8 Tips for Killing Off Characters (Writing Advice)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 29. 06. 2024
  • Killing off a character can impact your readers forever--but only if you do it right. Spoilers for Season 1 of Game of Thrones.
    Get Brandon's horror/thriller novel BAD PARTS: amzn.to/3esTFYC
    SUBSCRIBE to Writer Brandon McNulty here: / @writerbrandonmcnulty
    Brandon McNulty on Social Media:
    brandonmcnulty.com/
    / mcnultyfiction
    / mcnultyfiction
    DISCLAIMER: Some of my videos and/or descriptions contain affiliate links, which means that if you click on one of the product links, I’ll receive a small commission. This helps support the channel and allows me to continue to make videos like this. This does not affect my review of products. All opinions are my own. Thank you for the support!
    #WritingAdvice #WritingTips #GameOfThrones
    Credit to SkyDilen for my video intro.
    =======================================
    CHECK OUT MY OTHER VIDEOS:
    21 Words to Cut from Your Writing
    • 21 Words to Cut from Y...
    5 Time-Saving Tips for Writers (And Readers!)
    • 5 Time-Saving Tips for...
    5 Scientific Inaccuracies in Movies, TV, & Books
    • 5 Scientific Inaccurac...
    Query Letter Survival Tips
    • Query Letter Survival ... 5
    Fatal Mistakes that New Writers Make
    • 5 Fatal Mistakes that ...
    The BEST Writing Exercise Out There
    • The BEST Writing Exerc...
    How to Write a Book Pitch
    • How to Write a Book Pitch
    Writing Villains #1 - Start with Your Hero
    • Writing Villains #1 - ...
    Writing Villains #2 - Goals
    • Writing Villains #2 - ...
    Writing Villains #3 - Motivation
    • Writing Villains #3 - ...
    Writing Villains #4 - When to Introduce Your Villain
    • Writing Villains #4 - ...
    Writing Villains #5 - Plot Points for Villains
    • Writing Villains #5 - ...
    Writing Villains #6 - Impacting the Hero
    • Writing Villains #6 - ...
    The Anatomy of Story REVIEW:
    • The Anatomy of Story R...
    Save the Cat Writes a Novel REVIEW:
    • Save the Cat Writes a ...
    =======================================

Komentáře • 546

  • @PaulKMF1
    @PaulKMF1 Před rokem +1577

    So, avoid reactions like,
    "Oh my god, they killed Kenny!"
    "You bastards!"

    • @robertcooper457
      @robertcooper457 Před 11 měsíci +151

      South Park probably breaks all the rules, but the brilliance is that they make it work 😅

    • @kennysfdg471
      @kennysfdg471 Před 11 měsíci +33

      I felt that.

    • @Ethetjorsa
      @Ethetjorsa Před 10 měsíci +21

      I read that with a monotone voice

    • @trolman1450
      @trolman1450 Před 8 měsíci +5

      LMAOOOOOOOOOOOOOO so true!

    • @christianoutlaw
      @christianoutlaw Před 7 měsíci +3

      Unless you mean to do that and it can have the appropriate effect, mmm-kay?

  • @Dhips.
    @Dhips. Před 2 lety +2007

    I don't like when the reader/watcher get's a bunch of info about a character, who had very little to do till now, all the sudden is the focus. When this happens I right away think to myself "oh yeah you're dead. You're already dead." It's right next to "2 days before retirement" in a cop drama and "I can't wait to see my girl." in a war drama.

    • @WriterBrandonMcNulty
      @WriterBrandonMcNulty  Před 2 lety +453

      Great call! Whenever the spotlight (or magnifying glass) falls on a minor character, you can count on them dying soon. Happened a lot in The Walking Dead now that I think of it.
      "Hey, let's hurry up and make the audience care so the upcoming death matters!"

    • @eluemina2366
      @eluemina2366 Před rokem +26

      ​@@WriterBrandonMcNulty 😅😂😂

    • @margaretwordnerd5210
      @margaretwordnerd5210 Před rokem +64

      I recently read a trilogy that did this badly. The protagonist's lover and ex lover had bickered ceaselessly. When the lover sought the ex to apologize for misdeeds it was painfully obvious the lover was about to die. Sudden, melodramatic, and annoying death.

    • @lotharrenz4621
      @lotharrenz4621 Před rokem +55

      ah, the "Red Shirt Syndrome". It's like in cheap crime series where you can tell the bad guy out by the way the camera moves and spotlights them...

    • @FabbeNJ369
      @FabbeNJ369 Před rokem +16

      Yeah, I had that in my first draft on my current story, but I realized this, and changed it so the reader wouldn’t expect it. So I changed it so the character was more introduced in the beginning, and didn’t have too much introduction. Just the same as the other side characters

  • @jacevicki
    @jacevicki Před rokem +584

    Your #6 comment made me think of Jane in Breaking Bad. Her death clouded over Jesse for the rest of the series. The guilt of it ate at Walt until he confessed to Jesse. The grief made her dad mess up at work and caused the airplane crash. Her death affected the story going forward in many ways. And the amazing thing is you know in a lesser writer's hands her death is just going to be "Jesse sad, look at how evil Walter is getting." Instead it is flushed out, her death touched everyone who knew her significantly, and touched others indirectly as well.

    • @achimdemus-holzhaeuser1233
      @achimdemus-holzhaeuser1233 Před rokem +68

      Not to mention that they did not pull any punches.
      That scene was raw, drawn out and developed Walters character by miles, with him switching between emotions and wants.

    • @conorowens3892
      @conorowens3892 Před 11 měsíci +24

      Not only that- but it was a good way to introduce Mike as Saul's "cleaner."

    • @BishopS
      @BishopS Před 10 měsíci +11

      ​@conorowens3892 funny thing about that. Mike was never supposed to be there. Saul was originally written to help Jesse with the cover up, but Bob Odenkirk has scheduling conflicts so they brought in Mike for that scene.

    • @Kali-bs7oj
      @Kali-bs7oj Před 10 měsíci +10

      I like how the death has soo much character impact. It’s less heavy on the story side. Jesse stays in New Mexico, some financial troubles from the car damage, etc.
      But the character impacts are insane. We see walt trying to justify this to himself in the speech at the school, we see Walt trying to be a father figure to Jesse while clearly still guilty (when he approaches him in the crack house in the finale of S2).
      Once Walt and jesse’s relationship has been destroyed, Walt uses it to spite Jesse in Ozymandias. It’s a really effective moment in the story

    • @blokvader8283
      @blokvader8283 Před 9 měsíci +2

      The moment he said "they mess up at work" I immediately thought, "crashing 2 airplanes is a pretty big mess up"

  • @zoltanposfai3451
    @zoltanposfai3451 Před rokem +147

    Meanwhile, in comics-world: A character dies, means he/she went on an extended holiday.

    • @WriterBrandonMcNulty
      @WriterBrandonMcNulty  Před rokem +60

      UNLESS it's Uncle Ben or Thomas/Martha Wayne haha

    • @zoltanposfai3451
      @zoltanposfai3451 Před rokem +22

      @@WriterBrandonMcNulty Some characters, due to the over-proliferation of reboots and parallel universes are doomed to die over and over again. They deserve the Honorary Petunia Award.
      Speaking of proliferation: Since George Martin "popularised" sudden death of main characters, I saw many examples where authors used it for a fleeting shock effect, but left me pondering "Why?!?".

  • @inkwyvern5171
    @inkwyvern5171 Před rokem +451

    Another way of dealing with this is separating the emotions brought forth from death from death itself. Characters don't always have to die to be dead. They can turn coat. They can lose themselves or get lost along the way. Permanency in separation is as good as burying someone. This way it doesn't feel as cheap when characters return to the protagonists side instead of miraculously getting revived

    • @JustLooseMe
      @JustLooseMe Před rokem +40

      Or you could cripple them. Like in Full Metal Alchemist. People get put in a wheelchair or are blinded and they still play a major role. And it kinda feels more heavy than 'just' death.

    • @inkwyvern5171
      @inkwyvern5171 Před rokem +26

      @@JustLooseMe it's weird that we've cheapenened death more so than a handicap

    • @JustLooseMe
      @JustLooseMe Před rokem +30

      @@inkwyvern5171 Yes and no. Because Death is permanent there is no after math for the dead character. No more suffering, no more danger. Thats why it is easier to get over it.
      On the other hand, a bad ass who lost his eyesight has pain, struggle, and is more in danger than ever because he does have the same enemies as before but not the same capabilities. Therefore we are forced to worry about this character even more, and it hurts see him struggle time and time again even more because we saw first hand what he was capable of before his injury.
      It think it is just logical because you dont let the reader of the hook.
      The only difficulties are that the injury doesnt feel like you pulled your punches and that you dont throw away the character because he cant fight anymore.

    • @inkwyvern5171
      @inkwyvern5171 Před rokem +11

      @@JustLooseMe I struggle to kill my characters. I develop attachments to them and dread the impending scenes when it's their time.

    • @JustLooseMe
      @JustLooseMe Před rokem +9

      @@inkwyvern5171 oh yeah from a writers perspective for sure. I have the situation the other way around. I have a point in the story where a character has to die. It is the only way the protagonist can live and become the version he is at the end. Knowing all this I look forward to flesh out his character and at the same time I really dont want to because I might get to attached to him.

  • @sabershenanigans
    @sabershenanigans Před rokem +352

    I think my favourite character death is Count Dooku, in the novelisation of Revenge of the Sith. In the movie, he just gets outfought, betrayed and murdered - but in the novelisation there's so much more to it: we see his own idea of what was supposed to happen, leading up to his death. The entire fight is told from his perspective, making Anakin and Obi-Wan the antagonists for two-and-a-bit chapters and showing just how dark a threat Anakin poses to those he fights - and exactly how Palpatine manipulates EVERYONE - including and especially his own inner circle.
    It's tragic, it's poignant, it fits the theme of the story, and it hits astonishingly hard considering most people who read it will have already seen the movie and know exactly what's coming.

    • @SuperSaiyanD48
      @SuperSaiyanD48 Před rokem +40

      That novelization went *hard.* It's one of my favorite things to go back to when I'm writing.

    • @gabethebabe3337
      @gabethebabe3337 Před 11 měsíci +18

      I miss when Star Wars Novelizations expanded on the movies like this instead of just coming up with excuses for important plot points that shouldn't realistically happen (Rey downloading Kylo Ren's knowledge of lightsaber combat, and somehow beating him in a duel in TFA before retconning her to be Palpatine's granddaughter)

    • @magi6704
      @magi6704 Před 8 měsíci +1

      Absolutely right man! It's been a while since I have read revenge of the Sith but I remember that death sticking out for me.

  • @SequentiallyCompact
    @SequentiallyCompact Před rokem +481

    I think in T2, the T-800's 'death' was probably one of the most impactful on screen deaths of all time.

    • @andrewucla
      @andrewucla Před rokem +26

      👍🏼

    • @SryBut
      @SryBut Před 11 měsíci +5

      Naruto Spoiler:
      I go with Jirayas death. Like, it was kinda teased but DAMN, that shit just hit!

    • @kanemccarthy1979
      @kanemccarthy1979 Před 11 měsíci +6

      ​@@SryButI think it works so well because Kishimoto is excellent at not telegraphing character deaths, but is spectacular at building dread. Like a fight starts and you have no idea that it's coming at first but as it drags on...then you see them lose an arm...

    • @ltb1345
      @ltb1345 Před 11 měsíci +3

      @@kanemccarthy1979 Yeah.

    • @plugshirt1762
      @plugshirt1762 Před 5 měsíci

      @@kanemccarthy1979yeah but it gets really annoying when it dawns on you that they never will kill off any character that isn’t a mentor except neji who hadn’t been relevant for hundreds of episodes at that point. Naruto is really too scared to kill off characters when a lot of its die characters realistically should have died in their fights on top of the fact it would of been more impactful since they do pretty much nothing for most of the series

  • @me-myself-i787
    @me-myself-i787 Před 11 měsíci +360

    Edit: Someone mentioned I should've put a spoiler warning at the top, and they're probably right.
    There will be spoilers later in this comment.
    About some of these:
    Peter Parker's death in Into the Spiderverse was at the beginning, and be was supposed to be a mentor character to Miles but then died before he really got to teach Miles anything, which forced Miles to search for a new mentor. This was an integral part of Miles' character development.
    Then, later on, spoiler alert:
    Uncle Aaron dies. This is shortly after we discover he's the Prowler. We have grown to care about Aaron throughout the movie, so the reveal is surprising. We see the good in him because of everything that's happened previously. Then, when Miles reveals his face, Uncle Aaron realises what he's doing is wrong. These are real people he's killing. He decides to quit working as the Prowler. This is the start of a redemption arc.
    KingPin puts a stop to that.
    Both deaths were important to the plot, but Aaron's death was much more impactful.
    Also, Aaron's death was more surprising, since we expect a role-model to die in a Spiderman origin story. Peter's death serves that role. But we only later realise that Uncle Aaron was so much more of a role-model than Peter.

    • @teru_9921
      @teru_9921 Před 10 měsíci +38

      whoa, that's a really good observation! I never realized that Peter's death in the beginning acts as a device to fool the readers who mostly are already aware of the Spider-man story (aka 1 closest character always dies to trigger the creation of a true Spider-man)

    • @monke3548
      @monke3548 Před 9 měsíci +1

      You should've put the spoiler warning at the top. I do not mind your comment but that literally spoilt everything for me. I was planning on watching the movie.

  • @drumitch
    @drumitch Před rokem +116

    Oberyn Martell's death in Game of Thrones elicited the single most visceral emotional reaction from me that I've ever had in regards to a fictional character's death. I was furious. And it's not because it was bad or out of place, but as a viewer/reader, I really wanted him to get his revenge, but it was written very well with his personality in mind. He was blinded by his emotions (which allowed readers and viewers to empathize with him), which caused him to make a fatal mistake, and then he died a (seemingly) meaningless death to one of the most despicable people in Westeros.
    As much as I hated seeing him die that way, I think the story became so much more compelling with that death.

    • @theomegapotato370
      @theomegapotato370 Před 11 měsíci +10

      tbf, in a way he did get revenge on the Mountain, as in the books it is said that he suffered for weeks before eventually succumbing to the poison Oberyn tipped his spear in.

    • @johnclever8813
      @johnclever8813 Před 11 měsíci +2

      Mind putting a spoiler warning?

    • @imtired3861
      @imtired3861 Před 11 měsíci +10

      @@johnclever8813your in the comment section of a video discussing character death. You should’ve expected people to give examples of character death.

    • @ultratronger
      @ultratronger Před 9 měsíci +5

      @@johnclever8813 it's been 23 years since oberyn's death, 10 years if you count the show

    • @plugshirt1762
      @plugshirt1762 Před 5 měsíci +2

      @@ultratrongerbruh the argument of how old something is is so incredibly stupid considering how many thousands of works of media come out don’t is not feasible for everyone to have seen everything that has ever come out. As the other guy said it’s more so dense to not expect spoilers in a comment section about character death

  • @LunrFox
    @LunrFox Před 11 měsíci +57

    I recently played a video game that dealt with death and revival a lot.
    If a character died in the story, they were reborn, but they would not remember anything from their past life, and would be like a completely new person.

    • @TrueBK77
      @TrueBK77 Před 10 měsíci +6

      What game was that?

    • @eirdonne_
      @eirdonne_ Před 10 měsíci +1

      Literally any game ever@@TrueBK77

    • @robbieaulia6462
      @robbieaulia6462 Před 9 měsíci

      Damn, I didn't know Flappy Bird had such a deep and intriguing plot@@eirdonne_

    • @masterwolfgaming3436
      @masterwolfgaming3436 Před 9 měsíci +5

      ​@eirdonne_ Not trying to come off as a smartass, but that's simply not true. As someone who has played a ton of games over their life (I have Autism and video games are my special interest), most games don't do this, and instead apt for just killing off a character for story reasons and not reviving them (well, except for the main character when you respawn, but besides from meta games like Undertale, that character coming back isn't actually supposed to happen in the story).

    • @denisucuuu
      @denisucuuu Před 9 měsíci

      @@masterwolfgaming3436We don't care that you're autistic everyone plays video games 💀

  • @norskibox1780
    @norskibox1780 Před 11 měsíci +55

    The tip about a promising future reminds me of Narancia from Jojo's Bizarre Adventure. As they were close to finding the villain, he was talking with one of the other characters about how he was excited to try going to school again to get his life in shape and wanting to eat a nice pizza. I remember watching it and feeling so distraught that he never got to accomplish that.

    • @blokvader8283
      @blokvader8283 Před 9 měsíci +3

      Exactly what I was thinking of lmao

  • @SamuelMcAlpin-ft3uu
    @SamuelMcAlpin-ft3uu Před 9 měsíci +16

    I’ve always loved in Star Wars Rebels when, after Kanan gives his life to save Hera and the other rebels in the final season, the next episode is basically entirely devoted to their grief. Sabine and Zeb lash out at the Empire, Ezra finds himself rudderless once again without his Master’s guidance, and Hera is utterly destroyed by feeling responsible for the death of the man she loves. They all ultimately find their own ways to shake off the funk by the end of the episode, but it was great to see that explored in a way I feel too few shows do nowadays.

  • @TurquoiseStar17
    @TurquoiseStar17 Před rokem +94

    George R.R. Martin has said Gandalf's resurrection shaped his philosophy in killing characters no matter how matter now important they are. He set that tone from the first book with Ned Stark.
    Game of Thrones effectively abandoned this philosophy when Arya was stabbed repeatedly by the Waif, jumped in the dirty water and was immediately fine ("merely a flesh wound", to quote Monty Python). From then on, the fan favorite characters suddenly all developed plot armor thicker than dragon scales.

    • @bensomes7662
      @bensomes7662 Před 11 měsíci +16

      Good example with Arya, it seems like she has the ”plot armor”, what some people call it. To be fair that non-death wasn’t G.R.R.M’s books, so only the show writers to blame

    • @pn2294
      @pn2294 Před 11 měsíci +1

      Tbf, the first book of ASoIaF would’ve been the prologue of a different series
      How many parents do you actually expect to survive the prologue of a series?😂

    • @imtired3861
      @imtired3861 Před 11 měsíci +3

      @@pn2294Ned was more than just the parent character. He was the central character of the first book A Game Of Thrones. No character in a song of ice and fire has had more pov chapters in a single book then Ned. And by your logic Catelyn Tully also should have died because she too was a parent.

    • @pn2294
      @pn2294 Před 11 měsíci +3

      @@imtired3861 honestly this still isn’t any different than if Uncle Ben was the main character of the first episode of Spider-Man.

    • @silverhawkscape2677
      @silverhawkscape2677 Před 10 měsíci +4

      Why though? Gandalf made sense in his resurrection.

  • @Rudolph444
    @Rudolph444 Před 11 měsíci +20

    I love how Watership down creates the sense of tention after killing off a character almost right after their adventure stars to make it feel like anyone could die at any moment

    • @shoguncato84
      @shoguncato84 Před 8 měsíci

      I felt that way when watching Invincible

  • @Alpharelic
    @Alpharelic Před 11 měsíci +52

    The "future promise" one reminds me if Axel from The Walking Dead. I liked how with him, he had been a prisoner who was only just pitiful enough to talk Rick out of killing him, and afterwards his relationship with the group began to get better as he had a funny vibe to him. And then, while he's lamenting to Carol about his past in a way that puts it behind him, he gets shot through the head - no warning, no realisation that it's over, just gets one shot. That gave me a lot of shock

    • @teddyrichard1488
      @teddyrichard1488 Před 9 měsíci +4

      Governor Jumpscare

    • @denisucuuu
      @denisucuuu Před 9 měsíci +5

      And then you get absolutely obliterated emotionally when his dead body gets littered with dozens more bullets and Carol uses it as a shield. Shit's just disturbing

  • @DarkTider
    @DarkTider Před rokem +132

    #4 id say this is a double-edged sword.
    The good old "2 weeks until retirement" cliché comes to mind. By this point a promising future has conditioned the audience to expect the character to die, and it often feels trite and unimaginative to kill them in this method. Or even worse, it might even worsen your story and cheapen the death of it leaves a story arc incomplete or feels too sudden, especially if it means characters don't buy the death.
    The death of John snow in game of Thrones was the worst offender here, his death was handled so badly it was obvious he wasn't gone for good the moment he hits the ground, because there was too much unfinished business going on for anyone to buy that he was actually dead. It feels like a very "gotcha" tip, and one I feel is a pretty bad tip nowadays when bright future makes readers expect death is coming.

    • @Jonaelize
      @Jonaelize Před rokem +7

      Yeah, as soon as I hear or read about a character and their good fortune or promising future is mentioned, I'm already thinking, they are going to die soon. I think the promising future trope has to be handled with care. Maybe if the promising future isn't solely for this one character, but affects multiple people. Maybe if the character is just making believable plans (with uncertain outcomes).

    • @ceinwenchandler4716
      @ceinwenchandler4716 Před rokem +8

      XD I didn't know the "two weeks until retirement" thing was a cliche, so I accidentally subverted it in the beginning of one of my stories. The character in question actually does just go into retirement. Granted, he does have to drag his freshly disabled, workaholic best friend along with him, so his life afterward isn't as peaceful as he'd hoped, but he does at least get to leave the military.

    • @pauljamesyoung-70
      @pauljamesyoung-70 Před rokem +7

      A better way to see #4 is not as a promising future but a promise of a future. That is, the audience/reader can see that the character has more to accomplish in the story but then they are taken away.
      Chrissy Cunningham's death in Stranger Things is an example. They set her up like she has a part to play in the season with character development and a story but then is killed.
      If she was just a generic High school cheerleader with no story, no inner character issues, and no people she was connecting with her death wouldn't mean much to us.

    • @jeffhallinan194
      @jeffhallinan194 Před 11 měsíci +7

      If they followed Jon’s death path in the books it would have been more in-line with the video and less predictable to bring back. The whole book he’s trying to balance being this impartial leader with secretly aiding someone to avenge his family. At the end he decides to break his vows and abandon his post to rescue someone whom he believes to be his sister and join the king in the battle for his home…only for Jon to be killed by his own men. And we’ve seen with Beric Dondarrion and Lady Stoneheart how traumatic death is, so even when Jon gets resurrected in the books it is gonna scar him permanently.
      Book Jon’s death kills essentially a complete character, promises a future of him fighting to reclaim his home, ties in thematically with his choice to pursue love instead of duty, and will have a cost of resurrection

    • @Carlos-ux7gv
      @Carlos-ux7gv Před 11 měsíci +5

      You can promise a future for all other characters, not only the one to die, though you must avoid the "what are you going to do after the war" talk.

  • @lindildeev5721
    @lindildeev5721 Před rokem +22

    Another tip, more likely to be found in romantic stories, inspired by the promise a future tip: the no future character. It's that character who already knows he or she will die soon but his/her lover and close ones still hope that won't happen. The reader roots for them, believes that the character will make it but the inevitable fate comes crushing all our hopes.

  • @vpnightshadepersonal
    @vpnightshadepersonal Před rokem +94

    Excellent tips!
    I write under a pen name so won't reveal it here. I have killed 'villains' in all of my books. Sometimes they are main villains, sometimes they are minor villains (that work for main villains), sometimes they are what I refer to as 'on camera' kills or in great detail on the page, sometimes it happens 'off camera' where the reader is aware that the death is occurring but the death itself isn't described in detail (because usually it occurs after the villain has been tortured in detail by a main character - yes, some of my main characters walk a thin line between good and evil). The setting and method, is whatever the story calls for.
    But, the worst emotional experience for me, as a writer, was in my second book where the story called for the death of a major side character. I literally SOBBED throughout his death scene as I was writing it. I mixed it with the 'off camera' death of the major villain - where the reader knew that the hero was fighting and killing the villain 'off camera', but were witnessing the death of the major side character in the arms of the heroine 'on camera' due to a fatal injury sustained when he gave his life protecting hers. My readers lost their minds; but in a good way.
    I believe, that if we as writers, can't feel the death of a character, either triumph because it was the death of an evil character, or despair and grief because it was the death of a good character, why would we expect our readers to feel anything when it occurs? If we aren't emotionally connected to our characters - why would anyone else be?
    Of course, as a specific genre writer, I always ask myself the question at the end of my all of my novels, is this the book that is going to end my writing adventures? Have I pushed too far? I am working on my fifth book now - so as Aria Stark always said, "Not today." 😃 Love your videos!

    • @WriterBrandonMcNulty
      @WriterBrandonMcNulty  Před rokem +25

      Great point on the emotional resonance of a character's death. One trap I fall into a lot during my early drafts is that I have characters who die for the sake of "impact" but there is no impact because I didn't do the work to establish why those characters matter. I'm going through revisions on a story right now, and I need to keep that in mind.

  • @82dorrin
    @82dorrin Před rokem +39

    The "mentor death" segment made me think of The Kingsman.
    You're going through the movie thinking the mentor will probably die, somehow. But then the young hero gets killed, and it REALLY throws you for a loop. Especially with _how_ it happens.

    • @wooblydooblygod3857
      @wooblydooblygod3857 Před 11 měsíci +8

      I assume you're talking about the WW1 Kingsman.
      In which case, yes that was suc a good movie, and the events leading up to his death are the best part

    • @birdyjireh6391
      @birdyjireh6391 Před 10 měsíci +3

      I was thinking of that!!!!!! The shock, the abruptness, the unfairness of it all!

  • @userdata9511
    @userdata9511 Před 11 měsíci +56

    The most disappointing death I’ve seen in a story would probably have to be Avdol’s death from JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure part 3. The first time he “died” it had a big impact on Polnarref, allowing him to grow further as a character, and than later we find out that he didn’t actually die which was suprising and actually pretty cool to see, but than when they killed him for real later on it just wasn’t as impactful in my opinion.

    • @IDSearcher
      @IDSearcher Před 10 měsíci +11

      To be fair, he was supposed to die the first time, but Araki brought him back because fans loved him and demanded it.

    • @userdata9511
      @userdata9511 Před 10 měsíci +9

      @@IDSearcher Yeah, I didn’t have a problem with him coming back. It was when he died a 2nd time by Cream, because the 2nd time didn’t have the same impact and felt repetitive.

    • @tostey
      @tostey Před 10 měsíci +4

      @@userdata9511 I agree. I didn’t hate it, per se, but his second death was much less impactful. The anticlimactic death and the fact that it was the second time he had “died” made his death not feel real. I wasn’t even sure if he was dead or not until the very end.

    • @userdata9511
      @userdata9511 Před 10 měsíci +4

      @@tostey Well said. But regardless. I still hold the series to be among my favorite fictional works.

    • @blokvader8283
      @blokvader8283 Před 9 měsíci +6

      I'm a massive JoJo fan, and I feel like if it could be rewritten so those deaths still take place, I'd like it if Avdol's Dad was a real character who takes Avdol's place after he dies to Hol Horse and J Geil.
      Still though, I love how Araki made IGGY'S death more impactful than Avdol's lmaoo

  • @D-ei1pc
    @D-ei1pc Před rokem +154

    Jon Snow's death and revival in the tv show was disappointing cause it's as if nothing happened to him. He feels pretty much the same except maybe a bit more disgruntled . It felt like they did a better job with the resurrections of the side character Beric Dondarrion

    • @intergalactic92
      @intergalactic92 Před rokem +35

      On the contrary he did undergo a change….. they undid all his character development and regressed him to the whipping boy he was in the earlier seasons. It was completely negative on all counts, and thoroughly unsatisfying.

    • @justdan9264
      @justdan9264 Před rokem +8

      Mmhm, just look at Lady Stoneheart. So different compared to Jon in the show

    • @earthknight60
      @earthknight60 Před rokem +5

      I suspect that there will be significant changes in the book if GRRM ever gets around to finishing it.

    • @MelchVagquest
      @MelchVagquest Před rokem +2

      I actually disagree with this. I believe that Jon Snow lost his hope and fire after being resurrected. He felt compelled to lead the attack against the Boltons out of family loyalty but he no longer had the desire to lead that he had growing up.
      When Jon Snow first joined the Night's Watch, he wanted to become First Ranger like his uncle. He felt like he was being blocked but was then pleased with the idea of possibly becoming Lord Commander, after Sam put the idea in his head. He didn't like how he eventually did become Lord Commander, since he loved and respected Jeor Mormont. However, once he was elected, Jon did the best job that he could and believed he was the right man for the position.
      After being brought back, Jon says, "I did what I thought was right, and I got murdered for it." At this point, Jon's spark and desire is gone. He knows that some Free Folk will follow him because he stood up for them and he knows that some Northern families will follow him out of respect for the Starks, but Jon Snow doesn't want to do any of it. Before the Battle of the Bastards, Jon tells Melisandre to leave him dead if he falls in battle, but he sounds like he's actually hoping for it. It's not until Jon is about to suffocate and be trampled to death, that he makes the conscious decision to keep living.
      Lastly, one of the main reasons why Jon falls for Daenerys so hard, is that she makes you believe in the impossible. She reminds Jon of Ygritte's fierceness and he starts to feel some hope again, that was lost ever since his death.

    • @jackalope901
      @jackalope901 Před rokem +1

      In the books it’s not a question of whether he’ll come back but how it will change his character. Others certainly have.
      There’s also the matter of him warging into Ghost’s body first and foremost… He might not be too grateful towards those who just killed him

  • @Flerfonson
    @Flerfonson Před 10 měsíci +22

    Dobby. Dobby was a wonderful little house elf and didn’t deserve death. There was so much more that he could’ve done. I feel like his death wasn’t recognized enough after watching your video and after all the death prior to his, it just felt like one too many. Poor Dobby ❤️

    • @sarahsandstrom4853
      @sarahsandstrom4853 Před 9 měsíci +2

      This was also a great example of how a character death serves the purpose of moving the character forward and is impactful all the way to the end. Dobby is innocent and loyal, and represents how even those characters are vulnerable to the casualties of war.

  • @Tyranniod
    @Tyranniod Před rokem +20

    This is something I'm really trying to get right in my book. I want none of my characters to be safe. I want the reader to feel something when a character dies, whether that is relief or sadness. Either way I'm trying to build the characters up so that the moments hold weight and impact the rest of the story.

    • @waffler-yz3gw
      @waffler-yz3gw Před 8 měsíci

      i wanna write a book thats in first person, then the main character dies and the book switches midway through to third person. in theory, it'd make it super unique and throw everyone for a complete loop

  • @lillydevil2486
    @lillydevil2486 Před rokem +21

    Most disappointed 'death' was actually a 'Oh, he's alive again, haha' moment
    Long story short: Guy who MC has a crush on puts himself into a 'He's definitely not getting out alive situation' to buy MC and friends time to get away. But then he is illogically alive and waiting for MC in the epilogue. It's like, 'Sure, these feelings of grief don't matter now, huh?' moment and seemed stupid af

    • @elijahadkins6195
      @elijahadkins6195 Před rokem +7

      Aside from the "crush" angle, this was Billy's death in Jurassic Park 3. I watched it years ago when I was younger, and it was probably the first time I ever remember feeling disappointed that a character actually lived.

  • @darkyboode3239
    @darkyboode3239 Před rokem +16

    In regards to number 4, here are some examples in Stranger Things:
    Bob: Marrying Joyce and moving to Maine with her
    Alexei: Becoming a US citizen after defecting from the Soviet Union
    Eddie: Graduating from Hawkins Highschool

    • @sanjaykarthicks1226
      @sanjaykarthicks1226 Před 5 měsíci +1

      Still Stranger Things writers don't have balls to kill off a main character
      Example, Max Mayfield.

  • @TheAurgelmir
    @TheAurgelmir Před rokem +17

    As an RPG GM I find these tips really thought inspiring.
    I know that in many RPGs, especially Dungeons and Dragon's newer editions, death is cheap, and resurrection is cheaper. It makes the stories we tell around the table cheaper too.
    The wins the players characters get never feel as earned as in games where they know it was just as likely they would die as the villain

  • @JeremyHoffman
    @JeremyHoffman Před rokem +24

    Wow, you reopened something I'd forgotten about 10 years ago, that moment of excitement that Ned Stark was going to take the black and reuinite with Jon Snow at the Wall. Gut-wrenching! But I should have realized that Ned was doomed as soon as Lord Commander Mormont said, "He must be allowed to take the black, I need a man of his caliber here." No way things work out that well in book one.

    • @satana8157
      @satana8157 Před rokem +3

      The same happens with his son. He just realizes he can attack the Westerlands and "just" needs the Frey's army.

  • @magnusm4
    @magnusm4 Před rokem +11

    One thing about killing off a character is big consequences.
    Like you mentioned with the mentor. He knows everything and guides, then dies.
    Similar characters can be a very helpful or supportive, a safety that keeps everyone out of trouble. So their death isn't as much that they're dead but "Oh no, they're completely vulnerable now. How will they handle the situation now?". They had a plan and a backup, now both are gone and they're stuck in the middle. And the viewer can't directly tell how they're gonna deal with this.
    Take two factions and one is hunting the party blamed for a coup on both. A buddy gives them political protection and vouches for them so the other faction protects them so they can see the leader and plead innocence. Then he dies and they're blamed.
    Now the safe haven faction is hostile like they're outsiders and the bad faction can now hunt them. And now they're blamed for both crimes and have lost the only chance to redeem them selves. The party is caught with their pants down.

  • @JesusMusic1988
    @JesusMusic1988 Před 3 lety +46

    Hey this was an awesome video, very timely. I've been juggling with the thought of killing off my mentor character, and how to do it. This video gave me some insight in how to go about it. And yes, I agree that bringing a character back from the dead shouldn't be easier than curing the common cold.

    • @WriterBrandonMcNulty
      @WriterBrandonMcNulty  Před 3 lety +13

      Thanks for watching! And mentors have a bad habit of getting killed off, so definitely work hard to find a creative/unpredictable way of doing it.

    • @Bozzemoggel
      @Bozzemoggel Před rokem +8

      i´ve read something a while ago where the mentor was a master of poisons and the apprentice was getting more and more sick of his ways, finally planning to kill him and take over his business, but he was prepared and always one step ahead, killing her and while she was paralyzed and slowly died he was holding her, comforting and praising her for the skills she aquired along their way. When she was dead he was like "damn, it happened again, i´ll need another apprentice"... that storyline was something else

  • @unexpectedTrajectory
    @unexpectedTrajectory Před rokem +18

    This obviously isn't a "death" in the usual sense, but I remember as a kid I was *devastated* at the end of The Voyage of the Dawn Treader (C.S. Lewis) when Lucy is told she won't be coming back to Narnia (or maybe it was at the end of Prince Caspian when Peter and Susan are told the same, now I think maybe I conflated the two in my memory.) Just to say, there are non-lethal ways of removing characters and getting the emotional impact. And it made it OK for her character to reappear later without technically returning to Narnia and without her having to be resurrected.

    • @cardboardbox191
      @cardboardbox191 Před 11 měsíci

      My thought is you could cripple the mentor character. In the right kind of setting that could be really harsh.

    • @Blaqjaqshellaq
      @Blaqjaqshellaq Před 11 měsíci

      @@cardboardbox191 Remember the TV series BIRDS OF PREY where Batgirl became a crippled mentor?

    • @cardboardbox191
      @cardboardbox191 Před 11 měsíci +1

      @@Blaqjaqshellaq No I've never watched it. There's a Byzantine rule that the king needs to not be crippled I think it was something like full in mind and body. Certain societies especially in fiction might say why are we listening to this guy or lady if they can't even fight. Dousn't matter that they killed ten enemies with spears using a fruit-cutting knife before one of them got luck and took both their knees out.

  • @Ashen_squad
    @Ashen_squad Před 10 měsíci +7

    I have a story where the biggest point (That i've come up with so far) is the death and eventual return of the main character, but since it's my first time ever writing a long story, i'm really not sure if went about it the right way.
    The death itself is caused by a disease known as a Blight, the same genetic mutation that many characters have adapted to and gained special powers from.
    The MC slowly begins to falter in their duties as a guard, and even notices signs of serious illness/damage to their body, but hides it from the royal family and other guards out of habit and refusal to abandon their duty. Eventually though, the Blight advances and causes the mc to lose the ability to properly function - Joints become unable to move and keep them contained to a bed, they can barely speak, yet the physical pain is nothing compared to the pain of seeing their love, the princess, weeping over them and refusing to leave their side.
    After the disease finally kills them off, the grief of their companions and the princess causes many problems in the palace - The blind aerokinetic guard's powers begin to falter and cause her ability to navigate her surroundings to falter (She senses air flow to navigate), the princess remains locked up in her room for weeks at a time and eventually leaves her home to become a mercenary under a different name, etc.
    Eventually though, the mc returns as through an already mysterious power known as "The Hollow" (Still workshopping the actual event and names). The costs of becoming a Walker include loss of memory, white hair and occasional hits of pure agony at essentially random times. Because nobody was around for their revival and they wear a stolen combat suit w/ a mask, not even the princess recognises them when they meet face to face, and the mc also doesn't remember her due to the memory loss.
    I apologize for the massive wall of text, i can't help myself. Even though every single character has a name, i didn't put any in, mostly because i thought it would be better to just explain the concept
    Edit: This entire concept has recently been overhauled and improved to avoid annoying cliches, but i won't go into detail because this comment is long enough :/

  • @willowallen4688
    @willowallen4688 Před rokem +45

    Ive only killed one major character in all my stories, and I'm quite proud of how it turned out. He was the love interest to my main character and his death had been planned from the very beginning. The entire theme of the story centered around depression and it was very important that he die simply because my main character had been leaning on him as a crutch instead of finding out the root of her depression and dealing with it. I have quiiiite a few comments (because the story is on wattpad) of people mad at me because I made them cry and killed off such a nice character.
    So how did I pull this off? Well, he acted as the main characters protector because she is blind but is keeping it a secret from everyone but him (its a weird case for how she is able to pull this off effectively). Anyway, I foreshadowed his death quite a lot in the chapters leading up to it and even threw in a crow for extra measure. Now, what I think what got the majority of them crying was the scene right after his death where the main character is laying down crying to herself. Throughout the entire story, I had done my best to show how good of a relationship they had but she never quite said "I love you" to him. But now that she was alone, she regretted not telling him over and over again how much she loved him and how badly she really wanted to start a family with him.
    I remember quite clearly crying myself while writing it 😅 but now that its been a few years, I'm finally going back to it to clean up all the plot holes. I had a few commentors point out that sometimes it seemed she only stayed with him because he acted as her eyes when that wasnt my intention at all. I have quite a lot of rewriting to do, but I hope to make this scene just as impactful (or maybe even more so!) when I eventually get to it.

  • @redflag0477
    @redflag0477 Před 11 měsíci +8

    Stephen King is honestly great at character death The Dark Tower has some of the most impactful character deaths out of any story I have read.

  • @WriterBrandonMcNulty
    @WriterBrandonMcNulty  Před 4 lety +10

    What character death disappointed you the most? BE SURE TO MARK FOR SPOILERS AND LEAVE SPACE BEFORE ANSWERING!!

  • @saltysyd99
    @saltysyd99 Před rokem +10

    Star Wars: The Bad Batch Season 2 finale spoilers
    I think Tech's death fits pretty much every single point in this video. He:
    -was killed as a result of Tarkin not hesitating to use his firepower/Saw going all out (hate him) with no consideration of others' survival
    -was developed much more throughout the season in several emotional scenes (and got a whole episode to himself)
    -was very close to Omega, and we see her sad reaction when Hunter tells her he's gone
    -had been hoping to save Crosshair and eventually return to Pabu to finally find a peaceful life (and even had a sort of love interest growing with Phee)
    -perfectly showcased the recurring theme of sacrifice throughout both The Clone wars and The Bad Batch
    As for "coming back from the dead", it's a very common Star Wars trope, and it's kind of cheap at this point, so I hope that he stays dead in the third season. (in the nicest way possible haha)

    • @occycat.
      @occycat. Před 11 měsíci +1

      I thought that!

    • @saltysyd99
      @saltysyd99 Před 11 měsíci +3

      @@occycat. yay! I'm always happy to find other bad batch fans haha

    • @occycat.
      @occycat. Před 11 měsíci +4

      @@saltysyd99 YES! Bad batch is generally amazing!

  • @thatcanadian6698
    @thatcanadian6698 Před rokem +5

    The death of Tommy in The Shawshank Redemption fulfills numbers 1, 2, 3 and 4 all at once in my opinion. When I first saw Shawshank in the theatre people around us gasped and said things like 'oh my god' and 'oh no!' The screenwriter certainly didn't pull any punches on that one. His death was emotional because we were growing to like him as did the characters in the movie. He was becoming a complete character by honestly and openly exposing his past, and the explosive revelation about Elmo Blatch's jail cell confession made him suddenly and unexpectedly very important to the central character in the film, Andy Dufresne. Passing his high school equivalency test promised a bright future for him and his newborn child, but that was quickly snuffed out with one casual glance from the warden. Want to learn about character development, great story writing and how to toy with the audience's emotions? Watch Shawshank.

  • @flandyc4513
    @flandyc4513 Před rokem +8

    I would like to note that death cliche and thematic tie ins might seem like contradictory advice, but people should focus on how and when to use them.
    Even something as simple as having one of those "non bullies" end up dying in a surprise but inadvertant fashion.

  • @ryptoll4801
    @ryptoll4801 Před rokem +12

    I struggle to kill off any character that isn't either a minor character or a villain. I'm not really sure what I should do about that, because it's starting to feel like a bit of a problem now that I'm writing an action story that deals a lot with death, trauma and fighting in general. However, pretty much all the developed protagonists of my story deal with so much trauma and loss already that maybe that's the real reason I just don't want to deliver any death blows to them.
    Like they've gone through enough already, a death would be like overkill in that context. As if killing any of them would just make my already dark story too dark, as I don't want for it to become a downright tragedy. Also as my main theme for this story is "recovery" I really need for the amounts of tragedy vs rising from it to be well balanced and proportional. And... you can't recover from death. Even the one character I could have chosen to kill I instead chose to keep alive (but gravely injured) because that would actually lead to a more intense emotional impact and cause more resolution for the other characters. In almost all cases for my characters, death would either be too cheap, or take away too much of what little positivity they've got going. When you start a story with "All these characters have a lot of suffering and very little good things to hold onto" and want for most of them to have a positive arc, you kinda end up with not much to reasonably take away from them.
    Somehow I feel like that's better than to get fixated on the idea that just because the characters are in a life and death situation a lot, that means they can't all survive. I take it more to mean that if they all survive, they're going to be really (emotionally and physically) scarred. Basically, my point is: maybe death isn't the only kinda trauma of high emotional and shock value you can put your characters through.
    I say that because I realized I never had trouble killing off characters in my previous works, but now suddenly I do. In fact, I've been very trigger happy with my fully developed characters in other stories. I made a lot of deeply emotionally impactful deaths that had me crying through the script for every edit. It felt right because it was meaningful. Even though that wasn't action stories at all, they were dramas and tragedies. It's just with this particular story (my current project) that it suddenly doesn't sit right with me to kill off a lot of characters, even though this is the most action-packed story I've written so far. And maybe that's why I feel insecure about it, because this is my first action story and I don't wanna be bad at that genre.

  • @ellennewth6305
    @ellennewth6305 Před rokem +4

    Bonnie Blue Butler's death in "Gone With The Wind" was a hard one to take. But I love Scarlet's realization that her daughter has the same willful spirit as her father. She whispers "Just like papa" right before Bonnie jumps over the fence.

  • @ScarletFang423
    @ScarletFang423 Před 9 měsíci

    Hey Brandon! Thank you for making this video. Will definitely keep this information in mind and even come back and revisit this video when I feel ready to write a novel!

  • @gabriellabatel
    @gabriellabatel Před 9 měsíci

    This was SUCH an excellent set of tips, hit everything perfectly, thank you!

  • @Tony_Bone
    @Tony_Bone Před 9 měsíci +1

    Thanks man! This'll really help spice up my autobiography!

  • @daniealgriffin9469
    @daniealgriffin9469 Před rokem

    This guy is soo passionate!!!! direct and to the point!

  • @BlaykeWasHereStudiosOfficial

    I made a Lego Star Wars stop-motion and I just killed off random characters just for the sh*ts and giggles. And whenever a major death happened in the short film, the character would sorta just die like a background character. I MUST NOT MAKE THE SAME MISTAKE AGAIN

  • @NotEnoughAlpacas
    @NotEnoughAlpacas Před 9 měsíci +2

    Looking for Alaska by John Green is the book that got me back. It's so good at showing you how a death affects the other characters in the story, making you like the character, and tying that character's death into the theme

  • @samuelmurrill7438
    @samuelmurrill7438 Před rokem +2

    0:37 Thank you for clarifying, Brandon

  • @BigDyl37
    @BigDyl37 Před 10 měsíci +1

    Cheers for this, my autobiography is gonna be fire with this one!

  • @tigerlover2853
    @tigerlover2853 Před 9 měsíci +1

    Thanks, this is really gonna help with my autobiography!

  • @christianoutlaw
    @christianoutlaw Před 7 měsíci

    Thanks for all the awesome content. I'm glad this one came up in my feed. These were some excellent tips that gave me a lot to think about. In particular the last one about reviving the dead. I had a character that was pretty significant die midway through a book only to turn up not dead, kind of the classic "if you didn't see it happen, it didn't happen". Now that I say that it seems even more of a cliche that he survived. The fact that he just showed up again like nothing happened lacks a lot of impact and it didn't really have a huge amount of ramifications outside of the immediate aftermath. The idea for it to have some consequences already is adding a lot to it and it's giving him much more of an arc as a character. So that helped a lot and I really appreciate that.

  • @wetguts
    @wetguts Před 9 měsíci +2

    I think jedi survivor handled killing off the mentor pretty well, as when they died it was in the sequel from when we met them, and there was a whole epic build up to it in the first place. They made it no longer about the mentor dying but about a side character who died through the events of a sequel.

  • @alexibeshears7549
    @alexibeshears7549 Před rokem

    I really liked this. I've been working on a story on and off for a long time now and many things have changed since I first began working on it, but one thing that hasn't changed since I thought it up is the death of the main characters' sister. I am nowhere near writing that scene, but the fact that she dies is something that is integral to the story I'm writing as she is a symbol for the main character, in a way. Now I have a video to come back to for when I need to reference good death writing techniques.

  • @racheltheradiant4675
    @racheltheradiant4675 Před rokem +3

    One of the most meaningful deaths I've ever read in fiction was in C.L. Wlison's Tairen Soul series. The couple had a whole subplot and I was rooting for them until the end. I still sob when i read it.

  • @zpettigrew
    @zpettigrew Před rokem

    THANKS. This was quite helpful.

  • @paul_has_nolife
    @paul_has_nolife Před 10 měsíci +1

    thank you very much, this will be really useful for my autobiography

  • @drowned2204
    @drowned2204 Před 10 měsíci

    The thumbnail is lovely!

  • @russellvitranoiii3504

    Fascinating video! Your tips are very helpful. I'm currently working on a project with a death scene... and i just don't like how I got to the end of that last chapter. So I'll give it a rewrite and use your advice.
    What I really want to see is a convincing, serious... "reverse" mentor/protégé scenario, in which the mentor survives but the protégé doesn't. I can't think of any really good examples of that except, possibly and Spoiler Ahead, that scene in Deadpool 2 in which all those minor heroes get clobbered (albeit in fairly humorous ways) except for Deadpool and Domino, I believe.
    Oh, and I bought your book Entry Wounds. I'm excited to start reading it!

  • @dneill8493
    @dneill8493 Před 11 měsíci +1

    The death i never saw coming and upset me because of the struggle he went through before he died was Leonardo's character in The Departed. Hated his death but it had a hell of an impact. Fantastic movie.

  • @AhimtarHoN
    @AhimtarHoN Před rokem

    9:22 I really love how the Shaman King anime series (the recent remake) handled this exact point brillantly.

  • @giovdb
    @giovdb Před rokem +1

    One of my favorite deaths is Noah in the Walking Dead. He’s a young man who decides to step up in the community. He goes to the builder guy and says he wants to learn from him and wants to do his part. Later that same episode, he dies one of the most graphic deaths in a revolving door. SOOO good.

  • @ajdndbdjbdj
    @ajdndbdjbdj Před 11 měsíci

    Subbed for ma future projects
    Damn point 4 is actually gibes me ideas

  • @Yehyasafwat
    @Yehyasafwat Před dnem

    I am published author with 8 books most of which are best sellers. And I want to thank you. Your videos have been very helpful.
    Wish you all the best.

  • @trouvial
    @trouvial Před 10 měsíci

    it’s midnight. I’ve never even took interest in writing books, yet I’m here. nice!

  • @Tabaluca911
    @Tabaluca911 Před 9 měsíci

    great video, i just think the thumpnail is quite ironic considering martin recently said that he had problems with already killing off a character he later realised he needed

  • @goatthekid4513
    @goatthekid4513 Před 10 měsíci

    Thanks, ill definitely use this. My autobiography will be legendary

  • @reaganmonkey8
    @reaganmonkey8 Před 10 měsíci +1

    In large scale battles, you can’t get to know all the thousands of people who die.

  • @Insaniquangrybirds
    @Insaniquangrybirds Před 11 měsíci +3

    Well, I did have a few difficult options for Project Jector(still workshopping the name). Heaven mode is the easiest mode, which enemies are weaker, and if a character if defeated, you can bring them back to consciousness unless all your characters fall. Surface mode is the game’s normal mode that disallows that, if your character falls, you can’t use them until the level is clear, and the enemies are at normal strength. That leaves me with Heck Mode, the hard mode. It’s similar to how Fire Emblem does it, which if your character falls, they die, leaving you unable to use them for the rest of the game, and the enemies are strongest.

  • @stevezagieboylo9172
    @stevezagieboylo9172 Před rokem

    Even as a teen I sensed this lesson when reading Anne McCaffrey's Pern novels. In the first novel, she kills off the main character in a glorious and satisfying way, that buys time for the other characters to be able to grow into the hero roles. However, by the third book, she was so in love with the characters that you knew none of them were ever really at risk, making the suspense hollow.
    I love the bit about hinting at a promising future. That is a brilliant tip and I totally plan to use it soon.

  • @eatmorenachos
    @eatmorenachos Před rokem +4

    Put a red shirt on them, just like in Star Trek.

  • @ark-li3lu
    @ark-li3lu Před 3 lety +1

    You’re awesome dude 🤘

  • @SequentiallyCompact
    @SequentiallyCompact Před rokem +5

    I can't think of many resurrections that I don't hate. Coming back from the dead has become a cancer on fiction IMO. It's gotten to the point where I can't convince people who read my fiction that I've actually killed a character. I have a prelude story in a world where archaeology uncovers a lot more than it does in the real world, unearthing a vast ancient advanced civilization, and I had a demi-goddess character literally detonate and annihilate herself on a subatomic level, and I can't convince some readers that she is actually dead within the diegesis of the story.

    • @Maddolis
      @Maddolis Před rokem +1

      Alec Trevelyan in Goldeneye worked well I reckon.

    • @legrandliseurtri7495
      @legrandliseurtri7495 Před 11 měsíci

      The resurrection of a certain character in The Burning White by Brent Weeks still pisses me off to this day. I'll still re-read the series because there's so much to like about it, but that one decision really harms the ending.

    • @AverageCommentor
      @AverageCommentor Před 11 měsíci

      Gandalf worked perfectly fine I'd say.

  • @eastonburnor4018
    @eastonburnor4018 Před rokem

    Thank you. I’m 16 and I’ve been trying to write a book sense I was twelve.

  • @haristahir3472
    @haristahir3472 Před rokem +3

    plot armor go brrrrrrrrrrrr.

  • @Thurgor_Supreme
    @Thurgor_Supreme Před 8 měsíci +1

    In my story, my mage main character is still learning his abilities. He tries something never done before, a massive magical sphere to teleport his people away from a losing battle. However, everyone on the edge of the sphere only gets umm... "partially teleported" (cut in half). One of these people happens to be his best friend and it guilt wracks him for the rest of the story, in a way crippling his character development

  • @MoltenPlastic
    @MoltenPlastic Před 9 měsíci +1

    Something I hate about serial storytelling - Walking Dead was especially guilty of this - is when cool villains are set up and then killed off, and then the author realises they lost an awesome character and tries to create another villain just like the other one.

  • @ElliYeetYT
    @ElliYeetYT Před rokem +7

    My favourite way a character can be defeated or killed in a movie is with Poetic Justice/Irony, like foreshadowing that is hidden to set up a character’s death without us knowing initially or when they achieve their goal but still lose. Examples like:
    - Thanos at the end of “Avengers Endgame” being snapped away by the very stones that he tried to get all his life and those which his Infinity War counterpart already used in the prior movie.
    - Syndrome in “The Incredibles” being shredded by a plane turbine due to his cape, which is one of the things that Edna warned Mr Incredible about when denying superhero capes.
    - The Ring that Kept Gollum alive for centuries is the very thing that causes him to fall and die in the lava of Mount Doom in “LOTR: The Return Of The King.”
    - Megatron in the first live-action “Transformers” movie is defeated and shredded by the Allspark cube, the very thing that he seeked to use to amplify his Decepticon army.
    Anyway I’m sure there are many other examples but yeah irony is my favourite method in taking out a character.

    • @lowlife1368
      @lowlife1368 Před 11 měsíci +1

      Literally every character in Halo reach died in a ironic way.

  • @stevemanart
    @stevemanart Před 9 měsíci +1

    Goblin Slayer gets a lot of flack for gratuity in its violence (and for being a Japanese gameworld fantasy light novel series...), but the first few chapters being dedicated to adventurers who get violated by a group of goblins makes the deaths and worse really impactful beyond the shock. You saw their hubris and friendship, you learn about what they want to do with their lives, and most important you come to like them. In fact, until his death the book tries to make you think the novice warrior of the group is who eventually becomes the title character. But no. And no matter what one's opinions are on the series going forward, that intro makes those deaths matter.

  • @evalationx2649
    @evalationx2649 Před 10 měsíci +1

    A character death that has really stuck with me is from Walking Dead season2 when Sophia stumbled out of the barn after the characters spent half a season desperately looking for her.

  • @Kyomaku
    @Kyomaku Před 9 měsíci +1

    My general concept for killing characters is to write the general concept of the story and which characters are necessary for it. Then, add a few characters that aren't needed for the story, but develop them in the exact same way as you do your major supporting characters and main characters, as early as possible and as well written as possible. From the start, you account for them not being required for the story to function, and from the start, you already planned their death, yet from the pov of the reader, they can't really tell the difference from that character to the others, until the character dies off, giving the sense that any character can die, since the character did not really appear any different from the others until then. Only in hindsight will it become clear, that the character wasn't needed for the story and only added character development to the others.. Killing off undeveloped sidecharacters really is no fun anyways, no emotional impact, no surprise. As a reader, you almost always have the sense of security, that certain characters are simply safe, cause they're the main characters. Something that I really dislike but feels hard to overcome in writing

  • @sanjaykarthicks1226
    @sanjaykarthicks1226 Před 5 měsíci

    9:40 The best example of reviving a dead character is the revival of Catelyn Stark as Lady Stoneheart. Even though, she came back to life, she isn't herself anymore. She has become a killing machine to avenge her family deaths and she has become heartless.

  • @AnotherDuck
    @AnotherDuck Před rokem +2

    While killing a character with a promising future does have a strong impact, I think killing a character with a difficult future is often more of a waste. In particular someone who started or is just about to start a redemption arc. That’s cutting out a lot of potential drama and character development. Which is also a cliche.

  • @whatifanime7027
    @whatifanime7027 Před 11 měsíci

    this video really helped with my autobiography

  • @DestruoTheWithered
    @DestruoTheWithered Před rokem

    3:34 that is the thing that the Hamish Macbeth does, the book let's us see the dead character before they die, letting us get to know their personality a little, sometimes they make you love the character, or they make you hate the character to sympathise with the killer.

  • @PoppyRHdesk-
    @PoppyRHdesk- Před 5 měsíci +1

    I really needed to watch this, I’m writing a murder mystery series. My main rule is: never have characters that you know well perish. I never kill characters that were in previous books. It just ruins the series.

  • @dablackangel
    @dablackangel Před rokem +9

    Most painful character deaths: Robb Stark, Oberyn Martell, Rue and Finnick. And also Chris Chambers in Stand By Me (I know it was at the end... but it was still sad hearing about it)
    Most disappointing: Colossus (because they brought him back... they should have kept him dead)
    Best resurrection: Jean Grey and Lady Stoneheart... and we'll see about Jon Snow's resurrection in The Winds of Winter.
    Honourable mention would be for T'Challa / Chadwick Boseman 😢

  • @backpack_hermit25
    @backpack_hermit25 Před 10 měsíci +1

    A way I've managed to incorporate worries into the reader and doubt.
    It's a superhero story set in medieval times, the villain and the hero share a trait to steal the superhuman abilities of other people. One that is highly focused on is the power of literal immortality. Both the villain and hero are continiously shifting, switching and playing with a multitude of powers, rapidly changing with every punch they throw, with their entire loadout seeming to change every time they touch eachother. I like to use it to scare the reader into thinking, 'WHO IS IMMORTAL, WHO IS SAFE RIGHT NOW???' And in these intense main conflicts and fights, not even the characters can know, constantly trying everything they can to survive at all times. Along with a large group of people, who are witchhunted for having these people, trusting their only defenses, their superpowers to one person, giving up their defences so someone can risk it all and win.
    Another story I've written, clearly shows I love playing with the concept of immortality. I mean, almost all the characters are highly resilient, semi-immortal. About a species of monster that are alter-egos to humans, they embody the humans emotions and cannot die unless their human dies. But if they were to die? They'll be out of commission to reform, which can take a day to a week based on injuries, and each time they die, a piece of their humans soul is killed, making them more miserable, more depressed and/or sickly. But the main duo of the story, one of these mosnters who lost their shield of immortality, and a human being, are mortal from the very beginning of the story. And it created anxiety as they deal with grusome and incredibly grizzly scenarios that could kill them in half a second. This story is very focused on not letting your past ruin your life as it will come back to bite you through your own wreckless decisions.

  • @DoublesOK
    @DoublesOK Před rokem

    Good video. Also what if you want the characters to think someone is dead but not the reader.

  • @Ch1l1C0nCarnag3
    @Ch1l1C0nCarnag3 Před 8 měsíci

    Something I have in my story is the main character sees death quite a lot, but none of it being those close to them. Shortly after a major revelation that shakes the MC and turns their world upside down and causes him to act irrationally, the major character whom is closest to him dies, but he manages to bring her back through an expanded use of the powers he has been learning and practicing throughout the story. But during that fight she ended up losing one of her eyes, a wing and a large portion of her tail, leaving her permanently scarred and a constant reminder to him that it was his negligence that led to those wounds.
    Then not long after this they're thrown into a confrontation with a reoccurring antagonist working for the current "villain". This character has been on the fence between if they're friend or foe, as well as teaching the MC some valuable lessons that have helped him survive so the MC doesn't want to fight, making it seem like they'll find a way to bridge that gap and have them survive since I'd set the precendent "important characters don't die". But no, the antagonist gives him no choice. It's a fight to the death and thus resulting the first major death of the story and laying the groundwork for future deaths for other characters important to the main character.
    I view it as a way to set an expectation through the deaths of minor/non-characters, reinforce that expectation through the revival of a main character, only to immediately put a massive crack in the expectation with a major character death, and then finally shatter it completely with the deaths of some of the MC's closest allies.

  • @theunintelligentlydesigned4931

    #4 promising a future can become a cliche itself, especially the more promising the future. If a character is about to have all his dreams come true and it seems like his future is too good to be true, you know he gonna die. I would recommend tempering that promised future with some realism. Don't promise that his life will be great. Promise that his life will be just a little bit better.
    #6 reaction to death: I've seen a very bad example of this. I don't know what movie it was but there was a scene where six astronauts were space walking, climbing all over the outside of the craft to rescue it. I'm not sure what they were rescuing it from but one of the astronauts finally made it to this control panel and flipped the switch, only to be immediately pulverized by a bit of space debris. Then the danger was over and one of the five remaining said, "We all survived." and the five remaining astronauts calmly climbed back into the craft.

  • @Joey7Z7Horror
    @Joey7Z7Horror Před 7 měsíci +2

    [SPOILERS]
    As a horror specialist, the question of the day is very easy. Alex Browning. Was it the most emotionally disappointing for me? I feel like there might’ve been worse. However in Final Destination 2, they couldn’t get his actor so they just killed him inbetween movies. The way he died was getting a single brick to the head. Dull Machete award, this deserved

  • @nmappraiser9926
    @nmappraiser9926 Před měsícem

    Regarding complete characters, I dunno. Some of the most haunting scenes in fiction are deaths of minor characters. The chapter in "The Stand" that visits random deaths, from the toddler falling down a well, the father who lost all his kids to the plague, the teenager who locks herself into a meat locker with her family. These little snippets are so resonant, painting a picture in a pointilistic way, making the horror so real because of the implication that everyone is affected, not just the major characters. Obviously King is a master at creating characters you care about with just a few lines, but the fact that these people don't contribute to the plot doesn't mean they don't have an impact on the reader.

  • @nickmilano2516
    @nickmilano2516 Před 10 měsíci +1

    I’m making my own villain but his sad backstory. But the thing in his story that makes him more like he is today feels like it’s literally forcing it to make the sad part happen, because in his story, a accident happens, which makes him like that his brother accidentally tipped over something and it just feels like I couldn’t get a different other reason so I’m trying to fix it

  • @zioptis40
    @zioptis40 Před rokem +2

    For a story I’m writing, I kind of want to do a fake-out. Kill off one character, have the main character go insane and become what he wished to destroy and have the secondary character become the main so he can either redeem his friend, or have to kill him. Death will, obviously, still happen to good characters so the readers won’t think I’m spineless

  • @SandeeDude
    @SandeeDude Před 8 měsíci

    "Promise a future" is probably my least favourite approach because it makes it way too obvious that something bad is about to happen to that character. I immediately think "okay yeah they're screwed" and detach myself from that character before it happens, which ruins the shock and emotional impact of the death

  • @justacat869
    @justacat869 Před 10 měsíci

    About the resurrection trope, there's an aspect of it which is not very discussed but I find it fascinating: when the resurrection works technically as in the character is brought back to life but they are... different. Not like their old self. Maybe they forgot all the skills they have including basic survival skills and they need to be taught like a toddler. Maybe they have full amnesia (which cannot be cured with just a magic spell or something). Maybe the character cannot be who they used to be before their death so they have to learn to become someone new. Or maybe their resurrection comes at a great cost and another character close to them dies because of it. I think there are many possibilities to make resurrection interesting.

  • @aminahabour5781
    @aminahabour5781 Před rokem +1

    I think I've done a pretty job killing off my main character according to the tips you provided, which I'm so thankful for that you share them💓.I surprisingly covered the seven and a half if I could say that 😅Bcuz when I brought him back to life it was in a different timeline (fate)and it had a great cost subverting the original supposed fate for his surrounding, as his death saved many and was necessary.
    And the character's death disappointed me the most is the su*****d of Akonko From things fall apart by Chinua Achebe.

  • @nictheartist
    @nictheartist Před 10 měsíci

    2001 Maniacs subverted the Final Girl trope, although - if memory serves- it was more like a Final Couple.

  • @shawnwheelock8835
    @shawnwheelock8835 Před rokem +2

    I've been thinking about Gandolf death. There wasn't a cost to it, obviously. But it very much advanced the Christian themes of the story. Really interesting. Thank you.

    • @tabularasa0606
      @tabularasa0606 Před rokem +1

      1. He was an immortal, so he wasn't dead.
      2. He payed a huge price, he had to step into a role he didn't want. He wanted to be the advisor, work in the background. Instead he had to go against the person he looked up to, Saruman, to take his place as leader and move to the foreground.

  • @ForestOfContent
    @ForestOfContent Před 11 měsíci +1

    I'm a guy who is possibly gonna make an animated series/movie in the future, although it is still in its concept stages, and this video helped with some of the story parts that are no longer in the concept stages! Thanks!
    -Trigger warning: mentions of [self-deletion] later in the comment, trust me it is relevant to what I talk about.
    Also, I'd like to add to the part about bringing characters back to life. One of the best examples of this is the youtube movie "Emesis Blue". (Minor spoiler warning, if you haven't watched Emesis Blue, go do so, it's really good) The plot of the movie revolves around a machine that brings mercenaries back to life each time they die, but the cost is their mental health. Multiple of these mercenaries have either suffered from symptoms of schizophrenia, or more extreme stuff like time anomalies and time loops or physical and mental mutations. The machine has a chance to fail, and when it does... well, watch the movie for yourself. The effects of a failed revive are so extreme to the point that the 10th of the mercenaries (now there are 9) has attempted [self-deletion], so that he doesn't have to live through the torture. This, I believe is one of the best examples of the cost of ressurection I have seen so far. I have left certain details in the comment intentionally vague, because I would hate to spoil the movie for someone.

  • @D.M.S.
    @D.M.S. Před 11 měsíci +1

    "Oh man, I really love living!" *dies*

  • @GORYGIRL
    @GORYGIRL Před 3 lety +2

    LOVE YOUR WORK, THESE TIPS WILL PROVE HELPFUL TO ME FOR MY HORROR NOVEL THANK YOU! [JUST SO YOU KNOW, I'M NOT TYPING LIKE THIS TO YELL, I'M LEGALLY BLIND].
    BUT I HAVE A QUESTION REGARDING THE "GET TO KNOW" THE CHARACTERS...FORGIVE ME IF THIS SEEMS LIKE A SILLY QUESTION BUT...HOW MUCH INFO SHOULD SOMEONE WRITE TO "GET THE AUDIENCE TO KNOW THEM"? DOES THAT MEAN LIKE A DAY IN THEIR LIFE TYPE DEAL?
    I KNOW IT DOESN'T HAVE TO BE A BACKSTORY-TYPE THING, BUT STILL...JUST ASKING, I KNOW THE FLAWS AND PERSONALITY ARE IMPORTANT BUT I'M STILL CONFUSED...OR ARE THE FLAWS, PERSONALITY, AND INTERESTS ENOUGH?

    • @WriterBrandonMcNulty
      @WriterBrandonMcNulty  Před 3 lety +2

      No worries with the ALL CAPS. What do you use to type? I'm just curious.
      Also, WOULD IT HELP YOU IF I TYPED IN ALL CAPS? LET ME KNOW.
      As for getting the audience to know your characters, you need to give us a reason to CARE. You can show us that you character has a charming personality or a kind heart or a meaningful goal/desire in life.
      There are many ways to help us get to know characters, but we MUST CARE ABOUT THEM ASAP.

    • @GORYGIRL
      @GORYGIRL Před 3 lety +1

      @@WriterBrandonMcNulty THANKS FOR THINKING OF ME, IT MEANS A LOT, BUT YOU DON'T HAVE TO TYPE IN CAPS UNLESS YOU WANT TO. I CAN READ YOUR NORMAL LOWERCASE JUST FINE, I DO THIS FOR ME.
      AS FOR YOUR ANSWER[S] THANK YOU I'LL KEEP THEM IN MIND...BUT WHAT ABOUT JERK CHARACTERS? DO I NEED TO MAKE THEM UNLIKEABLE TO BE MEMORABLE? [EVEN IF THEY'RE NOT THE ANTAGONIST].
      OR DO I NEED TO GIVE THEM SOME LIKABLE TRAITS WITCH MAKES MORE SENSE ON A REALISTIC LEVEL?