Gangubai's daughter speaks to outlook
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 08. 2024
- Up the flight of stairs in a dingy building in Gully No. 14 in Kamathipura, if you turn to your right, a passageway appears. Under the reddish glow, the bust of Gangubai cast in marble appears. An epitaph is there. Not much. Estd. 1981 by Sasa Ratna alias Aunty Family. It isn’t really a replica of hers if you compare with the photo that hangs in her adopted daughter’s one-room tenement in the twelfth lane.
Babbi is one of the many children Gangubai adopted. Across from Babbi’s room is Gangubai’s former living quarters, which is now a small factory.
Babbi says Gangubai Kathiawadi didn’t represent the real Gangubai.
For instance, there was no Ramnik Lal, she says.
#Kamathipura #OutlookMagazine #Gangubai
Click on the link below to read the full story www.outlookind...
I watched the movie the other day , glad I learned about this incredible strong women she was.
She is not her biological daughter.... But Everyone called her mother.... That's why they are daughter
the way she says Ma with pure heart 💖
🥺❤
Heartbreaking..😢😢 hope she finds peace and healing
Its sad how Gangubai initially wanted to be an actress but was, I assume, forced into becoming a sex worker due to circumstances and now after her death, she has a movie on her life which the privileged upper class ppl profit off of it. On the brighter side tho, to be able to hear her story is great and inspiring.
Why do you always think it that way abt them earning profit!! They could have made some other story or some other movie to earn profits but they chose to show the Gangubai side world to the world. Tbh before this movie, many of us didn't even know who she was. After the makers made the movie, kam se kam we know the legend now. Don't always blame Bollywood. When it's doing good, appreciate it. Hollywood ko support karte ho har dam but at least when Bollywood is trying to bring a change to it's movies perspective, try to respect it and encourage them, instead of being a Kangana, who is only making comments to make controversies.
@@rridhi8614 thats why i said on the brighter side we heard abt her and got to know her story and rightfully so what she did is commendable and deserves to be known. It's not really black and white, its not abt bollywood is good or bad, right or wrong and I acknowledge that. But also I do think that Gangubai's unfilled dreams and then afterwards a movie being made on her is ironic and deserves to be talked about too.
Also it makes us question right that who knows how many of struggling actress from lower or middle class families were not able to achieve what they wanted and probably were forced into the same as Gangubai.
@@embrace7052 yeah. Agreed.
@@rridhi8614 IKRRRRR LIKE THEY JUST ALWAYSSD BASH BOLLYWOOD 🏃♀️
@@rouzie9500 Yeah, they don't look at the good part. India and Bollywood has it's own history. People always are into the western trends and so the Hollywood craze and Bollywood bash. Movies like 3 Idiots, Gangubai Kathiawadi, Wake Up Sid, Tumbaad, Yeh Saali Aashiqui, Tere Naal Love Ho Gaya, YJHD are all no less than Hollywood( mentioned all genre). If you guys haven't watched any of these, do watch and then judge Bollywood.
I also enjoyed the movie and the story. What I liked most was Gangubai’s insistence of dignity for all persons, including women and sex workers.
So proud of them and they are proud of her and they should be ...the daughter sounds so humble
She is not thedaughte. All used to call her ma. She said we have not seen our real mother but we used to call. Her ma
They are the daughter of others workers. But she protect and treat them like her daughter
What’s there to be proud of ?
she protected them while they were kids @@Jaydotay
Kis chiz ka proud feel karenge 🤣
Movie team should give some amount to this family ....big salute to Gangu bai .....Love you lot ...ur really great
Dummy
it would be amazing
They look so poor. People make money with the story of their mother. Why don’t they pay them something. They are also so simple they appear to not know this that they can demand that.
Edit: hey guys, thanks for thumbs up. Am surprised. But also happy that there are people who feel compassion
Any documentary is paid n made by permit
That! Really sad
What makes you think they’re not happy though? Lots of super rich people aren’t even happy with their lives
@@Myatheroses who said, they are not happy? I just wrote , they look poor.
And you feel the need to defend the rich people. And mind you in this case the ones who have made money by using someones story , are definitely happy.
@beak3242 dummy 🗿 don't you know people pay and sign a contract with protagonists family before making a documentary
The movie about this woman really touched me ,well done to the Director.
I think some% of the profit earned by the the movie "gangubai kathiawadi" Should do to her immediate family members 😇
Producer has to pay her family members or else they will do case on them😂
They did lol... of not they can sue the producers
@@bhavikjain7350they give money to legal heirs whose permission they need. The other people who just called her mother, they have no say either way. Just because padosi ka beta calls your parents as "mummy-pappa" that doesn't mean unki property me uska adhikaar hai.
Movie earned in cr on box office but real workers still struggling for basic needs..
Really true others behind fame real people good works n suffer
It would be appreciable if Mr Bhansali donate the amount he earned from movie which is based on this topic to these people. But we know this would not happen.
Such a dystopian world we live in
@@sandeepkhanvilkar8599 you got a real point Sandeep ... I wish that too ...
@@sandeepkhanvilkar8599 he is doing a business not charity that he will donate the amount..
The lady who's asking questions is just NOT letting the interviewee complete her sentences towards the end. Slow down!!
I think gangu bai is great women nahi to lakho log marte hai par kitne logo ka statue banta hai,jarur inke dil ko chuaa hai usne tabhi log itne time baad bhi yaad rakhe hai unko salute gangu bai...
Yes absolutely
Absolutely correct
czcams.com/video/Fb-7Y_0l3J0/video.html😆
Statue to mayawati ka bhi banta hai
I watched the move last night and it was great! Thank you for sharing the story.
I am just thinking about the contemporary time and that's giving me goosebumbs
If what this lady is saying is true, then why does gangubai's (adopted or not) grand daughter Bharti is saying that she didn't run brothel and also she was not from the kamathipura red light area. We know that she was forced into this thing, as she wanted to be an actor. But, Bharti was saying that this was untrue and she never became a sex worker. Her story of a social worker was indeed true as we've witnessed that in the movie as well. But, Bharti was not accepting the thing of gangubai being a madam of brothel, else the social worker thing was right.
We don't know who is saying right, who is saying wrong. But, whether she was a sex worker or not, she did alot of things for her people there and so that's what is commendable. We should respect them irrespective of their occupation.
Rightly said 👍🏽
From what I know she was sold to the brothel at the age of 16 by her husband. So yeah she was trapped and couldn't escape because she ran away with a lower caste man to marry him as her parents wouldn't have approved
Maybe it's hard for the grand daughter to accept some truths
That being said, I can't find her authentic story anywhere either
I'll guess we won't know for sure.
@@cottoncandace7704 exactly! Feel the same.
@@JustA.witch. But, her granddaughter is denying it.
well Ali was just doing a movie on the true story it doesn't mean they do a movie based on the story it has to be 100% same they have to change it to look modern as well but I think Alia deserves a hit for that movie im sure lots if research went into the movie itself and she had a really difficult role alias young and I think she did brilliant job to represent that movie im sure the lady herself if she was alive she would have said the same. because on those days u can't compare of today's generation so there will be some difference in the movie. we'll played Alia I luv the movie the direction was spot on the songs were brilliant and the way Ali played her role it was just really nice to see something different. . So nice of you to share daughter of Gangubhi sister I respect you so much how lovely is this lady I don't care they are poor their hearts are rich and I wouldn't swap that for the world. God bless you mam and you a lot more Thank you
The interviewer just keeps on speaking on top of the lady , let her speak no .
The movie was great, loved it.
The interviewer isn't remotely qualified to do interviews. She's just shooting off questions like as if in a rapid-fire round. The old lady in the red saree and blue blouse has more class and manners in speaking. The interviewer talks like a street-hawker in a busy market
Outlook seems to have done a half-baked job
Good interviewers are rare....most of them even in the western world, are just focused on covering all the questions
Really she is very courage and good hearted lady.
The movie is great and perfect. So happy to see such movies releasing
What a movie 🎥amazing nd gangu bai is a hero for all women ☺she help all the ladies that's why she gain so much respect name fam everything
"humlog na trailer nhi dekhte dimag kharab hota hai" 🤣🤣 bruh 🔥
I'm speechless❤🥺
Would love to know how much part of profit will they donate to the deprived women over there
I too was wondering. Bollywood takes inspiration from such stories and the turnover runs in crores. But do they share the pie?
And the saddest part is Gangubai herself wanted to be an actress but she couldn't now the rich upper class ppl made a movie on her and profiting off of it after she died.
If it makes profit
None
Probably 0%. You're talking about how India treats women. Don't be too shocked. In another 2 centuries things might change. Her story shows you as a woman you have to take your respect 🙏 with the cards you're dealt. Earning won't suffice.
The rude and abrupt style of asking questions. Why? Only because you think they are 'below' you in any way?
The way she communicated with people and the way she always spoke from her heart is what inspired me most about her, the most important thing is that she was born in 1907 and this The era was when British India officially adopted Indian Standard Time and she was one of the only women who were fighting for the prostitutes. Hats off to her for this, she was truly the Kohinoor of India but sadly we came to know about her very late. Indian Standard Time and she's a woman only who were fighting for prostitutes. Salute to her, she was a really Kohinoor of India but sadly we are very late know about her.
How GREAT she was!!!!
She worked a lot for these down trodden ladies a,great lady gangiubai
That’s my late grandma I am really proud of her I really wanna get to know much about my ancestors root my mum is from China but my dad from India .. my dad is her only Son I got my to inherit a lot … she is a great woman love you grandma RIP ❤️
What
what do you even mean?
But she doesnt have any kids of her own🤡 what are you talking about?
Gangubai uma mulher incrível! 🥰🥰🥰
Thankyou ma 🙏👍💖💖💖
Gangubai helped many poor ppl
maa banne k liye aurat hona zaroori nhi, mann se maa bana jaata h
Accha to tu meri maa ban jaa
I think high time hai ki hame apni thought process badalna chahiye inke liye aur haan jo movie banaye hai aur public ne jo profit diya hai unko usse inki help karna chahiye nahi toh kya fayda inki zindagi ko movie banaya hai toh inko support bhi unhe karna chahiye pls Alia ji aur Unse Jude log help them make there life little bit better 🙏
Movie making ek business hai naki charity.. free main movie nehi banti hai
@@saswatmishra539 pata free me nahi banti lekin itna toh profit hota hai ki samne wale ki thodhi help ki jaye so apni soch ko thodha upper kare aur kuch accha bole aur kuch accha karne ki koshish kare
@@saswatmishra539 charity nahi dene bole understand bhik nahi manga hai haq manga hai jinke Zindagi ko film.banake becha hai bas uska thodha sa haq dene ki baat ki so pehle khud samjho phir anna yaha reply dene
movie se awareness aayi h, govt kyu nhi help karti? People pay taxes so that it helps marginalised ppl..
She didn't die in 1977. She died in 2008
@loyaltyoptimismversatilityerudlol she died in 1977
There should be a law in this country when you make movies based on real life concerned party is compensated .it's become joke now that real life stories are super hits and the makers walk scott free without offering any money to their family
did I hear it right? she was not her biological mom. she stated she was like a mother. she stated she had not seen her real mother.
Yes
Yeah, Gangubai adopted many orphans and homeless children
Ys
this feels invasive on the part of Outlook Magazine....
She is not her daughter. Fix your caption.
Ys it makes confused really very wrong caption
@@aartinadapude4159 1:14
@@aartinadapude4159 adopted
Yes
By giving birth from womb only can be a mother right… Even Krishna was not Yasodha’s son but loved her like his own but before taking Devaki name we all grown up knowing first Krishna’s mother is yasodha…
She wanted to be an actress so that she can play the role of a hero , but she ended up being the hero who's role an actress has to play , struggle always pays off but it doesn't taste good if it's too late
It is a film so they have to add some different touch to it 🙂
Gangubai love you ❤️💜 you are very strong and beautiful
Alia really portrayed her well in the movie.
Yet another cheap way of gaining views by using faulty captions
She died in 2008
Not in 1977
Then she must have had more photos if she died in 2008
@@saurabhkale5042 Maybe she should have, but her Wikipedia says she died in 2008
@@sumeetgavi6222 Wikipedia isn’t a reliable source
@@a19a88 Maybe it is,
But just think may be the year 1977 is the indication of the year when her idol was made and someone have spelled it wrong
Just do the Math. Her only reliable photo shows her as easily 60+ in age. And she was a Madame in the 1960s. Therefore, she must have died in 2008. Some idiot has already changed Wikipedia death date to 1977, referencing this video.
Beautiful black roses 🖤❤️ my heart goes out to the women of India. Such beautiful souls.
Gangubai born in 1939 and died in 2008 .. She did not Died on 1977 🤣🤣 Wrong Info
Yesd
Par unki wikipedia mei toh 1977 likha hua hai
Society and Movie industry needs to learn what makes a person heroic and what does not.
Just more proof that this is Kalyug.
Kalyug is when villains(people who do bad) are more respected,loved more than the heros(those who do good)
Infact you can see that today also, people like villains in movies itself
Imagine real life
Gangubai did some good and some bad, but everyone in kalyug will do this only.
So let's just focus on positive no bad in that ig.
@@Sun-bl1um Yah Ravana also did some good. Doesnt mean people were confused about who should be the heroic character and protagonist.
You suffer from same confusion as a lot of other people. All of us are influence by the forces of Kalyug and corrupted.
@@rahulbosebose1 not really, if you hear ramayam itself
Ravan is bad because of his ego
Even ram respected ravan knowledge
Ravan was killed because he was affected by bad virtues.
And BTW in kalyug people actually praise ravan by saying he do anything for his sister
Without even knowing the real reason he kidnapped her
And the do the exact opposite with the Agni pariksha.
They don't even realize that if people today can speak so ill on sita imagine then
Plus they don't even know what is Agni pariksha why it happend etc.
@@rahulbosebose1 just a question....is it unfair just to listen to heroic stories who only did good works and no bad works, no faulty works, no guilt....coz there's no man who has ever done all good works....or a bad man who always has done bad things....villains also need to tell their own side of the story otherwise things will not be fair i guess
Bro what's wrong with her is she villain?? She was asking government to make prostitution legal many rape cases will go down u know right how many rapes happen in india we do not have strict rules or punishment for rape.
I feel like that raziabai question was so weird and not needed because no one in this world would teach their kids about a nemesis 🙄
Please let her talk.. Dont keep asking questions in middle
I am here after watching gangubai movie in Netflix.
Her son is telling everything than his mother I think they are cooking up a story ...
She is adopted daughter not REAL
Gangubai name used by the makers to misrepresent the convent school who has worked for the women and children from Kamathipura for 100 years even before Gangubai was born.
Convents do help, I agree.... But gangubai has done some very important things for the community and you can't just brush that off.
I think the greater question raised in the movie and society today is will schools in general help a sex worker’s kid study and people don’t usually do that just because they tend to look away from that part of society. It’s not just “convent” school.
czcams.com/video/Fb-7Y_0l3J0/video.html😁
@@urja330 exactly.
people just need to stop looking at films as straight forward as books. It's about ideas and issues not exact scenes and history. Understand the point and move on
Almost all Dons Help poor
Jb insaan popular ho jata h tb sbko yaad aati h
Arrey yaar do a proper homework then speak she died in 2008
Bolywood income by this movie bt there's no defference 😢
The murti looking like sila mousi 😅
Jo dil ka saaf hota hai wo safed kapra hi pasand karte hain
Neta log ekdum saaf....
@@rameshchadrapatel3448 ji nahi neta log bhrasht hote hain wo safed kapra apni pasand se nahi pahnate balki ye neta ka pahnawa hota hai...yaha safed kapra pahanne se mtlb hai jo dil se pasand ho
My god these interviewers are so impatient... let the lady speak...bombarding with question and cutting offf and overlapping...
Ur english is so irritating with uncountable fillers aa aa aaa aaaa aaaa 😏... Aayi badi angrazi zaadne overacting
Super star
Are bhaii y film h sirf originality nhi dal skte thoda mirch masala to dalna hi pdta h tbhi to public dekhegi 🧘
hmm sab log agar Kirti jese Yoga karte tabhi na samaj paate,Yoga karne se maan saaf hota hai
How sanjaylieela bhansali knew abt her ... Kuch bhii story ko tod nod karkey movie banalo
Nhi itni jldi ye decision pe nhi pahunch sakte ki movie me glt dikhaya....koi movie banane se pehle.... research team pura pta krti h history se le k present tk
Bansali adopted the story from the book mafia queen's of Mumbai.
@@harperwilson1595 whatever.....but i am damn sure that the film was a way more than that book
The stories are so amazing
Nahi maa hi bolti hai.. Proud daughter
Jin Jin pe film bani hai wo sa Sab acche hai koi bura nahi 🤣🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣
I thought she'd be rich because gangubai was rich
Good job God bless you 🤲🙏👌👌👍
Interviewer is bad man.. So fastly askng qstns... And also nt letting the women complete her sentences..
Plz watch ,enjoy the film and forget. You don’t want to watch, don’t watch, why make such issues? Media needs to be focused on petrol and gas. Plz don’t make big issues out of it. International countries ppl watch forget . Not to make issues for diverting citizens during elections time. Plz citizen’s focus on the vote ballot box not on so called created filmy stories. Hijab and now gangubhai Muddas are only keeping citizens of our country busy from not knowing what is actually happening in our country?
Films like these shouldn't be forgotten.
These bollywood creators will take someone's real life struggle as story and makes movie on it which includes 10% reality and other mirch masal to make it look like a drama movie axn jxn .... people are busy in recreating gangubai look and dancing on dholida .. while nobody have actually helped these sex-workers and similr things have happened with other biopic nd real story bases movies(like padman; itna pesa kmaya but kisi ne rural areas me jakr help tk ni ki ) !! Everything revolves around being content ; nothing more!! Actorrss ko fame mil jata h or real condition esi ki esi rhti h 🙌🏻
Upcoming movie The Kashmir Files ka review Kijiye 🙏
Ya fir uske upar bhi koi video banaiye plz
💯🚩🙏🏻
The woman asking her questions is so frustrating why isnt she letting her complete before jumping in for the next question. She is an elderly lady she should get the chance to complete first.
"Ganndu Bageecha"??? Did I hear that right
Wtf she died on 2008 at the age 101
Every woman of the area saying her ‘Maa’ is her royalty
ye jo log comments me likhte hai na ki me ye movie dekhkar meri ankho me aanshu a gaye ya me bahot roya vo sab jhuthe hai haan ladkiya emotinally hoja ti hai or movie dekh ke roti hai par ladke to juthe hai hum itne emotional nahi hote ke ek movie dekh ke rone lage.
This is the reality of our society
These people should be given some financial support from the stars who do films on their lives. It's like you use their life stories to make all the money and stardom for yourself. There should be some corporate social responsibility from bollywood as well, like it is expected from the corporations.
Her voice is nice ❤️
Brothel is nothing to be appreciated alot of young innocent girls are trafficked daily and they are forced to become prostitutes I don't why such actions are being appreciated!!🙄
Exactly my thoughts !! That's woman exploitation and not woman emancipation lol !! People only make money out of these movies ..only fools can take up that shit !
A human trafficker a brothel owner a drug peddler a murderer a mafia is being appreciated in our country as Sbl is presenting her as a hero..I doubt these directors some day will make movies on laden dawood ibrahim n prove them patriotic heroes n true ppl n wat not ..n ppl will buy it n start worshipping them just the way the are doing now for gangubai!!!
Who appreciated it?
Nobody is appreciating...Who is appreciating? The movie is a cinematic portrayal of a real story....She fought for the rights of prostitutes despite being a victim of the system herself..sx workers kind of ppl society looks down upon....Nobody looks out for sx workers or helps them cos its looked at as a taboo...Even our govt doesnt do anything..She was a woman and she cudnt do anything single-handedly without opposition in an area that was ruled by men hence she had to take help of the ones in charge, that were related to the mafia..There's nothin wrong with that.It was for a good cause.
Look man once ur stuck in this quicksand u csn never get out. If u stop the earning of all the poor women who are brought into this business they'll be struggling to eat and live properly even more. The vest solution to this is to not make any MORE prostitutes.
These people have now jumped on band wagon to say their story, not sure if made up
The daughter of late Gangubai looks fidget while talking
She's not her real daughter...
More details please
She died in 2008 and not 1977
1977 m death nhi hua galat bta rahe ho
Wow. They never mentioned her in the movie .
thi to 10-12 ladkiya jinka naam school me likha k Ayi thi gangu bai, unhi me se ek h ye
there were around 12 girls who were shown as Gangubai's daughters in the movie. they even show that she tried to get their admission in the school. They were also shown in the trailer but in the trailer they weren't mentioned clearly.
@@saveragoel ohh
Women! Atleast Let Her Speak?
Gangau Bai nice women
Just watched the Netflix film, really good
She made it !
Nice
Why are you interviewing if you won't let the woman Talk!!
JAI MATA DI 🙏 MATARANI BLESS YOU 🙏
She died in 2008
Y is d daughter so… poor,wat happnd to all d money her mom earned
she is not her biological daughter, all the 25 kids they weren't adopted officially but they were together and they took gangu as their mom.
@@Somi_luna oh ok
This women looks like sheikh Hasina pm of bd