✨
Your soft voice is so soothing. Thank you for the information
From what I understand, I know that で indicates that the word before it is a participant/instrument in the action, while に indicates that the word preceding it is the _target_ of the action.
I study japanese from november 2023, now i clear this two particle from your video..ありがとうございます.
A yt short taught me what I needed for last week's test ❤ I'm a sub now
Thank you for subscribing!
1.に
2.で
ありがとうございます❤
This hand waving at the end is so sweet. Love it. Great explanation, thank you!❤
Thank you 😊
ありがとうございます先生!❤️
ありがとうございます!❤
You are a great help
So concise! The exceptions for ある、いる and すむ are what confused me so much. Now I just remember those take に because they're special/show existence and I'm (mostly) good. Existing is special, almost like... traveling through time? So に makes sense! (I make up stories like this to help myself remember.)
Thank you 🙏
This has finally explained it. Ugh, I was wondering what the differences were. This makes sense now.
Watch more shorts about this particle helps me to understand more about it
Arigatou sensei
Subbed 🙏
Thank you, I finally understand the difference between the two 🙏 The teacher at school didn't explain anything when teach で and に so I was confused for a very long time 😅
Very clear!!!!! わかりやすい!
本当にありがとうございます、先生🙏🏻
this was so helpful, thank you!
waa so easy when u explain it! arigatou gozaimasu sensei💕
Many thanks for your teaching. i am grateful
😄👍
This means Japanese understood a connection between space and time when the language was invented. Anything relating to spacetime uses "ni" -- existence, moving between two distinct locations and referring to specific times.
"de" describes what's happening at a location or at a specific time, but not what time it happens. And not motion that happens between two distinct locations. In this way, "de" is similar to "ga" and "ni" is similar to "wa" in that place or location is similar to a topic -- it's prerequisite background information a group needs to know before having a conversation about what's happening there.
I was wondering why すんでいます
uses に thanks for the info
Super helpful, ありがとうございます!
yay very helpful! Thank you for the mini lesson!
Thank you
That's very helpful. Thank you.
My pleasure!😊✨
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS!! I always get the particles mixed up and this helps me to clarify these two. Hopefully I can commit this to memory ;u; (Found your shorts yesterday and have found them really useful!!)
Wow, this is so useful! I haven't really studied particles too much since I'm currently working my way through learning kanji (currently know about 200 kanji, this is gonna take a while 😅). But I'm definitely saving this video in my playlist to watch again in the future so I can better understand the Japanese sentence structure. You're a great teacher! 👍😃
ありがとうございます!
わかりました!ありがとうございます!
Very helpful, thank you!
It's such a great explanation!! Thank youuu 🥺🙏
My pleasure😊✨
わかりやすいです。ありがとうございます。🙏
😄😄
Particles are the hardest part of my Japanese language studies so far.
Explain was easy .ありがとうございます。
どういたしまして!!😄
で is not restricted to certain verbs, it can also apply to be a means to do something or modify 用言, which can be verbs but also adjectives and nouns + copula. で tells us the boundary or limit of an action or state of being that is happening, which can be physical or metaphorical. One example for it being a limiting term would be: 世界で一番おいしいラーメン. In which we limit the ramen to being the best in the world. Saying that it only applies to certain verbs does more harm than good especially to people new to the language, and will be especially confusing when confronting natural Japanese.
Ni can also be explained way easier. It indicates the target of an action, which can be a place, to which you can go to or you can be at. And if you say that it describes a target and not just a place you can also apply this knowledge to the reru/rareru & seru/saseru constructions to avoid further confusion.
I love your videos and this explanation is amazing, ありがとうございます!
But how exactly does に differ from へ when using the motion verbs? Like would 銀行へ行きました and 銀行に行きました be equally acceptable and mean the same thing, or is there a difference?
Again, love your content, お疲れ様でした!!
When speaking に and へ are usually interchangeable. When I speak, I don't use へ.
But when it comes to lyrics or poems, people show a vague destination, for example, 明日へ(it's a title of a song). Tomorrow is not an exact place, so in that case, へ is used. But when we don't speak like that, so when we speak, I think に is more often used.
@@SpeakJapaneseNaturally あぁ、そうそうですね!素晴らしい教師ですな!もう一度ありがとうございました!!!(apologies for any messiness in my Japanese wwww)
Thanks!
j dai-san, thank you so much for your support! I really appreciate it😊
@@SpeakJapaneseNaturally Not at all! Thank you for making all the wonderful and useful videos!
ああ!ビデオを見ていた後では分かり易くなっていました!一つ目の文は「に」を使って、二つ目の文は「で」を使いますね。
❤️
Thank you so much!! I have so much trouble with sentence particles 🥲
Thank you so much
Learnt something new today 🥰
So glad!😊
this is so helpful, thank you
My pleasure!!😊✨
Nice explanation! ❤
Super useful!
Glad to hear that!
I got the answer wrong in the end, that was an awesome test/example. Thanks a lot ふみさん
My second language is Japanese and I now just realised I never realised this, just intuited it.
ありがとうございます
😄👍
thank you 💜
😄✨
Super 👌. Thanks
😊✨🙌
thank you for this video! i finally understood this quickly haha
いく、くる、かえる=に to show movement to a place
いる、ある、すむ/すいんでる=に to show existence
It’s easier to know when to use で but I find it ambiguous somehow like hard to tell about using に
私わ日本にいます
今、家でCZcams を見ています
*は
We also learned that with ni you stay there for a longer time while de is just an action happening at a place.
You could say that… but for example
あ、あそこに猫がいるよ!oh, there’s a cat there!
あ、いなくなっちゃった! oh, it’s gone!
the time when there was a cat there could be very short 🤔
私は日本にいます
今、家でユーチューブを見ています
Konnichiwa sensei watasiwa neparu jin des
Nihon ni
Second one de
勉強仲間に文法について質問されたときに、日本語ですらうまく説明できなくて「ネイティブスピーカーだから」と逃げていました。
私には英語の文章の作り方や聞き取り練習にもなり、とても参考になります。ありがとうございます。
今後も活動、頑張ってください。、
ありがとうございます。
私も英語も日本語も勉強中です。
動画作成はいいアウトプットになってます😊✨
Can you do one for the difference between に and へ?
Here it is.
czcams.com/users/shortsLtCtWYH1AgI?si=Ay1SeUGpCO5kCwip
What about e/ni?
I learnt that it had to do with the action. If you're doing something and just happen to be in a specific place, you use で, but when the place is necessary for the action, you should use に. That way of thinking works in your examples, but am I right?
what is the difference between particles in japanese and prepositions in germanic and romance languages?
hi, how we can say control yourselfe in japanese?
when to use へ and に with verbs? We can also say がっこうへいきますInstead of がっこうにいます。Right?
For real it's still confusing sometimes
And what's about へ particle?
1. 私は日本 ( に ) います
2. 今、家 ( で ) ユーチューブ を見ています 🙏
かんぺきです!(Perfect)😁
@@SpeakJapaneseNaturally わー!!、教えてくれてありがとうございます、先生 😁🙏
I think it’s gakko e ikimasu ?
Yesssss i correct
Boku ha barito ni sunde imasu😂
Tokyo no tsukiji de nihongo wo benkyou shimashita
Is that correct?
Great explanation!
ありがとうございます!
Thank you!!😊✨
Sp when dp you use を?😅
However, for example このホテルで友達の結婚式があります。
「私は日本にいます」と「今、家でユーチューブを見ています」
I don't clean please explain me again. I usually use De😅
Remember not to use the ni particle with ガス.
So everything that involves the word
"At" is de?
How about へ ??
It also indicates the destination? Is it right?
For example, can we say that わたしはしごとへ いきます。I have seen this kind of sentence that my Japanese teacher have used.
Where can we use へ if not ?
What is the difference between に and へ?
I often confuse whether to use particle へ or に when I want to say about destination.
Thank in advance sensei.
What do you use for Yasumimasu ?
We say “yasumimasu” when we call workplace or school that you’re not coming today because of the sickness or some other reasons.
so de is an expression of a static location while ni is used for expressions of movement, is that correct?
Not really. When you say "there is/are 〜," you use に.
okay, thank you for correcting me! :)@@SpeakJapaneseNaturally
日本人だああああああやったぜ
どうもありがとうございます せんせい❤
Thank you for your information about japanese language.
Please,can you tell us when to use "ga" or "wa"? (Thank you!)
Ok, I’ll try, it won’t fit in 1 minute …. Please give me some time. I need time since this is a tough question to answer 😁
@@SpeakJapaneseNaturally oh, OMG,thank you for responding me,of course take your time.
I am living in Japan about around 16 years and I am still struggling with language,so it will be very helpful for me to get the explication and to can use it correctly.
Thank you again very,very much! I appreciate a lot.🎀
@dilfhound69 thank you !
I'm still learning so please correct me if i'm wrong (cmiiw). I usually try to "extend" the sentence so i can add subject+は(wa) and it sounds right, then the other one should be が (iirc you can't use the particle は more than once in a sentence). Exp:
本+?+あります in my mind if i try to add a subject, it becomes (私は)+本+が+あります.
Another usage of が if i remember correctly (iirc) is that, when you have 2 subjects in 1 sentence (by combining 2 seperate sentences), you use は for the 1st subject and が for the 2nd subject. Exp:
今母は朝ごはんを食べています。だから、父は新聞をよんでいます。2 sentences with は particle each, when combined, because the 2nd subject is a different subject, the は becomes が. So:
今母は朝ごはんを食べていますから、父が新聞を読んでいます。
Mam i have a doubt, where should we use "へ "could you please clear that for me
I’ll make a video about it😊
Thank you mam
how about ヘ?
This video will answer your question :)
czcams.com/users/shortsLtCtWYH1AgI?si=weaCq78nI5dh3VyS
Why do you use, wa and desu in the same sentence if the both mean is? I’m just really confused
Nvm I figured it out
ni ➡️ ( Koko ni ) sign shite kudasai masa ✔
に で
Thank you so much for this! Now I just need to understand へ versus those two 😅
I’m sure this video will be of some help.
The difference between に and へ | Japanese particles
czcams.com/users/shortsLtCtWYH1AgI?feature=share
Nakakalito Ang particles nakakagulo Ng utak
こんにちは、先生。
ご説明いただきありがとうございます。
What could be the difference between へ and に? Both describe the destination.
For example the beautiful and talented Misia sings the wonderful song 明日へ。
"" czcams.com/video/jqd0wnW_HCI/video.html ""
明日 means tomorrow so I think 明日へ means something like..." In direction of tomorrow ".
Can we say 明日に instead of 明日へ?
またね。🤗
に and へ are interchangeable.
But in speech, we use に more, and in lyrics and poems, へ is often used.
It is said, へ is used when you're heading to a certain direction, and に is used when you approach a certain place and attach to it. But as I said earlier, I use に when I speak☺️
純日本人なのに、なんで出てきたんだろうか。
文法をやり直せということだろうか・・・
😂😂
how i see it in my head で = here i/it/etc. に = to
に
で