2024 Draft QB Rankings: "A class of his own" | Chris Simms Unbuttoned (FULL Ep. 592) | NFL on NBC
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 03. 2024
- In one of our most-anticipated episodes of the year, Chris (@CSimmsQB) gives his tiers and ranks of the top QB prospects in the 2024 NFL Draft, while Ahmed (@ahmedNBC) reads some of your questions on the passers. But first, a homie has meme-ified Chris ogling prospects. #NBCSports #ChrisSimmsUnbuttoned #NFL
(3:30) QB Scouting: What does Chris look for in a passer?
(9:30) 2023 Draft QB Review: Looking back at what Simms got right & wrong last year.
(18:30) #1 Caleb Williams (USC)
(42:15) #2 Jayden Daniels (LSU)
(59:20) #3 Bo Nix (Oregon)
(1:13:15) #4 Michael Penix, Jr. (Washington)
(1:26:55) #5 J.J. McCarthy (Michigan)
(1:37:10) #6 Drake Maye (North Carolina)
» Watch Live Sports on Peacock: peacocktv.smart.link/v82e9dl56
» Subscribe to NFL on NBC: czcams.com/users/NFLonNBC?sub_...
NBC Sports Group serves sports fans 24/7 with premier live events, insightful studio shows, and compelling original programming. NBC Sports is an established leader in the sports media landscape with an unparalleled collection of sports properties that include the Olympics, NFL, Premier League, NASCAR, PGA TOUR, the Kentucky Derby, Tour de France, French Open, IndyCar and many more. Subscribe to our channel for the latest sporting news and highlights!
'Chris Simms Unbuttoned' features in-depth Xs and Os NFL analysis; one-on-one interviews with players, coaches, executives, and draft prospects; game recaps and previews; gambling segments; extensive player analysis leading into the NFL Draft; and much more.
Watch more from NFL on NBC CZcams: / nflonnbc
Visit NBC Sports: www.nbcsports.com
Find NBC Sports on Facebook: / nbcsports
Follow NBC Sports on Twitter: / nbcsports
Follow NBC Sports on Instagram: / nbcsports
www.nbcsports.com/nfl/sunday-...
nbcsports.com/motors/nascar
nbcsports.com/soccer/premier-...
2024 Draft QB Rankings: "A class of his own" | Chris Simms Unbuttoned (FULL Ep. 592) | NFL on NBC
/ nflonnbc - Sport
My most-anticipated annual CZcams series. Thanks Chris, I am a big fan!!
Here here! Thanks Chris!
Love chris
For Maye at 5 😂
@@dagoods528I like his Lb rankings maybe cus there such little 1st 2nd rounders usually
Christopher Zachory Wilson Simms has released his QB rankings
Interesting stuff starts at 18:00
1. Caleb Williams 19:00
2. Jayden Daniels 42:40
3. Bo Nix 1:00:12
4. Michael Penix 1:13:32
5. J.J. McCarthy 1:27:14
6. Drake Maye 1:37:57
Thanks for the time Mark's bro
Help. I took a drink every time he said "Right" and now I have Kedon Slovis as my QB2
im already drunk... right?
“Let alone” also a common theme
Chris simms is simultaneously the most overrated and underrated draft analyst we have. A bunch of people take his word as gospel, and the same amount dismiss everything he says because he’s been wrong before (lmfao).
In reality he’s one of the sharpest draft guys in the business. That doesn’t mean he’s batting 1000, but he is one of the best by far. I appreciate him not listening to draft group think and going solely off tape.
Nobody ever points out Daniel Jeremiah’s draft misses but he’s probably the most respected draft guy overall.
Totally agree especially about DJ.
No one ever knows-no matter how much conviction they have.
People appreciate nuanced reasoning for their predictions, and Chris and DJ both offer that.
He hasn't just been wrong. He's been hilariously wrong.
I wouldnt say he's one of the sharpest anymore. I still respect his opinion being that he doesn't follow the trends
People who hate Chris simms are losers 100%.
I would love to get a pod maybe on a slow week. Of Chris just ranking top 5-10 qb prospects of the past 5 seasons with ignoring how their professional careers have panned out. Would be awesome to see.
That would be pretty interesting actually
Great idea. Maybe he could put numbers to his grading system similar to madden numbers
That and going through the tape to show what he looks at. Or debating someone like Nate Tice who was also QB and looks at the tape but has Maye as his QB1.
Past 5 seasons I think Trevor Lawerence, Kyler Murray , Joe Burrow n Justin Herbert would be a top that list n it’s to early to tell on last years class they need to play more.
All of those top guys atleast TL, Murray n Burrow would rank higher than my QB in this class. Murray’s 6.80 grade was higher than Caleb Williams 6.70 grade n was a better prospect people don’t realize Murray is a generational caliber QB Talent, he’s just 5”10 if he was 6”2 he’d of been talked about as the next John Elway better than Luck coming out. I mean dudes not only a Heisman winner n 3X state champion regarded as the best HS Ever in Texas state history but think of all the elite athletes Americas produced…. And Kyler Murray is THE ONLY 1 EVER drafted 1st rd in the TOP 10 in TWO different drafts. He’s special n is an elite caliber passer that just happens to be an elite athlete with 4.30 speed.
Come next season with AZ having an Elite top 3-5 rush offense n what will be an elite stacked WR/TE room and AZ building an elite top 10 caliber OL in front of him protecting him giving him clean pockets n unpressured 9-10 dropbacks I will bet money Kyler Murray will be back playing at an Elite MVP Caliber level again next season back atop MVP Race in a career season with a talented loaded offense again for the first time since 2021, I think he’ll have a tremendous season.
He'd have Caleb #1
Y'all need to hire like Bill Hader or Will Ferrel to play a random person walking around the office in the background and accidentally causing chaos while never actually interacting with you guys.
This would be awesome😂
@@Biz613relax dude
Nice, lol!!! I was thinking of random mascots walking by and occasionally causing havoc.
I tend to pay attention to Sports Programs that have former players like Chris Simms as their main broadcaster rather than someone that never played in the NFL. Chris admits when he's wrong and has a very interesting show.
I'd be happy if they replaced Mike Florio with Chris Simms...
Let Simms cook! 👨🍳 🔥
Right
no one:
chris: "okay, let alone, right, ya know? damn."
Chris was one of the only ones to pick Patrick first. Thats enough 😂
He was also one of the only ones being all in on Lamar when the rest of the cretins barely wanted Lamar to be drafted as a QB.
he also was all in on zack wilson.. and loved tua more than herbert.
@johnanthony4353 he was way in on Herbert over Tua dude
Chris is so much better here than when he sits with that smug know-it-all Florio
🔥
can't stand that guy. genuinely is upsetting to me seeing his face on a thumbnail 😂
Thank you Chris Simms!
Simms is cooking with this one. Much love boys
Penix was a dual threat most of his life. After injuries he stayed in the pocket. He has runner instincts and awareness and has improved his pocket movement.
I love Chris when he drops rankings. The analysis and breakdown are priceless. As long as Chris makes these, I'll be watching.
Lmao that’s my tweet at 2:30
W
Liar!
always look forward to this one!!!
Thanks guys. Looking forward to all the rankings
Can’t wait to Hear these position Breakdowns. @ RB, WR, OT, OC, DT/NT, Edge, LB, & CB/S’s LFG!!! Top10’s by position! 🙌🏽
Chris Simms is every bit as good at QB analysis as Caleb Williams is at playing QB. He's the undisputed superstar QB analyst and shares his knowledge in a way that very understandable to ordinary Joes like me. Thanks Chris.
He ranked Zach Wilson #1 in 2021.
😂😂😂😂😂@@PapaChummy
@@PapaChummy😭 Was that after the combine? Zach fooled everybody straight garbage
@OrlandoSoto1111 in fairness no one gets it hundred percent right - and the jets are known for being disfunctional
Merry Christmas everyone!
Hey you guys. Thanks for letting it roll. Good stuff.😊
So it hit me during Chris’ interview with Caleb when he started talking about Aaron Rodgers’ being his favorite quarterback. That’s who you’re getting. You’re getting an Aaron Rodgers-like quarterbacking talent, along with a very Aaron-like personality.
Caleb Williams? That’s Darkness Retreat Jr. right there.
No Caleb is already operating like a pro qb on his second contract that’s why his personality is different from the others.
I watched Rodgers for a long time and their personalities aren’t the same.
Williams doesn't want to be treated like a slave.
What is wrong with that?
Rogers flat out misreprsents the truth.
Two completely different things.
9ers didnt draft Rodgers because they thought he was arrogant. Thats was stupid, If the player has never been in trouble draft him. Teams should be drafting guys based on the ability to play football not because their personality may hurt others feelings.
@@KamuiCage absolutely agree it would be very stupid not to draft him. He’s a special player. But…I stand by my point that I think there’s a high potential Chicago will be getting both sides of Aaron Rodgers. It’s gonna be a fun ride regardless for a franchise that desperately needs some fun again.
u can see he emulate a lot aarod. there is also some clear russell wilson.
People need to realize qb evaluation is almost impossible to get correct a lot. Chris still does a damn good job
Top notch sh🎉t Chris ! Appreciate the hard work you put into this.
Chris is spot on . He is the best QB evaluator. He should be paid for this.
Isn't the point here that Drake Maye is a project with a high ceiling? It doesn't feel like anyone outside of Caleb and Drake have the upside of a top ten QB in the league, so that's why they are 1 and 2, even if Drake Maye is a work in progress.
Did you watch the video?
Drake was sixth on his list!
Take a shot every time Simms says "Right"!
I don’t want to drunk in the middle of the afternoon
You’d need a couple bottles
Lmao he’s got a hyper “adhd kid” style of conversation
This and the nfl rankings are my favorite pods great job fellas
College QB’s Total TD’s:
Tom Brady: 29 games = 33 TD
Brock Purdy: 48 games = 52 TD
Andrew Luck: 38 games = 89 TD
Trevor Lawrence: 40 games = 108 TD
Patrick Mahomes: 32 games = 115 TD
Caleb Williams: 37 games = 120 TD
Justin Fields = 53 games = 87 TD
Drake Maye: 30 games = 79 TD
Jayden Daniels = 55 games = 124 TD
Michael Penix: 49 games = 104 TD
J.J. McCarthy: 40 games = 59 TD
Carson Beck = 25 games = 34 TD
Spencer Rattler = 48 games = 93 TD
Jordan Love = 38 games = 69 TD
Joe Burrow: 38 games = 91 TD
Justin Herbert: 43 games = 108 TD
Josh Allen: 27 games = 57 TD
Will Levis = 39 games = 63 TD
Matthew Stafford = 39 games = 57 TD
Bryce Young: 36 games = 87 TD
CJ Stroud: 27 games = 86 TD
Cam Newton: 20 games = 54 TD
Jalen Hurts: 56 games = 123 TD
Kyler Murray: 29 games = 63 TD
Baker Mayfield: 48 games = 152 TD
Colt Brennan = 38 games = 146 TD
Tim Tebow: 55 games = 145 TD
Peyton Manning: 45 games = 101 TD
Eli Manning: 43 games = 86 TD
John Smellway: 42 games = 82 TD
Jim Kelly: 44 games = 40 TD
Dan Marino: 44 games = 77 TD
Steve Young: 34 games = 74 TD
Joe Montana: 27 games = 39 TD
Joe flipping Namath: 30 games = 39 TD
What is your point? Different offenses, different eras, different everything...
Guess this goes to show stats mean very little without context
Context is that he accounted for 120 td's in only 37 games.
The Montana one is what got me. I know it was a different era but damn. Less than 1.5 touchdowns a game and ended up 4-0 in super bowls
Why you call him John Smellway? 😂
So happy to see this Bo nix tape. Been high since last years draft before he decided to go back!
Chris always has solid rankings, not always 100% hit but higher % than other talking heads out there! Can’t wait for other positions.
I'd love for Connor Rogers to talk with Sims about his rankings
No one cares about what Conner Rogers thinks...
@@msp5138imagine hating on someone you barely know, who hasn’t done anything wrong, who hasn’t hated on anyone lol. Why are you mad?
@@msp5138you’ve been on CZcams 17 years, 100 comments on this channel alone lmao. 1 subscriber. No one cares WHAT YOU THINK
@@msp5138Conner has a job talking sports, he has more money than you, and he talks sports for a living. You’re miserable and hating bc you can’t do that. We know you’d love to get paid to talk sports, unfortunately you’re not good enough😢
@@msp5138you mean someone who actually scouts college players
It’s back 🔥🔥❤❤👍👍
we may not agree alot on these rankings some years but on this one I'm so glad you see what I saw. Caleb and Daniels are levels above Maye. To see scouts and tv pundits claiming he's QB 1B only behind Williams all year has been frustrating to say the least.
Been waiting for ts
❤❤❤Awesome Job
Chris Simms unbuttoned Thanx Bra.
Curious about his thoughts on Spencer Rattler.
This is it!!! Can Simms predict the best QB in this years class AGAIN!???
“…..here’s the context of that in my evaluation too, alright?…” Ahmed’s face: huh?
Chris is helping Maye fall to the Giants at 6. I appreciate it!
I wondered when Bo Nix would rise up... Chris is the second guy today who ranked him this high, and the other guy GUARANTEED that GMs would fall in love with his "tape" (even though video tape hasn't been used this century -- football people are always one technology behind -- it used to always be "I have to watch the film" but now its always tape, I'm waiting for someone to say digital)
I agree with Chris, too on Bo Nix. I don't see why people are down on him. He's basically the perfect modern game manager. He's efficient, fast, and has a strong arm, and he gets to his first read quickly, and he hits it every time. What's the problem😂😂😂
I was watching the Go Long podcast and the former GM they had on there said GMs will "fall in love" with Nix@@123abcDamion
i think he will nail the sean payton one. perfect guy for him. pretty sure a lot of teams before him would have already filled their qb position. i still think justin fields will be a falcon before the draft. kirk cousins back with the vikings. the raiders will take one.
@@dodu8281This take of yours didn’t pan out at all!
If the Bears pass on Caleb, I don't think I can watch them anymore.
Especially after they Traded Fields......get the Kid Let's Go
@@worldbeater44April 25th my man! Less than a month and we get a generational qb! Great time to be a Bears fan! Suffered through many decades of having below average to average qbs.
If it weren't for Bo Nix this ranking *would* be color gradient coordinated once again. Love your stuff as always!
Comparing Caleb’s College stats to those of legendary NFL QB’s college stats:
Caleb Williams: 37 games = 93 TD / 14 Int / 10,082 Yards / 169 Rating + Rushing: 966 Yards / 27 TD
Tom Brady: 29 games = 30 TD / 17 Int / 4,773 Yards / 134 Rating + Rushing: -150 Yards / 3 TD
Peyton Manning: 45 games = 89 TD / 33 Int / 11,201 Yards / 147 Rating + Rushing: -181 Yards / 12 TD
Eli Manning: 43 games = 81 TD / 35 Int / 10,119 Yards / 137 Rating + Rushing: -135 Yards / 5 TD
Andrew Luck: 38 games = 82 TD / 22 Int / 9,430 Yards / 162 Rating + Rushing: 957 Yards / 7 TD
Cam Newton: 20 games = 30 TD / 7 Int / 2,908 Yards / 178 Rating + Rushing: 1,586 Yards / 24 TD
Colt Brennan: 38 games = 131 TD / 42 Int / 14,193 Yards / 167 Rating + Rushing: -547 Yards / 15 TD
Tim Tebow: 55 games = 88 TD / 16 Int / 9,285 Yards / 170 Rating + Rushing: 2,947 Yards / 57 TD
John Smellway: 42 games = 77 TD / 39 Int / 9,349 Yards / 139 Rating + Rushing: -279(?) Yards / 5 TD
Jim Kelly: 44 games = 33 TD / 28 Int / 5,228 Yards / 128 Rating + Rushing: 124 Yards / 7 TD
Dan Marino: 44 games = 74 TD / 64 Int / 7,905 Yards / 129 Rating + Rushing: -270 Yards / 3 TD
Steve Young: 34 games = 56 TD / 33 Int / 7,733 Yards / 149 Rating + Rushing: 1,080 Yards / 18 TD
Joe Montana: 27 games = 25 TD / 25 Int / 4,121 Yards / 125 Rating + Rushing: 104 Yards / 14 TD
Joe flipping Namath: 30 games = 24 TD / 20 Int / 2,713 Yards / 125 Rating + Rushing: 563 Yards / 15 TD
I really like Bo nix as well. Seems to make the right decisions and is super accurate. I think Maye is a classic boom or bust, I wouldn’t take him with the third pick for that reason but I could totally see him excelling in the right system.
Yesssss
I like this guy’s analysis
COULDNT BE MORE STOKEDD
What pundents missed on Richardson is he's a QB who can run at an elite level. His pocket awareness and arm talent is top tier. So is his running.
Too many people thought he was an athlete who was playing QB.
His mechanics have been rebuilt, and by all accounts, he still has a top tier arm. He just needs to learn to go out of bounds and be aware of defenders from behind.
Chris/Orlovsky/Rg3 and Ryan Leaf should do a joint breakdown
Jayden Daniel’s is an absolute beast.
I love how excited Simms gets whenever he can talk about Mahomes
I love how people just walk by lol
Chris Simms is the man!!!
Looking forward to seeing Jayden in the pros!!! As a Bama fan, glad he won’t be on the field for LSU 😅. But seriously wish him the best!!
oh yeah Unbuttoned that shirt, your chocking me
i never noticed it but Chris says “right” so much if you listen to it, that’s all you hear lol
I appreciate Chris' expertise on QBs. His assessment of Drake is persuasive. I am really curious as to where Drake will be drafted. It seems a reach for him to be chosen the 3rd QB ahead of JJ, Bo, and Michael.
Drake Maye = Mitch Trubisky
or maybe even Carson Wentz 😮
@@garyb7193 Carson was damned good until he got injured!~
@@Mattyice2611It is more than that they have in common. Both got overhyped during the season. Both had their flaws exposed leading up to the draft, and I suspect that like Trubisky, that Maye will be overdrafted versus where he should go. Now if Maye goes late first to a team that can sit him for a year and let him develop then their stories could diverge wildly, but I don't expect that to happen.
Chris is in his bagggg
Comparing 2024 Draft Class QB stats:
Caleb Williams: 37 games = 93 TD / 14 Int / 10,082 Yards / 169 Rating + Rushing: 966 Yards / 27 TD
Jayden Daniels = 55 games = 89 TD / 20 Int / 12,515 Yards / 158 Rating + Rushing: 3,307 Yards / 35 TD
Drake Maye: 30 games = 63 TD / 16 Int / 8,018 Yards / 154 Rating + Rushing: 1,209 Yards / 16 TD
J.J. McCarthy: 40 games = 49 TD / 11 Int / 6,226 Yards / 160 Rating + Rushing: 632 Yards / 10 TD
Michael Penix: 49 games = 91 TD / 32 Int / 12,788 Yards / 148 Rating + Rushing: 247 Yards / 13 TD
Bo Nix: 61 games = 113 TD / 26 Int / 15,352 Yards / 149 Rating + Rushing: 1,613 Yards / 38 TD
Spencer Rattler = 48 games = 77 TD / 32 Int / 10,807 Yards / 152 Rating + Rushing: 410 Yards / 16 TD
Carson Beck = 25 games = 30 TD / 8 Int / 4,427 Yards / 166 Rating + Rushing: 175 Yards / 4 TD
Looking forward to seeing where Bo ends up!! Wish him the best!!!
Drake Maye #6 is completely unhinged. The biggest shift to the NFL is the time to make decisions and the size of the windows. I agree, he looks to be slow on the progressions. But NO ONE in this class had to and did fit the ball into tighter windows more consistently. Give me the arm talent, teach him the mental game.
The funny thing is that Chris said he’s one of the best he’s ever seen reading defenses & making the right decisions. But all the caleb haters say he’s terrible at those things & plays backyard football 24/7
What are your thoughts ninja😊
the difference between the youtube comments and what I saw on twitter is hilarious
The episode I look the forward to the most every season. Simms and QB analysis goes together like lamb and tuna fish
Let’s go !
Simms QB ranking of the 2022 class, 1.Matt Corral 2.Kenny Pickett 3.Malik Willis 4.Sam Howell 5.Desmond Ridder.
So he got the order of total garbage wrong and missed on Purdy like the entire universe did?
@@davidclark3474Literally. All of them are bad anyways and everyone knew it as well. The class was bad so he was essentially analyzing a bunch of 2nd to 4th rounder which he definitely struggles with (see Mond). Apart from that and Wilson his analysis is usually spot on
@@davidclark3474 I didn't really have a point. Just thought it was interesting.
Matt Corral had some other stuff going on, that's why he failed. He'll be back to the league soon
@@TomatoPace Corral the NFL is done with you and thinks you don't have it good luck getting another shot. Corral has zero chance of being an NFL QB. He whiffed on his chance. He was a total project anyway. 2 years of hard work and he still might have failed. He had way to maybe problems as a QB.
What's with the no fade on the haircut?
Caleb is the best college QB I’ve ever seen. I don’t know if it translates to the NFL cause he can try to do too much hero ball but his peaks were absolutely unmatched.
it's hilarious seeing how many people say things like "too much hero ball, don't know if it translates to the NFL" lol it's like people expected him to stand like a statue in the pocket behind an absolutely porous useless o-line and carve people up like Brady in his prime........ if you actually watch he consistently displays elite pocket awareness, elite ability to slide from side to side while still keeping his eyes downfield and delivering on point throws while on the move with a lightning quick release...... yet people don't know if that "translates" to the NFL??? wow
Williams is overrated. Kyler Murray is a special elite caliber QB don’t get me wrong but if you look at their profiles over at NFL Website Murray is graded higher coming out at 6.80 n coming out was a generational caliber QB he was just shorter at 5”10.5, if he was 6”2/220 everybody would said he’s the next John Elway. Steve Young is only an inch taller than KM at 5”11.5. You look at Caleb Williams top ranked passer in this class he posted a 6.70 grade, not quite as good as KM and Williams Heisman season of 2022 wasn’t as good as Murray’s Heisman season of 2018.
@@K1forMVPKyler is another generational prospect, just because Williams isn’t as good doesn’t mean he won’t be great in the league. The bears are a significantly better situation than the Cardinals were Kyler’s rookie year.
Seems chris being a qb you know what other qbs see with the really great ones and i could see why you llove the qbs that can make throws very few can and u being a qb doesnt take anything for granted knowing how hard to play qb at professional level. Those guys that come along like several we have now in the AFC is really the golden age of great qbs. We are lucky to be alive now to see it!
Those guys you get wowed by so do I and most fans too but you really know how hard it is, but those guys with cannon arms throwing at any angle then their ability to run when they need to just all around great athletes it's easy to see them make 1 of those crazy great plays and you are sold. I get that.
Why is there such a wide gap on Nix between former NFL QBs and other analysts like PFF and Bleacher report, who have him rated much lower?
That play at 24:48 is absurd. Seriously go through it frame by frame and there isn't a single second that anyone looked open until he threw the TD.
I don't need to click that to know what play you're talking about. Watching the all-22, it's insane that he even found something to work with, let alone throw a touchdown.
Thanks for pointing that out 👍. It looked like a great play at normal speed, but it needs to be slowed down to really appreciate it.
This guy really loves the way Caleb plays in college. If the Bears have a bad season, then I guess it won't because of Calev.
I wish we could watch college football in Sweden. At least NFL Game Pass give me all I need for NFL. Oh and thanks Chris Simms very interesting as always listening to you.
The hate on Caleb Williams is the
Most I’ve ever seen from a QB prospect
Just wait til he fails~
I wish I was in your fantasy league 🤣
@@stevenwrighte1022 Exactly RIGHT,. Another Fantasy guy who thinks he knows about Football,..YOU DON'T~
Hate? From who? 😂..The media has been toting this dudes jock all year acting like he's gonna be Patrick Mahomes and Tom Brady's love child. It's ridiculous.
@@randomhero8662 What I luvv most is he's soo composed that he CAN'T have Any competition from Fields,.lol,..
Dude's going to be a Bust~
Drake Maye sounds a lot like Zach Wilson
oh god not even close lol
COME ON CHICAGO .. Get Me My Franchise QB .. CW lets GO
Is that a QB School "Let’s GO."?
@@sidpackard8613 uuhhh it could be!!?? 😂
My thoughts are why is Simms so convinced that Jayden will be a better playmaker or throwing the ball over the middle when even he admits its not something you've seen him do with consistency on tape.
It’s called love.
I think 16 is where my Seahawks may be too late for Penix. I am crossing my fingers that the Hawks draft him, and he sits behind Geno for a year. Only so he gets a feel for the NFL. He won't have a problem with the offense as Grubb Seattle's OC was his OC with the Huskies.
Chris a lot of people like to talk shit on you and your takes. I don’t see the point considering this is mostly guesswork🤷🏽♂️ Been a big fan since the Adam Lefkoe days!
As a Georgia Tech fan, I’ve been unsure why Drake Maye was hyped so high. UNC lost twice to GT with Maye at QB and I was not impressed. I’ve seen QBs like Russell Wilson, Phillip Rivers or Matt Ryan shred our team and it was obvious they were NFL talent. Maye never struck me that way.
DRake Maye went to my High school and I'm not a huge fan~
His personality isn't one that translates to me~
Qb is a Leadership role position~
Love seeing my USC dudes doing well. Super excited about Caleb! Fight on!!
Having said that, people talk shit about Brock Purdy size...how he's small...
Brock Purdy:
Height: 6 ft 1 in (1.85 m)
Weight: 220 lb (100 kg)
Caleb Williams:
Height 6 ft 1 in (1.85 m)
Weight 215 lb (98 kg)
I get that Caleb is more talented, better arm, athleticism, etc, but the size argument is dumb...
So wrong on Drake Maye. Dude is an absolute baller and he had to force balls into tight windows. Also brings ability to run for first downs. This criticism about him missing wide open throws is totally unfounded.
Watch the tape. It says otherwise. Was it some other QB playing for him when he airmails throws? No. Watch him play. Don't watch the highlights. 3 good throws a game doesn't make you a great QB.
2021 #1 Zach Wilson
Number one analyst
Simms is spot on with all 6 QBs. Caleb’s at the top, Drake Maye’s just a more talented Trubisky.
I think Jayden Daniels is the best QB in this draft. Hoping the Redskins draft him
There is no such team by that name
Finally! lol 💪🏽 let’s go!
Curious on simms point of view on Tualia Tagoviola. For some reason hes been buried for some reason
Because he’s not as talented as his older brother who is an average NFL QB. So with him you get an untalented backup, not worth drafting.
@@jamesclark7630 this ain't the most stable take on either Tagovialoa, good luck with it.
@@jamesclark7630Tua Is not average lol😊
Comparing Caleb’s College stats to those of current NFL QB’s college stats:
Caleb Williams: 37 games = 93 TD / 14 Int / 10,082 Yards / 169 Rating + Rushing: 966 Yards / 27 TD
Patrick Mahomes: 32 games = 93 TD / 29 Int / 11,252 Yards / 152 Rating + Rushing: 845 Yards / 22 TD
Justin Fields = 34 games = 67 TD / 9 Int / 5,701 Yards / 178 Rating + Rushing: 1,133 Yards / 19 TD
Joe Burrow: 38 games = 78 TD / 11 Int / 8,852 Yards / 172 Rating + Rushing: 820 Yards / 13 TD
Jordan Love = 38 games = 60 TD / 29 Int / 8,600 Yards / 137 Rating + Rushing: 403 Yards / 9 TD
Justin Herbert: 43 games = 95 TD / 23 Int / 10,541 Yards / 153 Rating + Rushing: 560 Yards / 13 TD
Josh Allen: 27 games = 44 TD / 21 Int / 5,066 Yards / 137 Rating + Rushing: 733 Yards / 13 TD
Trevor Lawrence: 40 games = 90 TD / 17 Int / 10,098 Yards / 164 Rating + Rushing: 943 Yards / 18 TD
Will Levis = 39 games = 46 TD / 25 Int / 5,876 Yards / 145 Rating + Rushing: 742 Yards / 17 TD
Matthew Stafford = 39 games = 51 TD / 33 Int / 7,731 Yards / 133 Rating + Rushing: 213 Yards / 6 TD
Bryce Young: 36 games = 80 TD / 12 Int / 8,356 Yards / 165 Rating + Rushing: 162 Yards / 7 TD
CJ Stroud: 27 games = 85 TD / 12 Int / 8,123 Yards / 182 Rating + Rushing: 136 Yards / 1 TD
Jalen Hurts: 56 games = 80 TD / 20 Int / 9,477 Yards / 162 Rating + Rushing: 3,274 Yards / 43 TD
Kyler Murray: 29 games = 50 TD / 14 Int / 5,406 Yards / 181 Rating + Rushing: 1,478 Yards / 13 TD
Baker Mayfield: 48 games = 131 TD / 30 Int / 14,607 Yards / 175 Rating + Rushing: 1,083 Yards / 21 TD
Brock Purdy: 48 games = 81 TD / 33 Int / 12,170 Yards / 151 Rating + Rushing: 1,177 Yards / 19 TD
Caleb has almost twice as many passing yards as JF in just 3 more games
LAMAR JACKSON = 38 games = 119 tds 9043 yds passing 69 passing tds 27 ints , 4132 rushing yards 50 tds
@@oaklandtraphouse Maybe I should have made a list of all the Heisman winning QB's.
@spiritualarchitect4276 your list is awesome just was missing LJ
Chris Simms deserves to be a GM with the amount of knowledge he brings to the table
Big fan of Penix. He’s going to be great in the pros! 🎉
Tier 1
1. Caleb Williams
2. Jayden Daniels
Tier 2
3. Bo Nix
4. Michael Penix jr.
Tier 3
5. Drake Maye
6. JJ McCarthy
SMH
Tier 1
Caleb
Drake
Tier 2
Jayden
JJ
Tier 3
Penix
Tier 4
Everyone else
Can not believe he put Nix at 3
Is this podcast done in an airport?
A lot of people getting down on Maye.. this draft talk getting interesting
Jordan Travis is my guy this year.
1. Caleb Williams
2. Drake Maye
3. Michael Penix
4. Jayden Daniels
5. Bo Nix
6. JJ McCarthy
I think Caleb as #1 as one of the best qb prospects of the last decades and Daniels as #2 with his huge athletic upside will age very well. Don’t think there a chance they’ll fail.
Maye at 6 is definitely a bit much but I can see him struggling. Still wouldn’t have him below McCarthy and Nix.
If Penix stays fit I have no doubt in my mind he’ll work out. His arm and his ball placement is just too good.
Nix is very much pro ready so I get where Chris is coming from. Just don’t think he has that much of an upside. With McCarthy I just don’t see it honestly
Christopher Zachory Wilson Simms has released his QB rankings