Did People In The Medieval World Believe in Ghosts?| Medieval Afterlife | History Hit

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 9. 04. 2024
  • Ghosts, ghouls and things that go bump in the night! Dr Eleanor Janega delves into the medieval phantasmic to find out what their restless dead can tell us about the worries of the living. Because if we want to understand what makes another society tick, it helps to take a look at what makes them scared.
    In this show, Eleanor visits the ruins of Byland Abbey to explore some of the most terrifying stories to survive the medieval period. The 12 ghostly tales written by a monk on the blank back pages of a religious manuscript, share traits with our own modern ghost stories but we learn that medieval perceptions of ghosts may be very different to our own.
    Then at one of the most important religious sites in medieval England, Canterbury Cathedral, Eleanor investigates how the church uses ghost stories for political gain and reinforcing religious values. Archivist Cressida Williams shows us some of the memento mori tropes implemented by the church, like Cadaver tombs and the ‘Three Living and Three Dead’ Illustrations, which acted as warnings against sin and reminders of the death that awaits us all.
    Eleanor comes face to face with the dead at the University of Bradford, which houses one of the UK's largest collection of human skeletal remains, Dr Jo Buckberry, explains why adhering to proper burial practices were crucial for making it into the afterlife and describes some of the gruesome ways they prevented the revenant dead from rising from the grave to haunt their communities.
    And to complete her journey, Eleanor braves Chillingham Castle, once used as a border stronghold staving off invasion from Scotland, it’s now home to a gathering of ghosts. First recorded over a hundred years ago by Lady Leonora Tankerville in the “golden age of horror” we discover the Victorian and Edwardian obsession with the supernatural… something that haunts us still….
    Discover the past on History Hit with ad-free exclusive podcasts and documentaries released weekly presented by world renowned historians Dan Snow, Suzannah Lipscomb, Lucy Worsely, Mary Beard and more. Watch, listen and read history wherever you are, whenever you want it. Available on all devices: Apple TV, Amazon Prime Video, Android TV, Samsung Smart TV, Roku, Xbox, Chromecast, and iOs & Android.
    We're offering a special discount to History Hit for our subscribers, get 50% off your first 3 months with code CZcams: www.historyhit.com/subscripti...
    #historyhit #medievalhistory #afterlife

Komentáře • 507

  • @ExUSSailor
    @ExUSSailor Před měsícem +478

    I don't think they were "obsessed" with it, I just think they had to deal with death much more than we, in modern society have to.

    • @Yandarval
      @Yandarval Před měsícem +44

      Pre the mass production of penicillin in the 1940s. Almost any cut or infection has a fair chance of killing you. So you are correct about death being something everyone had to deal with on a regular basis.

    • @ellie698
      @ellie698 Před měsícem +13

      Exactly this

    • @jimplummer4879
      @jimplummer4879 Před měsícem +4

      Yes !

    • @PrettyPoppyGirl651
      @PrettyPoppyGirl651 Před měsícem +34

      That is exactly why they were obsessed with death, there were rules, there were steps thats had to be performed & in the correct order, there was no other way to think, only this belief, only this way for a "happy" afterlife, being allowed into heaven. To do anything else was to be damned. So yea, I think obsessed is pretty accurate.

    • @422katieleigh
      @422katieleigh Před měsícem +31

      Eleanor has talked a lot about this and has the degrees and experience to back it up. When she says obsessed, she means obsessed.

  • @jamiebryant1524
    @jamiebryant1524 Před měsícem +307

    Please keep the Eleanor Janega content coming. She’s the perfect combo of super knowledgeable, easy to listen to, and quirky cool. I will watch anything she does!

    • @Me-wk3ix
      @Me-wk3ix Před měsícem +3

      Agreed!

    • @thewhitewolf58
      @thewhitewolf58 Před 25 dny +7

      Quirky, weird women are the best in the world.

    • @ColleenLytle-sq8tx
      @ColleenLytle-sq8tx Před 23 dny +4

      I agree, Dr. Eleanor Janega is the best woman narrator I've heard, next to Caitlin Doughty...as a matter of fact, I thougtht this WAS her until I looked.😁

    • @XlrationMedia
      @XlrationMedia Před 18 dny +1

      "Fronce"

    • @jolenaroe3001
      @jolenaroe3001 Před 18 dny

      Same!!

  • @Tadicuslegion78
    @Tadicuslegion78 Před měsícem +302

    "I'm not dead."
    "I can't take him like that. It's against regulations."
    "I don't want to go on the cart."

  • @oliviasayshi7517
    @oliviasayshi7517 Před měsícem +27

    She has the same intonations as Caitlyn Dougherty! Also amazing host!

    • @randibgood
      @randibgood Před 8 dny +2

      This video was the first recommended while watching the most recent one Caitlyn released. Then I saw your comment.
      I guess that's just a coincidence, or not. I've never watched a video from this channel.
      Things that make you go "hmmm"!
      LoL! 🤣

    • @RudePorker
      @RudePorker Před 5 dny

      Our creepy queens ❤️

    • @tremorsfan
      @tremorsfan Před 2 dny

      @@randibgood That's the algorithm for you.

  • @Air-bear
    @Air-bear Před měsícem +135

    Gadfly here 🤫. I was in the Vietnam conflict. I had a hard time sleeping in the jungle. Not due to the environment it seems. I mentioned this to a Vietnamese scout who was with us. He said my soul was in distress. That I should sleep facing the east when I arose. Said my spirit would know it faced the light. It worked…still set my bed accordingly 😑

    • @hillerymcdonald2303
      @hillerymcdonald2303 Před měsícem +14

      This is fascinating. What a cool story! Thank you for your service and sacrifice, truly, thank you.

    • @wretchedrider2157
      @wretchedrider2157 Před měsícem +6

      Hear hear!! Great story and my genuine thanks for your service 🍻

    • @shelbynamels7948
      @shelbynamels7948 Před měsícem +1

      Poppycock! Nothing to do with facing the light.
      You need to align the meridians of your body with the magnetic field of the earth.
      Our bed is set accordingly.

    • @Air-bear
      @Air-bear Před měsícem +3

      @@shelbynamels7948 gadfly here 👻. You know much about the ancient sun worshipers. 😵

    • @briganja
      @briganja Před měsícem +6

      Placebo effect is pretty amazing! Our brains influence our bodies so much

  • @beepboop204
    @beepboop204 Před měsícem +104

    it has always fascinated me, that fine line between "wanting to die" and being completely fine with dying, as opposed to "not wanting to die" and not accepting mortality.

    • @user-ug2hk3go6i
      @user-ug2hk3go6i Před měsícem +8

      I suspect that many claims of being fine with dying may fail when the claimant is dying.

    • @debbylou5729
      @debbylou5729 Před měsícem +9

      @@user-ug2hk3go6iI think you’re probably right. I do think the manner or circumstances make the difference. I’ve had family dying of old age or chronic illness feel it coming and embrace it. I also don’t believe we’re left alone. I’ve heard one aunt and my grandmother say things like, ‘oh, they’ve come’. My grandmother was almost radiant and called her husband by name

    • @beepboop204
      @beepboop204 Před měsícem +4

      @@user-ug2hk3go6i being alive is the same as dying. thats what being mortal is all about. so no, i dont think so

    • @abnurtharn2927
      @abnurtharn2927 Před měsícem +5

      @@beepboop204 “You will die. You will not live forever. Nor will any man nor any thing. Nothing is immortal. But only to us is it given to know that we must die. And that is a great gift: the gift of selfhood. For we have only what we know we must lose, what we are willing to lose... That selfhood which is our torment, and our treasure, and our humanity, does not endure. It changes; it is gone, a wave on the sea. Would you have the sea grow still and the tides cease, to save one wave, to save yourself?”

    • @user-ug2hk3go6i
      @user-ug2hk3go6i Před měsícem

      @@beepboop204 I'd say being alive is a rather different condition than dying.

  • @katebowers8107
    @katebowers8107 Před měsícem +87

    Divining rods:
    A method of not finding water that can also be used to not find ghosts.

    • @user-ug2hk3go6i
      @user-ug2hk3go6i Před měsícem +9

      Ah! Now that's the spirit!

    • @debbylou5729
      @debbylou5729 Před měsícem +9

      My BIL used a dousing rod to find water for a well on his property. He had hired several ‘experts’ that told him he’d need to make arrangements on adjoining or nearby property owners. This guy was as pragmatic as a person could be. A history teacher who taught in the jr college nearby. Goes to church etc. I watched him do it and it was really interesting to see. It was ‘Y’ shaped and when water was indicated it bent at a 45 degree angle it wasn’t just a quiver or shaking. It was straight out and then it was pointing straight down while the two parts in his hand remained straight

    • @katebowers8107
      @katebowers8107 Před měsícem +6

      Cool story, bro.

    • @user-ug2hk3go6i
      @user-ug2hk3go6i Před měsícem +6

      @@debbylou5729 It seems a surveyor's map would be a sound way to locate water.
      The fact the douser was a teacher and church goer are not relevant to dousing being effective or not.

    • @debbylou5729
      @debbylou5729 Před měsícem +6

      @@user-ug2hk3go6i I was establishing his character. This is not a fanciful, deluded man. In your wisdom you completely missed the fact that he used several experts. These were surveys done by geologists and people with knowledge of water tables and mapping of the geographical area

  • @Aspen7780
    @Aspen7780 Před měsícem +52

    I grew up with a mix of Native American and Catholic beliefs. As a result, my understanding from the Catholic side was to welcome death, embrace it, even look forward to it. That it’s unfortunate that we have to live a life because it interferes with our whole goal, which is to dwell with god in the afterworld. The life in the here and now really means little. This life only exists to prepare us for the next one and our actions in life will determine that. Because you don’t want to go to the Other Place. Our Native teachings (I’ll only say it’s from the Southwest) on the other hand taught that, you don’t think about those things unless you want them to actually happen. That to dwell so much on death and suffering was to invite it to happen because thoughts can induce action. So don’t worry so much about the afterlife because 1)it exists, and 2) we really don’t know what form it will take so 3) It will take care of itself, and 4) there really isn’t a punishment of sorts there except for the absolute worst of beings. Live for now. That doesn’t give you permission to go all crazy, but enjoy your life right now and all the blessings in it and don’t worry so much about what tomorrow brings. Death will come eventually so don’t hasten it. If anyone was obsessing or focused on death, they were sick in the heart. A sickness of the soul so to speak. Maybe akin to depression. Literally killing themselves with their own thoughts. I had a couple of devout Catholic relatives who would say “I don’t know why god hasn’t taken me yet” feeling like being left alive in old age was a form of punishment. Even praying for god to take them. I respect that, but I could never understand it. But then, I have never ascribed to the whole preparing for the afterlife is the whole point of living. A sort of purgatory in life. I have always preferred every day is a gift to be enjoyed. You can see the missionaries had a lot of work to do to make us good Catholics and focus on death.

    • @gnostic268
      @gnostic268 Před měsícem +11

      I'm also Native (Northern Great Plains) and was raised in a Christian liturgical tradition since the Freedom of Religion Act didn't happen until 1978. Our traditional cultural beliefs are that there is no difference between this world and the next other than if you weren't a good member of your people/tribe then you would have to go back and try again in the next world. However, there was no punishment such as hell, there would simply be another chance to get it right.

    • @Aspen7780
      @Aspen7780 Před měsícem +5

      @@gnostic268 The same for us too. Our traditions for down here is that the next place is a mirror image of this world. The only actual punishment being reserved for those being, the popular pan Native term “two hearted”, if you believe in those things. But for everyone else it’s a birth into another world, like our current one. I really don’t know if our concept of that “punishment” is really indigenous either or is it Christianity seeping into the Native religion. Anyways, lots in common!

    • @cynhiacations9879
      @cynhiacations9879 Před měsícem +1

      ​@@gnostic268this is the belief I have. To get it right to then move to the next level to get that level right.

    • @MFLimited
      @MFLimited Před 11 dny +2

      I really enjoyed reading your comment. I disagree that being raised as a Catholic is to be, basically a goth, focused on death 😂 perhaps that’s true of some older depressed people in certain Roman Catholic traditions? Definitely not the charismatic ones!I’m Anglican Catholic, Church of England. I’m currently living at a friary (a place with Franciscan Friars/monks), and life is very joyful here. There is zero obsession about death. There is a lot of spirituality and prayer. A lot of joy. Praying on the roof, playing music, having bonfires, planting crops and flowers, brewing beer, doing things with nearby communities, family camps, guests on retreat.
      So, I have no idea what you’re talking about. But I did find it interesting. Personally, I think about life and death. Death is inevitable, I may as well look forward to it. Why live in fear of it? But it does not mean I can’t revel in every moment here. Life is a gift.
      Old and very sick people I have known, who have prayed for death, have often been in terrible pain. I cannot judge them for not living in the moment, when they are suffering. I am happy they believe that their suffering will end and they will go somewhere better. From life to Afterlife.
      If I lived in Medieval Europe and there was plague and infant mortality at massive rates. Where 36% of women died in childbirth and childbirth related illnesses and somebody could have 20 children and lose them all to childhood illnesses easily. where small crimes could see you publicly executed in the most hideous ways. Can you imagine the depression you would be in? Life expectancy was 33. You’d have to be crazy not to think about death in that situation.

    • @Aspen7780
      @Aspen7780 Před 11 dny +3

      @@MFLimited the Catholicism I was exposed to growing up was much more fire and brimstone than your experience. And filled with “you have to do this or you have to do that…or else…”
      And the 2nd commandment condemned our traditions, our history, our ancestors, our ways and couldn’t be tolerated by the Church.
      We still live in the shadow of Spanish/Catholic colonialism. Submit to the king at the point of a sword and kneel or be hit over the head with the cross. We have stories of the first church being built by forced labor with laborers falling dead from exhaustion. Of traditional healers being executed or flogged at the insistence of priests attempting to stamp out all vestiges of our traditions. Of young girls being separated from their families and sent against their will to Mexico to become nuns so as to not learn our traditional ways, to be “saved”, and never to be heard from ever again. It’s hard to separate the actions of conquistadors from that of the church. It was all done in the name of a king and a pope. But it all led to the Pueblo Revolt of 1680. It might be ancient history for many people, but we here still live in its shadows over here.
      I do have respect for people of faith. I myself had too many questions and the way I thought about things and my own personal philosophies had no place in the Church. I couldn’t forsake our traditional culture heroes for saints. Our history and our religion are entwined. To become a true good catholic would mean to forsake our grandparents and their grandparents and our history. So confirming to strict Catholic doctrine wasn’t my thing. At best I was a cafeteria Catholic. There are still some Catholic teachings and traditions that I cherish though. And I do have greater respect for the Catholic Church over other Christian religions.

  • @user-fh6ov3wl4h
    @user-fh6ov3wl4h Před 8 dny +3

    Richard seems like absolutely the coolest guy one ever could meet

  • @jiwik731
    @jiwik731 Před měsícem +81

    There is nothing like ghosts.... i have been visiting that castle for more than 300 years and i have never seen a single one.

    • @debbylou5729
      @debbylou5729 Před měsícem +13

      Maybe they just don’t like you. That’s a long time to be shunned

    • @theaxe6198
      @theaxe6198 Před měsícem +6

      Nice one 😂

    • @ankhpom9296
      @ankhpom9296 Před měsícem +1

      Uh huh.

    • @ankhpom9296
      @ankhpom9296 Před měsícem +1

      The dowsing rods…I don’t believe.

    • @debbylou5729
      @debbylou5729 Před měsícem +2

      @@ankhpom9296 I don’t care. Guarantee you’ll try it if you’ve been without water for a few days

  • @mikki3961
    @mikki3961 Před měsícem +84

    If your life was fraught with danger, a fever or cut could kill you then an obsession with death is rather logical. To top it off, insufferable priests and officials telling you that you were a sinner just because you happened to be poor or lower class. Thanks Dr. Janega as always you present with respect and genuine enthusiasm.

  • @k.edwards3138
    @k.edwards3138 Před měsícem +83

    I love watching Dr Janega. She makes history interesting and, in some ways, exciting, and her enthusiasm is contagious. I've always loved history, but the demands of life have made me neglect reading and learning. Thanks to Dr Janega, I've started learning again about a subject I love.

  • @sharonkaczorowski8690
    @sharonkaczorowski8690 Před 16 dny +2

    As a kid in the Southern and Southwest US in the 50s and 60s I heard soooo many ghost stories…including a family ghost from the Civil War. According to the story a female ancestor whose husband was away fighting for the Confederacy came upon a Union soldier trying to steal her cow, whose milk was a big part of what little they had to eat. Being one of my female ancestors she shot him dead…lots of tough women. Supposedly, were any descendants to visit where she lived…location unknown…the man’s ghost would appear, demanding “where’s MY milk!!!” Other stories were far more scary, especially La Llorana, the Crying Woman.

  • @richardprescott6322
    @richardprescott6322 Před měsícem +18

    Couple of of my favourite paintings as, a kid - Bruegel - The Triumph of Death - lots of 'Skelingtons' running amock.
    Bosch - and his visions of hell - I think they are awesome.
    I got the prints recently and had them framed. I think the woman who framed thought I was insane. 😂

  • @kayscanningacademy
    @kayscanningacademy Před měsícem +5

    Some of these visions that folks had back then makes me feel like taking a too hot bath after having some bad rye bread is such a recipe....

  • @golden_smaug
    @golden_smaug Před 22 dny +4

    Dr Janega has got me deep in Medieval Litterature and history, she's so contagious

  • @cameronturner1865
    @cameronturner1865 Před měsícem +13

    Clicked on this as soon as I saw Dr. Janega. Love her appearances on The Medieval Podcast

  • @Gaeliclass
    @Gaeliclass Před měsícem +7

    Can you imagine if you had a severe injury or disease that was quite painful? You might want to die if you had no pain relief. A peasant with back problems, but they had to continue to plow the fields so their family wouldn't survive?

  • @brettcurtis5710
    @brettcurtis5710 Před měsícem +33

    Dr Eleanor Janega nails its again - wish I had teachers like her when I was at High School - so informative and with a sense of humour too!

  • @lukestratford
    @lukestratford Před 13 dny +3

    Eleanor is great! Love her documentaries ❤

  • @newgabe09
    @newgabe09 Před měsícem +5

    You feature Canterbury Cathedral..I'm quite sensitive to places and have sometimes 'seen and known' murders/deaths that have happened in a place- as verified by people who know the history of the place. Canterbury Cathedral filled me with chills of horror as soon as I entered, I had to leave straight away.

    • @dulciemidwinter1925
      @dulciemidwinter1925 Před 16 dny +2

      That's such a shame. Canterbury is a beautiful place. I go there quite a lot. Of course, a terrible murder happened there centuries ago, but don't forget that it then became a place of pilgrimage. Many, many pilgrims passed through those doors to visit the shrine of the saint. The monks may have regarded them as a money making commodity but the pilgrims themselves were making that journey because they wanted to be near to the Saint. I think that all that devotion has cancelled out any negative residual emotions. I find it a place of great peace and calm. Its not frightening at all.

  • @jfurl5900
    @jfurl5900 Před měsícem +12

    Purgatory was a real place to me as a child . The teachers pounded it into us verbally and literally that we would be going there and that we would be there for many thousands of years unless somebody was praying for us (on the outside) or among the living in other words.

    • @catlyn777
      @catlyn777 Před měsícem

      Me too and I was very confused by it.

    • @jujubean54ify
      @jujubean54ify Před 16 dny +1

      Aren’t you glad that you found out that there is no purgatory?

    • @BenBebbington
      @BenBebbington Před 2 dny +1

      ​@@jujubean54ifyPURGATORY IS REAL I know because I have seen it (a Lincolnshire village on a Sunday)

    • @jujubean54ify
      @jujubean54ify Před dnem

      That’s hilarious !!!!!

  • @user-uj7dm8jy6z
    @user-uj7dm8jy6z Před 5 dny +2

    back in the 70's my gran told me several scary ghost stories that still creep me out now

  • @billquinn6224
    @billquinn6224 Před měsícem +4

    I think it was because death was around them all the time and they developed a mind set that sooner or later death was going to knock on their door.
    Anyone who has been in combat has the feeling that somewhere out there, there is a bullet with your name on it and you stick around too long and that bullet will definitely find you.

  • @monicafiore20
    @monicafiore20 Před 12 dny +1

    Dr. Janega is the MAIN reason I watch History Hit! She's funny, so knowledgeable and super relatable! Please make more shows with her as the host 🙏

  • @myrollingpeach
    @myrollingpeach Před 19 dny +4

    Dr Janega is brilliant! I loved her book on women in the Medieval era too!

  • @commiebiogirl
    @commiebiogirl Před měsícem +65

    I'm a simple girl : I see Dr Eleanor, I click the video

  • @dereks1264
    @dereks1264 Před měsícem +22

    "...a tailor named snowball..."? There must be a story attached to that name.

    • @theaxe6198
      @theaxe6198 Před měsícem +2

      My favorite name - Seaxwulf

    • @jasonrr9817
      @jasonrr9817 Před měsícem +1

      In the original story a bunny had an encounter with a phantom hedgehog, but it was just NOT getting anyone to cough up silver to get holy men to shuffle ghostly paperwork. A few edits were necessary.

    • @AnthonyOMulligan-yv9cg
      @AnthonyOMulligan-yv9cg Před 16 dny +1

      I've known a few Snowballs......a Northern English and Scottish Surname

    • @alexandertreadgold3874
      @alexandertreadgold3874 Před 8 dny

      You can read the full story itself in The Tale of the Taylor and the Three Dead Kings

  • @Voodoomaria
    @Voodoomaria Před měsícem +17

    With lifespans less than half the current and medical care that could double as the Spanish Inquisition [didn't expect that, did you?], when something as small as a bug bite, as innocuous as drinking a cup of water, or as universally common as giving birth could lead to a horrible demise, it's not at all surprising that death was ever present on their minds.
    If you live in a house full of scorpions, then scorpions are going to occupy an inordinate amount of your thoughts.

    • @maryanneslater9675
      @maryanneslater9675 Před 18 dny +5

      One has to remember that short lifespan is the average lifespan. While a lot of people died of hard work, injury, illness or other hardships before age 60, quite a few lucky people did live long lives. Infant and child mortality lower the average considerably.

    • @SadisticSenpai61
      @SadisticSenpai61 Před 10 dny +1

      Considering that half of all children born died before they reached the age of 1 year old, that does have a rather big impact on the "average lifespan."

    • @bilindalaw-morley161
      @bilindalaw-morley161 Před 2 dny

      Take my "like" just for the Inquisition! It was, indeed, totally unexpected

    • @bilindalaw-morley161
      @bilindalaw-morley161 Před 2 dny

      ​@@maryanneslater9675Yes, statistics have a lot of responsibility for misunderstandings and over-simplifications. It's quite annoying that the false "information" is so stubbornly entrenched that you cannot convince those spouting it, because they "read a book once"...Now, of course, it's "I saw a TikTok once"

    • @Voodoomaria
      @Voodoomaria Před 2 dny

      I'm well aware that Stats lie, Numbers can be made to say pretty much anything you want to say, HOWEVER the mortality in that era WAS far higher than it is today
      What does it matter that it was infant mortality, OR the mother dying in child birth? The KEY point is, "HIGHER MORTALITY".
      You think saying "Oh it was just babies driving the numbers up" makes it any BETTER?
      So what's the infant mortality rate in MODERN hospitals? What's the mortality rate of modern mothers on the delivery table/chair?
      LOWER.
      Today people CAN treat what seem to be simple ailments with a round of pills and one and done, it's gone.
      Those SAME minor ailments in the absence of modern medical care CAN become lethal very quickly.
      In my work, I and a workmate scraped our skin, I on my knee, they on their arm.
      Just a scrape, a shallow surface abrasion, the kind EVERY kid gets growing up.
      I got treated, he didn't.
      Staph infection later, he was within HOURS of losing his arm [My leg had ballooned, but I got antibiotics as soon as the swelling started].
      Untreated, it COULD have killed him [or me].
      From a minor skin abrasion [AND in a modern environment, WITH modern first aid AND sanitary conditions].
      Now we HAD access to modern treatments.
      In the era we are discussing they did not.
      Diabetes was still a thing back then, How many diabetics made it out of childhood?
      Asthma, also a thing, aggravated by heating your home with poorly ventilated wood fired, How many of those survived?
      Allergies anyone?
      Or Influenza?
      Here's a fun one, Ergot Fungus.
      In damper weather it grew on their grain crops and LOOKED like the grain it was growing on.
      Not in and of it's self immediately lethal, BUT contains the principle chemicals of LSD.
      Imagine the mortality resulting from entire villages tripping out after eating their rye bread.
      The judicial murders that occurred due to THAT are well documented.
      People THESE days watch too many movies and think the ONLY difference between us and that era was the fashions, Poor cell phone reception, and horses instead of cars.

  • @barryallenflash1
    @barryallenflash1 Před 15 dny +2

    I watched a LOT of "ghost" videos, but none were as GREAT as this one! Thank you for all the knowledge that you shared and I and others now have!

  • @bringmethatcoffee5235
    @bringmethatcoffee5235 Před 14 dny +3

    you have a very.. calming(?) voice. i really enjoyed listening to you. will definitely check out more from this channel.

  • @vincentbono5176
    @vincentbono5176 Před 15 dny +1

    Some CZcams creators just sit in front of a wall with some nice lighting, but this video takes place on the set of Winterfell from the looks of it haha, that's fantastic dedication ❤

  • @devinshirekineally3721
    @devinshirekineally3721 Před 12 dny +2

    what a delightful program! well presented, entertaining and informative; just an all around wonderful job... thank you!

  • @amywebb4586
    @amywebb4586 Před 14 dny +1

    Absolutely loved this. I am in mortuary school & I love history so the history of death & burial was really interesting. Also, you give Jamie Lee Curtis vibes, I mean that in a good way.

  • @ricksmith5315
    @ricksmith5315 Před měsícem +8

    Love watching all your videos. Especially durning the Medieval period. You make it very interesting and informative. I have always been interested in this period. Thank you for all the content.

  • @petetirp9776
    @petetirp9776 Před měsícem +7

    Terrific production and editing. Kudos to the entire team.

  • @mjrchapin
    @mjrchapin Před 16 dny +2

    Amazing video! History, ghost stories, religion, life, death--it's got everything and is extremely well written and produced! More, please!

  • @NorahSweetheart87
    @NorahSweetheart87 Před měsícem +6

    I'd love to see this topic discussed more

  • @robotdeer
    @robotdeer Před měsícem +3

    I'm fairly certain I could watch Dr. Janega talk aboout anything and I'd be like "slay".

  • @joyavanessen3704
    @joyavanessen3704 Před 18 dny +1

    Oh her last words about society expectations...drop Mike gurl! Bam nicely put! Loved this whole video.

  • @jyotivig3666
    @jyotivig3666 Před měsícem +3

    A great talk Dr. Janega, would love to visit the Chillingham Castle.

  • @Steadyeddie3
    @Steadyeddie3 Před měsícem +8

    These ghost stories are awesome, I'd like to see more if possible

    • @ankhpom9296
      @ankhpom9296 Před měsícem

      Even in death there is still politics.

  • @mikecobalt7005
    @mikecobalt7005 Před měsícem +6

    :) Another excellent informative video. Dr Janega is always great at explaining ancient issues in a way everybody can understand and in an interesting manner.

  • @Sauvium1
    @Sauvium1 Před 14 dny +1

    I cannot get over how much Dr. Janega sounds like Caitlyn Doughty (Ask a Mortician). From voice to diction, it’s uncanny. The topic is pretty on point for that channel too and the way my brain was confused every time it wasn’t Caitlyn on the screen made my brain a bit itchy.

  • @ophelias4172
    @ophelias4172 Před 17 dny +1

    I’ve been to Chillingham castle and the stories are epic. If you get the chance you have to visit!!

  • @katbullar
    @katbullar Před 7 dny +1

    There are also depictions of bodily decay in music. The funeral sentences of William Croft are an example of it.

  • @Frank_Nemo
    @Frank_Nemo Před měsícem +4

    History shows that Medieval people were right to be so obsessed with death, especially when you consider that indeed they are now all dead. So, they were right on the money on that one.

  • @Jay-ql4gp
    @Jay-ql4gp Před měsícem

    I love this! Thank you so much!

  • @JaynaeMarieXIV
    @JaynaeMarieXIV Před dnem

    I love it! This was an awesome documentary. I have to get this channel because I am obsessed with history and would probably binge-watch everything on it.

  • @wellingtonsboots4074
    @wellingtonsboots4074 Před měsícem +2

    Thank you, enjoyed that interesting video

  • @robertweeks4240
    @robertweeks4240 Před 12 dny +1

    i make it a point to visit cemeteries when i'm on a roadtrip.... very interesting local history wherever you are travelling!

  • @victoriamartin9872
    @victoriamartin9872 Před 7 dny

    Wow! Fascinating and informative. First time hearing so much of this content. Loved it!

  • @starquant
    @starquant Před hodinou

    Extremely interesting. Thank you.

  • @cathrynbyrnes8737
    @cathrynbyrnes8737 Před měsícem +1

    That was good! I’d like to see more shows like this.

  • @Maleni143
    @Maleni143 Před měsícem

    This was fun! Thank you!

  • @zackhalter9571
    @zackhalter9571 Před měsícem +4

    Dr. Janega is the best!🎉

  • @mohammedsaysrashid3587
    @mohammedsaysrashid3587 Před měsícem +3

    It was interesting and thrilled watching introduced about that matter of cathedral enlightenment & clergy influenced on people's outlooks towards death, spiritual stories.. how those stories served churches inside and outside churches ⛪️ walls in medieval terms.

  • @zgburnett
    @zgburnett Před měsícem

    The paranormal investigation show sound affects, brings me back 👻

  • @r.e.tucker3223
    @r.e.tucker3223 Před 9 dny

    Brilliant video.

  • @scorpionic-night
    @scorpionic-night Před měsícem +1

    fascinating video. people haven't changed

  • @richardsoos8902
    @richardsoos8902 Před měsícem

    This was Fantastic!

  • @fishbone470
    @fishbone470 Před 24 dny

    Great video!

  • @Freshnewz10
    @Freshnewz10 Před 14 dny +1

    I believe that people became more obsessed with these modern concepts of ghosts after the Victorian age

  • @sasha1mama
    @sasha1mama Před 15 dny +2

    Ah ain't afeared a' no toast! Ah put butter on 'em. An' eat 'em!

  • @pamelatarajcak5634
    @pamelatarajcak5634 Před měsícem +1

    One thing that I'm noticing in all these tales is an underlying vein of hope. There's hope in each of them and a slighly happy ending. So unlike our ghost stories which always ends more negatively than not. Tolkien's eucatastrophe at work here.

  • @shaggycan
    @shaggycan Před měsícem +1

    24:30 I think it's more likely the marks on the skull come from difficulty mounting it on a spike. That's much more difficult to do than decapitation. Animals were regularly decapitated, but mounting heads wasn't done that someone had a lot of practice doing.

  • @theaxe6198
    @theaxe6198 Před měsícem +3

    I love Janega!

  • @chrisball3778
    @chrisball3778 Před měsícem +2

    'We're all haunted... just by societal expectations'. I.e. the real ghosts were the friends we met along the way...

  • @necroprankster524
    @necroprankster524 Před měsícem

    amazing as alwaysss

  • @oldmanjenkins38
    @oldmanjenkins38 Před měsícem

    In a time when life expectancy was not long (especially for children). It is no surprise you would think about death. From black plagues, civil wars. Heck even a staff infection would kill you! Another great video Dr Janega!

  • @user-ug2hk3go6i
    @user-ug2hk3go6i Před měsícem +1

    I'm always surprised by how much it rained in the Medieval period.

  • @debbralehrman5957
    @debbralehrman5957 Před měsícem

    Thanks guys👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼

  • @gtd-sq2pj
    @gtd-sq2pj Před 17 dny

    Very good!

  • @brakejanco
    @brakejanco Před 13 dny +1

    Dr. Eleanor teaching history in a leopard print fur coat is my Roman Empire.

  • @SceneArtisan
    @SceneArtisan Před 7 dny

    I wonder if Nuke's Top 5 would have anything to say about ghosts in medieval times,.. "What happened next, was, truly chilling!" .. or .. "It did not go well" .. or .. "Did you see it?"

  • @CharleneCTX
    @CharleneCTX Před měsícem +2

    I was listening, rather than watching, this video and was struck by how much Eleanor and Caitlin Doughty sound alike.

  • @ryantrumble4582
    @ryantrumble4582 Před měsícem +1

    entertaining presentation of a creepy subject. thanks

  • @metoo7557
    @metoo7557 Před měsícem +14

    Death was common every day to medieval peasants.. the rulers thought of them as disposable cattle. And treated them accordingly. Their lives had very little value to the rulers, as has been common throughout all of history.

    • @roberth721
      @roberth721 Před měsícem +2

      Can be argued that it hasn't changed.

    • @metoo7557
      @metoo7557 Před měsícem +1

      @@roberth721 It hasn't changed. it's not even arguable.

    • @markaurelius3119
      @markaurelius3119 Před měsícem

      ​@@metoo7557exactly. But we still fight over white-black, right-left.
      When there are only rich and poor. And everything we see was built on greed and in a chase for pleasures

  • @MrBlahblahismyname
    @MrBlahblahismyname Před 13 dny +1

    Dr. Janega can you do an Audible where you read your own book? I loved the book and I am too busy to reread it. Also you have such a unique voice and it would be great to hear the book with your cadence. Especially the humourous bites.

  • @SadisticSenpai61
    @SadisticSenpai61 Před 10 dny

    I think my favorite part of the divining rods segment was watching her hands move. The camera angle made it kinda obvious that she was moving her hands which is what made the rods move.
    It turns out ppl are not very good at holding their hands completely still. There's always a bit of movement and swaying.

    • @SomeoneBeginingWithI
      @SomeoneBeginingWithI Před 4 hodinami

      yep. Also if you're scared (for example if you believe there might be a ghost and are scared of ghosts) then it's natural for your hands to shake a little which would cause the rods to move and confirm your fear.

  • @debralittle1341
    @debralittle1341 Před měsícem +1

    What about those who were thrown into plague pits? Too many died so close together that there wasn't time for individual burials.

  • @natalie_popova
    @natalie_popova Před 27 dny +1

    i love u eleanor janega ❤️ keep her forever

  • @katherinecollins4685
    @katherinecollins4685 Před měsícem

    Interesting video

  • @s.eriksdotter
    @s.eriksdotter Před 9 dny

    More!!

  • @isthattrue1083
    @isthattrue1083 Před 8 dny +1

    That head may had been a trophy brought back from a war. That would explain why the body is missing. Why the blows are in the position they are. Even if they beheaded them because of sins, etc., they still would had been buried with the body.

  • @mhfromnh1421
    @mhfromnh1421 Před měsícem +2

    I have that same scarf!

    • @nymperico
      @nymperico Před měsícem +1

      Is it the Saoirse kufiyah? I thought I recognized it 🤩

  • @sarahwatts7152
    @sarahwatts7152 Před měsícem

    Halloween vibes in April? Yes please!

  • @jojotaylor8079
    @jojotaylor8079 Před měsícem +2

    People still are obsessed with it. it’s the most asked question in the world

  • @franklinowens
    @franklinowens Před měsícem +1

    We got the Halloween episode early this year! 🥳🖤

  • @692ALBANNACH
    @692ALBANNACH Před měsícem +3

    Perhaps because they were so surrounded with it.

  • @bluestarfish95
    @bluestarfish95 Před měsícem +13

    I Love Dr Janega Videos ❤

  • @Crustdaddii
    @Crustdaddii Před měsícem +1

    The Queen we all asked for…Dr. Eleanor Janega. 👑

  • @LiminalLexicon
    @LiminalLexicon Před 10 dny

    "For medieval people purgatory was a kind of hell", pretty sure that most religions still hold that. That was a great theological description of purgatory.

  • @catlyn777
    @catlyn777 Před měsícem +1

    Maybe it was a bit entertaining for some of them like today. I don’t doubt there were ghost hunters and ghost storytellers then, like today. People are still fascinated by ghost stories and the afterlife. I don’t think we’ve changed so much as humans.

  • @ytharper66
    @ytharper66 Před 8 dny +2

    That first ghost story sounds more like the Church extorting money from the people.

    • @mike3f0
      @mike3f0 Před 2 dny +1

      That's the root of "Ghost" stories, yup.

  • @bobdevreeze4741
    @bobdevreeze4741 Před měsícem +4

    It is the one absolute in life. If you are born , you will die. I don't see it as an obsession as much as I see it as a fascination. We know it going to happen..so what is next? Is there a next?

    • @R08Tam
      @R08Tam Před měsícem +1

      No

    • @NanaBren
      @NanaBren Před 7 dny

      Bob, I agree that humans are fascinated by the idea of death and an afterlife. The very uncertainty of when we will die feeds the imagination. If energy cannot truly be destroyed, only transformed, then it is possible that the energy that animates the physical body will be transformed into something else. I personally believe in an afterlife and that it doesn’t matter what religion you believe in or whether you are an atheist. Each person will experience something different. I respect that others believe differently. 😊

  • @SirAntoniousBlock
    @SirAntoniousBlock Před měsícem +1

    Ralph: “The trouble is, are there ghosts, Piggy? Or beasts?
    Piggy: _"Course there aren’t.”_
    Ralph: “Why not?”
    Piggy: _"Cos things wouldn’t make sense, houses and streets, and, TV, they wouldn’t work.”_

  • @myeyeswentdeaf6213
    @myeyeswentdeaf6213 Před 18 hodinami

    23:05 I remember seeing a video once about an executioner who would botch his executions just exactly like that, so it would take three or four hits with the axe to behead the person. I can’t remember his name, but was over there in Great Britain somewhere, and it’s believed he was taking bribes from the family of the condemned’s victims, to make the person who murdered their family members suffer.

  • @xaviervegiard5994
    @xaviervegiard5994 Před měsícem +1

    I love her 🖤

  • @Odanti
    @Odanti Před měsícem

    Change the castle's name to Wakefield's Castle. I like the sound of it.
    ❤️🙏❤️