Science VS Religion ~ Nouman Ali Khan ~ Trinidad
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 09. 2024
- Ustadh Nouman Ali Khan gives us a reality check from Surah Qiyamah
Qaroon The Traitor ~ Nouman Ali Khan + RARE SALAH!!
• Qaroon The Traitor ~ N...
The Other Lecture: "Fighting Fitnah" by Ustadh Nouman Ali Khan:
• Fighting Fitnah ~ Usta...
May Allah bless everyone who attended and will watch the lectures, Ameen
www.revivalofth...
https
The sense of guilt is to soul what the sense of pain is to body
It's just pain.
I am a muslim and a simple man from Turkey in İstanbul. This lecture is one of the best that i have ever listened. So clever, so true and indeed so realistic with human history. I appreciate the lecturer. The speech beautify my perpective of my path to islamic thinking even futher. Thank you.
Ma Sha Allah I love turkey I just spent a month and a half there it was beautiful alhamdulilah may Allah bless you brother...yes I enjoyed this lecture also
One of the best talk i have heard, a difficult topic explained beautifully in plain and simple manner, left you mesmerized in deep thinking.
may Allah keep this brother long enough for this ummah....masha allah he is so good .....all praise belong to Allah
This is by far one of the most well intellectual well educated ceremony to me by ustad Norman may Allah keep longer for this ummah and I hope Ustad noaman will do more ceremony has reading studies of what we leaving in in this world
he said something really important in the end, that is " we Muslims need to think more heavy"
+Jos Bankston you should think deeply as well
+Jos Bankston I do that is why I believe my conclusion are right
you are so shallow, you blow all the evidences just by saying "one old man from the 7th century",, this is where you need to focus.
+Jos Bankston what part of my answer you did not understand?
+Lee Johnson we see more even at sleep while you are awake
What a legend this guy is !
Such a difficult concept explained so simply and beautifully, as a student of psychology I can’t emphasise enough on how important it is to understand these basics.
So profound.. particularly about how we as Muslims are meant to connect to the unseen God while also realising and in control of our existence and importance in the seen world. Subhanallah.
The guilt part is amazing! Bless this person ya Allah!
Don't just praise him paise also maulvi's from whose books brother noman read these things.
I love how he explains guilt, MashaAllah.
My mind is blow,his way of explaining guilt amazed me
No doubt, very intellectual, world need to know reality.
Coming from a non-Muslim, I think this is great! I do wonder why the title of the video is Science vs. Religion. Isn't Nouman Ali Khan saying that Islam doesn't separate one from the other, and that it is the only of the Abrahamic faiths that requires a direct treatment of the external world? I think many people would benefit from this message of a holistic treatment of the soul, psyche, or ruh.
+Gaia Julia it was titled that as a significant portion of it was related to the conflict between those of science and faith - it's not titled Science VS Islam
I think that the major obstacle to our faith today, is that we live in the era of what can be called "scientific naturalism". This doctrine is a system of thought which says that the world can only be explained by itself. It is a system of tought based on rejection. Its origins and the reason for its success can be understood by studying history.
But we muslims will never surrender to this doctrine, because we believe in the GHAYB and the knowledge given through revelation.
Sociologically speaking, this behavior of ours (muslims) angers the ~Western World~ because we are seen as the poor undeducated ex-colonized fools who could not possibly possess The Truth. The Western World suffers a complex of superiority over us, this is why they are blinded to our argumentation, even if it were to sound right to their ears they wouldn't accept it (except if Allah wills). We should not feel inferior to this and we should focus on studying the Qur'an with confidence and peacefullly.
That's no true because Christianity is also about revelations. The west only gives a rats ass about Islam because you are sitting on billions of barrels of oil, that's all.
+Silvano Oliveira your mission seems to be you want to bring down islam ? why ? Stop . it clear that someone is Around to poking at you
Halim wallahi you haven spoken the truth.
these people are spiritually blind and they cannot see or do not understand right from wrong....
they are a here and now and tangible people.
they took the study of ALLAHs creation and closed up the doors of origin and narrowly said its all bu chance.
these people are crazy!!!
Halim by the way the actual seeing and observing of a species changing to another kind has never been seen.
they follow the scientist just because they said so.
lies upon lies.
Halim it's the white man's burden as Rudyard Kipling would say look at Japan they adopted western culture and westernized there country during the 19th century and become advanced same thing with former European colonies like India or countries that adopted western culture and westernized there country like China today if it was not for western openness they would be behind and backwards like Muslim countries today
Very thoughtful..intelligent..analytical and useful conference...Allahu Akbar
More brilliant bits of insight from NAK
بسم الله ما شاء الله، اسال الله العظيم ان يجعله في ميزان حسناتك و يبارك لك في علمك و يحسن دينك و دنياك. اللهم امين
"We are not spiritual people at the expense of living at this world"
May Allah reward this man.
this is actually quite sad. If I think about it, the ones who think about this world so much and less care about the deen, do all the good deeds. Like for example, the famous food activist - she's probably not too religious, but her works clearly save a world a lot. Then Gates, with their foundations. Then Tesla, with his idea of energy savings stuff, and many more. The ones that really focus on the afterlife like late Gandhi and Mother Theresa, also, definitely bring a world to a better situations. And those people are awesome.
And here i am, a muslim, with muslim colleagues friends and family, and very rare i found my fellow muslim who do care even a bit for the earth, the world, the people. We still don't care about less waste, about recycling. We are the munafiqun who pray five times a day, and still throw garbage to the river. we mock others who fight for environment, for justice for all children. We do totally the opposite.
And everytime i try to remind myself and others, i got mocked as well.
So, let's just keep on fighting fellow humans - who were blessed enough to find this video and received a bit of enlightenment here.
Let us not stop here. And let us do something good for the sake of balance between our deen and our dunya.
Perfect Balance is the beauty of Islam....Jazak Allah brother
20th June 2nd Ramadan
I'm watching
Mashallah may Allah swt make more people like you
Good deed keep it up
Very powerful
Thank you
الله فاتح عليه
كيف لشخص أن يربط بين هذه اﻷحداث بطريقة مشوقة ويوصل الرسالة بأسلوب في قمة الروعة!
شكرا استاذ نعمان
الله ينفع بك اﻷمة اﻹسلامية أكثر فأكثر
الله يجزيك كل خير في الدنيا واﻷخرة!
الله يكتر من أمثالك...
الحمد لله على نعمة اﻹسلام الحمد لله على نعمة القرآن. اللهم اجعلنا من أهل القرآن ووفقنا لما تحب وترضى.
i enjoyed this the only moment when i lost him is when he said that guilt comes only from the unseens, actually there are good scientific reasons why a spocial animal would evlove the feeling of guilt, to help sustain a healthy soeciety. Apart from that i hope Islam gets more thinking people and less radicals.
[KAIN] ReNz0r Muslims are the only thinking people.. Rest of all ideologies rely on conjectures and start thinking after getting started on basic questions. If there is an evolutionary explanation for any feeling then it does not mean it is against religion. Evolution itself is the Intelligent Design. That thuderbolt instantaneous creation is imagination of non-muslims. We believe God planned and designed everything. If it is evolutionary process that is behind all our behavior then that is it. That is the very design of God.
[KAIN] ReNz0r
If you think that life only evolves through the sole principle of natural selection, then it makes absolutely no sense to why we have a consciousness to begin with, since this very consciousness of ours renders a kind of will or determination which can go in total opposition against this so-called ultimate polarization which is supposed to be the natural selection.
Our message is way simpler and NATURAL (how ironic that this word can be used here) than the modern ~natural selection dogma~ and it simply says: the whole world belongs to God and we (human beings) are creatures which have been given the capacity to go against the will of God, for a limited amount of time (life) and for a precise purpose.
[CHI] ReNz0r
Hi
_ actually there are good scientific reasons why a spocial animal would evlove the feeling of guilt_
I get you. The issue I have is that the evolutionary mechanism proposed for phenomena such as altruism and guilt etc are based on conjecture.
These are just theories that are untestable since we are dealing with something that happened over millenia and which exists in the past and of behaviours for which there can be no evidence left.
_Apart from that i hope Islam gets more thinking people and less radicals._
I second that.
Peace to you
+[CHI] ReNz0r Allah has instilled guilt in Animals too so that their own society performs.
ReNz0r Insha Allah brother. Thank you.
speechless.. simply amazing!
A Muslim told me that becoming wealthy is not against Islam.
...because it's not, technically. Usury is, and you're required to pay "zakat" (or give alms) which scales to your wealth. Becoming wealthy in itself is not against Islam, and why would it be? To prevent materialism? To equate wealthiness at its core to materialism is quite silly, no?
Keiner Riku The bit I can't figure is the Islamic attitude to paying interest on loans, nothing is for nothing, and who is going to finance you with no return on their money?
john brown it's simply instead of paying it interest for people that r not worth to give to them give it as a zakat to the poor people that deserve it
me me Sorry, I did not word that well, i am talking about a person seeking a bank loan to buy something or finance a business, if finance is required it can never be free. how does a Muslim business man or shopkeeper finance their operation.
john brown u can just buy wt ever u wanna buy if u got the money for it
Thanks Godness,Islam is not against science.
mashallah... ya allah give every one.. the sence of understanding.. brother nouman allah bestow more of this mercy upon u...
jazak Allah khair nouman ali and also to the uploader of this video
Amazing inside story !
allahi yajzik alkhair for sharing this video
great intelligence, may Allah reward you sheikh!
Beautiful mashallah may Allah bless u my brother
Beautiful explained..! ماشاالله
finally a rational muslim.....
These speeches make me feel so stupid. Now i am afraid to talk to anyone about good deeds now, I have to check what Allah has said regarding that issue. Not only that I have to refrain from some of my activities. I have to know more from the Quaran and hadtih about the matter. But when ever i am in trouble, i open the Quran or see some videos and the answer is right there,. Most of the time it is directly from the Quran.
+iwatch videos you do know that pharmacist can't prescript to you medicine with out the doctor consent or else they will be responsible for the consequences right , to advice other's you have to have the right knowledge so you wouldn't misguide them
quran.com/2/44
Do you order righteousness of the people and forget yourselves while you recite the Scripture? Then will you not reason?
لا إِلَهَ إِلَّا أَنتَ سُبْحَانَكَ إِنِّي كُنتُ مِنَ الظَّالِمِينَ
...none has the right to be worshipped but You (O Allâh)], Glorified (and Exalted) are You. Truly, I have been of the wrong-doers." (Al-Anbiya 21:87) Please copy and paste.
Really admire his way of thinking!
Carry on brother... you are talking very nice indeed. just Go on to change the society
This Question has been answered by the Moroccan philosopher Taha Abdulrahman. But he still underrated brilliant intellectual, and sadly he is unknown by many muslims because his books are in Arabic. Even arabs don’t know him.
The concept of Religion “دين" and science "علم" is totally different in islam. Religion in the western sphere has been minimized to means only belief, in Islam the three blocks of religion are belief, knowledge-science, and work “good deeds” الإيمان، العلم، العمل.
Protestants do not say wealth means love from God. They say wealth means greed and it's unchristian.
They also say is three in one and that he begot a son in a moment of time. Please don't be distracted by wealth and greed. Exalt God from personae and begetting.
@ 2:26 - When this guy says "Church" he's really referring to the Roman Catholic church. No other.
Maa shaa Allah amazing jazakallahu Bro
Mashallah, this is so profound, in the sense that Muslims are talking about roots of the problem. Max Weber spoke about this concept of Protestantism leading to the rise of Capitalism and Materialism, which are such poisonous effects on us today. Why do so few Muslims focus on this??
Subhanallah! may allah give you more ilm of his book Quran
Sub7anallah , alhamdulilah for the blessing of Islam .
Love you
Patience and thankfulness of our life can be the only way of happiness in this mordern world... We should see all positive in our life.. Always should setisfy our inner self by doing right..
Otherwise no chance of happiness in this mordern world..
Who said science was a European invention. There were ancient Hindu and Muslim scientists and philosophers. In fact Muslims in Indian made great feats in mathematics and science, for example zero was founded by them.
This is the real reality of us muslims.
Why was Nouman Ali Khan so concerned at 17:28 when he mentioned Guyana? What is the problem in mentioning Guyana......anybody know why?
Could someone answer this cause I really want to know as well
He is a wise teacher
I would ask non-muslims... why do u ponder on this Islamic videos...? just ignore them.. don't dare to watch them... it's that simple... but that's what call guilt... which ur going to feel on the day of judgement.. when allah will ask u.. didn't I made ur heart curious.. to see Islamic videos... didn't I made u heard my msg... didn't I made u feel that is right.. but just of ego.. u disproved.. now taste......
imagine trying to gaslight people, i guess your learning
wonderful lecture.
22:50 to 30:00
*MUST WATCH*
The Christians who believe that wealth means that God loves are not the Protestants, but the Calvinists. Correct me if I'm wrong.
Dawah Bro Its all protestants.
Anyone know where can I find the transcript for this video? My English isn't very good and although the subtitle are a very good help, there were still a little bit of loop over here and there. Thank you
i think his message is not bad but religion and science are going to move further and further apart with time in my opinion.
hmm? what
For 1400 years, the Quran has not contradicted the reality of science. Will this miraculous book now be disproven after being unchallenged? Not likely.
@@wintergreen1000 The Qur'an isn't supposed to be a book of science anyway
@@wintergreen1000 it has inn many ways, evolution to biogenisis to physics
Thank you for the video :)
guilt is directly proportional to its culture, history and demos, was - is - will be different
The theory of evolution is not contradictory to islamic faith. Both support each other. Evolution refers to pre-adam humans who were human specie in every respect but were exactly the same as animals as to intelligence i.e. they were human animals who became extinct with time just like some other animals e.g. dinosaurs. Thereafter , Allah (swt) created Adam who is the first human of our breed with intelligence and free will. The science follows the evolution of humans physically whereas, there was an induction of supreme human being by Allah(swt) in between i.e. Adam .
+Let's Live Quran
Evolution can easily be viewed as a creative process. A process of constant creation. Every moment creates another and as such, the moment, or thing, that is part of the process evolves. Evolution, Creation, it's just two different names for the same thing if viewed from the right perspective. People should stop nitpicking over nothing. Religious or not. But that's just one of many perspectives on the matter that I have thought about.
vv nice..allahuakbar
"Who said science was a European invention. There were ancient Hindu and Muslim scientists and philosophers. In fact Muslims in Indian made great feats in mathematics and science, for example zero was founded by them."
Nobody has said that science was a European invention. The speaker is saying that it was the Europeans who propagated the notion of science as the dominant worldview. In philosophy this worldview is called physicalism, or more appropriately, materialism. After all, it is our worldview which dictates our morals and behaviours, and ultimately, our way of living.
The speaker's point is that science has been used in Europe as the antithesis of religion and spirituality - as an antithetical philosophy in response to religion - and that this oppositional stance of science against religion has been promulgated as a result of the rebellion against the authoritarian Christian religious doctrine.
But the reality is that it's a false dichotomy. Science and religion aren't natural enemies, and can consistently (in the logical sense of the word) coexist within their own frameworks (caveat: the creationist who believes the earth is 6,000 years old). Unfortunately, we've been brainwashed to think otherwise.
faismasterx WRONG. Hindus conceptualized zero hundreds of years before christianity and islam. It penetrated through the Persians and exported to Mediterranean area. Egyptians, Greeks, Chinese, Persians, they have made great contributions to mathematics and philosophy BEFORE christianity and islam. and they worshipped many gods. SCIENCE is independent of religion. Science and knowledge is independent of lies and propaganda. Religion is purely lies and propaganda.
+Nath Anter Working in science you see the lies that people are propogated by corporate minded pharmaceutical countries. You can discuss this directly with the director of the Lancet....especially since there is alot of fudging going on
Lee Johnson agree. But the blueprint, the essentials of scientific development were first and foremost laid out by the ancient chinese, indians, persians, egyptians, greeks, and others in between them. We owe these civilizations our science and knowledge building history. And science is independent of religion. And has, on many occasions, defeated majority of the supernatural claims of religion.
Question (and this is not a trick): Is faith the opposite of reason? Why/why not?
+faismasterx belief is a mental state of the brain. If belief is based on evidence, observation, testing, knowledge of tested, accurate, factual information , then it works.
Every Muslim relies on these simple scientific reasoning, let's say when crossing the street. They observe the road, listen whether the car is coming, maybe they know it's a crowded street and better look for a traffic lamp, to decide whether to cross or not.
When it comes to the claims about Allah, then social constructs and myths become dominant over factual reasoning, which we call 'departmentalisation'
Love ❤️ u Nauman
MashaAllah!
Haq:.Khalifa Aaed saw Janna and Nar.
The sun can take about 1,300,000 earth in its size/volume. Earth & sun distance is about 149,600,000 kilometers. The earth is spinning on its axis at a speed of about 1669 kilometers per hour.
Can a hiding unseen super natural power residing in beliefs create this?
Yes
Does anyone know where Ali Khan is getting the child crying reference and the eyes open praying reference staring around 28:00?
Can someone explain/confirm about the church he mentioned at 21st and park avenue? Because the one there is The Parish of Calvary ~ St. George's
and it is not a night club.
I have often been told consult a scholar, consult a scholar, when I have questions about islam that the lay-muslim cannot answer.
This is the problem that Martin Luther had with the church in his time and it should be the problem you, Mr Ali Khan, should have with islam today.
Subhanallah
I especially love how Flat Earthers are mad at Scientists, but Scientists are mad at Religion.
Scientists belittle Flat Earthers but Religion never belittles Scientists.
anyways Quran never speaks about flag earth
scientist are mad, arent you pushing your bielives on people, they arent mad they are dismissing your claims
Do you want to live in a world where you know all the gods but no facts, or would you prefer to know all the facts but no gods?
That's why we teach science to our children.
+Amon Ra well as muslim ..i prefer live with fact and God. of course science can't determine or examine God (if you ypu want to prove it existed) . still we can rasionalization the god. for science as far as i know in islam, Allah(as creator) being state in al quran is not similiar with the creation(everthing existed on earth n heaven) meaning also in science term...God is didnt made up with matter like human...or maybe also not have any matter. so similiar with darkmatter we try to search in science...it may not react to normal matter...which our device in taking measurement build by normal matter.
and again another properties of God is it not need space and didn't being influent with time becoz both of this is god created them. i have good place to start to search the region of god....where time and space no longer matter....beyond black hole ....well science still not figure out it yet what is out side (mathematicly) ..only imagination but that not fact. i still love reading about darkmatter...so how about you...do u live with fact?
+varkkha yes we do not know everything about black holes, dark matter and dark energy, but still we can detect and measure effects of them. We measure the gravitational force of the dark matter in our galaxy, we measure the expansion of the universe to find out the dark energy, we observe neighboring stars to detect the presence of the black hole and we have measured neutrinos flux and energy content.
So if this god has no properties which are detectable and measurable in some sense, how is it different from nothing?
Yes Allah didn't have properties that can be detectable (as state in Al quran). as black hole, dark matter and dark energy these thing exist same begining with big bang which also same with normal matter that may the reason why we still able to observe "it".
another properties of Allah is timeless and spaceless. but still it able to have properties of powerfull. so time and space exist after big bang...so before that before time and space exist....what make it trigger for big bang to happen?
even without knowing Allah. people still can conclude that something most powerfull at one point start the big bang before time and space exist. but the human knowledge based on the law exist in this world(world of our now)....to understand Allah..we must enter the knowledge of God region....
one way i can suggest it we understand what is beyond the black hole (hopefully) we able to understand it becoz black is where our current knowledge of physic unable to explain beyond it which i believe there are different law of universe there..without time without space able to exist. at least there we can able to understand with new knowledge(of math or physic) to understand it n might lead to able to detect something called Allah.
becoz nothing can't create something.
varkkha So even if can't detect or measure anything, you seem to know the properties of Allah: Powerful, timeless, he made the big bang bang, whatever...
And also you suggest that he is inside a black hole, you know maybe which one?
Based on what is Allah yes..that his properties. and yes everything being made are fom God. the existed of thing are the prove existhing of something beyond time and space base on big bang.
Nope...that not what i mean ..in order to able the acknowlage the existed of god in science view. the science mu be able to develope mathematical calculation using different law of physic base on studies in black hole becoz as we know our current law of physic unable to explain what beyond when time and space crumble there (by mathematical equation which science that it can be as fact...and where u be able to satisfied)
Hopefully we can determine what thing can be existed there (as their properties) and if it happen it able made me cross cheack the 99 properties of Allah as muslim know(mention in Al quran). by the way Allah didn't stay in the black hole becoz saying like that are refering God stay on a place while God is spaceless..which unable fo to point a certain space place for God. what i mean is beyond the black hole...any black hole, space is not relavent anymore..
All the scientific advancements have a basis in the Vedas.
Why?? WHY WHY WHY WHY must you and others put Anasheed in the background or music? Plz enough with these background noises..
science is natural philosophy
I don't get in Islamic lecture videos like this, atheists or Non-Muslims insisted on watching the video through the very end, and instead of giving thoughts or what they can or cannot agree, they just storm on the believers relentlessly as if we were wrong.
We use to live in a time where male lived to an average age of 40 and 1 out of every 5 female dies during child birth. It wasn't religion that helped us through these sufferings. it was advancement in Science and medicine. Islam is past her prime and like any past civilization that peaked she is no longer a model for progress which essentially rules out Science. That is why the most populous Muslim countries like Indonesia, India or Pakistan will remain poor and religious. Religion isn't the answer it is the hindrance that will stop you or your children from getting out of these third world trap when they single out progressive models as being evil.
chris chow I agree if it was not due to Science than premature babies like myself would be dead same with other advances due to Science
Khalifa Aaed been promoting Helal UE starting in Kuwait and end in Salala BUT noONE care.
Last five minutes
Watched all of it, I don’t agree with a lot of his premises and conclusions
QUE ALLAH LHE DE JANNAT
I can't help but feel some of his statements on history and modern science are rather reductionist, especially regarding psychology. He's guilty of the same mental trappings that cause "secularists" to view religious thinking/Islam as backwards and primitive. He's not qualified to comment on psychological findings the way he feels he's at liberty to. He's a student and teacher of Arabic.
At the end of the day, why can't we appreciate the benefits both religion and science have to offer? Why must we always view them as mutually exclusive? If a scientific theory challenges religious teachings, why can't we conduct an honest exploration of both instead of unequivocally condemning one over the other? It just seems so counter-productive...
❤️
Really? Are you the only ones? Generally a great lecture. I really loved it. But Islam is not the only religion that finds balance between material and spiritual world. Vaisnavism, Sikhism, Rastafarianism and many other religions are also very balanced at the core (of course, there are some unbalanced ways in these religions too, and in Islam too). I wonder when we put this sectarian approach aside and appreciate the truth regardless of wherever we find it.
X13thMonkeyX The followers of Islam do not worship the creation. They worship The Creator and that makes the difference.
What a nonsense. Vaisnavas, Sikhis and Rastafarians also worship the Creator. Who said that they worship the creation?
👍🏼😊
Turn on subtitles in the begining when he speaks arabic lol. Jesus is Lord btw.
Secret Agent Man . Did'nt find anything funny.
Secret Agent Man . Jesus is Prophet btw
How can he be god when he's already dead according to you christians? Secondly how can he help you when he's dead?
yap I change it to 667 thumbs up...........
Insane!
amena billehie wa maliktiehie wa koetubihie wa rosoelihie wa ljome lagier gier gier gier . XXXXX?
well this is the only muslim that makes sense
5:20
remove that third class crap music that begins around 27:00. We cannot concentrate on the lecture. The music is disturbing.
salam wa alaikom jezus non dood non non non
besmi Allah irahman irahim 👉☆ 1999 ?
The notorious Bollywood actor Seif Ali Khan is the older brother of Nouman Ali Khan. If you didn't know it, well now you know it.
it doesn't matter
That's not true
bro where do you get your info from?
Nouman Khan reductionist historical view.
gift of guilt (y)
Nouman Ali Khan talks to the crowd like they are in 7th grade....SMH
Jos Bankston Muslims made advancements in medicine,technology,mathematics, and much more..you are probably a stupid Donald Trump supporter
how do you want him to talk to the audience, he's got an audience full of people of all ages, he's gotta make sure everyone understands
+Jos Bankston why are you even here?
+Jos Bankston I'm a muslim, I have a responsibility to know more about my religion and to be reminded.
+Jos Bankston so yeah. it's weird That YOUR here. and then commenting mean stuff. I mean if you hate it so much then leave
Your interpretation of history is wrong.
then how come you aren't up there, since you're so much better educated than him
Lol, and ur this comment is wrong😂😂😂