Jinhao 100 vs Kaigelu 316a - Fountain Pen Showdown
Vložit
- čas přidán 25. 07. 2024
- The latest Fountain Pen First Impressions video is now available for your viewing pleasure.
In this video I am comparing:
The Jinhao 100 Centennial with Kobe No 60 Foreign Museum Mint ink
The Kaigelu 316a with Kobe No 60 Foreign Museum Mint ink.
Which pen will come out on top?
My CZcams Channels:
Fountain Pen Reviews: / @garryeves
Next Actions: / @nextactions
Tricky Little Questions: / @trickylittlequestions
You can follow me on
Facebook: / garry.eves
Instagram: / garryeves
Twitter: / garryeves
Patreon: / garryeves
The opinions are my own, based on my own experiences with the product. Not to be used for reference or as gospel.
00:00 Introduction
01:00 Body Walkthrough
06:31 Size Comparisons
09:44 Weights and Measures
12:22 Writing Sample
18:22 My Thoughts
Gary, thank you for all the work you do to share your knowledge and experience with us. I would like to share my opinion on one aspect of your presentation today. I realize that the general trend of you pen gurus is to try to match the ink to the color of the pen. This is great when the pen and ink are bold colors. When the ink is as faint as this light green, it is difficult to really evaluate on a computer screen. I saw that the Jinhao was having some hard starts, but it was difficult to be sure. With a deeper color your findings would have been more easily discerned. Also, in my own examples of Kaigelu 316A pens, the nibs seem to paint very wide (excessive) lines relative to the nib width; both fine and medium nibs.
👍
Enjoyed the head to head comparison, Garry. Great video. If Jinhao had that green resin, it would be the best of both worlds.
wow, great comparison, thanks for sharing Garry
Great video. These pens were meant to have a showdown, thanks!
I don’t have a Kaigelu 316a, but my Jinhao 100 Centennial hard-starts every single time. And I had to polish the nib to reduce the scratchiness enough to write. Not something I expected in an M nib. I’m not happy with it. No way I could use it to take notes because it would keep hard-starting, as if it had dried out for days. The ink in it should not cause issues: Waterman Auspicious Red.
Have yo tried pulling out the nib and feed, giving them a deep clean and putting back in?
@@GarryEves : No, so far I’ve been chicken to do that. Silly, since I really don’t like the pen’s current performance. I did flush out with pen flush and water before first use, as I always do. If I pull the nib and feed, should I pull straight out from the section?
@@catherinehubbard1167 I’ve got a video on my channel where is show how I change a nib on the 100. You can find it here -
czcams.com/video/J8Wl_xy5EPc/video.html
@@GarryEves : Thanks! I’ll try it, now that I have guidance.
Light coloured pens are aggravating. People who appreciate aesthetics usually respond very positively to Kaigelu colour combinations. My Kaigelus have a threaded converter so they stay in place. I have given these two pens as gifts so I can't check whether I have an earlier version of the pen.
👍
Hi, Gary. Great review on these 2 fountain pens, as always....Keep them coming.
I recently purchased a Kaigelu 316a in brown. Awesome look. It does stand out amongst my Jinhao pens.
But I have encountered a similar problem with the converter. When I tried to ink it up, converter failed to suck up the ink. I made sure the ink bottle was full of ink. I thought the converter was not inserted properly but it still did not pull any ink through the nib after a couple of tries, pushing it harder. I resorted to filing up the converter directly, instead of through the nib. And it does seem to work. I think you are right about the converter. I might swap it with a Jinhao converter and see how that goes.
The pen is very wet and very smooth too. It is perfect as a signing pen for special occasions.
👍
Excellent comparison.
For me, the Jinhao 100 performs better with any ink.
Nice comparison (apples to apples), Garry! Looks to be that Jinhao is the better value . Have you tried a converter swap? IE: Jinhao in the Kaigelu -- I think they are both "Chinese standard international" converters.BTW the weights and measures section, in my opinion, provides just the right information...there is no need for ultra-precise measurements. Great job with these videos. 😄
If I were watching this on public access television, I would've written you an angry letter about the "g" in "Weights" overlapping with the "M" in "Measures"
Have you seen the jinhao centennial 100 in the cream and brown color sold anywhere? It looks a bit like a latte. I've been looking everywhere and aliexpress is never in stock
I haven't, but saying that I haven't been looking at 100s for a while.
A very, very helpful review. the staining is probably a deal-killer for me, but I love the Jihhao quality! I have had so much success with the Jinhao 100 Centennial. I have given them away as gifts too, and each recipient has raved about them. I have had good luck with some Kaigelu 316 and 316a; however, I do not remember if I had that same converter. I would love to know how the Kaigelu performed if you try it with the Jinhao converter. It should fit. You would then know if the converter was the difference in performance (which I too suspect it is). Great job!
Thanks.
I've got a few Jinhao convertors, so will try swapping one in, thanks for the suggestion.
Heya Garry! I also have a KAIGELU 316a (m nib). However I've had no issues with flow, and I have had no issues with the converter falling out of it's spot. I honestly suspect that You have a DUD.
P.S.
I would love to see You use a proper slide caliper for Your "rules of measuring." And I also would love to see You use a higher sensitivity scale for Your "scales of weighing." These 2 additions would add sone excellence to Your devoted viewer's.
Thanks.
I do the measurements using a calliper. I'll experiment with doing that on screen.
Unfortunately I could only afford the kitchen scales. Eventually, I'd like to have a more expensive set, but thats not in the current plan.
The broader cap band covering the end of the barrel wins the battle. Although they are both nice.
Hey, which of these pens have a gold-plated nib?
Both nibs are two tone. Not sure if the gold is gold plating or some other gold coloured material.
Disappointed in the performance of the Kaigelu since I’ve heard great things about it over on the r/fp community. I have one in my AliExpress cart but now I’m reconsidering. Di you own the 356?
Not yet. It is on the list for future purchases.
I have leaned towards the 316a. However I just bought a 100 Skeleton and will reconsider my own thoughts on 316a. I am sorry that you had such a problem with the 316a. Mine has worked well.
Thanks. I do tend to be a bit nitpicky when I'm doing these. I do love my 316a.
@@GarryEves The converter is a bit odd, I would agree. But it has held tight if you push in the converter tightly.
Hi Garry, thank you for the great comparison video. Are the nib units interchangeable between the Jinhao 100 and Kaigelu 316a? Thanks!
They are both #6 nibs.
I've not tried swapping the full nib unit, but have pulled out the nib and feed and changed that way.
@@GarryEves thank you!