Why Didn't Spanish America Unite Like Brazil?
VloĆŸit
- Äas pĆidĂĄn 20. 06. 2024
- Thank you for watching! I hope you enjoyed the video!
đ« Attributions
NASA Goddard Space Flight Center Image by Reto Stöckli (land surface, shallow water, clouds). Enhancements by Robert Simmon (ocean color, compositing, 3D globes, animation). Data and technical support: MODIS Land Group; MODIS Science Data Support Team; MODIS Atmosphere Group; MODIS Ocean Group Additional data: USGS EROS Data Center (topography); USGS Terrestrial Remote Sensing Flagstaff Field Center (Antarctica); Defense Meteorological Satellite Program (city lights).
đ” Music
Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License
creativecommons.org/licenses/b...
Covert Affair
Spy Glass
Hard Boiled
Dances And Dames
Bass Walker
Walking Along
Umbrella Pants
Exotic Battle
Enter The Maze
Constance
Digya
Showdown
Minima
Crossing the Chasm
Invariance
Outfoxing The Fox
Infados
Expeditionary
Disco Sting
Electro Cabello
Aurea Carmina
Ether Disco
Stringed Disco
Faster Does It
I Knew A Guy
Fast Talkin
Just As Soon
Sovereign
Investigations
Marty Gots a Plan
Accralate
Sneaky Adventure
Drums of the Deep
it's funny that in Brazilian Historigraphy, we make the oposite question: Why Didn't Brazil dismebered Like Spanish America?
alliance with Britain
@@elultramontano uhm no? its waaaaaay more complicated than that
â@@elultramontano we already have answers being written for more than 150 years of historiography until today.
The british is one of the minor causes of the brazilian unity.
They sure helped in the independence processe by diplomatic and econonic means, but the political means of the unification during and after the independence war are autoctonous.
â@@jeanitacarambi354bro, I think there are two main reasons for Brazil to be united after its indepedence: Pedro I, who fought against regional independences processes, and Duque de Caxias, who did the same
@@user-dk1fg5ct7s you're right. Seeing the question as a a matter of agency of individuals, Pedro I and Caxias are two heroes of the national integrity.
But there are others points of viewing. As exemple, economic and social ones (many historians sees the manutering of slavery as a cause of a "pact" of the elites for the conservation of the economical estrutures and avoid of slave revolts).
I was not expecting the bit of brazilian and portuguese history at the end! You clearly did your research
As a brazilian i can confirm that all of the brazilian parts were factual
@@emanuel585 Ă©, eu reparei kkkk
Thanks! I spent a long time researching and writing the script
@@icebulb Amazing video! It would also be cool to have a video dedicated to the history of Dom Pedro II. He was a hyperpolyglot, educated in numerous subjects, was raised by José Bonifåcio, patriach of Brazil, and Rafael, o Anjo Negro, an ex-slave. Under him, the royal family had no slaves as he despised it and banned slavery with his daugther he had plans to integrate the ex-slaves into Brazilian society, but the Republican coup exiled him to Portugal and forgot all plans about ex-slave integration.
I will add him to the list! Although I already have lots of ideas in the back-burner haha
BRAZIL MENTIONED
NĂŁo de una forma muito boa
â@@tiosubaruomg achei que ele valorizou bem o Brasil, quase uma ode
An interesting thing that can be noticed is that whenever someone from another country mentions Brazil and talks about it, there are always Brazilians to come and watch and been a subscriber
đ xique-xique Bahia
Claro po
as a brazilian, I really liked this video. Definitely underrated.
Thank you! đ§đ·
this dude is the oversimplified of countryballs
I ABSOLUTELY LOVED THIS VIDEO!!! Itâs great to see latam history covered in detail and humor, greetings from Puerto Rico!
Love to see Puerto Ricans here! đ
"Latam" đ
@@TeSu-fs7mp it's an actual word
23:45 LOL!!!!!! Hi from Brazil đ§đ·đ§đ·
There's a lot of Brazilians in the comments hahaha it seems like the algorithm is showing my video there, I love it đ§đ·
Great Video, +1 sub from Brazil
Thanks!
Vitor gasta o dinheiro e compra HOI4. Confia em mim. VocĂȘ vai gostar
This channel is underrated
This is one of the best history channels I've ever seen
Best compliment I've ever received
20:03 this was actually sad đ
Brazil was the Portuguese royal family, Dom JoĂŁo VI moved the seat of the Portuguese government from Lisbon to Rio de Janeiro in 1808
I absolutely love how accurately you pronounce the names in the video. Like, most of the time I'm watching these kind of videos, people tend to pronounce the names of locations and historical figures in a funny way, and I don't blame them as it's hard to pronounce a word from another language, but you are able to pronounce EVERY single foregin word PERFECTLY. Congrats!!! Really good and informative video as well!
I mean, they're not exactly foreign words for me hahaha so you could say I'm cheating a little bit
@@icebulb Wait I didn't know you were spanish too lol
This dude deserved More View
A united spanish americas would've been a REALLY long chile: changed my mind
I'm on your side đ
@@icebulb đ€
11:22 His name was Juan Bautista Cabral
22:45 there is a very interesting historical fact here involving Brazil. During july and december 1822, Brazil occupied Upper Peru at the request of its governors, who feared an invasion by BolĂvar's forces. Later, in 1825, the Empire of Brazil would occupy part of Bolivia, with the aim of dissuading SimĂłn BolĂvar from helping the United Provinces of the RĂo de la Plata during the Cisplatine War.
I saw Brazil e vim mais rĂĄpido que pude.
Imma be honest: too lazy to watch it right. But one of the main and most important reasons, is that Brazil only really stopped being Portugal's "object" when it became a kingdom and an exile for the portuguese royal family. There were pretty much no universities here before that period, so the elites just sent their youth to Europe, and most of the ones that came back simply didn't have ideas of regional economical development. It took much long for Brazil to develop proper separate elites, which would compete enough to create political during the oligarchy era.
Yeah I mention that first half in the video!
I swear if the answer is âitâs basically napoleons faultâ Iâm gonna lose it
It's basically Napoleon's fault
Happy to see another upload from icebulb đȘ
More to come! I'm glad you enjoyed it
Damn, your videos are amazing! Oversimplified but in country balls.
That's right!
Country balls...
@@D9fjg did I say it wrong or smt?
crazy high quality video i was shocked to see only 2.5k subs
Thank you!
pretty high quality vid mate love it
Glad you enjoyed it!
W video man, thanks for actually explaining history properly
You're welcome ;)
25:08 The references, lol!
Great video, loved all the detail and gags on it, absolutely worth the wait.
Very useful video
Amazing work. sat through the entire 31 minutes extremely invested.
Thank you!
Fascinating video, man!
Glad you enjoyed it!
He has returned
Stronger than ever
YOOO HE'S BACKKKK
I never leftđ
i really enjoy how this video was portrayed! very informative, yet also making it funny and lighthearted. keep up the great work!
Will do!
Loved that your channel showed up on my recomended! Subscribed!
Welcome aboard!
Fantanstic video đ
Thank you!
i loved this so much! thank you for your time and how you do these funny and educational videos! Didn't get bored:)
That's awesome! Thank you so much!
honestly you nailed it man, you explained it better than how my school taught me (i'm in honduras)
Great work!
Thanks!
Great video â€
Glad you liked it!!
Great video
Thank you!
This is a really good video!
Thank you!
Good video man, keep it up
Thanks, will do!
This was very funny, especially all the gags you threw in
Haha thanks, I try to make it entertaining as well as informative!
Good stuff, brother, well done! Subbed.
Much appreciated!
Impressively quick, understandable and entertaining.
I'm glad you like it!
Loved it. New viewer to the channel but it will go places. The long-form content is great
Awesome, thank you!
Love this video!
Glad you enjoyed it!
I actually really liked this video, I'm subscribing ( also, the end cutscene was ominous )
Thanks for the sub! Haha yeah I went for an Avengers-esque end-scene
BRO, IT IS SO GOOD, IT IS PERFECT
Took a long time to make đ
El mejor video acerca de este tema que he visto, buen resumen, buen humor. Saludos desde Ecuador.
ÂĄGracias! đȘđš
Great video â„ïž
Thank you!!
this is amazing and interesting thank you
You're welcome!
I LOVE IT! This is like oversimplified. BUT ITS DIFFRENT! AND AWESOME! +1 SUB FROM POLAND!
Thanks for the sub! đ”đ±
wow this was a great video!
Thank you so much!
10/10 video man
Thank you!
I'm in love with the format of your videos.
They're very funny and have a good sense of humor. Congrats đđđđ
PS: hope you get recognized by this tremendous good work
Thank you for your support!
I never got much into Spanish and Portuguese colonial history but this brought greater interest in my mind. Now I feel more connected to something apart of my heritage
Awesome! đ
Amazing video, I'll sub
Thanks for the sub!
nice well done and editited video
Many many thanks!
Great job
Thanks!
You deserve more views,subscribers,likes etc
Haha thanks, they'll come with time
Ironic to think that Dom JoĂŁo VI did not want to return to Portugal and independence began with the intention of the courts to demote Brazil to a colony.
peak pronounciations on your part, 1 sub from brazil buddy
Thank you!
Your videos are top quality, i am your subscriber now.
Thanks for the sub!
HES BACK
That's rightđ
Yay!!! Icebulb returns!!! :D
Yessir!
Good video
Thanks!
Sick!
Thanks!
Nice video
Thanks! :)
this mustve taken a long time to animate and edit, very good video
The whole video took 6 months, including research and script. Glad you enjoyed it!
Bro, im new around here, pretty cool channel
Welcome!
@@icebulb bro, thx for the great vid and the entertaining and informative content
Zamn your back after those 7 months of exile
I hope to upload the next one in less time
Hi from Mangomarca, PerĂș. Nice video
Thanks!
This video is AMAZING đŁïžđŁïžđŁïž
Thank you! :)
as an argentinian I absolutely clap to you. You have summarized a topic so complex, so well and i just a few minutes. IDK if you are from Iberoamérica o from outside but congratulations! I'm a new sub
Thank you for your support! I'm from Spain btw
@@icebulb PLOT TWIST lmao!
I'm new subscriber I learn more about Latin America I didn't expect you mention my country Philippines.
No one gets left behind đ
Epic
Great video! Never learned anything about the history of south america in school, nice to watch a well done video about it now
Glad you enjoyed it!
The GOAT IS HERE
đ
Would have been funny if you added how Bolivar billed peru for the costs of their independence. An independence that many in Peru didnt want (as one of the most loyalist regions). But Bolivar couldnt permit the spanish to have a foothold in south america where they could try to reconquer the lost territories.
Goated video, learned a lot about post colonial SA
I'm glad you liked it!
You need to make a part 2 of what happens after.
I'm planning on making a follow-up video on the Texas Revolution and maybe one on the Paraguayan War
Bro how do you not have at least 50k??? I wouldâve never guessed that you only had 2k. A new subscriber. :)
Thank you for the sub!
Wow. This is amazing! Iâve always wanted to understand how South and Central America ended up this way. Iâve spent hours on Wikipedia and ChatGPT trying to figure it out, but always just got a vague idea. This was exactly what I needed!
Thanks for much for making. And for including Central America and Brazil, to make sure our curiosities were fully satisfied! Only thing Iâm still wondering is how Chile and Argentina ended up extending down South.
Btw, why are the music and sound effects identical to Oversimplified? Is it a tribute? I love it, of course!
Patagonia (the southernmost part of South America) was basically ungoverned by any formal states and only had a tiny population of indigenous people living there so it was basically free land to these two countries which they spent decades fighting over
Yup, that's a good summary
I'm glad the video was exactly what you were searching for!
And yeah, the music is Oversimplified's because it's the best copyright-free music out there, by artist Kevin Macleod.
The sound effects are the generic "whoosh" and "slap" everyone uses haha
Love that you love it! Thanks for the support!
"Only thing Iâm still wondering is how Chile and Argentina ended up extending down South"
Very similarly to how the US extended to the west, killing natives.
great video... a little to "Oversimplified" inspired... but I hope you found your own style soon.
No, it is amazingly made. Oversimplified glosses over too much history.
This channel is too good not to have 100k+ subs
Interesting Brazil managed to stay as one while spanish america broke due to a mix of politics and power vacuums
The second oversimplified
Of course Brazil would remain united, who else got an "colony" in europe if not Brazil?
W video
Now i can flex the fact that i know Latin America history
Honey wake up icebulb posted!
I've been waiting for this meme since I started my channel đđ
Spanish America was the balkanzing before the balkanzing was a thing
So glad I found this channel, great summary of all the chaos of the Latin American revolutions
I'm glad you found me too!
27:18 caught me off guard đ
Commenting for algorithm
Thanks!
this video is really really really understating peru's presence in the entire conflict. For one it was the original and only viceroyalty in america during the hapsburg era of the spanish empire. And despite you saying the rugged and accidented terrain is why spanish america is not united, yet the original viceroyalty of peru held everything from Panama to the Patagonia from 200+ years until Carlos III.
This is also to say, Peru was the most loyal out of all the viceroyalties in Peru. There was no initial impetus from anyone to declare independence there, it was all work done by both San Martin and Bolivar which then later propped up caudillos from peru proper. But before this the royal army of Peru was essentially a humongous bulk of this "royalist" force you speak of. It's so easy to just call the royalists spanish as if they were The royalists, when really for a grand majority it was the same mestizos, criollos, indigenous from the territories. In fact the royalist side actually did include a greater portion of indigenous and slave-descent soldiers since the wars of "independence" (more like secession really) would not benefit them as it was a very very criollo project.
But back to Peru, a lot of those counter reconquistas you mentioned in the video were in fact done by Peru. They were the ones marching in Santiago, Buenos aires, cartagena, Quito. So to a lot of the rest of hispanoamericans in south america Peru was seen as an imperial juggernaut and bulwark. They were forced to act against Peru as a sort of way to guarantee that they wouldn;t get reconquista'd again like they already had. And in the end the only reason they won was because Peru imploded in chaos just before the "independist" side did themselves.
Which is how it ties in to how Spain's politics did ruin Peru, and the exact issue that later became the carlist vs liberals was the death sentence for peru. The thing is that Ferdinand VII in 1820 wanted to send 20,000 troops to south america and quell the rebellions. Instead the troops go and commit a coup lead by rafael de riego and impose the liberal constitution of 1812. It's interesting how it lines up since when San Martin declares independence for Peru, Peru was being independized not even against the crown but against the liberal junta of that time.
It was during this period that a lot of the fighting back was done by royalists though, and surprisingly enough they were winning. Viceroy de la serna would start moving the capital and everything to avoid defeat, and as previously mentioned the fact that the indigenous were on his side made the andes a very strong fortress. But then 1823 came. Ferdinand VII finally comes back to power in the throne.... and the first thing he does is throw everything the trienio liberal had done. And by everything it was literally all of it. Viceroy de la serna was now in a complete legal void, since he was a viceroy appointed during the trienio liberal. This gave the chance to this one general Olañeta to rebel on the side of the conservative king as opposed to a liberal viceroy. The rebellion of Olañeta was a HUGE drain on peruvian forces, not just from the defects but fighting it back costed lots of lives. Some could even say that Olañeta in Peru was more pivotal to causing the actual independence than even bolivar himself who was losing on his end up until that point. The battle of Junin was a decisive one for this reason, as it was one where the independists had actually won and it only marked the end for the viceroyalty of peru. Peru in the end lost all of its stability since now the "presidents" were almost always caudillos elected by themselves pulling coups and this kept on for a really long time after independence, both Bolivar and the british put Peru in debt and asked for money back from literally being independized against its will. Even Bolivar himself had said "Peru gained nothing except its own independence".
Simon Bolivar himself in Peru to this day is not a very well regarded figure at all. As you mention he was made literally the first dictator of south america by the bootlicking congress of Peru. Bolivar abused his power and his constitucion vitalicia only lasted a few days since the man ended up getting kicked out rather soon after taking power. Bolivar for his part would openly state in letters how he disliked peruvians and quiteñans and had quite the vitriolic things to say about them, which is also in part why he took guayaquil and created bolivia as we know it. The Gran-colombo peruvian war was also a thing in this, where the territories of Maynas, tumbes, and Jaen fought to stay in peru alongside peru itself. They felt themselves more part of Peru than gran-colombinos and unlike guayaquil they succeeded in staying apart of peru in the end.
As for other miscellaneous comments, by 1796 the spanish americas already had the common hispanic market which was set up in 1778. This market was literally the reason Buenos aires became relevant in any way whatsoever through the leather trade. Before this point it was merely a backwater that had no spanish military presence, relied on contraband to even thrive, and was a very fringe portion of the viceroyalty of peru before becoming part of the newly made rio de la plata viceroyalty. It's so ironic how places that were being treated better like buenos aires and became rich as well ended up being the most secessionist, meanwhile Peru that lost a good portion of its territory stayed loyal to spain until the end.
Also speaking of secessionists, its no surprise as you mention the british movements during this time. All of the independist leaders from O'higgins, to Don Jose de San martin, and Bolivar were all into english masonry and this played a huge role in what they ended up doing in the end.
Speaking of which I found funny the bit with O'higgins becoming chilean, since in the end he was actually kicked out from Chile and went to live his final days back in Peru. To this day the house of O'higgins in Lima is still there.
Lastly Mexico and this whole part of New Spain as a whole declared independence as a result of the conservative vs liberal politics too. It was done however much more peaceful relatively than south america, as both the criollos mestizos and indigenous caciques and powerful people were more uniliterally agreeing that Spain being so liberal was not gonna fly. Good to note that this independence also just so happens to be in 1821... which was trienio liberal time.
All of these political conflicts were all exarcerbated as a result of the napoleonic wars. But had in many ways roots coming back all the way from the bourbon reforms, the same bourbon reforms that split peru and created so many of the modern borders we know, promoted absolutism, removed all the jesuits (which were the very soul of how some of these viceroyalties were so big to begin with), gave places like buenos aires and venezuela the power to exercise what they did. In the end a lot of reasons all coalleced in this sort of sequence of events, and lead an otherwise very prosperous empire that lasted 300 years to end in said part of the world.
đ”đ and đ§đ· are everywhere in the comments hahaha love it!
Oh and about the Novales Revolt, his officers were disgruntled âAmericanosâ i.e. Mexico, Peru, etc. and they captured the entire city of Manila except for Fort Santiago, which his brother controlled. Cheers!
A few reasons.. Geography, Regionalism, and lastly Hispanics donât get along with each other.
I would love to see a video about the American Revolution and like the war of 1812 and Mexican American war in the style of this!
Those are all in my To-Do list (except for the American Revolution, because it was covered by Oversimplified)