Worst Referee Decisions
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 01. 2023
- Hello Audience Welcome To Our Channel.
We Provide Interesting Spectacles Around Badminton Sports.
Hope You Like Him And Don't Forget To Subscribe To Our Channel.
If you ever wish a video to be taken down, all you need to do is ask and i will take it down immediately.
I have worked hard to build this channel and would be sad to lose it for something so trivial. Thanks for understanding. Peace.
Thank you
Source: BadmintonWorld.Tv
DISCLAIMER : Some contents are used for educational purpose under fair use. COPYRIGHT DISCLAIMER : Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
badminton rackets, badminton net, badminton grip, lee zii jia vs Kento momota bwf sudirman cup 2021, badminton, raquets, net, grip, shuttle, shuttlecock, best badminton racket, racket, yonex, - Sport
It's been mentioned many time, but Ill say it again, badminton need better review system, it's a shame for the sport and the players.
they dont take it seriously.
Bwf needs to be reformed
What made me mad is that umpires didn't get into trouble at all for all of their mistakes. I know that we all make mistakes, but we do pay for the mistakes and so should they. They deserve the punishments for causing trouble for players. It's kinda bullshit that they can still be arrogant like it's not a big deal.
I agree with everything u said but how do u know they are arrogant? They are just doing their job and made mistakes.
@@SiNNEi2 I don't know if they are arrogant off the court or as a person, but the way they treated the players after making a controversy call to me is arrogant. Of course, not all umpires are like that. Some of them was nice to apology, but most of the times I just heard them telling to players to respect their decision and brush it off by announcing the score. Even if bwf gave them the privilege to do that, it's still very bs way to handle it to me. That makes it look like it wasn't a big deal. I have had many controversies with my opponents in the tournaments as well because we self scored all the time, but I always apologize to my opponent for the trouble even though I was firmed with my decisions.
@@pham1020 Perhaps the word you are looking for is politeness, not arrogance. Being firm with decisions isn't arrogant, however sounds to me you cited them as being firm with decisions but could have been more polite =p
@@SiNNEi2 No, that's definitely beyond impolite to me. Perhaps the correct term that I should have used is "rude". But still doesn't change my opinion about that because they do look very arrogant when they do it.
Idiotic comment. They don't deserve punishment. They are told when they make a mistake and they get a grade. Punishing them will not help at all. You can give them lower level games if they consistently make big mistakes but not for a single mistake...
BWF should make much better review and judge system so that NOBODY would complain about the match result
they took all the money for themselves, no money to improve call system like VAR in soccer. That's why nobody watch badminton much because umpires suck
Badminton needs a better review system for all calls. In these videos an instant slow re-play that takes less than 1 min could have awarded points correctly. Case where players were given points when they shouldn't have, means the technology is not correct. Umpires and BWF needs to admit fault and errors to make itself become a more reputable and credible sport
nobody takes badminton seriously.
@@melonusk6120which is very unfortunate.
Some of these are indeed terrible calls, but quite a few are ridiculously close. Hard to blame the umpire when it takes a bit to see things even with slow mo replay.
Yeah that first one was tough
5:25, that's nasty. How is that possible to have umpire from same country?
its indian league
That is ethically not right at all. Correct.
you realise the line judge, audience and that dude on the wall are all indians ?
@@melonusk6120 no its not..
@@adrianwong69 well chinese have been cheating many time you see in their leagues
indian umpire ☕
The referee that said no challenge next time .. i was really dumbfounded by that.. even the var shows it was in and he still stuck to his decision.. woot? and what ? next time? when is next time? Next tournament? Lol..
I don't think Goh said he wasn't ready. He's saying that the server faked before serving. Which should be fault.
He was arguing in the match that he was not ready go and watch the real footage
Just because you think doesnot change the fact and the video
He didn't fake the serve... he just moved with his racket head to the side and Goh reacted to it and that shouldn't be a fault. The rules clearly state that you can move after racket hits the shuttle.
Goh was definitely wrong here.
infact Goh should be faulted.
Love the thumbnail “Stop crying” 😅
やりたい事を我慢してバドミントンに人生を捧げた結果の
審判がこれじゃたまったものじゃねーなぁ
Bwf needs to have a heavy punishment if a ref fck up, these refs are too prideful to admit they're wrong
最初のチェンユーフェイのやつはラケット出てるからフォルトでしょ
04:04 HD 4K quality video
3:43 二度打ちはアウトだろう！完全にダブルタッチ！
If you hit it twice, you're out! Completely double touch!
山口は目が良いんだな
よく、2度打ちに気づいたなぁ。スローでようやく解る
よ～く見ると3度打ちっぽいね
3:55 chenyufei contacted the shuttle THREE times. Wow, and the umpire missed that?
try to read how the badminton rule is
@@liangliangsong631 so it's legal?????
@@gameothers2022 she touched the shuttle 2 times instead of 3 times, and according to the badminton regulation, when one player hit the shuttle 2 times in one continuous movement, then it's legal.
@@liangliangsong631 I researched the rules again thanks to your comment, and I've just known that it's indeed legal if the shuttle is hit 2 times in one motion. For those who are curious, here's the rule I got from a forum:
13. FAULTS
It shall be a 'fault':
...
13.3 If in play, the shuttle:
...
13.3.8 is hit twice in succession by the same player. However, a shuttle hitting the head and the stringed area of the racket in one stroke shall not be a 'fault'.
@@kagendralaga it's great that you stepped out telling the truth to let everyone know the rule in such details. well done mate.
👍
Some people got ego soo big that when it's okay to make mistake since it's mendable but they wont
I guess what Pranav J Chopra did was a double action unlike what Chirag Shetty does today. Chirag has a flow-stop-hit whereas what Pranav did was ready-move the frame- hit
@prashanttrivedi2262 I felt like the server just changed the direction a bit to his left and served in one action, which should be a legal serve. Can you explain what flow-stop-hit and ready-move the frame-hit are?
@@ramprasadcr what I meant was that Jerry was in position and he switched his racket direction suddenly which should not have been the case, if one wishes to change the direction they should change the face of the racket' frame with the help of the fingers or wrist, not move the entire hand
Whereas chirag has a flow, he stops and then hits which is legal.
I’m really just waiting for the day that umpires and referees are made redundant.. everything should be based on tech
Camera can record the problem but cannot challenge the problem by player.
It's the highest speed sport, VAR is most necessary when compare with the others.
ビンジャオ選手って度々かわいそうな判定されるよね
アンセヨン選手との試合で（韓国開催？）ビンジャオ選手がアウトジャッジして、チャレンジしたら映像だとアウトなのにホークアイは全然イン判定にされたりしてた。
動画もそうだけど、納得いかないような内容なのに猛抗議しない当たり人柄の良さを感じる、真面目なんだろうなって。
If only we had the technological capability to review plays afterwards, watch from all angles, and then make the right call. Oh well,maybe in 75 years when we have such capabilities 🤫🤭
Oh the technology is available, they just have to want to use it.
@@jasontan5808 that was the point of my comment. Pure sarcasm
Challenge to umpire decision should be adopted.
How did these people qualify as umpires? Nepotism?
how about when minions vs ong teo? hawk eye is suck
BMF should abolish this stupid serve and stupid empire.
music way too loud (near the end it gets better)
1つ目のやつに関してはオーバーネットじゃね？
The player from India and the Umpire from the same country?
where is the 3rd umpire?
3:51 maybe i'm wrong, but I think it's considered as ok when double-hit is done in one stroke
U r wrong
you are wrong
India referee says is out but is in bro so easy to see bro
The flick serve against Goh was fine. Good job umpire. Others are a bit trickier, hard to see in real time.
that wasnt about flick serve , that was about that the player was not ready
@@punjabmixtape9383 Goh was ready, he even moved before the opponent made the serve, the umpire call was correct.
they need to train their eyes
There should be challenge for all cases, only thing have to do is video replay
How much for 2 high speed cameras around the net?
Referee 💜🙏🏻
Bad Indian umpire
Just take a look at the replay from cameras like we all do. It's a dead simple!! The whole umpires system is just BS!
I don't understand the MD match of goh/tan what was the decision there?
BWF needs an overhaul of its umpiring system. Way too strict and often harsh on the players. Needs to be a lot fairer, more time given and stop being so petty/arrogant.
何にしろ全スポーツの審判のひくさには驚きました、
3:55 Unintentional double hits are allowed
Today I learned you can hit the shuttle twice, as long as it's one stroke, and as long as one hit is with the strings and the other is with the frame.
5:21 best tournament in the world!
We watched so many human errors by Ref, and we also found so many dishonest players too
😮💨
India always blame politics to anything, dont use the them.
it is not double hit if one player hit with one continuous move.
It's really really suck why there isn't VTR challenging about referring fault yet. BWF??
any sport need controversy yes to make it more interesting,,,,
from this video we know where's the problem
is it just me.... or half of these bad calls are done by indian refs?
i think most of the umpire cant even play a decent game of badminton themselves judging from their body shapes. probably they need to learn to play badminton to be more competent umpire.
Can someone explain the first one?
Umpiring badminton is not easy. I played in a social grade where the action was not all that fast but one day I got asked to umpire a much higher grade match. And made quite a few mistakes - the losing player was not happy but he was the one who asked me to umpire😂😂
No player asked you to umpire. It is your job only. Please adopt the challenge to umpires decision due to their poor performance.
Background music == WHY
@ 2:34 serve must be below armpit to not be called a fault
This is one stupid sport that a wrong call is not being corrected by an umpire, what's the point of playing.... imagine these players gives their best, truly they deserve a good call
Badminton umpiring is real Bulls--t .
The umpire itself wearing glasses which means his sight are not 4K level to see the shuttle speed… so the nasty decisions had made😌😌😌
I'm happy somebody pointed out the Sameer Vs Shi Yuqi match! Sameer gave his brilliant performance and lost point at crucial stage.
And what's wrong with these line judges for being this blind or just partial?
its actually very difficult to make these calls as the players in pro leagues are very powerful so the shuttle travels at unfathomable speeds, that makes it very difficult to make calls for in or out, but this is all the more reason bwf needs to add more review systems to surveille the matches as its just upright disrespectful to leave the decisions to human eyes at this level
thats why we need review system
not the line judge, line judge get corrected by hawkeye replay. It is the umpire with no badminton experience that make badminton look so bad
If you pause the video and watch the shuttle position at the point of contact, the feathers which would be hit first in this case, would actually be on Shi Yuqi's side of the court, therefore not a foul.
Rule 13.4.2
It shall be a fault if in play, a player invades an opponent’s court over the net with racket or person except that the striker may follow the shuttle over the net with the racket in the course of a stroke after the initial point of contact with the shuttle is on the striker’s side of the net.
Though this would be a very hard call to make in real time.
Brille? Fielman!
Is the first one a mistake? Didn't racket crossed the net?
The racket *can* cross the net, after hitting the shuttle on the correct side of the net. Which is what appeared to happen.
after finished watch dam they aren't bad Referee but call them a trash people on earth -*-
審判が自我持つな
Incompetent umpires and the REFREES in their red polo, utterly useless. Still BWF stand with them.Time to revamp this system.
I don't understand India vs malaysia double men what happen with malaysian?
why BWF still using these unprofessional umpires? can someone tell me?
バドミントンの審判は動体視力の落ちた年寄りには無理だよ
本当にそれ❗プラス、私 長年審判やってますから。から来るプライド❗
stupid calls, those are why this sport is always behind tennis.
Take out those refers from badminton waste of time and players will be dissatisfied of game
If you don't admit it after hitting the ball twice, you will lose the face of the Chinese people
I knew this sport was immature. Not clean at the same time. That's too bad.
後半の字幕めんどくさくなっちゃったかな？何が問題になったかわからなかった……
Why does tennis has young kids with good eyes watching the lines, but in Badminton I only see old people probably with bad eyesight?😅
because tennis has lots of money... 2022 US Open total prize was $60,102,000. For badminton? All England 2022 $1,000,000.
Come on.... Badminton players are more sporty than football, should rivals who are aware of being able to use sportsmanship in football, giving 1 time way to goals, or bouncing the shuttlecock out
1ストロークで2回当たるのはいいんじゃなかったっけ
In football players cheat and gets away. In badminton it's the umpire that get away
since players can challenge the line judge with the hawkeye system, then why not they get the right to challenge the umpire with the recording playback system? BWF want to get fcuked?
3:46山口茜對陳雨菲那球以後一定還會被一直拿出來說，有沒有二次擊球陳雨菲一定最清楚，但她那得分後的笑容握拳與鏡頭重播畫面形成強烈對比 ! ! 安賽龍與周天成也曾發生過類似情形，因無法挑戰，周天成只好吞下，但下一球龍王就回送一分，林丹也發生過一次，對手殺球很貼邊線被線審判OUT，林丹示意主審要挑戰，主審還跟他(林丹)再次確認，林丹堅決挑戰，結果是顆壓線球，用自己的挑戰權還給對手一分！！這就是高度的差別。 Google translate：3:46 Akane Yamaguchi told Chen Yufei that the ball would be taken out all the time, Chen Yufei must know the most about whether there was a second hit, but her smiling fist after scoring was in sharp contrast to the replay of the camera!! Axelsen and A similar situation happened to Zhou Tiancheng. Because he could not challenge, Zhou Tiancheng had to swallow it, but the Dragon King sent back a point for the next ball. It also happened to Lin Dan once. The opponent smashed the ball very close to the sideline and was judged out by the line. Challenge, the referee also reconfirmed with him (Lin Dan), Lin Dan resolutely challenged, and the result was a line-pressing ball, and he used his right to challenge to return a point to the opponent! ! This is the difference in height.
try understand the rule first 🙂
13.3.7. ...However, a shuttle hitting the head and the stringed area of the racket in one stroke shall not be a ‘fault’. 一次挥拍，球碰到线和框，不算违例。陈雨菲这个球，放慢很多倍，反复看，也许有那么一点点违例的嫌疑。但是正常比赛中，裁判是不可能做到的，并且这也仅仅是有一点点嫌疑罢了，严格按照规则，这就不算违例。
if you do not know the badminton rule at all， try to be humble.
@@ilikerei 慢放多倍很容易让人忽略高速运动中的惯性和运动员重心改变带来的方向偏移。要定义这不是one stroke，广义来讲至少应当要有正常速度下的明显停顿和再次发力。我之前想要考裁判证，和training里认识的provincial umpire请教过这一条。
What's the crap background music for. You can't hear the sound of the rackets and shuttle just this annoying droning on Musak
最初のはラケットがネットを超えてるように見えるが？
INDIA
Remove the music
Why most of them are indians
Indian referees are not neutral..
There are 2 reason terrible judgement happen.
1. It is just that Umpire or Line judge cannot clearly see the shuttlecocks due to too fast. Challenge system is existing to solve this issue. I hope ,in the future, challenge system is utilized for judging over net fault or touch net fault as well as line judge. besides it, each country working on training to increase the ability of umpires is also mandatory.
2. Patronizing specific players of self-country, especially the country where the tournament is taking place. This should be expelled.
your bg music is too loud
3:47 according to the rule, that’s one motion, not the double hits!
There no point in arguing on some of these mistakes as human error is possible as its hard to detect. On such cases it is better for the players to keep on playing without losing the calm
Very Dirty referring
誤判的好瞎
Stupid reffree
The only sport where I have no shame in saying that most referees are a**h*** and sport allows them to be.
the first one, the racket is over on the other side, she didn't touch the net, but going over is illegal. Right call by the umpire
as long as contact point is on the players side its okay if other parts of the racket crosses the net.
Obviously these referees think they should be part of the storyline. I guess they weren't hugged enough when they were kids, so they need to get some attention, good or bad, as grown adults.
まあ公正じゃない事は明白特に中国は酷いね
What's going on with that music ?
Do we really need that ?
I don't get it !
Chen Y.F...no fair play