Common ground? Pro-Israel and Pro-Palestine students discuss protests | NewsNation Prime
Vložit
- čas přidán 26. 04. 2024
- Layla Hedroug was among the many Yale University students arrested last weekend at a pro-Palestinian protest, and says her school’s administration has been spreading false rhetoric about the protesters. Sabrina Soffer, from The George Washington University, says student demands are irrational, she knows students who’ve been attacked, and it’s not a school’s responsibility to make political statements. Both women said their peace on NewsNation’s “Weekend Prime.”
#yale #protests #israel
"NewsNation Prime" is America’s source for unbiased news offering a full range of perspectives from across the U.S. Weekends starting at 7p/6C. #Prime
NewsNation is your source for fact-based, unbiased news for all America.
More from NewsNation: www.newsnationnow.com/
Get our app: trib.al/TBXgYpp
Find us on cable: trib.al/YDOpGyG
How to watch on TV or streaming: trib.al/Vu0Ikij
The same thing happens all the time: they attack, and then they play a victim.
Yeah. Like Israel deleting 35,000 civilians and then crying about 19 year olds protesting.
YOu mean Hamas?
“They” cry out in pain, as “they” strike you…
@@pennyadrian7774 No way they couldn't mean that. That is how I took it.
its in thier DNA 😂
Human rights watch and Amnesty international don't have any problem with Russia and China..
Why would they take a pay cut?
Probably funded by quatar
You can’t handle the truth!
They do however have a problem with Ukraine.
Go move the laundry from the washer to the dryer.@@antnam4406
Support Israel! Support civilization!
They arrested Jewish president candidate Jill Stein?!!!
@@nisahmed9121 wtf does that have to do with anything? She isn't Israeli. I am sure she thoroughly enjoyed that. Will her support grow? She is just helping Trump and Biden. Her argument for those people is so self-defeating. I wish she would try again next election. Please don't use her 'Jewishness' for a cause. She wasn't arrested for that, and you know it.
Support Non-Muslims & Ex-Muslims ===> support freedom of thought, speech, expression, religion, women rights, LBGTQIA+ rights, Atheists, Non-Muslims in Islamic countries & Animals.
Anti-Zionism IS anti-semitism. It is anti-State of Israel.
@@corpsertag5967 You forgot to include the God of the universe. Not surprised since he made laws condemning. All of the above. You do know what happened to Sodom and gahmorra?
We stand with Israel, praise to the insight and calmness facing non sense claims
the protests shows otherwise people know Zionism is racist settler colonial project
Your message is wrong! Americans are done with all these protests. These students are paying money! No place for this awful harassment rhetoric!
Defund the universities. Send the money to Israel. Remember if the US turns it's back on Israel then Jesus will turn her back on the US. Ask your local pastor.
You'd better sit back, get your popcorn and get used to these protests. A line has been crossed and these protests, no matter how violently suppressed are here to stay. Expect 20 Kent States. The world sees Israel for what it is and Jews for what they are and we now recognize that they are two different things.
@@andrew_owens7680🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱👋🏿👋🏿
@@andrew_owens7680 Like 3:30 in, when she states that Israel is an ethnonationalist state. Funny, 'Palestinians' are an ethnonationalist term. Israel became a nation because of war. People just wanted to return home. I am tired of people acting like they know the history. It takes a lot of time to learn it. Her and her talking about white supremacy. Please.
Your comment sounds a bit like a threat. A line was crossed October 7th. People celebrated globally Oct. 8th. We recognize that Israelis deserve to be there no matter what. What the government does, is not the people's fault.
No one wants to eat popcorn right now. Grow up. People are dying. These kids know nothing about what is going on. 'Violently suppressed' you say. Yet the woman just shared threats and physical assault. Stay divided all you want. That is what they want. Israel off the face of the map. The west is next. They have publicly declared this.
Why are you not protesting in Iran for supplying Hamas and other proxies weapons. Why do you want US to stop supplying Isreal with weapons.?
Your demands are ludicrous…
The demands are legitimate
@@Arms26No they are not.
@@Mario-zn2fg YES they are. There is no reason to invest in companies that contribute to the illegal war in Gaza.
@@Arms26No their demands are not at all legitimate. They chose to go to the campus to get educated, but they do not make the college rules.
Perhaps they shouldn't be taking large sums of money from Qatar. In fact the bulk of the countries top colleges have Qatar as their biggest donor!
Israel is the ancient national identity of that region. "Palestine" was always a province, not a nation.
Yes, but Palestine as a provience included modern day Jordan, Lebanon and Syria. Odd that they don't wanna 'liberate' that part, only the part that the jewish people have.
@@coreyslater2801Exactly!
@@coreyslater2801Those nations also want nothing to do with Hamas and Hezbollah (aka the palestinians that live in Gaza and the West Bank who overwhelmingly support Hamas and Hezbollah).
These nations refuse to accept them as refuges.
It’s almost like those countries know the locally-supported ideology of those who elect Hamas and Hezbollah into power is destructive, no matter the circumstances, and those nations prefer Israel to deal with the mess versus allowing it to be brought within their boarders…
@@coreyslater2801the part where Jewish lived didn't exist 100 years ago?I wonder why?Did islamic empire in it's 1400 year history in the region displaced or removed Jews from the region,the answer is no.Jews isn't a race ,it's a religion.If you DNA test the Israeli ,95 percent atleast would have the European DNA not middle eastern/Semitic DNA.Even then we don't want to remove Israel,we want a two state solution based on the 1967 treaty and removal of all Israeli settlers from palestanians land.
Shouldn't these kids GO TO PALESTINE and help them there instead???
Maybe you should go to "Palestine" and see how you like it there....
@@Heyoka1441 i was. and it nice and flat !
If only
@@shak666
Another Genocide supporter...
Fascist Israeli government won’t let them in.
You don’t give a demand. you go to University to study. Basically if you don’t give me what I want I have a right to….
Like the old Wild West times . It’s Crazy
Muslim women should be protesting against islam not israel 😂 it's god damn hilarious
Why ?
35,000 Palestinians
@@hummingbird6420because they have no rights in their awful cult!
@@paulamarsh1 what kind of rights ? U r talking about !?
@@hummingbird6420the moral police beating and arresting women .
Can you image her doing this in her country
Her country? Israel or UK?
@@everythingandmore5537 ?
@@everythingandmore5537he was talking about the Jihadi female
@@JessJoanne
The Jewish lady probably is dual citizen
@@tedichekol2787
What did the Jihadi female did?
The irony is she speaks of her opinion openly here in the U.S. freely . Good luck doing that in Gaza .
The only irony is you being triggered by someone using that privilege.
@@broilergivenquirkily it seems only one of us is triggered and it isn’t me .
that's fair. i just hate reading stupidity.
"america is great we have free speech here!"
*someone uses free speech*
"get the fuck out!"
A+ logic
@@broilergivenquirkily I FULLY support her right to say whatever she wants . I’m actually a free speech absolutist. Where in my comment did I say she couldn’t express herself here ? Please inform me ?
@@broilergivenquirkily find it yet ?
As a student, if you are not happy with your school's whatever policy including dealing with foreign country, you can just simply quit and go somewhere else
Yea thats toddler mentality
Sounds pretty adult like to me. Just like working for a company. You can try and change things, but protesting like this isn't going to do one thing about Israel.
@@JessJoannebecause this sort of “protesting” is toddler mentality
exactly!!!! who are they to make demands???
@@Based_Is_Best didn't know there are ' sorts' of protesting
God bless Israel 🇮🇱❤🇺🇸
Nope time for that bs is over
for real. this girl didnt even go to yale. she went to morse college majoring on global affairs w an arabic certificate. its pathetic for sure.
@@Read.A.Journal.ArticleYou know what’s pathetic? You not realizing Morse College is in Yale.
but its not yale, is it? 🤣🤣🤣
@@serenityxox.____ i think your parent failed you by not teaching you things with different names are not the same thing. 🤭🤫😂🤣
I don’t understand why people hate Jews.
envy for talented and successful
It started centuries ago
@@marianna346That’s the simplest and most straightforward explanation.
@@marianna346😂😂😂 lols.
Why do u hate Palestinians
Praying for Israel 🇮🇱 🙏🏿
AMEN 🙏🏽
They need all the prayers they can get. Though I don't think prayers wipe away the sin of murder.
Agree. I am praying for Israel and I hope the US stop paying Israel to do genocide on our behalf.
@franklin9400 womp womp then Palestine is in trouble
@everythingandmore5537 if they wanted to commit genocide they would have years ago
Making 'demands' is not an action of protest. Making demands is a threatening act of terrorism if you don't get what you want..
They are mini Hamas
Well now. I do think there need to be a form of, OR ELSE, in there to make it a criminal demand, don´t You? smfh
But when the extreme right wing do it - FREEDOM OF SPEACH
Exactly
Making demand isn't an action of protest?😂😂 Then why would the people protest then?to eat popcorn?
Protest if you want, but don't make it only about the innocent Palestinians sufferings, protest for the suffering and kidnapped Israelis.
Don't make only against the IDF innocent killings, make it also against Hamas innocent killings and kidnappings.
Let the protest be about the sanctity of life of both Jews and Palestinians. Let it be equal and not one sided.
I'm a Persian jew i will not go back to Europe gfys
Nor the Iraquí Jews, nor Jews from Yemen, Sudan, Morocco, Egypt, Algeria etc etc. These students are a Woke Joke 😂
@@Dakini31yup but it's a lot mate❤
I've never heard a Persian Jew refer to it as Iranian jew. Not saying u are lying. Just saying, I've never heard it. I think everyone who'se family left in 79 or about them refer to Iran as Persia
👏👏👏👏👏
THANK YOU AMERICA FOR STANDING WITH ISRAEL!!!
Are they though? If you mean the institutions, then sure. Don't expect that same support from the population though.
@@ChrisAlbertH47Are you being serious?
If anything, it’s the other way around.
@@Based_Is_BestMy opinion (observation actually) is that the ones supporting Izrael tend to be institutions. Media, government, political lobby groups and the like.
While the people on the ground, tend to care more about what is being done to the Palestinians. As evidenced by an increasing movement of demonstration, protest, and criticism in various sections of society, not only in America, but all over the world.
If you think it's the other way around, fine by me 🤷♂ Time will tell.
@@ChrisAlbertH47 The protests only appear to be large and representative due to all the media coverage they receive.
The actual sentiment across the vast majority of the America and even the world is much different and much quieter, and thus seems less pronounced despite being the opposite.
@@Based_Is_BestIf you say so
The muslim is full of it
They arrested Jewish president candidate Jill Stein?!!!
@@nisahmed9121 Stop saying this please. Don't use Jewish as a hustle. She was not arrested for that. This takes away from a people who have been targeted for centuries and are still targeted. You are using this to try and convince others that we would care because of you saying 'Jewish'. It is like saying a black person was arrested, but not for being black. Ok....them being black is irrelevant. She probably wanted to get arrested. Now you get to use her 'Jewishness' for no reason. She was literally raised as a social justice warrior.
they are not their business to make demands
Israel got brains .
That lady in the headscarf.....not so much
ISRAEL STRONG!!!!! 👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾
Our police is way too soft!
It was an admirable opportunity but only one student showed up to have a discussion. The other one stopped talking short of denouncing the antisemitism and violence while vomiting rote propagandized rhetoric.
The disingenuous drivel is so boring
Hamas = Palestinian. These agitators should go to Afghanistan. Siria,Lebanon, Pakistan and love a local Molla and spread ,educate diversity .
The Yale student's first words sounds like pre-arranged talking points and alternative facts, making sure to emphasize race discrimination by police for extra shock points. It's the same stuff I've heard the past two weeks. I personally see the whole Israel/Gaza situation as tragic and in order to avoid further unnecessary death, some kind of compromise must be made, for what limit of peace it will bring. But I've seen plenty of video evidence over the past couple of weeks. The Pro-Palestine protests have obviously been infiltrated and controlled by external bad actors who are now spreading hate speech against fellow students with some cases of assaults, along with terroristic calls for jihad and intifada. They're attacking Jewish and Native American students alike for simply exercising their own free speech and counter-protesting. National Guard may need to step in if the schools can't control their campuses, or are complicit in the hateful rhetorical being conceived on their grounds.
The protesters are trespassing end of story. 😮😮😮
no matter what these kids do, Israel will always be there. It is God's country in the center of Arabia. ❤🙏🙏🙏for Israel and Jews worlwide
Condemn Hamas
If you want to help Palestines go to Gaza don’t go to school disturb other students .
They r helping by protesting to right people who r supporting everything don't u worry
Why shouldn't those people who want to send American taxpayers money to Israel also move there?
You don’t know mostly paying high taxes are American Jewish billionaire .
@@hummingbird6420their helping by supporting everything? Ok. Just real short and quick list 50 things they are supporting.
@@GeorgeMcConnell-nq3vd are u insane. 🙄. They means america. They are supporting isrelis by every mean.
Billions dollars , arms, with fight, with veto power what else remains 🙄
You got it twisted baby doll.
God so loved the world that he sent his only begotten son. Whose ever should believe in him shall not perish but have everlasting life. God bless.
Yes they were violent and made death threats
Why don’t they also demand the university divest from Qatar? We know why.
There is no common ground.
❤❤Jewish People🇮🇱 God bless America🇺🇸
yale and their diversity quotas... layla was majoring in global affairs with an arabic certificate at morse. wonder why yale hired her on🤣🤣🤣
lol and they call that education???
no wonder they cam miss a whole simister, they basically major in jihad
she talk like hamas,,,lying
No the other one is talking like a kkk
EXACTLY.@kujibango
@@salahali9793 LOL. You really just called someone speaking about violence stopping, KKK? What part did she make it sound anything like them. My goodness people really have to reach.
they all lie.
without lies islam dies
Is Palestine a country? Who created Pakistan and Jordan? Was Jordan Palestinian land? Is Gaza part of Egypt?
Who created Israel? Palestine has been there for centuries.
@@william3765 No it hasn't. There's never been an independent nation called "Palestine".
@@william3765😂 please, for the love of all things sane
@@william3765 this is concerning. Where did you learn that Palestine was a country? Do you know who started the 1948 war? Please open your mind
@@rywt4zc If you read the Bible, then you would know the truth and history of Israel and Palestine. Israel was always nomadic and never had any land. After wandering 40 years in the desert, they invaded the land of Canaan, which is Palestine today (the Philistines) and Iran (the Persians). The Israel that exists today was created by UK and US to create conflict and destabilize the middle east. Probably very few of them are descendants of any of the ancient 12 tribes of Israel.
the moment she talks about Anti-Zionism 😂 - I thought all right you can stop here everything is obvious.
How did the police know or had the time for it to who is Muslim who is not everyone over there dress the same she’s looking for sympathy like using children
God bless Israel
God can’t bless countries that violate his commandments
NO Really, no one understands that at some point children will get hurt, especially Jewish children??? Or that a Jewish child will feel so threatened that he will freak out, do the adults not understand what is going on?
it is interesting that they can say Easley to the Israeli to go back to Europe, But are offended when they are told to go back to their countries
Remember when we sent our kids to school for schooling, not radicalization? They can get radicalized online for free.
To the pro-Palestinian protestor, "nothing but the truth" means it is the truth 😂
🇨🇦🇺🇸❤🇮🇱
No.
“my friend was stabbed in the eye…”
“our protests are not violent…” 🤨
Her friend lied about that, and got busted by a video. Keep up to date
The “stabbed in the eye” has been debunked already it’s on video. The liar didn’t even wear an eye patch to make it look bad. In the video you see her lean forward towards the flag walking by. Stop it.
talk about privilege. imagine if that had been a muslim and/or palestinian protestor making such blatently false claims. They'd have been expelled, arrested, and likely splattered across every major news network by now.
Thousand years of war. Endless.🙏 hopefully peace will one day reach in everyone hearts.
Gazans can move to Jordan.
1948 Jordan baby.
And Israeli can go to Florida, problem solved
@@SQB55 Why would they go to Florida? I would never move there. They have a nation. Those people are not all from Gaza. They are not indigenous to west of Jordan, north of Sinai, south of Lebanon, and southwest of Syria. The place wasn't even named after them. They adopted that name as a nationalistic identity in response to Israel. They are there because of conquerors, yet they sure have a problem with Jews, don't they?
@@SQB55Israel is jews ancient land so they have rights
But Islamist Palestine can go to saudi quatar syrua Iraq where they're grandparents came from macca madina😂
@@user-xc1tf7zk8g lol so where do we send the americans by that logic.
From what we know the Israeli cabinet has people from ukraine, Romania, Iran, Poland. Maybe they should go to where their grandparents are. Wonder why genetic testing is banned in Israeli after discovering most are European decent.
Why is university tuition being used for weapons?
No, it hasn’t worked for 2000 years so far.
Just by observing the facial expressions of these two young girls, the anguish and humility of the young Muslim girl is remarkable. The other girl has arrogant eyes mixed with hate.
The one with the head wound bandage is pretty ignorant
may Absolute, Honest, Unbiased and Objective TRUTH and JUSTICE be
both Sought and Prevail
Occupation!
Lies....there IS no girl stabbed on the eye
Look how these students never interrupt and allow one another to speak..THANK GOD! Common ground can be found here..Palestinian Americans should not be harming Jewish Americans and vice versa.. when exposing a crime creates crime, the state has failed.
Oh boy, Sabrina had to throw in 😊😊
❤️🇮🇱❤️
Free
Results of being inclusive and open. OMG. When do you study Layla? Do you study at all Layla? Israel is somewhere else. Go there and fight for your faith.
That girl was not stabbed in the eye 😭 she exaggerated that story sooooo much. The video is out for all to see ..judge for urself
The USA brings democracy to the whole world, but there is no democracy in their own country. In 1968, students demonstrated against the Vietnam War. Today they are heroes. The same will be said about today's students
I couldn't believe it sounds so good from the pro Palestine side😊
PLC have organized a lot of protest for Palestine, they can do it in public area like park or any forum but not in campus, their student can study in the University but not to organize the siting campus protest the University policy when they are only 1% number of student who support them, the federal should the interest of PLC here, whether they have a interest which conflict with American interest.
Gaza
At least these college students have some brains and not blinded like our political leadership and media in general. They can see the clear hypocrisy of our governments
THE NOT PALESTINIAN GUESS SAY THAT A JEWS FIRL WAS HURT IN AN EYE. I SHOW THAT SUPOSELY INJURED GIRL IN AN INTERVIW AND THEIR EYES WERE PRISSTINE, PERFECT AND THE SKIN PERFECT AND YOU COULD NOT SEE ANY HURT THERE AT ALL. IT WAS I THINK FALSE ALLEGATIONS
Everybody's a victim
the far left had debunked the student who was stabbed in the eye, so they celebrate saying shes "playing the victim card" while completely ignoring the human chain surrounding her calling her names and preventing her freedom just for being of jewish faith, that is ugly behavior.
"Non-P.O.C. individuals." Cult-speak.
Oh, well - like politics, I didn't see any common ground, truly, being reached. Neither altered their belief - but you can't blame them; we're all kinda like that.
Englishman hear. 2 students. Does anyone care ? x
The debate should rather be labelled as "Anti Genocide debate🎉" and pro Genocide debate
what both sides of this conflict have to understand is this.
people of the world despise them both.
they don't want to hear them.
they want them to battle each other to the end, over there in their land.
How can Israel sustain its unity after October 7? Since the October 7 attack, we are not expressing hatred toward each other because our pain is much greater. But we are not far from how things were before October 7. We could return to that previous state in a matter of days.
It is also important to note that our divisiveness throughout the year weakened us and strengthened those who wished to attack us. A captured Hamas terrorist who participated in the October 7 attacks stated how the ongoing protests and demonstrations in Israel encouraged Hamas during their preparations for the attack.
When outside influences that pressure the formation of our unity move away, internal feelings of hatred resurface. We might believe that coming closer during tough times lets us develop while maintaining that closeness. However, this idea is incorrect.
We need to undergo a reset and rebuild our unity from scratch, without external pressure dictating our actions but out of our own choice to live in a common connection to each other, with a spirit of unity, support, care, encouragement and closeness dwelling in our relations.
When we are in a conflict of opinions, we need to equally respect those who we are against, acknowledging that they might also be right and have their own opinions, and that their opinions represent other people and citizens. Thus, we indeed should take heed to treat each other with more kindness.
Unity means that we are ready to set aside our own opinions in order to unite with others.
Just give Trump 1 hour and all these nonsense will stop.
Israeli
lol Deleting the comment only proves that it was the TRUTH
Good video
The students should demand free Education after this .if USA funds wars then it should also provide free education
From
the girl she references who was "stabbed in the eye" was a big lie. i implore you to check the video for yourself. its available.
Chemical warfare eh... fart spray
@@Aishhhhh12 i agree that was a ridiculous embellishment. we used to throw those stink bombs in the P.E. locker rooms in middle school. but i think the more important question is... why is mainstream media so quick to dismiss those claims, while a girl with a perfectly healthy set of eyes and a video that clearly shows she wasn't "stabbed" or "jabbed" is platformed everywhere?
@@Aishhhhh12 i agree that was a ridiculous embellishment. we used to throw those stink bombs in the P.E. locker rooms in middle school. but i think the more important question is... why is mainstream media so quick to dismiss those claims, while a girl with a perfectly healthy set of eyes and a video that clearly shows she wasn't "stabbed" or "jabbed" is platformed everywhere?
“Go back to your own country” words, and BEING STABBED IN THE EYE are 2 very different actions.
That eye stab claim has already been debunked. Yet it keeps getting repeated. Did you not find it odd that she was on the news 2 days later, with both eyes being just fine? She was also recording protesters while it supposedly happened. Have you ever wondered why she or the news didn't show you the recording?
Lies 4:04, taquya
Where are the protest camps set up for the people of Ukraine? For the people of Sudan? For the people of Syria?
“Nothing but peaceful” when clearly you have someone in front of you who just experienced everything but peaceful
Why is she lying about her friend getting stabbed in the eye though? That was debunked days ago. She was walking through a crowd and a flag someone was holding barely grazed her face. She wasn't even injured, let alone stabbed, and it clearly wasn't on purpose.
We should ban the wearing of kuffyehs.
Anti-Semitism = anti-Zionism! Those two are twins!
She wasn’t stabbed in the eye it’s been debunked 🤦♂️ just more forever victims
No it hasn't been debunked at all. There's video. That shows nothing. U can't see what happened to her at all since the camera is from her POV. That said, it doesn't look like it was on purpose. But it is far from debunked.
@@coreyslater2801 100% debunked and she is being charged with lying to police about the incident
@@willli8163 I'm more interesting in cutting through the lies and finding out the truth. Ive goggle sahar tartak, that's the girls name. I have seen no information by the DA, Police or media mentioning anything about Sahar being charged.
Could u please share where u have seen or read this information?
@@willli8163 Ive goggle sahar tartak, that's the girls name. I have seen no information by the DA, Police or media mentioning anything about Sahar being charged.
Could u please share where u have seen or read this information?
@@coreyslater2801 U won't find it. Cause it isn't true.
I don't understand why people lie, when we live in a world with goggle.
😂 📞 🫣 📞 what is implied by what is written. it is one of the glories of man to investigate it. 👩👧👦 it's BETTER to feel more beautiful THAN to feel like you ( human ) know everything 😔 the body is a slave to the soul. a soul who believes in the religion he reads
They arrested Jewish president candidate Jill Stein?!!!
Please don't use Jewishness for this. You know she was not arrested for that. You know it. This takes aways from the history and current targets of Jews for just being Jews.
The pro terror lady is irrational . Her reasoning is absurd.
*Fun fact: Jesus is LORD.*
What about the starving orphans?? Ppl. are ignoring this issue 😒 😢
if you feed them, they grow up and come over here, and make trouble here.
I don't want that.
In the Yemen war and even still there have been 85K kids who have died of starvation. If people actually cared we'd be helping them first. People have been ignoring this since 2015. So, yes. No one does care.
@@coreyslater2801 "We are the World" fed the starving kids in the 80's. they grew up and are now in Europe causing all sorts of problem.
@@davidjacobs8558 I don't think that's true the majority of the money went to Ethopia. And 1) I don't think Ethopians en masse are moving to Europe. And 2) The majority of Ethopians are christians, not Muslims. So they are usually more rational and less psychotic.