Golf 8 GTD vs. GTI vs. GTE | 0-100 & 100-200 km/h acceleration🏁 | by Automann
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 12. 2020
- As many of you were asking we decided to do a comparison video of the sporty Golf 8 GT models.....the GTD, the the GTE, and of course the GTI. Of course the result should be pretty clear but I think its still interesting how close GTD and GTE are in the end 100-200 and that the GTE still can keep up with the GTI up to 100 km/h. But please watch yourself and tell me your thoughts? Please make sure to also follow all our stuff about these cars on instagram! #GTI #GTE #GTD
----
* Drive in style with leather driving gloves - bit.ly/3Izmkxw
* How does your car perform? 0-100km/h acceleration, 1/4 mile or lap times - bit.ly/3vLiN7p
* More gift ideas for car people - bit.ly/3io5max
----
* Affiliate-Links: We may receive a commission if a purchase is made. There will be no additional costs for you.
----
Like our videos? Find more Automann-TV content on:
----
Instagram - / automanntv
Facebook - / automanntv
Web - www.automann.tv
Geschenk gesucht? - www.autogeschenke.de - Auta a dopravní prostředky
i bet those gloves make him 10% faster, at least!
hahahahahaha
@@diegocosta4619 hhh Costa Dorada Rica
😂
15%
I think its Even 15 % for sure
0-100 km/h:
(Golf R: 4,4 Sec.) czcams.com/video/Ohq1LaeF8Tk/video.html
GTI: 6,4 Sec. 3:37
GTE: 6,5 Sec. 2:23
GTD: 7,7 Sec. 1:05
100-200 km/h:
(Golf R: 11,5 Sec.) czcams.com/video/Ohq1LaeF8Tk/video.html
GTI: 15,9 Sec. 3:52
GTE: 18,0 Sec. 2:37
GTD: 20,6 Sec. 1:19
next year: id.3 gti (who knows?)
@@michaelheinrich44 thanks for the data, thats all i wanted to know, don't have to hear this guy talk
@@PIDOFREAK I like that he tell us some extra information 👍🏼
Pretty sure the polo GTI has a faster 0-60 than the golf GTI 🤷🏻♂️
@@mattsamuels3607 pretty sure no one asked
Für den Alltag: GTE 🌳
Für das Wochenende: GTI 💥
Für die Langstrecke: GTD 🏖
So könnte man sagen🤔👍🤩
stimmt
@@rosaliemiller3183 lmao
oder einfach den Golf R ...^^
Auch wenn ich es genauso sehe und anfänglich mit dem GTE geliebäugelt habe, entschied ich mich letztlich für den GTI. Die Elektromobilität steht noch in den Anfängen und wird uns zukünftig begleiten. Einen konventionellen GTI wird es wohl nach dem Golf 8 nicht mehr geben - vermute ich zumindest.
I've got a Passat Diesel and I'm a grandpa behind the wheel, why am I watching this?
I've got Jetta 1.6 TDI, I'm 25 and I don't have kids, so who am I? ;)
@@LiquidOcelot29 yourself i really hope
You need to drive a toyota then
@@LiquidOcelot29 you're dead
Congrats for the video!! Really interesting 👌🏻
Thanks for the upload...
😎👍🏼
Great comparison...
This video showed exactly what I wanted to see ty👍🏻
From someone who bought a Mk7.5 GTE after testing a GTI & GTD, the one thing a video will never show you is the feel of the electric torque working with the engine. Yes it's a little slower 0-60, but the E-boost on the engine just addictive. Makes the car feel so nippy and agile, but with the grunt to pull when it needs too (which I've found fully electric cars fall a little flat on)
Until the battery is depleted...so quite fast you're going to drive an overweighed Golf with a sluggish engine. Also, I wonder how does the full electric mode helps the engine (especially the turbo charger) to die faster, i.e. accelerating while the petrol engine is still cold (as far as I know there is no pre-heater install to have it ready at the optimal working temperature).
@@AvasilcaiAdrian most my drives are less than an hour, so its not an issue. It's all covered under warranty till 2024, so if anything does break, not my issue.
The 1.4 exhaust is à shame i buy à étron and i dont like isnt sport.. juste for confort and eco mode
There is pre heating! Its technology
I owned a golf gte drove it all round Europe until the mechatronic unit failed. That’s the part that controls full electric mode into gte mode into petrol mode the brain of the cars silky smooth gearbox. When that breaks 8/10k repair. The warranty company pulled a fly stunt and would not pay the bill as it was caused in Europe and I didn’t report it with in 48 hrs. Bastards. I woluld go for a gti or the gtd. this hybrid crap is crap that unit I’m talking about breaks in other cars regularly. Full electric fine full petrol or diesel fine just don’t get a mixer
Great video man, thanks!!
Concise clear video.well done
Brilliant comparison!
A lot of people are not financially stable this period and it's not easy, I always advise people, don't just waste your stimulus checks or salary, invest it in something that will yield more, even if it is a part of it. We can't keep relying on a paycheck that is already half-spent before we even receive it, there are investment opportunities that have helped a lot of people especially in the financial market. Having different streams of income is essential in this pandemic, especially now most of us have to earn and work from home. I've made impressive progress so far this year and it has helped me sort out a lot of bills and I do that through a registered investment company. You can get in touch with the manager via Instagram (@richard_brucefx) he will guide you properly
Very good and informative even for US based audiences. Thank you.
I have Passat with the same engine as in golf GTI. Performance is slightly worse because of bigger car. I would choose it again any day though! I also had the GTE option but didn’t took it for 3 reasons: 1. Price difference eats up the lifetime fuel savings, 2. Way smaller trunk because of batteries, 3. No experienced mechanics yet as this engine still seems to be an experiment.
I have gte mk7 and its amazing car fuell consumpt. And all just great work from Vw
I have a GTI and it is an amazing car but I am very excited by the new GTE as well. It is nice to see performance compact cars following in the footsteps of electric supercars. There is a lot of potential for fast electric compacts in the future!
Really cool video!
Oh yess. Great video. 👍🎄🎄👍
It is a very good comparison video. I hope i would get a GTI some day :)
great comparison,i would go with gtd tho,,after 3 golf ive changed over the years all of them petrol engines,i can say that this gtd of 2021 is a great car.consumption of petrol engine is really big if we r talking about gti or r models.i drove many times this particular gtd by a friend and is really great and fast for diesel engine and amazing on big trips,i did 400km with it and it was really really comfortable and enjoyable.Again,,great comparison!
Cooler Akzent . Den Rock ich immer in den Englischsprechprüfung.
Ja. Wenn Deutsche Englisch sprechen..... 😂👍
Gets better and better 😎🎄
1:05 GTD
2:25 GTE
3:38 GTI
Or skip to 4:24 to see the overview :)
Him: When it comes from 100-200 the GTI is the king of all!
R: Am i joke to you?
Nice comparison, the only thing with the GTE is that it makes a big difference whether the battery is fully charged or not. When you do the same test with a full battery, I think the GTE will be quicker. Not as quick as the GTI, but closer to it.
The GTE combustion engine has 150HP and when it runs out of battery it will be like a normal Golf. So not a reliable performance car
@@DukeMatt well thats not correct, the battery always keeps charge for the "boost" mode so the acceleration is the same, even when youre battery level shows 0%
Would be the opposite for the other cars which need an almost empty tank to be as quick as possible :D
I have the new GTE, I had the GTI and I can tell you that with the full loaded battery , the GTE is faster than the GTI !
Danke für den Beschleunigungs und Durchzugstest. Ich bleibe bei meinem AW GTI mit 245 PS. Eben der Klassenclown der GTI Schule🥳😎
I had a Golf 2ltr diesel GT140. I had it remapped from 138bhp to 168bhp. It was a little rocket through the gears and was able to hit 140mph no problem. It was quite vicious in the wet though and would spin up the front wheels in 3rd gear on occasions. Had Michelin tyres on too, guess it had to do with the different gearing from the normal GTD. Eventually traded it in for an Audi 2ltr Quattro which I also had remapped and that didn’t spin any wheels and just took off. 😂
Eins der schönsten Thumbnails aller Zeiten 👍🏼📍
Mmmmm, das Lenkrad vom GTE ist n bisschen seitwärts gekippt, Abzug in der B-Note
Interesting video. I had a test drive in a Cupra Leon Hybrid (245ps) and found it very good, until I had to plug it in. Oh well, waiting for the 310ps petrol. Can't wait for the review!
I drove the GTI and GTE. I do love the instant response from the electric motors.
I go for the GTE, in my country a lot cheaper than the GTI and only 0.1 seconds slower but more economical.
Just curious. How often do you find yourself doing a 0-60, as opposed to a 30-50 or 50-70?
@@gottliebdee263 not in a FWD car at least
Neither are made to be drag race monsters but more like having a daily driver that doesnt broke my pocket and is fun when i want
if you want a comfy reliable daily I would still go for gtd. You can add Stage 1 or Stage 2 tune and it will still return great consumption and reliability. Petrol is just faster, but spending 50% more on fuel is not smth I am comfortable with.
The perfect situation is having a diesel for daily driving and a fast petrol car for some fun and emotion
I have used one hour on reading the comments, your are the best suggestion, why wasting money on el or anything, diesel is reliable economical and the best option
Nice video
How did all this guys glue or adapt the cam to Film the Speedo? is there any kit for that?
2:24 0-36 in 0,1 Sekunden, Respekt!
not realy, because it was wheel spin and then you can see it goes back to 17 km/h
not really it goes back to 17 kmh
It's wheelspin
@@vad1010 he was joking
All 3 are very nice cars 😁😍
Could you please compare the Clubsport Model to the normal GTI and R
Good idea👍
@@Automann-TV I would appreciate such a video too
@@Automann-TV Clubsport 100-200 please, i own a tcr and i was wondering how much faster the Clubsport will be (my TCR best time 12,3sek and 12,6 on average)
@@hanshallo4468 the TCR is faster than the Golf R 100-200
Or anything above 60 kmph due to Golf R weight and power loss due to friction
Aka the AWD Systen
definitely a good idea, would love to see how a TCR compares to the other models
Interessantes Video. Grüße aus Hannover
Wow, very fast 👍
Golf GTI com sertesa e muito mais nave entre os três Meu sonho golf GTI paixão mundial....
Nice comparison. I was thinking what are the implications of wearing a head mounted camera in the event of a collision and air bag release. Won't the camera make the impact with air bag much worse?
Very good
And when you set these times in comparison to the fuel consumption, the GTE is the clear winner.
I have the GTE since two weeks now: 700 kilometers mostly German Autobahn still the first tank of gasoline. Of course I charged it when possible, but the efficiency of the GTE is crazy!
And for that u got a tiny petrol engine and some e-car without any emotions. I prefer driving my gti tcr instead.....
@@Fotomoloman the man who hasnt driven a gte explains what its like to drive one
And that's supposed to be good? I get almost 600kms from a tank on my gti in urban and weekend fun driving...
That's even before we talk about the weight penalty in the gte which will e heavily handicap its dynamic properties (which are important when comparing with a gti).
@@vipecrx If he was driving mainly city and not Autobaun the difference would be much larger compared to your GTI.
@@vroomgc so what you are saying is that the gte is more efficient in urban than motorway driving? Sure. Even if that was the case how is that worth having a vehicle that drinks more on the motorway than a gti in urban use?
Interessantes Video
Ich fahre bisher nur Benziner.
Hi
Where can I buy your hand protector?
Thanks
Omg nice gloves you goon
From UK to Dippoldiswalde, out of these 3, I reckon GTD
Magnifique 👍👍👍👍👍👍
h
Will you be doing the same for the Octavia?
Finally no surprise.
You forgot the TGI 1,5 EVO (DSG). I've been driving it for 8 months and I'm completely thrilled. The TGI is extremely economical and climate/environmentally friendly.❤👍🏼👍🏼♻️🌱
the golf 8 will be the last TGI Generation. VW quits this technology, since the gas-stations also will reduce their LPG and CNG fuels.
@@ImplantedMemories It is true that VW has discontinued TGI (CNG cars) technology since 2023 until further notice. The technology is absolutely mature and it is not true that the LPG filling station network is decreasing, it is currently still in existence. LPG is very widespread at 6700 gas stations. When it comes to CNG, there are currently around 700 filling stations in Germany, 98% of which are powered by biomethane. Some CNG filling stations have been closed, but new filling stations have emerged. And in Germany demand is still growing as many large truck fleets have switched to LNG. CNG and LNG, especially BioMethane, is a real alternative to electric cars/trucks because it is almost climate-neutral. The new government in 2025 will decide whether CNG technology will survive. Germany and Italy (1200 filling stations) currently have the largest CNG/LNG filling station network in Europe.
@@azando3740 yes that's correct for the most part, but LPG, CNG and LNG won't be CO2 neutral. They all contain a lot of carbon. Personally I think, fossil powerd gas cars won't be the future. Most manufactures focus on Hybrids and Electric cars.
@@ImplantedMemories Then find out how biomethane is produced. This is a CO2 neutral cycle. Corporate agricultural waste made from cow or horse manure, hay, compost, sewage sludge, etc. contains a lot of renewable energy. Perfect for district heating and clean BioCNGs. And then look at the CO2 balance of electric cars. Exploitation and overexploitation of nature and natural resources, problems with the processing and recycling of batteries and then the hazardous waste and catastrophic air pollution in the event of a fire. Electric cars are not fully developed. And in Germany alone there are already 2.1 million electric cars if all the other 43 million are to switch to combustion engines... what do you think where the electricity should come from and what that will do to the environment? It therefore makes sense to have a good energy mix of very clean gas cars, gasoline cars, diesel and new electric cars and hydrogen.
How about the GTI TCR? I cant find enough infoor videos about it
damn that gte hits hard
Can you do GTI, GTI Clubsport and R with them all on the same summer tyre?
Would like to see 1/4 number too
Awesome video
in europe we don't do 1/4. If you guys start useing meters and kilometers we might consider! haha
@@MrJoppashoppa 400m ;)
🔥🔥
can you even use the Golf’s touchscreen controls with gloves on? 🧤
Yes👍
I think there should be a feature if the car detects those gloves it should pull over and call the cops
@@troobs1990 🤣🤣🤣
@@troobs1990 yeah and eject the driver before pulling over....
Bro i got an mk3 1.9tdi and i cant see watching your reviews. Pretty dope
Could you do this with the mk7.5 please I’m considering the GTD but I’m not sure if it’s worth it
Geiles video und Vergleich
Was auch schön wäre
Vw golf 8 r gegen t rok und tiguan r die haben ja den gleichen motor aber 3 ganz verschiedene Klassen 😌
Ein Vergleich zwischen allen VW R-Modellen wäre auch interessant (Golf, Tiguan, T-Roc, Arteon, Touareg)
Wie aktiviert man beim golf 8 die launchcontrol? Habe esc aus, getriebe in S und fuß auf bremse und Gas probiert wie es bei allen vw ag autos bis jetzt war aber hat beim GTE nicht funktioniert
Musst ESC Sport und dann beherzt Bremse treten, danach Gas. Dann kommt die LC im Display.
Guter Vergleich 👍 habt ihr die Möglichkeit den Passat GTE mit dem Golf GTE zu vergleichen?
Noch nichts geplant aber wir schauen mal:)
Ive got the GTE and I love it. Also pay half road tax for having an electric motor (live in the Netherlands) and it still has some gas. I am tempted to get the new R though.
Lucky you
Yo bro, na 2 jaar wat vond je van die gte waard of ?
@@gong8596 still love it, though I have it serviced every year at a VW garage, it’s never ever given me problems! I am about to get this years R though and the wife will have the GTE.
@@PokemonKian thank you 🙏
Accelerating isn't all about smashing the accelerator. You should balance between power and friction. Without a wheelspin, even with less throttle you'd accelerate quicker.
Is there a way to disable the fake engine noise?
Womit befestigst Du die GoPro?
Next do the same but a fuel consumption comparison at 100kph/70mph?
Definitely 👍
GTI consumption is monstrous!!! best diesel
czcams.com/video/9QDLElfIjFs/video.html
@@fabryg9512 we dont buy sport cars to be obsessed with consumption
@@fabryg9512 not really. On average you get about 1-2L more per 100km, but the way a petrol engine behaves, its elasticity, its long rev range and especially its quiteness more than makes up for that higher fuel consumption. And heck, if you afford paying over 30000 euros on a new car, why would I care about a few euros more per trip?
@@vladmihai306 in reality it consumes triple if you go slightly faster .. 250/300 km with a full tank
Gutes Video. Aber der Akku beim gte war nur bei 43%. Wenn der Akku voll gewesen wäre, wäre das Ergebnis noch ein wenig anders ausgefallen. Ich hab nen gte, und der Unterschied ist relativ groß von nem leeren Akku zu einem vollen. Wenn der Akku bei 10% ist, sind es GEFÜHLTE 30 PS weniger
🔝🔝🔝🔝🔥🔥🔥🔥
schon krass wie langsam einem die beschleunigung vorkommt wenn man vorher das Tesla Model 3 video von dir gesehen hat :D
Nur fährt den Tesla kein Mensch > 130 km/h. Dann ist das Vergnügen halt recht zeitnah beendet.
Can you change the A/C temperature or radio volume wearing gloves?
Yes
Found the only guy who wears driving gloves
I would go for the GTE, best of both worlds. 👍
Try owning one, you'll think twice
@@aleech7931 Why?
@@hi-bemusic very glitchy car, crap handling and traction isn't the best, but it goes like a rocket
For daily use is more then good!
Golf lovers, do you guys love the seats?
No
I like these seats yes
No not for what the car is on the outside
Yes very much
I own the golf 7 Allstar edition and I really like the seats but I the seats from my A45 AMG are better. (The AMG was much more expensive so I think that's okay)
Vanno dritte anche in curva?
It looks like you tested the GTD in the autumn, and GTI in winter. Were the temperatures and wind speeds and directions similar? These factors are pretty important in high-speed acceleration especially.
I have had my 2024 gtd for about a week and it's a lot faster. 0 to 60 6.9 seconds.
Please link for the gloves
I have the bmw f31 320d 190hp.
Good fuel economy even high speeds .
For big distances traves still beter diesel power
Nice video. The standard software in the DGS sucks big time. There is so much improvement to make and these video shows it again. Biggest step is a DGS tuning with an expert company.
Well this tells me it's the golf GTE for me. Nearly just as fast af gti and more fuel efficient. For to forget since it is GTE and not gti, a bit cheaper in insurance as well. Besides max allowed speed where I live is 130 km/h any way.
Great video, thank you.
I think they've finally got the power matching right between the electric motor and the ICE, on the GTE!
It would be interesting to know, that if (because the power figures are almost the same for the Mk7.5/7) the matching of the power was via a software upgrade and could this be applied to the lower Mark's?
Also, have you done a timing for 0-100 for the GTE on electric only?
0-100 in full eletric is 10.5 sec
GTD nice
How many versions of a Hair dressers car does one need ?
Merry Christmas everyone 🎄🎁
Merry Christmas to you 🤶...
Ich liebe es wie man soo hört dass du deutscher bist an deinem englisch niceeee
Hallo Automann-TV , here is Autowomen- Radio .
Handschalter oder DSG beim GTI? Was macht mehr Spaß?
Den 8er GTI dürfte es garnicht mehr als Schalter geben, aber aus dem vw Konzern definitiv DSG , Schalter macht bei anderen Modellen mehr Spaß wir i30n oder Focus st / rs
Ist ja nachher die Vorliebe. Wenn nachher die Autos vollautomatisch driften können. Was macht dann mehr Spaß . Eigenes Risiko auf dem Abflug... Das lernen nicht Abzugliegen oder einfach Pedal runter drücken und die Elektronik mache lassen.
What Brand are the Gloves?
No specific brand but made from his grandma´s old panties
- interesting engine concept GTE
- and about failure of one system or fuel empty remain electrical ride or not
- or battery empty on fuel
if yes super fine system
_
that is what I want
_
that is not mismatch with future electrical system helping all accelerations
GTI -like
Danke für den Test. Ich nehme den R :D
Wow Golfs are like baby Chiron. Especially the diesel!!
The GTI, 245p ...best variant ever💪
Hey, do you wear gloves ?
I got a Polo GTI, so my 0-100 is Golf GTI level, but my 100-200 is Gold GTD level. :D
I dont know why, but i always get 0-100 at around 6,3 sec on my Polo, even tho VW says it needs 6,7
A lot of people are not financially stable this period and it's not easy, I always advise people, don't just waste your stimulus checks or salary, invest it in something that will yield more, even if it is a part of it. We can't keep relying on a paycheck that is already half-spent before we even receive it, there are investment opportunities that have helped a lot of people especially in the financial market. Having different streams of income is essential in this pandemic, especially now most of us have to earn and work from home. I've made impressive progress so far this year and it has helped me sort out a lot of bills and I do that through a registered investment company. You can get in touch with the manager via Instagram (@richard_brucefx) he will guide you properly
I love those hot hatches fwd but if it can beat the 1.5 turbo civic, then it is compatible for the type t
Type r*
Civic 1.5T S+ needs to be remapped to full potencial - 240 HP / 340NM then is just hell fast 1.5 engine
GTD is best 😍🖤
A352? Meine Heimat. Höre jeden Abend wenn einer den Hahn auf reißt
The GTe wheel spinning lol
The string back just gives you a bit of extra purchase.
Nice AP reference.