What exactly went wrong with Total drama all stars and how I would change it!
Vložit
- čas přidán 1. 08. 2024
- I channeled my inner Tamashi
How could they've botched this so easily... It's such a shame
Chapters
0:00 Intro
1:49 Part 1 (The timing of it's creation)
4:14 Part 2 (The Characters)
9:14 Part 3 (How would I change it)
19:19 Part 4 (Is there any good)
czcams.com/video/Etll1CCRgKc/video.html
Friends I have been branching on to animation
So please give it a check please please please
The biggest mistake was the creative decision to split Season 5 13/13 with Pahkitew instead of making All-Stars a full 26. Could've done 22 characters as an homage to the original Island, split up between ROTI and the First Gen. Not that Pahkitew was bad, but this was such a waste
But then we wouldn't have Jasmine who was a good character in Pahkitew Island.
I mean.. Pahiktew was bad for a lot of reasons. I think they could just transfer over some of the better characters from Pahkitew to Revenge of the Island, giving Revenge a full 26 episodes as well. I think it would be cool if half way through this 26 episode ROTI, the Island just disappears and they go to Pahkitew, then the plot twist of the Island being mechanical would be revealed in All Stars or at the end of ROTI (but the island doesn't explode and instead they use the robotic Island for All Stars to simulate World Tour episodes)
@@maddiemcnugget1076 But WhAt about the Ridonculous Race?!?!
The thing is they did that with action but there wasnt enough people to be eliminated just about every episode. But they shouldn’t of made each season 13 episodes either cuz then there were too many ppl to fit each episode so they had to do a double elimination on revenge, all stars, and pahkitew
@@MeeMeeCandy777 they could’ve pulled a World Tour and add her and some other good PI characters into the mix as new people
Heather being eliminated after 6 episodes is just UNACCEPTABLE
Because Alejandro supposed to be eliminated, but since he used his own Statue, he was therefore immunity and because of Heather had the second most voted with one voted due to the rest of them voted of Alejandro, she was therefore been eliminated.
Heather can't always be in the top 5-
heather stroy ended in world tour
This is great I would love the season if it was like this also I’d prefer Lindsay winning especially since she’s been robbed so many times
it's sad that shes the only member of the Heather Beth Lindsay alliance
not winning
Joshua Aaron Philip Ballena Beth did not win
Yes she did or world tour would not happen look at the the celebrity manhunt episode
@@0mnom519 technically all of them didn't win. The official winners were Duncan and Alejandro.
@@adaleah_leah Yeah but each country has it own winners, but as the serie is from Canada you are right since they won in that country
“All Stars is my favorite season!”
No
We don’t joke like that
But all stars is my favorite season don't @ me
TheNascarFanatic73 Why
i love it too
It wasn't my favourite season but I didn't think it was that bad tbh
@@blaneyfan73 🤢
I agree with every except Sierra making it farther than Heather
Yeah
Why don't u like sierra making it farther than heather?
@@CopperShortsword it just feels wrong, Heather is a legendary character, has made it further than Sierra and has much more story potential. I will take Heather Vs Alejandro again over Sierra hallucinating Cody any day. Keep in mind I actually like Sierra, she cracks me up sometimes.
i agree , heather has more potential plot drama wise while it would feel like sierra would float .
@@WatermelonNoel I totally agree with you. Heather is a really strong competitor but All stars made her look dumb and a weak villain. Maybe if Sierra let go of her Cody obsession she could’ve been a good competitor and possibly an ally. Literally all stars made Sierra so annoying and delusional and made Heather basically a side character that does nothing at all to the plot (Note Heather is my favorite total drama character and Sierra was pretty good in World tour).
Owen, really, guys, who had the idea of making an All-Stars series and not bring one of the best characters, which is also very iconic AND he won the first season... I really missed Owen.
I KNOW HES MY FAVORITE CHARACTER!!!!!!!!!!!
yeah why wasnt owen in all stars?
At least I respect them for valuing plot over comedy. Except the plot sucked at the end
owen did not win there is no official winner because every country has it own winner
@@leone2633 well, there’s technically 2 winners depending on where you live so Owen technically would be a winner
Lindsay woulda made an awesome winner. I was pissed when she was eliminated first. When I saw it I threw my remote across the room and screamed. (I was 6)
Agree with me that she should’ve been in the finale of action instead of Beth?
Seen any my videos Hanna Brady?
Care to check them out? That is just a rumor
I agree with you dude, Beth advancing ahead of Lindsay was ridiculous in terms of how it happened (and Duncan laughing at Lindsay's mistake that cost her the million made me want to punch eight holes in my wall or TV) and Beth's win only ended up undermining all the effort Lindsay made. No, you wanna know who I'm really angry at? Owen. The only reason he was brought back was because he's the creators favourite. He was part of the reason why Lindsay was eliminated by voting for Courtney (KNOWING that she had immunity mind you)! The word "fuck" doesn't even begin to describe how insanely pissed off I am with that elimination. I stopped watching TDA altogether because of that, and I'm glad I did because after her elimination, the rest of the episodes became more dull and forgettable.
bridgette and beth should of been in this season also b and topher
@@matthewduffy1710 the creators could have kept him in longer without eliminating him also all he did was slightly sabotage people and he wasn’t gonna win no matter what because he was just spying and sabotaging
If All Stars had been just like just said, It would have turned into my favorite season easily. I believe that you picked the perfect characters to develop, instead of making the boring ones survive long time (Cameron, Zoey, Mike, Duncan) I just would have eliminated Sierra in the episode where Sam was eliminated, then Mike, then Heather and then Sam, the rest stayed the same as you said. Lindsay making it to the final has always been my dream, and I also think Courtney deserved way better
OMG THANK YOU!
I agree.
Although I like Duncan,Zoey,Cameron and Mike, they all made it pretty far in the seasons they were in. Heather is my favorite total drama character and she should’ve been eliminated sooner since she didn’t really do anything smart or add anything to the plot. I also agree on how Courtney and Lindsay deserved better; they should’ve been the finale since they both always get robbed each season.
Duncan??? Boring??? Must be a Trent fan or Harold fan or something like that salty ah
@@kingworldadventures I'm actually a Duncan fan haha, it's just that we had seen ENOUGH of him, way too much
@@kingworldadventures as a Harold fan I am very offended (jk)
I would love to see Courtney finally win a season. also keeping that promise she made all the way back season 1 would have been a great way to end her character arc.
Courtney never winning is probably the best for her sanity and ego
Fun fact: in revenge of the island for a split second in the scene where mike has taken over his personality’s you can see mal looking angry in the background as a red shadow in mikes mind
I’ve seen it too
What i heard this was glitch or something
Dang that twist with Lindsey and the statue would have been perfect.
The only reason I watched All Stars was for Alejandro and Heather's moments 😂
lol
someone send this to Fresh Tv pls
I wish Cody was in All Stars. I wanted to see more of him.
Lilothestitch Beth is more of All-Star than Cody.
Ugly Fense Why do you say that?
Lilothestitch Beth won Action in some countries, Cody got 3rd in WT. Beth also beat Cody in Island, so she is objectively more of an All-Star.
Ugly Fense I kinda feel like they both should’ve been in All-Stars
Lilothestitch Okay, I think it’s just that an OG cast member had to be in all 3 seasons to be an All-Star. And Alejandro and Sierra aren’t OG cast members, so they can go around this rule.
Your channel is horribly underrated
It's fine I don't mind it
@@dramaticScar lol
@@Cobgd what Lol???
@@dramaticScar idk
@@dramaticScar not anymore it isn't :)
I’d do a similar thing, but bring Zoey and Mike a bit further. I would personally change Sam and Sierra to Owen and Dawn, Dawn because I feel like she could really help Mike with Mal, and yes I’d keep Mal. Also I agree the best thing in that season was Scott 😂 will you be my boyfriend, I mean boyfriend, I mean you girl, me boy- AH
He is so cute
Or when he said:
“COURTNEY! I’M YOUR GIRLFRIEND!!
Dawn was in like 3 episodes bro, why would dawn be in all stars?
I AGREE WITH EVERYTHING OMG THIS VIDEO IS REALLY GOOD!!!
Thank you much... I really tried hard
How I'd fix Pahketew Island:
1. Have it take place a year after Revenge of the Island. That way, you can have the new artificial island be a replacement for Wawanakwa because of it still being decontaminated from all of its toxic waste, and have Chris not being in the right mental capacity, due to his recent prison sentence, leading to Max and Scarlet (the villain duo) getting away with cheating just to either win their own team the challenge or sabotage their own team to get rid of the weak links, as Scott did previously.
2. Reduce Sugar to a simple comedy relief and have her eliminated in one of the earlier episodes. She should not be an antagonist at all.
3. Make it clear that Max and Scarlet are the main antagonists and have the latter being the brains behind their evil-doing, while the former acts them out. And make it clear that they were evil geniuses in High School, and how they learned from how to commit terrorism, but it led to them getting expelled, but because again, Chris has no sense of reality after his prison sentence, they get put on the show, and get away with cheating, even though Chef is more aware of it. But once the third to last episode comes, and they with their skills, find out that the island is artificial and make it go completely haywire, holding Cameron, the winner of last season, and the brain behind the temporary island, hostage, just so they can get the money alone without going through any effort into actually trying to win it fair and square. But they're stopped as Chris finally snaps back to reality, and tells them to get them out and disable the bomb, and Shawn, who watches action movies a lot, knows all of the tropes, and gets through most of the obstacles with ease, and wins the challenge, while Max and Scarlet are completely disqualified from the season.
4. I would have Max and Scarlet be the ones to reveal that Sky has a boyfriend named Keith, making Dave go insane, just as they're about to get together, and this would force him to be eliminated right after the merge. This would give Sky an explanation of who Keith is, basically being a bit of a bad-boy kind of person, and his charm got her to like him, but she looks back at it and vows that after the show's over, that she'll break up with him, and make it up with Dave, maybe even split the money if she wins.
5. I'd have the Amy and Samey sub-plot resolve differently. Instead of Samey trying to be Amy, have Zoey involved as one of the appearances from the second generation, and have Zoey tell Samey that because of her being a lonely child, she had no friends and was a bit of a loner, while also having Samey tell her about her mean twin sister. I'd also have them on separate teams for good measure. Have Amy be in the show until the dueling episode where Max actually zaps Samey instead of Ella, and finally have Amy realize the error of her ways, revealing what she'd become if she continued harming her sister, and have her take a sister over a million dollars, and have the two quit the show.
6. Have the second generation make appearances, just like in Revenge of the Island with the first generation. And have them be based on their personality, like, Lightning's big brawns but small brains be used for the obstacle course, Mike's mental disability being used when Chris starts going too far, Cameron's big brain but small muscles being used as a tool for the third to last episode, etc.
7. Have the finale resolve any love story plotlines. I'd have Dave and Sky make it all up after Max and Scarlet sabotaged their relationship, and have them promise to split the money if Sky wins. And I'd have Shawn and Jasmine do the same if Jasmine wins. (Yes, I'm changing the final two, because Shawn's armpit farts shouldn't have led him to win in the end. And I'd have Jasmine win because of her decent singing performance of Waltzing Matilda.) And I'd have it still play out the same way regardless of who wins, the winner splits the money with her boyfriend, while the loser says she'll take a boyfriend over a million dollars anyway, showing the ending message of selflessness. with those who crave money always losing everything, while those who are selfless, lead to them doing good in life.
8. Have them set up All-Stars with a special episode called, Total Drama Re-Union, with all of the competitors except for Ezekiel returning, as they'd trick the former contestants into thinking that they'd all be replaced by the mutants banished from Wawanakwa, but that end with the competitors once again getting lost, and it just so happens that the most liked characters from those seasons get rescued, while the less than savory characters get left off the show, as the show would be all about Generation vs. Generation vs. Generation.
9. Have Topher's excuse for wanting to get rid of Chris being because of his mental state, instead of his love. We really don't need a male Sierra around here, do we?
10. Tone down Ella. Instead of making her very princessy, have her be Dawn's cousin, who is also very nature friendly, and have her be aware of who Max and Scarlet are, and have her try to kick them off, but have Scarlet's genius preventing her from doing so. And please, DON'T MAKE HER SING! Okay?
Nicklas Zande STVS TDP est. 2001 Lightning won Revenge of the Island in other countries, so they don’t necessarily hold Cameron hostage.
Now these are some damn Good fixes for Pahkitew island I'm impressed
Ugly Fense Pretty sure he won in only one country. Either way they can just not reference that and say finalist instead in this metaphorical version.
Goddam that sounds really good
Impressive
I dont even know WHY THEY PUTTEN SAM owen is more popular than him
He’s better than everyone except DJ and heather
We don’t touch DJ and heather.
@@huxleytv1213 no no we dont
Papa Louie Survivor thanks for the support fam
I like DJ but he’s kinda useless
they did this most likely for the 1st generation n’ 2nd generation ratio .
why does everyone beg for owen in all stars? i understand he’s the “heart of the show” or whatever but having both gwen and owen in the same season means that no matter what ending you accept, there is a competing winner, which isn’t fair. plus, i don’t think i would have been able to take another season of overdone fart jokes.
Exactly... especially with the team that was writting the jokes... In the Ridonculous race his farts had some legir comedic value...
He could be easily the first boot.
Crack Daiquiri 1. Both Heather and Alejandro were in All-Stars. Also, both Cameron and Lightning were in, so I don’t think that’s a problem.
Joao Pedro How about he’s the second boot? Everybody thinks either Owen will make it far, or he’ll be the first boot, so it would be a great troll.
Owen is the og winner, it’d be great and it’d attract more fans to watch allstars
This Is what we REALLY deserve including this AMAIZING finale
Thank you so much!!!!
Lindsay should have made the finale of action instead of Beth. Courtney vs Scott should have been the finale of TDAS.
Dude your final challenge idea is incredible i would've enjoyed that much more
NO YOU ARE INCREDIBLE
Alejandro did u find heather?
Hi
So uh
How are you two?
If you guys have been paying attention, Lindsay and Courtney were the first in the bottom two who didn't get eliminated in Island, the first bottom two in the original All Stars, and they had a rivalry in Action. And they're in the finale in this version.
there are people who say that they suffered more in this season. BUT WHAT CAN YOU TELL ME ABOUT TDROTI? A radioactive island where Chris didn't give a break to the new ones, who had no experience putting them with super strong challenges and throwing them off in a catapult, after being eliminated in the ceremony, seems to me the strongest season to watch, real. And the cast is a thousand times higher than that of pahkitew island
I would've wanted to see Duncan win again
Nice video! I personally like All Stars, but I will admit, it does have a lot of problems
The only problem with your rewriting is too many male characters being eliminated before the girls. I would prefer something more balanced. Honestly I would prefer if this season was after Pahkitew and it should have been a 26 episodes season.. This way we could get more development to the casts of Revenge and Pahkitew..
Yeah I noticed that...
And yes I agree and even stated that pahkitew island thing in the video
@@fireheart2079 Cause girl characters are more annoying on average.
@@davidc. lol, I want to disagree so badly
New subscriber love the elimination order yay for Lindsay and Courtney
Omg I think I'vs done something right for a change ✌😆✌
So your user name means dark evil
I think instead of gwen Scott should have been eliminated
@@sleepyboidraco Gwen needed to be eliminated first, she didnt know what she did to meh >;C
courtny couldn't get stung again because bees can only sting once then they die.
I know that
but this is still a cartoon ... they believe that radioactive expusure can make squirlls shoot lasers...
Dramatic Scar You misspelled “squirrel”. Courtney will hunt you if you do not spell correctly.
I honestly agree with most of the points made in this video and even the changes made to All-Stars, especially the hundredth episode plot. The only thing I would definitely disagree with is the Courtney and Gwen switch since I don't think it's really necessary. Although I'm a Courtney fan, I don't mind her switching to the villain team. But I am not a Gwen fan so I don't personally see her switching. Additionally, I think if the two were on separate teams in the season then it'd be harder for them to patch their friendship and I really liked how the original All Star season had them make up. Other than that, great video!
Great point
11:27 I think a more logical way to have Mike eliminated in Moon Madness would be for the bacon hat to trigger Manitoba Smith. Mike spends the rest of the episode as Manitoba, but as they’re racing towards the finish line, something happens that causes the hat to fall off. Like in the original, Mike becomes confused and gives the Villains enough time to beat them. Since Mike cost them the challenge, the Hamsters send him home.
every single character in TDAS had a downgrade, especially Courtney and Heather.. althought I love them idk what happened to them tbh
Hold on...
You name is Rui?
My name is Rui.
@@dramaticScar really?? omg, where are you from???
@@lextxt Portugal.
@@dramaticScar omg, me too!!
@@lextxt omd um tuguinha!
You would have definitely made this season much better
Thank you 😍😍😍
Dramatic Scar your welcome
@@FarCryfanLove could you watch my most recent video please????
Dramatic Scar sure
The problem with total drama all stars is that it needed a bigger cast also Bridget and Owen should have been in it.
Agree with everything.
And your version is way better than the flop we got (I want all female finale so much)
EDIT: actually I think there is something that TDAS did better than any other season: they did not made the formula of one team that losting all the time and one team winning all the time. First episode HH lose, than the VV lost twice in a row, than the HH lose twice a row, than VV and finally HH. any other season, with the expetion of TDI there is dumb winning streak of one team (team victory and killer grips are the biggest victim of this)
Also the toxic rats
Yeah, but if I remember right, the Toxic Rats lost for a reason : Scott. Didn't he tried to sabotage his team's challenge in order to eliminate them one by one ? Especially with manipulation behind (B, Dawn, you will be missed.)
翡翠Jade I’m offended that I’m never included in these comments positively
Some guy at the box office just said:
Hey let's pick out 14 characters to ruin!
Everyone else: yeah yeah that's a great idea
The challenge would be to face cris’s favorite challenge from each season
If I had to personally cast the contestants to equally balance between gender, generations and hero/villain status, while still only using 14, I would cast them like this.
HH
-Zoey
-Mike
-Cameron
-Gwen
-Courtney
-Lindsay
-Owen
VV
-Heather
-Alejandro
-Duncan
-Jo
-Lightning
-Scott
-Anne-Maria
I feel like Owen could be a decent replacement for Sam, and would probably be eliminated around the same time. I know he doesn’t have much left to do in the series, but he’s pretty much *the* all star, and it’d be weird not to include him. And Anne-Maria could potentially be an interesting side-antagonist, or could help discover Mike’s inability to swap personalities in an attempt to find Vito. Unless you’re not including Mal, of course.
Of course, fitting Brick in could also be a possibility, as I’d love to see more interaction between him and Jo.
I love this finale! not only do Courtney and Lindsay seriously deserve justice after their eliminations in Action and Island, but the way you set it up is actually amazing! good work!
this season should've been season 5, with the season 4 cast, the plot is that because of the smaller budget they had to split the season, they get a second chance to win the million and the winner gets the chance for another million, this time they have to build the island and a part of a bigger plan from later on, and season 6 would be the old cast and new cast competing for their longest season with 3 teams, and things like Ezekiel not being eliminated first, and alliances like Alejandro taking Justin under his wing and showing him how to use his looks and not worry about getting dirty or hurt which was what led to his elimination is season 2, A rivalry between Jo and Eva that leads to it getting more tense, Dawn and Ezekiel having a relationship which leads him getting way further. The teams would be 3 teams with the classic teams being split into 2 teams of 12, The first time would be Owen Cody Sierra Katie and Sadie Ezekiel Izzy Noah Tyler Eva Duncan and Harold called the crazed bears. Team 2 would be Alejandro Leshawna Lindsey Beth Justin Heather Courtney DJ Gwen Geoff Bridgette Trent called the Soaring Pythons. Team 3 would be the season 4 cast now going by the Toxic Mutants. All guys would share one cabin and all girls would share the other cabin so the old and new can know each-other leading to tension alliances and even relationships which will boost ratings, the team that comes in dead last will go to the elimination ceremony where they will vote off one of their fellow teammates, The people who are safe will receive an arrowhead, whoever doesn't get an arrowhead will be forced to take the sling of shame. The winning team will be rewarded for winning with whatever and the 2nd place team gets to sulk and wonder what went wrong but at least take consolation in the fact that they didn't completely lose. For the first elimination ceremony, It's the Crazed bears who came dead last, the arrow heads go to Harold Tyler Izzy Noah Owen Katie Sadie Eva Duncan Cody. The last 2 without an arrowhead are Ezekial and Sierra, the music picks up, the tension rises, Zeke is about to star hyperventilating, Sierra starts to sweat, the camera zooms in on the arrowhead, Ezekial closes his eyes in fear, he is shaking, then Chris decides..... and says "Ezekial?! wait really, well okay, here you go buddy. Zeke Opens his eyes, grabs the arrowhead and hugs it, rubbing it against his face, Sierra while disappointed, looks at Cody one last time and smiles as she is flung from the sling, Cody starts to tear up, the camera switches to Chris, and the episode ends
Instead of removing characters like Sierra and Sam to replace them with characters like Owen and Leshawna, the writers could've added Owen, Cody, Leshawna, Brick, and Anne Maria to the show like they've planned. But hey, fortunately, Owen appeared in the final episode of All Stars so that's something.
This was very well made! I really like your version of the season. A Lindsay and Courtney finale would be epic. Also the fund raising episode for Zeke warmed my heart.
You earned yourself one more subscriber!
I don't care about zeke...
But the whole ferrel zeke is just stupid
THIS SOUNDS LIKE SUCH A GOOD FINALE OMG
Thank you... this was a shower thought
When you eliminated Gwen, I knew Lindsay would win.
Milo, THEY LITERALLY TYPED IN “LINDSAY” HOW COULD YOU GET THAT WRONG!?
I have another idea for the finale.
Each contestant spins a wheel and whichever is the eliminated contestant, the eliminated contestant chooses a challenge of an episode they lost in, including this season, and the other has to do a challenge based off on that.
Like say Lindsay lands on Zoey. Zoey chooses Courtney to get a flower from Larry/Laurie and avoid obstacles thrown at her. Courtney spins and lands on Gwen, who made Lindsay sheer a sheep until she gets one with Gwen's face on. Each contestant has to do it under 10 minutes. If Lindsay or Courtney refuse or do not complete a challenge, they lose one of the three hearts. Both Lindsay and Courtney has one heart each left, so Chris shoves all of the contestants in a wooden crate and put them in a lazy river and gets Courtney and Lindsay to get on boats and fish out an eliminated contestant. Then the contestant has to complete a challenge they would be bad at. Like for example, if Lindsay fishes out Zoey, Zoey will have to slap Mike or something, and if Courtney fishes out Gwen, Gwen has to tread in a well for 10 minutes. Depending on when the eliminated contestants are eliminated, each contestant scores different points for whoever fishes them out. The sooner the were eliminated, the lower they score, and the farther they went, the higher they score, so Cameron is worth 1 point and Jo worth twelve, both Lindsay and Courtney have the same amount of points to reach foe a goal, 20 points and fishes out Cameron and Jo. Lindsay has 19 points and Courtney has 8 points. Jo has to lose to Brick for Courtney, and Cameron has to fight Team E-Scope all at once. Characters who aren't in the season cheers on for who they want. Lindsay wins if Cameron wins against Izzy, Noah, and Eva. Courtney wins if Jo loses to.Brick.
Tell me what yiu all think?
Haven't even started the video but Lindsay shouldn't of been 1st boot
İ actually think that a season of *ridonculous race, pahkitew island, og cast, revenge of the island and tdwt cast(blaineley, alejandro and sierra)* *would make a great all stars season with don hosting it*
Even better, what if Don and Chris (and maybe even Blainely or Topher) are fighting for control over the show? It would be peak comedy to see them constantly undermine each other, and maybe have a subplot over Don thinking Total Drama should try to be more safe for the contestants, with Chris pushing back against him, saying it'll be bad for ratings or something
dang that aftermath idea really caught me off guard
i was like "aftermath wha uhh huh. ezekiel finally is gonna have his arc closed? finally"
Bro, Zoeys fear is getting voted out by a jock (but he might have not watched her audition yet)
So for Zoeys turn lightning or Tyler should have been brought back being seen voting for Zoey in the way they vote in tdas
lol they just bring Tyler back to vote her off. And then they just kick him off too. Poor Tyler, but it would be nice for him to appear to give Lindsay a hug (and then he gets flushed or somethin)
@@maddiemcnugget1076 but Lindsay and Tyler broke up
@@cancerandaids3822 off screen! So not in show cannon 😐😐😐
So i know that total drama isn’t just supposed to be animated reality tv, but the thing that ALMOST ALL all stars seasons have in common, is how many seasons the contestants come from. At the time, total drama didn’t have all the characters it does today. despite the last two casts of characters not being the greatest, I still think the producers should have waited a while before making an all stars.
13:20 - Anyone noticed that Gwen span the wheel counter clockwise but it started moving clockwise? And then in the next scene it's spinning counter clockwise.
Jesus I love you
what
@@kornelbut I love it when people notice this
Ah alright
I agree all the way.
Great video man. If I had to change the cast, I would cut Sam and Sierra with Brick and maybe Izzy. I picked Izzy so she could be crazy and insane.
In your finale I think Lindsay would've one, but I because I'm a big Courtney stan, I'd like to think she did.
I think the challenge that could have been basic straining, i think it was the challenge Owen broke his jaw, or whatever that is
3:33 did any one notice Lightning’s picture fade out while everyone’s eating else stayed the same ?
It's from the video I used
The only reason why i saw TDAS was for Gwen and Courtney friendship
My way:
Teams:
Heroic Hamsters: Brick, Cameron, Courtney, Lindsay, Mike, Sierra, Zoey
Villainous Vultures: Alejandro, Duncan, Gwen, Heather, Jo, Lightning, Scott
Episode 1: Villains win, Heroes lose
Votes:
Sierra: Brick, Cameron, Courtney, Mike, Zoey
Courtney: Lindsay, Sierra
14th: Sierra
Exile: Lightning
Episode 2: Heroes win, Villains lose
Votes:
Lightning: Alejandro, Duncan, Gwen, Jo, Scott
Jo: Heather, Lightning
13th: Lightning
Exile: Brick
Episode 3: Heroes win, Villains lose
Votes:
Jo: Duncan, Gwen, Heather, Scott
Heather: Alejandro, Jo
12th: Jo
Courtney and Duncan swap teams (Duncan shielded Gwen from a leech and Courtney used Brick as a human shield)
Exile: Lindsay
Episode 4: Villains win, Heroes lose
11th: Cameron (Mal rigged the votes against him)
Exile: Scott
Episode 5: Villains win, Heroes lose
Votes:
Brick: Lindsay, Mal, Zoey
Duncan: Brick
Mike: Duncan
10th: Brick
Duncan and Gwen stay together
Exile: Scott
Episode 6: Villains win, Heroes lose
Votes:
Lindsay: Mal, Zoey
Duncan: Lindsay
Mike: Duncan
9th: Lindsay
Exile: Alejandro
Episode 7: Heroes win, villains lose
Votes:
Alejandro: Courtney, Gwen, Heather, Scott
Heather: Alejandro
8th: Heather (Alejandro used the invincibility statue)
Exile: Mal
MERGE
Episode 8: Immunity: Alejandro
Votes:
Duncan: Alejandro, Courtney, Mal, Scott
Mal: Duncan, Gwen
Courtney: Zoey
7th: Duncan
Exile: Scott
Episode 9: Immunity: Gwen
Non-elimination round
Exile: Mal
Episode 10: Immunity: Mal
Votes:
Alejandro: Courtney, Gwen, Mal, Scott, Zoey
Zoey: Alejandro
6th: Alejandro
Exile: Gwen
Episode 11: Immunity: Courtney
Votes:
Gwen: Mal, Scott
Scott: Gwen, Zoey
Mal: Courtney
4th/5th: Gwen/Scott
Episode 12: Immunity: Zoey
Votes:
Mal: Zoey
3rd: Mal (He is still in control of Mike)
Episode 13:
Courtney's helpers: Gwen and Scott
Zoey's helpers: Duncan and Mal
Duncan and Zoey defeat Mal together
2nd (Alternate Winner): Courtney
1st (Official Winner): Zoey
I would wanna see Duncan win again
Here is the person I was fearing when I wrote this
@@dramaticScar thanks for the best response ever!
@@dramaticScaroh no, how dare someone have a different opinion to you
Dude. You are sooo cool right now. In my fanmade redemption, Courtney is runner up and Lindsay's is th ed winner. I guess all of us were hoping for either Courtney or Lindsay to win the whole season.😁
The reason I watched all stars was to see Courtney winning
@@dramaticScar yea. A lot us were expecting Scott/Lindsay and Courtney to go into the finale. I was disappointed when it didn't happen.
Kloforia Foxy i honestly prefer the scott vs courtney with courtney winning but i do respect the lindsay vs courtney finale, i just believe that scott vs courtney would be more interesting to see then lindsay being in the finale.
@@vimier scott and Courtney are two out of some of my favorite characters; I really felt like they could've had a rivalry. But they ruined her in all stars. We knew she was always competitive and it really shown in tdwt. These two would make some fierce competition.😁
Kloforia Foxy exactly! i would’ve loved to see the rivalry go as far as to the finale!
If Total Drama All Stars Was Made In 2013 That Will Mean Despicable Me 2, Uncle Grandpa & GTA V Are The Most Popular & Hated Games, Shows & Movies In 2013
GTA V was kind of inferior to GTA IV.
The worst thing was, Brick didn't join his girlfriend in All Stars. 😭✋
idk having 2 new casts in a row would probably make people think that the originals were just gone forever. Unless they kept making cameos in TDPI.
"are you robin thicke because get the fuck away from me" LMFAOOO
They teased Mal in Revenge of the island. There’s a scene where you can see Mal standing in the background for a split second.
Wow, I feel like I'd rather watch your version, especially with a female VS female finale since here in the USA, Heather is the only female to ever win.
2:45
DONT THINK I DONT RECOGNIZE THAT BACKGROUND MUSIC.
SIMS 2 DS IS MY JAM.
RIGHT?... some songs are so boppy!!!
If you still willing to do total drama plz make a tier list. I would ❤ to see it.😀
I have done one very recently... legit watch all my videos
@@dramaticScar okay then. Thanks.😁
Pleasantly surprised! Everybody dunks on All Stars without giving a realistic way to improve it! Loved your rewrite! Well done! 👏
Alright I'm gonna be honest.
IMO, Mal's existence is justified because having the main antagonist be one of the Villainous Vultures would be boring as hell.
My cast -
Heroic Hamsters:
Owen
Harold
Cody
Mike
Cameron
Brick
Leshawna
Sierra
Beth
Lindsay
Zoey
Villianous Vultures:
Gwen
Heather
Courtney
Izzy
Jo
Anne Maria
Alejandro
Duncan
Justin
Scott
Lightning
What do u think?
Wow. Your suggestions were awesome!
NO!... YOU ARE AWSOME!!!
@@dramaticScar lol ok
You made the season iconic 😂😂 good final 2
personally i like zoey and mike but all stars always just felt off, i felt that all the characters weren't written as good as the other series they were in. though i wouldve loved if the second generation of total drama contestants got more time in a new season. some of them couldve gotten more screentime and character development and now im going stop typing because thats too much time spent on a two year old total drama video 😭
Dramactic Scar: i dont like those characters (refering to zoey and mike)
Total Drama Ricky: AM I A JOKE TO YOU
jo should've gotten more screentime as an antagonist
Love this!!! So much better!!!
I would have had all stars be a bigger season and with twenty caste members, ten from each generation:
OGS: Gwen, Leshawna, Heather, Lindsay, Courtney, Duncan, Alejandro, Geoff, DJ, & Trent
REVENGE: B, Brick, Cameron, Mike, Scott, Dawn, Zoey, Jo, Anne Maria, Dakotazoid
Sam made it further than Dawn, so he's objectively more of an All-Star.
Great video! I really like the way you fixed the problems with this season. The only thing I'd change is that I'd make Scott one of the finalists. I agree that Lindsay has been done dirty in every season she's in, but I think Scott deserves it for being so great in All Stars. This would also make it so that there are two finalists from each generation of contestants, which would be really cool.
And if you remember my older comment, I decided to delete it, because it looked like I was trying to show off, and it wasn't even right to begin with. And to add insult to injury, I'm Brazilian, so that comment was made even dumber. I guess I was having a really bad day (I can't say for sure, though). Point is, I shouldn't have written that comment to begin with, so I decided to delete it.
Wait what comment?! it's ok I can take a negative
I’ve always wanted to see courtney, Lindsey, and even Scott win
Yes
Fantastic way to do that:
Lindsay in action finale instead of Beth
Courtney and Scott as all stars finale
My 13 all stars:
Same ones in it:
Courtney
Lindsay
Zoey
Scott
Alejandro
Heather
New All Stars
Dawn
Lashawna
Brick
Owen
Beth
Izzy
Cody
Elim order:
13. Scott
12. Alejandro
11. Owen
10. Izzy
9. Beth
8. Heather
7. Brick
6.Lashawna
5. Dawn
4. Courtney
3. Cody
2. Lindsay
1. Zoey
Or
3. Lindsay
2. Zoey
1. Cody
Or
3. Zoey
2. Cody
1. Lindsay
I would also love to see a Dawn Lindsay finale
it's definetly good character choices, but I would switch Beth with noah
Andriana Semeniuc Noah’s a bit overrated, also he would’ve been in RR after this and PI
@@apple8104 true, I wouldn't call him overrated, but it is your opinion which I respect
Dawn and Izzy aren't really All-Stars though. I mean, Sam made it further than Dawn and Izzy is just not as prominent as Harold or DJ.
*cries in corner of better than Dawn*
4:33 *duncan and courtney, what the pencil are you doing*
6:46 *search for mal in in turkish and get yourself surprised*
Yes Mal is a big fat mal
@@dramaticScar 4:33 is still hilarious though
@@duncanchillake8024 ahah many thanks !!!!!
gOoDs-
@Ethan Constantinescu and gwen is telling them to stop recording it lol
This season should have used Sierra being a hyper fan to make her the biggest asset. She knows these people and this show, she gets so obsessed she saps the fun out of it and has to learn it’s just a game, not life or death (yes Chris is still the host, but you get what I mean).
Gwuncan break up is the best thing of this season tho
I like how you changed it but I would suggested you don’t vote Duncan out so early in the game
Why?
@@dramaticScarI don't care how much you hate him, he has purpose in every season, and the sendoff you gave him was hardly better than his canon sendoff (which also sucked horribly).
@@dramaticScar dude was literally written to be his absolute worst in All Stars, honestly you could make an episode comparing how he acts in Island and Action, compared to WT and As, but despite bad writing, he was still way more entertaining than most of the other characters and storylines they had in all stars
great vid my dude i agrre with everything you said but i wished some charathers got a chncae to shine
Yey positive feedback.
@@dramaticScar yup plus i wnat brick dawn harold izzy trent and many orthers get a chncae they dersvse to win somehting
incredible we love it
Lindsay is my favorite character so your version already won some points. however, I will also add that this is a much better version of what we actually got. The TD writers should hire you.
I know you probably don’t care but I made a version of all stars, I did relationships, drama, more drama, but still kept the spirit(I think). Even if you don’t care, could you at least take a look? I don’t expect you too but it’d be cool.
MY VERSION OF THE SEASON, full season with relationships, etc:
Cast, these are all categorized into teams.
Geoff, Leshawna, Duncan, Heather, Gwen, Owen
Mike, Jo, Scott, Zoey, Lightning, Mike
Scarlett, Max, Jasmine, Sugar, Sky, Shawn
20th: Cameron(The more villainous side of the team realized how big of a threat the trio of Mike, Zoey, and Cameron were so decided they needed to work together. Cameron was the weakest one so they agreed to vote him in order to guarantee winning the tiebreaker. The trio voted out Scott and, predictably, a tie breaker happened. Scott easily one making Cameron the first boot)
19th: Max(Scarlett went through intense therapy after Pakithew, becoming sane again. She struggled to prove herself to her team to avoid elimination, when they lost pretty quickly Scarlett figured she’d be out so she went to a last resort. She tricked Max into thinking he’s better than everyone else and was super egotistical, in a 4-2 vote, Scarlett’s strategy saved her)
18th: Lightning(Basically the same reason as before but slightly different, Scott and Jo figured they could beat Mike or Zoey in a tiebreaker so they decided to boot the biggest threat, Lightning)
17th: Duncan(He started to miss Courtney which made Gwen insecure about the challenge, Geoff realized this and confronted Duncan about it who was a huge jerk about it. Geoff, who realizes this isn’t a healthy relationship like him and Bridgette had to tell Gwen about everything. She ain’t having none of that and in a familiar scene with swapped roles, Heather tells everyone to vote for Duncan. Nice callback to season one but just with it being Heather showing how much she’s developed)
16th: Sky(Scarlett, now not evil, had her head in the game at this point. She realized how much of an obvious boot she’d be so after a bit of strategical thinking, she allies with Jasmine who also gets Shawn on her side, Sky and Sugar were left as the odd ones out but Sky was a much bigger threat. Sugar and Sky were both surprised that Sky was out)
15th: Mike(Without Mal he has no purpose this season, just saying. Jo and Scott knew that Mike was the teams biggest asset but also the biggest threat in the whole game, they decided to team up to boot him out. Scott, once more, got bottom 2 but managed to win the tiebreaker anyway because he didn’t want to leave this early due to a certain girl who isn’t revealed yet)
14th: Owen(The pancake challenge with the mad skillz obstacle course is in this episode, the same scenario with Sam happens but this time it’s Owen. Simple elimination. The immunity idol is already known to be on bony island and Scott is sent to bony island)
13th: Zoey(She started being friends with Gwen but with her being outnumbered by Jo and Scott, she had no chance. Scott reveals to the cast that there is no immunity idol and that he looked everywhere. Chris, who doesn’t know what to do about this, starts setting up the playroom challenge)
12th: Jasmine(Scarlett is receiving strange love letters from I quote, an ‘Intellectual inferior’ but doesn’t know who. Anyway, the Pakithew team actually has great coordination in the playroom challenge and the invincibility idol is found. Sugar realized how badly she’s outnumbered and decided she had too do something about it. Sugar intentionally throws the challenge and rigs the votes to get out Jasmine, the biggest threat on the team)
*ALEJANDRO DEBUTS BECAUSE CHRIS WANTS DRAMA*
11th: Sugar(Scarlett realizes what happens with the votes and reveals it too everyone, making Sugar the common enemy. Even Heather says “Now that’s low, not that I’m not impressed, but still.”. Scott starts to struggle socially, wanting to ask out the now revealed crush, Scarlett but not knowing what to even say. Leshawna, Geoff, and Gwen form a likely alliance, did I make a crackship with Scott and Scarlett? I needed a new relationship to add, sry)
*SKY RETURNS*
11th: Shawn(Sky is back and furious of her elimination, she goes against everyone as a wild card deciding that this will be her season. She decides to take out her old team who she has the most beef with first. Scott asks Scarlett out and she’s kind of taken by surprise by it, showing non-evil or intelligent emotion. Scarlett accepts and the two form an alliance along with starting to date. Alejandro learns who has the idol)
10th: Gwen(Jo notices that literally no one on the island has beef with Gwen except for Heather, realizing how she could manipulate this situation she decides to work with Heather to boot Gwen. Sky votes for Jasmine. Jasmine doesn’t realize this and vote for Scott. Scarlett decides Gwen is a strategical threat and votes for her, Jo and Heather vote for Gwen. Alejandro votes Gwen too since he can’t manipulate her successfully. Gwen and Leshawna vote for Shawn. Geoff votes for Jo, this chaos in the voting system happened to dump Gwen out of the game)
9th: Heather(Heather, being a strong competitor is an obvious threat to Jo. Jo, knowing this, decides to take her out while her guard is lowered. Meanwhile, Heather is convincing everyone to vote for Alejandro because she had the immunity idol and knows that she’ll be safe so all she needs is a few votes. Alejandro is meant to get eliminated but, with the help of Jo, stole Heathers idol and directs season ones villain to the flush of shame)
No one: (Reward challenge episode more focused on developing the characters, Geoff starts to miss Bridgette, Sky’s need for vengeance continues, etc.)
8th/7th: Sky and Geoff(Jo plays on Sky’s rage, manipulating her into constantly screwing up the challenge for her and the other contestants. Meanwhile, Leshawna tries to get Alejandro out because of what happened in world tour. Scarlett and Scott make a surprisingly good couple, they don’t overstep and seem understanding of each other’s boundaries which makes them popular to the viewers as well. Geoff begins to miss Bridgette even more which hinders him in the challenge, eventually he decides to quit during the elimination. Sky is a huge threat and she’s clearly being a jerk to everyone so she gets voted out. Scarlett starts to realize a pattern with the eliminations, Jasmine begins to step back into the game after Shawn was booted)
6th: Alejandro(Jo realizes how dangerous Scarlett is as an opponent and decides she needs to get her out. Meanwhile, the challenge is similar to the very episode Leshawna got manipulated by Alejandro in world tour but this time she’s having none of it, she beats Alejandro similar to Heather in S3. We get a glimpse to the aftermath show where Heather cheers at the live footage of Alejandro getting beaten up, just for laughs from. The viewers I add this. Jo votes for Scarlett. Scarlett and Scott vote for Alejandro who’s proven a huge threat, Alejandro votes for Scarlett knowing she already has a voter. Jasmine who doesn’t really know Alejandro that well decides he can be dismissed and votes for Scarlett because of what happened in Pakithew. Scarlett and Alejandro are closely matched in the tiebreaker but Scott, anxious on Scarlett getting out interferes secretly, getting Alejandro out, Scott won immunity btw)
5th: Jasmine(Scarlett, after gaining more evidence, confirms Jo’s villainy and exposes what she’s done. Leshawna and Scott work with Scarlett to try and get Jo out of the game. Jasmine realizes that if Jo wins immunity she’s doomed so she tries to sabatige Jo. Jo, however, ends up winning the challenge because Jasmine unintentionally messed up everyone else’s runs in the challenge leaving everyone in an obvious decision who to vote)
4th: Scott(It’s an auto-elimination challenge and Scott loses, simple. Safe order was: Leshawna, Scarlett, Jo, and Scott was last. In a dramatic elimination ceremony, Scott and Scarlett exchange a first kiss before Scott gets the flush of shame. Now we’re down to the final three..)
No one: *Aftermath show where every previous contestant from every season, in all stars or not, all get screen time. They’re voting for who to get an advantage in the final round and Leshawna wins by a large margin, a nice opposite to when she was out in S1)
3rd: Scarlett(She played an ultimately good game but when the time came she couldn’t manage as well as her rivals in the physical challenge, lagging behind everyone else. Leshawna uses her advantage but Jo wins and picks Leshawna, who she thinks is less of a threat)
2nd: Jo(After a very strategical, brutal, and main antagonistic game shes up against Leshawna. I’d do the final challenge very similar with yours as you put here.
Jo is good at the island section, lags behind in action, does well in WT, and excels in ROTI
Leshawna easily passes through island and action but struggles with world tour which gives Jo the lead, she manages to redeem herself by using the junk pile to boost through ROTI. It’s down to Pakithew and...)
1st: Leshawna(Jo’s winning through the Pakithew section, managing to mock Leshawna in the process. Leshawna gets fed up though, unleashing the power we saw in when she beat up Heather in WT and Alejandro previously and pushing ahead at the final moment, winning Total Drama ALL STARS! She is also the canon winner)
I liked this version...
I just missed out where exactly do the teams merge...
Also I don't think Geoff is a brilliant character so I believe I would place Courtney here...
I also liked Scarlett has such a nice character.
I messed that up
They merge at the same time Alejandro debuts, I made a mistake with Jasmine getting eliminated twice as well so I’d probably have to modify this. I really only put Geoff that high though because of what they did in action to his character, I wanted to accomplish two things with this.
1. Develop or re-develop the characters that were previously derailed in island
2. Keep Scott’s development
What characters do you want in all stars
I think the only reason why people like All-Stars is because they like Mike and Zoey and hated Courtney.
I'm glad you commented..
I've started recording me doing a tier list???
Since the idea was yours can I give you credit on my video???
Dramatic Scar I would love to see a Tier List for the Total Drama Characters.
Dramatic Scar And yes you can give me credit too.
Lilothestitch Noahh likes Courtney and dislikes Zoey, so that argument is debunked.
@@uglyfense7754 And Mike?
Awesome video. Since cast changes were left alone, I personally would’ve made it so that it was the final 3 of every season. I feel that objectively fits the whole All-Stars theme way better.
Of course that would only be 12 people so then you add Lindsay and someone else.
Actually only 10... because Heather and Owen were twice the final 3
@@dramaticScar Courtney and Sierra would replace Owen and Heather respectively in Action and World Tour since they came 4th.
Also what if we changed the cast completely
no just no if thats the only choice
The 22 contestants would be
Gen 1: Tyler, Beth, Leshawna, Bridgette, Geoff, Harold, Beth, Noah, Owen, Izzy, Cody
Gen 2: Dawn, Brick, B, Anne Maria, Staci, Dakota
Gen 3: Jasmine, Shawn, Sky, Sugar, Ella
As for the challenges, to me they kind of did feel like old ones.
Episode 1- First challeneg ever
Episode 2- Paris challenge
Episode 3- Paintball challenge
Episode 4- They've eaten gross foods before
Episode 5- Episode 5 of TDI
Episode 6- Egg Hunt from Season 3
Episode 7- Phobia Factor Challenge
Episode 8- Race around the island (I feel like they've done that before)
Episode 9- I guess they've had challenges in the mines before?
Episode 10- They've had obstacle courses before.
Episode 11- We don't talk about this episode (But it has an unrelated challenge)
Episode 12- Pirate Treasure from Season 1
Episode 13- Idk, nothing.
change pahkitew island for all of us, please!
Least I can do for now is 50 things right :)
I think owen didnt compete because he thought he was still am ex competitor and came by in the finale cuz why not
5:10 What about B (Beverley) ?(IDK how to write)
I love the Sims 2 DS music you used at 1:53!
I Said before, and i say it again. Total drama all star is sort spoof of two Survivor season.
All-Stars" and the "Heroes vs. Villains.
Actually I have been investigating about it... I'm glad you gave me that validation
@@dramaticScarand i forgot few more thing
The name of this episode shares the same name as Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains.
Gwen's reaction of being placed on the Villains' team is similar to the reaction of Sandra Diaz-Twine.
And Here some more stuff about that Sandra: She may be hot-tempered and potty-mouthed, but nothing she did on her first season really justified her being placed on the Villains tribe. The fact that she was the mortal enemy of one of the show's most hated villains ever (Jonny Fairplay) should have made her a Hero by itself, and that's not even taking into account how Rupert (who also played this season on the Heroes' side) was one of Sandra's closest allies on Pearl Islands and happily voted for her to win back then. Lampshaded by her when she states she should be with the Heroes, and tries repeatedly (and unsuccessfully) to join their alliance and warn them of each of Russel's plans.
Lindsay's elimination is a reference to Sugar Kiper. Both are blonde females from the Heroes' team who end up being the first contestants voted off the season after being responsible for their team's loss in the challenge and rubbing their fellow teammates the wrong way.