This commentary was verry good! Not to short just, straight to the point with some additional extra info for those that dont know everything! I like this guys🙌🏻
Thank you! I think the strategy of just talking over the video in a single take might be a winner. Still want to make sure we have an ambient option only, if thats possible. Working on it! - Das
@@NASASpaceflight Thanks for listening to the feedback, and improving this episode's narration 1000% over the first. But please do keep the narration-free versions, as I nevertheless still prefer them.
@@NASASpaceflight Hey, wait a minute - if you are going to introduce a new feature, THAT's the one that should be made members-only. Why would you hide away the ambient version we've been enjoying for years, if not to try to force those of unable to afford memberships (but who otherwise attempt to contribute in every other way) to buy one? Feels like we're being punished for being poor. My 2¢, anyway. If only that bought a membership. :-)
This commentary is an improvement over last time. More compact interesting information/trivia about what's seen and not just reading the description. I like it.
Narration 100,000% Yes! I'd stopped watching daily updates because of the need to read the captions, which was very difficult if watching on phone. Will become a daily watcher again! Thanks!
A far better commentary than the last one, Good to hear more information about what is being shown, with some of the ambient track...it made for a far more watchable video than the last one. Also the more you voice over, the more you will find the right style, and level of narration required to tell the story for each new update.
I like the commentary because often I play the videos while I'm doing something else and I'm not always looking at the screen. With no commentary I might miss something I would be interested in. With the commentary I know to look back at the screen.
Today's was even better than yesterday... Yesterday you kinda introduced each clip but not much else... The added context made the entire video feel much more fluid... I really hope the 200+ other comments are supportive and that you make this a regular thing. I wouldn't change a thing.
I think you have added just enough casual and informative commentary, but I understand why some want only ambient sounds. No need to turn this into a daily SBU. Great Job!
This is great! Keep the light atmosphere with little stories about the wife having NSF Livestreams open when you wake up, gives a nice touch to the relaxing video.
Amazing Das, like the commentary with flare. I also read the comments and i can see how some like it with just ambiance. But for some who may not read quickly or possibly have a hard time seeing the summary commentary is great. Keep up the great work Das and NSF team.
I haven't checked in on Starbase in quite some time, so I was shocked to discover in this video that there is a second tower, that it's nearing completion, that they have reconfigured the tank farm, that there is an enormous office building on site, and...well, pretty much everything is shocking. The speed of development is breathtaking. 😮
I like the commentary, Das. It makes it easier to focus on the video instead of reading labels. And commentary from those of you who get to frequent Starbase and know what you're talking about is even more appreciated. Adding some background is always nice, too. You all do a great job. I've always loved this channel. Hope to visit Starbase some day, maybe see you there!
Great addition! I love the idea of both. The commentary is great for my 'catch-up' moments. At other times, I like the Starbase ASMR when I just need back ground noise. Being able to choose will be a major plus. Great work Das, and the NSF team as always !
I'm honest with you. I didn't watch the non commentary vids a lot but I enjoy what I saw here. I really like the way das does (no pun intended) this commentary.
This is the first time I seen this with the commentary and I really like it. I have watched every starship launch and am very appreciative of what Spacex is doing and the coverage that NSF have for us. You guys ROCK! The commentary is always good for me as I need the explanation lol. And You’ve added just enough commentary. Keep up the good work and for all the people like myself that love this stuff but don’t know a lot about it, THANK YOU !
As a feedback, this is more interesting than the other "read the labels" commentary video, just adding a little bit of context to the scenes shown increases the content value and doesn't make it redundant to the weekly update which should be a cherry pick, having two tracks of audio makes sense to the people that enjoys it silent or adding his own explanations(ex: a school teacher), i saw somewhere that having a defined schedule increases the audience on YT, and makes sense, human brain loves predictability, like your favorite tv show, airing from xxx to xxx at Wednesday for example, that should be good too. Thanks for your hard work keeping us updated on whats happening on Starbase and all the Space sector.
Thank you Das! Thank you for taking comments to heart and actually doing something that was requested. Always a great thing that the ENTIRE NSF crew does.
Being one of the ambient tribe people, I really enjoyed this commentary! I apriciate the optionality aspect for future videos tho. Great work as always, NSF.
I think you'll nailed it with this video. And I like them called 'modules' partially because that's what's on the stand on the transport, and also because module just sounds fun: installing the mobility module, installing the vision module, as opposed to getting in the car or putting on the glasses.
Okay I loved that format a lot better. It felt a little repetitive before. I really liked you adding more information on what we were seeing :) but thank you for all your hard work :)
This is SUCH a WAY BETTER WAY of presenting all the ART you guys capture w/ these cameras. Don't comment often if ever but I needed to share that this is great and very likely to keep me watching until the end of the video. Thank you!
I do enjoy the moments, as long as the moments are clearly made by a human being. It's definitely a plus with the moments done by a person I could see.
I joined NSF a few months after it was established in 2005. It is amazing how it has grown. The new casual, but knowledgeable commentary is another step forward. Good work!
The commentary is better this time - the previous one it was just too sparse. I think it's about right like this ... thanks DAS, and the team as ever for a great job! And a shout-out too for Mary, BocaChicaGal! I also think the idea of having the option of switching the voice-over in or out is certainly worth exploring.
Hey Das....much better this time with talking off the cuff and not just reading the banner. Thank you so much for posting the ambient version for members because I am one of the 20% who enjoy that! however I do appreciate NSF listening to all of. us and giving at least the members the option and I appreciate you making the effort to eventually have the option for everyone. Even though I do prefer the ambient track, you did a great job! thanks for all of your hard work.
I often watch videos while cooking/eating or otherwise lightly multitasking, so I've always preferred the ones with narration a little. Much easier to not have to be eyes glued to the screen to catch every label. I do understand that it is one more thing someone has to take time to prep though. Great to catch something Das is hosting too!
Das, great adjustment from the last commentated video! I enjoyed the asides, explanations, a little humor, and extemporaneous commentary. Now, if I had a choice between ambient and commentated, I would definitely take the commentary!!
This level of commentary was PERFECT, imho. The narrator described what the visual was showing. Again, I feel this is a vast improvement. Thank you for adding your Value Added NSF Commentary. Keep up the good work.
i think the commentry is needed so you know what is happening really like this style of feedback for us thank you to the camera and media crew for your hard work
Love the commentary! Keep it up. I like hearing an unscripted, candid commentary from you. I won't watch non-commentary videos, as I would just wait for the weekly updates. This allows me to keep more on tabs.
I LOVE THE COMMENTARY!! Especially on this one after Das points out the pulleys on the section being moved at 3:22. After he finished saying it the video had move to something else and I missed it, so had to back it up about 10 seconds and watch it again.
This commentary was verry good! Not to short just, straight to the point with some additional extra info for those that dont know everything! I like this guys🙌🏻
Thank you! I think the strategy of just talking over the video in a single take might be a winner. Still want to make sure we have an ambient option only, if thats possible. Working on it! - Das
@@NASASpaceflighti think this format is perfect
@@NASASpaceflight Thanks for listening to the feedback, and improving this episode's narration 1000% over the first. But please do keep the narration-free versions, as I nevertheless still prefer them.
@@NASASpaceflight Hey, wait a minute - if you are going to introduce a new feature, THAT's the one that should be made members-only. Why would you hide away the ambient version we've been enjoying for years, if not to try to force those of unable to afford memberships (but who otherwise attempt to contribute in every other way) to buy one? Feels like we're being punished for being poor. My 2¢, anyway. If only that bought a membership. :-)
This commentary is an improvement over last time. More compact interesting information/trivia about what's seen and not just reading the description. I like it.
Exact.
Same here. Much better and I really enjoy your comentary Das 👍👍👍
This is the perfect balance 50% commentary, 50% ambient
Really appreciate the Das commentary.
Optional commentary sounds like a great idea.
I like the new format. Das has too much talent to just read the screen notes. Keep it up, I LIKE!
Appreciate the kind words. I'm pretty high maintenance when it comes to having other people tell me exactly what to say. 😅 - Das
commentary > ambient > just reading labels
Ideally there would be 2 audio tracks (commentary and just ambient) that we can choose from.
I do hope we're able to get that feature back. We tested it a while ago... will keep yall updated. - Das
@@NASASpaceflightmaybe two videos? With and without commentary? Or for subscribers only can get the ambient sounds?
That's a really good idea! Did you comment before you got to the end of the video....? heh - Das
MUTE
Guys you are literally repeating exactly what Das said they are going to do lol.
Das talking felt like a chill pilot talking while we come in to land.
Fellow GrowlerJams enjoyer? 😅 - Das
I like that way of putting it.
I LOVE that you do this blind and one take. No need to spend more time than that and makes it more interesting.
The optional commentary sounds cool, that way everyone gets what they wanted :D
Love Das commentary. Since he can’t do live streams as much as in past years, this is great. A happy, positive voice.
YES!! Totally agree!
The added commentary reminds me of watching the behind the scenes reels of a DVD
I prefer the commentary. I like listening to experts. I'm an engineer and that's how we learn.
Narration 100,000% Yes! I'd stopped watching daily updates because of the need to read the captions, which was very difficult if watching on phone. Will become a daily watcher again! Thanks!
Like the laid-back review. I enjoy the commentary. I have a hard time paying attention without commentary. Thanks
COMMENTARY RULES 🗣🗣🔥🔥🔥
🗣🗣WEN FROSTY....?
Thanks for supporting us as we try new things. Expected way more pitchforks in the comments hah- Das
The commentary is much appreciated and doubles the value of the stream.
Perfect commentary. Just the right amount.
A far better commentary than the last one, Good to hear more information about what is being shown, with some of the ambient track...it made for a far more watchable video than the last one. Also the more you voice over, the more you will find the right style, and level of narration required to tell the story for each new update.
another great video guys..thanks Das was a pleasure meeting you at leicester space centre
So glad I was able to make it out there! Always a good time. - Das
I like the commentary because often I play the videos while I'm doing something else and I'm not always looking at the screen. With no commentary I might miss something I would be interested in. With the commentary I know to look back at the screen.
Thank you John (Das)! & NSF!
Today's was even better than yesterday... Yesterday you kinda introduced each clip but not much else... The added context made the entire video feel much more fluid...
I really hope the 200+ other comments are supportive and that you make this a regular thing. I wouldn't change a thing.
Love the new changes.
Appreciated the commentary!
Das. By far, the BEST commentator at NSF. PERIOD!
I like the commentary you were making this time. Much better than reading the screen labels.
I love the new format with the audio! Great work!
Massive upgrade over first attempt (just like IFT-2!). Keep up the good work!!
If you think SpaceX rapidly iterates... wait til you get a load of us. 😅 - Das
I think you have added just enough casual and informative commentary, but I understand why some want only ambient sounds. No need to turn this into a daily SBU. Great Job!
Yeah, always good to hear Das. I like the commentary version. Doesn’t need to be scripted. This is the way.
This is great! Keep the light atmosphere with little stories about the wife having NSF Livestreams open when you wake up, gives a nice touch to the relaxing video.
Thank you for the commentary. Much better experience.
Like the new balance of commentary, the context makes all the difference.
I personally like the commentary. I watch / listen while in my office at work, looking over at the video when something peaks my interest.
Significantly better with the commentary. Context is king.
Amazing Das, like the commentary with flare. I also read the comments and i can see how some like it with just ambiance. But for some who may not read quickly or possibly have a hard time seeing the summary commentary is great. Keep up the great work Das and NSF team.
Great job on the commentary! Thank you NSF for all your hard work!
I've always skipped this type of videos timelines, but this time I'm loving the commentry❤.
I haven't checked in on Starbase in quite some time, so I was shocked to discover in this video that there is a second tower, that it's nearing completion, that they have reconfigured the tank farm, that there is an enormous office building on site, and...well, pretty much everything is shocking. The speed of development is breathtaking. 😮
Thank you, Thoroughly enjoyed...I love having bits explained..Keep up the good work . I like the format. 😊🚀
This 'casual' commentary is cool too!
I like the commentary, Das. It makes it easier to focus on the video instead of reading labels. And commentary from those of you who get to frequent Starbase and know what you're talking about is even more appreciated. Adding some background is always nice, too. You all do a great job. I've always loved this channel. Hope to visit Starbase some day, maybe see you there!
Thanks for the commentary - very worthwhile!
Great addition! I love the idea of both. The commentary is great for my 'catch-up' moments. At other times, I like the Starbase ASMR when I just need back ground noise. Being able to choose will be a major plus. Great work Das, and the NSF team as always !
I'm honest with you. I didn't watch the non commentary vids a lot but I enjoy what I saw here. I really like the way das does (no pun intended) this commentary.
Appreciate it! - Das
I'm definitely here for the new commentary!! 🧡🧡
I love this style. Feels like sitting beside Das and watching the video. Let the videos come more frequently and more lengthy if possible
Dig the Smooth Cool Sounds coming down from DAS. Real talk. Real info. Real nice.
This is the first time I seen this with the commentary and I really like it. I have watched every starship launch and am very appreciative of what Spacex is doing and the coverage that NSF have for us. You guys ROCK! The commentary is always good for me as I need the explanation lol. And You’ve added just enough commentary. Keep up the good work and for all the people like myself that love this stuff but don’t know a lot about it,
THANK YOU !
I looooove this new format! I also love that gor members you get the non-talking version. And that, as a god dang Pad Rat!
the new format is great rather than wondering what i am seeing the expert description is great please continue this format
Thanks NSF team great commentary wonderful ❤
Thanks Das and NSF team, the added commentary was enjoyable, great work.
Watching NSF updates now since several years (since the starhopper test flight) and I like the new commentary! Great work!
Be interesting to rotate through the NSF staff. One video das, then chris, then alex, then jack and so on
2:16 I haven’t seen this view since they started stacking tower 2. I love it!
Much better this time around.
Just to say like this 'Directors commentary' style with thee added value. Thanks for all your work.
As a feedback, this is more interesting than the other "read the labels" commentary video, just adding a little bit of context to the scenes shown increases the content value and doesn't make it redundant to the weekly update which should be a cherry pick, having two tracks of audio makes sense to the people that enjoys it silent or adding his own explanations(ex: a school teacher), i saw somewhere that having a defined schedule increases the audience on YT, and makes sense, human brain loves predictability, like your favorite tv show, airing from xxx to xxx at Wednesday for example, that should be good too.
Thanks for your hard work keeping us updated on whats happening on Starbase and all the Space sector.
Commentary was great! The dog seems to like watching with me all the same; the big machines are always captivating!
Narrating these videos is one of the best ideas NSF has had... I used to skip a ton of stuff, but giving it context and color helped a LOT🎉!
I like your enhanced conversational commentary on this one.
I am on Team Commentary with the ambient sound in the background. Adds so much to the video. Insightful, educational, and entertaining. Thank you Das!
Thank you, Das for the "value add NSF staff commentary"... This format is awesome and very much appreciated!
this is amazing! great idea team!
Thank you Das! Thank you for taking comments to heart and actually doing something that was requested. Always a great thing that the ENTIRE NSF crew does.
The commentary on the go, unprepared, is much better than in the previous video. Good work, Das👍🏻
Great having some commentary. Thanks so much DAS. I do think this has been fleshed out just right… ❤
Appreciate it! I may not be able to do them all, but honestly it helps me keep up with what's going on as well. - Das
Being one of the ambient tribe people, I really enjoyed this commentary! I apriciate the optionality aspect for future videos tho. Great work as always, NSF.
I thought for a long time, these daily updates could do with some quick&dirty commentary. And I do like it! Please keep it up!
Love yr voiceover! Your relaxed cadence is perfect. Calling out equipment names & their operations is much appreciated
I think you'll nailed it with this video. And I like them called 'modules' partially because that's what's on the stand on the transport, and also because module just sounds fun: installing the mobility module, installing the vision module, as opposed to getting in the car or putting on the glasses.
Okay I loved that format a lot better. It felt a little repetitive before. I really liked you adding more information on what we were seeing :) but thank you for all your hard work :)
Commentary is nice. It’s personal and relaxing and not over complicated.
This is SUCH a WAY BETTER WAY of presenting all the ART you guys capture w/ these cameras. Don't comment often if ever but I needed to share that this is great and very likely to keep me watching until the end of the video. Thank you!
Long time watcher, first time commenter. Means a lot, thanks! - Das
I do enjoy the moments, as long as the moments are clearly made by a human being. It's definitely a plus with the moments done by a person I could see.
That's a nice evolution of the format! The "live" commentary adds context without feeling scripted.
Love this format. Das's voice is perfect for this commentary just like Elysia is for Weekly updates. Go NSF❤
I joined NSF a few months after it was established in 2005. It is amazing how it has grown. The new casual, but knowledgeable commentary is another step forward. Good work!
I love the commentary. It's a way to keep informed about the progress at starbase without having to look at the legend
The commentary is better this time - the previous one it was just too sparse. I think it's about right like this ... thanks DAS, and the team as ever for a great job! And a shout-out too for Mary, BocaChicaGal! I also think the idea of having the option of switching the voice-over in or out is certainly worth exploring.
Das, really appreciate the cometary it brings another dimension, more of this please.
Hey Das....much better this time with talking off the cuff and not just reading the banner. Thank you so much for posting the ambient version for members because I am one of the 20% who enjoy that! however I do appreciate NSF listening to all of. us and giving at least the members the option and I appreciate you making the effort to eventually have the option for everyone. Even though I do prefer the ambient track, you did a great job! thanks for all of your hard work.
Spot on now you’re finding your groove with it.
I often watch videos while cooking/eating or otherwise lightly multitasking, so I've always preferred the ones with narration a little. Much easier to not have to be eyes glued to the screen to catch every label. I do understand that it is one more thing someone has to take time to prep though.
Great to catch something Das is hosting too!
Das, great adjustment from the last commentated video! I enjoyed the asides, explanations, a little humor, and extemporaneous commentary. Now, if I had a choice between ambient and commentated, I would definitely take the commentary!!
I think this is something i would watch and play because the audio commentary. But understand why some would like a commentary track.
Very Cool !! "Talky wen not frosty"... I love it !!!
This level of commentary was PERFECT, imho. The narrator described what the visual was showing. Again, I feel this is a vast improvement. Thank you for adding your Value Added NSF Commentary. Keep up the good work.
i think the commentry is needed so you know what is happening really like this style of feedback for us thank you to the camera and media crew for your hard work
All your doing is ok.. thanks for the quick updates and all the late nights of filming Starbase
It's great having some commentary going with the video.
commentary always more informative than none. Das you rock!
Love the commentary! Keep it up. I like hearing an unscripted, candid commentary from you. I won't watch non-commentary videos, as I would just wait for the weekly updates. This allows me to keep more on tabs.
I like this new suplimentary commentary. Keep going with it 👍
Love the casual commentary, it’s great 👍🏼
Personally I enjoy watching anything that involves Das!😅
Das doing the banter he's good at! I liked the ambient noise but adding in some additional info is really nice. No complaints here!
Love the new approach to these videos. Thank you.
I LOVE THE COMMENTARY!! Especially on this one after Das points out the pulleys on the section being moved at 3:22. After he finished saying it the video had move to something else and I missed it, so had to back it up about 10 seconds and watch it again.