what happens if you choose Ravenclaw in Hogwarts Legacy
Vložit
- čas přidán 9. 02. 2023
- This is what happens when the sorting hat chooses Ravenclaw for you in Hogwarts Legacy. This is the unique dialogue that occurs. Full video of all 4 house dialogues are on my main channel.
- Hry
Imagine forgetting something after walking out and realizing you gotta solve another fkin riddle to go back in.
Maybe the riddle doesn't reset for 90 days 😂
Imagine having to urgently use the restroom
@@inaarakalani9594 I'm sure the hufflebuddies would let you use theirs
😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@inaarakalani9594 Luckily there are restrooms in the commonroom.
Gryffindor: password
Slytherin: password
Hufflepuff: just knock
Ravenclaw: “Why is a raven like a writing desk?”
😂😂😂
Because Edgar Allen Poe wrote on both
I mean it’s still a secret knock isn’t it?
This reminds me of my Alice and wonderland play
you have to knock in a certain pattern. probably changes every year. also the gryfindor and slytherin were both broken into so…
Imagine the other students arriving at the Great Hall and seeing all the Ravenclaws sleeping on the floor because nobody could solve the fckn riddle LOL
That could definitely happen in test season 😝
A bunch of people sitting over a diagram or answer list, debating over who's right.
At that point I would hope Professor Flitwick would take pity on his house and solve the riddle for them, reminding them on the way in that "It is never unwise to ask for assistance. The greatest discoveries are often found in collaboration." Or something like that.
@@FantasyIsUnderrated me justifying cheating my entire school life in degree that involves numbers
As a Ravenclaw I confirm this does happen from time to time
Imagine needing to take a quick shit and you have to solve a riddle first
I think that's what happened to Moaning Myrtle
Door: Hehe…there’s a small lake over which a giant moon is always hanging. But it does not exist in nature yet always answers its call…
Do they have shitters in the commons? I thought they were in the hall outside the house commons.
@@Mephilis78 Hufflepuff doesn’t have shitters, from what I read. Guess all that plant compost had to come from somewhere.
For a Ravenclaw its easier. Youre obviously not a Ravenclaw 😂
Why are you sleeping on the floor Ravenclaw?
Student: cause my bedroomdoor asked if chicken came first or the egg
😂😂😂
The cockerel.
Simple question: Logically the egg came first, but from what we know the riddles in the Ravenclaw tower are more then simple logic. Live itself is a circle and creation is always alligned with destruction. So I think that the answer is: A circle has no beginn or ending.
@@nick0197 Luna got asked the same question in the book, and she answered the same thing.
@@nick0197 a circle, 0, 8, triangle, a square, diamond, oval, star have no beginning and no ending tho
Just shapes
“Sleep well”, the only night you’ll ever sleep in this game
Does anyone wondered why they didn't started magic drug manufacturing wizards circle? Like half of Hogwarts subjects could teach you. Whereas Voldemort and his crew literally looked like drug addicts
Literally
What game is this??? Please tell me the name.
@@atishijain8427hogwarts legacy
@@atishijain8427hogwarts legacy
As a Ravenclaw, I’d constantly be locked out of my common room. I said I was smart, I never said I was good at puzzles
AMEN
I’m good at puzzles just not riddles 😂
I’m not good at riddles 😢
me always accompanying a ravenclaw that is good with riddles for this reason 🤣🤣
Same lol
Weasley/GRIFF: The pass is...
Weasley/SLYTH: The pass is...
Weasley/HUFF: The knock is...
Weasley/RAVE: You figure it out.
Right like she doesn't even give a hint or nothing
@brandon warner probably because it changes on a day be day basis. And if you can't solve the riddle do you really belong to ravenclaw...
@@singularleaf3895 true fair enough
@@singularleaf3895no, it changes each time.
I love being a hufflepuff, they have it easy all the time
Slytherin:walk into a wall and a snake will magically makes a door appear.
Gryfindor: speak to a painting.
Hufflepuff:walk into a beer barrel.
Ravenclaw:how people end up homeless
Ha 😂
This is why ravenclaws have to have a second entrance from the rooftop☠️☠️
You got me laughing. If you can’t solve the riddle, you better be good at flying your broom.
I'd be using that entrance all day everyday, cause I can't.
I thought it was purely for the view. I don't envy that anymore if that is the case.
👀💯😂
No they’re smart
This is why I couldn't be a Ravenclaw. I had no clue what the hell she's saying.
Same 💀
The ghost lived longer a poltergeist could never have lived for its existence is neither living nor dead
A ghost was alive at some point. They exist when a person dies but have unfinished business in the living world, or when they just cannot accept their demise.
Poltergeists, on the other hand, are Non-Human Spiritous Aparitions, a.k.a non-beings. That means that Poltergeists have never been alive to begin with. They typically form in places full of children and teenagers, as they enjoy the chaos. Poltergeists will only haunt one place at a time. That means that Peeves, for example, will never haunt any place apart from Hogwarts.
As non-beings Poltergeists are amortal (they can never die for they've never been alive).
Other examples of Non-human Spiritous Aparitions/non-beings are Dementors, Boggarts and possibly Banshees.
her answer is what is it. lived is a past participle of live.. past participle of lived is not an implication that they are dead since its only the past not the opposite. so equating a non-being into the word “lived” implies that they are still alive with the past of living. Ghost is not considered “that had lived” since ghost is a different form which is not in essence a human being which means the word live cannot be used to its form since its not alive. If the Crow said who lived longer the dead or the ghost then that means the dead is the answer.
Poltergeist is German for Noisy Ghost, I believe.
Imagine coming home drunk. Never getting in 😂
Gotta be on point lol🍻🍺😂
“What’s the thing you do when you don’t want to do anyt-“
me: “bombarda maxima”
If anyone asks a Slytherine tried breaking in
One thing about Hogwarts is there are no cameras the Professor has to take your word for it
The answer was nothing I think, it wasn't that hard. It doesn't mean I'd never use this method though.
-Umbridge said, Calmly
Ravenclaw door: What....Is the air speed velocity of an unladden swallow?
MC: What do you mean? African or European Swallow?
Ravenclaw door: Huh? I didn't know that? *Door exploded*
😂😂😂
How do you know so much about swallows?
@@davidquintana5446 well you have to know these things when you're king
Oh god HP and Pythons fandom mixed.... Couldn't be better😂 last question though, how do you recognise if it's a witch
She turned me into a newt!
God, I'd be permanently sleeping like a hobo in a sleeping bag under the damn ravenclaw common room because I'd never be able to solve any riddles.
That sounds like it's the common theme. Especially with these ridiculous riddle answers
Me too buddy. Although I think that ravenclaw's sometimes Solve the Riddle together so you might be able to get away with nodding enthusiastically and making noises at the right points in the conversation in order to get in.
Well then you wouldn’t be a ravenclaw to begin with, cuz they’re smart and good at solving riddles 😛
Twist: you forgot your sleeping bag in your common room
Imagine the other students arriving at the Great Hall and seeing all the Ravenclaws sleeping on the floor because nobody could solve the fckn riddle LOL
Just imagine being a ravenclaw and getting drunk . You need a sober housemate to solve riddles for you when you get back
How are you supposed to get drunk while at school?
@@osasunaitor alcohol
@@osasunaitorbutterbear canonically is somewhat alcoholic
Like a designated driver
@@osasunaitorin boarding school, you get someone older looking to buy you drinks and mixers from the nearby town and enjoy after bed hours
Ravenclaw is the house I always identified with most. It saddens me that we don't get a quest chain with a Ravenclaw the way we have Natsai for Gryffindor, Sebastian for Slytherin and Poppy for Hufflepuff.
I love all three of those characters... so why can't we have a Ravenclaw who is at that tier of friendship?
Ravenclaws are always overlooked, even in the books, the movies and the merch :(
@@WALLIS.. Us nerds always get overlooked.
This is what made me believe that - despite the fact the MC is completely customizable - they’re secretly supposed to be a Ravenclaw. By playing as that house you sort of fill in the gap of not having a Ravenclaw student side quest (because we are the quest) and its a good parallel between our MC and Isadora who was also a Ravenclaw student, same gift - same choice (to stop or harness the power)- same house.
The closest we had was Amit Thakkar.
@@stephenking5852 Yeah... and I felt bad for involving him in all of that Ranrok business. Poor guy just wants to spend his days at Hogwarts stargazing and we end up putting him in danger all because we need someone who can read Gobbledegook.
Natty, Poppy and Sebastian willingly dive into their respective situations knowing and accepting the risks.
Ravenclaws don’t have sober designated drivers, they have sober designated riddle solvers
I got sorted into Ravenclaw on the Wizarding World site, yet I can’t solve riddles to save my life 🤦♂️😂
The answer she gives is a bad one, believe the answer is ghost.
@@DarkXenoGaming I always thought ghost whenever I see this bit. As I said, I can’t work out riddles 😂
I hate Riddles
@@DarkXenoGaming isn't that what she said? The poltergeist, a non-being, never lived at all so the answer was the ghost.
@@methuselah8885 yes I believe so. But there is a ton of debate on it. The way she answers it is vague, but yes I believe the answer is ghost as you have explained it.
As a Ravenclaw, I’m proud to announce I’ve been sleeping outside the entrance for the last seven years because I’m a dumb asf
Would straight up start arguing with the door about answers until it gets fed up and let's me in
I feel like a villainous Ravenclaw would poison the other houses' water supply and hide the antidote behind a riddle, just to test their reaction time...😅
Nah that wouldn’t be a full ravenclaw…that would be like a Slytherclaw…
@@Mushroomsrock573there you go
@@Mushroomsrock573Nah a Slytherin would straight use avada kedavra or "NYEEHH"
Imagine trying to get to bed after a party 😅 door ask a riddle and you just answer: "Fuck you I'm drunk af😂"
be even more funny if drunk was the answer as well
Imagine coming back from a long day of work to be denied entry until you answer a riddle.
To punish the nerds in Ravenclaw, the place is so high up that all the students there must do Ironman events going up and down the stairs.
It Andy design so they'll keep fit when in and out of the library
Fit mentally and physically
Imagine being chased by a basilisk and the door wont open cus you dont know what is what😂
Edit: omg guys please don't attack me😭, i was just joking. I just thought a basilisk can't speak so how th it will answer the riddle on the door. So quick assumption, the common room would be just as safe to run to.🧘
So that is why Myrtle died
@@methuselah8885 I mean, she got murked in the bathroom by it
@@_Bloom_307 she was crying because she couldn't answer the riddle.
@@methuselah8885 oh, my b
@@_Bloom_307 well, I'm kidding. She was crying over what a classmate of hers said, but it's funny to imagine that it was because she got locked out of the common room.
This is why if you’re a Ravenclaw you gotta leave for the day with absolutely everything and triple check. I imagine some Ravenclaw friends all asking each other if they have everything before leaving for classes lmao
Im just imagining from there perspective of dumbledore: going downstairs at night to see all the ravenclaws just sleeping on the floor bc the riddle was "why do your feet smell you crusty critter?"
Everyone in Ravenclaw got Quizlet on bookmark in their phones just to get in
Imagine all the Ravenclaws sleeping in the great hall cuz the door asked if oranges are called oranges bc they are orange or if orange is called orange bc oranges are orange
😂😂😂😂
As a ravenclaw i solved it so i guess my ravenclaw besties don't need to sleep on the floor after 4 months.
The anwer is oranges are called oranges because they are orangje
They named it orange patato, because it was round like an patato and orange.
imagine if you couldsolve the riddle instead of it being a cutscene
annoying af, if you have to do it every single time you want to go in your common room. Some things dont translate well into gameplay.
Imagine if the game needed the player to enter the correct answer by text or voice recognition... and if the player never got it they just spent the year sleeping in the corridor and being mocked by the other Ravenclaws.
Actually don’t think you would be the Only Ravenclaw sleeping or wondering the castle at night
Honestly if you can’t solve the riddle then the hat wouldn’t put you in Ravenclaw 😂
Pretty sure it's canon though that some Ravenclaws do indeed fail to answer the riddle and get stuck outside waiting for another Ravenclaw to come along and either answer it for them or help them solve it. Also, not all Ravenclaws are good at solving riddles even if most are. This one was really easy but as a Ravenclaw I can confirm that I am terrible with riddles.
@@lynnz7501 That sounds horrible xD
@@lynnz7501 Yep for the most part Ravenclaws can solve the riddle sometimes and it’s quite common for them to work together until someone solves it then the door opens for everyone waiting outside to get in. I don’t think it’s logical that every single Ravenclaw can solve the riddle every single time. They’re people so sometimes they fail.
It kind of sucks that the Ravenclaw route doesn’t have a side quest character like the rest of the houses. You have Natsai, Poppy, and Sebastian quest lines but there’s no quest lines for a Ravenclaw student.
You get the owl poop 💩 in the tower
There is the miniquest with that astronomy guy, right? He is in ravenclaw.
@@Roguest283 Amit does make an appearance but his involvement doesn’t really stand out like the other 3. Their questlines span the whole game and are extremely interesting, with Sebastian’s arguably being better than the main quest, while Amit’s are short lived and kind of boring. Maybe he’ll get a quest line in a future DLC but who knows.
To be fair, the Ravenclaw students we met are really boring so I wouldn't care for a quest with them anyway. Maybe a questline for the wand Ollivander wanted to retrieve?
There _was_ a Ravenclaw sidequest character, but they were bad at riddles, so they got hypothermia from sleeping on the floor before being eaten by gremlins.
Imagine you don't get the riddle and have to sleep infront of the door 💀
Imagine having like a really crappy day you fail everything you're on the verge of a mental breakdown all you want is to lie down and forget you exist but your goddamn door wants you to answer the meaning of life that would be my villain origin story smh
Imagine being a ravenclaw everytime you want to get back to your common room you have to solve a riddle yup that's pain.
How a ghost could never have been?
Before being ghost some were human, didn't they?
The dialogue is confusing, she is saying the answer ISNT a poltergeist, since it never has been, thus making the answer ghost. I think.
a poltergeist has never been a human, the ghost has, therefore, what she said
@@DarkXenoGaming yes the dialogue is so confusing...
Don’t worry guys, you yourself doesn’t need to answer the character just does ut itself and when you walk in an out you walk in an out, you dont need to answer any riddle or at least i havent had to.
Ghosts by definition were once alive
Poltergeist had always been as themselves
They were never alive
While a Poltergeist may have existed longer than a Ghost that was once mortal, only a Ghost was once alive, which is the answer to the Riddle
Door: What's the password!
CZcamsrs: A living door?
Door: The password?
CZcamsrs: *Avada Kedavra!*
I'd have thought the ghost because he used to be a human so he lived, while a poltergeist never did
That is the correct answer, ghost.
Bro I would straight up argue with that door because that was the easiest shit I’ve ever heard. I’d be like “shut the door because I’ve had riddles on popsicle sticks harder than that.”
Haha 😂😂😂
This is why I’m Ravenclaw. I know poltergeist’s are amortal (being they never lived or died) so the obvious answer was ghosts 😂
Thank Christ I found a comment that made this riddle make sense. I was thinking "non-being" meant it didn't exist but ghosts and poltergeists both exist in this universe and it was frustrating
I'm just imagining Luna giving the door the riddles to solve instead
Only problem with this riddle: you have to know ahead of time that a poltergeist isn't a phantom of the deceased like a regular ghost. Poltergeist literally means "noisy ghost", so many would think it is just a ghost that likes to cause trouble.
Just Bombarda Maxima the door
I really wish that they put riddles depending on the difficulty that the player chose to make it more interesting.
That would be fun!
I remember a fanfiction I read where it was discovered that Ravenclaw was a fan of dirty jokes and riddles lol.
I just finished this game as a chosen Ravenclaw...loved every second...now I'm suffering from post game heartache 😢
What’s the name of the game called? The one I downloaded is definitely from the one that I’ve been seeing all over
start another playthrough and this time, be a bad guy 🤭
That’s why there are four slots. Make new saves, pick different houses, KILL THOSE WHO STAND IN YOUR WAY!!! *coughs* sorry I had a frog in my through. I meant to say “pick different conversation options. KEEP ZENOBIAS GOBSTONES AND GRACE PINCH-SMEDDLY’S ASTRO THINGY!!! MAKE PEOPLE PAY TO GET THEIR SH*T BACK!!!
The post game is so boring. And I don’t think I can restart the story by becoming another house student
As a Ravenclaw of many years, who is absolutely *abysmal* when it comes to riddle solving, it has been my long held belief that I would never be able to get into my Commonroom without help.
I'd be that sad student who is just sitting by the door, re-evaluating my life, and waiting for a fellow Ravenclaw to come save me. I'd be the one obsessing over my schedule and organizing it to Hell and back, just so I can fugure out how to avoid the door as much as possible. Whenever people see me studying, it'll actually be me going over said schedule, or looking up answers to as many riddles as possible...
I would get no proper schoolwork done. My life would revolve around my frustrations of interacting with this door.
Pretty poor Ravenclaw then aren't you
@@LordTalax What part of that makes me a poor Ravenclaw? You do realize that not all Ravenclaws are the same, right? You do know that not all Ravenclaws are genius book nerds who know the answer to every question and riddle, correct?
What makes a Ravenclaw isn't intelligence. It's a strong love for learning. (What you want to learn could be anything.) Just because I royally suck at riddles doesn't mean I don't love to learn. I very much *do* love learning.
I don't need to be a riddlemaster to prove myself a true Raveclaw. That's just ridiculous.
@silversamurai0267 plus the sorting hat could've put a person in ravenclaw due to them love learning but not intelligent enough like a stereotypical ravenclaw so that it'll challenge them to learn more and help them become more intelligent and being around those who are will help the student become more intelligent. though that's just a guess in my part anyways I'm a hufflepuff not a ravenclaw so honestly I don't know lol
Or. you could walk to the common room with other Ravenclaws. Work smarter not harder.
@@BooksInTheVoid That wouldn't aways be possible. There will undoubtedly be times when I need in, but there are no other Ravenclaws around. Certainly, if we're all walking back after eating dinner then I don't have to worry. But what if I left something in the dorm as we're om our way to classes? I could ask a friend to help, but then we'll both be late.
That's if I even manage to make friends. I'm an anti-social introvert. Odds are I won't have anyone to ask. And knowing my luck, whenever I need into the dorm will almost always be when no one else is going in.
I'm really not joking when I say that this door would be my undoing.
Personally, I would't mind some tricky questions, just for fun, but it's so kind from Avalanche that they didn't destroyed the game with tougher trials.
This scene is so touching 💙💙
we all know that a true Ravenclaw would have just left the window open so they would have to do all of this.
This professor is so sweet
It's Mrs.Patmore from Downton Abbey!
@@tai9801 thank you
Growing up, I always thought of myself as being in ravenclaw since I’m the studious, good grades type. But every single time I have ever taken a sorting quiz, it put me in slytherin… even when I fudged my answers to try to make it put me in ravenclaw. Gee, not sure why it thinks I’m a slytherin 😂
I'm the same. Had good grades in high school and graduated college with honors so I thought Ravenclaw would be my house but turned out I was also Slytherin.
I think you’re just very ambitious ig?
I thought the same too. Esp when I did Pottermore. When I looked back on the way I answered the questions, I was thinking more on a cunning level than a "smart" level. Then it all made sense. Whenever I play a game and I'm Slytherin, I'm ultra nice and helpful to people. I'm buttering them up so if I need something, I can either throw it back in their face I helped them out or they just think I'm a sweetie and want to help me cause of that. 😇😇. Using my cunning and ambition in creative, fun ways.
So, I hardly EVER replay video games (unless it's been like 5+ years) - but with that being said - Hogwarts Legacy is SUCH A GOOD GAME, that I would be willing to replay it as a different house.
What shea saying is a poltergeist was never even human ita simply psychic energy given physical form so the ghost lived longer
That's how I interpret it as well
Just because it wasn't human doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
@@GeorgeMonet no, poltergeists are phenomena that exist spontaneously, before being poltergeists they were nothing
what people don't know is that you don't need to say a password after the intro cutscene. after that it's simple as walking up to the door an it opens. people were like "oh I'm not joining Ravenclaw because I don't want to answer a riddle every time"
I'm Hufflepuff, and thought I had to knock on the correct barrel again, only for the door to pop open whenever I walked by. 😅 Plus there's rarely a reason to enter the common room except for the rare quest or puzzle.
I was a little disappointed in that but I know why they did it. But if they had made the mascot a raven I would have restarted
Yea, the common rooms are almost like unnecessary elements in this game. What for if we can’t even sleep on the bed or even sit on the couch? All we do to spend the night is by sleeping on the floor 😂
I choose my house because my favorite color is green, I keep things simple.
As fellow Ravenclaw - every time getting back to common room would be as stressful as exams, but if you won't pass you sleep on the floor 😂
I would carry spare pillow and blanket for that exact reason 😅
I suspect that the idea is that ghosts were once living, but poltergeists are a different sentient ethereal entity.
Yup 👍
Ravenclaw is basically the Airforce.
No handholding and crayon eating like Griffindor and Huffpuff for you!
Ravenclaw gang
What up!
Represent
When I started playing the Hogwarts legacy and my character received an acceptance letter to the school which was signed off as "Pr. Weasley" my first reaction was like "did Ron become a professor?" 😲
But soon after, as I dived into the game, I realised that my character was like in the 19th century, so no chance for Ron to be a professor, unfortunately 😅
This story is 100 years ago before Harry or Ron came to Hogwarts or born.
Yeah, the Weasley's are actually pureblood wizards and witches until Ron and Hermione. They just weren't dicks about it like the Malfoys or Blacks. I mean Bellatrix disowned her whole sisters side of the family just cuz she fell in love with a muggle lol, even tried to kill her niece.
@@tubebammy She ultimately did kill her niece.
@@katherine6326 you’re right. I forgot she ultimately did succeed
Ravenclaw is my House!
I instantly panicked at this point cause I’m so shit with riddles 😂 I thought they were gonna make us answer
Same!!
This clip made me realize that being a ravenclaw sounds bloody draining
Too much brain power needed
I'll just fly to one of the windows using brooms. 🤣🤣
As they say "work smart not hard" I'm not wasting time answering riddles and what not knowing I could get it wrong. And wait for godly hours to someone answer it for me🤣😅
Just imagine hearing people screaming at the door to be let in cause they’re tired while you’re trying to go to sleep 😂
I really wish they did more with the common room, even if it forced you to occasionally return to sleep as part of the main quest line. Even just to meet up with your fellow house mates and muck around would help flesh things out immensely
Imagine being tired asf and you have to solve a riddle😂
I have no clue why a riddler can be a good option to keep safe your room. Literally everyone in each house has brilliant minds, who can do the same (for example Hermione) , so bad idea. The safest password is Hufflepuff because you have to follow a sequence in the correct knock, which you don't know, and if you miss the first time you will be doused in Vinegar, something really fucked up. Griffyndoor and Slytherin are fine as well. Ironically the most intelligent house founder screwed up badly here.
I feel like Ron Weasley would be sleeping outside
The riddle is open to interpretation. Take Peeves the Poltergeist. It could be argued he's "living" by always playing pranks on the students, therefore qualifying as a correct answer. It could mean emotionally living instead of physically living
That is one way to look at it for sure 👍
I'd never be getting into the dorms. 😅
The ravenclaw common room was beautiful
OMG the voice of the teacher is the cook from Downton Abbey!!
Imagine just trying to get your notebook and the door gave you a lengthy number sequence. 😄✌️
Riddle: blah blah I don’t feel like writing it out
Me, a ravenclaw: *desperately searching up the difference between a ghost and a poltergeist*
“A non-being can never have been.”
Door: I’m sorry, we were looking for “Ghost” or “Poltergeist.”
She could have just said "ghost" rather than explaining why. She's thinking harder not smarter or is that Ravenclaws thing?
100% agree
In the harry potter universe "Ghosts" arent actually souls of dead humans but imprints of people who have lived. So they never technically lived and are classified as "Non beings" same as poltergeists or boggarts. I'll admit its confusing if you dont know that is the distinction. Because the mc gives the correct answer which is neither.
What a stupid answer.
I was thinking it was a question on actual ghost lore, not a nonsensical puzzle answer.
just imagine being really tired and you're locked out of your own common room because you're to tired to solve a riddle.
This Professor reminds me of Angela Lansbury.
That riddle made no sense as a ghost was and has been and therefore still is the same as a poltergeist.
I believe her answer was ghost, saying that a Poltergeist had never been (i.e. never lived) and therefore the answer is ghost. Stupid. I know.
This is why your boy wasn't a ravenclaw lol xD
The most perfect thing is that after you've slept, prof. Weasly waits for you inside the common room
Walk of shame home
Professor Weasley, headmaster of gryffindor: I won't be of much help.
Professor McGonagall, headmaster of gryffindor: pathetic.
See, I thought it was the Poltergeist because the peeves the Poltergeist is made up of the living Energies of teenagers according to lore, and ghosts are dead. So a ghost is dead while a poltergeist continues to live
Haven't heard that one before (and there's been like 3000 comments on it on my TikTok video of it). Good thought! 👍
But she said lived past tense...a ghost had lived a life before, a poltergiest has never been alive in the scientific sense of the word.
@@vianjelos that is how I understood it as well
Let’s be real, how often did you go to the common room in this game
Maybe once to unlock the chest to get your house specific cloak
only when it spawns me there for new seasons and when I'm returning those token things
Imagine being chased by a Death Eater and then getting killed by it because you couldn’t get in your common room fast enough because you can’t solve the riddle.
🤣🤣
Perfect voice actress for Professor Weasley, love it. :)
One would have to ask the definition of live since a ghost has a second life and a poltergeist is a being (which is alive in its own sense) that has been around for a unknown amount of time
Honestly annoyed it didn't let you solve it yourself.
Lol same
For anyone worried about not being able to solve the riddles, I'm pretty sure that you could still be allowed in as long as you explain your reasoning.
As a ravenclaw this would drive me crazy. "I just want to go to bed!!"
Only went to the common room once 😂 mid game
I thought it meant the answer is neither. As humans have lived but ghosts have not lived. A ghost/poltergeist is a different state (non-being) and can’t be considered as ever living in that state.
That's what I thought as well. The dialogue is just confusing because they're trying to make the answer mystical of some sort.
No. NON being means you DON'T EXIST. But ghosts and Poltergeists BOTH EXIST.
but ghosts in order to be ghosts first lived, unlike poltergeists, so although they are both not alive, ghosts "lived" longer
Only Ravenclaws can pass this "If the fish flew to the shopping mall, what color does music taste like?"
The funny thing is there aren’t exact answers to any riddles the eagle speaks, just as long as the student uses their mind and wit to come up with any answer to the question. I’d have said a ghost because they were once a living being and a poltergeist is the essence of a place, not actually alive.
A ghost is a person that was living, so I don't get the answer
I think she's saying the answer IS ghost. The way she answered it is weird
Neither a ghost or a poltergeist are living as they are dead, is what she means
And of course she knows the password hh
Since I'm a Slytherin I'm fighting the urge to yell "NERD!"
😂😂
In the books it mentions that if you can't figure it out you have to wait for someone else to solve it.