Things I DONT like about the Reformed tradition - KingdomCraft
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 08. 2024
- Music:
The first song is the music for Psalm 36 of the Genevan Psalter by Claude Goudimel. The lyrics to that can be found here:
genevanpsalter...
The rest of the music is written by me.
Love your content, your passion for Christ, and your dedication to Christian Orthodoxy. I'm a relatively recent convert to Christianity / Catholicism, was baptized in 2021. For all my research and study about the views of justification between Reformed vs Catholic, it really does seem to me that most of the time we're saying sorta the same things, just with slightly different understandings and senses of specific words. As far as I understand, we are saved by grace through faith; and not a dead faith, but one that has produced fruit worthy of repentance. It seems to me the primary controversy is that of authority; Sola Scriptura vs Papacy. You seem much younger than myself, but you're clearly intelligent and thoughtful, blessed by God and called to do his good works which he has prepared for you since before you were born. Sometimes it seems like there are so few orthodox Christians, especially among the younger folks. Thank you for what you do, and your chill videos are always a pleasure to watch.
The Lord bless you and keep you:
The Lord make his face to shine upon you, and be gracious to you:
The Lord lift up his countenance upon you, and give you peace.
rcc says faith allows the works of salvation.
salvation through faith alone include Acts 16:31; Romans 3:28; 4:5; 5:1; Galatians 2:16; 3:24; Ephesians 1:13; and Philippians 3:9.
Yeah, we're saved through faith alone. But know that all who live in Christ will be called to do works for the Glory of God. Don't forget about the works of the saints, both material and spiritual. I am Protestant, but I care very deeply about orthodoxy, sacraments, and remembrance of the saints.
@@David-bh7hs all born-again are saints. not an orthodox or catholic call.
@@donhaddix3770 I know, but some are obviously worth more to remember than others. I think the list of catholic saints is inclusive, but not absolutely the list of all saints.
@@David-bh7hs are the catholic saints actually saints. I think many are not.
Just found your channel. I love the idea of preaching from a minecraft church😂
I found the channel just _after_ I decided that a MineCraft server building famous historical churches would be a cool thing for my church's youth group to get into.
After a warm-up with a quaint little New England stone church by the sea, I'm going to try doing a 1:1 Hagia Sophia, as close to the historic Christian version as possible.
Pray for us. And if you can, send blueprints. =)
@@jimluebke3869 idk how you doing with the hagia sophia, but do note that 1:1 ratios don't work that well on minecraft. If you're trying to replicate the sense of grandeur of the church I'd advice you to actually make it bigger. Double it or even triple it
@@danielchequer5842 I've found a version that's more or less the right size. The fine details are lost obviously, and the spacing means that some arcades have the wrong number of columns, but it looks pretty good. =)
@@jimluebke3869 It's ok then. Can't get fine details in this game anyway. Most important is to replicate the feeling of it
Great channel, been following you for about a month now I think, and you've got very informative videos. I was raised as an independent Baptist myself, but other Christians (namely online Catholics, but also my dad, who has converted to Anglicanism in the past few years) convinced me to return to my faith, so I've been trying to keep my ears open to learn more about other traditions and historical theology.
I'm Lutheran now (LCMS, not the heretical elca) because of CZcams Christians helping me to gain a zeal for the study of the bible and church history.
I've been enjoying the backlog. I hope it's not weird being an older viewer (31) but it's very nice to see guys who are exploring and discussing the faith at the same age I was when I began to question and take my faith seriously in college. Let me say with my little bit of extra life experience, stay as close to Christ as you can. Even though other paths may seem flashier and more fun at times, you'll be happier and God will bless your life in ways you couldn't imagine.
This is absolutely amazing. I just discovered this channel. As a reformed Presby myself this is very interesting to watch.
I honestly didn't know about the reformed reluctance to celebrate Christmas! My church doesn't want to have specific holiday services, because every day is the Lord's Day and no Sunday is more important than the rest. But everyone in my church loves Christmas and we have separate get-togethers around Christmas to celebrate.
Our church is strongly cessantionist. This is largely supported in the Greek language of Paul. Which is SUPER complicated when you don't know Greek. So I completely understand why many aren't. However, one of the smartest people I know, especially in Reformed Theology, is a continuationlist (idk how to spell both frankly). I think that many in the Reformed Churches have their view, but aren't strict on it, because Scripture itself is vague on the matter.
We are, however, strictly against the idea that speaking in tongues in some "angelic" language. Where in the Scripture does an angel speak in a different tongue? Also Paul explicitly tells us in Corinthians that when speaking in a tongue, there must be a translator. But we all are different, and these are all minor issues.
These are just my thoughts. I loved the video, and I really liked your perspective!
That's really interesting! I didn't know that about Reformed Presbys. I'm continuationist, and believe strongly in the power and movement of the Holy Spirit today, but I agree that a lot of us get super caught up in talking about minor issues when there are bigger ones to worry about.
Honestly I've started bench watching your whole series, which has really helped me with my faith. You, Treasure Christ,fight for Truth, and the daily Disciple have really helped me with my faith. And I've been thinking it would be crazy if you 4 did a Colab video together. Just a fun thought Godspeed
Very cool channel luv!! Was recommended by the channel Ruzlan 😁 thank you for your work 🙏❤️
Im baptist and our small church has been around for 150+ years. There are stories about an exorcism that happened at our church. It would have been when I was a child and I am 40.
Cool insight on your views. I wasn't predestined to be Reformed but I appreciate your delivery.
Can you make a video about the Deuterocanonical books sometime? I don't see many videos about it from a protestant/reformed point of view in CZcams.
Can't lie I l truly respect and admire reformed theology. I myself iam a young conservative charismatic in the UK and randomly stumbled upon you video where you spoke out the heritage churches being taken over by liberal theology. And it's was so true especially here in the UK any old building church in the town center are so liberal it's about of joke to call them churches at all. There are things In my theology I don't agree with but it's more about application of certain scriptures.
reformed has a lot of error.
I’m new to the channel and I definitely want to get caught up on your videos, any suggestion on where to start?
I'd say start with his history of the church video, its funny and well edited and gets you hyped to learn some more about specific facets
When you open your server I'm going to open a non-denominational (Baptist) church (warehouse) across from your big weird building with weird crosses in it (the service isn't spiritual enough).
These are fun to watch after work, thanks for all the content!
Im currenty Presbyterian and I've heard of our church presbyters talking about miracles and exorcism they have witnessed experience.
Like for example.
One of presbyters talk about this pastor during the 90s who was going on a mission somewhere isolated, he got lost so he prayed and then a tiger comes which frightened him. But he got this relief in him which persuaded him to follow the tiger. As he followed the tiger he ended up where he was supposed to go.
There are some Christmas traditions that are pretty non-Catholic in addition to being non-Christian. You may have heard of the tradition of "Wassailing" in an old carol (which makes it all sound like jolly fun), but it pays to recall that it's basically roving gangs of rowdy young men doing something like "trick-or-treating" for beer.
dude you gotta post links for the background music you use in your videos it's seriously epic (love your content btw as a fellow zoomer who has been redeemed)
Thank you! Redeemedzoomer.com has a link to my soundcloud
If your pastors don't emphasize the reality of demons and spiritual warfare, you're probably in the wrong church.
Someone real here
W
I agree with the sentiment of we shouldn't try to be as anti-catholic as possible. In a similar fashion, I think the early church may have gone a little wrong in trying to be as anti-jewish as possible. Obviously that wasn't how they started, but whereas they both had the same sabbath and even same buildings for worship in the beginning, obviously something had to change. But, did they really need to move the sabbath day from what God initiated at creation? I think we have freedom, as the church, to do so, and the sabbath was made for us, but in general I would've been strongly against the idea. Long time down the road, and I definitely think unity trumps personal idealism. Paul mentioned being all things to all people so that by all means he might save some. I think there's a lot of freedom to be had. It shouldn't be something that divides us.
I'm not against musical instruments, but using Psalm 150 to support the usage of instruments in public worship might be a weak argument.
Ps 150 lists a lot of musical instruments, but based on the Mosaic law, only a few mentioned there could be used in temple worship. So what Ps 150 is talking about is evidently not temple/public worship, but private praise to the Lord.
Perhaps a better justification of instruments would be to see it as accidents (or circumstances) rather than elements of worship. This element/circumstance distinction helps us to differentiate what parts of worship to regulate (the elements) and what is for the church to decide (circumstances).
Are you a theology major? The knowledge you have is pretty impressive
Typically, people this smart are college dropouts.
He said in another video he is a math and music major if im not mistaken
Exorcism is definitely one of the coolest parts about the catholic church
“THERE is no day commanded in scripture to be kept holy under the gospel but the Lord’s day, which is the Christian Sabbath. Festival days, vulgarly called Holy-days, having no warrant in the word of God, are not to be continued.”
- Westminster Directory for the Public Worship of God (Appendix)
In the United Kingdom the church with the most exorcists is the Church of England.
How about a video on why you are not pentecostal?
The regulative principle:
Okay, so I can do it if it's in scripture.
"On that day you shall bring money to Jerusalem and purchase wine, strong liquor, or whatever makes you happy."
This is a feast the Jews were commanded to participate in, and Christ has fulfilled its purpose, but it does explicitly state that God wants his chosen people to have awesome parties with booze and drugs... Soooooo....
Another interesting ramification: "Everything is permissible, but not everything is useful." So anything that is useful is permissible by scripture. Is Christmas useful? Survey says yes.
Therefore Christmas is at least permissible.
Finally, my favorite, by the regulative principle's own rules, the Regulative Principle itself is nonbiblical, making it a paradoxical principle.
God I love me some theology in the morning.
What do you think of the miracle of the holy fire that happens during the Orthodox Pascha(aka Easter)?
I didn't know I needed this.
2:50 the thing about celebrating Christmas is that Hebrews never really celebrated birthdays and were more cognizant of the anniversary of someone's death. Orthodox Jews today annually mourn on the (yahrzeit) of a deceased parent or loved one.
great video but how diid you not flinch/scream in terror when the creeper appeared and blew up?? lol 13:13
I agree that contemporary worship music is bad, but what if we Praised Him with a fat wah-pedal guitar solo on a bigsby or like a pedal steel or with heavy downtuned riffs?
The rumors are true! Redeemed Zoomer is a crypto-Anglican! Praise God! (Only kidding of course)
I kinda am but
1. I’m against images of Christ
2. The word Presbyterian is so cool
@@redeemedzoomer6053 Hahaha! As an Anglican, I have much to say for how cool our denominational name sounds. I can't tell you how many secular laymen assume I am a part of some Angel worshipping cult
@@redeemedzoomer6053 the Homily on the Peril of Idolatry is against images of Christ.
@@Young_Anglican Meanwhile Non-denominational and baptist... yeah... not that cool tbh. (Pretty much me tho)
Love it man. What’s your view on eschatology
Amillennial with a focus on spreading the Kingdom here and now
@@redeemedzoomer6053 pre-trib. amil makes everything figurative while the bible is literal.
@@donhaddix3770 so you think everything in the Bible is literal? What about when Jesus says “this is my body”?
@@redeemedzoomer6053 symbolic with literal meaning, such as Satan as dragon is literal. mk being in heaven is not.
this is my body is symbolic of his death, which had not occurred when said, a remembrance, sin bread does not literally become flesh and we are not cannibals.
@@redeemedzoomer6053 symbolic with literal meaning, such as Satan as dragon is literal. mk being in heaven is not.
this is my body is symbolic of his death, which had not occurred when said, a remembrance, bread does not literally become flesh and we are not cannibals.
The Catholic Church can't be cessationist if it believes that miracles can occur at the intercession of modern saints, right? If I understand correctly, that's a criterion for sainthood.
@Jack Hummell As far as signs and wonders go, though, it seems to me that a miracle that you don't need faith to notice is different in a significant way.
Love these video
If John Calvin did say something about only needing 4 walls and a sermon I 100% agree with him.
Huh really thought-provoking view of the Catholic Church there near the end from a reformed person. I was actually considering becoming part of a Reformed Pentecostal church because I have similar issues regarding the supernatural and cessationism
Love your channel already…and youre making me buy minecraft lol
Counterpoint: RPCNA style of no instruments encourages people to get good at singing 😂. Some of the Psalm singing with just voices can be really pretty with an in tune congregation
Interesting this case of using the catholicism as a "chest" for undefined/unsolved questions.
Please link the song at 6:50 it's so good
I wrote it, it’s on my SoundCloud here: on.soundcloud.com/ixA4A
11:43 It’s really a STAIN on the reformed tradition. Ha, I see what you did there.
yooo that wasn't even intentional! You were the first to point this out to me haha
@@redeemedzoomer6053
Oh lol, well I guess God preordained that pun then, proof of God’s existence right there.
They don't have a teaching on charismata, there are charismatic catholics. They are not the norm.
Ruslan sent me here.
Oh man, RZ, you're just begging for jokes to be made on what a "Reformed Exorcism" would look like.
Something along the lines of the CofE "Cake or Death" inquisition...
Ur videos are dope
Regarding church design, I want to speak on behalf of newer churches. Beauty is quite subjective, that can’t be denied. Most (what feels like all) people who prefer traditional things act as though new things are poorly and lazily made, and there is no care for beauty. I’m here to tell you that isn’t true whatsoever. I think new contemporary churches with warehouse design are MUCH more beautiful than the gaudy churches of yore. I do think it’s cool that many European churches are built over generations so there’s history to them, but overall I think traditional architecture is hideous and uncreative. It’s just slapping a bunch of crap together with as many embellishments as possible mindlessly assembled as will fit in a space. It’s a person who’s never payed attention to beauty’s idea of beauty. God makes beautiful things, and you know what He doesn’t do? He doesn’t cobble everything together. He works with a pallet and allows for space. It’s like classical music. Beethoven was dead and his music sounds like it was written by a deaf guy who just happened to know music theory. It’s melody soup. Modern songwriting is intentional, holistic, and expressive. Classical church design is aesthetic soup. It’s haphazard, lazy, and gaudy. Modern church design is careful, cool, and functional.
No disrespect, I just feel that those of us who don’t like traditional things need to speak up more and out the traditionalists in their place.
I think this will go down as the worst opinion in history
@@giggerchas1488 went to reply but saw this and couldn’t help but laugh 😂