Can you give me some insight into what he achieved and what he was planning to do? I dont know much about early russian history, or russian history in general so I'd love to learn. If you do not personally have time to tell me, can you link me some good sources that may provide good Information? Thanks in advance.
@@ryangoslingIRL I think he amancepated (I forgot how to spell) the people living in peasantry got released but still had to pay their lord debts, industrial stuff, many other things
@@ryangoslingIRLhe was planning to enact constitutional reform just days before assassination. His reforms were towards liberalisation and democratic.
Honestly from my viewpoint what could have made this better is Russia losing the Russo Turkish war in 1878, this although ousting russian power in the Balkans means that in the Russo Japanese war Russia achieves victory, I think this would have been a better trade off and allowing the Tzars to stay in full power until the death of Nicholas II
@@flaviusbelisarius7517 **looks at 105** certified Super Idol de xiàoróng dōu méi nǐ de tián bā yuè zhèngwǔ de yángguāng dōu méi nǐ yàoyǎn rè'ài 105 °C de nǐ dī dī qīngchún de zhēngliúshuǐ moment
I feel like this is a questionable scenario, every single time a major event like ww1 or ww2 breaks out russia is basically reset again to be just like it was so russia isn't too powerful at the start of every conflict. it just seems kind of weird how they had multiple puppets and power and then basically lose it for no reason
@@vincentbj84 I see. Now we are talking about this alternate scenario, but do you think that the same applies for the real Constantinople in our time? Do you think that it is Turkish territory for example?
Как житель России скажу точно, что ключевым событием после 1815 года должна была стать скорейшая отмена Александром I крепостного права. Именно после победы над Наполеоном ВСЕ общество было готово к переменам "сверху", тем более, что они были необходимы. Из-за того, что этот проктятый аграрный вопрос не будет решен, отмена феодальных пережитков и переход к более прогрессивному капиталистическому хозяйству затормозится. В России не сложится самого важного: многочисленной прослойки населения с высокой покупательной способностью. Вместо этого принятая в 1861 году Крестьянская реформа землю крестьянам в собственность не даст, а выкупные платежи высосут из большей части населения деньги до нитки, и лишь революция 1905-1907 гг силой заставит отменить выкупные платежи. Из-за того, что развитие внутреннего рынка и промышленного переворота застопорится, хронической проблемой станет также тотальная безграмотность. К 1913 году грамотными у нас будут считаться около 25-27% населения в среднем по стране (в Средней Азии, к слову, этот показатель будет 3-5%). При этом человек считался грамотным, если мог поставить свою подпись и прочесть свои имя и фамилию, а не осмыслить сложный текст. Как итог, проблема беграмотности будет полностью решена только большевиками.
I think the only problem with this particular Alt-history scenario is the population at the end of this timeline, this is due to the fact that because the Communist USSR never came to be, and Vladimir Lenin and Joseph Stalin never came to power and destroyed the Kulaks, caused the Ukrainian famine, created the Gulag Archipelago, and did not cause the deaths of nearly 60+ million people. The population rate of the Russian Empire at the current rise, most women gave birth to 4.5 to 7 children each before World War 1, Russia would have had a population between 450 to 500 million people, which is absolutely massive compared to its current population. Due to this population size, the colonial territories and protectorates that the Russia contained within itself would be completely Russified in the Baltics, Caucuses, and Central Asia, as well as in the temperate and bearable regions of Southern Siberia would be littered with cities, as big or bigger than Novosibirsk, which could probably contend with the European portions of Russia in terms of development. But other than that this was a great video and I hope you make more like it.
Yes you may be right, but 500 million seems to me a bit excessive, for the Baltic countries, a small part is Russian but the regions have kept an autonomy and have not been assimilated, on the other hand Belarusians, Ukrainians or others are considered like Russian or just Russian dialects in this reality, and some regions have been partially "Russified", such as Moldova.
@@vincentbj84 The reason I say 450 to 500 million is because, when the communists came into to power they not only killed millions of their people by forcedly making Russia industrialize, instead of letting it naturally occur, as it was before World War 1, and creating man-made famines. They also created a system that was most times harmful and terrible to raise a family, there is quite a lot of accounts from women in Soviet Russia who stated that hospitals, when one could receive attention, were so uncomfortable and terrible, most women would rather not get pregnant or not have children at all. You can actually see the birthrate of Russia drop tremendously after the Soviets took over, I believe some statistics show Russia having a birthrate 7.18 per woman before WW1 and after WW2, where most victorious nations had significant baby booms such as the USA, where the birth rate dropped to 2.58 per woman after WW2 had ended, which is quite significant. When a pre-industrialized nation usually develops the birth rates drop naturally as women are emancipated, gain their franchise, and join the work force, but in the case of Russia, when the communists took over they destroyed everything about both their culture and what they considered unneeded industries in order to develop its military. That is why Russia's population growth is so stagnant and one of the lowest in the world, along with every other post-communist state. There's a great video by one Whatifalthist where he talks about how Russia would have likely developed, if the Soviet Union never existed, I highly recommend it. czcams.com/video/aq3WtOuRCMw/video.html
Merci. Les Musiques: - Imperial anthem of Russia - Preobrajensky march - Russian Empire (1721-1918) Military March "Герой/Hero - Varshavyanka - Farewell of Slavianka - Юбилейный Встречный Марш 25 лет РККА (9:27) - hymne de Russie/URSS Voilà
Oui je voulais moins affaiblir la Russie avec une révolution d'octobre, je voulais faire tenir les russes tout du long de la 1er GM et empêcher les bolcheviks de passer au pouvoir, en 1905, je pense qu'il aurait pu avoir plus de chance que les mencheviks ou autres socialistes prennent le pouvoir, la Russie aurait pu se développer plus rapidement je pense. Et la guerre contre les Japonais était déjà mal reçu dans la réalité, le tsar a voulu mettre vite fin à cette guerre vue les troubles du pays, dans cette histoire alternative la guerre dure un ans de plus, donc ça a amplifié la rev.
Merci. Les Musiques: - Imperial anthem of Russia - Preobrajensky march - Russian Empire (1721-1918) Military March "Герой/Hero - Varshavyanka - Farewell of Slavianka - Юбилейный Встречный Марш 25 лет РККА (8:53) - hymne de Russie/URSS Voilà
My Analysis 1. China is Democratic 2. Königsberg is Independent 3. Korea Is United (Love that Flag) 4. There is a Possibility that Tsar Returns to Russia as they Was Exiled 5. No Martial Law in the Philippines since There is No Communist in this World 6. Benigno “Ninoy” Aquino never Assassinated so he was the Successor of Marcos 7. No Cold War Since Russia and US has the Same Government 8. Baltic Independence will be Peaceful
Yes, probably, except for the Tsar, this Republic has kept Socialist roots (more moderate) since the Revolution. Yes no cold war either, a stronger and closer Russia makes Europe stronger and pushes aside the United States, the United States keeping a more isiolationist policy, a unified Europe and the US out, a better scenario lol
Ah, would have been too busy, I already translate in English in addition to my mother tongue, some complained that the text was too small I only translated the country, head of state and cities, more for the sake of visibility, then translated from Russian by Google translate, I don't know if that would have been exceptional ...
That’s wrong history and Russia surrender in 1922 and Soviet Union win war and Vladimir Putin also was Soviet Union army next he become leader in Russia
I'd love to see a Russian alt-history where Alexander II isn't assassinated and can continue his reforms.
Can you give me some insight into what he achieved and what he was planning to do? I dont know much about early russian history, or russian history in general so I'd love to learn. If you do not personally have time to tell me, can you link me some good sources that may provide good Information? Thanks in advance.
@@ryangoslingIRL I think he amancepated (I forgot how to spell) the people living in peasantry got released but still had to pay their lord debts, industrial stuff, many other things
@@thepeanut2681 Yeah i know that part but like, future reforms and stuff
@@ryangoslingIRLhe was planning to enact constitutional reform just days before assassination. His reforms were towards liberalisation and democratic.
Vidéo de très grande qualité! Pour la mère Russie! За мать России!
D'habitude les russes ne disent pas la mère Russie mais la mère patrie
Arriba España
@@vioretto_нет это не так
I'm really loving the hell out of these alternate videos ❗ Great job‼️ 👍👍
This so deserves more views keep up the good work!
I wish this alternative was true... Great job!
This is so artistic :D
Merci! Je sais bien ce sera une vidéo intéressante!
yes Greece borders looks nice in this alternative timeline. These are the borders Greece should have in the real timeline too
mdrr ta photo elle est magique
merveilleuse vidéo
Good video
Tu as été élu deux fois, et bein bravo. Elle est très bien faite ta vidéo et je vois que tu n'as pas oublié les Gagaouzes, continue comme ça.
Oui, bien vu, cette fois j'ai pas oublié, j'ai passé pas mal de temps sur la carte "ethnolinguistique"
Honestly from my viewpoint what could have made this better is Russia losing the Russo Turkish war in 1878, this although ousting russian power in the Balkans means that in the Russo Japanese war Russia achieves victory, I think this would have been a better trade off and allowing the Tzars to stay in full power until the death of Nicholas II
Imagine a king serving for 100 years
Gigachad king
That's possibly going to happen but with a queen. You know which british monarch i'm talking about
@@mariasirona1622 not really, memes apart i doubt she'd get to her 120s
@@hellowelcometochillis2781 maybe to 105 or so. Her mother died at 101
@@flaviusbelisarius7517 **looks at 105** certified Super Idol de xiàoróng dōu méi nǐ de tián bā yuè zhèngwǔ de yángguāng dōu méi nǐ yàoyǎn rè'ài 105 °C de nǐ dī dī qīngchún de zhēngliúshuǐ moment
Beautyful alt. history!!!
This should be great!
Прикольно.
Beutiful alternate history, also who was that Vincent guy? I saw him on a few Russian memes.
ah good, you saw me In other Russian videos? lol
@@vincentbj84 yeah, that face I saw somewhere but I forgot where lol.
@@bulletghost3452 maybe in my Channel, it's me lol, thé last président
I really like it!
I feel like this is a questionable scenario, every single time a major event like ww1 or ww2 breaks out russia is basically reset again to be just like it was so russia isn't too powerful at the start of every conflict. it just seems kind of weird how they had multiple puppets and power and then basically lose it for no reason
in that finland part you made russia push too deep in south because push to helsinki would be hell to russia
Could u make the text bigger? I couldnt see the texts
Edit:the text talking about the event
Yes I try to do that on the other videos
Oh mon dieu l'avant première a 17h30
nice job 🇹🇷
Nice!
Gg t'as dû mettre un temps fou
Oui, qq jours, hier la journée entière pour faire les dernières images, d'ailleurs je me suis tapé une migraine à la fin, mdr.
@@vincentbj84 ouais c'est satisfaisant d'aller faire des recherches sur internet pour trouver quel drapeau passe
@@vincentbj84 8:26 what's the name of the song
I'm curious. Is Constantinople Russian or Greek territory by the end of this alternate scenario?
Constantinople is Greek, it was occupied by the Russians only after ww1
@@vincentbj84 I see. Now we are talking about this alternate scenario, but do you think that the same applies for the real Constantinople in our time? Do you think that it is Turkish territory for example?
Very Nice Video! From INDIA 🇮🇳
thanks, my future video will be about india (from my PAX EUROPAEA lore)
4:33 What's the song?
Du grand sale, vraiment le seul problème c'est les évènement écrit trop petit, sinon excellent 👌👌👌
Ok, je ferrai plus gaffe la prochaine fois.
Intresting
Listen bro, can you tell me how to make such a map?
With paint.net and movie maker, or photo of Windows.
I do a tuto on my channel, search
@@vincentbj84 Thank you bro)! I subscribed to you, good luck in your work
8:26 what is the name of the song?
Farewell of slavienka
Pozdro z Polski 🇵🇱
Как житель России скажу точно, что ключевым событием после 1815 года должна была стать скорейшая отмена Александром I крепостного права. Именно после победы над Наполеоном ВСЕ общество было готово к переменам "сверху", тем более, что они были необходимы. Из-за того, что этот проктятый аграрный вопрос не будет решен, отмена феодальных пережитков и переход к более прогрессивному капиталистическому хозяйству затормозится. В России не сложится самого важного: многочисленной прослойки населения с высокой покупательной способностью. Вместо этого принятая в 1861 году Крестьянская реформа землю крестьянам в собственность не даст, а выкупные платежи высосут из большей части населения деньги до нитки, и лишь революция 1905-1907 гг силой заставит отменить выкупные платежи.
Из-за того, что развитие внутреннего рынка и промышленного переворота застопорится, хронической проблемой станет также тотальная безграмотность. К 1913 году грамотными у нас будут считаться около 25-27% населения в среднем по стране (в Средней Азии, к слову, этот показатель будет 3-5%). При этом человек считался грамотным, если мог поставить свою подпись и прочесть свои имя и фамилию, а не осмыслить сложный текст. Как итог, проблема беграмотности будет полностью решена только большевиками.
I think the only problem with this particular Alt-history scenario is the population at the end of this timeline, this is due to the fact that because the Communist USSR never came to be, and Vladimir Lenin and Joseph Stalin never came to power and destroyed the Kulaks, caused the Ukrainian famine, created the Gulag Archipelago, and did not cause the deaths of nearly 60+ million people. The population rate of the Russian Empire at the current rise, most women gave birth to 4.5 to 7 children each before World War 1, Russia would have had a population between 450 to 500 million people, which is absolutely massive compared to its current population. Due to this population size, the colonial territories and protectorates that the Russia contained within itself would be completely Russified in the Baltics, Caucuses, and Central Asia, as well as in the temperate and bearable regions of Southern Siberia would be littered with cities, as big or bigger than Novosibirsk, which could probably contend with the European portions of Russia in terms of development. But other than that this was a great video and I hope you make more like it.
Yes you may be right, but 500 million seems to me a bit excessive, for the Baltic countries, a small part is Russian but the regions have kept an autonomy and have not been assimilated, on the other hand Belarusians, Ukrainians or others are considered like Russian or just Russian dialects in this reality, and some regions have been partially "Russified", such as Moldova.
@@vincentbj84 The reason I say 450 to 500 million is because, when the communists came into to power they not only killed millions of their people by forcedly making Russia industrialize, instead of letting it naturally occur, as it was before World War 1, and creating man-made famines. They also created a system that was most times harmful and terrible to raise a family, there is quite a lot of accounts from women in Soviet Russia who stated that hospitals, when one could receive attention, were so uncomfortable and terrible, most women would rather not get pregnant or not have children at all. You can actually see the birthrate of Russia drop tremendously after the Soviets took over, I believe some statistics show Russia having a birthrate 7.18 per woman before WW1 and after WW2, where most victorious nations had significant baby booms such as the USA, where the birth rate dropped to 2.58 per woman after WW2 had ended, which is quite significant. When a pre-industrialized nation usually develops the birth rates drop naturally as women are emancipated, gain their franchise, and join the work force, but in the case of Russia, when the communists took over they destroyed everything about both their culture and what they considered unneeded industries in order to develop its military. That is why Russia's population growth is so stagnant and one of the lowest in the world, along with every other post-communist state. There's a great video by one Whatifalthist where he talks about how Russia would have likely developed, if the Soviet Union never existed, I highly recommend it. czcams.com/video/aq3WtOuRCMw/video.html
What is the march at 9:27?
Merci.
Les Musiques:
- Imperial anthem of Russia
- Preobrajensky march
- Russian Empire (1721-1918) Military March "Герой/Hero
- Varshavyanka
- Farewell of Slavianka
- Юбилейный Встречный Марш 25 лет РККА (9:27)
- hymne de Russie/URSS
Voilà
in 2009 it is fitting that the Russian president is Dmitry Medvedev
Dunno I feel like they wouldnt let the Baltics independent but cool senario either wag
Could anyone tell me what is the song in 7:45?
Farewell Slaviankia
@@vincentbj84 thank you
Эх, а бречковская ведь бабушка русской революции 4:47 победила в первой мировой
Not Bad :)
Je trouve juste que le changement des romanov à la république socialiste est un peu "rush" mais le scénario est vraiment génial.
Oui je voulais moins affaiblir la Russie avec une révolution d'octobre, je voulais faire tenir les russes tout du long de la 1er GM et empêcher les bolcheviks de passer au pouvoir, en 1905, je pense qu'il aurait pu avoir plus de chance que les mencheviks ou autres socialistes prennent le pouvoir, la Russie aurait pu se développer plus rapidement je pense. Et la guerre contre les Japonais était déjà mal reçu dans la réalité, le tsar a voulu mettre vite fin à cette guerre vue les troubles du pays, dans cette histoire alternative la guerre dure un ans de plus, donc ça a amplifié la rev.
@@vincentbj84 OK, je vois, c'est bien.
Toton Muno et Vincent BJ pour le président!
👍👍👍
@Kanał Michała mystère... My secret meme...
It's a good Guy
@Kanał Michała No, he's a recurring character in my videos.
What's the name of music on 8:53 ?
Merci.
Les Musiques:
- Imperial anthem of Russia
- Preobrajensky march
- Russian Empire (1721-1918) Military March "Герой/Hero
- Varshavyanka
- Farewell of Slavianka
- Юбилейный Встречный Марш 25 лет РККА (8:53)
- hymne de Russie/URSS
Voilà
@@vincentbj84 thank you
Откуда взялись большевики после победы?
My Analysis
1. China is Democratic
2. Königsberg is Independent
3. Korea Is United (Love that Flag)
4. There is a Possibility that Tsar Returns to Russia as they Was Exiled
5. No Martial Law in the Philippines since There is No Communist in this World
6. Benigno “Ninoy” Aquino never Assassinated so he was the Successor of Marcos
7. No Cold War Since Russia and US has the Same Government
8. Baltic Independence will be Peaceful
Yes, probably, except for the Tsar, this Republic has kept Socialist roots (more moderate) since the Revolution.
Yes no cold war either, a stronger and closer Russia makes Europe stronger and pushes aside the United States, the United States keeping a more isiolationist policy, a unified Europe and the US out, a better scenario lol
@@vincentbj84 i better live to this world than today (sorry for bad english)
8:50 Андропов :)
4:55 this Golda Mayer ?
Who is Goda Mayer, I don't think it's her
@@vincentbj84 face
Ляпы в переводе они и в Африке ляпы перевода, но ничего страшного
Очень жаль, что ты не дублировал описание в видео на русском.
Ah, would have been too busy, I already translate in English in addition to my mother tongue, some complained that the text was too small I only translated the country, head of state and cities, more for the sake of visibility, then translated from Russian by Google translate, I don't know if that would have been exceptional ...
@@vincentbj84 may I know the march at 9:30?
I am Russian
I really wish the Decembrists won :(
I hope someday Russia will become a Western and Democratic State
I think we all do, I love Russia but I absolutely DESPISE Putin and his autocracy. Let us hope Russia wakes up and removes him.
Не Бречковская, а Брешко-Брешковская.
ok, thx
Quelques erreurs d'orthographe MAIS vidéo très cool
Ah oui PT,j'en fais moins, mais j'en fais toujours quelques unes
Surtout en anglais, j'utilise un traducteur
Japan has had a emperor who served for about 115 years
Search it up
Which is interd5ing
Lenin never took the power, is a nobody in this scenario, but still has the city of Ulyanovsk named after him 😂
И не впадлу тебе было делать полуразвал России под ее гимн!?
Not a perfect world, but it is a decent world. Better than ours.
this is literally the russian history but the bolsheviks are democratic
9:45
2022 Russian Revolution 1917-2022
Europe and some parts of the world is with an alliance with Russia is a good thing
communists dislike this
Yes probably
That’s wrong history and Russia surrender in 1922 and Soviet Union win war and Vladimir Putin also was Soviet Union army next he become leader in Russia
"Alternate" history...
Винсент большой джов?😂 Серьезно? Что за глупое имя?