Creatine in Midlife - The #1 Supplement for Women’s Muscle, Bone, and Brain Health | Dr. Susan

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 13. 09. 2024

Komentáře • 140

  • @maylepujol4889
    @maylepujol4889 Před 12 dny +2

    For some time now I have noticed my husband take creatine and thought this was just for men!! Finally, after doing research and finding your page, I have the best information for myself, a 51yr. old woman. Thank you so much :)

  • @dorothyg111
    @dorothyg111 Před měsícem +35

    I’ve started taking the Creatine and I felt amazing, my brain was very sharp and I had more energy but it messed with my sleep. I started waking up at 2-3 at night and I couldn’t get to sleep after that so I stopped because sleeping is more important for me.

  • @Melodie007
    @Melodie007 Před 21 dnem +4

    Just starting Creatine at age 66. Finding a good formulation seems to be the key, for me.

  • @kcsunnyone
    @kcsunnyone Před 23 dny +9

    I began taking creatine 5 grams in May 2023 at 60 yrs of age, but didn't take it regularly. I started BHRT pellet in January 2024 and added creatine 5 g daily in May 2024. I definitely think it helps my brain and muscles and I had no gastric issues when I began taking it.

    • @apacur
      @apacur Před 17 dny

      What type of Creatine?

  • @cornflowertoile3026
    @cornflowertoile3026 Před 24 dny +6

    Just discovered your channel today, this was a great study, thanks. I have found that when I take creatine muscle injuries heal quicker.

  • @bewellwithdanyel938
    @bewellwithdanyel938 Před 3 dny

    I really appreciate this thorough overview. I’m not at all surprised that the most widely studied supplement is one that built muscles. I.e. studied for men. we’re finally entering era where studies for women at very stages in life is going is essential and beginning to be a thing! Finally! Although there’s still a long way to go, I’m sure. This information needs to get out to every woman!

  • @mkwil65
    @mkwil65 Před měsícem +8

    Received my Thorne order last week and have added to my tea every morning. Can’t thank you enough for your education and help Dr. Susan? I’ve truly learned so much from you!

    • @kathynewkirk683
      @kathynewkirk683 Před měsícem +1

      I have read on other channels that heat might affect the effectiveness of creatine.

    • @toriwolf5978
      @toriwolf5978 Před 11 dny

      Not suppose to put it in tea or coffee they work against each other take separately !❤

  • @deborahbrown6610
    @deborahbrown6610 Před dnem +2

    You did not address creatine in relation to chronic kidney disease. With so many having prediabetes and diabetes which can lead to ckd how do you feel about supplementation?
    CKD is affected by creatine. Please advise 😊

  • @Candleflower42
    @Candleflower42 Před měsícem +8

    My brother was diagnosed with Lewy Body dementia a year ago. Doing very well so far and very good to do exercise. I’ll send this and hope he’ll add creatine! I take it and my kidney function was a little off so informed my doc she said next draw stay off for a few days before. Broke my femur (bad break) 4 years ago age 67 and my leg just never came back in spite of much rehab. No more biking, hiking, even working in the yard is difficult. Don’t fall ladies, it really can drastically change your life. Dr. Susan if you read this and don’t mind my unrelated question, I’m on an estrogen patch and the pharmacy only gave me half the 100mg progesterone and no refill for a month. Can I be off progesterone for a month with no risk of cancer? I’m going to have doc up my estrogen dose as level came back 47 and a bone doc on CZcams Dr Doug show says at least 60 to protect bones. It was 550 on the biest - had doc change me to patch since you said slightly higher risk of stroke with oral if older. I’ll tell ya it’s amazing what we can learn from experts on CZcams and then take that to our doctors. Thank you for all your great content!

    • @drsusan
      @drsusan  Před měsícem +2

      I can't make specific recommendations without being your doctor but short term unopposed estrogen is not a problem for uterine cancer - but in general should take it regularly

    • @Zumbunnies
      @Zumbunnies Před měsícem +1

      I changed from progesterone cream to the micronized capsules and from 100 to 200 and boy has it made a difference for me. Just FYI.

    • @Candleflower42
      @Candleflower42 Před měsícem +2

      @@Zumbunnies I’m glad you found something that makes a difference. Mine are 100 and a gelatinous oval shape, I don’t know what micronized means, but I’ve never felt any different on or off hormones take strictly for bones.

    • @Contessa998
      @Contessa998 Před 20 dny

      @@Candleflower42
      Cannot tolerate progesterone. Only cream form. Those gelatin capsules make me sick 🤢 and depressed

    • @Candleflower42
      @Candleflower42 Před 20 dny

      @@Contessa998 thanks too bad I’ve never noticed anything re how I feel with or without hormones or given in any way. I’ve got chronic fatigue so wish they’d perk me up but no. Glad the cream is available for you.

  • @lisaharmon5527
    @lisaharmon5527 Před 29 dny +16

    Most researched supplement but affects everyone differently. I took 3-5g per day for 2.5 months and gained 12 lbs. I recognize it was mostly water, but did not like the 12 additional pounds.

    • @maylepujol4889
      @maylepujol4889 Před 12 dny

      I haven not started taking... this was my concern. Thanks for sharing!!

    • @lisaharmon5527
      @lisaharmon5527 Před 12 dny

      YW! You could react very differently as that was just my experience.

    • @Lidia.Bella.Italiana
      @Lidia.Bella.Italiana Před 9 dny +1

      It's water retention that solely goes into the muscles. It's not fat... It's how the muscles stay hydrated enough to grow. You need to drink a lot of water while taking it to prevent dehydration.
      The water retention goes away once the muscles have absorbed all the creatine.
      By then, the weight gain is muscle gain... so train.... not complain.

    • @lisaharmon5527
      @lisaharmon5527 Před 9 dny +1

      @@Lidia.Bella.Italiana no one is complaining. It’s just a statement of observation that was experienced by me! Women need to understand what can happen and why so not to be shocked, Each can choose to continue use or not.

    • @undefined7222
      @undefined7222 Před 2 dny

      I did not perceive the author as complaining, instead it sounded like reporting their experience to inform others. I am curious as to the why therefore the added comment that the water gain may be temporary as body acclimates added another dimension to the water weight gain.

  • @luciannedemarco6296
    @luciannedemarco6296 Před 3 dny

    Thank you for being so very generous with your information and so very thorough! Much appreciated!

  • @GwenMotoGirl
    @GwenMotoGirl Před měsícem +7

    I had the stomach upset when I started it a year ago but not really a surprise as so many things do. I cut back and ramped up to 5g over time, and now it doesn’t bother me. I think it’s an important part of my training and good health goals. Thanks for talking about this. You cleared up some things for me.

    • @cookiebuzz
      @cookiebuzz Před měsícem +5

      Hmmm. I read so many reviews that said they had nausea and/or vomiting so that scared me off. Maybe a build up would work. (I have a death fear of vomiting)!! 😂🤪🤪

    • @GwenMotoGirl
      @GwenMotoGirl Před měsícem +4

      @@cookiebuzz I feel that! I’ll take 2 weeks of strep over 1 night of vomiting. Maybe you can try again.

    • @cookiebuzz
      @cookiebuzz Před měsícem +4

      @@GwenMotoGirl The few times in my life I was nauseated to the point of vomiting I prayed for death, (& meant it), and held it back. Stupid, I know, but it’s always been my boogeyman!

    • @GwenMotoGirl
      @GwenMotoGirl Před měsícem +1

      @@cookiebuzz it’s awful! I just got over a bug a few days ago. 🤢

    • @cookiebuzz
      @cookiebuzz Před měsícem +2

      @@GwenMotoGirl UGH. Sorry for you!

  • @maaikeswellness1225
    @maaikeswellness1225 Před 28 dny +2

    DR Susan, I ran into this very interesting video today. So many light bulbs and it fascinates me as I love doing things naturally for health and mental health decline. And I teach as a coach to my clients. I am also in Houston and would love the opportunity of chatting with you and doing a podcast.

  • @Paralegal1
    @Paralegal1 Před 4 dny

    GREAT segment, thank you soooo much! I ❤ you, Dr. Susan!

  • @Healthandbeautyatallages

    Wonderful information! I’ve been taking Créatine for over a year and really find it helpful for muscle retention.

  • @ednamariacroxton8859
    @ednamariacroxton8859 Před 4 dny

    I use Thorne as well. I just put one scoop directly in my mouth and drink one or two sips of water. 30 mins before workouts.

  • @margotdenger1485
    @margotdenger1485 Před měsícem +3

    Excellent video, as always! Thank you!

  • @conniemartin9468
    @conniemartin9468 Před měsícem +3

    THANK YOU FOR THIS INFORMATION

  • @flower7022
    @flower7022 Před měsícem +1

    Your videos are right on target . Thank you

  • @carolmaplesden916
    @carolmaplesden916 Před 10 dny

    Thank you
    This is great information

  • @cynthiaporcaro9937
    @cynthiaporcaro9937 Před měsícem +2

    Just started last week and bought your Thorne, can't wait to see some results

  • @debbiemartell8100
    @debbiemartell8100 Před měsícem +1

    Excellent video Dr 😊

  • @Jo-wt6qr
    @Jo-wt6qr Před 19 dny

    Thanks for such an interesting video- brilliant

  • @glorialazcano5862
    @glorialazcano5862 Před měsícem

    Amazing video thank you 🙏🏼

  • @teenarecine3857
    @teenarecine3857 Před měsícem +1

    Thanks so much

  • @paintkit
    @paintkit Před 14 dny +1

    Hello, I did learn a lot and have been considering taking Creatin. In fact, I bought it before your video ended. I do wonder about Collagen mixing with Creatin in coffee or taken at the same time in water?

    • @drsusan
      @drsusan  Před 10 dny

      Go for it!

    • @paintkit
      @paintkit Před 9 dny

      @@drsusan Is it common to have allergic reactions to Creatin? Such as congestion in my sinuses and fogginess in the morning? I've been using Thorne Creatin for 3 days. I'm 76 years young and have done HRT for years.

  • @craigerwin4007
    @craigerwin4007 Před 6 dny

    Thanks for this video! Do you take it ongoing forever or do you cycle it? Also many years ago I had a friend who experienced irregular heartbeat after taking this and after a quick study at the time I found other cases of this... any thoughts on this? Thanks so much!

  • @Starts_like_this
    @Starts_like_this Před 14 dny

    Wow ❤ you are in Houston that is awesome!

  • @flomystictarot
    @flomystictarot Před měsícem

    Insightful. love this.

  • @elainelerma9356
    @elainelerma9356 Před měsícem +2

    I have been taking it for a month mine is salty but I’m used to it now. I need to change mine it’s been expensive I take CG5 creative and Glutamine

  • @Leah-fn4wl
    @Leah-fn4wl Před 20 dny +1

    I was told that if you take creatine, you must drink a gallon of water. What is the recommended amount of water and why?

    • @drsusan
      @drsusan  Před 18 dny +1

      I dissolved my creatine in about 4 ounces of water and chug it down in a shot and that has been shown to be perfectly fine

  • @chrisb9724
    @chrisb9724 Před 7 dny

    Could the Creatine supplement affect blood work and when should I stop taking prior to blood work?

  • @shannonpuckett6604
    @shannonpuckett6604 Před 22 dny +3

    I’ve been taking creatine since April or may 2024 and I am a cancer patient I remission. I have been weight lifting and strength training and eating a high protein diet trying to work on rebuilding my muscles because IV chemo and the chemo pills I’ve been on for the past 5 years have destroyed any muscle tissue I may have had! I went in for my 2 month screening at the oncologist and my creatin was 2.0! I read up on it and it pointed to creatine so I dropped it from my diet and went back in after a week and rechecked and I was at 1.2 creatin. I’ve always drank a gallon of water daily. What’s going on? I was only taking 5gr a day. I’m so upset that I’m currently off creatine

    • @drsusan
      @drsusan  Před 18 dny +4

      Creatine is passed through your kidneys as creatinine (different ) . The doctor may not understand that you are taking the supplements and so they are reading the creatinine suggesting that there's something wrong with your kidneys with that is not incorrect because it's simply reflecting how much creatine you are passing in your system.
      Creatinine will always be higher in patients who are taking creatine. It doesn't mean their kidney function is failing. It just means they're passing it through their kidneys.
      Many doctors don't understand this so you may need to explain it to them at least tell them that you're taking creatine and that is naturally going to elevate your creatinine. There's a lot of misunderstanding and like a education amongst physicians on this issue and it is absolutely not linked to kidney or liver failure that has been shown in countless studies.

    • @toriwolf5978
      @toriwolf5978 Před 11 dny

      I read you should stop taking creatine supplement 3 weeks before any blood work and it it’s fine then …then go back on it wither checking out ! I love taking my creatine ….

    • @LowCarbLeonie
      @LowCarbLeonie Před 10 dny

      Same thing with high protein diet.

  • @memoirsofmyboyz
    @memoirsofmyboyz Před 28 dny +3

    Thanks for this video Dr Susan! I started with 5gm just two doses and it triggered my vertigo pretty badly, and i felt dizzy. I cut back to 1.5 gm just to see if it made a difference and the vertigo has reduced but i am concerned about a prolonged bout. I have had vertigo for more than 10 years but it comes and goes every few months. What approach would you suggest i take?

    • @drsusan
      @drsusan  Před 26 dny

      I have not had experience with that particular symptom, but would certainly try continuing at a lower dose and then if you can't tolerate it, it's something you can live without!

    • @zolozek3327
      @zolozek3327 Před 20 hodinami

      Hydrate. With aminos s and electrolytes

  • @paintkit
    @paintkit Před 7 dny

    I have another question about the difference between isolate vs monohydrate Creatine?

  • @shearwatereco4722
    @shearwatereco4722 Před měsícem +4

    Can you make a video about the side effects and issues with creatine please. Ive had lots of issues from poor sleep, pain in my kidneys, lower back pain, lots of muscle pain and bloating...i feel better off it....why? 45, perimenopause, on hrt, fairly active, healthy eating however ive really started craving carbs and sugars since starting creatine....absolutely starving all the time. I really believe the creatine is not good for everyone and from my experiences i disagree with the supposed research

    • @drsusan
      @drsusan  Před 26 dny +2

      Everybody is different and that is not a common set of symptoms, but certainly it's not for everybody so the research supports that for the average person it's very beneficial and most people would not have any of those side effects. Can't argue with your own experience so it certainly is different for every person -and you may be one of those who just can't take it.

    • @Farahfoodie
      @Farahfoodie Před 11 dny

      I started using it and after some days I got such a bad pain in my lower back, then I reduced and it was getting better. Today I increased it and I have again such bad back pain( actually never had this in my life before ), also I can’t sleep at night and my belly is bloated. I guess I’ll stop it.

  • @pennyrapp7372
    @pennyrapp7372 Před 3 dny

    I took creatine for three months and I weight train and I didn’t like the way my arms got puffy. I took 5 g a day. Do you think I should take three or 2 1/2? 05 foot seven and I weigh 160 pounds so I have a medium frame.

  • @johnstewartvet
    @johnstewartvet Před 18 dny

    Seems there is universal agreement that Creatine is of benefit as supplement

  • @deborahgardner9489
    @deborahgardner9489 Před 27 dny

    Dr. Susan, I’ve been taking it for a few weeks and feel good so far. I bought capsules and take two (5 grams), but wonder if my next purchase should be the powder? Is there a difference?

    • @drsusan
      @drsusan  Před 26 dny +1

      Probably not any difference if it's creatine monohydrate

    • @deborahgardner9489
      @deborahgardner9489 Před 26 dny

      @@drsusan Great, thanks!

    • @jillking4751
      @jillking4751 Před 26 dny

      @@deborahgardner9489powder can be cheaper than capsules. It’s flavourless so I just mix the powder in a glass of water; or in my morning coffee. I live in Australia and purchase this and other sups at Bulk Nutrients (based in Tasmania).

  • @reesepup4624
    @reesepup4624 Před 6 dny

    What about taking testosterone in my bio identical hrt? Doesn’t that help with muscle?

  • @apacur
    @apacur Před 17 dny

    What type of Creatine?

  • @annenyman1307
    @annenyman1307 Před 13 dny

    I am always interested of possible side-effects and for those of you, who suffer male type hair loss due to high DHT, creatine can boos hair loss, because it can increase DHT.
    I have pcos, which cause me male type hairloss and even though creatine sounds very good, I don’t dare to even try it. 😢

    • @drsusan
      @drsusan  Před 10 dny

      It does not increase DHT in humans. No science supporting that claim

  • @Shelley6821
    @Shelley6821 Před měsícem +1

    what about taking collagen peptides? would it have the same effect?

    • @drsusan
      @drsusan  Před měsícem +1

      No - totally different, also useful , but nothing to do with the ATP pathway

    • @sunbeam9222
      @sunbeam9222 Před 29 dny +1

      I take both, need all the help one can get 😅

  • @krickenthekraken8844
    @krickenthekraken8844 Před 28 dny +2

    I bought the same thorn product and started taking it a few weeks ago, and noticed that my body had a significant change in body odor in a bad way. I stopped taking it, and the odor went away. It was a very sour smell and because a couple months ago, I really started lifting heavier weights. I was really, excited about trying creatine, but this odor is not something I can tolerate and I’m sure the people that are working around me can’t either. Have you heard of this? Is there anything you think I might be able to do to off set it?

    • @drsusan
      @drsusan  Před 26 dny +2

      That's hard to explain, but everybody is different. We can also develop a body odor when we start working out more because it elevates our testosterone so they might be a number of different factors that play, but cannot deny your own experience.!

  • @rhondacoburn7888
    @rhondacoburn7888 Před 22 dny +3

    hypothyroidism can I take creatine.

  • @jbmg28
    @jbmg28 Před měsícem

    Dr. Stacy Sims recommended 3 gm for women who weigh less than 120 lbs. Your opinion?

    • @drsusan
      @drsusan  Před měsícem +5

      Yes I said about the same. About half the dose. There's a huge range of what's safe as you know

  • @simonesauerland5513
    @simonesauerland5513 Před 19 dny

    But how long do I have to take it??? before I see a result as I am 70 years I didn’t have muscle 💪🏼 loss with 69 years very very little I eat salmon 🍣 and chicken 🍗 as you recommended cartilage I eat but I shocked how fast I have lost muscle ???? 😢😢😢

  • @lucierancourt2079
    @lucierancourt2079 Před 25 dny

    Is there a counter indication for heart patients? Even for someone who had a mitral valve replacement? Thank you!

    • @seaslife60
      @seaslife60 Před 25 dny

      Talk to your doctor.

    • @drsusan
      @drsusan  Před 18 dny

      In general, absolutely not it has nothing to do with heart Hall other than benefiting your heart through having healthier or muscle but obviously talk to someone who is your provider who knows what they are talking about

  • @eunicehehir6374
    @eunicehehir6374 Před 24 dny

    I'm 65yrs and will start taking this building up to 5g gently and with a meal ... maybe breakfast with a cuppa. Thanks again Dr Susan😊

  • @Isabell520
    @Isabell520 Před měsícem +4

    What. Kind of creative ? Mono hydrate?

    • @anne-louisegoldie
      @anne-louisegoldie Před měsícem

      Yes, monohydrate.

    • @jillmartin5734
      @jillmartin5734 Před měsícem

      @@anne-louisegoldiecheck where the creatine is made , make sure not in china, as their is usually lead in creatine from china, you never know what they put in it…

    • @jillmartin5734
      @jillmartin5734 Před měsícem +1

      Not safe …

    • @Zumbunnies
      @Zumbunnies Před měsícem

      @@jillmartin5734roughly 500 studies would prove otherwise, but you know best.

    • @cornflowertoile3026
      @cornflowertoile3026 Před 24 dny

      @@anne-louisegoldieyes that is the one she recommended.

  • @olgaromo5919
    @olgaromo5919 Před 12 dny

    Does it break a fast?

    • @drsusan
      @drsusan  Před 10 dny +1

      That's really splitting hairs! Makes no difference when you take it. It has a few calories. But not of any significance:). If you are determined to be truly fasting take it during your eating window

  • @terrytorvund7222
    @terrytorvund7222 Před měsícem

    I take creatine gummies. They ok?

    • @drsusan
      @drsusan  Před 26 dny

      Some research suggests that they don't have much if any active creatine so I would stick with the powder personally

  • @Melodie007
    @Melodie007 Před 21 dnem

  • @Godskingdomcouncelorcrystal

    I have osteoarthritis and take Diclofenac 75mg 2 times a day. I do lift weights to strengthen my bones but read online to not take it while taking Diclofenac. Is this true? Am I able to take it ? Says not to take together but if I take it separate is it still possible? Would love to take it.

    • @drsusan
      @drsusan  Před 10 dny +1

      I'm general fine to take both - can't comment on your specific situation but no reason why it would cause a problem

  • @kathynewkirk683
    @kathynewkirk683 Před měsícem +2

    I’ve heard from other doctors channel that for brain effects, you need to take larger doses…

    • @drsusan
      @drsusan  Před měsícem +1

      Some studies looked at 12 grams for women and brain health - there's a big range of what's been studied .

    • @sunbeam9222
      @sunbeam9222 Před 29 dny

      Interesting

  • @sterlgirlceline
    @sterlgirlceline Před 22 dny

    🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌼💛

  • @doloresmendoza506
    @doloresmendoza506 Před měsícem +7

    You don't need a supplement to build muscle. Just eat a very low carb and high animal protein and fat. You will increase your muscle mass and tone.❤

    • @drsusan
      @drsusan  Před měsícem +14

      Of course you don't need it to build muscle, but multiple studies have shown that it enhances building muscle over diet and exercise alone so definitely something to consider but personal choice!

    • @celeste-236
      @celeste-236 Před 29 dny +14

      Sorry Dolores but I eat beef DAILY, I’m animal based and low carb and without HRT, which I’m on now, animal based did nothing for my muscles. In fact, until I started HRT, I was losing muscle. And as my doctor told me, my testosterone is still too low,& he just increased it, because diet will NOT fix your hormones, contrary to what the carnivore community says. The truth is that if you’re post menopausal and over 60 you need HRT, and yes you do need creatinine, and to lift weights as well.

    • @lisabass5188
      @lisabass5188 Před 20 dny +2

      Correct, nothing takes the place of estrogen!​@@celeste-236

  • @Contessa998
    @Contessa998 Před 20 dny

    Creating made my butt big and ugly. Lots of water retention 😮😅😂

    • @drsusan
      @drsusan  Před 18 dny

      Try a standard dose, the water is only inside your muscle. It's not gonna make you get fat so just hang in there and maybe try half the standard dose.

  • @ct5274
    @ct5274 Před 10 dny

    BS. How about sharing the side affects and there are plenty.

  • @valeriyadountcheva5255

    Sorry, but you cannot build muscle seating on the couch 😂

  • @natgarrison2300
    @natgarrison2300 Před 7 dny

    She is selling the stuff, so don't trust her!

  • @gijoyjoy
    @gijoyjoy Před 24 dny +1

    I think I need Creatine for many reasons. But right now my brain needs it to stop my face from cringing every time you mispronounce the word Creatine! 🥴 It’s not Creatun.

    • @drsusan
      @drsusan  Před 18 dny +6

      Apologies for born being born in New Zealand, and not having their traditional American accent!

    • @diyancing
      @diyancing Před 17 dny +6

      Your voice and accent are lovely!

    • @marywesthues30
      @marywesthues30 Před 14 dny

      Thank you Dr. Susan!

    • @annyoung1092
      @annyoung1092 Před 13 dny

      Geez