This ancient rock is changing our theory on the origin of life | Tara Djokic
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 10. 2019
- Visit TED.com to get our entire library of TED Talks, transcripts, translations, personalized Talk recommendations and more.
Exactly when and where did life on Earth begin? Scientists have long thought that it emerged three billion years ago in the ocean -- until astrobiologist Tara Djokic and her team made an unexpected discovery in the western Australian desert. Learn how an ancient rock found near a hot volcanic pool is shifting our understanding of the origin-of-life puzzle.
Get TED Talks recommended just for you! Learn more at TED.com/signup.
The TED Talks channel features the best talks and performances from the TED Conference, where the world's leading thinkers and doers give the talk of their lives in 18 minutes (or less). Look for talks on Technology, Entertainment and Design -- plus science, business, global issues, the arts and more. You're welcome to link to or embed these videos, forward them to others and share these ideas with people you know. For more information on using TED for commercial purposes (e.g. employee learning, in a film or online course), submit a Media Request here: media-requests.TED.com
Follow TED on Twitter: / tedtalks
Like TED on Facebook: / ted
Subscribe to our channel: / ted - Věda a technologie
If people are comparing her to Carl Sagan’s speaking style, I’d take that as a compliment. That man could demystify some pretty complex, and socially pertinent topics in a remarkable way. I for one applaud her. Well done.
Australian English is not good English. Sorry to say that.
@@seanleith5312 and what is a "good" English according to you? There's nothing like a "good English". It's international language with many variants eh
I'm starting to worry about the kind of world we are leaving behind for Kieth Richards.
@@spaghetti_monster and twinkies, I believe twinkies have a longer shelf life than even Kieth himself...but we will see! Or perhaps not.
Hilarious and factual. Right on
there is a nearly endless supply of wife possibilities, so, peace friend.
LOL. Priceless. Your comment is probably the most intellectual comment in the string of comments on this video and the most intellectual experience of my watching this video. No, I am not being flippant or sarcastic. Truly a genius statement. Hilarious!
A beauty !
After watching several
Ted talks I realize one thing, I should have been studying instead of watching the
3 Stooges.
vincentj Ahh, but it’s good to laugh at such comedy genius...
The Three Stooges were much more entertaining than this monologue of garble. I wonder what she was trying to make valid I have no idea . Was there a message here ?
USA USA USA
Maybe studying the 3 Stooges rather than just watching them…specially Moe, he was a genius
Ironically all we’ve proven so far is that we are all as dumb as rocks
Now that's a bit jaded, don't you think? Yes it's easy to focus on the stupid, and it is rampant, but remember to see the opposite. We also gave rise to Mozart and Da Vinci, Einstein and Hawking, Colin Chapman and Robin Williams. Today our artists push and stretch our limits ever further and our scientists continue to pull the threads unlocking the realities of the very fabric of the universe we are a part of.
Remember, if you only see rocks you will probably become a rock.
Haha...We are what we are. your comment pre-supposes that we are meant to be around forever. try thinking this way- just like 3.5 billion yrs ago bacteria produced an oxygenated earth, we are here changing the conditions that support life on earth. in fact our job may well be to put all of this carbon back in the atmosphere and set the stage for the next round of evolution. it is not all about a lineal progression of more advanced evolution. that is not the history of life on this earth to date. it just sucks if you are too precious about humanity. its not precious in a geological timescale.
I am made from the dust of the stars, so in answer to you comment, yes.
Oh, you are sooo right...humans are the worst of all species-dumb-egocentric- critters have the game rocked...can't wait til we're extinct and critters will no longer be tortured.
@@BRUSHYSURFING The universe eventually dies as does all things- there hads been 84 big bangs and there will be a total of 112. Look up what the Hindus say and then watch Carl Sagan confirm it....quoting the Hindus.
My theory is we were created by aliens as a science project. Now we are the most popular channel on their comedy channel network.
You are closer than you probably realise to fact the speaker seems unaware of. We have known as long as synthetic chemistry that no matter how much chance you give chemicals they can not really reach complex molecules like carbohydrates. This is directly leading to intelligent design re examination! ET is the Only alternative to God.
@@gazmasonik2411 Actually they told me while I was taken in their ship. They are awesome.
They told me they preferred that Mars documentary the Red planet. Didn't understand comedy preferred extinction events! Raving about Bloody David Attenborough he's everywhere. So someome isn't being honest
Lol!!!!
@@gazmasonik2411 Then who or what created those aliens which created us..?
In the future, this comment section would be a digitally fossilised evidence for why the human beings went extinct.
Aishwariya Sweety who or what will be reading it..... I’m perplexed by that life form.
I was here 🥺
@@zaydawood5354 my guess is AI or some alien intelligence. Or intelligence that forms on earth after millions of years of our demise.
🤣🤣🤣
Aishwariya Sweety
Likely the reason even.
It will be evidence we tried, that we knew only love and kindness matter, that that frequency is that of source energy, and that gratitude to God in all that we do produces more abundance the lack there of and to seek first the kingdom of God.
It will be a digital record of our love, and attempts, to save one another.
This was amazing! Great job👏
Fake Science is always Amazing....
Hahaha 🤣
@@davidvasquezcalero1053 🤣🤣🤣
Reasonable hypothesis for what is unknown and not proven. That is the best we can do for now.
It's God awful. pukeworthy
So owning a pet rock during the 1970s wasn't so stupid after all,
Wow! Did anyone notice how her head was perfectly round, like a melon with eyes.
Yeah I suppose, if she bent over, grabbed her ankles, and asked really nice, I'd
It's market value could sky rocket after this video ! 😃
day tripper yes it was, I had one !
It took a real idiot to buy a pet rock.
yeah to spread darwins atheistic beliefs to spread his agenda to drag humanity to think that there is no GOD and we are here just accidentally :D
I think the way she speaks made me to watch the whole video.
I think the way she speaks is what led me to reading posts like this one while she droned on about 4 bil yrs and we’ve now got it all figured out. Just saying...
She is beautiful and articulates her self very well.
M 500 it made me skip forward. It's funny how people have such opposing reactions to the same stimuli.
She must be Carl Sagan's lost daughter. Both talk so painfully slow that they drive me crazy. And English is not my native language. I can't imagine the anxiety native English speakers would feel.
@@MucaroBoricua Go into settings and increase the speed
What a fabulous speaker. A good example of how to present information in a captivating way without the need for showmanship.
and with any facts...
Beautiful presentation of a myriad of assumptions and guesses.
One interesting sidenote she doesn’t mention- bacteria love human hosts, amongst other living candidates. All that fancy oxygen they helped create inadvertently gave them luxury condos.
true; however, there are bacteria that thrive in many environments, halophiles, psychrophiles, thermophiles, etc. Also, there are certain bacteria that consume gases such as Hydrogen sulfide. also there are aerobic and anaerobic bacteria which means that some bacteria don't love oxygen at all.
TestosteroneRN fascinating stuff. I know bits and pieces but always happy to have some new terms and concepts to investigate 🤘
I have seen a video on bacteria and the sheer amount of bacteria on the planet and in our bodies. I'm foggy on the numbers they quoted but it was insane like 1 in 10 cells in your body are actually yours and the conspiracy theory is bacteria dominate the planet and we are their cows lol
concept1027
Hey... you miss the point. Modern research into the Human biomesphere (as extended to all complex life) suggest that we are as parasitic of the microbes as they are of us. That their free lunch is ours. That in fact the degree of symbiosis is truly symbiotic, as in without our walking zoo of microbial life we would not and could not function and be complete at all.
They ain't just hitchin' a free ride... they have helped form us as we are. They are an integral part.
But I agree... she should stick to waving a rock around and theorising about life's Origins. Her comments on Complex Life leave a lot to be desired. Plants only photosynthesize and release oxygen for example, because they have incorporated the very same oxygen releasing bacteria she speaks of, into their cells. It is simply no good to suggest as she has that plants later took over the role of producing oxygen, since the bacteria are still there, and still responsible.
Michael Gallagher Actually it’s closer to 1.3 bacteria per human cell. Research shows somewhere round 30-50 trillion bacterial cells in each human- so yes we are their cows or maybe we’re in their matrix.
I am subtitling this video into Arabic, hoping to be able for all Arabian people, and useful for humanity.
Good job!
@@stealthis thanks!
It's being reviewed right now. Once it approved, it will be public.
Good work mate! We need all brains on earth thinking about this stuff. I hope the listeners/readers (and yourself) will be free from persecution though. I do worry that we have lost too many Einsteins, Attenboroughs or Darwin's to poverty, diesese or dogma in the last hundred years alone. Knowledge will be the saviour of our species, ideology perhaps the end
Arabs need to drop the religion first
@@emceeboogieboots1608 all you mentioned struggled to be as them. Don't worry. All that come, will be come.
I love the timing and the way she talk
What a marvelous speaker!
Totally agree! She is so clear and her presentation takes us on an informative journey.
She could use more body language.
She's a really good speaker. I wish more people cared about our little blue rock.
And that's where her reliability and authenticity lived and died... Such a really good statuesque speaker with a lot of BOMBAST and EMOTIONAL STUFF unworthy of scientific note... Sheesh! Tara Djokc never proved that Geyserite in Australia "This ancient rock is changing our theory on the origin of life..." 90% fluff and 9% emotional crescendo, less than 1% of information in visuals and audio... such a RELATIVELY MODERN way of BLUFFING one's way to make people "feel" science! :)
@@thevagabondsgambit jeez dude, does she really make you feel that insecure?
@@davebox588 Hahahahaha... Nah... :) You're dead wrong! :)
What made you think that any MAN WHO CORRECTS A WOMAN is insecure of her "error" and "faults"? If that were the case, you can't even correct the error and imprudence your daughters and nieces, much less your WIFE and female subordinates... Sheesh! What a gum hole of pain a "suppressed principled man" would you become!! Don't ever get married, or become leader of any woman, Dave Box! You'd SUCK AT MAN'S GOD-GIVEN DUTY to all women... Hwahwahwahwahwa!
Oh, and, if ever, learn to step out of your pro-feminist/pro-choice mentality and HAVE SOME GOOD CLEAN AIR in the world of RESOLUTE AND INTELLIGENT MEN! But if you Will NOT, you can NOT benefit from the manliness within you...
Toodles, man-trying-to-get-into-feminist-pants!
HOah! Deus Vult! Semper Fidelis! Men of the Faith, onward to battle for the hearts and minds, and the souls of the beloved Flock of Jesus Christ, the Catholic Faithful! WE WILL NEVER RELENT against the snares of the Devil! Vive, Cristo Rey et Spiritus Sanctus! Viva, Ecclessia Catholica Traditional! Ave Maria - Mater Dei... salve regina! Gloria Deo! Dei, fiat voluntas Tua! HOah!
Start caring by learning some facts based in historical records and not hyperbole. No ocean dwelling fish ever "crawled" out of the ocean to become a land animal, if this had occurred there would be millions upon millions in the fossil record indicating the slow progression of this mutation which, if it had occurred, would have put these mutating life forms in grave danger of survival due to their slow evolution and they most likely would died off long before attaining life on land. Evolution is junk science, period. Here's some real science based in the historical record with good comparisons to the crap spewed by humans over time about the currency "evolving" climate crisis nonsense: realclimatescience.com
@@thevagabondsgambit try looking through TED talks, find male scientists expounding on their peer reviewed research, then see how many men challenge their research. Not many, is the answer. You're American and those bossy females who know stuff keep making you feel bad because if only you hadn't tried to be the cool kid at school you could have been a genius by now.
Next time, maybe answer with a bit less alcohol in your system, have a bit more respect when a scientist tells you something in front of an audience of his/her peers, and a be less obvious INCEL.
Tara obviously spent a lot of time preparing for this very interesting talk. Her delivery was crystal clear and very engaging.
That's what I said "capitilla".
Oh! Beautiful! What a beautiful presentation!
great speaker. so pleasant.
Yes, she is!! LOL!!
Nothing more beautiful than an intelligent and dedicated woman. Your wisdom and words are golden, in comparison to so many others.
You are nuts.
@@charlesfleming7281 Most of the time...
People sometimes forget that this planet is hosting all sorts of beautiful living creatures, not just humans.
thank god you reminded me. should we feel guilty when we wash? i mean all those bacteria and nematode worms n stuff??
@@HarryNicNicholas nah, but it doesn't hurt to feel grateful for their work with oxygen. To develop empathy towards living things it is best to start with other mammals, like dogs. Then work your way towards other branches of life. It has nothing to do with guilt.
Please don't tell that to the children dying of Ebola, one of the deadliest viruses on this planet. It may be beautiful to you but to them ... not so much.
@@Josef-EU Ebola is not a creature. But regardless you are missing the point.
Aki Rodic
Living... beautiful... etc..
I Loved this talk. Thank you Dr Djokic for sharing your fascinating findings and your valuable perspective.
ajcook7777 : she’s trying to remember what to say .
Loved this! You rock!
Play at 1.25X speed
Thank you
THANK YOU!!!!!!!!!
Ahahahah
I had 3 cups of coffee....1.5 worked for me hahahaha.
Seriously....good call
Underrated
Lovely and informative. We must care for our Earth just as it has cared for us.
The Earth doesnt care. It has no conciousness 🤣🤣🤣
You won't be in Heaven praying to dirt...Read the Bible and trust in JESUS...Only JESUS can save your soul...You get planted in dirt...I'm trusting JESUS...Hope you do to...HE'S REAL and RETURNING...You are a child of GOD Or a lost soul of the devil's...One or the other...I know for a fact JESUS is alive and returning...I have a video on my channel called this is my story...Its about how I know JESUS is Real...I have 5 video's Its easy to find when you get their...You don't want to lose your soul for their LIES...
@@pastorbillyromines273 What lies?
@@pastorbillyromines273 PRAY to Xenu and Lord Odin... ONLY their Alien space craft and long Norse beard can SAVE us... Ganesha too he's REAL... and that horse Mohammed flew around on, he's the ONE true pegasus God... REPENT now... or live forever in the garden of MANY stinging nettles.
@@jhunt5578 I'm Viking by blood not a wannabe...That false god oden isn't real...I'm sure of that...I've know JESUS/GOD is REAL...I feel so sorry for you...I hope you find JESUS before its to late and your standing before HIM in JUDGEMENT...
That was a clearheaded, eloquent, and powerful presentation.
Thanks Tara. Very interesting. 🧐
Nothing is more humbling and adventuresome than intellect and open curiosity.
like the flame when a match strikes, we appear and burn brightly for a moment - then gone in a sputter of wasted carbon
Good. An apt metaphor
Hold up, let me run that through a mass spec
I want to be a public speaker like her. Tara Djokic is a very good speaker.
Deep sea vents would have been shielded from solar radiation, which i contend might be a key component of the creation and evolution of life.
what if there is no deep sea, or events for that matter, but rather just a bunch of conscious bubbles programmed to think there was
Or perhaps this one: we were created to invent what happened to bring us into being, so that whoever created us could implement that invention and see what happened…and also by us inventing it we would elevate our consciousness enough to realize we were programmed and thus program other bubbles to do the same
@@Williamb612 Noooooooo!!! Stop that, you're making me think when I'd just kicked the habit!! 😵
Tall, beautiful, brilliant, pointed ears... This elf is AMAZING!
She's Serbian, she's not an Elf. Go search about Serbian woman's, we have most beautiful and smartest woman's in the world for sure!
And hit the special K after frosting it with a few xannax before taping a Ted talk. O.o
Lol but for reall though she is really pretty.
@@MisterXdotcom A superb example (especially for people who don't know classical music yet: czcams.com/video/1htCAVefsBU/video.html).
@@MisterXdotcom dude calling someone elf is a compliment.. Like legolas from Lord of the rings
Calm, measured.
Good talk Tara
Very inspiring and makes us humble towards nature, great speach
Beautifully delivered talk
Fascinating talk! And what a cool job. Who knew there was such a thing as astrobiology.
Life is more likely to arrived to our planet as encapsulated bacteria and fungal spores than arising on earth. This makes our scientific community uncomfortable because it suggests worlds have to be destroyed for life to spread. Thus our blue green planet is no exception to being destroyed by cosmic disaster such as a direct hit by asteroid...
@@davidhollenshead4892 a very interesting possibility!
@@davidhollenshead4892 interesting, but I'd like to see something authorative that suggests it. Also, if there was evidence to support the idea, why would it make a scientist uncomfortable? Far wilder conclusions have been arrived at over the last century or so.
@@GCU-YouNaughtyMonsters Yes! Panspermia is just a romantic notion based on nothing! It saddens me to sometimes hear super intelligent people like Neil De Grass tyson even consider it. I can't understand why! The Earth having the most conditions favorable for the emergence of life( The Goldie locks zone, Eons of favorable geology,a magnetosphere, water, oxygen, all the essential elements etc...) then why would anyone ever consider this totally baseless hypothesis! I would first put Okum's Razor and all the vast amounts of sciences we have accumulated before this fantasy!!! Or maybe the aliens did build the Pyramids?
Melissa H
Yeah... people get paid for spouting any old drivel nowadays so long as there's some cool images on large screens as companion.
Her conclusion sounds like it was taken from Sagan's "A Pale Blue Dot".
PLAGURISM IS RAMPANT AMONG IDIOTS
That's why they invented religions! For the ignorant fools!
@@robertorourke6614 it's spelled plagiarism. And multiple scientists coming to a common conclusion based on a careful scientific analysis of the data and the observations is not plagiarism. It's called reproducing the results and is an important part of determining the veracity of one's conclusions. That's how science works. If no one can reproduce your experimental results, then it's most likely a problem with your results.
@@crhkrebs you are correct plagiarism. I thought I had corrected that error & thats most important point in this discussion apart from the kiss. & the recent statement that nothing came from nothing. as far as reality goes, science is not even close to its sperm & the egg stage, unfortunately you,ve got a stuffed shirt name & I learned it from a book horrible attitude,
sorry but I have no use of brain cells for consciousness & am not a pearl to swine thrower, If you did not come here to be insulted, tell me, where you usually go?
@@robertorourke6614 off your rocker and into the grass eh?
2:23 “What remains a missing piece of the puzzle is how life began”
I think there are plenty of other equally significant “missing pieces” of this puzzle and I doubt if they will ever be found.
Informative and provocative. Good stuff.
I like the way she said “like our microbial predecessor “
She is an awesome presenter!
VERY well done.
"Earthlings are so weird, they're impossible to write about! We're gonna spend half the movie explaining their back story."
"Don't worry, I've got an idea for a nine-minute intro scene."
"What is it?"
"An human scientist telling the entire history of life on Earth to explain a rock she found."
"Noone's gonna buy it, but put it in anyway."
Well, this was great! Very informative and thought-provoking
Please keep doing Ted ,talks. Forget the idiots out there making fun of you.eventually scientists like your self will come one step further to understanding our beginnings. Thank you !
Ted talks used to be mind blowing. Things that people did not know about and often did not think about till there was a Ted talk on it. ... USED to be.
Her final Thank you was surprisingly quiet compared to the rest of the speech...
It’s usually at sunset that my prose turns a deeper shade of purple.
"The Secrets Are In The Rocks"
Famous words I was once told by a popular and highly knowledgeable crackhead.
🤣😂 That crackhead ain't wrong at all lol 😆
Hunter Biden?
🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@psikogeek No, Don jr.
great talk
I would be interested to know which paper(s) in existence that describe the successful manufacture of simple cellular structures. Anyone has a reference or references by any chance?
I always wondered what lecturing on Diazepam would be like.....
Haha this just made my day. :D lol thanks I need that.
ramp it up to 1.25 and that sounds how she should be talking
She made more sense when watched at x2 the speed. :-)
Yeh, you are right, who would thought ahy.
X1.25
I'm so used to watching these talks at 1.5 or 1.75 that 1 speed seems like they are talking very slow.
Thank you. So slow and boring.
1.5 but yes.
The ending is really good..
Bravo! To this young Lady!!!
Well Done!
Yeah, great talk. Too bad bacteria just dont form by themselves. Its easy to say they did. Now try explaining where billions of (GlcNAc)-N-acetylmuramic acid molecules came from and all hooked up in the area smaller than the tip of a needle. Im not even gonna mention the inner membrane.
Cool! So we’re preparing the earth for its future inhabitants! Hopefully they are as much better than us - as we were better than what we replaced! This is obviously the next great evolutionary step for our our planet and for life. We should all do our best to help expedite this transition and usher in the future!
Are we really? Better? Microbial life mamaged to maintain a somewhat stable environment for millions of years, before some "radicals" started pumping tons of oxygen into the atmosphere. How long can we keep things stable the way they're heading right now?
So, not better - simply different. As different as the next dominant species on this planet will be to us.
@@JescoLincke Could be we are just more efficient and effective at bringing about rapid evolutionary change than the microbial life we supposedly succeeded. We need to be careful when throwing around theories about the remote past, because sometimes it sounds like the current trajectory of life of earth is merely the inevitable progression of what, we claim, brought us to the scene.
Interesting topic delivered by an excellent speaker! I really enjoyed this one!
bj0rn
Hah... Non-Critical Fan Fare.
@@gammakeraulophon well it is undeniably an interesting topic, she does speak well, and he clearly enjoyed the talk. So what's your beef?
Dave Box
Go look at my original replies to which you have left unanswered and you 'may' find out.
Here is a summary (not that I expect you to reply with any substance, since interacting with real Science is not your thing.. you seem to just favour the non critical 'lovely' and the unquestioning 'interesting' as valid comment);
You miss all kinds of points here in relation to bacterial microbes.
Modern research into the Human biomesphere (as extended to all complex life) suggest that we are as parasitic of the microbes as they are of us. That their free lunch is ours. That in fact the degree of symbiosis is truly symbiotic, as in without our walking zoo of microbial life we would not and could not function and be complete at all.
They ain't just hitchin' a free ride... they have helped form us as we are. They are an integral part.
This Speaker should stick to waving a rock around and theorising about Life's Origins;
Rock = X Years More Ancient Than Previously Expected, Origin of Life Is 'Perhaps' Geyser Related Rather Than Ocean Floor.
And such is it... such is her thesis. Would take about 15 seconds to present.
The rest is rather superfluous and inaccurate padding at best, and empty and unsubstantiated conjecture at worst.
She makes a fool's play at pretending to know about (later) Complex Life formation. But her comments leave a lot to be desired.
Plants only photosynthesize and release oxygen because they have incorporated the very same oxygen releasing bacteria she speaks of, into their cells.
It is simply no good to suggest as she has that plants later took over the role of producing oxygen, since the bacteria are still there, and are still responsible.
Likewise, her comment to suggest that microbial life's 3 billion year reign is over.
They are both everywhere and continuingly instrumental.
Beyond the rock and some life origin hypothesis.. I fail to understand the commentary.
Largely superfluous and stage playing outside of it's core hypothesis.
But as per usual plenty of children out there enjoyed it.
@Mark Jolliffe
Thanks for taking the time to elaborate.
@@gammakeraulophon its either just say life started by some chance or admit that its impossible due to pure and applied chemistry. They cant examine any other way . It hurts too much.
This is so good
Food for thought and well presented.
Very interesting presentation. Thank you.
For sure, whatever we are able to reveal in our past will help us to better understand what we are experiencing in the present. Obviously, there is always an earlier beginning, therefore, there is always more to the story. Because we are limited in how much earlier in time we can go (even as we continue to expand the scope of these limits), we can never really see the "Big Picture." Whatever we perceive, to what ever scope we can perceive it, it is never more than a fragment of the whole. As we are only able to perceive fragments and never the whole, there is nothing or anyone that is ever what it or they appear to be, nor is anything or anyone ever about what we suspect, think or believe it or they are about. Consequently, we never deal with actual facts, we deal with transitory "facts" and we deal with the interpretations of what we are able to perceive (the transitory facts) within our individualized scope of perceptions.That noted, we can always enlarge the picture that we can see. I encourage one and all to enlarge their "picture" of existence by exploring the past [not to believe but to integrate] through the book Revelatorium. There's no charge. It's available online. I suggest beginning with chapters (Starrgrams) 12 & 13. Respectively, Atlantis and The Crucifixion of Christ. IYI here's the link to Atlantis: www.revelatorium.com/starrgram12.html
Maybe not..perhaps we are perpetually in the present, being programmed to perceive a past…we could seriously be messed with…
@@Williamb612 I believe that there is a very high probability that what you're saying is the case. The concepts of past and future alike are probably just programs being projected by the "monkey mind" aka ego that we have chosen to believe.
A masterfully executed lecture.
Fossil fuels always get the full blame for the CO2 "pollution" No-one ever mentions the vast amounts released by the disruption of soil in plowing for agriculture and the amount of burning of land especially in Africa. It's easier to blame SUV's.
Wow inspiring! Thanks!!!
Too bad its a fairy tale
Wow now that's an interesting discovery
Tantiwa Hopak
Wow... you made an exclamation.
@@gammakeraulophon what about yourself ?
What a load off crap. Scaremonger got nothing to live or hope for in life.
Anybody know what research she refers to when talking about chemicals forming simple cellular life ??
There is no research yielding such evidence. Miller's goo was over sixty years ago, and nothing has come close to answering your question.
Aleixo Pinto ~ Always remember: If you repeat something often enough, and widely enough, it becomes true.
She is so Beautiful....
She actually reminds me of my daughter older & brought up by me.
Thank you.
So what...
Yes there is a community, and we are connected.
Everything is alive. Life does not end at the other side of a cell's membrane. A city is an organism too. There is no isolated system in the universe. It's systems within systems, overlapping each other.
Really interesting subject and I thought Tara Djokic delivered it well.
😍😍😍 life is not fair
2:43 "Here I came across something rather special...
...it was an ancient fossilized lens protector"
I was thinking the exact same thing! How could she miss out on such an opportunity?!
😂 probably placed there for size reference, yes she could crack a joke here and there, like most hot scientists, she relies on her looks too much.
or the sharpie.
Lero2409 ~ My thought also. 😝
Can we get subtitle of all videos?
Wow, that hit home
A very fascinating find and presentation. Thanks,
Life, once evolved to its most complex form, extinguishes itself. < This paraphrases the speaker's key point - a profound suggestion based on scientific observation. It strikes me as more poignant and more valuable than any distraction about aliens or about religion, as among the comments here.
Thank You! I was feeling somewhat like an alien on some far off planet after reading most of these comments.Most of these people shouldn't bother being in this area but rather playing games on their i-phones or watching a rerun of The Apprentice. You are a lovely sign of evolved life. Hats Off!
agreed... 100%...
We are definitely life's most complex form so far, but if we could somehow manage to not extinguish ourselves, perhaps we could give life enough time to evolve to an even more complex form. Or perhaps we have indeed reached a dead end in evolutionary terms, where self extinction is inevitable. Maybe that's why we feel so lonely in this corner of the galaxy.
Just take a look at written human history. Sadly, humans are really good at killing each other. I don't think we have to worry as much about CO2 killing us. As a species we seem pretty bent on self-destruction.
That's actually a possible tenant for the Fermi Paradox, we haven't seen intelligent life because it extinguishes itself
I have raised children and now watch as my children raise children of their own. It can give one a unique perspective. I still see my adult children as children, and for many good reasons, at times. Then again, I am wise enough to see that truth is still evident in myself, again, at times. We are all children and this world is our room. Like all children I have ever known we children of Earth are just terrible at keeping our room clean. We really should grow up (just a bit, mind you) and learn to be a bit better about that.
She speaks well....an excellent speaker!
Those kind of videos are so fantastic.. Thank you.
Pedro Anastasio Boffa
And yes... thankyou thankyou thankyou... always such comments that raise the thumbs so rapidly.. even though they have no real substance.
Thankyou PAB, Thankyou.
How can a unintelligent species recognize an intelligent species
The intelligent species will not ask, "Are there intelligent species?"
New life can be still created , in hot pools . New organic material can get into the pool from what was created before .
Very good!!!
An excellent presentation by a brilliant lady. So clear and concise and informative.
The Hawai’ians hold this in their creation story, the Kumilipo.
This atom and eveolutuon story speaks of the birth of life from a pool of life:
-
Perhaps, it is time that we start honoring Science and Spirituality as the two wings of the bird. 🦅
Let me know when Hawaiian spirituality cures AIDS or invents a useful new synthetic compound. Until then, it's getting about as much honor as any religion/spirituality merits scientifically.
😂😂😂
Nice comment, but spirituality will never remove an infected appendix, design a km long bridge that can carry thousands of tons of vehicles, make plane fly hundreds of people across the globe or even treat a blood infection just to name a few examples. Spirituality is important to human beings because it makes you feel good (hormonal response) but it is definitely not even remotely comparable to science in explaining the natural wonder that the cosmos is.
Excellent education that all should be cogniscent of.
Illuminating & cause for serious thought
"If rocks could talk" They might say 'ouch', after hitting one in the head.
of course rock can't and couldn't talk.The Alliens visiting in the time these stromalites were the only form of life found the conversation so utterly boring they never came back again and removed Earth from every galactic tourist guide.
She is the type of smart that makes Nerds look cool and relatable. And, this talk is awesome too.
If you mean "she's got a completely dead voice and shows no emotion at all, and is hence deeply uninspiring" - then yeah!
That pretty much sums up everything.
Tara Djokik said what TED and Silicon Valley dictatorship have wanted she would say. Anyway, her lecture was very good, clear, objective and informative.
Brazil
Fun Fact: those vents were discovered by Robert Ballard-who discovered the wreck of the Titanic
David Baker oh that’s very fun 🤓
@@bowtguy4929 maybe shouldn't have bothered with that word!😂😂😂
David Baker ~ ...at the same time. 😋
@@jimhughes1962 yep! Before breakfast, one day!😂😂
(No, not as far as I know!)
She gotta point.
Stramats filled the atmos w/ ox
Fascinating 👍
Fantastic wow Loved this
Someone has studied Carl Sagan school of public speaking!
Nope, someone who went to the Public Speaking school of public speaking. Slow, clear enunciation.
@@davebox588 And no notes! No flubs. Impressive.
Slow... with... gaps... to seem profound... yet... utterly banal... self important... pomposity...
These cheeses please Jesus where can we see your Ted talk?
@@thesecheesespleasejesus4238 we can argue about the rest of your criticism, but can you justify 'banal'? This is her PhD thesis and has been presented several times already. I believe she is now Doctor Djokic.
A little insecure and envious are we?
The complexity of life is and will always be mysterious event. I’m still waiting for a transitional form. Surely, with all of the evolution that supposedly took place we would find at least be able to find one
And we can't find this painfully slow transitional form ANYWHERE! Evolution is a fraud and cannot be proved.
Got kids?
Go look in a mirror.
You've just spotted a transitional form.
Everything is in transition. Literally any fossil is a transitional form.
Nice logical fallacy! This one is called an argument from ignorance.
Richard Barton Great follow up! Another argument from ignorance logical fallacy.
Loved that🤩
Life is changing our history and it always will 🙂
What she’s leaving out is the fact that any decent organic chemist can explain to her that even with a good ‘soup’ it’s mathematically improbable that any amino acids that could’ve been available could ever actually form any proteins in a non-directed manner.
But as with any self replicating system… it only has to start once.
@@christianweller4288 Way before replicating you need a Functioning Cell. Read anything on the complexity of a Cell lately?
Life has a very complex, intricate and magnificently defined operating structure. It is called DNA. There is not one example of "life" without this DNA "operating system" that organizes the protein factories that produce life. Question? Since the DNA precedes life, How do you "evolve" the complex DNA molecules that produce life? Question No. 2: Everything in the universe appears to be "devolving" from a higher state of energy, ie, organization, to a lower state. Examples: Suns die, not enhance, planets cool off, best theory is that is the way they are formed, by cooling, originating from a singularity. Why is "life" the only thing ever postulated to "evolve" into a higher state of energy, ie, organization? Seems contrary to the entire structure of the universe.
"There is not one example of "life" without this DNA "operating system" that organizes the protein factories that produce life." Aaah......RNA containing viruses may beg to differ. "Everything in the universe appears to be "devolving" from a higher state of energy, ie, organization, to a lower state." Wrong. You should familiarize yourself with what happens in the Orion Nebula or the Ophiuchi Cloud complex, just to name some nearby examples. And you should learn a bit more about Entropy if you think it is a valid argument against the evolution of complexity.
excellent video
Wow.. life itself is mysterious phenomenon... and we are the human beings capable to perceive it as it is...