Horizon Forbidden West | Launch Version vs Patch 1.3.55 | XeSS 1.3, Nvidia Reflex and more.

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 22. 05. 2024
  • ⏰Timestamps :
    0:00 Intro
    0:50 Nvidia Reflex
    1:57 XeSS 1.3
    3:20 XeSS 1.3 vs XeSS 1.2 vs DLSS vs FSR2
    4:36 Texture Streaming and Memory Management improvements
    5:23 Launch Version vs Patch 1.3.55
    5:55 Outro
    ✨Support the channel by :
    🔴 Subscribing and watching my videos
    🔴 Using the Super Thanks Button under the video
    🔴 Buying me a coffee from here : www.buymeacoffee.com/Benchmar...
    🔴 Or from here : www.paypal.com/paypalme/bench...
    ►Check out more optimization guides :
    • Optimization guides
    ►Join the channel :
    / @benchmarking4386
    ►Full Specs :
    ●CPU : AMD RYZEN 5 5600X 6-Core 3.7 GHz (Up to 4.6GHz).
    ●Cooler : Enermax LIQFUSION 240mm Liquid Cooler.
    ●Motherboard : Asus Prime B550m-k.
    ●GPU : ASUS DUAL GeForce RTX 3060 Ti V2 MINI.
    ●RAM : G.Skill Trident Z Neo 32 GB (2x16 GB) 3600 MHz DDR4 CL16.
    ●SSD : WD Black SN770 1TB + Samsung 980 pro 1TB.
    ●PSU : Corsair RM750 80+ Gold Certified.
    ●Case : Lian Li LANCOOL 215.
    ●Windows 11 Pro Version 23H2.
  • Hry

Komentáře • 172

  • @benchmarking4386
    @benchmarking4386  Před 28 dny +6

    For anyone wandering, even with the latest Patch cutscenes still exhibit inconsistent performance, I've made an unlisted video showcasing the performance of the first cutscene between the launch version and patch 1.3.55 : czcams.com/video/bwPC1BPlosk/video.html

    • @AfinQuaaa
      @AfinQuaaa Před 5 dny

      We NEED A GHOST OF TSUSHIMA GUIDE PLEASE

  • @hollowinside1962
    @hollowinside1962 Před 28 dny +40

    I hope Ghost of Tsushima will have a good port

    • @SunwishMaximal
      @SunwishMaximal Před 28 dny

      Judging by requirements it is complete shit, PS4 game requires same GPU (4080) as forbidden west to play in 4k, while graphics are obviously a lot shittier in Tsushima.
      Personally I think it is bullshit though. Probably it will be very easy to run and people will praise the game for it, ignoring the fact that it is very outdated graphics-wise, as they did with uncharted 4

    • @hollowinside1962
      @hollowinside1962 Před 28 dny +3

      @@SunwishMaximal i thought i was the only one that felt like the sys req were quite high

    • @stangamer1151
      @stangamer1151 Před 28 dny

      ​​@@SunwishMaximalUncharted 4 is not so easy to run actually. You need at least RTX 4070 Ti to run this game at native 4K. This GPU is usually 2.2x faster than PS5 APU.
      But that game still looks gorgeus anyway, especially at 4K.
      I think GoT will also need 4070 Ti for 4K/Max. They probably mentioned 4080 just to be on a safe side.

    • @metroplex29
      @metroplex29 Před 28 dny +1

      I mean is nixxes so yeah, it will at least for the most part. Just wait for some patches ans ur good to go.

    • @doomslayer8985
      @doomslayer8985 Před 28 dny

      All Nixxes pc ports are good, as long as you wait for a few patches (at least a month) most bugs and issues will be solved. Like the only thing to fix in this game is the cutscene fps drop, nvidia reflex implementation and data streaming on very high textures quality.

  • @kaslofchen257
    @kaslofchen257 Před 28 dny +19

    the texture update seems sweeeeet, thanks for the benchmark & comparison man

  • @fishbone007
    @fishbone007 Před 28 dny

    Good video, thanks for keeping us up to date.

  • @gamersmudngrubshow6119

    Thank you for all your diligence.

  • @Alexu4Trance
    @Alexu4Trance Před 18 hodinami

    Man, you have the best channel! Thank you! ❤

  • @lukasneuschl
    @lukasneuschl Před 28 dny

    Love your videos mate. Keep it up.

  • @soulan1s
    @soulan1s Před dnem

    Great video, Thanks!

  • @amenbrother777
    @amenbrother777 Před 28 dny

    Hello, thanks for your optimising guides. Helped me alot.
    Rx6650xt user. Before the patch I used to use 7.5-7.7GB of Vram with High Textures.
    After the patch, With high Texture it is sitting around 6.9-7.2Gb of Vram. While I noticed that the ram usage went up by 2 Gb.

  • @akashjha8864
    @akashjha8864 Před 28 dny +3

    Yep 100%. I’m surprised why most people are oblivious to this but Reflex still messes up the frametimes bad…like a camera judder. Glad you bring it up.

    • @miguelaraneta3144
      @miguelaraneta3144 Před 28 dny +1

      I suspect that's just the way it is since reducing latency means frametimes can vary per second

    • @doomslayer8985
      @doomslayer8985 Před 28 dny

      All nixxes pc ports have a bad reflex implementation and sadly they never fix it

    • @akashjha8864
      @akashjha8864 Před 23 dny

      @@miguelaraneta3144 nope every game with reflex is buttery smooth except this. Even the mother of all PC games cyberpunk 2077 is buttery smooth with on+boost.

  • @AfinQuaaa
    @AfinQuaaa Před 5 dny

    I actually love this guy. Thank you for your hard work your community appreciates it

  • @youraverageanimeenjoyer3220

    Reflex on + boost is working properly after the patch
    On my 4080
    Before the patch
    Reflex on + boost locked my gpu utilization to 80%
    Now it works properly giving me a 100% utilization

  • @doomslayer8985
    @doomslayer8985 Před 28 dny +5

    This is exactly why i wait months to play a game until it gets fully patched, bugfixed and potential performance stability improvements.

  • @fortunefiderikumo
    @fortunefiderikumo Před 28 dny +1

    i think the NV reflex patch note is talking about how enabling on+boost caused your GPU usage to be capped at 80 something percent

  • @nxw_g
    @nxw_g Před 8 dny

    Thank you for this type of video and the subtitles in portuguese br, i'm eagerly awaiting the video about ghost of tsushima

  • @cpt.tombstone
    @cpt.tombstone Před 28 dny

    I also had bad frame time consistency at launch, but a full DDU wipe of the Nvidia driver and consequent reinstall of the same version fixed the issue for me.

  • @hernandityoy3326
    @hernandityoy3326 Před 23 dny

    Hey there, any performance improvements in Burning Shores area from the DLC? Thankyou, and great video!

  • @tvcultural68
    @tvcultural68 Před 28 dny +13

    "It's too late now for them to have released a texture streaming patch. I've already finished the base game and the DLC.

    • @mafioso12dk
      @mafioso12dk Před 28 dny +17

      That's why I don't buy games on launch anymore. You pay more for worse version of the game.

    • @rzr0015
      @rzr0015 Před 28 dny +1

      You buy single player Sony games?​@@mafioso12dk

    • @stangamer1151
      @stangamer1151 Před 28 dny +2

      At least, they fixed this issue. So many players can now get better gaming experience.
      Some other devs do not even bother with fixing such major issues like this one at all.

    • @metroplex29
      @metroplex29 Před 28 dny +4

      Too late for you

    • @Teraplexor1
      @Teraplexor1 Před 28 dny +1

      I mean what's stopping you from replaying and doing a ultra hard play through or new game plus.

  • @jimjamsam3482
    @jimjamsam3482 Před 28 dny

    the King

  • @Jakiyyyyy
    @Jakiyyyyy Před 28 dny +7

    Reflex On relies on your GPU especially if you have a CPU bottleneck and you play with locked fps. On+Boost relies more on your CPU especially if you are being GPU bounded. Generally in most cases you want to stick with On. In single player games you can just leave it disabled, no big deal.

    • @doomslayer8985
      @doomslayer8985 Před 28 dny

      Most games have a bad nvidia reflex implementation, I turn them off unless i notice some input latency

    • @mahdilj5882
      @mahdilj5882 Před 28 dny +1

      Problem is if u wanna use FG its on and lock so in horizon makes the game feels weird even with like 90 fps

    • @Jakiyyyyy
      @Jakiyyyyy Před 28 dny

      @@mahdilj5882 The game is so buggish now if you want to use FG with upscaler. If you want that you can enable it with native res.

    • @ZenTunE-
      @ZenTunE- Před 28 dny

      I wouldn't agree with just keeping it off for single player. It doesn't matter if it's single player or pvp, delay feels bad in any game. Just like low fps 🤔
      (Obviously less severe than frames but maybe you get what I'm saying, 0 difference between what game it is, if it has aiming, it applies all the same)

    • @ZenTunE-
      @ZenTunE- Před 28 dny

      Makes sense, explains why I get worse performance with boost.
      That said, even just On does still add the same frametime inconsistency as seen in the video.

  • @TheBadger
    @TheBadger Před 25 dny +1

    1.3.57.0 fixes the Nvidia Reflex issue for me, game is buttery smooth and looks amazing with Nukem's frame gen mod.

    • @doomslayer8985
      @doomslayer8985 Před 25 dny

      Cant wait for the official FSR 3.1 implementation

  • @ZenTunE-
    @ZenTunE- Před 28 dny

    I can confirm the reflex issue for me too.
    10th gen i5 +3080 10gig

  • @Nintenboy01
    @Nintenboy01 Před 28 dny +1

    Hi sir, wondering if you get terrible stuttering and pauses of nearly 1 second in Need for Speed Unbound? I even upgraded to 4070 Super and 5700X3D but still bad

  • @arfianwismiga5912
    @arfianwismiga5912 Před 28 dny +2

    hope they can improve the performance

  • @Jadblabla..
    @Jadblabla.. Před 6 dny +2

    waiting for your ghost of tsushima video not gonna play it until then

  • @Damian94-wj6rm
    @Damian94-wj6rm Před 28 dny

    Hey, could you make a video about optimization of another underrated Remedy's game - Quantum Break?

  • @FPSBOOST2024
    @FPSBOOST2024 Před 24 dny

    What is your channel category? ( Gaming - technology or ....)

  • @corpacivasilecosmin2086

    So is better to use xess than fsr if you have an amd gpu

  • @mrkoddy
    @mrkoddy Před 28 dny

    Thank you for your regular benchmark. How can I get 1% low, D3D12 fps and Average fps with RTSS? If I enable fps in RTSS it doesn't display real time fps in the overlay

    • @benchmarking4386
      @benchmarking4386  Před 28 dny

      First you should make sure that all the framerate options that you want to show are enabled in the monitoring tab with "Show in On-Screen Display" checked, this will give you the real time fps(D3D12) and to get other metrics like avg,1% and 0.1% you might need to start benchmarking , you can go to Benchmark tab to see which hotkey "begin recording" and which one end it.
      and if you want to get these metrics without Benchmarking, go to Riva -> Setup -> Statistics to go to percentile buffer tab and select 'ring'.

    • @mrkoddy
      @mrkoddy Před 28 dny

      @@benchmarking4386 Thank you! It will help to chose best setting so I get 30 fps for 1% low on my specs

  • @iamhuman5533
    @iamhuman5533 Před 6 dny +2

    Ghost of Tsushima waitng for me!!!!!!

  • @tanthokg
    @tanthokg Před 25 dny

    Playing on 7900XTX, at launch the FPS is around 110+, with the latest patch it's 130+

  • @rizl_ini
    @rizl_ini Před 28 dny +4

    How about cutscene issue? Still dropping fps?

    • @TaFuRElTaBlErO
      @TaFuRElTaBlErO Před 28 dny

      Yes. This update doesn't fix nothing of that.

    • @doomslayer8985
      @doomslayer8985 Před 25 dny

      Nope, I'm gonna keep waiting until they officially fix nvidia reflex, cutscene fps drops, burning shore dlc performance and FSR 3.1 implementation. At that level you are playing a whole different game

  • @marvinbecker7453
    @marvinbecker7453 Před 28 dny +1

    ad launch it wass a good pc p
    ort now its a very good pc port

  • @IvanChristopher.
    @IvanChristopher. Před 28 dny

    Absolutely gorgeous game, really tried to like it but just couldn't do it

  • @JasmanjotSingh404
    @JasmanjotSingh404 Před 6 dny +2

    Ghost of Tsushima optimized settings bro please upload fast!!

  • @stealthhunter6998
    @stealthhunter6998 Před 28 dny

    Having reflex on is super unstable for me too.

  • @Hi_Im_o2
    @Hi_Im_o2 Před 9 dny

    can you please use amd gpus for optimization???

  • @BISHTGAMER
    @BISHTGAMER Před 27 dny

    you should meet panam, with nvidia reflex on😛

  • @Abelardo-Vidal
    @Abelardo-Vidal Před 28 dny +3

    Greetings. Thank you for keeping us informed about updates, you are the best benchmarking. I don't know if this happens to anyone else and it has been impossible for me to play the DLC: Burning shores, both with the previous version and with this new update. The game does not exceed 30-40 fps. no matter what settings you use: DLAA; DLSS-Quality. Note: I played the entire campaign without much problem (70-110 fps using DLSS in quality, although many times I had performance loss when I had been playing for more than 1 hour and I had to restart for it to be fixed. My PC: RTX 3070 Ryzen 5 5600x 32gb RAM - 3600MHZ (Windows 10 Pro)

    • @yes-gn4kn
      @yes-gn4kn Před 28 dny +2

      vram usage is higher in burning shores i believe, try turning down textures and especially clouds since they are rendered differently in the dlc

    • @benchmarking4386
      @benchmarking4386  Před 28 dny +3

      This seems like a memory leak or Vram issue, I've seen a lot of users specially those with 8gb GPUs suffering from this problem.
      Try lowering Textures to Medium and monitor your Vram and Ram usage while you're playing.
      Also The Clouds in the dlc are more demanding, make sure to use Low or Medium Cloud Quality.
      Good luck.

    • @hozanotm1837
      @hozanotm1837 Před 28 dny +4

      Belive me just set the shadow quality to medium and you will get more fps brother i have same card 3070 and i had trouble with vram usage but as soon i set the shadow quality to medium i am getting 70 fps and more at DLC

    • @hozanotm1837
      @hozanotm1837 Před 28 dny +3

      ​@@benchmarking4386no need to lower the texture just the shadow to medium and you will get the best visuals and performance

    • @Abelardo-Vidal
      @Abelardo-Vidal Před 28 dny

      @@yes-gn4kn I always monitor vram usage with Msi Afterburner and it never exceeds 7.6GB. I'll try lowering the quality of the textures even more to see how it goes, thanks.

  • @forest5040
    @forest5040 Před 28 dny

    Will you make video on Ghost of tsushima pls

  • @tomthomas3499
    @tomthomas3499 Před 28 dny

    The fps drop involving lots of npc is still there in my experience, high textures with med shadows, though Xess ultra quality plus and Xess AA is a nice addition, at this point i think i have to accept that 8gb is just ain't enough with high textures in latest AAA, and this is without RT involved, sad but that's just the reality...

    • @doomslayer8985
      @doomslayer8985 Před 25 dny

      I do have 6gb vram (3060 laptop) and what you said is partially true, but lately the gap between high and ultra is so low it ain't worth it, 8gb are still enough for 1080/1440 just individually optimize your games graphics settings with your vram budget and raw performance with these videos and you are fine

    • @tanthokg
      @tanthokg Před 25 dny

      I think the fps drops relating to lots of NPCs might relate to the CPU, I think there's a setting called Crowd Quality

    • @SaiyanMan2492
      @SaiyanMan2492 Před 25 dny +1

      I upgraded my ram to 32gb 3200 and still face this issue. It's the game.

  • @HoKcc
    @HoKcc Před 28 dny

    I have 6650 xt, 5700x and 32 gb ram and still cant play on high texture. After 30 sek fps drops to 20-35, power usage drops to 70 W.

  • @lorenzowolf2074
    @lorenzowolf2074 Před 28 dny

    Hey King are you gonna to do a new Dead Island 2 review? Now that is on steam the stuttering are killing me. Thanks!

    • @benchmarking4386
      @benchmarking4386  Před 28 dny +3

      Stuttering? That's odd because, if I recall correctly, Dead Island 2 is one of the few 2023 UE4 games with minimal amount of stuttering, alongside Atomic Heart.
      I'm not entirely sure if I can cover it again, but I'll investigate. If there are significant changes in settings and performance, I'll consider making a new video, no promises though.

    • @Jakiyyyyy
      @Jakiyyyyy Před 28 dny

      I noticed that the stuttering get even worse with High or Ultra textures. With Medium textures it does reduce a bit but what is the point? You can do Ultra settings with high fps perfectly fine but with Medium textures. That's a bummer actually. On AMD card, it can eat up to 9GB on 1080p. That's crazy.

  • @minagad7684
    @minagad7684 Před 5 dny +1

    Waiting for Ghost of Tsushima vid!

  • @spremutadisucco9728
    @spremutadisucco9728 Před 6 dny +1

    Hi benchmarking, sorry if I'm writing to you here but I don't know where else to do it, I blindly trust your guides so much so that every time I play a game I hope for a possible video from you about it. Given this, I wanted to ask you if you could make a video about Ghost of Tsushima, maybe it was already in your plans but I wanted to make sure since as I previously said "I play better because of your videos".

    • @benchmarking4386
      @benchmarking4386  Před 6 dny +1

      Hi
      I'm working on it.
      Hopefully, the video will be available this weekend.

    • @spremutadisucco9728
      @spremutadisucco9728 Před 6 dny

      @@benchmarking4386 thank you so much, you are undoubtedly the best

  • @zErGiiOxD
    @zErGiiOxD Před 28 dny

    Streaming textures means that textures will streaming from internet servers? As Cod Modern Warfare 2? Or im wrong?

    • @metroplex29
      @metroplex29 Před 28 dny +1

      No, texture Streaming has nothing to do with servers nor internet.

    • @killrblue
      @killrblue Před 6 dny

      No it means the textures dynamically change quality depending on how far they ate away and if the camera is looking at it or not

  • @user-zl5xv6ez9p
    @user-zl5xv6ez9p Před 28 dny +2

    Did Nixxes fixed massive FPS drops in cutscenes with this patch?

    • @stealthhunter6998
      @stealthhunter6998 Před 28 dny

      Commenting here so I get a noti for the answer to this.

    • @benchmarking4386
      @benchmarking4386  Před 28 dny +3

      To be honest, I haven't checked any cutscenes with this new version. I'll check tomorrow and get back to you.
      One thing to keep in mind, though: cutscenes in this game use better quality visuals compared to normal gameplay, such as better Models and Depth of Field, which is why they tend to perform worse.

    • @stealthhunter6998
      @stealthhunter6998 Před 28 dny +1

      @@benchmarking4386 I turned depth of field off (not the greatest fan on it) and still get the issue. I have 10GB vram. Having it on highest textures during a cutscene it would drop fps dramatically as if I ran out of VRAM (even though RTSS said it was 8/10 used still). Going to high stopped the issue but the texture quality actually looks pretty bad on high (or did I haven’t seen it in this new update).

    • @tomthomas3499
      @tomthomas3499 Před 28 dny +1

      Still there i'm afraid, using High textures, medium shadows and xess AA with no upscaling, running around then teleporting to different region and my fps drop to low 30s even sometime low 20s, restarted and the same cutscene will run fine 60-70fps.

    • @stealthhunter6998
      @stealthhunter6998 Před 28 dny

      @@tomthomas3499 RIP seems like I’ll be sticking to high. Wonder what it takes (vram) to run ultra textures without those cutscenes dying.

  • @aarond.170
    @aarond.170 Před 28 dny

    Anyone knows what causes the reason of sudden fps drop? Like when inside plainsong im having an fps lock of 72. I capped that fps for freesync. But when i to outside specifically in blight it fps drops to 60-50fps also when i get interacted with water. Im using r7 5700x+rx6600 and 16gb ram 3200mhz.

    • @SaiyanMan2492
      @SaiyanMan2492 Před 25 dny

      It's the game's trashy optimization. They can't seem to fix that issue.

  • @acvblbrry
    @acvblbrry Před 9 dny

    BROOOOOOOOOOOOOO, CAN YOU PLEASE DO A OPTIMIZATION VID ON GHOST OF TSUSHIMA THIS WEEK COZ I REALLY WANT TO PLAY IT AND YOUR OPTIMIZATION VIDEOS IS THE ONLY THING THAT I WATCH ON CZcams! PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE, THANK YOU SO MUCH! 🔥🔥🔥

  • @hassainemoussa1186
    @hassainemoussa1186 Před 26 dny

    The best in the world

  • @FrontsLeader
    @FrontsLeader Před 25 dny

    Can you do a guide for "Rust"

  • @matthewchristopher1313

    since the new update my game gets fps hiccups even tho im running on 150 fps plus.

  • @BrandonLor-gx8qi
    @BrandonLor-gx8qi Před 20 dny

    What resolution do you use?

  • @ariclls2078
    @ariclls2078 Před 22 dny

    Please bring Forza Horizon 5... I think that it's one of main games when testing pc performance and having a optimization video would be essential

  • @TaFuRElTaBlErO
    @TaFuRElTaBlErO Před 28 dny

    When FSR3 implementation?

  • @bloodyysweet
    @bloodyysweet Před 6 dny +1

    Waiting for ghost of tshushima please!!

  • @hrushikeshpimple4091
    @hrushikeshpimple4091 Před 20 dny

    Please make video on watch dogs legion optimization

  • @yosribou1464
    @yosribou1464 Před 6 dny +1

    yo bro drop the ghost of tsushima optimized settings video, i downloaded the game and i won't launch it until i watch your video, we're waiting

  • @1spell539
    @1spell539 Před 7 dny

    ghost of tsushima next

  • @lukadahmer8249
    @lukadahmer8249 Před 6 dny

    will you make ghost of tsushima

  • @omsuwiperkasa
    @omsuwiperkasa Před 27 dny +1

    fps drop everytime translucent objects appear such as holo's , lightings and fire camps. even worse on cutscenes.

  • @himojohnson161
    @himojohnson161 Před 25 dny

    Witcher 3 update 4.04 when King

  • @ShadyMike
    @ShadyMike Před 28 dny

    Everyone is saying how good the PC port is but them leaving auto sprint off of keyboard and mouse but having it there for controller is unacceptable IMO.

  • @x_wzxt
    @x_wzxt Před 7 dny +2

    Ghost Of Tsushima Please King?:)

  • @attilahajbel6401
    @attilahajbel6401 Před 28 dny

    Of course DLSS is the better option, but if you have an AMD or Intel card, XeSS is the way to go.

    • @doomslayer8985
      @doomslayer8985 Před 28 dny

      better than nothing imo, DLSS and XeSS are better than both TAA+FXAA combined which is used in almost all modern games out there

  • @shreyanshsingh1814
    @shreyanshsingh1814 Před 6 dny

    waiting for Ghost of tsushima

  • @hi_rohan_is_here
    @hi_rohan_is_here Před 22 dny

    Apex legends optimised graphics settings please.

  • @27aiman
    @27aiman Před 27 dny

    where is he from guys ?

  • @melexie9155
    @melexie9155 Před 26 dny +1

    Make kingdom come deliverance pls

  • @potataoDOCE
    @potataoDOCE Před 28 dny +2

    Fallout 4!!!!!!!!

  • @viktoremil5428
    @viktoremil5428 Před 28 dny +1

    Fallout 4, please

  • @slipnotololo4586
    @slipnotololo4586 Před 6 dny +2

    Where is ghost of Tsushima

    • @benchmarking4386
      @benchmarking4386  Před 6 dny +2

      working on it. Hopefully, the video will be available this weekend.

    • @slipnotololo4586
      @slipnotololo4586 Před 6 dny +1

      @@benchmarking4386 ty mate, you're awesome)

  • @rymdhundar
    @rymdhundar Před 28 dny

    Still only FSR 2? Shame on them.

  • @i3l4ckskillzz79
    @i3l4ckskillzz79 Před 28 dny

    Reflex runs fine on my 4090. Frame time looks like a straight line

    • @arfianwismiga5912
      @arfianwismiga5912 Před 28 dny +1

      dude, you're using best GPU
      😑

    • @i3l4ckskillzz79
      @i3l4ckskillzz79 Před 28 dny

      @@arfianwismiga5912 yes but i heard about problems with reflex everywhere even for people with 4090s that´s why i dont understand the whole situation. i hadn´t had a problem with that sinze launch

  • @_n8thagr8_63
    @_n8thagr8_63 Před 28 dny

    Very pretty game. Very average everything else lol

  • @emichzn
    @emichzn Před 6 dny

    Ghost of Tsushima?

  • @bm______
    @bm______ Před 28 dny +1

    I wish this game was actually fun