Latino Conservatives Debate Liberals on the Wall, Amnesty, and Political Polarization (Part 2/2)
Vložit
- čas přidán 13. 06. 2019
- Part 2 of our sit-down between liberal and conservative members of the Latinx community duking it out at the VICE Miami office.
WATCH PART 1: • Liberal Latinos Debate...
What does it mean to be Latinx? Who voted for Trump, and why? How are his policies affecting the community? What should be done about the crisis at the border, should there be a wall? What does the American Dream look like for Latinx individuals?
00:13 - Trump's Border Wall
02:41 - Undocumented Immigration & Asylum Seekers
06:37 - Amnesty for illegal immigrants already in the US
08:06 - Family Separation: Is family separation at the border immoral?
11:41 - Crisis in Venezuela and refugees
13:10 - What is the American dream for the Latinx community?
14:40 - Divisiveness & Polarization: Can we find common ground?
17:19 - The Political System
18:23 - Who would vote for Trump again in 2020? Why?
19:10 - Welfare & Corporate Handouts
19:48 - Modern Day Colonialism
20:45 - The 2020 Election
21:28 - What does it mean to be Latinx?
Click here to subscribe to VICE: bit.ly/Subscribe-to-VICE
About VICE:
The Definitive Guide To Enlightening Information. From every corner of the planet, our immersive, caustic, ground-breaking and often bizarre stories have changed the way people think about culture, crime, art, parties, fashion, protest, the internet and other subjects that don't even have names yet. Browse the growing library and discover corners of the world you never knew existed. Welcome to VICE.
Connect with VICE:
Check out our full video catalog: bit.ly/VICE-Videos
Videos, daily editorial and more: vice.com
More videos from the VICE network: www. vicevideo
Click here to get the best of VICE daily: bit.ly/1SquZ6v
Like VICE on Facebook: vice
Follow VICE on Twitter: / vice
Follow us on Instagram: / vice
The VICE CZcams Network:
VICE: / vice
MUNCHIES: / munchies
VICE News: / vicenews
VICELAND: / vicelandtv
Broadly: / broadly
Noisey: / noisey
Motherboard: / motherboardtv
VICE Sports: / noc
i-D: / idmagazine
Waypoint: / waypoint - Zábava
¿Quieres ver el video en español? Haz clic en el botón de configuración para cambiar la pista de audio.
Want to watch this in Spanish? Head over to the settings button to change the audio track.
This was the saddest debate I've ever seen. Also, when you are having a debate, the "moderator" is not supposed to be one-sided.
Gigigirl502
That'd only be a problem if the moderator got involved in the conversation or gave one side more time than the other. Her personal views have nothing to do with it. She did a perfectly fine job
Scoring57 she wanted to be involved so bad, plus she just kept questioning the conservative view points....not neutral!
Andrew Sokolowski yes!! She also tried playing the emotional card saying “speaking of your immigrant family what do you think about Trump saying this country cannot take any more immigrants” If she was a true mediator she wouldn’t bring her emotions or his emotions to try to get the young man to agree with her. We see right thru this bull
@Andrew Sokolowski
And you could simply answer that it is moral. Doesn't really matter how she framed the question
Scoring57 have you see the video black conservatives vs liberals...the young man that was the mediator was involved, cared for his community and was black he still managed to remain neutral what you’re supposed to do during a DEBATE
If you're going to have a debate, you need a mediator who is impartial. She's clearly biased.
Totally agree. You can very easily tell she's Left and liberal
Vice is a very liberal platform, but the guy who mediated the debate between black conservatives and black liberals did a way better job of remaining neutral.
For vice media this is the most medium they have ever been. But she was trying to highlight all the emotions over law. Still this video and black conservative video are most reasonable content vice has published.
Good luck finding someone who's actually impartial(ABSOLUTELY EVERYONE is biased, to pretend that isn't true is disingenuous). Although I agree her political leaning is fairly obvious.
@@julia.c.mcclure92 agreed.that was their best segment.
It would be interesting to have these people come back now in 2022 and re-have this "debate" and see if they still feel the same or if anyone changed
On a real note, if we Americans work together and stop worrying about the fictional Boogeyman, we can go forward.
That would be awesome.
totally agree especially the girl that said shes more for "having your own business" you weren't complaining about that loan you got during covid but oh snap less government funding and spending righttt😭😭😂😂😂
“Re-have”…?
Such a great Idea
As a Latino I can say that if anything needs to be cancelled it's Latinx.
I'm my entire 4 decades of life, outside of media, the only people I have heard use the term latinx are non-latino liberals and it makes me cringe everytime. I once made a young white liberal cry because I pointed out that we don't use that term and they shouldn't put that on me because it may be considered derogatory.
VICE accomplished one thing from this video, they got both conservative & liberal latinos to agree on how utterly ridiculous the word “Latinx” is.
Jusker Duu 😂
What does latinx mean
@@thekoalakingdomshow6319 It's an ointment for piles I think
Only American white people call people from South America latinx
@@whydontyouhateme i wish that word would die
the interviewer was very biased her questions did not encourage understanding.
cynthia ferguson agreed. It was so obvious where she stood.
She is Jorge Ramos daughter...the Univision reporter who went to war with Trump
she was horrible. When they were discussing the use of children as tools at the border she totally deflected.
Utterly useless moderator, the black man that did it for the black con vs lib was far better, asked better questions, less bias, and mor intelligent. New video should have brighter people, and a better mod who keeps the people from going off tangent and calling out both sides
She looked like she was freaked out or something?
As a Mexican American This debate was an embarrassment imo
I'm a Mexican American as well and I was proud of some of them. That girl at the top right though... I wouldn't be mad if they edited her out.
@@native00 what’s wrong with that?
@@nicomoreno5028 I felt the same about editing out the Orange shirt girl to the bottom right, the girl with the big dress, dude in The middle with the glasses and the drama Queen next to him with the indigenous garments.
@@nicomoreno5028 she made the most valid points in each of these videos. Why the dislike for her? Also, were you born here or did you immigrate? Why do people hang onto things that they fled from or refused to change? I suppose you can be proud enough of 2 places to use those terms if you're both grateful of the place that gave you a home and are actively involved in solving the issues of the previous country that you fled from. Otherwise, pick a place to be and do it for a reason.
@@justlucky8254 I was born here. I'm pretty liberal. I guess that's the easiest way to explain it to someone who agrees with her. No offense intended. Her opinions weren't even the biggest issue... it was the way she presented them. She really came across as classist. To understand the struggle of your brothers and sisters (literally anyone and everyone, not just natives/latinos) and to empathize with them in their struggles can really add perspective and enrich a person's life. Her mind seems too closed for even that.
It was 3 conservatives vs 6 liberals including the moderator. Not even remotely fair
There are 4 conservatives. 5 Liberals.
But I’m my opinion they won
It was fair. One Conservative can handle a few Liberal's.
And the Cons made more valid points. Facts/feelings
And the conservatives won, liberals have never even used a fact once in my entire time of watching any liberal talk ever.
Did anyone else watch all 50 minutes of these 2 parts and conclude that this entire show had absolutely no point at all and nothing was gained?
YES
The others were all better and actually informative. This one was yelling. After the one that was conservative and liberal women, one of the things they all agreed on was how nice and civil everyone was.
Billy Giuliano I dont know I think they explain it better then actually white Americans lol but again they come from a country where right n left is very different from the United States so it was interesting to watch
Nicely said!
I learned a lot. But perspective.
That moderator should’ve been in one of those seats, since she wants to argue against the conservatives so much
Cuz she was spoiled latino who grew up in a bubble in the suburbs.
@Stockton ca Her dad is Jorge Ramos, a leftist journalist who has personal beef with Trump and paints all Republicans as racist.
@@bgbgef She is not a real latino. she is just an american.
@@TheStepmonkeywhy would you say that?
This whole debate was a mess.
I’ve been on a Vice debate binge and this is the only one of those debates where absolutely no one was able to state a fact, list a statistic, reference a study, etc
The debate was completely feeling based, and it was a shame to not see people who were willing to get down to the nitty gritty and debate policies and laws
👏
It clearly wasn't a debate. It was people sharing their views which was enlightening but pathetic at the same time. The college self-proclaimed wonderboy in the center has been so brainwashed with left-wing liberal ideology it was palpable. He basically didn't have an original thing to say during any of his word salads. That was straight out of his "enlightened" professors mouth. Get off the Kool-Aid little man.
I agree
Moderator was shook when none of them agreed with the term latinx lmaooo
She was sloppy as hell and seemed nervous the whole time
Yeah I won’t lie she was pretty hipster lol no wonder she was so thankful at the end to have experienced all these brown multi lingual ethnic group of people 😂
It’s a stupid term
LatinX = all people from Latin American ancestry ???
So
White means = all people from Caucasian descent in the world??
American racial census is as stupid as necessary
@@19ars92 LatinX isnt a thing in actual latino communities lmao
@@19ars92 White is not an ethnicity. You can be a white Latin_ whatever.
Conservative: **speaks**
Liberal: **cuts them off**
Liberal: **speaks**
Conservative: **cuts them off**
Liberal: **LET HER SPEAK MAN**
Ok...
Xgkotkot I read this comment as it happened in the video
Liberals do the same thing so good for you noticing that
The dude in the glasses who said that I think is a conservative correct me if I'm wrong
Anthony Luna he said in the last video he leans left *corrected*
unfortunately, that's how it goes
The LatinX topic was the one time I saw them all come together as a whole!!! That’s a real conversation They had!
This conversation displays how uneducated our communities are in many topics & the emotional immaturity we carry and lack of consideration for others. We are not always right & we need to take account of other peoples individual experiences. We will never grasp perspective if we constantly interrupt when others are speaking. This was embarrassing to watch on many levels.
felt like everything was outta place and falling apart … literally had to lower the volume when it came to some of this so I couldn’t hear the cringiness outta them except for the Colombian chick and the one in pink with skirt,they knew wassup
Unfortunately this tough subject was mishandled by emotional opinions and very few actual facts
Luis Henry everyone votes with feelings.
As a matter of fact thats how opinions are formed. We have an initial emotional opinion and then find facts to prove that initial emotional reaction. But yeah no one here really knew policies but then again I’m sure they all have lives and can’t dive deep into them.
It's called the feminization of the western world.
PowerTuber 3.0 We should all become narcs and psychopaths with no feelings, like Trump, right?
@@Powertuber1000 stop being gay
You cant have a mediator who is clearly a leftist, that's not how you interview a group of people with differing opinions
It's VICE fakenews, what do you expect? 😎😂
Russian Roulette I wouldn’t really mind if she was a leftist, or even a rightist. But her questions, and bias attitude was just wrong and unbearable. You can be a leftist, but you should ask questions with an open mind, and stop attacking one side. She was so far the worst mediator of all conservative vs. liberals.
Agreed. Vice has had much better. I dont like vice, just want to better understand people. This didn't help much. But much love to my American brothers and sisters from other countries.
Russian Roulette effing definition of leftist bias. She gives the word to the liberals.
i don’t think she portrayed her bias through this talk though. just my opinion
The wall doesn’t say “don’t come in” it says "use the door"
The door was locked
@@shaneekabailey1214 you knock and do it the right way, dont pick the lock. when you pick a lock to get somewhere youre trespassing and youre a criminal.
@@shaneekabailey1214well if a door is locked, I’m pretty sure you knock and don’t break in…right..?
Wise words 👌
@I Am Sylar funny how the door was wide open when it was Europeans but anyone who isn't has to knock first. Are you really dense enough to believe that the white majority became that because millions of them had the financial means to do? I'm here to tell you that they absolutely did not.
I've noticed that conservatives would want to be friends with liberals but liberals wouldn't want to be friends with conservatives. Do you notice that?
yup
@@jimschlat but then again liberald preach acceptance and having an openmind.
@@whateverman2674 unless its not exactly the same as their beliefs
@@jimschlat RIGHT 😅
@@whateverman2674 Exactly, most intolerant people ever
This conversation wasn't nearly as good as the black conservatives vs black liberals video.
P Lindsay; seriously I’m Latino and was excited to hear this. Until the mediator started interjecting biased questions making everyone argue around our issues as a nation rather than facilitating it.
P Lindsay facts!
I came to this vid from the black: con vs lib debate & it did show me different viewpoints.
Yes kween
Not even close
Why is it that the liberals can interrupt the conservatives but when a conservative interrupts a liberal its "let her finish bro"
thats dead ass america right now lol. shits crazy
Identity politics, group ideology, tribalism, collectivism, that's why. The "I want equality people" don't see the whole debate as a free discussion with interruptions and nuances. “All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.”
Liberals believe that liberals are superior to anyone else. They hate conservatives and they especially hate America.
If you interrupt the liberal, they can’t make their point. They can’t hold a coherent thought too long.
They're white knights
Lady in orange just came off as cruel and smoothed brained, insulting the other girl for wearing makeup and saying she didn’t care about being an insulting person
"Would you argue that YOUR MOM would be one of those people?"
This woman, I swear.
She was trying to give him some perspective because his mom entered illegally. She said "could".
@@nicomoreno5028 she's a moderator not a debater. It wasn't her question to ask.
@@nicomoreno5028 Just because he may disagree with his mother’s actions, doesn’t mean he doesn’t love his mom.
@@joshsalcedo2407 Oh yeah, I get that. She wasn't saying that. She was trying to get him to look at it from that perspective. If it were his mother were in that position, would he have the same opinion?
@@shiv.k99 She was asking questions throughout.
The moderater seems biased with an agenda
Seems, it's VICE.
I think her faulty fact checking proved that when they were discussing unemployment.
She is bias.
Vice has a biased agenda
Why do you think that? I didn't see anything biased.
Please release the FULL unedited version of this. Every time someone started to make a good point that I got interested in they were cut off.
Vice is a Liberal organisation. Will never happen. Just like the drive by media whatever fits their agenda.
I agree. There were several times where you could tell the person isn't done and is getting to thier point, but nope, on to the next question.
I agree, the conservatives did interrupt a lot in this discussion.
…......…...really? REALLY???? Oh so we can start ignoring people when they are trying to make a point? @james harm
XD I'm used to this @james harm
The dude in the middle with glasses laughed when they mentioned the American dream like it he's not living it. He claimed to come from a poor Nicaraguan family and now he's about to graduate with a PhD I'd say he's living the American dream.
disliked him the most honestly. winey baby is what he is.
He may have laughed because once upon a time The American Dream sent the US to other countries, and just like in the Middle East, lead to more problems within the government. Also, the American Dream used to be for white rich men. You're not wrong, if he laughed at the entire opportunity of what it is today, that would had been hypocritical, but he gave a few examples of how that dream is affecting Native Americans. That's the American dream at the expense of exploiting others.
@@Flash-pp3cr good point. Can't go back in time and change the wrongs but the way he laughed made it seem like that doesn't exist when apparently he's about to have a pretty nice American dream his family coming from nothing to him graduating with a PhD. I haven't seen this video in some time don't remember exactly what happened
@@match328 These leftists are completely clueless about how fortunate they are. I've traveled extensively and seen the horrors of poverty in other countries, including the country I immigrated from. I am eternally grateful to be here and to have had the chance to financially succeed as I did, knowing that the day our family got the letter from the embassy to come here was the greatest day of our life.
@@abecore who could ever have caused poverty from those other countries? Especially in latin America?
Something I've been noticing is always that the leftist are usually the most hostile...... I thought it was supposed to be the opposite, but is almost as if they forcefully want you to agree with their point of view. Looking at my Dominican fellow compatriota there making faces, being sarcastic and acting as she knows it all makes me feel a type of way.
You are exactly on point. They are always the loudest, angriest and think they are always right and if you don't agree they attack and will not want to be your friend. All liberals are this way and that's why to us regular people they are all bat shyt crazy lol
Liberals almost always most hostile
Why should a left leaning minority be ok and make amends with a conservative who willing to vote to strip their rights away? Because the Puerto Ricans being colonized and killed doesn’t affect the conservatives.
@@amandaliu7439 the same can be said visa versa. Except if you're referring to baby murder, that was never a right which is why the Supreme Court finally pushed that decision back to the states dimwit.🙄 oh please leave Puerto Rico out of your delusional mouth!
@@amandaliu7439 lol Puertoricans being Colonized and Killed? Sure ok. Puertorican government can even organize to receive and distribute all help/aid received during Maria and even under American government watch, they are extremely corrupt. Puerto Rico doesn't produce much of anything at this point, US bailed Puerto Rico in the 1930s or 1940s when its people were practically dying of hunger and immigrating to DR. Now is easy to live in the US while also bashing the US and promoting Puertorican independance.... but anyhow, the situation can be seeing from different point of views so you can choose your stand and that's perfectly fine.
Usually I enjoy these but this was by far the worst moderator. Practically arguing in the debate herself, wording questions to give an obvious, strong bias. Did she even know she was a moderator?
maximilian fontaine agree!!!!w
maximilian fontaine facts!
Agreed
@@unorubbertoe I knew she was going to be biased just by her haircut. 😆
maximilian fontaine I’m glad im not the only one who noticed that. Even gave her own input at times
Latinx sounds like a cleaning product.
Solunous i feel horrible for actually laughing at that 🤣
Lmfao for real
Winner
Porn site
Solunous I am latino and I never heard about that term.
Something that has always bothered me about the term “American” is that it is somehow exclusive to one country in the Americas
Thank you! It sounds so blatantly ignorant to me and yet somehow nobody ever seems to mind it?
Is such a egocentric move to people in the U.S.A call themselves americans. America isn't just U.S.A
In English, that’s the only word we have. We don’t have an equivalent term to “estadounidense,” which is the term I use when speaking Spanish. We don’t do it to be disrespectful or exclusionary; it’s just a feature of our language.
Also, it only seems to be people from Spanish-speaking countries that have a problem with this. Canadians don’t identify as Americans unless perhaps they actually are US citizens. And I doubt that someone from Mexico, Colombia, or Argentina would describe themselves as “American” when asked.
Also, in the US, we’re taught that North and South America are separate continents. We say “the Americas” if we’re referring to both together.
United States is known as America and that's how it is, nothing wrong with that
@@seandavila835this right here. I don’t know why it’s so hard for some people to understand. Why would we say “Americans” to refer to the entirety of both North, South, and Latin Americas? In most situations we would never even talk about all the people in that land mass, especially with how Latinos want to differentiate between all these nationalities and ethnicities. We use Americans because when you hear that you know exactly who it refers to, it’s really that simple.
I really hope you have another forum like this. I'm VERY INTERESTED in hearing more from the Latino community
We also can be better than this.
Very poor job by the interviewer
lmao
Really terrible and smug.
You won the dumbest comment of the year. Congrats
Marcus Fig I’m a about to pull of a magic trick
No u
Yeah she’s a whore
The liberals got mad when they got interrupted, but they kept interrupting the conservatives
And they Conservatives not once demanded not to be interrupted.
Noticed that as well, the girl on the lower right was a bitch, the one in pink dress is just an idiot
@@vernhanna4399 , I think the girl with long black hair is the dumbest one
Interesting on what you heard and who was interrupting who.
@Pierre Noel if that's what you think, then the point went way over your head.
Can we see an updated version of this after Biden’s Presidency ?
😂 for real
this has to be done again part 3 2024 lets go!!!!!!!
As a Latino, stop the bickering and put in the work. Look at the Asian community... they are not getting caught up in the propaganda.
hi Alan. this is Kate from from your patho class. nice to see u here. haha
Antho40plus2 lol howdy
I always say this! It’s such a good point that no one talks about...
Exactly!!
Julianna Campo are you serious? Do some research before you speak. Asians have been through some crazy shit in America. They just got over that victim hood shit real fucking quick, picked themselves up, came together as a community and rushed head first towards their goals.
Moderator wanted to cry when the one thing they all agreed on was that they hated the term “Latinx” Hahahahahahaha
yeah cause its fucking stupid
@@user-nm6od9mf5t agreed
Cause Vice and its moderators are really just stupidly Woke. The word Latinx is just a term invented by LGBT+ Latino Americans, though it's used sparingly in Mexico. Vast Central America and South America hasn't been poisoned by it.
@@TickleMeElmo55 Noooo it was created by woke white liberals who wanted to be hip and trendy with latinos and tried to brainwash them with their liberal agenda
Latinx sounds like an X-Men character.
Hispanic conservative here, from the hood of South Central Los Angeles. Over the years I’ve learned being a democrat just means live with victim mentality, and think with emotion rather than logic. These democrats are pathetic.
Hispanic 23 year old conservative who also came up from the hood in Houston and I completely agree. We need to start taking action and protect what this country stands for or we’ll end up in the same position that our parents went through when fleeing their country in search for a better life.
I agree with you. And I've been conservative my whole life. However, I am pro immigration. I don't understand how a so called conservative Christian who is pro life ( like I am) would actually turn away starving kids and families. Just like the liberals, how do you kill babies and be pro immigration. Hypocrites on both sides.
Latina moderate here, I hate the victim mentality and yes its a HUGE liberal talking point. Im not opprssed for my ethnicity or gender. Ive been poor, I used to do food shopping at the dollar store a pack of rice some fake butter and hotdogs lasted me a week because I didnt have anything else..I worked hard to get out of poverty on my own..as a woman, as a latina, as someone who didnt go to college..none of that held me back. If I lived in a perpetual victim mentality Id still be in that same tiny studio apartment eatting rice and hotdogs drinking tap water. Its such a reductive mindset to hold. Unless you are imprisioned/enslaved..no one is holding you back from improving yourself but yourself.
They also look and act like clowns. I could not take the pirate looking guy seriously in that outfit. Nor the big lady in pink. Ridiculous.
To not be friends with someone bc of voting choices is truly sad. We can agree to disagree and move on, but it's a choice!
Totally agree. Back when gay marriage was being legalized I wouldn’t be friends with anyone who was against it because that had a direct impact on my life personally. However, presidential elections are not as black and white. I don’t think it’s fair to unfriend someone just because they voted for who they perceive to be the lesser of two evils.
The lefties in this video r such hypocrites. They talked about humanity and being human blah blah blah yet they automatically hate Trump supporters and won't even be friends with them.
Did the guy in top left compare illegal immigration to the middle passage slavery? Wow.
nevermindme313 exactly
Fuckkkkkkkked up. Two total different things. First of all, African Americans didn’t have a choice to come to America. Big fuckin difference.
this is the worst debate i've ever seen - way too emotional and devoid of facts and although personal anecdote is important, it was overused
I couldn't hear anyone over the yelling and bitching
B L it’s really more of a panel, obviously
Personal anecdotes are an individuals facts so I’m not too sure what you mean.
Petrio Perez that doesn’t account for everyone though
@@sanderstar1000 but they named it a debate so tone down that attitude with that "obviously"
"He seems to love immigrants in his bedroom." OMG I DIED hahaha she is so underrated but I stan this QUEEN.
dude "chain migrated" her parents, too. A1 hypocrite.
As a lifelong democrat and 1st generation Mexican American, i'm sooo grateful to have woken up from the indoctrination I was fed my entire life. Both my parents went to university(neither finished) but came here and didn't complain and made something of themselves in the 90's. We aren't rich but its been years since we've been poor. I'm tired of emotions trumping objectivity. There will always be racista there will always be ppm at the top abd ppl at the bottom. We live in the freest time in human history, in the richest countey with the most freedom out of all, we have a lot more opportunity hwre despite whatever challenges each individual of any race sex gendet may face, so lets make policies that hwlp creatw opportunity and not focused on further burdening tax payer dollars to OVERhelp and create dependent, usurping communities( be it latino, white, black, asian, its not abt race). Lets stop complaining, eveeyone has to struggle to get somewhere, no one can start at the same equal place, that idealistic, not realistic. Foe the 1st time, im voting republican.
voting for democrats or republicans is just dumb,neither of them care about you..
@@jessiemartinez3056 idc if they care about me. But if policies they make give me more economic opportunity and resources to protect myself from the world, i want that. Me caring about them caring about me is emotional. Which is what these neo left wingers are all about. No thanks
@@lalomex1123 yeah sure if you really believe that then you must still be blind,, you just switching sides when they both exactly the same ,,you were wrong when you said you were a democrat and you will be proven wrong once again in a few years time,, good day
Don’t forget 50% of this conversation was cut out.
Improving Cameron That’s why vice is leftist media
So true, they act like they are in the middle but they aint
Probably a conservative estimate. Watch the video comparing the video Vice released vs actual footage of their interview with Jordan Peterson
They didn't want to show how much smarter the conservative side was
I thought moderaters were suppose to stay out of the conversation she challenged every conservative on their views but not a single libral
Most of the gripes that the Conservatives have were being addressed by Obama & Trump scrapped them! Obama deported more illegals than any other president so he knew that America couldn't grant everyone asylum. Obama signed an Exec Order to allow minors to file for asylum in their own country to prevent them from trusting coyotes and being trafficked. DEMs want to invest in a high tech virtual wall (sensors, alarms) and hire more border security. The "conservatives" aren't informed. Also, I am so freaking tired of hearing "conservative" imbeciles bash welfare for the poor when taxpayers subsidize a min wage FOR WEALTHY CORPORATIONS while praising capitalism that doesn't even exist in USA! We practice cronyism in America. Our "free" market is a joke & will continue to be a joke as long as we vote for politicians that SELL legislature to their Big Donors that stack the deck at the top. Google ALEC & Citizens United which created a Gov that works for BIG Donors while ignoring the will of the people.
Big Oil buys U.S. Military protections around the globe while contributing NO taxes! Big Chemical buys protection when they poison entire communities or cause cancer, auto-immune illnesses AND buys deregulation that allows them to continue doing it! Trump put our entire Big Agriculture industry on welfare in his 2nd year in office so "conservatives" can spare me their welfare gripes about our poor considering a lot of our veterans receive SNAP benefits. I just wish "Conservatives" were more informed because they are literally voting for the same issues that they are bitching about! Obama restructured George W's tax cuts for the TOP so that the middle class paid less tax!
Look, I am not a socialist! I believe countries thrive with a hybrid system -- robust social programs & REAL capitalism where competition lowers prices and produces a living wage which boosts consumer SPENDING & DEMAND and results in long term JOBS. In USA, our states give million $ tax cuts for jobs that defund education emergency services, prevent modern infrastructure. This is not sustainable when worker's wages are too low to buy the products that are being made! Too much logic?
BTW: Corporate Predators can't be trusted with vulnerable populations like healthcare for example --- for-profit healthcare makes every disease that I am diagnosed with a profitable commodity and removes the will for producing CURES for disease. Instead, we are forced to buy expensive medication like opioids that cover up symptoms. Corporate stockholders will never "cure" themselves out of business! Also, OUR tax $ fund research for a lot of drugs that are then passed on to Big Pharma to manufacture & profit off --- American taxpayers literally pay $2000 a month for a drug that costs Australian's $8! THIS is your for-profit healthcare system at work in Crony-Capitalist country! A Republican majority passed a law that prevented using Medicare's bargaining power to lower drugs! Republicans passed a law that prevents our CDC from studying gun violence in USA. Left & right MUST vote together to end the Big Donor BRIBES if we want a gov that works for average people instead of Corporate Predators.
Immigrants BUILT America. They didn't destroy the American Dream. Crony-Capitalists & the greedy 1% destroyed the American Dream. We have take it back before they leave 99% of the population on a dying planet that they poisoned & pillaged! Watch Elysium because THIS is our future unless struggling white, black, brown races vote together to end Gov corruption.
Realty Check: Japan is not socialist. Australia is not socialist. Germany is not socialist. England is not socialist. France is not socialist. ALL offer their people a public health system. America can do this too as long as we are INFORMED & stop allowing Big Healthcare & Big Pharma to manipulate us with lies. They will not give up trillions of $ without a fight.
That's Vice for you.
C Davis if all this information out there why isn’t anyone doing anything about it? 🤯
And her hair is fucking retarded
The Punisher i swear it got worse every time the camera went back to her 😂
In part 1, she said they were going to talk about things that aren't normally brought to the forefront. Then they talked about racism, the wall, and living wages.
It is refreshing to me though, to know there's all kinds of different people even within a specific "community" and that we shouldn't paint with broad strokes.
It's a bit disappointing to think though, that there's so many people who say "if you disagree with me, we can't be cool with each other." Like, these discussions shouldn't get so heated because people disagree.
This was a good example of holidays with my family and them wanting to talk politics.
"Separating families is racism," "Separating families is slavery."
ummm....no, sir, that's not even close to what either of those words mean.
Tom he meant it as they separated families during slavery. Idiot
Jo Jo no but he did say that separating families is slavery which is retarded af
problem is they don't speak english... so don't expect them to use language accurately
It was also a hispanic activist group that sued obama for keeping the families together. They argued that kids should be housed in better accommodations.
Now we have Hispanics arguing to put the kids back in holding with grown men? I mean i get in Mexico the age of consent is 12, but in the US thats dirty.
@@geomundi8333 How does it feel to only speak ONE language?
Get a better moderator. She was so biased. I wanted to hear the conservatives side detailed but she didn't allowed.
Agreed
It's VICE so.... That'll never happen
I noticed that the liberal side seemed very obsessed with identity politics and beginning every sentence with as a ... fill in identity, the top right young lady was extremely beautiful and seem ideological very American and didn't pass as white or any other ethnicity so I can only imagine the hell she catches
i felt exactly the same way watching the interview, the mod said some very leading statements.
Wesley Rowden The bottom right afro-latina was toxic as fuck
The girl at the top right has the most common sense.Doesn’t see in black and white like everyone else .
The way that guy said to the Colombian woman “You created that problem” tells me everything I need to know about leftist hypocrisy towards racism.
Girl on the bottom right is infuriating. An example of how not to debate. All feelings, no intellect. Acting like a child
Zach Bond and interrupts all the conservatives but once a conservative says one word they freak out
Zach Bond period.
She mad about her skin color
It's the blackness in her that's coming out.
Unbearable. Can’t stand her at all.
The Black Conservative/Liberal discussion was soooooo much better. This was 🗑
Well they looked for some silly people. And there were no real conservatives there apart of the black t-shirt guy and the beautiful girl on the top right. Don't even need to talk about the lady on the dress, the one on the jeans and the funny looking dude just spilling emotional things.
The moderator wasn’t interrupting in the black conservative one
Gabriel Castro Top right girl is fine as fuck
I thought this one was ok.
Cause the moderator wasn’t a leftist cuck
If these people who are against the wall are claiming they're for humanity, I challenge them to leave the door to their home wide open and just willingly accept strangers into their home
It's so weird how an immigrant or children of immigrants are the most vocal on closing the border. They made it here, their parents made it here but everyone else tough luck! Crazy
just because your parents crossed doesn't make it right
This moderator was garbage, cutting people off when they were making good points
She's Jorge "the scumbag" Ramos daughter. No surprise there.
She's more concerned for the Alphabet Soups
You don't know a a host does
I agree. If it's a conservative vs. left interview, we should have interviewed of both sects as well!
Wow Fail This is obviously an edited discussion, but please don’t think critically before forming an opinion.
This debate is too emotional, little facts and a lot of feelings. I feel, I feel, I feel! It was frustrating watching this video.
Feelings are why people vote. I'm interested in knowing what motivates people to vote the way they do
Yes. And the moderator pushed for that.
hispanics are emotional lol
Facts
Moises Fonseca trump supporters weren’t “feeling”
I want to see a plethora of different debates among groups
The girl in the jeans and pink (bottom right) is the Latina Karen lol
Wrong with the debate
1) biased and horrible moderator
2) the use of Latin x ,, stop making that a thing it will never be ( moderator was a bit pissed and embarrassed when they bashed the term Latin x 🤣😂)
3) get even amount of political sides
4) get better debaters
the reason some people prefer the term latinx is because they feel as though latino excludes them for not being male. Latinx is more inclusive. Female= latina
male=latino
they=latinx
@@kasip7544 except in spanish grammar, when you got a group of men, it's "latinos", a group of women are "latinas", and if you have a group that consists of both, you use the masculine plural "latinos". thats just basic grammar. even when you have a neutral plural, you use a masculine article like los estudiantes, los luchadores, los hispanohablandes los professores, etc.
@@000xyz This person (xo_kassy _xo) forgot Latino is a Spanish word, not English. Apparently, their feelings override their education.
Latin is gender neutral,
It’s a stupid term because in groups latin becomes a gender neutral term
Liberals say something
Host: silent
Conservatives say something:
Host: BUT WHAT IF IT WAS YOU???
Edit: Im just saying if anyone wants to make judgements on me that could be wrong let me just say this. Im actually latino that has parents who both came here illegally. My dad cam from Mexico Michoacán and my mom came from El Salvador. But i think we should all agree that illegal immigration is something we shouldn’t promote or allow.
Edit 2: just because she admits playing devils advocate doesn’t make it ok. In the black versions of this video the host would just ask questions, ask to elaborate if it was needed, and just kept the peace and maintained order. What this one does is ask questions of her own to the conservatives responses like if she were one of the liberals. Thats being biased and thats not how its supposed to be done. She needed to be completely neutral about this.
A new leftist tactic
Well, to be fair, we all know the host is biased and left of center in politics so, no surprise there.
@@arreola891 yeap
I don't understand this comment, the host let them talk and argue, 1 time she asked the guy let me play devils advocate and proceeded to as a question. Otherwise she let them all talk..This just seems another way to play the whoa is me card if you to the right. this left and right crap is just that crap. Everyone had a say on the questions asked.... would you be complaining if it this was Fox, and the commentator was asking the liberals question? Probably not. Again my stance of left and right is garbage, divisive.
@@juliom7113 thank you.... atleats we released it.
They should do a follow up to this conversation.
No productive discussion can be had when the moderator exhibits bias and cuts people off and ignores people who disagree with her!
Honestly they are such a bad representation of the political view of Latino families
Elizama Aguilar that was my exact thought. The guys on the Right were bad parrots and the guys on the left only had good knowledge on only certain positions. I need to be on one of these...
Nicholas Brown I’m from El Paso Texas and believe me we want the wall ! It’s bull shit that my family had to pay and wait years rather then just coming here illegally.
Moro11 and it takes longer to come legit because people keep cutting. A cousin and his family applied years ago and have done all the paperwork and still waiting. My moms shithead brother has been deported 2 or 3 times while they are waiting and keeps coming back…
@@garymericano well, the good thing about that is, that I'm thinking Trump might give everyone that's here, amnesty, just to get funding for the wall. That's the only way I can see the Dems going for it. Unless we wait another 3 years and get a new change of power.
David Stevens Jr the wall will help but it won’t be a permanent fix. We have dirty border patrol here in my home town who keep opening the fence and abandoning post. Letting hundreds of people just run into our country undetected. In El Paso we have tunnels underground going from one country to another. We also need changes In legislation. Women crossing over from Juarez shouldn’t be able to have their children here for free! since the child is considered an American citizen, they are granted food stamps and wic. And Free healthcare for the child. The parents drive over and take from the American tax payer and go back to their country. That’s some bull shit! Our laws are killing us! Most other countries have harsher laws and penalties then us! There should be no catch and release, you either follow the laws or you go back home from where you came. It’s that simple, people need to see that children are being raped, kidnapped, sold, trafficked and the same goes for women. My opinion is we wouldn’t grant a get out of jail free card for criminals in our country why would we do it for non citizens? Why are people bitching about vaccinations when we are turning a blind eye to these people who have the fucking plague, or the measles, and other crazy third world diseases. I’m first generation and I actually live by the border. I see how this effects me and others in my community first hand, and people in New York , Massachusetts, want to tell me how I should feel about what is going on! And how I’m stupid!?? These people are fucken delusional.
isn’t the mediator supposed to be unbiased?
This is Vice
RIGHT!!!
She became increasingly disheveled as the debate progressed 🙄 she was stressing
SHUT THE FUCK UP YOU FUCKS OMG
THE BITCH WAS ASKING QUESTIONS DOING HER FUCKING JOB
I would love to argue with the 5 liberals.
Selective compassion and empathy is a real thing. Crossing the border illegally is only ok if it's in my family to better my life and benefits me and my family. Everyone else should do it the "right way".
You should rewatch if that is your take. You clearly were no paying attention
The ones that harp on “respect” are the most disrespectful
I dont like how vice is cutting out so much of the conversation. Cut the freaking long version or at least provide a link to the ENTIRE conversation.
Vice is anti-trump paid by George Soros and Disney
Exactly. They did a much better job with the black conservative video
@@beekcleeez7858 I swear I've heard Alex Jones say that a hundred times, hahaha
@@arknark truth though right?
I remember for the black conservative one did they didnt just cut things out but they would also moved around different bits as well like responses from entirely different questions
Everyone in the panel hated term Latinx but on the website they labeled this panel Latinx. Never change Vice.
It's 2022... bring these people back. I wana see how they have changed
Especially with the way joe Biden has handled the souther border
The top right women is now a trump supporter. She originally voted for Hilary
When the woman in the bottom right called the woman behind her "exhausting" it was peak irony.
The woman on the bottom right is the epitome of racism. She can't get dressed without feeling oppressed
The lady in big dress was most annoying after her, both made 0 points and just used regurgitated statements
@@itszirvah Exactly
Im stoned as hell and I just came up with a fascinatung highdea... the tragic truth about our great county (and many other countries) is that politics will always be divided into two opposing ideas. If anyone has seen the movirle Star Strek, this dilemna is the same dilemna that Spock dealt with- the battle between Emotion vs. Logic. There are people who act more on emotion and those who act more on logic. Although both groups of people possess qualities from both types of traits, one group is a little more liberal (emotional) while the other is more conservative (logical). Neither trait is more wrong or right. We all need to acknowledge that there should be a steady balance between being logical and being emotion because without a balance between the two, instability is inevitable. Finding balance between logic and emotion is crucial for a country. It starts with the individual and extends to the ones in power. I'll end this message with a statement that we should all take into serious consideration- If we want to unite as a country and really "Great", We need to be respectful and empathetic TO one another and act logical FOR one another.
@@johnrodolfo DAMN that's deep. i agree. it's also unfortunate that some parties control medias to brainwash and push their agendas and paint the other side with a broad brush. cuz if ur not with them on even 1 thing, ur against them. and racist.
The afro latina is so much focussed on virtue signalling and being the victim she can't even formulate a sound argument on any question.
Why you so bothered by a strong black woman....the white bitches were doing the same
mariposa ofasia What makes her strong? Being a professional victim?
mariposa ofasia 😂😂😂😂 what makes her strong? She literally can’t make a formidable argument or rebuttal
mariposa ofasia Shes strong how? and lmao its so hypocritical that you jump to defend the black one and IMMEDIATELY turn around and shit on the the brown ones when theyre ALL latino, youre a fucking idiot lmfaooo
mariposa ofasia and the difference between what the brown ones did and the black ones did was that the black ones literally just played the victim the whole time, the brown ones dont care about their race and they just want to work hard and be good americans.
Nothing wrong with moving to another country as long as you do it legally
You can really hear that deeply rooted, anti America sentiment some of these young folks have been sold. When I was growing up the school system wasn't involved in indoctrinating & while the media leaned it wasn't the division & hate promoting institution it is now. I remember being young & liberal, lacking perspective & believing America was evil. Over the yrs, with maturity & a willingness to understand different perspectives objectively, I still see the evil & greed but I understand history & what this country has accomplished.
I'm left leaning and the best arguments and behaviours came from the conservatives. Emotional arguments don't last
Thank you, I’m surprised to hear this bc many liberals would never be able to admit that
@@taylor3200 THE REAL LEFT is still here. We are just embarrassed af by the politicians who represent us. It's a joke to think Hillary or Biden would be a better president than anyone on earth tbh
@@taylor3200 Unfortunately the "woke police" and safe space crowd are poisoning the left , I still do believe in left wing core values but this is ridiculous
Lmaooo what arguments did they give that were actually good? Honestly most of them were half-baked defenses to nearly indefensible issues like family separation. Granted I think moderator did a bad job at taking different angles to the talking points, but I really don’t see how the conservatives provided solid reasoning.
@@taylor3200 I'm a far left liberal and I admit stuff like that all the time. I even preferred Trump over Hillary because I looked at the situation objectively.
the way they came together at the very end to collectively shit on the term latinx was beautiful..
Latin American people in general (I'm not talking about those born into the US, those are a lost cause), as weird as it may sound, is conservative as hell. If they vote for the left is not about "social justice" bulls**t, is about economic stuff.
LOL what is th epoint to avoid the a or o ending?
@CONSERVATIVE OPINION Huh ONly Southern Democrats opposed Thurgood Marshall at a time when black people were in transition with the parties.
@L Franco If the Republican party open it's arms to the Latin American vote now, they (the Reps) will get a huge boost in a future. Ted Cruz and Rubio are a beginning, not the best one, but it's something. There are thousands of right winged Latin Americans getting in the US now, and they are sick of what's happening there because of what the socialists have been doing.
@@castronator29 It's already kinda happening. The difference in hispanic votes for Trump is significant between 2016 and 2020. It really was white men that made him loose
Immigration should be based upon meritocracy, assimilation, and love for America. I see many Latino immigrants now who are Christian and traditionalist coming into the county from South America and making it a better more Christian place. I applaud this kind of immigration and I want to see more of it.
Didn't realize this was part 2, but about 7 min into the video I had to stop it. Their recent Vice Debates have been done well, so I'm hoping Vice comes back to this discussion with a much better panel and moderator because this was unbearable to watch and hear.
WHY BE INFORMED when you can use YOUR FEELINGS as your FACTS
Sad one, but real.
You copy Phil d Franco lol
D. N. Well said
@@HellYeaShit
Yup! I bought the shirt too lol
Just like Defranco imitates Ben Shapiro. Lol.
Your mom cutting tomatos at Taco Bell is not a funny thing. Respect to all the hard working people who made it from nothing.
And raised a conservative son.
@@ginamero Culturally Mexicans are conservative.
@@stevenjohnson4207 Very true.
He can laugh about it because he has a good sense of humor and doesn't follow the politically correct mindset. Both the hard working aspect and that fact of being able to laugh at the face of adversity. Respect. We Puerto Ricans share that, making a joke out of anything including our own misfortune. Helps to put one foot after the other.
Yeah we need to have fresh tomatoes for my tacos.
I'm pretty independent politically but i must say the black debate of this subject was way better moderated, not to mention way less biased. This was harder to watch
Knowledge is power ... That is the only thing I can say.
Thank you Vice for this great video.
My biggest critique of these conversations is:
1. The weak moderation.
2. The editing. Release the clips in their entirety. Don’t edit any of it.
Weak moderation? She was actively biased. Weak implies she isn’t trying to moderate. I rather a weak moderator than someone like her
2 is Facts
Just stfu 🤦
@@Isaac79922 you cant tell people to shut up if you want them to conform to your beliefs, provide evidence of why they should shutup and pls dont silence people by verbally harassing them.
I’m more critical that the moderator isn’t aware of the existence of shampoo😂
It was sad to see the man at the bottom left speaking on his opinions and feelings and the moderator interrupting him by saying, "But what if it was you and your mother!?" I think she did that to him at least twice during the whole conversation. Like yeah empathy is important, though I don't particularly think he's lacking it based on his responses, but it is not HER job to interject like that. She's to ask questions and keep the discussion guided and civil. Not push it in one political direction and make one half of the participants come across as bad guys. I call for a redo on this. Was mostly OK with the selection of participants, but would also love to maybe see a couple who are a bit older in the mix. And a different mod for sure, unless this lady can do a better job of biting her tongue next time. Frankly this is what I've come to expect from Vice - something framed as objective which turns out quite the opposite. Shame.
I agree, though I thought it was an interesting question; but I think she was going for the "gotcha!" moment. My impression was that that guy was on the right track, but he hasn't really given his views enough thought. Although, it could just be that he doesn't articulate those opinions well in public.
Cara S. Yeah cause he’s being a hypocrite
She was a participant and not a moderator. She wasn't terrible, but she was certainly irritating.
@Lando R My friend America can't take everybody, here in South America we did some really stupid decisions in terms of politics , only our politicians are rich, the majority of the poor people would LOVE to be poor in America. We must learn with the mistakes we did in the past and not do it again. If you are latino in USA and you go back to your home country you will be called a GRINGO so don't talk for us if you don't live how we do. The guy was speaking his heart and that woman was being very disrespectful.
She was pretending to be fair but was just being manipulative. Shutting down and trying to steer us away from the facts he was speaking. Very biased.
This should’ve been a debate in Texas.
One of the issues I have with this, is the interrupting & speaking over another during this debate. The moderator should have had better control or a whistle lol. Also, the Colombian American panelist who spoke about Puerto Ricans and their experience of mostly being on welfare & not wanting independence really displayed her lack of understanding of the Puerto Rican experience & its history. It was very surface level understanding of the islands history & I was quite frustrated that more time was not given to expose her misconstrued opinion. I do hope they have another panel in the future though on this topic.
Black liberals vs. conservatives was a much more informed discussion.
And now you truly understand everything there is to know behind the "Black lives matter" movement right?
Woo there Jo. Why don't you tell us how you really feel. Proof is in the pudding. And you have no pudding. So....🤷
Don't feel bad, I watch CZcams as well. I just tend not to believe, until verified.
real_clemente I agree!!
real_clemente Actually it wasn’t. The TPUsa plant there was the absolute worse & performed just like these guys on the Right...
JoMoe G. Good lord, care to cite that information? Lol
You guys seem like you could use a better interviewer.. hint hint
Yes she was little bias in my opinion
I subbed to you, don't let me down, my good man.
Hey, man! I love your videos. Keep up the great work.
But you're barely informed
she could have at least got out of her pajamas and combed her hair. Edgy Millennial Latinex....LOL. She looks white to me.....
the pink dress lady is so cute and she speaks truth without being disrespectful i like her
I love how easy it is to tell which side of the argument someone is on. Basically, attractive people are conservative.
That’s because they do things in moderation. That’s a conservative.
All of the people are attractive, being beautiful doesn’t mean you must look like Kim Kardashian…
it is a shame that this debate was so poorly moderated.
The moderator is supposed to be neutral and guide the questions right? She outright was expressing her opinion to the point she should have been in the seats.
What do you expect it's vice they are the definition of liberal mouth pieces
I almost lost my mind when she pushed the guy in black to answer her “what if it was your mother?” nonsense. If somebody murders my parents I will hunt that piece of shit down and probably beat him to death but that doesn’t make me agree with death penalty.
She was DOING HER JOB SHE WAS ASKING QUESTIONS IT WAS NOT BIASED YOU MORON
@@fuzz479 yes she was she was as unprofessional as her hair cut.
All emotions, no substance and the moderator was clearly biased.
100%
Were we watching the same thing? There were plenty of facts.
Emotions on the left, reason on the right.
@@WonderZed I have to say. The guy on the bottom right was the only one that stood out to me.
As a male latino, I've come to my own agreement that each one of the ladies in the panel is cute.
It would be nice to see all the participants return in a round table forum now that they have shaken off the butterflies and now have gained a little experience in a video recorded debate and not be so emotional. Fair points all around.
I’d love to see this now, especially the way joe Biden has handled the southern border 😂
I liked that they all came together to denounce Latinx.
Na Br period I dislike that term so much like it’s just so dumb to me.
Angel Venegas lmao I just found out that was a term is that just another way to say Latino?
Donald Trump yeah apparently it’s to be an “all gender” way. Like just say Latino/Latina
@@angelvenegas2141 They'll make you use that term in their Progressive future.
Me too. Finally, someone said it!
Can we get a better moderator.... her bias influences responses and brings the whole vid down.
I'm pretty sure that's Simon Rex...
When you see that girl just know there is always gonna be left wing bias.
That's difinetly a libtard, pushing the narrative , no borders initiative and make this a third world country getting there thanks to the Demon crats and commi libtards
James M Libtard isn’t a word, sir. It makes you appear intellectually deficient.
Yes, she actually argued with participants and was unable to remain unbiased throughout her moderating duties here
This was great.
Very good conversation on both sides