PHYSICIAN'S FORMULA ORGANIC WEAR vs ILIA TRUE SKIN SERUM FOUNDATION | Wear Test Gone WRONG.
Vložit
- čas přidán 2. 03. 2020
- Welp, this didn't go to plan AT ALL. I'm posting this video to share some unexpected info about Physician's Formula and their new Organic Wear line that made me rethink my entire review.
Physician's Formula Organic Wear Silk Foundation Elixir in Fair: go.magik.ly/ml/unpq/
Physicians Formula Organic Wear Blush in Apricot Glow: go.magik.ly/ml/unpr/
Ilia True Skin Serum Foundation in Formentera: go.magik.ly/ml/unps/
What else is on my face:
Becca Undereye Brightening Corrector: go.magik.ly/ml/unpu/
New Glossier Skywash: glossier.79ic8e.net/kqNeL
Glossier Lidstar: glossier.79ic8e.net/PNN6q
Glossier Boy Brow: glossier.79ic8e.net/X3Yay
Glossier Lip Gloss: glossier.79ic8e.net/z9NKx
Florence By Mills See You Never Concealer in F005: go.magik.ly/ml/rd7y/
Honest Beauty Cream Blushes in Coral Peach: amzn.to/2T2cRoa
Salt New York Creme Tint Pro in Contour: www.saltnewyork.com/?rfsn=374...
I use MagicLinks for all my ready-to-shop product links. Check it out here: bit.ly/34uCpjz
Other Discount Links:
Other Discount Links:
10% off at Glossier: glossier.79ic8e.net/gkoXg
10% off at Thrive Causemetics: prf.hn/l/K9NlQaL
15% off at Farfetch: farfetch.mention-me.com/m/ol/...
10% off at Follain: shrsl.com/1fqs1 Use code KACKIE10
20% off at ICONOLAB: bit.ly/2YV2MJE Use code KACKIE
10% off at Thrive Causemetics: prf.hn/l/K9NlQaL
1 month FREE at Rocksbox: www.talkable.com/x/3I6wPX
$2,500 off your complete smile makeover at The Cosmetic Dentists of Austin: Mention my name on your first call!
FTC disclosure: This video is not sponsored. This video contains affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission for purchases made through my links. - Jak na to + styl
Thank you for always being so transparent!! Can't wait for your pretty fresh review!
MAJOR UPDATE (7/22/20) - Physicians Formula is selling in China, but they are avoiding pre-market testing.
Dang it physician's formula! 😣😡
And i just bought their butter bronzer a few weeks ago. I will finish all my physician formula products and not repurchase them. Not going to throw them away, that would be wasteful. Looks like i need to hit up the milani bronzer now since they are still cruelty free.
So disappointed! 😢😒
"You just blend, until it finds its happy place..." -Kackie Quotes
Thank you for bringing up that they’re not cruelty free anymore! I was waiting for this review from you because I was so interested in this line, and then I saw the news from CFK and was like wtf not another one. So frustrating. But as always thanks for your transparency! Just recently found you and started watching and love your overall aesthetic and personality! Also, always more blush 😂
Aw yay! Yeah it's sad news, but I wanted to tell everyone before they might have spent their money on it! So not cool.
@@kackie any updates on an alternative product?
Wtf, I’m so disappointed physicians formula is no longer cruelty free 🥺😔
Saaaaaaaame
that is so disappointing! why?!?!?!
@@OfficialJaclynSteele I believe they were talking about selling their products in China where animal testing of cosmetic products is MANDATORY & that is not gonna change !! Chinese government showed they might change their policy on it ,but I highly doubt it !! As they got no human rights even !! And they slaughter animals on the streets for foods in China still !!! They kill cats/ dogs in the streets & eat them in February every year !! Very very sad & upsetting !!
For Physician's formula...it's a business company & the country's government creates it's laws ,you can't do anything about that !! Yes,they can choose not to sell in China ,but again it is a business company ,so we can't really blame 'em 100 % ! Besides ," cruelty free " doesn't mean really 100 % cruelty free ,either !! All the laws have loopholes as otherwise they never settle on agreements !! To pass a law ,they need to compromise ! That's how it is !! Think of the endangered species act !!? I am Japanese, so I know Japanese whalers are killing whales for the meats ,not researchs at all !! They know that ,too !!! Otherwise ,that wouldn't have been continuing in the world !!! All they have to do is asking the proof ,documents / reports .SEE ? Cruelty free products are the same in a way ! As if they come up ingredients that there are no datas ,then they'll have to test it !! That's the law !!! See ? And for new kinds foods ,diet products so on & medical claims ,they have to test it on poor animals !! Their ingredients can be tested on animals ,though the company itself doesn't run tests on animals ,but they get cleared to claim as a " cruelty free " brand !! See ? So,we really xan't just blame Physician's formula alone !! And very important to support companies doing a lot good stuffs ,too !! We have to look at the forest not just the trees !!! It's really sad 😔 😟 😢 that some animal testing goes on especially for cosmetics !! But,again they are running business ,not a charity organization, or morally correct company !! We have to change the laws ( you can if you're American ,I am not ),meanwhile vote for the candidates who take this matter seriously & support companies produce healthier ,safer ,animal friendly products ,not to boycott ,or punish 'em !! Boycotts don't work so much !! But ,if you actually buy their products & let 'em know you aren't happy about it ,then they'll listen to you more !!! 💜🥁🐉🎤💞
The cruelty free thing is kind of a grey area. Animal testing in China has gone from mandatory to only testing when there is an issue with a particular product. Physicians Formula have advised the authorities in China that in the unlikely event animal testing should be required, they would pull that product from that region rather than subject it to testing.
Source:
mybeautybunny.com/physicians-formula-is-no-longer-cruelty-free/
Yeah, we discussed this at length on my Instagram. To me, riding the fine lines isn't really enough. But I agree it's a gray area, and I leave that up to the individual.
Thank you so much for this video Kackie! I had no idea either that PF sold out just like MAC and will never purchase anything from them again.
I didn’t know the hair at your crown (regrowth) was your natural color! It’s such a beautiful shade 😁
Queen coming in clutch with the reviews 💚
I got the Undone skin tint from Target. I think it’s a fairly nice product so far.
Physicians formula are subject to post market animal testing in China, not premarket. The USFDA has the exact same policy. So if PF are not cruelty free because they could potentially subject to postmarket testing, every single brand that sells in the US is also not cruelty free, by this logic.
Hey Kackie, thanks for another informative and entertaining video. I was wondering whether you had any thoughts on Flower Beauty by Drew Barrymore? I’m thinking about trying their light illusion foundation and would value your opinion.
I really wanted to review the Physician‘s Formula foundation as well for my channel but if they‘re not cruelty-free I just can‘t do it. As everything is cruelty-free on mine... gosh! But thank you sooooooooo much for letting us all know 🐰
Have you ever tried the tropic skincare customizable palette? I‘m really thinking about buying one. However I can obly find reviews from ambassadors and I want to know wether their products are actually good. It‘s the best ethical customizable palette I‘ve seen.
What shades of the skywash? It's taupe and either cocoa or sienna?
We're the same skin tone and the new/re released Honest Beauty CC cream in the shade fair is EXTREMELY dark and EXTREMELY orange. I bought it last week and was SOOOOOOOOOO excited to try it out and the second I pumped it on the back of my hand major disappointment set in 😕😕 I also picked up some of their new Lit Powder Blushes and they're GORGEOUS. DEFINITELY a dupe for the Becca Luminous Blushes 😊❤😊❤😊
P.S. thank you for noting the castor oil in the Becca under eye corrector. I'd missed that it had that, have been considered trying it, and I have drier under eyes. So that makes me think it might really work for me. Thanks again!😁
You betcha!!
Very confused because they have replied to someone's instagram comment that they are cruelty free but obviously are not if they are selling in China
I used to have ugly natural hair too! When I was young, my hair was straight but then I started coloring my hair and frying it with bleach. When I stopped coloring my hair five-six years ago, I developed this natural kinky inconsistent wave in my hair and I had no idea what was going on. It was this way for a year or two but as I took better care of my hair and stopped coloring it, it (veeeeery slowly) transitioned into a beautiful loose wave! Now I have “curly” hair. Lol my father has curly hair so it made sense that I would too, except for the fact that my hair was straight before. Lol! But maybe this is the start of your curly hair journey! If you’re interested in having curly hair, you could try the curly girl method to help bring them to life!
maybe i will!! thanks :D
Hi Kackie! You mentioned ordering 4 contour pans from Kiki’s makeup line. I’m wondering if you know what the expiration period is for her creme tints. I ordered some and I wanted a few backup pans in case they sell out but I wasn’t sure how long they last 🙂
no idea! haha sorry. she's super responsive though. i'm sure she'd be happy to answer on her IG.
I used the physician’s formula foundation for the first time yesterday and I loved it and it applied wonderfully with a brush as well and also it’s $11.98 at Walmart 👍
Wow, I did not know that they aren't cruelty free either. Thank you for the info.
This is disappointing news about Physicians Formula. I only use one product from them, but I use it almost every day. The Butter Bronzer is my one and only powder bronzer that I’ve found that I love and I hate to have to look for a replacement now. I just don’t understand an established company regressing like this.
I loved the butter bronzer and blush. They both were awesome when I used them. It is sad that the company is not cruelty free anymore. Idk how they can go backwards.
WOW! THATS AWFULof them to say they were cruelty free. I LITERALLY chose this foundation because I looked it up in the store, and it said cruelty free. 😡😡
I wouldn't buy either of these because they have oils in them and that breaks me out, but I watched anyway because I love your personality and informative videos!
I’m so tired of the wilful ignorance of all these brands that use cruelty free greenwashing in their messaging when they 100% know that selling in mainland China in any capacity takes away their right to claim they are cruelty free. If their customers know, of course they know too, and it’s just so insulting to their customers to pretend otherwise. I’ve heard some shady things about Charlotte Tilbury recently too which I really don’t wanna believe 🙈 it makes it so hard to try maintain a cruelty free routine when brands keep moving the goalposts like this 🙈 thanks for the video Kackie, you’re right, it was great to hang out and watch even if it didn’t turn out as you hoped 🧡
Feeling bamboozled by a brand’s cruelty free status is the worst! I’ve seen lots of brands claim to be cruelty free who sell in China and I feel like a lot of those slip under the radar.
I also got the cute baby mini palette bundle during the presale and I’m so excited to try those creme tints! 💕
Mimes are good though! I think they're hilarious. I think this is the first time I've ever heard you dislike a blush. I do really hate that some brands change their cruelty-free status so that they aren't. That bothers me a lot, cruelty-free is so important to me.
I don’t like that blush at all either. I tried the blush in the pinkier color and it stays so wet and tacky
I would be curious to know if they are selling direct to consumer online or if they are actually in stores. I have some Burt’s bees products and they get around the animal testing laws by only selling to China online.
Yeah usually the blogs are good about chronicling those exceptions. Charlotte Tilbury does that, I believe. My logic is they should make a statement one way or the other. It shouldn't be on their customers to do all the work!
Oh I completely agree. It seems shady at best. I checked a couple of their IG posts and they are still claiming they are cruelty free because they don’t personally do testing. A firm yes or no would be nice for sure
Bryanne Garver They only sell to China online.
I have the same hair! My hair does not look good air dried!
This is crazy. I literally just bought a cream bronzer from them I tried today and LOVED. They make so much great stuff and I use their products literally every day, but I guess I won’t be buying from them anymore because of this. They were just becoming my favorite drugstore brand. Sad. Of course, I’ll still use up what I already have (I don’t want to be wasteful) but looks like I won’t be purchasing anything else.
So annoying when brands go from cruelty free to not, wet n wild did that pretty recently too so there’s just not a lot of options at the drugstore.
I heard physicians formula and wet n wild have the same parent company. After the truth about wnw came out, I hoped it wouldn't happen to pf too. 😒
Rachel D so annoying! That parent company is real shady about it too, not very upfront!
Lol, I have an ugly natural hair texture, too! 🙆🏻♀️ Lots of products before and after blow drying to tame the frizz. If there is any moisture at all in the air it goes haywire!
I giggled when you said “V pigmented!” 😂
Fun to “hang out” with you, even if Physicians Formula is off my list now. 😡 and, hey, that blush had been in the back of my mind as something to try, but now that I know it’s awful and not cruelty free, I can cross it off my list. Maybe I’ll just go to the kitchen and drop some food coloring in canola oil instead.
😂you'd save some money
😂
If they say it on their website then Maybe this particular foundation is cruelty free even though the brand itself has switched. A lot of brands do that
Squalane is horrible for causing breakouts, although I love Ilia foundation. So bummed I cannot wear it
So appreciate information as I am trying to steer clear when possible from China made products
Ok wth is happening this week- I just found out batiste isn’t CF (i now know u have to look it up bc companies are putting CF on the bottle when they’re not 🙄) and now PF??!! 😭😭 Anddddd PETA posted an article 4 days ago recommending PF products 🤔🤯
Random comment, I am here for the review, but I will speak about the hair: I was at the same place, really just meh hair, and I was also always saying I just don't want to do anything to it. Never dye it, never style it, just blow dry it only once after I wash them and then no heat again. And I was SO BORED. So I went ahead and got a pixie, and now I LOVE IT. I feel sooo cool with it. I love love love it. Concerning products, I just use a bit of wax or clay to put it in place and that's it. Very fast, and looks very stylish. Just saying.
Thanks for your video. I shared with a few friends. Disappointed - I won't be buying from this brand after my current products run out.
Oh man, Physicians Formula, what a disappointment...I bet now they are going to take L'oreal's approach: claiming they are cruelty free in the US or Europe, and being super vague about "just obliging the laws of certain countries blahblahblah".
If a country is requiring you to test on animals, don't sell your products in said country. Otherwise all your green washing marketing doesn't mean shit. Bye Physicians Formula.
You said it!
I did not like that foundation at all! Good to know because I really wanted to try the Ilia one...😕
@6:15 You just described my hair. Like, exactly.
lol i'm so sorry
Why do brands regress into a non-cruelty free status. Most of them are very popular as is, so they don't need to sell in China.
AGREED.
Holy carp, a bad blush!
This is super disappointing to hear. I happen to love the PF Organic Wear Silk Foundation Elixir. I intend to finish the bottle I have since I already purchased it, but I won’t be buying anymore afterwards. I wish these brands would stop caving to greed, and changing their standards like this. I also don’t understand how they can continue to label things as CF if they’re not...
i think since they were CF at some point they may still have the left over products that were CF. I've noticed most PF items (new restock items) no longer say CF
The ordinary has a foundation that is 6.50. Vegan and cruelty free
The physicians formula smell bothered me when i tried it. And didn’t sit well on my skin. Idk. It didn’t feel organic. 😢. Pacifica is cruelty free, natural and they recycle ♻️ and reuse their containers.
This was a great video! I’m so disappointed about Physician’s Formula. They are going backwards and it looks like they are trying to lie about it/cover it up?! So not cool. If you’re going to sell out and sell in China, than at least have the decency to be up front about it. SMH.
So I guess CZcams isn't notifying me when you upload anymore... RUDE
Rude much like Physician's Formula!
Speaking of cruelty-free, there is an ASPCA ad running - and it ran here at the top of this video - that freaks me out so much I lose an hour every time I see it. Two lab assistants are forcing a tube down a dog's throat, and while I totally support the mission of the organization, this video borders on abuse porn for me. IDK if you have any control over your ad feed, but FWIW, I really will have to stop coming by if I see it again. Just an FYI. Cheers!
It makes you think if you can really trust anything they say about their products...
Wheres the actual proof? Give me actual proof please.
I currently have the easiest hair cut ever. I've done my spring buzz cut to restart my hair. 😂
you and kiki! haha
🙄
Lol I wish my makeup faded/wore like yours did lol
(sees intro) wow how bad could it be? (watches video in two parts 8 hours apart) oh pretty bad
BTW I for one can’t wait for the pretty fresh review.
what products do you use in your hair?? fine hair ladies need help 🥴
I might have to do a whole ass video lol it's a lot
i will definitely watch if you post one !!!
Your sweet and funny and full of good information and your my new friend. Thumbs up, sub & bell!! Great video!
Not cool physicians formula NOT COOL
Do some basic research and have facts before making comments
Ugh! So disappointing!!
Too much talking, I can’t follow up.