BAND-MAID - Manners/BLACK HOLE (Live) reaction | My girls...

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 10. 08. 2021
  • We're finally checking out some LIVE Band Maid again, and this time it's their toughest challenge yet... How Black with this Hole be? Let's find out.
    'Conqueror' Album reaction: / thechampofmedium
    LIKE, COMMENT, and SUB!... please and thank you.
    / of_medium​​​​​​
    #BandMaid #Manners #BlackHole
    ***I don't own any of the music in this video. This video is intended to support the content, not recreate or use for personal gain.
  • Hudba

Komentáře • 256

  • @falconsooner
    @falconsooner Před 2 lety +95

    I really like the fact that these weren't overly produced. Has a more raw live sound. Miku's vocal effects steal the show. Love Mincho's rapid fire slides at the end. Saiki's eyes go a bit crazy in Black Hole and love her extra rasp.

    • @TihomirBozic69
      @TihomirBozic69 Před 2 lety +15

      I am a fan of assassin trio, MISA, Akane, Kanami... in any order you like... but Miku's triplets and Saiki's psycho eyes got me... Saiki was so into it, and Miku surprised me.

    • @wave8359
      @wave8359 Před rokem

      @@TihomirBozic69 yes--agreed entirely !

  • @TomClark-Futoura
    @TomClark-Futoura Před 2 lety +104

    I still hear things after hundreds of listens to a song, too -- like Miku's singing with her unique vocal accents and close harmonies. Or Kanami's verse riffing around the drums and Saiki's melodies. Or MISA's independant counter riffing while incorporating a little bit of what everybody else is doing. (She's very busy. No wonder she doesn't smile much because of all that concentration). And of course Akane continues to amaze me because I'm always hearing new things from her.
    This is why their songs continue to grow on me after all these years. Like I've said before: Band-Maid writes and performs the most dense yet beautifully integrated hard rock music in history Thx, Champ! btw - Re: your Saiki vocal comment @ 7:30: as you know, RnR is not supposed to be perfect. It's supposed to be expressive. ;-)

  • @realdocloco
    @realdocloco Před 2 lety +70

    I'm not sure I would be able to play consistently those triplets Miku's playing - or I would have to train and concentrate a lot! What she brings live is now as essential as what the other four play or sing. More, she adds a scent of unpredictability and madness throughout, and I can't think of another band with such a "joker" card up their sleeve.

    • @JuanSan66
      @JuanSan66 Před 2 lety +12

      Hey!, Miku The Joker. I like it!

    • @jamesredman1263
      @jamesredman1263 Před 2 lety +6

      Yes, Miku the Joker describes her so well!

    • @jon87583
      @jon87583 Před 2 lety +3

      @@jamesredman1263 And, minus the evil intentions, every bit as clever as The Joker.

    • @wave8359
      @wave8359 Před rokem +2

      Love your referring to Miku as the wild card !!
      Miku seems to have come from supporting everyone to sort of entwining with everyone !
      She was rock solid,with the 4 geniuses----but now she is a rock-solid genius with the other 4 (OTHER) geniuses !!!!
      Favourite always is the call-and-response with her and Saiki !

  • @scottmcgregor562
    @scottmcgregor562 Před 2 lety +35

    I will say it again. On these recent live videos. Miku has impressed me the most. She seems so comfortable with her vocals and guitar playing and the confidence that she displays. She makes it look so easy. This pigeon is amazing.

    • @unshakensalsa6220
      @unshakensalsa6220 Před 2 lety +7

      Miku you mean.

    • @SLKRR
      @SLKRR Před 2 lety +12

      The only time Miku looked nervous in that live was when playing Sayonakidori - a song which she specifically asked Kanami to make difficult for her to sing. One thing I love about this band is that none of the members are content to stay in their comfort zones … always pushing vocal range, pushing tempo, adding new guitar and bass techniques, etc. Just read an interview from 2016 where they talked about how challenging it was to their abilities to make Brand-New MAID … and they are so far ahead of that now, they could probably play that album in their sleep!

    • @scottmcgregor562
      @scottmcgregor562 Před 2 lety +2

      @@SLKRR oops. Sure did.

  • @markmark6378
    @markmark6378 Před 2 lety +22

    Yea! They for sure absolutely SLAYED Black Hole! Everyone! Those vocals from both Saiki and Miku made me speechless!

  • @jeremydawkins8814
    @jeremydawkins8814 Před 2 lety +15

    Manners and Black Hole are a Blooming Thrill to watch Band Maid Take me higher with everything they do.I sometimes find myself Screaming with Extasy when seeing them takes me back to the Nonfiction Days of great rock.Just role the Dice for a great song.

    • @ViiOlet810
      @ViiOlet810 Před 2 lety +2

      I tip my tiny hat to you Sir 🎩 nice work 😎🤘

  • @Bekka_Noyb
    @Bekka_Noyb Před 2 lety +32

    I think Miku did sing the same parts in the album version, but they were indistinguishable in the original mix.
    Think this version really highlights both Miku's & MISA's importance to this track! ♥

    • @snowdog5895
      @snowdog5895 Před 2 lety +2

      100%

    • @TomClark-Futoura
      @TomClark-Futoura Před 2 lety +3

      Other than a few intros and some solo work, from day one, they usually play and sing exactly like they record -- written and discipled.

  • @SLKRR
    @SLKRR Před 2 lety +40

    All that “extra” stuff is already on the studio recording, but it gets buried in the mix (and the ridiculous loudness doesn’t help).
    As for this live mix, the guitar seems fine to me (not disappearing like on Line Cube DVD), but they absolutely did boost the sound of the bass and the drums, so it doesn’t stand out quite as much. And since I love listening to the bass and drums, I’ve got no complaints!

    • @cold-fire
      @cold-fire Před 2 lety +7

      Even though Miku's numerous backup vocals are pushed farther back in the mix on the album, I noticed it straight away because I think it's the biggest improvement they've made to their sound for the new album.

    • @mr.bluebird6544
      @mr.bluebird6544 Před 2 lety +6

      @@cold-fire I totally agree with that, my favorite part of their new material as well. I had to go back and re-listen to Manners for Miku's vocals...sure enough they were there.

    • @TomClark-Futoura
      @TomClark-Futoura Před 2 lety +3

      @@cold-fire Agree. I think Miku's vocals are unique, fun, and surprisingly smart. Nothing like them from any band that I know of.

    • @wave8359
      @wave8359 Před rokem +1

      @@TomClark-Futoura also agreed----more and more like vocal duo rather than just vocal-plus-backup.

    • @TomClark-Futoura
      @TomClark-Futoura Před rokem

      @@wave8359 It's like the closely sung vocals between Saiki and Miku make up a totally unique sound for the Maids that very few bands have achieved. The Everly Bros. close harmonies oddly come to mind. But that close, dual-vocal sound, plus the addition of Miku's unexpected backup accents, really sets them apart.

  • @thunderchild7137
    @thunderchild7137 Před 2 lety +12

    The reason we all love live performances from them is we get to hear the stuff that's there on the studio recording but you can only hear clearly on the live performance. And yes they need, NEED, an audience again. That is such a energy boost that I am sure by now they are craving the experience.

    • @kschell286
      @kschell286 Před 2 lety

      Because whoever mixes their albums is terrible. World Domination was the only one that sounded decent

  • @Jonas_S_
    @Jonas_S_ Před 2 lety +27

    I was actually wondering if they could really pull off Black Hole Live when I first heard it. Now I'm kicking myself for ever doubting them.
    Actually I asked Kanami to give me a spanking, but she said her arms were too tired from all that guitar playing. 😛

    • @GaryHolloway-810
      @GaryHolloway-810 Před 2 lety +3

      I bet she giggled, clapped & jumped up & down tho :)

    • @Jonas_S_
      @Jonas_S_ Před 2 lety +2

      @@GaryHolloway-810 Yep, as usual ;)

    • @GaryHolloway-810
      @GaryHolloway-810 Před 2 lety +1

      @@Jonas_S_ Haha. That's our Mincho.🙂

    • @discipleofthecapedbaldy962
      @discipleofthecapedbaldy962 Před 2 lety +2

      Probably a good thing you didn't ask Akane - not sure how the human body would hold up to 220 Spanks Per Minute XD

  • @ShikataGaNai100
    @ShikataGaNai100 Před 2 lety +24

    The best live band of the last 30 years or more.

  • @55tallanh
    @55tallanh Před 2 lety +19

    We can agree that Miku is the MVP backup singer of all-time.

  • @stups9975
    @stups9975 Před 2 lety +18

    Black Hole is the song that I keep hitting repeat on. My only complaint about the song is that it is too short .. but boy does it hit 🤟🏻

  • @mickyart
    @mickyart Před 2 lety +20

    Loved this live (those parts where they go off stage are crazy...) anyway, loved the reaction to these pearls. "Black Hole" is surely part of a (really freaking difficult) Top 5. After "Unseen World" I am eagerly waiting for the next new album - I wasn't expecting "Unseen World" to be what it was and can't imagine what next one will be like (a mesh between Unseen and Conqueror? Some new unexplored ideas?) ... I saw Kanami asking Herman Li on Twitch about the highest BPM song of Dragon Force and promised to top it... so we might have yet another "Black Hole"-like song in the future being "cooked"... and Akane going nuts even more.
    The ONLY down side of this performance: no crowd! Can you imagine both these songs live at Budokan filled with a devoted Band-Maid crowd? ... I'm going to rewatch the April 13th 2018, Zepp Tokyo again just because I need these girls to have a crowd, it's their 6th member...

  • @thammond1946
    @thammond1946 Před 2 lety +7

    By far my favorite band since X, and that was 40 years ago.

  • @falagar4567
    @falagar4567 Před 2 lety +11

    Champ is getting the full Maidiac experience. No matter how many times you listen to their songs, there's always a chance you will discover something new that was there all along.

  • @xsteveconwayx
    @xsteveconwayx Před 2 lety +15

    I’m really starting to appreciate Saiki more and more. Her vocals are so impressive and she’s really stepped into her own as a live performer these past few years. She’s really gained a lot of confidence and stage presence. Plus, I’ve always had a thing for those lollipop girls (big heads on skinny bodies) lol.
    They really need to start putting out live albums. The Descendents put out 2 live albums while being together roughly the same time frame as Band-Maid. I want a live album I can listen to in the car, dammit!

    • @laughingbuddha2948
      @laughingbuddha2948 Před 2 lety +2

      I dare say Saiki's head is in perfect proportion to her body. I feel I'm channeling Will Smith at the grammy's right now. :-)

    • @wave8359
      @wave8359 Před rokem

      Yes!---Just Yes !

  • @JWPanimation
    @JWPanimation Před 2 lety +22

    Saw this live when they posted it. Great performance of both of these songs. BUT, why oh why did they not keep a camera dedicated to Akane for Black Hole???

  • @billmcleangunsmith
    @billmcleangunsmith Před 2 lety +15

    I've said that the guitar solo in "Manners" is more of a duet, Kanami and MISA.

  • @Running-withscissors
    @Running-withscissors Před 2 lety +21

    Headphones really are required for this performance. To me it sounds very muddled on speakers only (yes I have good speakers haha) and the non-audience recordings have been hit or miss at times. This band feeds off an audience.. That said, Saiki on this gig was on fire compared to previous ones.

  • @glenkelley6799
    @glenkelley6799 Před 2 lety +13

    Great reaction and yes, they always want to please their audience, adding little bits here and there, new intros, sometimes a new ending, Miku's vocals more forward, MISA more clearly present and Akane's madness in the middle. Best live band is a very, very long time.

  • @VegetaRabbit
    @VegetaRabbit Před 2 lety +14

    Studio: not enough MISA and Miku
    Live: plenty of MISA and Miku, but not enough Kanami
    I think I like the live version better, the bass&drum intro on Manners is cool and being able to hear MISA & Miku better really adds to the music

  • @sugoruyo
    @sugoruyo Před 2 lety +8

    DAMN, that groove MISA is laying down is gnarly. She’s my favourite live bassist at this point. Truly plays bass lead live. She’s an absolute beast of a bass player.
    Miku kicking ass as well with the backing vocals.

  • @markmathewssgbcpenaltyboxs6389

    Love Manners! I especially loved the intro and that is why Band-Maid live is so much better! Thank you for reacting to this video.

  • @David-yt6kp
    @David-yt6kp Před 2 lety +12

    I don't know where Miku got the idea for the lyrics to this song, but they are quite interesting. Some have called Miku the Japanese Stevie Nicks as a lyricist.

    • @markyg236
      @markyg236 Před 2 lety +2

      Black Hole lyrics are akin to Peart's "Natural Science"

  • @RevStickleback
    @RevStickleback Před 2 lety +9

    One thing I do like about seeing them live and their smaller shows in Europe and the USA is that there isn't quite the same level of production as they obviously put in for the stuff going out on a DVD. I like to be able to really hear them play live. It's obviously not as clean sounding, but the energy takes it up a level. Kanami writes for the stage, not the studio.

    • @wave8359
      @wave8359 Před rokem +1

      That's so well put: " Kanami writes for the stage, not the studio".----perfect!

  • @philcalvino884
    @philcalvino884 Před 2 lety +8

    Thanks, Champ, your reaction was worth the wait. All of them hit all the marks on both songs. I'm kind of with you on the guitars, though, would like to have them just a bit more in the mix. But the hell with complaining, it was outstanding!

  • @chatelain567
    @chatelain567 Před 2 lety +9

    Akane murdering her drum kit, misa going almost atonal because she can, incredible vocal duos,not a second of relaxin' from kanamichan and miku at the top of her art in record time; Band maid for a rock anthology for the ages.

  • @ralphboyer2538
    @ralphboyer2538 Před 2 lety +10

    I love the original "Manners" MV, but I like this one better. All of the elements are the same as in the MV, but the mix is very different. Both Misa and Miku really shine in this mix. Love it!

  • @Ezekku
    @Ezekku Před 2 lety +6

    Fucking hell I can't her enough of Miku's live vocals, both voices sound so SO perfect together

  • @stevenclloyd
    @stevenclloyd Před 2 lety +10

    i think that is why the live versions sound "better" the guitars are hard paned left and right and you can really hear what each are doing

  • @JuanSan66
    @JuanSan66 Před 2 lety +9

    At this point we can say that the versions of the songs on their albums are basic models that they are in charge of polishing and improving in the live versions. Within the complexity of songwriting on their more progressive side!. How few bands are capable of doing that! Rush and how many more?

  • @EM-vh6nj
    @EM-vh6nj Před 2 lety +24

    Another great reaction. I only discovered Bandmaid this past March. You and Chase Carneson helped me appreciate how great this band is. You both really know what you're talking about and provide useful musical info done in a passionate manner. Lately, I've been introduced to reactors such as Wave Potter and Ryan Mear who are also musicians who provide great commentary. I'm glad you mentioned Domination and Freedom. I think you touched on the essence of Bandmaid. That is, take a good music video and make a great live version. It's almost expected now. Also, I agree that Manners and Black Hole would be so much better performed in front of a live audience. I dream of that day. Sorry for being so long winded. One last note. I'm in my mid 60's and consider Led Zeppelin to be my all time favourite band. Never thought I'd hear a band on their technical level, but Bandmaid is inching ever closer. Cheers from Canada

    • @jamesredman1263
      @jamesredman1263 Před 2 lety +3

      In case you haven't already seen it, Jimmy Page is a fan. He sent a note to Akane after the band took part in a music awards show in Tokyo in 2016, asking to meet her backstage and get a photo taken together. It was granted and posted. He was impressed with her drumming and told her so, and she answered with typically humble Japanese response that she will continue to do her best.

    • @curtisrrobles7885
      @curtisrrobles7885 Před 2 lety +2

      You sound like the rest of us about your age. 😉 I'm glad you have found the Band-Maid train 🚆. I was fortunate to have found them on YT back in 2016. I have looked back since. I'm also fortunate to have seen B-M play twice here in LA back in 2018 and 2019. Just amazing. I hope you get to see our Maids in concert at least once. 🤙🏼

    • @rootxetri1887
      @rootxetri1887 Před 2 lety +4

      Jbf guitar and music is another great musician who reacts to bandmaid :) check him out for great musical insights

    • @hiawatha.g
      @hiawatha.g Před 2 lety +1

      Fellow geezer here, saw Zeppelin, Purple 3x, Queen, lots of others in the glory days. Never thought rock would be back, but it is, it just wears dresses and lives in Japan. If you are into technical, I give you a band that was not as big as those others but was technically even better--King Crimson. Check them out. "Red" album. I assume you have also discovered Lovebites. While I think Band-Maid's songwriting is better, Lovebites are taking technical to another level. And like Band-Maid, they are astonishing live.

    • @EM-vh6nj
      @EM-vh6nj Před 2 lety +5

      @@curtisrrobles7885 Thanks for the reply. I'm not a concert guy at all. Not really interested in that at all until now. Attending a BM concert is certainly high on my bucket list.

  • @billb.5183
    @billb.5183 Před 2 lety +10

    4:16 I thought that was a new vocal part also on Manners, but it's actually not. It's just hard to hear on the studio recording. It is there though.

    • @MaartenT
      @MaartenT Před 2 lety +4

      The same goes for the horn parts in Manners (which are so quiet that I even have a hard time hearing them now that I know they are there) and for the BLACK HOLE parts as far as I know when I went back to them after listening to the live video. But I agree, I thought they were new as well when I was listening to the Live video the first time. They are just extremely quiet on the album.
      I personally also prefer these live versions over the album version and I really love the album versions.
      I tend to love their Live mixing more, except that Kanami is usually a bit too quiet in the mix (but I love that they usually pump up MISA's bass).

  • @CHRISCONTEPSS
    @CHRISCONTEPSS Před 2 lety +5

    MIKU steals the show tonight PO!!!
    They are always SO MUCH more than the sum total of the individual performances, but somehow you REALLY notice Miku's EVOLUTION into a MAJOR FORCE as an instrumentalist and vocalist! She truly is the glue for this band now. That says so much when you consider her work on support parts stands out as much as Saiki's vocals, Akane's appropriate frenetic drumming (fyi she has achieved 16th note double kicks at 212 BPM!!!! at end of Black Hole) , and MISA . . .oh so forward . . . assassinating the mix!!!!
    PeaCE and LOve PO!!!!

  • @CoolClearWaterNM
    @CoolClearWaterNM Před 2 lety +2

    Thank you. Watching your reaction videos is like settling in with a friend for an evening of good drinks and good music. And music doesn't get any better than Band-Maid!
    Keep 'em coming!

    • @TheChampOfMedium
      @TheChampOfMedium  Před 2 lety

      Thanks dude... jsyk all my rock reactions will be moved over to my other channel soon. Champ Rock.

  • @chrisegbertky
    @chrisegbertky Před rokem +1

    I like your reactions Champ. It's fun rewatching your really early reactions to Domination!

  • @heroofchaos5766
    @heroofchaos5766 Před 2 lety +9

    Been waiting for this one! And yeah Miku is back at it!

  • @takooyab2892
    @takooyab2892 Před 2 lety +3

    GO‼️MIKU‼️
    GO‼️MIKU‼️
    GO‼️MIKU‼️
    Miku's backing chorus is a transcendental technique.❣️

  • @tinyhato
    @tinyhato Před 2 lety +7

    Great job, Champ as always. I think Miku is a competent rhythm player at this point and we don't need to be surprised when she can do something. I don't think we should expect a solo from her on the next album, but she's not a liability that Kanami needs to work around (unless she wants to do some Lovebites style writing, which I don't think she does).
    I'm very interested in your take on Conqueror and cluppo's new song.

  • @spupydo
    @spupydo Před 2 lety +5

    Manners bass solo is on the album too. People just focus in the guitar solo but you can hear the bass very clear.

  • @bishopsteiner7134
    @bishopsteiner7134 Před 2 lety +1

    this live performance really makes me love the bass line on this song so much.

  • @crabuki1273
    @crabuki1273 Před 2 lety +8

    I think my favorite part of this is how Kanami is doing some one finger downward bends (like just after 1:35 in this video - downward as in the direction the string goes, the pitch still goes up). I'm so used to seeing the strings pushed upwards to get that sound that it surprised me. Tiny little Japanese lady's dainty fingers bending steel to her will.
    I don't think there's much new here, I think the mix is letting you hear some things differently.
    You think maybe they were lacking a little bit of melody... which is why you jumped in to sing along! (Very shortly after nearly blowing my speakers and scaring my dog with your pained AGHAHGGHH.) ;-)

    • @GaryHolloway-810
      @GaryHolloway-810 Před 2 lety +3

      How nice yyou took the time to notice Mincho's dainty fingers even tho you have huge crushing claws. Miku's harmonies can get a little drowned out in the layered vocals of the studio versions, but they're much clearer in this live mix :)

    • @curtisrrobles7885
      @curtisrrobles7885 Před 2 lety +2

      🤙🏼

  • @zer0tzer0
    @zer0tzer0 Před 2 lety +1

    Yeah, it's like a rehearsal taping, or Live-To-Tape for a television program or something. Ready for shows!

  • @sheldoncooper8199
    @sheldoncooper8199 Před 2 lety

    Man They ve improved soo muuch as a Band since 2019. Cant wait to see em Live its gone be the greatest Day of my Life.

  • @danbuter
    @danbuter Před 2 lety +3

    I really, really hope they tour near me. I really want to see them so bad! Great reaction!

  • @perrinklumpp4664
    @perrinklumpp4664 Před 2 lety +2

    Wheee!!!! Thanks for giving us a terrific reaction! And you only bored us for a 1:03. That's a whole extra 27 seconds you didn't bore us!! ;)
    What makes Black Hole even more impressive is that they played it as song 21 of a 22 song set. THAT is trusting yourself and trusting your band-mates to be able to play a song like that when you are tired. Thank you again for a great reaction and breakdown.

  • @bodnarn
    @bodnarn Před 2 lety +2

    With everything going on it's so easy to overlook Saiki, but she really is vocal perfection for this genre.

  • @_JimS
    @_JimS Před 2 lety +6

    I too thought Miku ADDED an extra part with that echo but no....it's in the original song but you have to listen for it......yeah it made me go back and listen to the original. Saiki gets some growls in this recording too, I just love when she growls. How about Saiki's eyeballs all bugged out during Black Hole...Lol!. Miku, I feel, didn't add anything extra, just her mix was up it did add to the live performance here for sure......but I'm sure that's what you meant.

    • @glenkelley6799
      @glenkelley6799 Před 2 lety +1

      I think she was feeling the centrifugal force of the black hole at that point

  • @stephenkalisz6495
    @stephenkalisz6495 Před 2 lety +2

    this is a late comment, but i felt it necessary. as much as i like bandmaid live, thrill the mv was the song that captured me. fan for life.

  • @stephenriggs8177
    @stephenriggs8177 Před 2 lety +8

    If this were an annual review, Miku's moved from "meets expectations" to "exceeds expectations."

  • @Muzicman-ut3jr
    @Muzicman-ut3jr Před 2 lety +3

    The extra vocal you were hearing is on the recorded track!! These two songs are excellent!

  • @ytnamax
    @ytnamax Před 2 lety +1

    Just in case, very close range filmed live stage of "Take Me Higher/Freedom/Moratorium" - czcams.com/video/RxmRiWHZ3TI/video.html (with Akane`s drum solo! and with mega lengthy Kanami`s intro-solo!)
    And here is video with all members having a go on drums - czcams.com/video/Zu3kkzWf7qU/video.html

  • @nurofen7759
    @nurofen7759 Před 2 lety +1

    Hey there. Did You watch new movie "KATE" where Band Maid was featured? Tell us about Your thoughts!

  • @foxgod4466
    @foxgod4466 Před 2 lety +1

    Absolutely Amazing performance! The girls are Perfect! No more words! I love the perfect chaos in "Black Hole" and Miku's ❤️🕊️ performance in "Manners". Good react again man. See you at the next 🤟🏻🦊🇯🇵🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

  • @avader5
    @avader5 Před 2 lety +2

    Hey man you don't have to apologize, in my book you are a great guy you're one of the few that created a playlist for their band-maid reviews!!

  • @phaeron
    @phaeron Před 2 lety +2

    👉🏻【 'Our rock never dies ever. Forever!' - from BAND-MAID 'Manners' 】🕊️ That's all I can say! 😉

  • @TheXkmedia
    @TheXkmedia Před 2 lety +10

    Miku's vocal track is not an extra added, it's on the album. It does seem to be a little more pronouced here.

  • @segashieh
    @segashieh Před 2 lety

    Those two songs deserve to be played in front of thousands and thousands of people. Looking forward to see that day coming to real.

  • @pedroharukiwatanabe5512
    @pedroharukiwatanabe5512 Před 2 lety +2

    First things is Black hole is hands down my favourite by them and it was crazy when I saw that they played it live, yk? Second thing is: The vocal lines in black hole r all the same. I haven't finished the react yet, so idk if u already noticed it, but I actually listened to all Miku's vocals in that song cuz I love em and they're all there

  • @Gavrev
    @Gavrev Před 2 lety +1

    I've always been surprised and fallen in love with their live performances. It's always a thing when you write a song that may be produced a certain way in the studio and then come to replicate that in the live environment. I have a mate of some musically historical note who says he always insisted that their default position should be accurate replication, and whilst the material from both main bands he was in was obviously as challenging as it ever is, the base material was arguably less complex in terms of the writing (I'm sure he'd agree). The stuff which Band Maid, Lovebites etc.. put out could quite easily be compromised by what seems to be written, and yet they all handle their material brilliantly!

  • @miqoto
    @miqoto Před 2 lety +1

    hey Champ! glad youre doing more of the girls! :D all the parts you asked if were new, are in the original versions, just buried in the layers.

  • @drvijil
    @drvijil Před 2 lety +1

    Great version of Manners. Miku's extra vocalizations, Misa's bass solo, and the synthesized horn parts are all on the original just at lower volume and is much more subtle in the background. I think Akane's drumming on Black Hole absolutely slays.

  • @futon1832
    @futon1832 Před 2 lety +1

    I definitely recommend Black Hole from the previous live they played it on, it just shows how badly mixed the day of the maid concert was. It's like a day and night difference.

    • @lordvorador5735
      @lordvorador5735 Před 2 lety

      Umm, I don't know about that. I watched them both live & I think Day of Maid smoked Feb.11 in the mix, at least live... Now if you're comparing the Feb11 blu-ray to this version (both have post-production), then maybe the Blu-ray takes the win.

  • @shishkabobby
    @shishkabobby Před 2 lety +3

    During the drum solo, the bass is so synchronized that you loose the leading edge to the drum beats. I just hear the bass tones reverberating from the drum beats. Amazing for a live show.

    • @wave8359
      @wave8359 Před rokem

      Thought so too----sounds like a drubass, or perhaps a badrum !

  • @ronaldbowers2240
    @ronaldbowers2240 Před 2 lety +2

    The album version of songs are just the base, they get to step up the game when performing.

  • @michaels3659
    @michaels3659 Před 2 lety +2

    You need to listen to Cross live. A great song from the 2017 album Just Bring It. You get to check out Kanami with some rare backup vocals…

  • @bigbrutalbassbeer410
    @bigbrutalbassbeer410 Před 2 lety +4

    Miku killin’ it like John Wick. Po.💪🏻🤘🏻

  • @domker
    @domker Před 2 lety

    (11:51) I love when Miku adds that "aa" here - all Miku.

  • @tommcfall1274
    @tommcfall1274 Před 2 lety +3

    The most amazing band on the planet!!!!

  • @johneg27
    @johneg27 Před 2 lety +3

    My body was waiting for this

  • @yerayortiz7285
    @yerayortiz7285 Před 2 lety +2

    I think you'll love the last Cluppo mv Flapping Wings. After the second listen I'm starting to tolerate it a bit more. Miku's lyrics pull me in but the autotune pushes me out. Still struggling with it, but in the end more Kobato is always better 🤘🕊️

  • @785boats
    @785boats Před 2 lety +1

    Absolutely sensational. I don't think Misa plays just a basic bass rhythm anymore. She seems to play lead bass line runs up & down the neck for the whole song. Not just when you see her on camera. Nice to see Miku playing her signature Zemaitis 'Flappy Pigeon' guitar.
    czcams.com/video/oEPK4_ov4p8/video.html

  • @ethangospodareck
    @ethangospodareck Před 2 lety +1

    As far as Manners goes, everything you heard is on the album except maybe the brass section. I still haven't picked up on that in the studio version. And Black Hole, that extra vocal line was indeed on the album.

  • @victorwd4555
    @victorwd4555 Před 2 lety +1

    10:18 --> literally me, or maybe literally everyone LOL
    Edit: started with 9:30 , almost forget that.

  • @patron40silver
    @patron40silver Před 2 lety +5

    Master MISA makes my innards rumble....and I like it.

  • @krismartinez4766
    @krismartinez4766 Před 2 lety +3

    During the bumblebee riff part.. listen to Miku for some lead notes working with MISA.. just sayin'.. always appreciate your reaction Champ..

  • @ShikataGaNai100
    @ShikataGaNai100 Před 2 lety +10

    "Yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah!" - Miku Kobato

    • @curtisrrobles7885
      @curtisrrobles7885 Před 2 lety +1

      🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼🕊

  • @jon87583
    @jon87583 Před 2 lety +1

    Ballads: Have you ever listened to "Page" from the Conqueror album? I think that would qualify as a ballad. Along with the more recent "About Us" - both work really hard at jerking a tear or 2 from my eyes.

  • @204pjfaherty
    @204pjfaherty Před 2 lety

    I waved a cloth a couple of times at my PC screen to get rid of a fly. Turns out it was your black pointer. Silly me! 🤣👆

  • @Mojje42
    @Mojje42 Před 2 lety +1

    i don't think i could say the live versions of their songs are better... different yes and that's
    what i love about Band maid... you can listen to the records and then watch a live show and not feel
    like you've already heard the songs over and over
    in this latest live show (online) given that i've just watched 4 live shows one could tell that
    there being no audience made a slight impact.... they still did an Amazing show but one could almost tell they
    would have been happier with an audience
    2h + 1h + 2h + 2.5h Amazing live shows and nice to have a reason to crank up the stereo

  • @Mikupigeon
    @Mikupigeon Před 2 lety +5

    Saiki was on fire that day! Loved it!

  • @joeking6763
    @joeking6763 Před 2 lety

    So let's do this - take the studio version and the live version and compare segment by segment to each other. Their Live songs are going to be awesome when they do get out in concert. They always add to the songs in the Live versions.
    KANAMI asked Herman Li what the fastest song he plays (225bpm) Kanami stated that 220 was her fastest (BLACK HOLE) but she would write a song for 225bpm.
    Herman Li video here czcams.com/video/oS2U9YzaFK8/video.html

  • @cesarvillalpando7376
    @cesarvillalpando7376 Před 2 lety

    Where have you been man? Maidiacs missed you.
    Nice work as usually

  • @drogonr9318
    @drogonr9318 Před 2 lety +1

    Nice reaction. Black Hole...getting pulled inside that lovely madness. Miku was impressive, starting from those triplets to her harmonies and overall guitarwork. Seems like a hard song for her to play and sing and she nailed it. I'm glad they released Black Hole with Manners - highlights one of the crazy fun things about the band: it's diversity. Unfortunately, it sounded to me like a mic was missing from Akane's kick drum, otherwise she was fire. Misa was a volcano. Saiki was her usual beautiful vocals. But Kanami's guitarwork ... was so far back in the mix as to be practically off-stage. Again. Yeah I'm exaggerating a little, but this is a bad place to have your lead guitar in a rock band. Live Band-Maid songs have started to sound like bass-drum exclusives, and I'm beginning to wonder whether this is how the band wants it. These two songs would imo have sounded dramatically better with the lead guitar turned up 20%. They need to go find whoever recorded their old Studio Coast and Zepp shows and get them on the payroll asap.

  • @Puyax01
    @Puyax01 Před 2 lety +1

    10:40 Akane and MISA going berserk amazingly 🔥🔥🔥

  • @DavidMISAMISAMISACook
    @DavidMISAMISAMISACook Před 2 lety +5

    MISA MISA MISA!

    • @curtisrrobles7885
      @curtisrrobles7885 Před 2 lety +2

      🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼

    • @GaryHolloway-810
      @GaryHolloway-810 Před 2 lety +2

      Dave you did not give me the heads up on Chrono falco's comment. I've just scrolled down & found it myself. Shocking dereliction of duty. Lol

    • @curtisrrobles7885
      @curtisrrobles7885 Před 2 lety +2

      @@GaryHolloway-810 I just got done reading them too. Just wow.

    • @GaryHolloway-810
      @GaryHolloway-810 Před 2 lety +2

      @@curtisrrobles7885 I know. Miku's harmonies don't clash, they're just clearer in the live mix. Don't tell Jim Moriarty about CF's comment cos he may of been overtly gushing about Miku what with all the love hearts in his comment.😆

    • @curtisrrobles7885
      @curtisrrobles7885 Před 2 lety +1

      @@GaryHolloway-810 😆

  • @jon87583
    @jon87583 Před 2 lety +2

    It would be interesting to know if it's still the case that Kanami does Miku's parts in the studio - have they said anything about that in interviews? I think she's at the point where she'd want to play those parts herself - she's earned it.

    • @gradyshmalady8284
      @gradyshmalady8284 Před 2 lety +1

      I had heard that Kanami did do Miku's parts for the UW album. Miku did say she will do them next time. Regardless, if you watched the acoustic okyu-ji the other day you know she can hold her own.

    • @jon87583
      @jon87583 Před 2 lety +3

      @@gradyshmalady8284 Yep - she's a solid guitarist now. I was so proud of her, both for her part in the whole-band songs and the "Miku" songs with just Misa & Akane

  • @Wirmish
    @Wirmish Před 2 lety

    Some Japanese bands. Take your pick: BAND-MAID [All their songs... really!], LOVEBITES [Raise some Hell, and all the other songs], MAXIMUM THE HORMONE [Yoshu Fukushu], DEXCORE [Red Eye], CROSSFAITH [Catastrophe], SiM [Killing Me], NINGEN ISU [Heartless Scat], UNLUCKY MORPHEUS [Black Pentagram], YOUSEI TEIKOKU [Astral Dogma], COLDRAIN [Die Tomorrow], CRYSTAL LAKE [The Circle], GIVEN BY THE FLAMES [Ronove], ANGRY FROG REBIRTH [2Step Syndrome], SILENTLY SHOOTING TRAITORS [Manipulate], ALDIOUS [Dominator], BRIDEAR [Light in the Dark], CINQ ELEMENT [Destiny], MARY'S BLOOD [Marionette], GRAUPEL [Bereavement], DOLL$BOXX [Take my Chance], SOKONINARU [Tenohira De Odoru], HELLO SLEEPWALKERS [Flying Saucer], TELECiDE [Tied up Memories], NEKO [Ghost on a Record], ROTTENGRAFFTY [Hallelujah], LYNCH [Devil], DIR EN GREY [Ningen wo Kaburu], X JAPAN [Kurenai], DAZZLE VISION [Second], JUPITER [My Enemy], GALNERYUS [Angel of Salvation], BLOOD STAIN CHILD [Del-Sol], NEMOPHILA [Dissension], DADAROMA [Lucid Dream], JILUKA [Suzaku], HANABIE [We Love Sweets], and many many more...

  • @davidmejia7908
    @davidmejia7908 Před 2 lety +2

    Miku is singing a counter melody through the whole song, it is a bit hidden on the studio version.

  • @philproffitt8363
    @philproffitt8363 Před 2 lety

    The studio of Manners is deceptively complex/layered so a lot of work live...they done great. Needs an audience rockin' with them of course. Black Hole is manic but they can just let go...so felt easier. Superb.

  • @darrellroninson3476
    @darrellroninson3476 Před 2 lety +1

    They do different and they do well at it!

  • @denisav3089
    @denisav3089 Před 2 lety +1

    We (I) need a cut of Black Hole focusing only on Akane's drums.

  • @flashpeter625
    @flashpeter625 Před 2 lety

    Nice to get 6 songs in one video. First Manners, and then the 5 songs played over each other that are collectively called "Black Hole".

  • @Richzee777
    @Richzee777 Před 2 lety +2

    One does not simply listen to 1 Band-Maid song.

  • @curtisrrobles7885
    @curtisrrobles7885 Před 2 lety +2

    MISA!! MISA!!! MISA!!! 🥃🥃🥃

  • @rolandkarlsson7072
    @rolandkarlsson7072 Před 6 měsíci

    Yes, this version has so much more than the album version. The most prominent two things is MISA and Miku. MISA is playing a solo almost al way through the song, almost never stops. And the bass is so high in the mix. And Miku just slays both with guitar and vocals. Of course, the others also are phenomenal, but MISA and Miku is my main take from this video with Manners.

  • @bigfan007
    @bigfan007 Před 2 lety

    Love Band-Maid and your reactions. My first reaction is this live version of Manners lacks the punch of the music video. Hey I am not sure if you have ever reacted to the all-sisters band, The Warning, but their new single “Evolve” is great. Keep up the great work!

  • @Bloosee
    @Bloosee Před 2 lety +5

    Why aren't they the biggest band in the world.

  • @denissmith9772
    @denissmith9772 Před 2 lety

    Jungle boogie horns! Cool and the gang!